China is Not Safe
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 сер 2022
- 🌏Get Exclusive NordVPN deal here ➼ NordVPN.com/serpentza - It's risk-free with Nord's 30-day money-back guarantee! ✌
Must watch videos, the ones they're trying to hide:
China lacks good Samaritans and it's Terrible!
• China LACKS good Samar...
Mainland China's Worst Societal Problem:
• Mainland China's worst...
There is a huge moral crisis in China:
• There is a Huge MORAL ...
More and more we're seeing evidence of how dangerous it is to be a woman in China, but now the CCP is ferociously trying to hide it....
Watch Stay Awesome, China! here:
• Stay Awesome China - F...
For a deeper dive into China's Propaganda influence and soft power, watch our liveshow ADVPodcasts: / advpodcasts
Support Sasha and I on Patreon: / serpentza
Paypal: paypal.me/winstonsterzel
Bitcoin - bc1qxfjp2t6x5dpslv59u0jl89m6k643hcn8h2jsvp
Ethereum - 0x6Da150a2A8529110017Ed4db68B3dF0084900280
DOCUMENTARY LINKS:
Conquering Southern China:
vimeo.com/ondemand/conquering...
Conquering Northern China:
vimeo.com/ondemand/conquering...
Stay Awesome China (my new documentary): vimeo.com/ondemand/stayawesom...
For Motorcycle adventures around the world, and a talk-show on two wheels go to ADVChina every Monday 1pm EST
/ advchina
For a realistic perspective on China and world travel from an American father and a Chinese mother with two half-Chinese daughters go to Laowhy86 every Wednesday 1pm EST
• Chinese People Won't T...
For a no-nonsense on the street look at Chinese culture and beyond from China's original UA-camr, join SerpentZA on Friday at 1pm EST
/ serpentza
Join me on Facebook: / winstoninchina
Twitter: @serpentza
Instagram: serpent_za
Thank you so much to each and every one of you for helping me fight the Chinese censorship machine by watching my videos, you're awesome! And thank you for Nordvpn for sponsoring me when so many don't, if you use a VPN, choose Nord: NordVPN.com/serpentza
Ye
Always watch them. You are Awesome!
Thanks for what you do.. my dad taught me he was the rudeness police when asked why he always got involved in other people's conflict.. world would be worse without such effort, thank you for making it, Winston.
Can we please get a cut or something, can we see that footage of you stepping in and intervening in that altercation at what looked like a restaurant?
Today in Australia I got a robot caller that stated Chinese Embassy then a tirade in Chinese....I'm pretty vocal about the CPP and it's antihuman behaviour....it was very odd. It's a shame I couldn't tape it to have it translated.
I've personally witnessed this. I was visiting a friend in Nanjing in early 2008. We were in a Taxi and saw a woman on a bike get clipped by a motor scooter. Her head hit the ground HARD. The guy on the scooter yelled at her motionless body (even though it was his fault) and sped off. Nobody else even broke stride. I thought she was dead. My buddy made the Taxi stop and we checked her out. Fortunately she was only knocked out for 20 seconds or so, but I was shocked how everybody just acted as though nothing happened. A VERY selfish and cruel society.
Can't blame the society when it's the government that put laws into place and ruled against good Samaritans. Turns out if you get punished for just trying to help, people are going to be less inclined to help when you have an overbearing CCP government watching you.
I doubt the guy on the scooter could afford that woman's hospital bills, if she had any. It may seem cruel, but when everyone is struggling to survive, and helping someone could take away what little money you have, most people are going to mind their own business.
@@jessn.3851 Stop defending trash, trash.
@@jessn.3851 The CCP literally twisted Chinese society into this so no one will group together for support.
@@jessn.3851 When you accidentally almost murder someone at least stop for a min and help them so they don't become deceased....lest end up have a murder charge on your hands. Man you people idk your brains are lost in the frost or something..idk man idk about you people not even people more like bots.
That's some societal rot right there.
A society that strongly discourage basic human compassion is a society fundamentally evil and on the decline.
straight out of 1984
@@LTEAndroid not even comparable
@@LTEAndroid bad bot.
@@bigjohn3141 Eh, they're getting close
All Ideologues are the same with the same endgame, sorry if you believe otherwise
You think conservatives or leftists both don't salivate over the level of control the CCP has over their citizens, you've fallen for their bs
Christian republicans are the most generous american when it comes to donating money to charity.
This very effect happened to my mother just in the past year in Shanghai. She was riding a moped in the correct lane, a car came past and suddenly pulled into a driveway pushing her off her moped and sending her flying 5 metres further along. Not a single bystander stepped in to help her, mind you this was on one of the busiest streets of the city. This behaviour is atrocious, she was laying there with a broken shoulder and ribs. The driver didn’t even apologise, he merely just said “I am late to a meeting” and proceeded to drive off leaving her on the side of the road. What makes me furious about this is that he kept disputing the crash even when the police went through the surveillance footage and it was black and white his fault. Hats off to the police though, because when the driver refused to come in to the police station for questioning they confiscated his car. We are now taking this to court and we are very confident of us winning the case.
Omg!!! I hope your mother is okay! That is so scary
There is a court in China?!
@@cecillec2331 yes Chinese court is very one sided and normally only goes the way of the locals however, on this occasion the evidence was all there and the court helped us out a lot.
I'm worried the guy would just pay off the judge.
I remember a few years back seeing a video out of China of a small boy getting off the school bus then getting run over, and neither the school bus driver or even the person filming did nothing while this poor child laid in the street dying, beyond disgusting.
I've seen good samaritan videos from China as well but yeah it's not as common
Good samaritan videos I've seen from China was a guy stuck under a van that had tipped over and around 10 people helped pushed to the van. I've seen a few like that
omg. Rip
What a disgusting society...
@@lrn_news9171 This doesn't help.
