I know I do not speak for everyone, but if you wanted to do one or two days a week of Historic Brawl every week instead of Standard, that would be great by me.
Regarding the Atraxa thing in the last game with Tasha: you'd get to steal the Atraxa. There's triggers or replacement effects created when a commander goes to almost every zone - graveyard, exile, hand, deck - but not for the stack or battlefield, so there's nothing they can do about it.
It does hit the graveyard, but the rules change that happened a while back to allow commander death triggers turned the CZ replacement effect for public zones into a state-based action, and because SBAs are not checked during the resolution of a spell or ability Tasha gets away with her library-to-grave-to-battlefield thievery.
@@LordZurkov Nah, Tasha is weird. She makes your opponent reveal until they hit three creatures, puts those directly into play, and then sends the rest to the grave. Not relevant here since you're right, the sba for going to the grave wouldn't have a chance to intervene, but she wouldn't trigger something like Flayer of the Hatebound but can steal creatures even under a Leyline of the Void esque effect.
@@Kestral287 Yeah FR. A lot of the times decks don't have a way to specifically screw you over if you top your commander or send it to the GY. But it's definitely WAY smarter and safer just to send it to commander zone in those situations. Not to mention Tasha was revealed and it wasn't a surprise or anything.
CGB, so glad you made this! Working on this EDH deck with my sister. Previously made a Ghidorah (Illuna, Apex of Wishes) similar to your earlier historic brawl video. Keep up the inspiring content!
This new set is the funnest in a long time, especially in draft. I love the artwork too, the new "esika" card with the rainbow is the best artwork in the set!
For tasha, none of the creatures actually hit the graveyard, just the other revealed cards, so you would get the atraxa. It wouldn't matter anyway, since state based actions, like the one that lets you put you commander into the command zone, don't check until a spell or ability finished resolving. Either way, you would get the atraxa.
I can’t wait to see you try Hidetsugu and Kairi in historic brawl CGB. It took me a couple matches to figure out how to pilot it well, but that death trigger is disgusting.
@@KodasGarden i do like my controlgames, but if you wanna play some weird dragondeck and my commander finds itself in a weird limbo of phased out, its not fun. But i guess, if it was me, i would have conceded much early then them🤣🤣
@@KodasGarden i mean being able to forever negate the commander of your oponent (because most decks dont have a direct answer to teferi in brawl) is kinda well unfun
Hey CGb-Community : i got into mtga a while ago but im still quite new to limited. I signed up for sealed:mom recently, first time ever playing sealed. How much time do have to finish my sealed event? How many weeks are left to sign up for sealed again? Cheers@all
Im addicted to your videos. I basically watch them everyday. One question: How much money does it cost to have your impressive collection of cards in MTGarena?
If you want a robust collection, I recommend learning to draft. If you do well at drafting and play a lot, you can collect the entirety of each set as they're released without spending any cash on MTGA.
59:27 if u knew about the x card you could have bounced the treasure token before they untapped and hope they didn't have the land but hindsight is 20/20
I faced against an Atraxa deck today, though I gotta say rather than an Atraxa deck that one was "boardwipe tribal" deck as all they did past turn 4 was wipe the board, they casted crux of fate, then depopulate, then white sun's twilight and still had fumigate on hand.
Kenrith lets you play any of them you want and gives your creatures haste and trample to help them attack the battles. Plus all the other obvious value stapled to Kenrith. Unfortunately that value puts him in hell queue usually, which might create too much pressure on your slightly meme-y battle deck. Kyodai maybe, to keep the competition lower? Fill out the creature slots with aggressive attackers that can help flip your battles and use the commander as a combat trick, in a pinch, maybe late game, cast him and if need be pump him to attack the battles in the air. Could honestly be the perfect deck for Kyodai now that I'm thinking of it.
Man, the Recurring Nightmare/Survival of the Fittest combo was the undisputed champ from back when I played competitively. I don't know if I can watch the video, it'll trigger my shakes, haha.
