Battle of the Whiskeys: Budget vs Expensive in Cocktails | Is It Worth the Extra Cost?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 740

  • @JeremySiers
    @JeremySiers  Рік тому +9

    Get 30% off your first box, plus a FREE gift, when you give Tiege Hanley a try at tiege.com/siersextra

  • @Draevon68
    @Draevon68 Рік тому +8

    I've wondered if a better whiskey makes much of a difference in a cocktail and thankfully you did it for me. Thank you for saving me the expense of trying this myself. And you chose two of my favorites, Old Fashion and Sentimental Gentleman. Great video.
    Btw, anyone else notice in these last two whiskey videos that Jeremy seems to get a little tipsy but his wife handles the drinks just fine? Hmm....

  • @maximizedmedia
    @maximizedmedia Рік тому +1

    I love some OGD, both the 114 and Bonded! Great budget pour, for sure!!

  • @ronswoodturningshopandstuf5759

    what a fun time watching this video. I agree, no high dollar juice in a simple cocktail

  • @jessecross8317
    @jessecross8317 Рік тому +12

    Great video as always. When it comes to cocktails my rule is: "don't break the bank, but use something that holds up to the flavors." So finding that happy medium is important. #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

    • @runekingthor9409
      @runekingthor9409 Рік тому

      My heart hurt when u poured that 38 year scotch into a cocktail. Thanks brother for all u do! #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @fernandorivera9701
    @fernandorivera9701 Рік тому

    My heart broke a little there when I saw that Scotch in a mixer. But all is fair in love and content creation. Thanks Jeremy for taking one for the channel!

  • @CalebMiles65
    @CalebMiles65 Рік тому

    Great to know what to mix and what not to mix.

  • @KennethRathburn
    @KennethRathburn Рік тому +1

    I've gradually warmed up to using pricier stuff in cocktails because, when they're good and justify their price, they usually translate to that much better of a cocktails. It's like when you're throwing a recipe together; sometimes it's only as good as the ingredients you put together (I say sometimes becomes not everyone will enjoy or appreciate it).
    Case in point: ECBP in an Old Fashioned. Shit's a game changer.

  • @gfsandy
    @gfsandy Рік тому

    My first time watching this channel. This is a delightful couple! And a solid, honest discourse on whiskey.

  • @PapaPeyo2
    @PapaPeyo2 10 місяців тому

    Wow!!!! You guys are the best!!!! I came home tonight after watching the video earlier and made me a Ginger Ale Whiskey with Wild Turkey rare breed Rye whiskey that rocked me out of my shoes….Loved it. Ended up having 3 more and my night was fulfilled…. Thank you guys…. Jeremy Love the videos, I’m learning so much watching!!!!

  • @natemiller770
    @natemiller770 Рік тому

    my favorite cheap Bourbon to blast in a cocktail is Four Roses. Its always 3 rows deep, in every liquor store, and around $20ish bucks!

  • @jamesf5346
    @jamesf5346 Рік тому

    I like the Stagg Jr as an old fashioned it is great!!! Because the high proof holds up ..

  • @Jay_Aitch82
    @Jay_Aitch82 Рік тому

    Great vidya. Y’all killed it. Thanks for taking one for the team.

  • @lurchrsp
    @lurchrsp Рік тому +1

    Drambuie is really sweet, I have found the sharper elements found in cheaper blended scotch like Dewer's White Label helped to bring balance to a Rusty Nail.

  • @Eddy_A-s_Cafe
    @Eddy_A-s_Cafe Рік тому

    Definitely want to try some of these cocktails.

  • @garyhovey9305
    @garyhovey9305 Рік тому

    FANTASTIC VIDEO!!! Bottom line is if i'm mixing for special occasions and want to make guests feel special then I'm pouring EH all day! But i'f I'm focussing on making a well balanced cocktail then Old Grand-dad is the standard bourbon of choice. I am a HUGE fan of Old Grand-dad 100 proof for cocktails! with a VERY high rye (27%) content in the mashbill it holds up great to the sugars and bitters.

