Top 10 Biggest Differences in One Piece Live Action
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- The live-action anime curse is broken! Join Ashley as we look at the biggest changes made across Netflix’s shockingly awesome adaptation of Eichiro Oda’s legendary manga "One Piece"! Our countdown includes Garp, Battle at the Baratie, Buggy’s Circus, and more! Have you watched Netflix's live action "One Piece"? What did you think? Tell us in the comments!
Check out these other great videos:
Top 10 One Piece Moments That Gave You Chills: • Top 10 One Piece Momen...
Top 10 One Piece Transformations: • Top 10 One Piece Trans...
Top 20 Most Epic One Piece Moments Ever: • Top 20 Most Epic One P...
Become a channel member to get access to special perks:
/ @watchmojo
Don't forget to play our Live Trivia games at 3pm and 8pm EST for a chance to win cash! The faster you answer, the more points you get!: www.watchmojo....
Have your idea become a video!
wmojo.com/suggest
Subscribe for more great content!
wmojo.com/watc...
Visit our shop for awesome merch!
shop.watchmojo...
Your trusted authority for Top 10 lists, reviews, tips and tricks, biographies, origins, and entertainment news
#OnePiece #Netflix #Anime #Manga #luffy #otaku
What do you think of the live action One Piece series so far? Let us know in the comments!
For everything One Piece, check out our playlist!: ua-cam.com/video/2uAzp6ymY6w/v-deo.html
Don't forget to play our Live Trivia (www.watchmojo.com/play) games at 3pm and 8pm EST for a chance to win cash! The faster you answer, the more points you get!
Love it❤❤❤❤❤
One Piece VS Naruto VS Bleach!
I binged all 8 episodes loved it from start to finish, love the easter eggs and name drops and introduce stuff like the baroque works which will show up in s2 setting up the big bad
i'm not watching it
Hey watchmojo you forgot about the scene in episode 6 where nami read the book about the story of Noland and the city of gold for zoro, and in the anime the story of Noland was supposed to happen in the skypia arc
Another main change which really works is they made luffy a bit more level headed compared to his manga counterpart while retaining his goofy happy go lucky personality. He was also unhinged and chaotic in the anime especially in the beginning. This could have been a major turn off for first time viewers who don't have an idea how shounen heroes can be.
yeah...or not...I really liked that aspect of his character...and still do
@@metalmario1231 I love it but I think it wouldn't have been translated well on to screen
@@prathapcharan luffy was unhinged and chaotic bcz he grew up among bandits, also luffy is just a 17 years old kid . and kids that age are unhinged and chaotic specially when they growup away from their family.
@@pralayaryan lol really. If so why is Ace so respectable and calm compared to luffy. It's just his inherent character trait that oda gave him.
@@prathapcharanshanks crew are a bunch of goofballs. Ace had better role models
You know, despite these differences, I really love this adaptation!
Yeah we are😊
Me too! Cant wait for the second season!
If the didn't kill garps char and and nami scene it would have been good
True the heart is there.
Yeah it’s not bad, I’m really shocked
I didn't expect Garp is getting introduced too early and I also didn't expect Coby has more screen times now. Which is really good to see how Coby and Luffy are going to find their own dreams even in different opposite side. We see the pirate's life in Luffy's POV, and we see the marine's life in Coby's POV, so it's a good change.
Also, I don't expect Luffy will have a lot of different shirts either instead of sticking with his red sleveless shirt.
HAHAHAHA funny you mentioned the different outfits.
I like the Garp and Koby twist in the story. We get a glimpse of Garp's strength and his concern for Luffy. Atleast we know he really made a move to prevent Luffy straying off path. But he respected his dedication and the scene turned out like a send off for Luffy.
I just wished he was more relaxed.
I also like the build up of Koby and Helmeppo's characters. Garp didn't take them immediately. He got to know them and decided to train them himself.
Fun fact the change of clothes they're wearing are all canon they were drawn by the author Oda himself in the color walks.
I mean, you expect him to wear the same outfit like Flintsones and Scooby doo live action movies?
I think coby got more screen time because he is transgender
@@mesh3lal-3tmi53 lmao, wrong.
To be honest Garp chasing Luffy before he got into the Grand Line is pretty good. I mean it make sense if Garp want his grandson to stop being a pirate, the best way is to stop him early on.
Garp also wanted to test him to make sure he can handle the new world when the time comes
Garp wants Luffy to be a marine because this puts him on a path thats more safe and secure. But he sees how stubborn Luffy is in wanting to a pirate, where the chances of danger and death is highly imminent. Garp wanted to see if Luffy has the resolve and grit to face such danger even when backed into a corner, knowing if he doesn't have that then he surely wouldn't last and he might as well give up.
