Thank-you for contributing to a science-based understanding of Gender Dysphoria. We, as people with GD, deserve accurate answers about the condition(s) we have.
I had dysphoria since 5 years old , I feel it's an innate condition, I early in life started acting differently from my sex . I was afraid from others reaction . I suprressed these feelings , but they came back in my 30s . Now I'm trans . Non transitioned
Well done Dr Bailey. Very clearly put. "Concerns" - yep, what a catchall. When I practiced as a lawyer sometimes the other side would say they had "concerns" about someone and very few magistrates would press the point and insist that the "concerns" be validly based with evidence to show for it.
I appreciate Bailey and his work but he says at around 29:00 that he doesn't think that pornography causes autogynephilia yet the screen says definitively "pornography does not cause male sexuality, it reveals it". Yet.... He straight after says that we don't know what causes autogynephilia. So don't say either that you think porn isn't the cause and also don't say that porn *doesn't cause it*, definitively. On the other hand, I know that those academics and professionals who bring gender and trans into question need to be careful with what they say. Kenneth Zucker knows this all too well, as well.
I think it’s implied by the context that the screen comment means that it is more likely that watching autogynephilic pornography reveals autogynephilia rather than causes it.
I dont think autogynaphilia is a paraphilia. Its heterosexual gender dysphoria. There is some individuals who experience dysphoria at an early age . Before experiencing any sexual fantasy
Thank you for your information and understanding. I follow many transgender people and a few de-transitioners. I hope they study rapid onset and hormones for young adults. 🙏
Yeah... you lost me at the assumption that Jazz wouldn't have transitioned had she not been allowed to transition at childhood. If that were the case, there would not be older transitioned trans women. I have a feeling this is just as misguided and foolish as the whatever camp. He's also hanging a lot on autogynophilia. There's a lot of problems with that hypothesis, and he's just stating it like its fact. Why are most bi and female attracted trans women more likely to be partnered? If you are attracted to yourself being a woman, wouldn't you be attracted to yourself?What about transwomen who were questioning their gender at a young age, like four or five, and are still attracted to women? That seems to contradict his whole argument right there. Especially when presented as they are exclusive from each other. Honestly, this just sounds like transphobia disguised as a scientific discussion.
I agree as well. Another big tell is that he refers to people with Disassocitive Identity Disorder as multiple personality disorder. It hasnt been called this in decades.
He doesn’t claim that Jazz definitely would not have transition if she had been encouraged during childhood to be male. He pointed out that it is important to consider the counterfactual. If she had experienced adolescence and early adulthood as a male she would have had opportunities to have positive experiences as a male. That might have caused her gender dysphoria to resolve without the need for endocrine and surgical interventions.
He addressed the topic of young boys who question their agenda in the section about early onset gender dysphoria. He says that rapid onset gender dysphoria among male adolescents is strongly associated with autogynephilia. However, he points out that that not all autogynephiles experience gender dysphoria. He specifically says that autogynephiles are NOT aroused by themselves - they do not have a narcissistic form of sexual arousal. He also says that autogynephiles typically have sexual relationships with women. Autogynephilia is not a substitute for wanting to have a mutually satisfying sexual relationship with another person.
@nicholashaines8481 there is no such thing as rapid onset gender dysphoria. It's made up. The hypothesis was based on junk science, by talking to the parents of children who are not accepting of their children, and not talking to transgender children themselves.
One day we will secure all privacy for all trans people who will be respected and treated as their gender with love respect and PRIVACY of all gender related documents and care. No longer will gender be a test of passing or unpassing and medical privacy will become number one in the fight against the attack of female privacy rights everywhere for All females and compassion for the privacy right of trans identity and respect for our fellow man and woman !!! ❤🎉❤ it begins with us!
The standard of care in Europe is counseling into the upper teens, with possible use of blockers to delay physical disformity. Heavy on self understanding and support. He is not a clinician or a medical doctor. He is a research psychologist. Apples and oranges.