  • @danielgrassman2175
    @danielgrassman2175 Рік тому

    Appreciate your sacrifice of your top of the top shelf supply! As always, great video!

  • @jjhlew
    @jjhlew Рік тому

    While I occasionally enjoy an Old Fashioned, my wife and I love a good Whiskey Sour. Our budget whiskey is Evan Williams Bottled in Bond.

  • @mistermena8204
    @mistermena8204 Рік тому

    I really enjoy the relationship you guys have

  • @BourbonJack
    @BourbonJack 11 місяців тому

    $800/750ml = $1.07ml. 1 ounce = 29.57ml so roughly $120 for the last cocktail for the 4 ounces. Thanks for testing it out, always interested to see comparisons between expensive and budget in cocktails. My frugal soul would hurt, too, lol. Also it's nice to sip in order to appreciate the time and effort for the more expensive craft items and the nuances that come with it..

  • @swopeti
    @swopeti Рік тому

    i normally use bottles i dont enjoy neat for mixers just to kill them but i have made some killer ranch waters with some high end tequila.

  • @jerryMonster738
    @jerryMonster738 Рік тому

    at last Whisky, i love Old Fashioned and for me 101 it's delicious. Great video 👍

  • @julianhuskey4343
    @julianhuskey4343 Рік тому

    Thanks for taking one for the team, that 101 is my goto for bourbon cocktails. Love the turkey. #Givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @maxhorner2409
    @maxhorner2409 Рік тому

    Love how yall started with my favorite cocktail. Drink almost exclusively old fashioned when i get a cocktail
    #give me a flask
    #save the stag

  • @lukejones8385
    @lukejones8385 Рік тому

    Just received my first bottle of Wild Turkey 101 follow your recommendation, will let you know how it tastes.

  • @seang1979
    @seang1979 Рік тому

    I have the same attitude about using expensive whiskey in a cocktail. I usually make my old fashions with WT rye 101. However, when that ran out I caved in and used my sagamore double oak. ( not insanely expensive but still about $65 where I live). I have to say, it was friggin delicious. And then I decided to try it with a peated nikka yoichi. And that was amazing as well and a totally different experience. Now I’m willing to try all my whiskeys and realize that it can totally change the profile of the cocktail. I don’t know why I make rules for myself anymore.

  • @jasonkappel2630
    @jasonkappel2630 Рік тому

    I proof up my Eagle Rare with a little Stagg Jr on occasion in a home blend.

  • @docdp5532
    @docdp5532 Рік тому

    Love a good Old Fashion. Great video as always with Big Al.

  • @BrandochGarage
    @BrandochGarage Рік тому

    A lot of factors here to consider more than just the drink. Who is it for, how many? etc. Use the best ingredients you can comfortably afford. Just like cooking with wine. The better wines will generally make a better dinner.

  • @MrBoarder1188
    @MrBoarder1188 Рік тому

    Great work guys I appreciate the legitimately honest opinions, big whiskey fan.

  • @MtnLife-sv9fu
    @MtnLife-sv9fu Рік тому +1

    I actually checked out that coffea brand, very nice. Keep on keepin on...

  • @mechanix6191
    @mechanix6191 Рік тому

    I'd say it also depends on the cocktail. With a traditional Old Fashioned I'd prefer something from the higher end range, maybe less than $80, because the spirit isn't buried with a lot of other strong flavors, however, if I was making a smoked apple cinnamon Old Fashioned then I'd probably lean more towards the lower end because the spirit would be competing too much with other stuff.
    I'd probably also go lower end for a Lion's Tail because the lime and all spice would compete too much. But with a Vieux Carré I'd probably go higher end again.