Maybe disney should watch this. This live action adaption showed how you can change the source material, make the cast more diverse and still tell a great story. I very much enjoyed the first episodes.
Don't give them any ideas
well one piece universe is already very diverse if you look up the databook
@@sunfei7254Director still did a awesome job on diversity where majority of one piece fan could agree upon. For example Zero was typical samurai swordsman so cast Asian was the right choice and Sanji always had a European trait. Disney force swap diversity that’s why people have negative view on their live action film
@@AkagiRedSun that's exactly my point. Thank you
Zoro already taking care of diversity
Honestly Monkey D. Luffy's Stretching Powers Looks much better than Mr. Fantastic In Fantastic Four (2005) and Fantastic 4 (2015)
Hopefully the new MCU remake does it better
@@abc.animal5143you’re hoping for too much. 😂
@@pjbpiano we’ll see
@@pjbpianoshouldn’t be an issue if they actually pay their VFX people
That's a stupid comparison as this is much latest. Those movies were back then. If they were done on the same year then that would be a fair comparison.
The reason Koby is in the first season because he's becoming more important in the latest arcs. His growth is shown in some of the various story arcs that'll come along later. So he'll be important to Luffy's story.
also they used manga material that was not used in anime koby has a few cover sheets that never made it into the anime and those are canon
I think Oda took like notice from Kobys repremiere during garps "intro" in the manga for like anime only watchers. Cause Im sure a buncha them saw him after Enies Lobby and were like "how the hell did that happen?" ya know? Its a pretty good revision imo
we can't just have actor to play in one episode in season 1, and then reaper 5 season later xD
@@Adamusaliasas the live adaptation is focusing on kobey the anime and manga skipped around alot
Also, it's great to make how Marine's life look like in Koby's POV and how he works hard as a rookie and how Helmeppo also have a character development for getting humble after his dad, Morgan got defeated. We usually see it on Luffy's POV all the time but it's good to see it through Koby's POV. It's honestly a good change.
Boy, with Oda supervising things on the creative, no wonder this live adaptation will go places. Even with shortened timeline and less characters, it produced the story that is worth watching.
Well played, Oda, you magnificent genius.
I was thinking he was working close to this adaptation. Has made quite a difference and makes me appreciate it more. You can tell it was done by someone who loves the series. Makes it less impressive only because if it was some random person making these directive calls that would've been insane.
It goes in to the trash bin.
If the anime was like this it wouldn’t be close to how good it is. Literal trash that’s rushed.
@@paperplane-db8qf it is great and 3 years is not rushed,
@@tuehojbjerg969 it literally changes the story and order of events. It changes the dialogue. How is this great? It’s trash writing.
It cuts off so many things for no reason. It’s definitely rushed as it wasn’t given the proper time.
PFFFFFFFT Nah this is a one piece W you're crazy@@paperplane-db8qf
Already looking forward to Chopper, Vivi, Robin, and Franky showing up now, although that's probably much further off
Chopper and Robin will show up season 2, for sure.
@@a.jherbert5436 how in the hell is that going to work? Unless they cut a crap load of content
@@sombodi200 thats not to much. arabasta saga is literally the next saga after east blue. this is naturally season 2. there is almost no content cut there. smaller arc is covered in one episode and the bigger one in 2 arc.
do you all forget Fire Fist Ace in Alabasta arc?, I can't wait his bounty poster 500 million berrys.
@@Sleepwalker507 yeah we will meet many important character in Arabasta saga. Robin, Vivi, Ace, Chopper, Smoker, Dragon, Crocodile
Mihawk's Entry Was 🔥🌪️🗡️
I absolutely loved the change with Kuro and Kayas house. I loved the conversation between Nami and Kaya too
The episode gave me "dead at night" vibes like the game.
What about them cutting Usopp out of his own arc? You forget he’s even there.
Jeff Ward as Buggy is a better joker that Jared Leto Joker.
Can't agree more. 😂
amazing writers. instead of just doing a 1:1 copy, they chose to make beautiful twists in the story while still respecting the main source material and giving the anime/manga fans an element of surprise simultaneously.
Well the lead developer for the show is a huge fan of the anime and Manga.
Zoro asked: "Who is shanks?"...
A pirate hunter not knowing an emperor...
@@botta6186he only looks at the little peoples bountys and he was only a purate hunter for food and booze
@@TheoneShadow2728 then tell me why he knew about whitebeard's tatoo on ace's back 😂
Not only the name but his jolly roger too 😂
@@botta6186 because whitebeard is more famous then shanks, and in the anime and manga that zoro doesn't know who shanks is.
