I probably should have explained more on why I chose B, which is because there wasn’t really any other characters that I think would be as entertaining I’d definitely love to see him over Anne Maria that’s for sure. Plus keep in mind the gen 2 cast only had 1 season so it’s a lot more harder to breakdown, As For Lindsay’s voice actor I kept hearing mixed results on if it was action or all stars so that’s why I didn’t confirm anything
@@Gummyz25 lot of ppl will disagree but I just think with them having only 1 season to shine and there performance of what we did get it’s enough for me imo
@Shorts From The Pit not dawn, like b she was a relatively early boot and imo gets tons more attention from the fan base than she deserves, she’s hardly done anything and doesn’t qualify as an all-star imo
Y’know what I would have preferred? A Not-Star season. Where they brought back low placing/early eliminated contestants to compete to give them more focus and make them shine
Ive done so many versions of this on tier list maker and tyler noah and harold are usualy my higest picks for winner. i would prefer it to be called Total Drama Losers then not stars thoough
Yesss Tyler, Brick and Harold, are so underrated Owen, Cameron and Harold would do so well Also I can’t stand Trent in the slightest If Justin was in it, he’d be out quite quickly, tricked by Alejandro G3 I’d bring back Shawn, Ella, Topher, Max, Beardo and my boy Rodney
Personally since Mal was incredibly awful as a villain I would prefer Anne Maria being the principal antagonist, also she was about to make it to Merge in TDROTI but it seemed like they wanted to throw her away so they gave her that stupid elimination
Kinda weird how Pakithew is considered season 5 when it's more season 6. Tyler deserves a redemption and i imagine him on a wholesome friendship with Brick as both guys share a good sportsmanship & loyalty.
Yeah that’s true I should have mentioned that and I used to call it season 6 a lot too lol I don’t get how it’s called season 5B when revenge of the island was it’s own thing
@@ListsofLegends Exactly. It will always stay as season 6 in my books. instead of the cheesy season 5.5 . Makes no sense. And TDRR is season 7 also (for me)
I personally think at least Leshawna, Harold, and Dakota would have saved all stars. Cody, Brick, Ane Maria, Noah, Tyler, DJ, Justin, and Owen would have saved the show as well. But I think the main problem with making an all stars season at the time it was released was that there isn't much to work with. There are only two casts of characters to choose the "best of the best" out of, so it would have been better for this season to be made after the revival, or even after the ridonculous race, because then there would be lots more to work with.
Eva would have been a good option too; her temper would put her in the villainous team by default, but since she's not an actually bad person, she'd be trying to make them all to behave and play fair, even if she'd do it though intimidation.
It would be interesting if they gave more focus to certain things they said in their audition tapes. Like I think Brick mentions wanting to use the prize money for fashion school or something, he could have an interesting friendship with Lindsay. Or they could make Leonard more like an actual LARPer with random knowledge pertaining to battle tactics and military history which could give him a weird friendship with Brick too or earn respect from some of the other contestants. Beardo and B could possibly even be friends with the not talking thing and having an understanding. Justin and Alejandro would be a very interesting team. They have so much in common, but they're so different. Or they could be rivals and it makes Justin a better villain or hero. Pairing up contestants with people similar to them could be interesting considering how many there are.
Top 8 characters that should have been in TD allstars (in my opinion:) 8: Ann Maria 7: Owen 6: Bridgette 5: Dawn 4: Harold 3: justin 2: Leshawna 1: Brick Honorble mentions: izzy, DJ, Dakota, Cody, Noah, Trent, Tyler, & B.
My all stars cast: Total cast: 22 14 island members (7 boys, 7 girls) Courtney Duncan Heather Alejandro Gwen Owen Leshawna Noah Lindsey Tyler Izzy Justin Sierra Cody 8 tdiroti members (4 girls, 4 boys) Anne Maria Lightning Dawn Scott Jo Brick Zoe Mike Villains: Heroes: Courtney Izzy Gwen Leshawna Heather Lindsey Anne Maria Dawn Jo Zoe Alejandro Sierra Duncan Cody Justin Tyler Scott Mike Lightning Brick Noah Owen
Here's my opinion about Owen being in all stars: I actually like Owen but I personally don't think he deserves to be in All Stars. Ask me why? He already was in 4 seasons, Tdi, Tda, Tdwt, and Tdrr. I feel like he already had a lot of screentime and tere wasn't much else they could do with his character. This is just my opinion don't come at me for it 20 likes and I'll do why or why not do I want someone else to be in all stars
7:55 Owen wasn’t added because his voice actor wasn’t avaliable until the finale. That’s why Owen made a cameo appearance. Because of that, they replaced Owen with Sam and gave all of Owen’s roles to Sam.
They could’ve at least replaced owen with a different character from gen 1 or gen 2 because sam didn’t even make it to the merge. And sam was basically an environmental punching bag.