  • @ZacBarclay
    @ZacBarclay Рік тому +1

    Not only do I dig your content, but watching how much fun you guys have together, is just the positivity we need on the interwebs. #GIMMIEAFLASK #SAVETHESTAGG

  • @johnandrus3901
    @johnandrus3901 Рік тому

    Nice comparison. It would have been interesting to compare the Scotch in something like a perfect or dry Rob Roy. The lighter flavored vermouth may have brought around a different result. Drambuie can really mask or overpower the Scotch, depending on how you mix them.

  • @David-ux4df
    @David-ux4df Рік тому

    You deserve a thumbs up for making that sentimental gentleman 👍🏽

  • @Maxstratus2002
    @Maxstratus2002 Рік тому

    The results were interesting and thank you for taking one for the team Jeremy.
    Now the real question would you have the same results for Rum and/or Blended Whiskey?

  • @K148-q9j
    @K148-q9j Рік тому

    Great video! Completely agree with y’all! Hurt my heart seeing that Stagg Jr going into a cocktail! Been fortunate enough to try it a couple of times, but still haven’t been able to get my mitts on a bottle…keep up the great work! Cheers!!!🥃

  • @curtischeeks919
    @curtischeeks919 Рік тому

    Love your videos! Love you and the wife together! Thanks so much. You made my night.

  • @fredaripco3897
    @fredaripco3897 Рік тому

    Jeremy, Friendly recommendation you need to try Auchentoshan 3 wood.

  • @cirojr82
    @cirojr82 Рік тому

    Sir, you shoud definitely bring your Mrs. more to the show. Such a pleasant surprise to see you both sharing thoughts and ideas. Greetings from Brazil.

  • @RockabillyJames1
    @RockabillyJames1 Рік тому

    Stumbled upon your channel a few days ago and went with your recommendation for budget bourbons. Used Wild Turkey 101 for an old fashioned last night and it was killer. Thanks! By the way, I love Beard Brand and hang out with the guys every time I'm in Austin.

  • @mbizzle03
    @mbizzle03 Рік тому

    I've had expensive whiskeys and Wild Turkey 101 is still my favorite.

  • @Sixx28
    @Sixx28 Рік тому

    Years ago I made up a cocktail called “What a pear!” Using Stagg Jr, unfiltered apple juice, pear liqueur, some bitters, and pear slices! I remember it being quite good. Just haven’t had the chance to get Stagg Jr again to make it. Haha

  • @silversevenescapes
    @silversevenescapes Рік тому

    Awesome Video!! you guys have such great points of views on whiskey and a great variety of cocktails.

  • @davidpretorius
    @davidpretorius Рік тому

    Guys, this was awesome. Thank you

  • @shawndaniel2719
    @shawndaniel2719 Рік тому

    Nothing like a good drink and a cigar !!!!👍🏻

  • @karloruiz5163
    @karloruiz5163 Рік тому

    Awesomeness!!
    Always a pleasure..
    Monkey shoulder rocks…. As a budget mixer scotch…
    Cheers

  • @victorcoronado5048
    @victorcoronado5048 Рік тому

    Great video! I totally agree, save the top shelf for sipping and savoring!
    #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @davidbarnish1143
    @davidbarnish1143 Рік тому

    I agree don’t use expensive whiskey for cocktails. I use Makers Mark or Wild Turkey 101

  • @tonycappuccino7897
    @tonycappuccino7897 Рік тому

    Ginger Ale replacement = Polar ginger lime mule seltzer with your whiskey of choice and lime… game over 💪🏻

  • @piperjon
    @piperjon Рік тому

    Great Video. I have to wonder what the result would have been had you used rare bread vs stagg. Still would have been budget vs expensive but the proof would have been closer.

  • @bandicootman
    @bandicootman Рік тому

    You guys should try the comparison on a rob roy or a perfect rob Roy

  • @chrisrampley5985
    @chrisrampley5985 Рік тому

    Best timed “that’s what she said” maybe, ever! Well done!