Orwellian abuse of language to call puberty a physical deformity. Europe is reversing course on Dr. Mengele-type experiments on children and the U.S. needs to catch up.
Dr. Bailey is a victim of persecution and censorship by trans activists who have been successful in interfering with the article on rapid onset gender dysphoria mentioned above. If I were in Dr. Bailey's position, I would be consulting with a qualified attorney as to my prospects of recovering monetary damages and other forms of compensation from those responsible. Note: I am a 1970s graduate of what was then known simply as Northwestern University's College of Arts and Sciences.
@@cactusrabbit1681 "Dr. Bailey is a victim of persecution and censorship by trans activists who have been successful in interfering with the article on rapid onset gender dysphoria mentioned above." The article was retracted on dubious grounds solely because of pressure from trans activists and trans "allies."
There is no such thing as Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria. I am a transexual, and certified counselor in Europe. Any person who is transsexual has to have evidence of the permanence the condition. Counselors and doctors who are reputable work through all aspects.
Is it child abuse to expose a child to pornographic material? I wonder if the girls presenting in such high numbers could be a trauma response to their innocence being destroyed by facilitators disrespecting age appropriate boundaries.
Michael Bailey is one of the most unethical researchers on this subject that has ever lived. His last research used the same unethical methods that f his first. He’s proven he can’t handle or do science. Why are you still giving him any time?
The organization platforming him knows exactly what they're doing. They make every attempt to appear non-partisan, but their agenda is clear once you look into them.
Thank-you for contributing to a science-based understanding of Gender Dysphoria. We, as people with GD, deserve accurate answers about the condition(s) we have.
I had dysphoria since 5 years old , I feel it's an innate condition, I early in life started acting differently from my sex . I was afraid from others reaction . I suprressed these feelings , but they came back in my 30s . Now I'm trans . Non transitioned
A really insightful and informative presentation. Thank you so much
Well done Dr Bailey. Very clearly put. "Concerns" - yep, what a catchall. When I practiced as a lawyer sometimes the other side would say they had "concerns" about someone and very few magistrates would press the point and insist that the "concerns" be validly based with evidence to show for it.
Thank you! Excellent and fair-minded treatment of the topic.
I appreciate Bailey and his work but he says at around 29:00 that he doesn't think that pornography causes autogynephilia yet the screen says definitively "pornography does not cause male sexuality, it reveals it".
Yet.... He straight after says that we don't know what causes autogynephilia.
So don't say either that you think porn isn't the cause and also don't say that porn *doesn't cause it*, definitively.
On the other hand, I know that those academics and professionals who bring gender and trans into question need to be careful with what they say. Kenneth Zucker knows this all too well, as well.
Yep. Zucker with all his experience was no match for the bs, hateful extremists that so many people give into.
I think it’s implied by the context that the screen comment means that it is more likely that watching autogynephilic pornography reveals autogynephilia rather than causes it.
I dont think autogynaphilia is a paraphilia. Its heterosexual gender dysphoria. There is some individuals who experience dysphoria at an early age . Before experiencing any sexual fantasy
Thank you for your information and understanding. I follow many transgender people and a few de-transitioners. I hope they study rapid onset and hormones for young adults. 🙏
Thank you for your work with this! You are appreciated!! ❤
I would like more information about autohomoerotic gender dysphoria in females. Are there studies?
One of the few accurate sources on gender dysphoria in male adolescents.
Thank you 🙏🩺
Yeah... you lost me at the assumption that Jazz wouldn't have transitioned had she not been allowed to transition at childhood. If that were the case, there would not be older transitioned trans women. I have a feeling this is just as misguided and foolish as the whatever camp.
He's also hanging a lot on autogynophilia. There's a lot of problems with that hypothesis, and he's just stating it like its fact. Why are most bi and female attracted trans women more likely to be partnered? If you are attracted to yourself being a woman, wouldn't you be attracted to yourself?What about transwomen who were questioning their gender at a young age, like four or five, and are still attracted to women? That seems to contradict his whole argument right there. Especially when presented as they are exclusive from each other.