I did remember something important after arlong showed up. He's got a much bigger territory than just Cocoyashi village.
I think Arlong Park is comprised of several other islands he and his crew took over with Namis village serving as his HQ.
So it makes sense that the town Buggy was occupying falls under Arlongs jurisdiction.
What happened to the fish man waiter?
@@alfredhinton8792still working for Zeff I guess, last seen of him, he's the one tending Garp when they arrive
Also, where the hell is Hachi? Because Hachi will be an important for Fishman Island arc and he's the only Arlong's crew that still around.
@@margarethmichelina5146 hachis not in there?! By Chuu and the other guy are?!
He must be off screen somewhere either that or he's off island running errands.
Dude doesn't like to stay in one spot for very long. I do hope he shows up tho. They're already talking about season two on the web.
@@furionmax7824 Gotta take into account budget issues when dealing with that much cgi. An octopus fishman using six sword style has to be a bitch to adapt into live action.
Even, with all the changes, everything feels so much like one piece, garp's chase for luffy, setup for arlong, buggy being used and thrown, it all has a perfect one piece arc feel to it, despite of the changes.
Even with these differences, this was truly the best live action anime adaptation of all time
edit: correction One of the best
@urbanyouthsis it becuz ur french?
Nah ronin kenshi is the best it clears the one piece live action
Alitta Battle Angel was also awsome
@@nbflilwon7081OPLA is the best live action .
True, especially since they had a pretty low bar to beat
This is the best Anime Adaptation I've ever seen, that just goes to show how amazing One Piece is in all Platforms
👍 Peace and love ❤️ !!!
They could have easily screwed it up. The fact that they didn't shows how much respect they had for the source material.
Try rurouni kenshin live actions
Not to forget Alice in borderland
@@therealwilldalbey Wdym they didn't? The live action's plot is terrible.
I actually think these differences made the live action even better and more interesting. I especially liked Koby having that much screen time.
Better and more interesting? Never
I hope
They don’t expand koby and Garp in parallel with luffy. So much other content should be covered.
@@ok_jilvaneibut its true though
Some of theese diferences made it better
Especially garp being there from begining
Knowing the history between garp and gold rogers
And adding to zoro's original apearence is great
@@joshbrosh6626 even the anime changed Zeff's story of cutting his leg to eat and these people hate the adaptation. Clowns
@@someguy3508This is really happen in the Manga.. Anime Watchers don't know how to read Manga?
Everyone did an amazing job as each character, I especially like Jeff Ward as Buggy, and how they made Luffy much smarter
They also changed Sanji's character A LOT. In the live-action, Fullbody and and another guest get into an argument. Sanji tells them that the rules of the Baratie are "no fighting and no wasting food". When they throw their plates on the floor, he offers them wine and tries to calm the situation down. When they start fighting each other, Sanji attacks them as if to stop the fight, he then tells the guests that there is no cause for alarm and "please, enjoy your meals".
Now, in the manga, Sanji grabs Fullbody by the neck because he wasted food. The other cooks have to hold him back and he even threatens Fullbody's life. He regularly starts fights at the Baratie according to the other cooks. When the fight is over, it's Patty who says "Please enjoy your meals" (Sanji doesn't give a shit about customer service)
Pretty stark difference in the characterization which is interesting I think.
He's also, in a really good change, less womanizing and less of a self-misandrist.
I wouldn’t call that a good change. Flaws make nuanced characters; removing them makes them generic and dull.
This is why the live adaption is trash. They change a character and the plot for no valid reason.
Shitty writing
@@tcrpgfani still love that he's a flirt but he doesn't overreact about it
I am so happy for Jeff Ward who plays Buggy. He was also Deke in Marvel's Agent of Sheild for those marvel fans out there
Jeff Ward is an absolute scene stealer in AoS and as Buggy as well. He got a bright future ahead
One change I absolutely didn't like was the fact that no one in Nami's village knew of her sacrifice. Nojiko had tattoos for a reason.
they changed it, SPOILERS!!
.
.
.
.
.
.
They changed how villagers knew Nami's sacrifice. Nojiko was still oblivious of what was going on until Nami said so. Anime was different because everyone there is suddenly emotionally intelligent but it's different here.
@@kusa3221 Nojiko got her tattoos to show her support to Nami. That's probably what made her a character worth remembering. I'm fine by the rest of the villagers but Nojiko antagonizing Nami was hard to watch. Ofc newbies won't care and I hope we get a season 2.
@@Ghost.Nappa56"Ofc newbies won't care" Shuddup
Definitely agree, it changed the heart of that story.