@@detective2221 What do you mean? They pushed the van off the guy who was stuck underneath, the van tipped over and fell on the guy and one guy saw it and run to help and then other people joined in. I can post the link
what a dystopic hellscape
More like a communist hellhole.
Dystopian is how the word is used.
@@barnacleboi2595 its overused lmfao
There is a show in Australia called Bondi Rescue. I have noticed that whenever the lifeguards rescue Chinese tourists, and that is often, the people rescued don’t appreciate, or seem to realise, that their lives have just been saved. No thanks usually, just a weird look and a wave at the most.
they arent human, simply Clone NPC's hatched in a Cloning Center
Most of them seem to be Korean
Bizarre and a tad bit creepy...
@@user-ny7vz9fh5y 😊
great wall of china was built to keep them in and away from rest of the world just look at it carefully
I have witnessed similar in the UK, where people would rather cross the road to avoid helping someone.
I was so pleased to see the opposite while on holiday in Florida USA; when someone got hurt, almost everyone around rushed to help.
Likewise many people came to my aid when I had a accident in the USA.
Yes people in the US and Canada tend to be helpful
Same. It's one of my favourite things about my home, Canada. The other day I had a flat tire in the middle of Walmart parking lot when it was -30c out, pitch black out, and SO windy. I couldn't even put my gloves down because the wind would pick it up and fling it 500 meters within 3 seconds. I had some trouble getting the flat tire off because the wheelbearings were frozen and stuck, so I was down there freezing my fingers off for about an hour and 15 minutes when it shouldn't even take half of that. Anyways... I would guess about 30 + different people came up to me asking if I needed help. So nice to know if I had needed help it would have been there. Same with other times I've gotten stuck in the snow or fallen in public and needed help.
I’m a social studies teacher, and I was teaching mostly English language abroad. I brought up the ‘diffusion of responsibility’ and the Kitty Genovese case to talk about the the need to help and the need to get involved and I tried to teach: “don’t be a bystander.” The local teacher (they always put in a local teacher who had a different agenda than me) directly undercut my lesson to tell the kids the opposite of what I’d just said (she used direct, authoritative, Chinese). Despite the language barrier, the kids often understood me quite well because of miming, drawing, and plus the kids who spoke good English due to their private ‘after-school-school’ lessons-those kids-those kids would often translate and help out their peers. But yah: I straight-up taught: “don’t be a bystander,” and then their local teacher straight-up taught: “don’t ever get involved.”
Chinese here, can confirm this is true. This is the kind of instinct that got suppressed long ago by the cultural revolution and the Great Leap Forward in the 20th century. When people are all fearing for their own life they tends not to care about others - which is exactly what use to happen: grandparents got dragged away by the red guards, beaten in public grounds and my parents couldn’t do shit, everyone just stood and watched and yelled “long live CCP and Mao” or something like that. You are taught to not intervene or else you get arrested too. Plus people are already too tired and desperate trying to make their own living to care about others.
Still hasn't got any better, mostly with this new Communist government. Brave of you to admit your country's cultural faults. If you can, get out, the collapse is gonna be ugly there
if u chinese u should know in america people can looting rob store and nobody will stop them ,its normal everyday theres no moral in america
My close Chinese friends confirmed this as well. They said the gov has taught them not to intervene... because of the past and possibly in the future - if the government is doing something to the people, they don't won't want interference. So basically it just transcends to all other actions, like "if it's not your business - don't worry about it"
@@valetudo1569 very true and I’m glad your friend pointed it out!
Just read the amazing book ‘Wild Swans’ by Jung Chan who wrote an amazing true life story of this period and the impact not only on her family but on society at large. Population left totally traumatised by being brainwashed into turning on each other. Truely horrible. Unfortunately, once it finally came to an end, little was done to try and rehabilitate the society so badly impacted, as new leadership just wanted to move on (and not admit terrible mistakes had been made). Little wonder the people were left in a state where only personal self interest mattered, and sadly, that appears to have rippled down to later generations.
It's necessary to isolate people in order to control people. The isolation leads to anxiety and fear of others that can easily be manipulated by the CCP and refocused on anything they want.
Similar thing happening in the West with 'diversity'. Divide people along cultural lines, demonise anyone who speaks out about it and use this division to better exert control over the native population.
Bit like the Covid hysteria, divide and conquer........
@@AnthonyJones-vk6xq
(🤔…)
@@AnthonyJones-vk6xq unfortunately, there are still too many lobotomized sheep.
@@AnthonyJones-vk6xq Yep, exactly that.
I am from Vietnam. Unfortunately and sadly, this problem is also becoming more common in Vietnam. Thank you for sharing your experiences.
I think self-preservation is a huge issue. My son goes to China regularly and he sees that they don't see individuality. He's gone so many times that he's learnt a few names of staff at the hotel and started to ask them "how are you?" and he said they stood there like statues, perplexed. But eventually they got used to it.
Ethnocentric form of collectivism has some qualities too
@@lrn_news9171 and flaw too
Witnessed an accident in Hong Kong involving 3 people on two motorbikes on Nathan Rd, Tsim Sha Tsui. Only myself and a foreign nurse on the other side rendered assistance, while Chinese people lined the sidewalk gawking. I left as soon as I determined that there was nothing more I could do. Chinese people and their indifference to human suffering disgusts me. The whole society.
Wow! Best comment here! You're so right! These people who are indifferent to the sufferings of their own Chinese people are morally-bankrupt.
I've experienced watching how they fight with each other in one Chinese store . .
Probably the most arrogant comment I hear is that China is superior in every way; both economically, civilly, and morally. Examples like this and many show that China is far from becoming a civilized country, if they ever can become one.
@@cessna172ident Wow! An excellent shot! My associates and I here reading your thoughts, totally agree with you! You spot it on. Logically true!
(We're working in a legal industry.)
But Why????? Why are people like this I want to know
@@Agent-wp8fv Communist China is spiritually-dead, morally-bankrupt country.