1:08:16 The Commander would be allowed to move to the command zone. You get so many people to scoop when you're at so low life and they're at a high amount. Pretty sure it's just rage quitting over all the control.
That last atraxa player quit for no reason! You had to answer his board his hand and an atraxa otw. If you get it with Tasha and he can't move zones, he still is in a winning position. Idk if he saw you had it and the answers you needed I'd be less confused but just quitting from a winning position like that is wild.
The year is 20XX. Everyone plays the same Atraxa deck at TAS levels of perfection. Because of this, the winner of a match depends solely on who goes first. The coinflip metagame has evolved to ridiculous levels due to it being the only remaining factor to decide matches.
You would have gained control of atraxa in the last game. There is no window for them to put it into the command zone as it does not change zones before being put onto the battlefield. Wish we could have seen it.
It does change zones (twice, actually), but the CZ redirection effect is a state-based action when moving to public zones, and SBAs are not checked during the resolution of a spell or ability, so Tasha does steal it.
@@LordZurkov just because i would like to ensure I understand, what zones does it change to? aside from library to battlefield which does not trigger CZ redirect
OG Atraxa seems like a hard nut to crack in Arena, I guess a lot of the staples that make her bonkers in paper commander aren't on the client. I've seen so many decks with her at the helm since her release and none of them have done anything, I've only lost to it due to mana screw (drew four lands in my 49 land deck, Etali with lands, ramp, and all top end, I drew more 6+ mana cards than I did lands in six turns, felt great) and even then it was by no means crushing. I don't know, maybe it's more of a multiplayer inclined card, I haven't pulled one and after seeing it's performance I'm not gonna craft it so I haven't tried building it myself yet.
I dont even know how its a hard nut to crack honestly. No matter how you build her, it seems to me like theres plenty of support. As CGB showcased, superfriends with plenty control works. I could also see a very synergistic midrange counters build work too, where you just go super big and wide. Early game interaction is key no matter what, and I feel not enough players are doing that and its why they just don't do anything most games.
She actually is a pain to figure out. I've tried many iteration and, while doing good, I can feel the deck isn't optimal and feel a bit of a let down. Which is a shame because I love the card. What are those cards that makes her bonkers in edh you were talking about? I am thinking right now of fetch lands because mana base is a nightmare but maybe you had other cards in mind.
Hey sorry if this is a dumb question, do you know why I can't find atraxa in game in the deck builder? I tried checking off all expansions and owned/unowned but she's not there :(
Bro. It's 6:42 in the morning. That's too many cards to read this early in the morning. I have misplaced my coffee somewhere on my insides; let me pause and brew another cup because this deck is too tech
nope dude you can't bring it back because in the change of the position of atraxa from deck to gaveyard the player can decides if put it on comand zone or not
Also, when you do emergent ultimatum you can do time warp, vraska, vorinclex. Most people don’t see the combo and puts time warp back. Then you ultimate vraska for 18 poison counters.
I don't know if you ever take decks from the comments, but I really want to see a selesnya +1/+1 counters deck with the new MOM cards. I have one and it's pretty fun, so seeing your take on it would be nice.
Somehow the comments are populated by negative remarks, so I suppose Ill put my 0.02 in. Deck has some interesting things, and it has some cool (if straightforward) synergies. I enjoyed the gameplay, and the tactical discussion you offer is always nice. I came for daily CGB mtg content, and here it is. Since I do not have the disposable funds to MtG on Arena/paper, especially not for the diverse decks you put on the channel, its an enjoyable experience where one gets to "backseat" to some degree with all these cards. It never ceases to amaze me how much people want to complain and gripe instead of doing something a bit more meaningful, like voting with their feet. The views and engagement matter more than being nasty in a YT comment section. Go figure.
It's pretty unbelievable you haven't made a Historic Brawl deck with Jin-Gitaxis as your commander. I am pretty sure I speak for everyone when I say, "I'm upset!"