@@violetrose674 point out to me where I am wrong. All I am saying is those who are new to one piece won't care.
I know a few OP haters who watched the show just to hate watch and end up liking it alot. The one thing they had a problem with OP was the pacing and i think the changes helped with that a lot.
Honestly, if i would to introduce one piece to somebody, i would tell them to watch this show first, its a great start.
Then watch the rest through One Pace
This is what you get when you consult the Animes author while filming!! It's outstanding I did find the differences a bit odd but found the little side stories told a lot about the characters back story! Can't wait for season 2!!
Finally, an anime live action adaptation we can all love!
The guy who plays buggy really needs to be cast as The Joker. Also this show was awesome, can't wait for season 2
I know what you mean. He would be perfect as The Joker. He has almost the same personality as him. I really enjoy this show.
I think it monster would be better
This proves that there's a lot of actors who can play the Joker not just one or two, and the producers need to find these talents, not just hire the most fancy and expensive actors to play the Joker when unknown actors with real talent can do it too....
I wonder how are they gonna handle the Giants characters, they're gonna need a lot of budgets for CGI and also for Chopper, Laboon, any Zoan Devil Fruits Users. The way they handle Arlong's face is not bad, honestly and I don't know if it's a CGI or a prothestic make up but it looks as close to original Arlong.
@@margarethmichelina5146 this is one of my biggest fears for the next season, it could be a huge fall, after a good adaptation and make these characters with normal human size, I will be so pissed off, to get a chance and let it go away like that, the two giants needs to be like the anime, the island where things are bigger they need to do that, the important characters with huge size needs to be there to make the One Piece something unique as it is on the source material, White Beard, Big Mom, and these other characters where sizes matter need to be well done on the next seasons, imagine how bad things can be if the next seasons we get to see White Beard in normal human size 😳
GG the show is ruined. 😖
Even though Mihawk's introduction was changed, his look and display of skill are right out of the Manga. I only wish Garp had some larger canon balls on board his ship.
Yes, those cannonballs need to be wayyy bigger and heavier-looking!
I'm looking forward to seeing who plays Boa Hancock. I always imagined an actress like Michelle Yeoh playing her: elegant, urbane, but tough as nails
You left some honorable mentions - Crew taking Buggy hostage, Sanji healing Zoro or Kaya kisses Usopp etc
That kiss made me realise this was made for a more mature audience it was a nice idea
Finishing up the series as we speak...the series is fun and mostly true to the source material. Looking forward to see a S2 and how it goes moving forward. They did a great job
The Mister 7 change shows just how much the showrunners know and love One Piece !!!!
Because Oda himself is in charge on directing.
it wasn't shown but this fight is canon to the original
Helmeppo and Koby being the most accurate to the anime out of all the characters (in my humble opinion) was quite a shock and I loved every second of both of them on screen.
Zoro still stole the show for me, as he did in the anime. So happy this is getting really positive reviews all around!
They were so good. They feel and look almost exactly like their manga counterparts and it's pretty incredible.
They even trolling us that at first we thought Helmeppo gonna have a long hair only for Zoro to cut it up like his original counterpart in early arc. Also, the guy who played Helmeppo looks like what happen if you put Tom Holland and Evan Peters together.
This live action adaptation was way better then I expected. And my expectations were quite low to start with. I wonder how they are gonna introduce or show Haki at some point? Season 2 hype!
They alrey did Shanks used Haki to scare the Sea King!
@@skaraturbogarp also used observation against luffy
Twice actually garp used observation
I know both of them did display observation and conquer haki. And Garp used armament haki with his fight with Luffy. To anyone who is a fan of show we already know. But to the casual observer, it is not obvious and Haki was never introduced in story at this point. I thought they would explain it sooner but I guess that would something they can bring up in season two or three if the show lasts that long.
I mean, we already saw Conqueror’s Haki from Shanks. That’s how he got rid of the Lord of the Coast.
It also looked like Garp had Observation Haki in his fight with Luffy.
That last scene with Garp reacting to Luffy returning his cannon was the point where I went from not liking the live action changes to Garp, to absolutely loving it!
I love they Change the Scenes of Each Arc to be more Interesting and not be Boring for those who watch the Anime that they know what happen and they add some Easter Eggs that in the Manga that Censored in Anime, and the Casts are also great, Can't wait for Season 2 💖
I like that Buggy played a more prominent role too. He was actually funny!
i was really surprised with how much i liked Arlong in the series . my expectations died after the first trailer dropped
The actor for Arlong was great
same! I thought the makeup wud lead to clunky acting but boy was I wrong! He was awesome!!
He's my favourite villian after Buggy
You can tell the actor is having a blast playing him and that helps. Honestly all the actors in this show look like they are having the time of their lives.