Characters from gen 1 that should’ve been in all stars Owen: come on its Owen, EVERYBODY’S GOTTA LIKE THIS LOVABLE GOOFBALL he’s literally on all the promotion posters Noah: if Noah and Owen was in all stars, there’d be a storyline between the two and their friendship and Noah would get more screen time Tyler: if Tyler was in all stars, maybe Lindsay wouldn’t have been the first boot, they could’ve formed an alliance Izzy: Izzy is a Brazil sized nut job in Noah’s words, and more moments of her being crazy would be perfect for all stars Harold: maybe if harold was in all stars his rivalry with Duncan would continue, plus he was literally robbed by Owen in action Leshawna: if they put Leshawna in all stars her rivalry with heather would be continued so Leshawna should have been in all stars 100% Cody: if they put Cody in all stars it would fix Sierra’s problem with Cameron and her derailment Beth: she was the alternate winner of action, and your telling me she shouldn’t be in all stars? Maybe she could’ve made a friendship with Sierra Characters from Gen 2 that should’ve been in all stars Brick if it’s gonna be heroes vs villains, then why isn’t brick there? He literally saved everyone in the cave, he’s the real hero, plus his rivalry with Jo would continue so that would be nice Silent B: since he didn’t have much screen time on revenge of the island, with his smarts, he could’ve carried the heroes team in every challenge Dawn: she could’ve maybe done something this time, and she could’ve used her aura powers and notice that mike is actually a villain, and try to warn her team Dakota: maybe they could’ve fixed her character and not make her dakotazoid, then if she was in all stars, it would make Sam’s character more interesting
I think ezekiel should have came back because: 1: he could start to learn how to be human again by watching the other contestants and learning from them 2: he could have also used his money to become normal again if he won (well, if he desired normal-ness) 3: even if he gets eliminated first again, at least we can see how he competes as a feral animal. 4: he’s one of my favourite characters too,
I love Beth and I think she should have returned in tdas Now don't get me wrong but she was part of the reason Lindsay did so well in tda however this time around Beth would have been an early boot for all stars which would have made Lindsay need to strategize and search for new allies and that would've made her a really good winner in all stars
Wow, very good you got most of my characters of who I think should have been on total drama All-Stars except for one which was Cody because he worked very hard to get to the final three in world tour and besides Cody working together again with Sierra would be awesome
seen a few theories surrounding why he wasn’t in universe as for this one it’s possible but the bro literally was back to compete in no time flat when the WT plane fell on him
Here are my picks: Dawn (replacing Sierra) Brick (replacing Sam) Harold (Heroes team) Leshawna (Heroes team) DJ (Heroes team) Beth/Izzy (Heroes team) Justin (Villains team) Anne Maria (Villains team) (I think she's not really a bad person, but she's not the nicest either) Also in this timeline, Duncan and Courtney would both be in the Villains team from the start to make the teams balanced.
My top 8 people who should of been in all stars are 1 owen because he deserves it 2 leshawna I can see her making it far 3 brick I can see him making it far to 4 dawn because she has so much potential 5 Harold because he could bring a lot to the table 6 Anne maria since she was meant to be in it but they cut her and Owen out last second 7 Justin because he could interact well with Anne maria and the fans ship them so ye 8 b since I would like to see him and dawn interact
Arguments Can Be Made That Anne Maria Should Be On This List, As She Was Originally Going To Be In It, But Then Got Replaced By Gwen. In Fact, Every Character Would Be Great In All Stars (Other Than Staci, Dakotazoid, Katie, And Sadie). And Yeah, Owen Is The Only Winner Not In All Stars Other Than Beth.
3:50 the reason why b and Dawn ere eliminated early and not considered for all stars was that they were last minute additions. They weren’t in the prototype, they were last minute additions and early elimination fitter. A lot of people want them both back(especially Dawn) but they not only weren’t included, they weren’t even considered. Edit: So, yeah, Owen, Cody, Anne Maria and Brick were all confirmed to return but got replaced. Leshawna, Harold, Justin and Noah were considered but never put in the final production.
Owen would be a good fit for all stars but I think they didn’t include him since he was in rr personally I wouldn’t want to see Owen for five seasons(especially how he made the finale,third place,8th place, and then the nineteenth out of 26th episode in rr)
I feel like Lashawna,Brick, Owen, and Dawn could’ve been in All Stars because Leshawna was 5th place in the first season and if it wasn’t for her dumb elimination in the episode Haute Campture,she would’ve gotten farther.i also would’ve liked to see how she would interact with the gen 2 cast.It would’ve been cool to see her friendship with heather again because they seriously messed it up in world tour. Heather didn’t even do anything in the challenge where she beat heather up. Brick should’ve been in all stars because he was a good leader and like you said , the writers could’ve continued his rivalry with jo because i enjoyed their rivalry in revenge of the island because i found it funny. And maybe the writers could’ve made them into a couple. I think Owen should’ve been in all stars because he made it pretty far in the seasons that he was in. I also would’ve loved to see him interact with the gen 2 cast. I feel like zoey, mike, & cam would’ve been really good friends with Owen.Lastly, i feel like Dawn should have been in all stars so that she could actually do something in challenges because she barely did anything for her team to help win the challenge. She was mostly reading people’s auras.I would also like to see how she would interact with the people from gen 1.A lot of people think that anne maria should have been in this season but i don’t really agree because anne maria didn’t really do anything to help her team win the challenges. All she did was tend to her hair and tan.
I feel that those decisions would have definitely helped improve all stars I voted B should be in all stars as well while yes he didn’t make it far but I feel you should compensate a bit more for revenge of the Island characters since they had only 1 season prior to all stars to shine and it was a shorter seasons with the shortest cast. Owen definitely should’ve been In there since he’s practically the face of total drama next to Chris
Brick should’ve been in there, Izzy and Owen could’ve gotten together again, Anne Maria could’ve gotten revenge, Justin could’ve been in there for more “villainous” actions and would get what he wants like what he usually does and would work well with Alejandro and Pahkitew Island should’ve been in there before All Stars and Trent needed to be there and the fact that there should’ve been more characters, people always make non canon Total Drama seasons and make Justin and Anne Maria date, and who replaced Brick and Anne Maria?
You forgot someone… WHERES ANNE MARIA!? She is totally an All-Star and could have possibly made it to the finale with a possible alliance with Leshawna and Cameron against like Mal or Tyler or something She is totally an All-Star and deserves to be in said season!
This is how All Stars should've turned out. Have Owen and Beth compete since they were finalists and replace Sierra and Sam with Brick and Anne Maria. Have Scott and Courtney the Final 2. Have Good writing for the characters. Have Mal never exist. And have a better elimination order.