What to expect from these people who have no moral values and principles on their lives?
The worst part is that this video covers a very small fraction of videos of these incidents. There's literally hundreds of cases of children being ran over and left on the street in China.
why dont they stay out of the street
@@kl-yg6ks there's no where in the city for children to play except the street sometimes.
@@kl-yg6ks natural selection
Distracted poor parenting
@@kl-yg6ks have you not seen the kids falling of the balcony? lots of those as well. The videos you see were someone catches the falling child is but a small percentage of the actual numbers.
I love your video. I used your phrase Stay Awesome each time when I said good bye to my MOM those last months before she died. It is a cherished greeting.
I live in Australia and even if there is an injured animal beside the road people will do something. Its shocking to me that people just look away and pretend its not happening. I honestly could not live with my self.
As a Kazakh Guy from Türan Qazaqstan (Kazakhstan 🇰🇿), I know any horrible things about China 🇨🇳.
It’s insane that people would write this off as a bystander effect. I watching someone die in front of you and doing nothing about it is not normal for a modern society.
Fear of consequences such as retaliation seems obvious.
If you can’t do anything, at least have the decency to run for help or turn your back. People in these videos are watching like, “pass me the popcorn” and then the ones who can’t help but can pull out their phone to film.
Bystander effect is everywhere, ok. But bystanders pulling out their phones? That takes it to a whole new level. Maybe I’m wrong, maybe westerner bystanders film as well. But it seems, since we have to be reminded that this stuff happens in western society, we must not be filming it as much.
Usually there is a bystander effect in the USA but not until there are already people helping and too many people helping is a bad thing in some cases.
It is a factor and it mostly happens in big cities where people legitimately do not care about anyone but themselves. Case and point a woman was "assaulted" in Philadelphia on a rail line and no one lifted a finger to help her in 2021. However, in main land China this is far more than that. It's a systemic issue ontop of the bystander effect. When you're punished for intervening it doesn't encourage samaritanism
The reason is simple. When the CCP's goons come after you they don't want a populace that will spring into action to protect their community members. Like when gang members attacked the protesters outside the bank in the Henan province. Divided people are easier to rule.
Soulless bugmen.
I was sitting in a bench next to a road in my city and for a moment I looked behind me, where the road was, and there was this little girl (5 years old or less) standing in the middle of the road, with a bunny plushie in her hand.
To my surprise, although there was a lot of people around her, on either sides of the road, no one seemed to care a bit.
Some people even seemed to notice what was happening, without doing anything besides looking at her with an intermittent worried look on their faces.
I, of course, jumped over the bench and ran to get her out the road, but a car passed on front of me. Luckily, the car was on the opposite lane than the girl, but even when I tried to stop it, the car driver did not let me pass in front of the car, and I had to wait until it had passed to run to the girl and pick her up.
I grabed her from under her arms and carried her out of the road.
My mom, who had just started to understand why I jumped onto the road, took her away and found her mother a few minutes after.
I didn't even follow my mum to help her find the girl's mother; I was so shocked.
Most people around us didn't even seem worried or cared to ask anything.
Do I have to say anything else?
I'm confused, are you saying this is the norm in Spain?
@@siemprestruggle9272 Ok, wrote this a while ago, and I don't even know why I wrote I'm from Spain. It has nothing to do with the comment lol. I barely remember what this video was about but I was just trying to connect the message with a recent experience of mine. People in big cities simply don't care about others around them. It's sad.
Winston, you're awesome.
Thank you for all of the quality content; your videos are, almost without exception, informative *and* entertaining.
Once I was walking to work in China and saw somebody laying in the street in broad daylight. I thought it was a joke or he was just drunk...bc nobody was reacting to him.
As I got closer and started to walk past him, I thought "hmm let me just make sure everything is alright". As I walk closer - I see he's laying in a pool of his own blood, bleeding out of his ear.
Anyways I scramble trying to get peoples attention, screaming and pointing to the gentlemen on the floor. Everybody either acts like I'm invisible or scurries off even quicker.
Finally I find a young girl and she is shocked when I point her to what had happened. She quickly calls an ambulance - and all of sudden - a giant crowed forms. Somehow with this girl calling an ambulance and taking care of the problem, people can *magically* see and hear us.
This was actually a year or so after I saw your video about good Samaritan's in China and I thought "Wow Winston's video was correct"
That's what we get where government is "God". Afraid to offend government, and once government is called to help, everyone is there to virtue signal.
And the next weird and awful thing is you cannot berate or point their unwillingness of anyone for not getting involved......I tried that in Shanghai in 1994 and I felt on danger because of it
@@kennorthunder2428 EXACTLY!!
Oh wow. That was my experience there but milder. I’m glad you stepped in
@@enshrinehd Yeah it's a weird thing in China where they know shit is fucked up but if you mention it or point it out - They get offended.
Weird bc I'm American and I've had random people tell me that my President's suck, or any other bad thing they might think about the US... but I'd be not do that to them. smh
I experienced both sides of this phenomenon whilst I was in China and can assert that Serpentza makes a very accurate point. On one occasion, I had a fairly serious fall from a double pavement into the street. I hurt my shoulder, hip and back and must have been clearly in pain. No one attempted to offer any sort of help but simply carried on as if I did not exist. After about two minutes, I managed to drag myself to my feet and I noticed an old lady staring at me with an absolutely cold indifference, no feeling whatsoever behind her blank stare.
On a second occasion, I witnessed a woman with two children aboard her electric bike get stuck on a zebra crossing (such crossings are routinely ignored by motorists in China). Cars were bearing down from the lights a couple of hundred metres distant. I did what most people would do and rushed out to help push the woman and her children clear. My Chinese girlfriend of the time looked at me disapprovingly and asked what did I think I was doing. So strange; I wasn't looking for plaudits but criticising such an action seemed a bit much.