Aw man, if Ichormoon Gauntlet isn't in this deck what deck could it be in? I liked the idea of that card so much. Maybe it would fit instead of Time Warp? It fills a similar role but it's cheaper
Historic Brawl when there's a new set to explore in standard? Come on CGB... We do love your brawl videos, but not now is not the time. It's time for the one in best of one to shine and guide us in this new Meta!!
Please do a Kaya control deck. With Kaya The Intangible Slayer and a whole bunch of awesome control. I built one today that is unstoppable 100% winrate so far
28:00 I hated that game so much. It was a complete "I'm the blue player so I just don't let your deck do the thing." Also, having a 100 singleton deck and getting Broker's Ascendancy, Narset, Supreme Verdict, again and again in these games? Shuffler's fine.
16:40 the name of that player ahahahaha. Its a slag term in spanish, it literally says "the vagina of your mother". But it is used as an insult or as a swear when something goes wrong.
Sensei, could you please build a Emergent Ultimatum that guarantees the win? Like Omniscience, Grim Tutor and One with Multiverse? I don't know how to do the rest 🤣
Standard Video - ua-cam.com/video/82N3SgSRSy4/v-deo.html
I know I do not speak for everyone, but if you wanted to do one or two days a week of Historic Brawl every week instead of Standard, that would be great by me.
Agreed 100 percent
i’m liking the mix of both
You speak for me
Please Ide say 2 to 3
Id love some drafts too
the Tamiyo ultimate + atraxa + sea gate was such a nutty combo I literally squirmed in my chair out of excitement.
Regarding the Atraxa thing in the last game with Tasha: you'd get to steal the Atraxa. There's triggers or replacement effects created when a commander goes to almost every zone - graveyard, exile, hand, deck - but not for the stack or battlefield, so there's nothing they can do about it.
It does hit the graveyard, but the rules change that happened a while back to allow commander death triggers turned the CZ replacement effect for public zones into a state-based action, and because SBAs are not checked during the resolution of a spell or ability Tasha gets away with her library-to-grave-to-battlefield thievery.
@@LordZurkov Nah, Tasha is weird. She makes your opponent reveal until they hit three creatures, puts those directly into play, and then sends the rest to the grave. Not relevant here since you're right, the sba for going to the grave wouldn't have a chance to intervene, but she wouldn't trigger something like Flayer of the Hatebound but can steal creatures even under a Leyline of the Void esque effect.
@@Kestral287 Yeah, you're right, command zone rules only take place when it comes to moving to exile, GY, hand etc. Tasha with gust is a scary combo.
@Hono Shirayuki Eh. Only if they put their commander in the deck in the first place. The smart play is just to not do that if you don't have to.
@@Kestral287 Yeah FR. A lot of the times decks don't have a way to specifically screw you over if you top your commander or send it to the GY. But it's definitely WAY smarter and safer just to send it to commander zone in those situations. Not to mention Tasha was revealed and it wasn't a surprise or anything.
I believe "Ajani, the Greathearted" would be a good addition to this deck since he gives counters to creatures and planewalkers.
46:14 ok I'm not the only one that noticed or I'm just blind but uhh that land mos def has vigilance?
It does have vigilance, Wrenn gives the land that on the +1.
Not only is it vigilant but it would have also drawn a card with tamiyos trigger
I noticed that as well good eyea though
@@TotalTimoTime yea i was like wait why wouldn't he atk now? 😂
Attacking is for people who want to end games 🙂
I really enjoy your Historic Brawl content more than the Standard play, but any CGB upload is more than fine!
1:07:30
Nope, you get full access to Atraxa in that scenario.
CGB, so glad you made this! Working on this EDH deck with my sister. Previously made a Ghidorah (Illuna, Apex of Wishes) similar to your earlier historic brawl video. Keep up the inspiring content!
46:09
Missed a card and 3 damage, the land has vigilance
That moment at 13:55 when the Freudian slip happened...
"Luminarch Ass Pirate" is the name I will forevermore hear.
It's not a slip. He was calling it that the entire time it was in standard.
This new set is the funnest in a long time, especially in draft. I love the artwork too, the new "esika" card with the rainbow is the best artwork in the set!