I think if any Winner Wins again it should be Heather bc she was the only character who never got her money. I guess u could argue Owen never got it since he decided to do Action. But still. Heathers money literally got stolen out of her hands.
i won't take away any characters, but i would add leshawna owen harold brick anne maria cody beth and dakotazoid, not as a contestant or intern, but as just moral support for sam
My list that who should have been in All-Stars: 1. Cody All though he competed World Tour, i wanted him in All-Stars, for obvious reasons. 2. Anne Maria She wanted to quit in Revenge of the Island, but got her diamond along with Brick being eliminated, so i want her in this. :/ 3. Izzy She already was in All-Stars but not competed, she was gonna compete in this season. 4. Harold his beatbox is good, he was supposed to be in All-Stars. 5. Brick I wish he was in All-Stars ;-; 6. Dawn Same as Brick 7. Leshawna Same as Brick and Dawn 8. (LAST) Owen Owen was already in All-Stars, but not competed along with Izzy, he appeared in the finale of All-Stars, i wish he was here. That's my list (Enjoy)
I’ve seen people say all stars and yeah a few action I couldn’t find any concrete info online so I just said whatever it was let’s pretend she got farther
If made total drama all-stars this is what it would look like Cast ⬇️ Harold (Heroes) Duncan (Villains) Gwen (Heroes) Courtney (Villains) Owen (Heroes) Lightning (Villains) Brick (Heroes) Jo (Villains) Lindsay (Heroes) Noah (Villains) Beth (Heroes) Justin (Villains) B (Heroes) Alejandro (Villains) Mike (Heroes) Heather (Villains) Zoey (Heroes) Scott (Villains) Cameron (Heroes) Anne-Maria (Villains) Sam (Heroes) Dakota (Villains) Dawn (Heroes) Leshawna (Villains) DJ (Heroes) Izzy (Villains) Tyler (Heroes) Sadie (Villains) Cody (Heroes) Blainley (Villains) Katie (Heroes)
Here’s my list 1:Noah 2:Owen 3:leshawna 4:Tyler 5:Dakota 6:I wish Lindsey would compete more 7:and Duncan wouldn’t be trying to prove he is a punk 8:and Alejandro not being brain dead
Will there be more all stars season because when you think about it if there ever is going to be a second All-Stars Chris should back everyone who's ever make it to the finale
So many people disagree with me on B but it’s my fault for not being clear about why I picked him, gen 2 didn’t get much screen time because they had one season that’s it pre all stars wise I just think B has better storyline than Anne Maria imo she’s better all stars worthy I’m by placement yes but if we went just based of that then it would have been lame in my book
Well she's not, all star material, just because somebody wasn't in 2 seasons doesn't mean they're 'robbed', and all stars is about the people who got furthest and played the best, eva got 2nd boot in 1 season
@@threeguysandagirlinabeachhouse with robbed i mean losing her golden oppertunity to particpate on the 2nd and 3rd season. Now it's much worse that Zeke is more relevant than her
For a redemption story yes, it’s like my reasoning with B story wise she’s better but I should have explained myself better in the video If we’re going just based off placement than it kinda doesn’t make much sense because revenge of the island cast only has one season pre all stars
I agree with nearly all of these I would love if B would return he was pretty interesting And Justin I would like him to return but the same as B I don't think the fully fit in the all stars category And once again this is a really good video
I would rather have Anne Maria in all stars instead of B since she got further, needs development and was planned to be in the cast, don't get me wrong I love B but I would rather have him in Fans Vs Favorites or Second Chances just my opinion tho
As for the several ppl you want to see back, i prefer not since they are the most overused characters whereas the underrated characters are losing sight, if you catch my drift. Maybe as a cameo it would be benefical, but not as a contestant-wise.
B being in all stars makes no sense. He placed 12th and only lasted 3 episodes. Instead, I’d add Anne Maria since she lasted much farther and was booted right before the merge. If we were to have 9 from each generation, just keep everyone who was originally in All Stars (yes including Sam), and just add in Brick and Anne Maria. Other than that, the list is fine. Nice vid.
@@ListsofLegends True. If I were to bring be back, it would probably be for another season that includes the revenge cast. Maybe have him show his full potential there. I liked that idea you came up with having the team decide if either Scott or B was the real enemy.
The only reason the writers scrapped Brick was because they wanted Sam to compete again. Why not just have both of them compete at the same time, or have Sam not compete at all
My perfect all stars cast: Gen 1: Owen,Gwen,Duncan,Heather,Alejandro,Courtney,Trent,Justin,LeShawna,Tyler Gen 2: Cameron,Lightning,Zoey,Scott,Jo,Mike,Brick,Anne Maria I think having the cast 50/50 is a disgrace towards gen 1 who had 22 characters with 3 seasons of development. If you want more gen 2 characters give them another season before all stars.