I could relate several other incidents but they all tell of the same, very depressing phenomenon. Chinese society under the CPC is hugely depressing in this way.
Agree with you, 🙄 last week a situation with chinese woman here in Germany on station with a lot of people... she don't understand me that first people get out of train before she get into the train 🤷🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏼♀️
“What do you think your doing” sounds like you deprived her of a rare treat.
Thats terrible mate, and yet the CCP wants to spread their influence to the whole world.. no thanks
@@karinaemelie1665 it isn’t even about others, you yourself have an easier time getting in when you let others out first
i hope you broke up with her after this...
Keep speaking out !!! Your work means a lot. It informs of things we would not hear of but for you!
Great video, Wilson. Heart-wrenching. My late husband was an ABC, and he was the most loving and kindest person I know.
"I'm sorry china " Jon Xina
Kind of off topic, but I remember something about a kindergarten teacher in mainland China using a pair of scissors to cut off the finger of an unruly girl. The excuse she gave was that she had had enough. I told a Chinese friend, an otherwise upstanding and good natured individual, and he merely shrugged and giggled. The way he brushed it off made me think "What is wrong with you ?"
I had a Chinese boyfriend. Very weird by western standards, felt he had no empathy, trusted no one, and would laugh at horrible things happening to people
My Chinese born wife, shocks me quite often. With her lack of regard, for others. After my elderly mother died. She insisted many times, that I no longer had, to look after my stepdad.
@@billpetersen298 that's pretty unusual, honestly. Filial piety can be a pain in the ass, but it's very common in Asia, including China. Expected even. Could be just that she doesn't value your dad because he's not Chinese :(
After reading this this makes me feel the same. How could you be just indifferent about it
@@billpetersen298 WTF?
Thanks for bringing this to light once again! Keep up the great work
Wow, already 5 years since that video? Time sure flies... Thank you Winston for being a voice of reason and holding your ground!
OT: That kid at 10:09 has some really funky ears...
Don't mock people's ears.
in some parts of Malaysia, If someone caught trying to kidnap a kid, they best be running away. If they got caught they'll be beaten to death before Police even arrived.
thats how everyone in the whole world should react
@@Mrdestiny17 I don't know how the human brain can actually ignore a child in distress.
We are evolutionarily hardwired to pretty much die if a child is in any sort of bad situation.
This is dehumanisation to a shocking scale.
I remember watching a social experiment where a dude tries to steal an empty push chair in NYC and he gets stomped out by like 6 different dudes who run over, and a group of women grab the push chair to check on what they assume is a frightened baby.
While thats a shit 3rd world country the ways those countries deal with felons is actually the best thing
people need to be more aware, not trying to be hero but at least do something right? instead of just watching
thats what happens in china, well some parts. My mum (from guangzhou) said that if a kidnapper gets caught, theyd be beaten to death by people or smth
Been watching you for 5 years now, keep it up Winston!
Thanks for sharing info like this, it's really important
I saw a social experiment of a woman getting attacked and nobody did anything, but then, there was 1 hero and he was ready to throw DOWN with the people doing the experiment. They were like "NO NO NO LOOK" pointing at the camera. But you could tell it was unexpected.
That is the risk with such experiments. Kudos to the guy ready to defend another.
I also saw a video of a reverse experiment ie a woman was beating a man and everyone just said that he probably deserved it.
@@blarfroer8066 The worst fear may be a set-up by a man and a woman to get someone involved for the purposes of robbing them. This sad, though rare reality also contributes to some minding their own business.
There is a really interesting experiment where they reverse the situation with a male attacking a woman and vice versa. When the male attacks people do actually intervene, particularly young men. When the roles are reversed however, nobody helps the guy at all, some folks even laughing at his situation. A bit of everyday sexism, I guess.
I remember watching an American show called "What would you do?" that does all kinds of social experiments. Sometimes it's a kid being bullied, an elderly being mistreated, a spouse who is cheating/flirting with someone else. I'm sure there are clips here on youtube.
Even though my grandmother was quite selfish and annoying, she actually stood up and stopped a guy beating a child as he accused the child was trying to pickpocket him. No other people helped of course and that just shows the indifferent attitude is definitely a post communist thing. If you have a chance to talk to old people that grew up before the cultural devolution they will most likely to tell you morality in society as a whole has gone down the drain compared to the olden days.
And there are fewer and fewer of them with every passing day. Soon, there won't be anyone left who remembers a different time. It's like how it won't be long before there won't be any North Koreans who remember a time before the Kims and this dictatorship is all North Koreans will have known. 😕
If the alternative is the people that carried out the Cultural Revolution, I'll stick with indifference.
@@I.____.....__...__ there is still Taiwan and the millions of overseas traditional Chinese diaspoa that emigrated before CCP.
😅I know, I was trying to beat up this kid I was trying to frame for the police inquiry on my heavy heroin and human trafficking lifestyle, and she came out of nowhere and slapped me, I decided not to off her right away as I didn't want the drama. Anyways I've moved on now.
See crack is a lot more profitable and the Colombians are easier to deal with, you can't cause overdoses to advertise the quality of your smack, you gotta feed the crackheads for a while some really good stuff, they fry their brains on it and then they'll make a few K's that month shoplifting and the like.
China has been a conflicted country for centuries. People who yearn for the "olden days" often ignore all the bad stuff that happened every couple of decades, like genocides with millions of casualties.
I'm with you mate! Best wishes from Poland!
Just found your channel about a week ago ...binge watched them and your other channels . Keep it up bravo
Absolutely disgusting. I knew it was dystopian, but it always blows my mind how dystopian and deprived the society actually is. The video samaritan video from 2017 was one of the best and enlightening videos on your channel . I remember it well
I truly feel terrible for these individuals since their refusal to accept even minor help indicates that they live in constant terror for their own lives. May God help them.