I love how Arlong was portrayed greatly in OPLA series and plus I love prosthetic makeup on the fish-men especially the Big Bad himself! Practical effects rule! Additionally, I really love this animalistic version of Arlong because he shows his beastly self a lot especially with lots of snarls and growls. The actor who played the evil Shark Man did a phenomenal job! Plus him forming a villainous team-up with Buggy? Brilliant! 💯
Didn't go into this with any expectations but I was pleasantly surprised of how good the live action version is executed. The cast fits very well and even the shortened time frames work perfectly. Only thing I wish were that the fight scenes were a bit better with cgi or choreography. Other than that, cant wait for season 2
Choreography I think was great really, only lacking was yeah Luffy's fight scenes. Felt restricted for when he could use his ability cause of real world costs behind it
@@nighttimeasbestos5958 what I’m thinking too! Heard they ran into issues within production anyways and it was supposed to be 10 episodes but what they delivered is amazing either way
I liked it, definitely some changes I did not like but a few I did only thing I really have issues with are small also if they tone town the sexiness of Nani and Robin eventually they need do the same with the men cough cough pointless shirtless Sanji…
We just finished watching the first season. Neither of us could really get into the anime series, but we sure enjoyed the live action! That scene where Luffy is fighting his grandpa was great. We both thought, “Aw grandpa is so proud! His little grandson is fighting back!”
🎉Jeff Ward as Buggy❤
[Ian MacShane as The Narrater]
Ive never watched the anime or read the manga but I absolutely love the Netflix adaptation itself very enjoyable the characters story and effects are amazing I hope a ton of people watch and enjoy it great video and review 😊❤🎉
For me it’s like they choose a what if siutration. But it works so well and in the end they are all together and I can’t wait to hopefully see more of them. In the German version you spacialy get a feeling like coming home because they choose to take anime voices as the voices for Netflix. So when you grown up with the great German snycro now you have the one from Netflix as well.
well anime and manga is way better than this netflix adaptation.... better watch real than netflix .
@@NabinRai-zy2td it’s ok that not all seems to like it. I think that’s the case by any adaptation. For example I don’t like the dead of the nil movie that came out 2022 or so.
@@NabinRai-zy2td that's fine and your opinion I like the adaptation if you and others don't none of you should feel pressured to watch it I love it sorry you don't
@@danielhilgeman798 opinion u tel it anything bt i hav watched both ...well im sorry that u like cheap copy of it....
Honestly this is how you do a live adaptation!!!! Yes they changed some aspects ( no hatchi?) But when it came to important aspects of the story they not only presented it but also still gave me chills!!! Like when Nami told Luffy to save her I still felt the same feeling I had when I first seen it, I hope this does continue it deserves to be continued!!!!
Any adaptation is better with minor changes as it gives people a chance to enjoy the story without knowing what comes next.
No epic walk to Arlong park but I do agree, they freaking nailed the Nami scene.
Technically Hatchi was there; it seems he was the guy Nami was gambling with, if the cast list is accurate. Just wondering if they'll flesh him out later or drop him from Sabaody.
In terms of a flow for live action I find the changes and adaptations to be spot on, looking forward to the next season immensely.
The series is flames! They absolutely nailed it. I don't think they could've done any better with season one.
On episode 6 and this has been really really good! Best live action adaptation I’ve seen by far. I especially loved how they went for character costume recognition. No matter how goofy they seem to some people it is great to see and adds that personality flare to the series. I remember when the X-Men first came to the big screen and they went for “realism” by dressing them in all black instead of their comic book costumes we knew. One Piece had no such problem! Everybody looks the part.
Im glad Arlong got more time and not just introduced in the Last 2 episodes. We needed the build up on Baratie. Koby and Garp focus as secondary storyline was a great choice.
Never was into this anime... but this live version is awesome. The action, sets, music, acting, filming, story, and fighting scenes were all excellent. A good example of putting the quality of the story over any woke/social/religious agenda pushing.
One piece world is ruled by World government and it will make you see how true and honest Oda is. But I don't think live action will make that far
“Quality of the story” lmao.
Changing characters for no reasons, changing the order of events. It’s typical trash writing.
I'd say the anime was still better. I like some changes but I think the action scenes here sometimes feel too short
Most of the changes I think work pretty well. It's a bit of a shame about some of them like Orange Island being so condensed but it makes sense considering what they did with the pacing. Garp is the only one that really stands out, him being involved so early and in such a big way really makes you wonder how they are going to use him in the future for the rest of the series.
We can finally say we are now finally getting a good live action adaptation of an anime.