Honestly, this just sounds like transphobia disguised as a scientific discussion.
I 100% agree with you!! That was very well said, thank you for sharing!
I agree as well.
Another big tell is that he refers to people with Disassocitive Identity Disorder as multiple personality disorder. It hasnt been called this in decades.
He doesn’t claim that Jazz definitely would not have transition if she had been encouraged during childhood to be male. He pointed out that it is important to consider the counterfactual. If she had experienced adolescence and early adulthood as a male she would have had opportunities to have positive experiences as a male. That might have caused her gender dysphoria to resolve without the need for endocrine and surgical interventions.
He addressed the topic of young boys who question their agenda in the section about early onset gender dysphoria. He says that rapid onset gender dysphoria among male adolescents is strongly associated with autogynephilia. However, he points out that that not all autogynephiles experience gender dysphoria. He specifically says that autogynephiles are NOT aroused by themselves - they do not have a narcissistic form of sexual arousal. He also says that autogynephiles typically have sexual relationships with women. Autogynephilia is not a substitute for wanting to have a mutually satisfying sexual relationship with another person.
@nicholashaines8481 there is no such thing as rapid onset gender dysphoria. It's made up. The hypothesis was based on junk science, by talking to the parents of children who are not accepting of their children, and not talking to transgender children themselves.
One day we will secure all privacy for all trans people who will be respected and treated as their gender with love respect and PRIVACY of all gender related documents and care. No longer will gender be a test of passing or unpassing and medical privacy will become number one in the fight against the attack of female privacy rights everywhere for All females and compassion for the privacy right of trans identity and respect for our fellow man and woman !!! ❤🎉❤ it begins with us!
It will be a better world when this is so.
The standard of care in Europe is counseling into the upper teens, with possible use of blockers to delay physical disformity. Heavy on self understanding and support. He is not a clinician or a medical doctor. He is a research psychologist. Apples and oranges.
Blockers cause deformity
Orwellian abuse of language to call puberty a physical deformity. Europe is reversing course on Dr. Mengele-type experiments on children and the U.S. needs to catch up.
Dr. Bailey is a victim of persecution and censorship by trans activists who have been successful in interfering with the article on rapid onset gender dysphoria mentioned above. If I were in Dr. Bailey's position, I would be consulting with a qualified attorney as to my prospects of recovering monetary damages and other forms of compensation from those responsible. Note: I am a 1970s graduate of what was then known simply as Northwestern University's College of Arts and Sciences.
That article was retracted though...
@@cactusrabbit1681 "Dr. Bailey is a victim of persecution and censorship by trans activists who have been successful in interfering with the article on rapid onset gender dysphoria mentioned above." The article was retracted on dubious grounds solely because of pressure from trans activists and trans "allies."
There is no such thing as Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria. I am a transexual, and certified counselor in Europe. Any person who is transsexual has to have evidence of the permanence the condition. Counselors and doctors who are reputable work through all aspects.
Thank you for sharing this!! I completely agree with you !!
As if your ilk wants any good research done of ROGD.
Is it child abuse to expose a child to pornographic material?
I wonder if the girls presenting in such high numbers could be a trauma response to their innocence being destroyed by facilitators disrespecting age appropriate boundaries.
If you understood transgenersism you would suggest such a thing.
Thank you
Your so full of it
Michael Bailey is one of the most unethical researchers on this subject that has ever lived. His last research used the same unethical methods that f his first. He’s proven he can’t handle or do science. Why are you still giving him any time?
The organization platforming him knows exactly what they're doing. They make every attempt to appear non-partisan, but their agenda is clear once you look into them.
This is old disproved science.
This guy is going backwards
I just farted.
It obviously is a brain fart! I can smell it through the screen, the stentch