  • @itsmariotamez
    @itsmariotamez Рік тому

    I entered into the whiskey world because of you man! Great video 👏

  • @anthonyavila4027
    @anthonyavila4027 Рік тому

    I really can't believe you used stagg jr. In a mixed drink , but it was awesome to see , really enjoy your content.

  • @revdforster
    @revdforster Рік тому

    Y'all killing it, If this was a podcast I'd listen for hours

    • @revdforster
      @revdforster Рік тому

      NM, I wrote this prematurely before the video wrapped. Love the other channel

  • @tennesseejed187
    @tennesseejed187 Рік тому

    Not to snob out but there is a mash bill component in an old fashion. OGD being high rye compared to EHT makes sense as to why it would be favorable. They're both fine whiskeys but if I'm picking one for that specific cocktail its always the high rye regardless of brand, cost, perception, or hyped cost. A cocktail is a recipe and like any recipe and the ingredients are important to creating the desired experience. For my taste rye or high rye bourbon in an old fashion is the way to go.

  • @jackwilson4284
    @jackwilson4284 Рік тому

    I prefer a Smokey Nail, Ardbeg and Talisker work well without being too expensive

  • @brockhalliwell3035
    @brockhalliwell3035 Рік тому

    Really enjoyed this one guys! You two have a great way about you and very entertaining. I agree, very disrespectful to put a high end scotch in a cocktail 😮😊

  • @MjMeathammer
    @MjMeathammer Рік тому

    I'm glad to see that I'm not the only one that finds that there are cheaper alternative whiskies for cocktails. I typically use bottom shelf for mixed drinks (whiskey & coke), mid range for cocktails and the higher priced bottles for just enjoying neat. #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @Cobra97forme
    @Cobra97forme Рік тому

    As always, awesome video. Thanks for burning through that bank breaking whiskey for our entertainment!

  • @jeremyherring3388
    @jeremyherring3388 Рік тому

    Another great video. I won't use my more expensive bottles in a cocktail and I will vary the amount of mixer used to pair with the whiskey (lower proof = less mixer). Try using the walnut bitters in the old fashion to make the drink even better and Famous Grouse is another budget friendly scotch whisky to use in a cocktail. #gimmieaflask #savethestaff

  • @dry509
    @dry509 11 місяців тому

    What is your favorite for old fashioned?

  • @matthewalexanderkatsock
    @matthewalexanderkatsock Рік тому

    Love the chemistry between you two. Always a good one with Big Al! #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @marshallbuckley1094
    @marshallbuckley1094 Рік тому

    Stagg Jr is possibly the best bourbon I’ve ever had the pleasure of trying. Thanks for taking one (few) for the team! #savethestagg

  • @paulcernansky7634
    @paulcernansky7634 Рік тому

    I cried seeing you mix an $800 bottle of scotch 😢. Thanks for taking one for the team! #gimmeaflask #savethestagg

  • @FrogPondBrewery1
    @FrogPondBrewery1 Рік тому

    What walnut liquor did you use?

  • @mkramme
    @mkramme Рік тому

    The Old Fashion is now my favorite after trying many mixed drinks, that is if I am not drinking my Whiskey straight.
    Thanks for introduction to Wild Turkey as a good price point Whiskey, with Big Al giving it a thumbs up to another fellow woman Whiskey lover. #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @angelogabriel6862
    @angelogabriel6862 Рік тому

    Honestly, there is no one, not a single human, capable of delivering B-Roll like Jeremy

  • @bertdram4087
    @bertdram4087 Рік тому

    I like the videos with the both of you. you are a great team!

  • @karatekid10908
    @karatekid10908 Рік тому

    always curious how expensive to go before its not worth it anymore. Budget budget really makes a difference in cocktails I dont think medium to expensive does. Love your videos #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @gregflores5839
    @gregflores5839 Рік тому

    Yes !!!! Don't use good stuff in mix drinks. I like eagle rare, blantons, Buffalo trace on the rocks. That's it .