trents comes back then there is a love square he also would of been placed on the villians tean and duncan heroes team.trent could equally more drama since mal is there
B was in 3 episodes in a 13 episode season Katie was in 6 episodes in a 26 episode season so uhhh Katie deserves it just as much as B does And that's not a compliment
I feel like this had the potential to be the best season or equal to world tour if it was 26 episodes, had a bigger cast, def no Mal hate that guy and character assassin
and I also agree with you there they could have easily done something with all stars because when it was announced that gen 1 and gen 2 combining together I was like no way but than it didn't have some of the characters that you thought would going to come back which is complete bs it's not really an all star season to me but at the same time I still enjoyed it but the writing is terrible a total missed opportunity
MY ALL STARS we are not removing but adding players + pakitew island players will be in and CAST: Gen 1: Gwen Courtney Duncan Heather Lindsay Alejandro Sierra Owen Leshawna Gen 2: Jo Mike Zoey Sam Scott Lighting Cameron Brick Anne maria
You know the original cast was supposed to be gen 1 Noah,Justin,Cody,Courtney,Harold,Lindsey,Leshawna,Duncan,Heather,Owen and Alejandro gen 2 Brick,Anne Maria,Mike,Jo,Scott,Zoey,Lightning and Cameron originally Gwen was not planned for all stars
top 8 character that i would add in all star ( my opinion) 1st generation 1 leshawna 2 harold 3 Justin 4 eva 2 generation 1 dawn 2 anna maria 3 brick 4 B yeah that's it :/
My list (this is my list on who should have been in all stars so these aren't the characters I like the most and want to be in all stars but the people who deserved to be in all stars) 8: Trent 7: Brick 6: Geoff 5: Izzy 4: DJ 3: Harold 2: LeShawna 1: Owen
I probably should have explained more on why I chose B, which is because there wasn’t really any other characters that I think would be as entertaining I’d definitely love to see him over Anne Maria that’s for sure. Plus keep in mind the gen 2 cast only had 1 season so it’s a lot more harder to breakdown, As For Lindsay’s voice actor I kept hearing mixed results on if it was action or all stars so that’s why I didn’t confirm anything
@Shorts From The Pit yeah I can understand why people disagree though
I don’t think dawn or b should be in all stars. They were in 5 and 3 episodes as a contestant
@@Gummyz25 lot of ppl will disagree but I just think with them having only 1 season to shine and there performance of what we did get it’s enough for me imo
@Shorts From The Pit not dawn, like b she was a relatively early boot and imo gets tons more attention from the fan base than she deserves, she’s hardly done anything and doesn’t qualify as an all-star imo
@@ListsofLegends Lindsey Had A Family Emergency In S2 Sad And All Stars
Y’know what I would have preferred?
A Not-Star season.
Where they brought back low placing/early eliminated contestants to compete to give them more focus and make them shine
That would have been great too
Easy Noah W
dawn would win for sure
Ezekiel maybe
Ive done so many versions of this on tier list maker and tyler noah and harold are usualy my higest picks for winner. i would prefer it to be called Total Drama Losers then not stars thoough
Leshawna and Cameron would get along perfectly in all stars
I think so too!
Yoooooooooooo
@@SobbleWobble13 what’s upppp
@@ListsofLegends hey 👋
@@SobbleWobble13 hey there 👋
I still wanna see DAWN back. Literally robbed and would love to see a potential Dawn & Ella duo
I’d love to see her again and have her not be a wasted character
Agreed
WOMP WOMP
Yesss Tyler, Brick and Harold, are so underrated
Owen, Cameron and Harold would do so well
Also I can’t stand Trent in the slightest
If Justin was in it, he’d be out quite quickly, tricked by Alejandro
G3 I’d bring back Shawn, Ella, Topher, Max, Beardo and my boy Rodney
Personally since Mal was incredibly awful as a villain I would prefer Anne Maria being the principal antagonist, also she was about to make it to Merge in TDROTI but it seemed like they wanted to throw her away so they gave her that stupid elimination
Yeah she was robbed and didn't deserve it and her merging could have developed her some more
She could work as an antagonist I just don’t like her character tbh unpopular opinion
@@bottomofthechart44 she definitely got cheated same with Brick
If they added characters that deserved it and it was around 20 contestants imagine how better the season would have been
@@bottomofthechart44 million is miles better
Kinda weird how Pakithew is considered season 5 when it's more season 6.
Tyler deserves a redemption and i imagine him on a wholesome friendship with Brick as both guys share a good sportsmanship & loyalty.
Yeah that’s true I should have mentioned that and I used to call it season 6 a lot too lol I don’t get how it’s called season 5B when revenge of the island was it’s own thing
@@ListsofLegends Exactly. It will always stay as season 6 in my books. instead of the cheesy season 5.5 . Makes no sense. And TDRR is season 7 also (for me)
@@duncan3998 yeah them calling it season 5 made no sense
Doesn’t pakithew island come after all stars, I thought Chris mentions camp wawanakwa sinking in PI and that happened in all stars
@@turxe3110 Yes
In a trailer they showed the 14 in og and others were cody noah brick Anna maria leshawna owen brigette and harold
8. Tyler
7. Dakota
6. Trent
5. Geoff
4. Harold
3. Brick
2. Owen
1. LeShawna
Nice list 👍🏽
I would've LOVED to see Geoff in all stars! considering how he did make the final 6 in island.
I personally think at least Leshawna, Harold, and Dakota would have saved all stars. Cody, Brick, Ane Maria, Noah, Tyler, DJ, Justin, and Owen would have saved the show as well. But I think the main problem with making an all stars season at the time it was released was that there isn't much to work with. There are only two casts of characters to choose the "best of the best" out of, so it would have been better for this season to be made after the revival, or even after the ridonculous race, because then there would be lots more to work with.
If written correctly it would have been substantially better
Eva would have been a good option too; her temper would put her in the villainous team by default, but since she's not an actually bad person, she'd be trying to make them all to behave and play fair, even if she'd do it though intimidation.
Yeah true she’s strong not a fan of her character but will say I think she’d do well in the challenges
It would be interesting if they gave more focus to certain things they said in their audition tapes. Like I think Brick mentions wanting to use the prize money for fashion school or something, he could have an interesting friendship with Lindsay. Or they could make Leonard more like an actual LARPer with random knowledge pertaining to battle tactics and military history which could give him a weird friendship with Brick too or earn respect from some of the other contestants. Beardo and B could possibly even be friends with the not talking thing and having an understanding. Justin and Alejandro would be a very interesting team. They have so much in common, but they're so different. Or they could be rivals and it makes Justin a better villain or hero. Pairing up contestants with people similar to them could be interesting considering how many there are.
Justin and Alejandro would have been really cool especially in world tour
Double trouble 😈
I think DJ should absolutely been in all stars. Every single time he was eliminated on the show, he got robbed in some way.
Yeah I didn’t like how he got mama Boy treatment too much either
Top 8 characters that should have been in TD allstars (in my opinion:)
8: Ann Maria
7: Owen
6: Bridgette
5: Dawn
4: Harold
3: justin
2: Leshawna
1: Brick
Honorble mentions: izzy, DJ, Dakota, Cody, Noah, Trent, Tyler, & B.