They have done an awesome job. I hope they keep it up in season 2.
11:20 definitely they casted the right actor for garp. From his intimidating presence to his ability to play to garp’s raw personality he nails it!
despite the differences, i loved everything the anime and netflix adaption have in common. they managed to get so many key moments right and epic as they should be
Just done watching the whole series and I think it's the best live action I've ever watched in my entire life
This is my first time watching One Piece and I am in my late 30's. Yes, some elements of the show are "crazy" but it was a solid show. I enjoyed almost all of it. The butler episodes were enjoyable and thrilling, the sword hand guy episodes were good, the final arc was good also. My only complaint was the salt water thing... I couldnt understand how the clown knew of his weakness. Maybe I missed it in the show but when I read up, I understood. Strengths of this show - a very very solid cast who can act, it is visually appealing, and the screenplay and choreography are on point. Each episode became more intense 9.4/10
A big part of this adaptation's success is the casting and characterization and attention to side-characters. Koby, Helmeppo, Buggy, Kaya, Kuro, Zeff... amazing!
I absolutely love this live action BUT they removed some of the most iconic scenes and Hachi one of the most important early characters has completely been removed
Imo, I feel like it's understandable because an octopus-man is really hard to adapt and the fact that he wields 8 swords. If they decided to really adapt him, I think they're just gonna introduce him later
no budget no make 6 hand hachi and his pet cow sea king
@@bjnazerigaming8302 it's budget is apparently as high as got s7-8 but it's stil not enough ig
Jango too
Also, Hachi's gonna be important for Fishman Island's arc later. And he's the only Arlong's crew who is still around.
For a non one piece fan, I loved how they delivered the story.
One Piece has become one of my favorite Netflix series now and at par with ASOUE. I just love the style and set they used on both these shows.
Not gonna lie I was a little angtsy about Garp having such a thick accent and seeming all...wary / secretive. But that laughter scene in the end convinced me he's aight.
despite the minor or major differences this was a damn good produced show, and stayed pretty true to the manga with the whole Zeff eating his own leg. the focus on Koby and Hellmepo was an interesting choice and Buggy that performance really leaves an impression. I do wonder if or how they will address Alvida and her powers when the time comes.
To be honest i didn't like the anime that much, but this adaptation really got me hooked, that's how an anime adaptation should be
Loved it. Netflix delivered with this live action adaptation
They still did a side story with Garp, which had me worried it was going to be Vicious in Cowboy Bebop all over again. It turned out ok, but please don’t try to keep doing that. Knowing less is sometimes better.
This show really blew away my expectations. All I wanted was for it to be good. Nothing more then that. I was hopeful it would be, but I was still scared. But I had no idea it would be this amazing. I had so much fun watching this and I already hunger for a season 2.
Let me guess, 'squee' became your go to sound when we are played when the merry set sail.
That naked Helmeppo suprised me! 😂
Gotta get the fan service running🤣 it felt like normal one piece fan service since they didnt show the front of the body.
Garp was the only weak point for me only because he was too serious. I did grew to really like him after he threw that canonball at luffy. Then i was like "oh theres garp." 😂 still a fun character, though.
I think He will lighten up next season, giving the actor time to zone into garps fun side
Been fan of one piece since childhood. Some of the changes in live action are quite good. I can see why they change the story of garp. The cast choice were also quite good specially zeff,captain kuro and buggy except beckman ( that was a bad choice ). There were some things that wasn't as good as the anime or manga like Zoro character build, sanji joining straw hats, usopp arc but overall it was a good adaptation. Excited for the season two . Drum island and alabasta arc
I hate how every battle/arc took place in like one spot in a dimly lit room at night.
Also the bar fight. Helmeppo was going to continue on about his business, zorro was the one who escalated it and didn't really do anything to save the girl. That's like the complete opposite of how it should've happened imo. Also it completely goes against the lesson luffy learned from shanks when the bandit smashed the bottle, shanks didn't escalate or fight, he simply cleaned it up.
Knowing that the creator of One Piece was a definite presence in this adaption, I believe that with him knowing his stories so well, he was able to add, change, adjust and remove areas of the Manga/Anime that would make the most sense in a condensed form. When you respect the fans and the creators, you can’t go wrong. It took them I believe 7 years to make this happen and it definitely shows.
Wouldn't take 7 years for season 2 I think. Production for Season 1 got pushed back like 2 years because of COVID, and I'd imagine with alot of sets built like the Going Merry and talent picked the whole process would probs not last as long.
They also made Sanji more of a "flirter" and "ladies man" as opposed to being a full blown pervert, which is a god change in my opinion 😅
I really love this series! The past story arcs really make you feel for the characters.