I just wish we got quickdraft of the new set in the first week too. Kinda sucks that you only get the expensive 10k gold one at first
For tasha, none of the creatures actually hit the graveyard, just the other revealed cards, so you would get the atraxa. It wouldn't matter anyway, since state based actions, like the one that lets you put you commander into the command zone, don't check until a spell or ability finished resolving. Either way, you would get the atraxa.
That Tamiyo ult was so good into Seagate and Vorinclex, wish he didn't concede for the content!
I can’t wait to see you try Hidetsugu and Kairi in historic brawl CGB. It took me a couple matches to figure out how to pilot it well, but that death trigger is disgusting.
21:34 😂 🤣 just bodily functions, don’t mind me
Not playing ichormoon gauntlet and the blue dominus is a huge wasted opportunity. Just imagine that with Teferi Master of time *drool
And the Green Blue proliferate card draw guy.
Damn that match against vaevictus made me miss professor onyx in standard lol
That game showed again everything thats wrong with Teferi...
@@vanikkan872 I think you mean everything that's RIGHT
But nah, I understand people's hatred of Teferi, it feels real bad to not have an answer
@@KodasGarden i do like my controlgames, but if you wanna play some weird dragondeck and my commander finds itself in a weird limbo of phased out, its not fun. But i guess, if it was me, i would have conceded much early then them🤣🤣
@@KodasGarden i mean being able to forever negate the commander of your oponent (because most decks dont have a direct answer to teferi in brawl) is kinda well unfun
Ok, verdant rejuvenation, seeking Teferi Hero, Tamiyo Researcher and Mordenkainen and Vorinclex, damn, remove all from your oponent's field.😢
Hey CGb-Community : i got into mtga a while ago but im still quite new to limited. I signed up for sealed:mom recently, first time ever playing sealed. How much time do have to finish my sealed event? How many weeks are left to sign up for sealed again? Cheers@all
Im addicted to your videos. I basically watch them everyday. One question: How much money does it cost to have your impressive collection of cards in MTGarena?
He pretty much buys all the preorder bundles every set, it’s a lot
If you want a robust collection, I recommend learning to draft. If you do well at drafting and play a lot, you can collect the entirety of each set as they're released without spending any cash on MTGA.
If Thalia and the Gitrog monster wore Swiftfoot boots would they wear them like this or like this?
59:27 if u knew about the x card you could have bounced the treasure token before they untapped and hope they didn't have the land but hindsight is 20/20
Its amazing seeing the difference in average game length between this and Ragavan.
Thanks CGB. That was a fun looking deck.
I faced against an Atraxa deck today, though I gotta say rather than an Atraxa deck that one was "boardwipe tribal" deck as all they did past turn 4 was wipe the board, they casted crux of fate, then depopulate, then white sun's twilight and still had fumigate on hand.
I’d love to see a battle themed brawl video, tho I don’t know a good commander
Probably any commanders that help attack your battles / care about noncreatures. Ovika and Kykar come to mind.
Kenrith lets you play any of them you want and gives your creatures haste and trample to help them attack the battles. Plus all the other obvious value stapled to Kenrith. Unfortunately that value puts him in hell queue usually, which might create too much pressure on your slightly meme-y battle deck. Kyodai maybe, to keep the competition lower? Fill out the creature slots with aggressive attackers that can help flip your battles and use the commander as a combat trick, in a pinch, maybe late game, cast him and if need be pump him to attack the battles in the air. Could honestly be the perfect deck for Kyodai now that I'm thinking of it.
Man, the Recurring Nightmare/Survival of the Fittest combo was the undisputed champ from back when I played competitively. I don't know if I can watch the video, it'll trigger my shakes, haha.
Managed to steal some wins in matches against Atraxa while playing Ragavan. Monkey too fast and too furious.
If I would get to choose how to lose, crackle of power would be on top of the list.
That was awesome! Super enjoyable matches.
1:08:16 The Commander would be allowed to move to the command zone. You get so many people to scoop when you're at so low life and they're at a high amount. Pretty sure it's just rage quitting over all the control.