Very nice list!
@@ListsofLegends agreed
@@ListsofLegends thank you 😊
Cody made it to the final 3 in world tour, and left because of an injury in season 1. he def should've been in all stars.
My all stars cast:
Total cast: 22
14 island members (7 boys, 7 girls)
Courtney Duncan
Heather Alejandro
Gwen Owen
Leshawna Noah
Lindsey Tyler
Izzy Justin
Sierra Cody
8 tdiroti members (4 girls, 4 boys)
Anne Maria Lightning
Dawn Scott
Jo Brick
Zoe Mike
Villains: Heroes:
Courtney Izzy
Gwen Leshawna
Heather Lindsey
Anne Maria Dawn
Jo Zoe
Alejandro Sierra
Duncan Cody
Justin Tyler
Scott Mike
Lightning Brick
Noah Owen
Here's my opinion about Owen being in all stars:
I actually like Owen but I personally don't think he deserves to be in All Stars. Ask me why? He already was in 4 seasons, Tdi, Tda, Tdwt, and Tdrr. I feel like he already had a lot of screentime and tere wasn't much else they could do with his character.
This is just my opinion don't come at me for it
20 likes and I'll do why or why not do I want someone else to be in all stars
7:55 Owen wasn’t added because his voice actor wasn’t avaliable until the finale. That’s why Owen made a cameo appearance. Because of that, they replaced Owen with Sam and gave all of Owen’s roles to Sam.
I’ve seen a but online but I didn’t want to say without confirmation
@@ListsofLegends ok
They could’ve at least replaced owen with a different character from gen 1 or gen 2 because sam didn’t even make it to the merge. And sam was basically an environmental punching bag.
I mean one main problem of all Star Was there should more then 13 epsiode
My ranking
8.B
7.Harold
6.Leshawna
5.Brick
4.Tyler
3.DJ
2.Owen
1.Cody
Nice ranking!
I completely agree with the list and ty so much for adding Tyler I wish he could just win a season already
Thank you! Yes Tyler is one of my favorite characters and he’s the perfect comical relief character so far all stars hits fits that role
Fun fact : apparently leshawna cody noah harold and justin was suppose to join all stars plus brick anne maria
Characters from gen 1 that should’ve been in all stars
Owen: come on its Owen, EVERYBODY’S GOTTA LIKE THIS LOVABLE GOOFBALL he’s literally on all the promotion posters
Noah: if Noah and Owen was in all stars, there’d be a storyline between the two and their friendship and Noah would get more screen time
Tyler: if Tyler was in all stars, maybe Lindsay wouldn’t have been the first boot, they could’ve formed an alliance
Izzy: Izzy is a Brazil sized nut job in Noah’s words, and more moments of her being crazy would be perfect for all stars
Harold: maybe if harold was in all stars his rivalry with Duncan would continue, plus he was literally robbed by Owen in action
Leshawna: if they put Leshawna in all stars her rivalry with heather would be continued so Leshawna should have been in all stars 100%
Cody: if they put Cody in all stars it would fix Sierra’s problem with Cameron and her derailment
Beth: she was the alternate winner of action, and your telling me she shouldn’t be in all stars? Maybe she could’ve made a friendship with Sierra
Characters from Gen 2 that should’ve been in all stars
Brick if it’s gonna be heroes vs villains, then why isn’t brick there? He literally saved everyone in the cave, he’s the real hero, plus his rivalry with Jo would continue so that would be nice
Silent B: since he didn’t have much screen time on revenge of the island, with his smarts, he could’ve carried the heroes team in every challenge
Dawn: she could’ve maybe done something this time, and she could’ve used her aura powers and notice that mike is actually a villain, and try to warn her team
Dakota: maybe they could’ve fixed her character and not make her dakotazoid, then if she was in all stars, it would make Sam’s character more interesting
I think dj and maybe Geoff should be in all stars
Yeah Owen and Noah would be great to see in all stars
@@-Gamerly- yup that’s why I included him as an honorable mention he’s a good character
I would want Noah and Owen in all stars
@@FrankWIN that would have made season a lot better
I think ezekiel should have came back because:
1: he could start to learn how to be human again by watching the other contestants and learning from them
2: he could have also used his money to become normal again if he won (well, if he desired normal-ness)
3: even if he gets eliminated first again, at least we can see how he competes as a feral animal.
4: he’s one of my favourite characters too,
Agreeed :)
I always imagine justin and alejandro interact with each other because I can see them both becoming a rivalry and being jealous of each other
One day hopefully
@Bara Bro facts ⬆️
I love Beth and I think she should have returned in tdas
Now don't get me wrong but she was part of the reason Lindsay did so well in tda however this time around Beth would have been an early boot for all stars which would have made Lindsay need to strategize and search for new allies and that would've made her a really good winner in all stars
I could definitely see the argument, especially if there are more people than what we got in canon
Wow, very good you got most of my characters of who I think should have been on total drama All-Stars except for one which was Cody because he worked very hard to get to the final three in world tour and besides Cody working together again with Sierra would be awesome
owen was obviously in the hospital recovering from the explosion from roti 1
seen a few theories surrounding why he wasn’t in universe as for this one it’s possible but the bro literally was back to compete in no time flat when the WT plane fell on him
Here are my picks:
Dawn (replacing Sierra)
Brick (replacing Sam)
Harold (Heroes team)
Leshawna (Heroes team)
DJ (Heroes team)
Beth/Izzy (Heroes team)
Justin (Villains team)
Anne Maria (Villains team) (I think she's not really a bad person, but she's not the nicest either)
Also in this timeline, Duncan and Courtney would both be in the Villains team from the start to make the teams balanced.