Once the United Nations implements the one world government, new world order in 2030 (See "U.N. Agenda 2030") turning the world into a totalitarian communist cesspool, Europe, America and all the formerly "nice" polite countries will become exactly like China is now.
You cannot act like it isn't here too already.. Check out new york subs... Lots of videos just like this a woman getting attacked and everyone just stands and watches maybe record it... It is worldwide.
@@lockheartrobin7114 Still worse in China yanno
I went to darknet for research purposes..Its wayy worse worse worse ...oh god what have I done☠
When I was younger China held a certain allure to me. I always wished to see it's beautiful landscapes and mountain ranges, but every day that seems less and less viable. Truly a disgrace the CCP... an abhorrent excuse for humanity.
Thank you Winston! Don't ever stop putting your videos on UA-cam.
good to see you uploading serpenza
I was at Beijing Railway station in 2001. A woman in front of us collapsed and smashed her face on the floor. No one except us approached her. When she came to, with blood pouring down her face she looked even more startled at us trying to help her! We also saw a man get knocked off his bike and run over. No one stopped. It was an inhumane dystopia.
They don't even give a s*** about each other.
i wat at america in 2021 , bunch american group rob old people in street ,and people just dont care didnt help her and pppl looting store in mall , and nobody stop them too theres no moral in america
this explained a lot when people fainted during the early days of covid in china...
just NPC things
sounds like cap, when i visited beijing, me and my parents were walking and some guy who was running ran into us, and someone helped us up and asked if we were ok, this was in 2016, tho i guess this is on a smaller scale than smashing ur face on the floor
3:49 Agent 47 breaking up a fight. I never tire of that clip. Stay awesome Winston!
Thank you Winston on the structured informative content always. I have never been to China but through your videos and also other channels too I learn about the modern China a lot... Good and bad sides , attractive and less attractive ... like everywhere nowhere is perfect right? I support your work as of a journalist whois trying to present to us one beautiful and increasingly advanced country. I hope that the world will be a better place in future and that also the freedoms and liberties will not be questioned by bthe future fair systems. I can not judge but I learn. Thank you again.
Shocking
This really is deep. About a month ago, an auntie crashed her ebike about 200m in front of me. Multiple people just passed her and didn't even try to help, some people were watching, but they did nothing. I have a camera on my bike, I helped her get back up, fortunately she wasn't hurt, she got back on her bike and rode away, she didn't even show any sign of gratitude that I helped her. When I got home from work that night, I showed the video to my wife and my wife yelled at me, she said that I could have been blamed and I shouldn't have helped.
This is a cancer that is deeply rooted in Mainland China, and I'm thankful that you're exposing it to the world. I hope this changes, but I'm not optimistic about it. I've lived here for so long, my optimism about positive societal change here is non-existent.
Whats so positive about saving the lowest common denominator? Let some darwinism happen. No peanut allergies in China 😂
Watching at this comment section it seems there were thousands of people that witnessed a disastrous accident IN CHINA and heroically saved their lives, releasing them from horrific suffering, in the middle of a silent, guilty crowd.
Well I seem to be the only person who actually lived there for 6 years and never witnessed - and never had the chance to be an acclaimed hero 😢- such horrible accidents, neither my friends and relatives, foreigners and chineses alike. I’m not saying you’re lying, although I find it extremely suspicious 😂.
Actually it’s quite the opposite, a friend of mine hurt his foot quite badly and some random restaurant staff rushed at him for help.
I remember trying to help a guy in China pick up a girl who had passed out in the middle of the pavement (for god knows what reason). I literally had to explain (in Chinese) like 5 times before he could understand that I was actually trying to help. He said: "people are not like you", I was like: "she needs to get to a fckin hospital". Needless to say, people were just walking by, even though we could have done with more help dealing with a deadweight girl flopping around everywhere. Getting a taxi to stop was not easy either.
This really makes me wonder how common rape, human trafficking and forced prostitution must be in China when people can see a literal toddler get dragged away and just simply ignore it.
@@MasterIceyy You forgot black market organ selling.
Same here. I was visiting a friend in Nanjing in early 2008. We were in a Taxi and saw a woman on a bike get clipped by a motor scooter. Her head hit the ground HARD. The guy on the scooter yelled at her motionless body (even though it was his fault) and sped off. Nobody else even broke stride. I thought she was dead. My buddy (who was there learning Chinese) made the Taxi stop and we checked her out. The driver was confused why we wanted to stop when we weren't yet to our destination so we had to yell at him. Fortunately she was only knocked out for 20 seconds or so. When she came to, it took her a while to realize we were there to help rather than to abduct or rob her. I was shocked how everybody just acted as though nothing happened. A VERY selfish and cruel society.
@@MasterIceyy I’m wondering that too. I don’t understand how anyone could behave like that. How anyone could be so cold blooded. That old guy that dragged that drowning woman out of the water was a British diplomat (or something similar as this happened years ago) and despite his age he jumped into the water and saved that woman. But he was the only one who helped her and it made international news for a brief time. I was curious so I researched a bit and found out a bit about that element of Chinese society.
But I suppose my biggest recent concerns for the ordinary Chinese people is how many died of starvation during the strict lockdowns, particularly in Shanghai. I just wonder that for every person that escaped their own homes to sneak out and get food, how many didn’t. The elderly or anyone without the ability to climb things that were forgotten by the CCP. With the callous attitude of the Chinese people I wonder if neighbours bothered to help them.
Besides the obvious things like the Uyghur extermination camps and people like Peng Shuai I wonder if the CCP has secretly started a Chinese version of The Handmaid’s Tale with any women they “disappear” when someone becomes a problem.
@@mikoto7693 Well we saw that video where a woman was chained up and was being used as a sex slave by 3 or 4 brothers because they couldn't find a wife.
2 Guys found and freed her and were later arrested and imprisoned for literally freeing this woman, where as the 4 brothers faced no legal consequences and no one knows what became of the woman.