If darksteel hydra isn’t in this deck, it definitely could go in it.
That last atraxa player quit for no reason! You had to answer his board his hand and an atraxa otw. If you get it with Tasha and he can't move zones, he still is in a winning position. Idk if he saw you had it and the answers you needed I'd be less confused but just quitting from a winning position like that is wild.
The year is 20XX. Everyone plays the same Atraxa deck at TAS levels of perfection. Because of this, the winner of a match depends solely on who goes first. The coinflip metagame has evolved to ridiculous levels due to it being the only remaining factor to decide matches.
The dude never didn’t have it but forgets about sudo Omniscience bahaha. Got em
You would have gained control of atraxa in the last game. There is no window for them to put it into the command zone as it does not change zones before being put onto the battlefield. Wish we could have seen it.
It does change zones (twice, actually), but the CZ redirection effect is a state-based action when moving to public zones, and SBAs are not checked during the resolution of a spell or ability, so Tasha does steal it.
@@LordZurkov just because i would like to ensure I understand, what zones does it change to? aside from library to battlefield which does not trigger CZ redirect
OG Atraxa seems like a hard nut to crack in Arena, I guess a lot of the staples that make her bonkers in paper commander aren't on the client. I've seen so many decks with her at the helm since her release and none of them have done anything, I've only lost to it due to mana screw (drew four lands in my 49 land deck, Etali with lands, ramp, and all top end, I drew more 6+ mana cards than I did lands in six turns, felt great) and even then it was by no means crushing. I don't know, maybe it's more of a multiplayer inclined card, I haven't pulled one and after seeing it's performance I'm not gonna craft it so I haven't tried building it myself yet.
I dont even know how its a hard nut to crack honestly. No matter how you build her, it seems to me like theres plenty of support. As CGB showcased, superfriends with plenty control works. I could also see a very synergistic midrange counters build work too, where you just go super big and wide. Early game interaction is key no matter what, and I feel not enough players are doing that and its why they just don't do anything most games.
She actually is a pain to figure out. I've tried many iteration and, while doing good, I can feel the deck isn't optimal and feel a bit of a let down. Which is a shame because I love the card. What are those cards that makes her bonkers in edh you were talking about? I am thinking right now of fetch lands because mana base is a nightmare but maybe you had other cards in mind.
Beyond cool. Imma craft this one.
Just opened this atraxa today... Moments later CGB does atraxa historic brawl. This is a sign I MUST CRAFT,🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hey sorry if this is a dumb question, do you know why I can't find atraxa in game in the deck builder? I tried checking off all expansions and owned/unowned but she's not there :(
i wouldve tried to sneak in the card when you proliferate you do it twice. and the card that searches for two planeswalkers is dope too
Love historic brawl vids.
Atraxa has been my commander for like 8 years. The only deck that I still have that is that old. Not sure how I feel about it on arena.
do you have something against supreme verdict?
I haven't seen her in queue yet, but expecting it now!
16:49 the nickname of the player lmao
Don’t forget ezuri's predation… probably the nastiest
Second match I'm wondering why you don't farewell to get rid of the boots too
The good old times when Recurring Nightmare was dominating the meta...
Just got this Atraka may build this deck off from CGB
Astral Cornucopia did some work.
Bro. It's 6:42 in the morning. That's too many cards to read this early in the morning. I have misplaced my coffee somewhere on my insides; let me pause and brew another cup because this deck is too tech
I pulled this for a buddy when opening boxes last weekend…. The Foil , alt art …. Like a $200 cards ….. (sad face)😢😢
Wait I thought brawl was only 60 cards. What am I missing here? If this 100 card is a Permanente thing I may try to get back to arena. Love commander
'Historic' Brawl is a 100-card format, which includes all the cards available in Arena. Unfortunately that also includes the Digital Only cards... 🤦
nope dude you can't bring it back because in the change of the position of atraxa from deck to gaveyard the player can decides if put it on comand zone or not
The realmbreaker lands get vigilance so no need to not attack to hold up a blocker fyi
Great vid, We need an update because of all the new planeswalkers we have and new card base
feaking awesome as always
I just made this deck and Jesus Christ is it nuts, ppl can’t do anything when u slam 9 planeswalkers in there face
My favorite commander with poison.