My top 8 people who should of been in all stars are
1 owen because he deserves it
2 leshawna I can see her making it far
3 brick I can see him making it far to
4 dawn because she has so much potential
5 Harold because he could bring a lot to the table
6 Anne maria since she was meant to be in it but they cut her and Owen out last second
7 Justin because he could interact well with Anne maria and the fans ship them so ye
8 b since I would like to see him and dawn interact
Very nice characters and reasoning
Arguments Can Be Made That Anne Maria Should Be On This List, As She Was Originally Going To Be In It, But Then Got Replaced By Gwen. In Fact, Every Character Would Be Great In All Stars (Other Than Staci, Dakotazoid, Katie, And Sadie). And Yeah, Owen Is The Only Winner Not In All Stars Other Than Beth.
3:50 the reason why b and Dawn ere eliminated early and not considered for all stars was that they were last minute additions. They weren’t in the prototype, they were last minute additions and early elimination fitter. A lot of people want them both back(especially Dawn) but they not only weren’t included, they weren’t even considered.
Edit: So, yeah, Owen, Cody, Anne Maria and Brick were all confirmed to return but got replaced. Leshawna, Harold, Justin and Noah were considered but never put in the final production.
If so the reason why I included with mainly for better entertainment (more than sam)
If All Star came out after Pahkithew Island, we probably would've gotten Jasmine, Shawn, Sky, Ella, Sugar and Max.
Most likely ya
thb is all stars cam out after pahkithew island, we could've got a redemption arc on Dave. if they did it right. I would've watched it.
ill give 4 guys and 4 gals
girls - Leshawna, Bridgette, Izzy, and Dawn
Guys - Tyler, Brick, B, and DJ
Owen would be a good fit for all stars but I think they didn’t include him since he was in rr personally I wouldn’t want to see Owen for five seasons(especially how he made the finale,third place,8th place, and then the nineteenth out of 26th episode in rr)
3:02 off-topic of this video, but like is B supposed to be Total Drama's representation of non-verbal people? Or does he just simply not like to talk?
He doesn’t like to
I feel like Lashawna,Brick, Owen, and Dawn could’ve been in All Stars because Leshawna was 5th place in the first season and if it wasn’t for her dumb elimination in the episode Haute Campture,she would’ve gotten farther.i also would’ve liked to see how she would interact with the gen 2 cast.It would’ve been cool to see her friendship with heather again because they seriously messed it up in world tour. Heather didn’t even do anything in the challenge where she beat heather up. Brick should’ve been in all stars because he was a good leader and like you said , the writers could’ve continued his rivalry with jo because i enjoyed their rivalry in revenge of the island because i found it funny. And maybe the writers could’ve made them into a couple. I think Owen should’ve been in all stars because he made it pretty far in the seasons that he was in. I also would’ve loved to see him interact with the gen 2 cast. I feel like zoey, mike, & cam would’ve been really good friends with Owen.Lastly, i feel like Dawn should have been in all stars so that she could actually do something in challenges because she barely did anything for her team to help win the challenge. She was mostly reading people’s auras.I would also like to see how she would interact with the people from gen 1.A lot of people think that anne maria should have been in this season but i don’t really agree because anne maria didn’t really do anything to help her team win the challenges. All she did was tend to her hair and tan.
I feel that those decisions would have definitely helped improve all stars I voted B should be in all stars as well while yes he didn’t make it far but I feel you should compensate a bit more for revenge of the Island characters since they had only 1 season prior to all stars to shine and it was a shorter seasons with the shortest cast. Owen definitely should’ve been In there since he’s practically the face of total drama next to Chris
Thanks for adding Trent ❤️❤️ (BTW, what do you think of the idea of Izzy being in all stars an getting far?)
Izzy is an okay character to me so I wouldn’t mind seeing her get far and it would be interesting seeing her interact with gen 2 especially mike
I forgot about izzy if there was 18 contestants I say she would get like 13th or 14th maybe
@@tendolife I did not gonna cap same with Cody
@@ListsofLegends Nice (Shes my 2nd fav 🧡)
Dude why are you talking about yourself in the third person
Brick should’ve been in there, Izzy and Owen could’ve gotten together again, Anne Maria could’ve gotten revenge, Justin could’ve been in there for more “villainous” actions and would get what he wants like what he usually does and would work well with Alejandro and Pahkitew Island should’ve been in there before All Stars and Trent needed to be there and the fact that there should’ve been more characters, people always make non canon Total Drama seasons and make Justin and Anne Maria date, and who replaced Brick and Anne Maria?
Ay again with that background music! Keep using it I love it
I love it too! Fits with most of my videos
Justin
Tyler
Cody
Izzy
Harold
Leshawna
Owen
Dawn
Anne Maria
Brick
Super duper list
Harold, Leshawna, DJ, B, and Brick definitely should’ve been on the show.
Would’ve love it
You forgot someone…
WHERES ANNE MARIA!?
She is totally an All-Star and could have possibly made it to the finale with a possible alliance with Leshawna and Cameron against like Mal or Tyler or something
She is totally an All-Star and deserves to be in said season!
Exactly!! I was thinking like whre was she??
I'm curious what leshawana would be like in all stars with Alejandro in it, cause she probably would want revenge
I think she would too because the end of world tour hinted to it
@@ListsofLegends yea
Cody should been in and you forgot him?He could have go in to the final
This is how All Stars should've turned out.
Have Owen and Beth compete since they were finalists and replace Sierra and Sam with Brick and Anne Maria.
Have Scott and Courtney the Final 2.
Have Good writing for the characters.
Have Mal never exist.
And have a better elimination order.
Cody is an all star. Change my mind
My top 8 characters that I think should’ve been in All-Stars
Yup you got some really goodies there
Its nice that they put Owen in the show but it sucks that he’s not competing
I think if any Winner Wins again it should be Heather bc she was the only character who never got her money. I guess u could argue Owen never got it since he decided to do Action. But still. Heathers money literally got stolen out of her hands.