Thai, Viet, Malay, Indonesian, Filipino, Mongolian, Korean, Japanese and many women and underage girls from around the world are being trafficked into China because of the 1 child policy that destroyed the gender balance of the nation
I APPLAUD you for stepping up in that one older video! Bravo, sir!
Keep up the great work Winston
I remember your 5 year old video, and I support it. China has a moral deficit that is clear to all. While many Chinese feel their country is safe, go to the countryside and you'll see a different environment. People will protect those that they know or are related to, but strangers receive no help. The number of legal cases where good Samaritans were financially held liable really hurt China's moral fiber. If the courts do not encourage people to help strangers, but rather punish them, then people will hesitate to help those that they do not know. It is understandable.
is there a link to it?
The thing is those good samaritan lawsuits happen in America too. As Winston said I think it is more of a societal illness than a legal issue.
@@deepg7084 In North America we have Good Samaritan laws that protect those who, to the best of their ability and training, try to help people in physical danger. Yes you can be sued, but you will be protected by law. China has no Good Samaritan laws.
@@TorBoy9 in america u will get rob and nobody will help u ,theres no moral in america
@@TorBoy9 Thanks for telling.
Here in Germany, anyone can be reported and sued for failure to provide assistance, as a negative trend has also become apparent.
I saw it right when you posted it. So grateful for your .very important - work...and horrified of ANY censorship.
Well done, sir...as always...from NZ.
Love your videos. I often let people know what good, informative videos you create and are definitely worth watching and not to believe most of the BS you see on TV today. Job well done Winston!
Well said, Mr. Clive
I was out for a walk recently and decided to take a break, sitting on a brick wall. Had two cars stop and ask me if I were okay. I don't know if I looked that tired or what, but it was nice of them to take a minute out of their day, and perhaps more to see if I were okay.
Thank you for exposing this. It's disgusting.
THEY are disgusting.
@@RockyRMR They are. CCP has ruined Chinese culture.
@@RockyRMR The hair is on its way out mate.
@@J_X999 always the people with no face in their profile pic commenting on peoples appearance 🤣
@@RockyRMR They bite through the faces of live mice. Watching th squirm while their psychopathic breed smiles and laughs, is something else.
I've watched them pour boiling soy sauce on live octopus babies who writhed in agony.
Cue democrat "animal rights activists" to try to say how this is morally ok.
You're a man of honour Winston! Not only do you say something, you also take action!
Thanks Winston, I watched that video several years ago and it appalled me. Your videos are always very interesting for a guy from Canada (my Grandad was South African by the way).
Thank you for everything you do to inform us of what is going on.
I’ve been aware of this issue for awhile now. That old man who jumped into the water to save a drowning woman was some sort of British official or diplomat. Because he was British, he ended up on the news and in the headlines for a short while. It was both nice because our diplomat was a hero who risked his life given his age but also horrific that the Chinese are quite content to watch someone drown without trying to help.
The bystander effect is very real around the world unfortunately and I’ve seen two instances of this personally. The first was when I was 17 walking to college one morning and I came across a young woman in a pink business suit with heels and a matching handbag just passed out on the pavement with a lot of pedestrians either avoiding her or stepped over her. So I stepped forward and began with the very basic first aid and called an ambulance. I knew she was alive because she was breathing and I could feel a pulse but she didn’t respond to any stimuli even when the paramedics came. I still sometimes wonder what happened to her.
The second time was when I was in my twenties and a motorcycle came off worse when it smashed into a car and the rider flew off his motorcycle and had a very hard landing on the road surface. Thanks to his helmet and leathers certain injuries were avoided. But he still broke his arm and pelvis along with a couple internal injuries. And yet I was the first person to approach and park behind and put the hazard lights on to warn other drivers and jump out with my first aid kit in hand. (By then I’d learned proper first aid and I still keep a first aid kit in my car to this day.)
It seems that often, once one person reacts and “takes responsibility” it galvanises other people to help. In short order we had me and two others assisting the rider, two more tending to the driver of the car and his passengers while yet others had organised the means for approaching drivers to turn around then going to the junctions to block the road and divert traffic. For a group of total random strangers we worked together well until the police and other emergency services arrived and took over.
I think it might have been a point of pride for other people as well as me when we noticed that the police were just taking up our positions along with a few signs that we didn’t have, rather than making their own plan.
While crimes in Britain is off the roof
@@ugooko7569
"Off the roof"
Learn English before trying to deflect, little Pink
Most Chinese people can't swim and the ones who do probably know next to nothing about life saving - funny considering how many medals they win in swimming meets.
@@ugooko7569 50 cent army
You can cut the Chinese some slack with the British diplomat rescuing a drowning person thing, most Chinese people can't swim. Winston himself mentioned this in a video where he and c milk covered that incident
I can't believe I remembered the original video. You're such a great kid Winston I am proud to know you a little bit. Bless you and your family 🏞️❤️🍀🇦🇺
Thank you for your channel - you do important work! 💛
You were really badass when you intervened in that restaurant. Respectful, manly, awesome. True heroic decision worth following ☝️
I’m going to share the hell out of that video!! Great work! I saw that video a long time ago and it’s unbelievable that people stand by and do nothing to help people in horrible situations! Keep up the great work!
Thank you Winston! I love your videos!!
Thank you for your courage!
It's like a bug society. One of them get squished and they just keep on going.
About a year ago I saw a young girl in Hunan fall into some deep water who clearly couldn't swim. A couple of local young men immediately jumped in to rescue her. I know this isn't normally the case but It restored my faith a little, I feel the younger generation are a bit more conscious to helping those in need
A doctor friend of mine from Wuhan who lives in Europe once rescued a kid from drowning in China and resuscitated it. When the kid went to hospital, friends of my friend who work in that hospital told him that the kid‘s parents asked for the lung X-Ray to see if there are any rib fractures so they could sue my friend for recompensation. Which is insane because my friend saved the kid‘s life!