  • @3rdnut1
    @3rdnut1 Рік тому

    J T S Brown is my mixer go too.

  • @blind7000
    @blind7000 Рік тому

    19:05 Love the video and the idea but here is what I have found, when you change the whiskey you need to change your proportions. Even when talking cheaper if I go higher proof vs lower proof, if I have a very barrel forward or sweet forward or wine finish forward whiskey. You adjust to emphasize the whiskey it is in, same way you would with using a fancy ingredient cooking.
    Now you can't really do that in a head to head or you would know right away but that is what I found the key to getting the most out of a cocktail with an expensive or fancy whiskey.
    #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @monagave
    @monagave Рік тому

    I love the cocktail content Jeremy

  • @Gzickgraf
    @Gzickgraf Рік тому

    This was another fun one! Super cool idea to actually test the blind preferences. While i usually tend to throw higher proofed whiskeys in my cocktails to keep the whiskey flavors strong, I tend to keep my less budget friendly ones away from mixers. Also, Fred Noe, Jim Beam Master Distiller's quote is the best way to "drink whiskey is any d*mn way you please"
    #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @davids2911
    @davids2911 Рік тому

    Wonder how OGD114 would of compared on the ginger drink

  • @72kennym
    @72kennym Рік тому +2

    Feel your pain mixing some of those! 😂 Thanks for taking that for the team! #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @Tracylord25
    @Tracylord25 Рік тому

    Another great video brother!! Welcome back Big Al!! Always a pleasure seeing you too!! #GIMMEAFLASK #SAVETHESTAGG

  • @robertjay1179
    @robertjay1179 Рік тому

    Hey, that was fun
    Watching!

  • @nickmanville900
    @nickmanville900 Рік тому +1

    As difficult as it may be to find, Stagg is still just a $60 bottle of bourbon.
    I literally picked some up last week at my local convenience store for $60 (The new batch 19 22B is great!).
    It's great stuff, but please don't let yourself get ripped off by the scalpers. This is by no means $250+ whiskey.
    Sure, if you want some right this instant, it'll cost you about that much.
    But if you find the right place and get your name on a list you can get one within a few weeks/months for a much fairer price.

    • @JeremySiers
      @JeremySiers  Рік тому +2

      Brotha I wish that were true everywhere, unfortunately it just isn’t. I haven’t seen a bottle of stagg in my area for over 5 years for less than $150. Some places just don’t get the same allocations that other areas do. Sooo, unfortunately if you want a bottle you have to pay. I am pretty close with all the local stores because of how much whiskey I buy and I still can’t get a bottle for close to the $60 your talking about. 😏

    • @nickmanville900
      @nickmanville900 Рік тому +2

      @@JeremySiers Damn that's really unfortunate.
      I'm just about as far as you can get from Kentucky while staying within the US here in Seattle. I was thinking if we were getting it for MSRP distribution must have been getting more reliable. Maybe there just isnt enough demand in my area for people to be price gouging.

    • @JeremySiers
      @JeremySiers  Рік тому

      Yeah man, the whiskey business is a weird one. Especially with allocated whiskeys like stagg jr, George t stagg, Weller, etc. Different areas get different allocations. Some areas don’t get any at all. So depending on the amount allocated to an area and the demand in that area prices can be all over the place. It’s a cluster f$ck to be honest 😜😂. Some states also have restrictions where they have to sell it at a certain price. Others don’t, so prices can go a bit crazy depending on how rare it is.