That’s a good point lol
i won't take away any characters, but i would add
leshawna
owen
harold
brick
anne maria
cody
beth
and dakotazoid, not as a contestant or intern, but as just moral support for sam
I like it lol
Tyler definitely deserves more screen time he is very funny and was one of the best characters in seasons 1-3
I know right! I absolutely love Tyler
He’s super underrated not gonna lie
You mean season 3. Didn’t really get much in season 1 and wasn’t in season 2, but I really liked him in season 3
Because he’s still gotta pay back that favor-
My list that who should have been in All-Stars:
1. Cody
All though he competed World Tour, i wanted him in All-Stars, for obvious reasons.
2. Anne Maria
She wanted to quit in Revenge of the Island, but got her diamond along with Brick being eliminated, so i want her in this. :/
3. Izzy
She already was in All-Stars but not competed, she was gonna compete in this season.
4. Harold
his beatbox is good, he was supposed to be in All-Stars.
5. Brick
I wish he was in All-Stars ;-;
6. Dawn
Same as Brick
7. Leshawna
Same as Brick and Dawn
8. (LAST) Owen
Owen was already in All-Stars, but not competed along with Izzy, he appeared in the finale of All-Stars, i wish he was here.
That's my list (Enjoy)
Thank you, great list!
@@ListsofLegends thanks!
@@ClydeThePokeyGhost
My list:
1. Dawn
2. Dakota
3. Trent
4. Leshawna
5. Harold
6. Anne Maria
7. Justin
8. Owen
4:29
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure this was the cause of Lindsay's boot in action, not all-stars.
I’ve seen people say all stars and yeah a few action I couldn’t find any concrete info online so I just said whatever it was let’s pretend she got farther
Is it really such a bad thing that All-stars couldn't ruin or further ruin everyone .
Right lol
I agree with almost every one on this list. The only person I would switch out is B for either Dawn or Dakota.
Yeah I understand lol
@@ListsofLegends Loved the video by the way. You did an excellent job!
Are you working on disventure camp video ? No rush tho .
Yes I’ve been looking into it :)
If made total drama all-stars this is what it would look like
Cast ⬇️
Harold (Heroes)
Duncan (Villains)
Gwen (Heroes)
Courtney (Villains)
Owen (Heroes)
Lightning (Villains)
Brick (Heroes)
Jo (Villains)
Lindsay (Heroes)
Noah (Villains)
Beth (Heroes)
Justin (Villains)
B (Heroes)
Alejandro (Villains)
Mike (Heroes)
Heather (Villains)
Zoey (Heroes)
Scott (Villains)
Cameron (Heroes)
Anne-Maria (Villains)
Sam (Heroes)
Dakota (Villains)
Dawn (Heroes)
Leshawna (Villains)
DJ (Heroes)
Izzy (Villains)
Tyler (Heroes)
Sadie (Villains)
Cody (Heroes)
Blainley (Villains)
Katie (Heroes)
Here’s my list
1:Noah
2:Owen
3:leshawna
4:Tyler
5:Dakota
6:I wish Lindsey would compete more
7:and Duncan wouldn’t be trying to prove he is a punk
8:and Alejandro not being brain dead
I forgot dj and Harold and brick
Great list!
7:56 I mean, Nolan Jeff and Owen were in RR so
Still not all stars
My list if that's ok:
Original cast:
- Leshawna
- DJ
- Owen
- Justin
Roti cast:
- Brick
- B
- Anne Maria
- Dawn
Love the List!
Will there be more all stars season because when you think about it if there ever is going to be a second All-Stars Chris should back everyone who's ever make it to the finale
yoooo you actually added Brick and B !!!! thank you for listening to me !!!
So many people disagree with me on B but it’s my fault for not being clear about why I picked him, gen 2 didn’t get much screen time because they had one season that’s it pre all stars wise I just think B has better storyline than Anne Maria imo she’s better all stars worthy I’m by placement yes but if we went just based of that then it would have been lame in my book
@@ListsofLegends yea i agree
@@ListsofLegends me too
I love leshawna but idk how they can redeem her character back
They’d have to redeem a lot of characters tbh especially after all stars what a mess
im gonna go foward and say that i also would like to see owen win again, it would make a nice full circle
He’s the face of total drama so to me they’d have to bring him back
Wait, don't you think Eva deserves a return?? She is very criminally underrated and got robbed twice.
Well she's not, all star material, just because somebody wasn't in 2 seasons doesn't mean they're 'robbed', and all stars is about the people who got furthest and played the best, eva got 2nd boot in 1 season
@@threeguysandagirlinabeachhouse with robbed i mean losing her golden oppertunity to particpate on the 2nd and 3rd season. Now it's much worse that Zeke is more relevant than her
For a redemption story yes, it’s like my reasoning with B story wise she’s better but I should have explained myself better in the video If we’re going just based off placement than it kinda doesn’t make much sense because revenge of the island cast only has one season pre all stars
I agree with nearly all of these
I would love if B would return he was pretty interesting
And Justin I would like him to return but the same as B I don't think the fully fit in the all stars category
And once again this is a really good video
Thanks and yeah lot of people disagree on B I should have been better explained my reasoning in the video
@@ListsofLegends I understand why you like him tho he's a good character
@@tendolife thanks! Yeah I love B lol
@@ListsofLegends lol
Hey man i like beardo he was funny as hell lol
Hey at least someone likes him lol
Only 17 seconds, huh? 👀
Imao indeed
I would rather have Anne Maria in all stars instead of B since she got further, needs development and was planned to be in the cast, don't get me wrong I love B but I would rather have him in Fans Vs Favorites or Second Chances just my opinion tho
A lot of people do it’s just an unpopular opinion I don’t like Anne Maria that much tbh
I can see why you don't like Anne Maria, thank you for commenting back
@@paulmartin8444 yeah of course
As for the several ppl you want to see back, i prefer not since they are the most overused characters whereas the underrated characters are losing sight, if you catch my drift.