@@themonsir1 Yeah, the Chinese people care more about money than anything else. This is what destruction of traditional values (aka The Great Leap FoRwArD) and driving people towards materialism does to a society.
@@themonsir1 cold blood reptiles!
@@themonsir1 That is insane, what kind of person even does that!!!!!. They truly are not human.
@@themonsir1 That is why it is so scary to get involved - in a litigious society, everybody wants someone to blame so they can seek compensation, or feel content that justice has been served. When compensation is the primary goal it doesn't matter who gets the blame. If you attempt to help a victim of an assault, an ignorant bystander could identify you as the assailant.
Well done man!
This is very similar to what happens in Japan too. Tokyo Lens explained what happened to him when he helped out on the subway. The police took him in and the other party that was causing violence tried to shift blame on him. But luckily there was another witness that stepped forward to explain what happened. It's sad that overall society in general likes to blame people no matter if it's their fault to begin with.
Thanks for uploading, Serpentza. Always a good show
I worked in the semiconductor capital equipment development and noted the indifference of the mainland Chinese to others quandaries. Some were shocked when I stopped what I was doing and helped for a moment with some simple task.
Many were nice folks and smiled and we talked. A few others were "wolf warrior" types and were sneeringly contemptuous or suspicious of what it was I wanted.
They all had PhDs so not necessarily a cross section. I scratched the surface a couple of times and racism was an issue as well. It seemed rampant.
The CCP has sold a lot lies to its populace and it will be a rude awakening.
so its not wrong they suspicous to u ,because u are serpentza follower and anti china lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Whenever there's a problem or lie about China, we can always blame the CCP somehow
@@J_X999 yeah - seems appropriate.
CCP = bunch of liars and thieves who steal from their own.
it's so common it happens every second...
The world needs you, Sir!
I have a couple friends from Macau and Tawain, and although I've met very kind people from Mainland China, the consensus was that people from the Mainland were very different. My friends from the other regions told me they had serious issues with them and their behaviour, which I didn't understand until I learned more. I can only advocate for individuals, because I think we all know, that there are always people that care out there, but it's so sad that people are afraid to help even if they want.
I'm another guy that often steps in.
Sometimes somebody has to.
This really helps me understand some people I know so thank you!
Thanks for your investigative reports !
I am learning a lot but it is depressing to hear that people are so passive.
They're like mindless robots 🤖
I just happened to watch that video about 2 or 3 weeks ago. The lack of willingness to help anyone in immediate danger is not only bizarre, but it does mean that the society is in a socially destructive downward spiral.
no mate, they just passed a new law that says that if you dont help someone in need you could be convicted and also that if you help somebody you can not be held liable for their injuries.
@@PhillipGregoryMusic But will that law actually be enforced or is it just one of many laws that looks nice on paper but doesn't mean anything?
@@jessn.3851 It will atm not be enforced by neither the public or insurance companies.
Well done, I love your work.
THANK YOU WINSTON !!!!
I have to say, I was in a popular town centre tourist attraction in Australia on a very hot day.
There was a dirty young man passed out on the footpath among diners in a street cafe.
I rang the local government and had to shame them with bad publicity in the press before the staff would lift a finger to help this guy.
He could have had a stroke, a fit, heat stress whatever, but the fact is nobody was helping him.
I had to protect myself, I tried rousing him but didn't want to moved him.
The local government receptionist told ME to organise an ambulance for him.
I had to point out that it was her job not mine to ensure their public spaces were safe to use.
I'm not letting the CCP off the hook, but they simply have to engage people to come to the rescue (rangers?) of these lost people in Cities.
This doesn't relate to the more horrific instances in Winston 's video, but it would go some way to reducing the violence and suffering.
Whatever the cultural case may be, when the societal case is that the state will persecute you for trying to help others it'll eventually result in this behavior anyway. This speaks volumes to the level of control the Chinese state has over it's own citizens.
They want the people to be as separate as possible
I don't think it's just the CCP stopping citizens from caring about each other. I think they are a callous and cowardly group of subhumans. They show hatred towards animals. Just a disgusting country that needs to be walled off from the rest of us. It'll save us from the next pandemic that invariably comes from China.
Yup. I think its the perception of control. Cos the party, although not socialist, sorts of promises to care for the ppl. Difficult to explain, as I am a brit living in China. UK has, or did have, cradle to grave social system. China promised it, but never delivered. So the party seems to have made itself out to be the guardian, as in, trust us and nothing bad will happen. So when something bad does happen, the ppl stand and watch, and say, how can this happen, cos the party protects us. If an old dude is knocked over on a zebra.. sweep it up, it never happened. Cos the party does not let it happen. Same with the heatwave just now.. its americas fault. To me, everyone is told trust the guv and nowt bad will happen. When it does go wrong, as it does all over the world, the party says nope. It never happened. If it did.. its the wests fault. 👍
So yup, since the 1930, the party has been offering a socialist utopia. Nobody needs have to worry about anything. The party will look after you. But while europe has pretty much delivered on that ( I am a socialist), no system being perfect of course, China has not.. its always.. hang on a bit longer, we are almost there.. just need more time.. pedestrians ran over on crossings need to be hidden. Cos there is no free ambulance, no free doctors, like in europe. In europe, treat first, deal with the incident. It wont bankrupt you if a car knocks you over. But thats not the case here. Its not automatic free care. If a car knocks you down, and the driver is a party official ( they are arsehole drivers), prosecute those who help. Cos the party member cant be blamed. Sweep it under the carpet. And the party is massive here. They have recently started putting notices on doors.. party members live here. And hey, it was even worse before XI banned guv red number plates on cars. Back then, maybe 12 years ago, guv plated cars never had to obey any rules. Now the red plates are gone, the drivers still have the same protection, but nobody knows who they are. Tip.. avoid white BMW SUVs. 😂😂. Sorry for the ramble. 👍
Wow, so shocking. Your work is so important. Take care!