I love this adaptation, the first season is amazing... Never watched the anime but will start watching it
Really enjoyed this series. Hope there is a season 2
That Helmeppo random ass shot was HILARIOUS and fit well with his character lmao. Also, Helmeppo is underrated but he has the biggest character development in the series LOL. He went from being a nepo brat to a living-by-the-code marine in episode 8. Helmeppo deserves some love hahahahhaa
Almost every change is an improvement.
Jango absent is probably the weirdest for me since he was the reason why Morgan bragging about capturing Kuro because he hypnotized him to do so
I was expecting Luffy to kick buggy in the nuts after buggy flaunts his ability not take damage
I was actually waiting for this to happen
Me too! but I understood they wanted to make him comical like Jack Sparrow and not a total mockery... that fits perfectly in manga and anime, but would look cringe in the live action (as the complete idiocy of anime/manga luffy against this version)
I’ll give Netflix another chance just because of this series
Garp, Helmeppo and Koby were definetly the most benefited by this version, loved their inclusion! i feel Oda probably didn't had Garp in mind back when he wrote east blue, and felt like it would be proper to introduce him earlier, really works well in this context, and i love to see a more detailed look on why Koby and Helmeppo end up being friends after their rocky start. Helmeppo in particular was great, he was soo hateable at first, but i really believed he changed by the end, he had a great arc, that actor deserves mayor props, he was hillarious, super punchable at first and endearing at the end.
Also can't ignore how this expanded role for Koby greatly emphasized the duality of the factions of One Piece, with the whole "good marines and bad marines" thing. By this point in the original marines weren't very well developed, and this made them instantly more interesting.
//i feel Oda probably didn't had Garp in mind back when he wrote east blue//
No bro, in Romance Dawn version 2, he already introduced Garp as Luffy's grandfather but the difference is , garp was a pirate and he wants Luffy to follow his footsteps.
Garp was introduced in east blue and already trained Koby and Helmeppo . You need to rewatch or read the manga from the beginning
I like that they already set our expectations that it will have its own thing, but I like it and it makes sense in live action so I still like it.
Is it as good as the original? No. Is it better than I expected? Yes. Is it the best live action adaptation of an anime ever? Hell yes.
Something that would be cool is that some/most of the characters should be played by the people they are based on (if they are still alive). Hogan as White Beard.... would love to see that.
I love the live action adaptation. i can't wait for season 2. They did One Piece so good. 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾 Keep up the amazing work.
So what if there are differences. It's no big deal. We actually love and enjoy the live action. Can't wait for more.
I love how they made buggy into a more twisted version of the joker
Well, just as twisted. That stunt he pulled with the people of Orange Town was straight out of an episode of "Batman: The Animated Series." I don't just mean that figuratively, as it was almost exactly as depicted in the episode "Almost Got Him."
The best compliment I can give is that with the fact the story is made to be more compact yet it doesn't feel skipped at all is amazing.
If they did not made those changes it would be boring
Glad they made those changes,it kept me interesting
how? isnt the reason why it got adopted because the the manga and anime are liked by ever1? how could something boring b worthy of being made to live action?
@@sanjaydhirwan791 he talking about earlier arc in anime and manga that actually quite boring and so dragging it's get interested in Alabasta arc
@@kennethkusuma3582 and I will repeat that if they were boring the series would had never kicked off, it was the world and character building that paid off later, one piece didnt start of like a battle flashy anime like nowadays, it had a pretty standard animation but the story and characters kept the series going, even before alabasta lot of major story points were put forward
@@sanjaydhirwan791 yeah I know, still that doesn't hide it still dragging and boring even it have nice building world and character and mostly one piece fan agree with that
@@kennethkusuma3582 the reason the pacing is slow and it is dragged is that they cannot catch up with the manga, or they will have a fullmetal alchemist situation, also the pace of the show dropped mostly after time skip, the pre time skip episodes were properly paced and good mix of the humor and emotions, the live action wants to cover years worth of content in 8 episodes that too in their own way making the changes, if they are lucky to get more seasons just wait and watch how they butcher the story, coz they would have written themselves to a corner
Hands down the best live action adaptation. It’s not perfect and nothing ever is but it made me relive the love of the one piece crew and why these moments matter the same as the important plot developments
The changes they chose to apply worked really well, maybe because Oda himself approved them knowing his key characters will still be the same afterwards. Zoro joined Luffy 100% not because he returned his swords, but because he'd rather let him die for his dream against Mihawk rather than stop him. Arlong's message was delivered much clearer for just a few episodes. Kuro's change was so big, and yet gave the same feeling of threat and near hopelessness. Even Kaya and Usopp's kiss felt needed for some reason because of how complete they have fleshed out their relationship that blossomed from deep friendship.