Maybe as a cameo it would be benefical, but not as a contestant-wise.
That’s cool yeah some characters I think in my opinion would need to so people would tune in
@@ListsofLegends Picture this as a alternative All-stars team formations.
Heroes: Dawn, B, Brick, Tyler, Zoey, Trent & Leshawna
Villains: Scott, Eva, Jo, Lightning, Anne-Maria, Alejandro & Blaineley
Pretty good, eh?
😎
@@duncan3998 Anne Maria I don’t like much tbh but everyone else is aye okay lol
@@ListsofLegends I can replace her with Justin? lol
@@duncan3998 sounds good 👌
They should've delayed all stars until after pahkitew or merge the pahkitew cast with revenge
100% yea that should have, how can they give revenge of the island one season lol?
B being in all stars makes no sense. He placed 12th and only lasted 3 episodes. Instead, I’d add Anne Maria since she lasted much farther and was booted right before the merge.
If we were to have 9 from each generation, just keep everyone who was originally in All Stars (yes including Sam), and just add in Brick and Anne Maria.
Other than that, the list is fine. Nice vid.
Thank you, a lot will disagree on B but I just think he would be more entertaining to watch than Anne Maria tbh
@@ListsofLegends True. If I were to bring be back, it would probably be for another season that includes the revenge cast. Maybe have him show his full potential there. I liked that idea you came up with having the team decide if either Scott or B was the real enemy.
@@mystictj9626 thank you! When it came in my head I just knew I had to share it lol
The only reason the writers scrapped Brick was because they wanted Sam to compete again. Why not just have both of them compete at the same time, or have Sam not compete at all
bro how is this channel not at 1k sub?!
Thank you!! I hope to reach it soon
My perfect all stars cast:
Gen 1:
Owen,Gwen,Duncan,Heather,Alejandro,Courtney,Trent,Justin,LeShawna,Tyler
Gen 2:
Cameron,Lightning,Zoey,Scott,Jo,Mike,Brick,Anne Maria
I think having the cast 50/50 is a disgrace towards gen 1 who had 22 characters with 3 seasons of development. If you want more gen 2 characters give them another season before all stars.
Nicely done
I add dawn and b to
YESS
I think Harold and Cameron would be great rivals tbh
I do too!
Beth deserved to be in All Stars I think
She was a runner up/winner so yes she would qualify imo
What about a recast on chracters from different shows playing the roles as who woudl play gwen another goth?
That would be interesting to see
My list:
Owen, Leshawna, Harold, Beth, Cody, Justin, Anne Maria, Brick
Nice list
Best list ever but I would make it top 10 with those 8 and add dj and dawn that would be awesome
DJ yeah 100% id love him in all stars
trents comes back then there is a love square he also would of been placed on the villians tean and duncan heroes team.trent could equally more drama since mal is there
Trent definitely needs redemption no doubt
dont forget izzy, she deserves way more
She did have net duo with chef and a relationship with Owen so yeah she could have a storyline there
Love this list
Thank you!
You said Tyler still going to paid Alejandro that favor I thought I was hilarious
Yup I’ve seen it alright 🤣
B was in 3 episodes in a 13 episode season
Katie was in 6 episodes in a 26 episode season so uhhh
Katie deserves it just as much as B does
And that's not a compliment
I can’t stand Katie lol
Why Is It Always Top 8s
Yea I agree some of the characters didn’t even go back on the show again
Yeah it’s sad to see
@@ListsofLegends yea it is
I feel like this had the potential to be the best season or equal to world tour if it was 26 episodes, had a bigger cast, def no Mal hate that guy and character assassin
Yeah exactly
My opinion:
8: Noah
7: Tyler
6: Justin
5: Cody
4: Trent
3: Harold
2: Owen
1: LeShawna
Honorable Mentions: DJ,Izzy(The Explosive E-Scope, Geoff,Bridgette
Forgot about Cody ngl 💀
and I also agree with you there they could have easily done something with all stars because when it was announced that gen 1 and gen 2 combining together I was like no way but than it didn't have some of the characters that you thought would going to come back which is complete bs it's not really an all star season to me but at the same time I still enjoyed it but the writing is terrible a total missed opportunity
Yeah very much so
MY ALL STARS
we are not removing but adding players + pakitew island players will be in and CAST:
Gen 1: Gwen Courtney Duncan Heather Lindsay Alejandro Sierra Owen Leshawna
Gen 2: Jo Mike Zoey Sam Scott Lighting Cameron Brick Anne maria
Heros: Gwen Lindsay Sierra Owen Mike Zoey Sam Cameron Brick
Villains: Courtney Duncan Heather Alejandro Jo Scott Lighting Anne Maria
Very nice
You know the original cast was supposed to be gen 1 Noah,Justin,Cody,Courtney,Harold,Lindsey,Leshawna,Duncan,Heather,Owen and Alejandro gen 2 Brick,Anne Maria,Mike,Jo,Scott,Zoey,Lightning and Cameron originally Gwen was not planned for all stars
Is this true
top 8 character that i would add in all star ( my opinion)
1st generation
1 leshawna
2 harold
3 Justin
4 eva
2 generation
1 dawn
2 anna maria
3 brick
4 B
yeah that's it :/
Coool list
My list (this is my list on who should have been in all stars so these aren't the characters I like the most and want to be in all stars but the people who deserved to be in all stars)
8: Trent
7: Brick
6: Geoff
5: Izzy
4: DJ
3: Harold
2: LeShawna
1: Owen
Yeah I miss Geoff when he competed
I don’t know how leshawna didn’t get into all stars
They really fumbled the bag not having Leshawna in this season.
Agreeeeeed
my picks :
Owen
Leshawna
Izzy
Harold
Dawn
B
Brick
Anne Maria
Nice picks
Justin too underrated