The world needs many more people like you. Thanks so much for what you do.
Thank you Winston. You are awesome and providing a much needed public service in making people aware of the depths of depravity of the PRC.
Man thanks for this video, i grew up in an area with a lot of asian immigration and i've always found myself frustrated by the level of not getting involved some of them were. I remember once i fell on my bike in an alley and it was pretty bad. This asian family just drove around me as they were getting out their parking spaces without even asking me if i was okay. I actually broke my rib and the only person that came to ask me if i was okay was some kid playing in his balconey. That frustrated me a lot and now i understand the societal forces that made them act that way.
Thats a cool old Vaio in the advert. I remember those, nifty novelties from another time, back when Sony could bang out hits each year.
God bless ya Winston. You’re a bloody hero.
This channel is incredibly valuable. Like a documentary that document every aspects of the modern China
It skips over a LOT. But most of the negatives are covered brilliantly by this channel
I saw that video back in the day already. I started following you, when I was being headhunted to go work in China for big bucks in Aviation. It was very tempting, but the more I dug into the conditions, the treatment, and the lying, all backed up by many of your videos, it became evident it would be a chase after fool's gold. I'm so glad I didn't upend my world and go to China for what would have been a disaster. Keep up the good work.
Wow! You did the right decision then!
Several expats who flew to China (for great payments) had to return to their home countries or just go somewhere else after all the lockdowns started in 2020. In 2021 they returned to be locked again in 2022. Some people are just soooo greedy.
@@jmshwood2801 Or missed out on the China boom
But.. DUDE WHY..? I have lived in China for many year and it is certainly not even close to what they’re describing. Surely is not heaven, there are many downsides but it is just like everything in life, you have to balance the pros and cons. It is actually incredibly safe. The quality of life is not as good as some other countries, some Chinese behavior can be quite frustrating. But There are actually good chances for your career to skyrocket, with all the opportunities there are…
Saw that video awhile ago. Only found your channels when the pandemic started..watched all videos leaned so much n very in shock!
Speechless
I was born in USSR. I can tell you exactly what I see here. In tyrannical societies all the crimes are committed by policeman, their friends and relatives and they commit a lot of crimes. And guess how all of that not getting into criminal statistics. Just standing up for yourself is a death sentence there, they will kill you or call you a criminal.
I think that is a bit of overstatement. Most crimes were committed by the "friends" of corrupt officials who had enough cover to get you removed if you complained. I think something similar is happening in the US as politicians are vocal in opposing security guards and police responding to thefts or assaults so a lot of people just give up.
@@Lawofimprobability Overstatement? Overstatement?! Seriously?! Dude, I hate to say it, but you have porridge in your head. You think that in such society as China's you can be rich person or official without friends in enforcement organizations? Who else is a friend of police in China? Mafia. Whom police in China protects their friends from? Decent people this is whom. And police in US, well, US is clearly turns tyrannical, it is just another sign. So stop being naive or you will not live long.
@@SergKiev87Note your wording. "In tyrannical societies ALL THE CRIMES..."
That is overstatement. I would agree most crimes are done by people with corrupt connections but not all.
@@Lawofimprobability "ALL THE CRIMES..." Is this what your problem is? I can see you never lived in tyrannical society. We are speaking different languages here. In tyrannical society if some degenerate did you wrong and you somehow know, that he has no connections to speak of, you will think twice before calling police. Because you know, they need to blame someone for their own crimes and here going you - bad criminal statistic, with your demands. Who is friend of the police in such society? Whom it protects from whom? Look, police there not even trying to hide what they are. Unlike US police that sometimes imprison criminals, to protect them from you.
@@SergKiev87 I was born under Communism in Romania. I saw the effects ranging from alcoholic teachers to industrial accidents to the corruption.
I care about precision since imprecise orders get people killed. Accuracy is needed to fix problems, not overly broad wording that causes new problems.
I experienced a case of the bystander affect myself when living in China. I was walking down the road and a taxi pulled up to a woman pushing a stroller down the street and three guys jumped out and snatched her baby. I ran after them but they got back in the taxi and took off. When I returned to her a couple of minutes later (I had chased the taxi for a bit) the woman was lying on the ground crying with 10-15 people standing around her gawking. It was quite an insight into Chinese culture.
That's fucked up
they were feeding on her sorrow loosh
( i know none of u get this)
For them its just a good show...
@@williss1192 fucking dogs.
What could these 10-15 people do though?
Great piece..
i have seeing that video long long ago , Took me some years to subscribe to your channel , always watched your videos , and keep up sharing the true. God bless you ! stay awesome!
The level of dehumanization in the PRC can hardly be calculated or understood by the West.
Ummmm, did you see how they described and attacked those who refused to take the shot? Families disowned their own family members. Our governments in the west are not far off from the CCP when it comes to manipulating it's people.
Yet the western world tries to use their own logic/morals/standards when dealing with the CCP. It's idiotic. We can't trust anything that's coming out of China.
@@grimfang5023 It is true that the entire world is going further and further away from decent morals and ethics, however I don't really know a single person in any western country that I've lived in who would watch a woman get run over by vehicles repeatedly and stand by doing nothing.
@KrO Which people are you referring to?
@KrO What I'm trying to determine is if you're referring to the people of China or Westerners.
A Government that dehumanizes it's people makes it's people devoid of humanity.
I mean that's basically what government does and the ultimate logical conclusion of what truly is it's nature. Suppress, Violate and Destroy.
Welcome to Communist China, lol.
I remember that video! I've been a consistent fab of you and C-milk. You guys are treasures for westerns wanting insight into China.
I stopped the Video halfway, watched you 5 Year old Video and came back...now i'm Checking out The China Show!
Hope you can in the future still make such Video's becouse they are REALLY IMPORTANT!