And I have to commend how they utilized Garp, Helmeppo and Coby between episodes and showed the growth that we never really processed in the anime at that point in the story.
Buggy in Circus is a good differentation for Buggy. When Nami see the Outside of Circus, you will see that Buggy is a Threatening and a Notorius Pirate in Orange Town but i will love it if they gave ChoChou a Moment in this Arc kindly sad but okay..
It sounds like we may see more stuff like this early on in future seasons, like the Garp grandpa reveal in east blue saga instead of end of Enies lobby saga. Like maybe season 2 with the giants and little garden, they could get a map of Skypeia and leave it as set up after Alabasta saga. Or maybe Aokiji will show up in season 2 trying to find Robin while she’s still with Baroque Works
I binged one piece live action on Thursday and Friday and I loved Garp but Buggy was my favorite part of it
If the show felt a bit rushed in certain areas i wouldnt blame that on the crew. I would say thats a Netflix problem. Netflix refuses to give shows enough episodes to establish a proper show. Their microwave approach to producing content is ridiculous and has a track record of failing. Now with that said Oda and the rest of the crew performed amazingly with what they were given (10 episodes). The show could have benefited narratively if each straw hat member was given a three episode ark with a finale. I'd say 13 episodes would have been the bare minimum with 15 being the max.
Take note, Shyamalan! This is how you condense a series right!
Am I the only one shocked that Nami actually paid twice ? (once to bride the waiter, and the other when she offered drinks)
'cause... like... she's Nami but actually OFFERED TO PAY TWICE ???
As long as Oda is on board every step of the way, things should be fine.
They did the adaptation pretty well i actually want a season 2 unlike a certain space bounty hunter netflix adaptation we will never speak of
Monkey D Garp! Was a real surprise, a welcome one. Can't wait for the reveal of his son, Supreme Commander Monkey D. Dragon (Monkey D. Luffy's father).
Feel like they made 1 huge fail with Koby though. Originally Koby stands up to Alvida and that makes Luffy respect and help him, in the live action Luffy insults Alvida for him, Koby never shows any courage and Luffy really has no reason to help him. There's also 0 reason why they couldn't have done this properly, Koby and Luffy were literally standing next to each other, Koby should've just said it himself. Imo this is the worst change, since it required 0 effort to do properly.
I think I understand your point. But at the same time, Koby not having the courage at first is a little more realistic for live action. Alvida in LA is much more scary, threatending and violent so naturally, it wouldn't take such a short time to stand up to her. He was terrorized for so long and he witnessed people killed by Alvida for saying the wrong thing. AND he was the one who had to clean up the mess!
Luffy helped him for reasons I think is different from the anime. Koby has a prejudice against pirates saying they're scum, and Koby tells him he can't eat until Alvida does. Luffy is a good guy, that's enough of a reason for Luffy to help Koby and to show there can be good pirates like the ones he idolized. Hence his constant "I'm a different kind of pirate."
And Koby punched Helmeppo when he tried to stop Luffy. That's still an act of courage he managed to show in the first episode before he and Luffy separated. So I wouldn't say he didn't show ANY courage.
@@sakurachan288 I feel like you're over apologetic about the LA, from what we see from Alvida she isn't really worse then in the OS and Kobys situation was the exact same, yet somehow you find it an excuse for changing a major point in the series. He doesn't seem to help him for any reason at all in the LA and Koby isn't actually given much choice unlike in the OS where everything happens because Koby stood up to Alvida.
Lastly I don't see how punching Helmeppo was showing courage at all and if it was supposed to it failed hard. How does KOing someone from their blind spot show any courage at all? It's cowardly if anything.
@@FutureVegeta Agree to disagree. Luffy is a good person, he doesn't need a huge reason to help someone who clearly needs it. I don't remember much from the anime so as a viewer whose watching from a different point of view, I could still see what led to Luffy wanting to help out Koby. Plus, Luffy asked for his help first on directions, and Koby helped. Why wouldn't he return the favor and help Koby get away from a bad pirate?
And from someone who probably hasn't shown a glimpse of a fighting streak before meeting Luffy, stopping Helmeppo was an act of courage. It's still valid in my eyes.
Tbh the LA has bigger flaws than what you mentioned. Plus, we get to see over the course of the whole season on Koby's courage. It's not immediate like the anime, it was slowly building up which made his eventual courage more rewarding imo
@@sakurachan288 just no, clearly you have no idea how important that moment is in regards to the rest of the serie and both Koby and Luffys character.
@@FutureVegeta ok future vegeta