YUHS!!!!! Let’s go!!!
ulting tamiyo goes hard.
Leaving a comment so you know HB is okay too!
36:24 nahhh they just quit cuz you take forever.
Yeah i mean he wasn't going to win straight away so him conceding was kinda strange i think
Wish I could hit the like button 1000x 🥴
I don't get why the opponent conceded at 36:22, it's not like he could have used the -9 right away, right ?
That Onyx ult is the most disgusting
Mf usin SUPERFIENDS Atraxa...only way he can make it more trolly is have the strat be not winning and make em surrender lol
Also, when you do emergent ultimatum you can do time warp, vraska, vorinclex. Most people don’t see the combo and puts time warp back. Then you ultimate vraska for 18 poison counters.
best opponent name at 16:55
chileans being chileans
Staff of completion
I don't know if you ever take decks from the comments, but I really want to see a selesnya +1/+1 counters deck with the new MOM cards. I have one and it's pretty fun, so seeing your take on it would be nice.
Somehow the comments are populated by negative remarks, so I suppose Ill put my 0.02 in.
Deck has some interesting things, and it has some cool (if straightforward) synergies. I enjoyed the gameplay, and the tactical discussion you offer is always nice. I came for daily CGB mtg content, and here it is. Since I do not have the disposable funds to MtG on Arena/paper, especially not for the diverse decks you put on the channel, its an enjoyable experience where one gets to "backseat" to some degree with all these cards.
It never ceases to amaze me how much people want to complain and gripe instead of doing something a bit more meaningful, like voting with their feet. The views and engagement matter more than being nasty in a YT comment section. Go figure.
its the most played commmander according to edh
It's pretty unbelievable you haven't made a Historic Brawl deck with Jin-Gitaxis as your commander. I am pretty sure I speak for everyone when I say, "I'm upset!"
to see gin suffer was grate
i love historic brawl
Nice!!
Aw man, if Ichormoon Gauntlet isn't in this deck what deck could it be in? I liked the idea of that card so much.
Maybe it would fit instead of Time Warp? It fills a similar role but it's cheaper
Anyone care to explain why he didnt counter that Ulamog with Tale´s End, and went with countering his triggered ability instead?
21:31 😂
Cards Go Boom
Cgb is life
I guarantee that atraxa deck didn't have creatures and was going to get 1 shot by Tasha
Brokers ascendancy and attraxa should not be allowed to exist in the same. The combo scales wayyy too fast
Historic Brawl when there's a new set to explore in standard? Come on CGB... We do love your brawl videos, but not now is not the time. It's time for the one in best of one to shine and guide us in this new Meta!!
What new meta? 😅
Please do a Kaya control deck. With Kaya The Intangible Slayer and a whole bunch of awesome control. I built one today that is unstoppable 100% winrate so far
No You're Cool!
Siempre hay un Chileno
Can I add you on MTGA?
28:00 I hated that game so much. It was a complete "I'm the blue player so I just don't let your deck do the thing." Also, having a 100 singleton deck and getting Broker's Ascendancy, Narset, Supreme Verdict, again and again in these games? Shuffler's fine.
16:40 the name of that player ahahahaha.
Its a slag term in spanish, it literally says "the vagina of your mother". But it is used as an insult or as a swear when something goes wrong.
No post game rap makes me sad :/
Luminarch Asspirate
Sensei, could you please build a Emergent Ultimatum that guarantees the win? Like Omniscience, Grim Tutor and One with Multiverse? I don't know how to do the rest 🤣
Omniscience, vorinclex and new vraska basically guarantees a win, they must give you omni or they lose immediately
More historic!
But… vigilance
I cannot decide which Atraxa I hate most in Brawl, the All Be One or the March of Machines
Angel wh*re?
Recurring