  • @rooster1266
    @rooster1266 Рік тому

    Love when big Al stops by for some whiskey videos. #Gimmeaflask #savethestag

  • @danbarber1984
    @danbarber1984 Рік тому

    Love the WT101 for sippin and mixin. #givemeaflask #savethestagg

  • @cjckmn
    @cjckmn Рік тому

    Good video. Gotta love the Rusty Nail! DRAMBUIE!!! Thanks for the entertainment and takin one for the team. Don't know that I'd have the stones to put the 38 year in anything but a pristine Glencarin. #gimmeaflask #savethestagg

  • @rdevous
    @rdevous Рік тому

    Have you tried Mr. Black a coffee liqueur…love to make Iced coffee with a triple shot, Half and Half,sweetened to taste with several Splenda packets…keep the videos coming…

  • @davidgammon4399
    @davidgammon4399 Рік тому

    Love the video,did you and AL finish the cocktails

  • @StefonCarpinoMagic
    @StefonCarpinoMagic Рік тому

    My buddy and I have a phrase “Coke your blue“ meaning to enjoy whatever it is you have how you have it. Kind of like the whiskey tribe. If you want to put Johnny Walker blue into your glass of Coke, all the power to you. He was gifted a small bottle of Johnny Walker blue, and we both tried it and decided that it is no better than Johnny Walker Black. That’s just our opinion, of course that is subjective. We still have the bottle, and the only time we use it is if someone decides to be a snob and we want to make them cringe by pouring an ounce or so into a glass of Coke. Love the content! #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @vancesmith4743
    @vancesmith4743 Рік тому

    I love when you guys do these comparison videos, especially “ Big All”. You guys are a professional couple in the beginning, by the end, you guys are LOUD, GIGGLY AND CURSING. SHIT IF FUNNY AS HELL! 😂😂😂😂

  • @dirtycommtroop
    @dirtycommtroop Рік тому

    I make all my Manhattans with Old Forester 100 pf Rye. If I'm mixing I want 100 proof and it doesn't have to be expensive.

  • @GhastlyGrapes
    @GhastlyGrapes Рік тому

    Love me a whiskey ginger

  • @TobyGuidry
    @TobyGuidry Рік тому

    I have this conversation all the time. My rule of thumb is that I'm not going to use a bottle over $35 as a mixer. Sure, it may make a great cocktail, but it's not worth the difference in flavor. I go for the dual threats like Rittenhouse Rye where it's good either way (cocktail or neat). #gimmieaflask #savethestagg

  • @jessecarstens
    @jessecarstens Рік тому

    Love when you two get together and drink like this! #GIMMIEAFLASK #SAVETHESTAGG

  • @Mikey_556
    @Mikey_556 Рік тому

    Do u guys pre game with a drink before recording? I definitely would . Great video 🍻

  • @thomashoffmann3212
    @thomashoffmann3212 Рік тому

    #givemeaflask #savethestag I am Single Malt Scotch snob! But I tried Monkey Shoulders several years ago when it first came out and it is the only blended scotch I will drink! You are right it is sacrilegious to mix expensive whiskey in a cocktail! Love your show!

  • @jayinu
    @jayinu Рік тому

    Some of my favorite videos are the ones with Big Al! Always a good time. #GIMMIEAFLASK #SAVETHESTAGG

  • @Brewzle
    @Brewzle Рік тому

    Let's see how the Stagg, Jr holds up to Rare Breed instead of the 101 proof Turkey.

    • @treborkroy5280
      @treborkroy5280 Рік тому

      Hear a lot of people say they prefer the 101, something about being balanced better.

  • @craigc8542
    @craigc8542 Рік тому

    Monkey Shoulder is a good budget scotch, but If you're willing to entertain a suggestion from another whiskey drinker, you should try McClelland's Highland. It's one of those bottles that's priced well below its worth. You and "Big AL" keep it up these videos. My wife & I love em - Thanks

  • @jerudcozine1383
    @jerudcozine1383 Рік тому

    Man that Gentleman is Pricey! $64 just in scotch per glass. You definitely took it for the team.

  • @ronhofferber9847
    @ronhofferber9847 Рік тому

    Great video, but painful to waste the stagg. Y’all do well together.

  • @odieman8526
    @odieman8526 Рік тому

    Thanks for taking one for the team using your expensive whisky
    #givemeaflask #savethestagg