KAISERREICH VS KAISERREDUX | HOI 4 | WHICH MODIFICATION IS BETTER?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024
  • KAISERREICH VS KAISERREDUX | HOI 4 | WHICH MODIFICATION IS BETTER?
    ✅ My Instagram - / mykhailo_lapkun
    ✅ Join Our Discord - / discord
    ✅ Cooperation & ads - lapkunbusiness@gmail.com
    ✅ Sponsor my Channel - / @mikhail_poltavskiy
    #poltavskiy #hoi4 #heartsofiron4 #hoi4 #heartsofiron4 #kaiserreich #kaiserredux

КОМЕНТАРІ • 238

  • @ananomalocaris1682
    @ananomalocaris1682 Рік тому +224

    Kaiserreich aims to ask: “What if Germany won WW1?”
    Kaiserredux aims to ask: “What’s the funniest thing this obscure war criminal can do?”

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +34

      What’s the funniest war crime can you imagine???

    • @iamtherealElite
      @iamtherealElite 10 місяців тому +4

      @@Mikhail_Poltavskiyeating children pizza at a school event in a warzone

    • @ultimatestuff7111
      @ultimatestuff7111 6 місяців тому +4

      @@iamtherealElitewhat about drinking baby formula from sippy cups in front of starving children

    • @iamtherealElite
      @iamtherealElite 6 місяців тому +2

      @@ultimatestuff7111 what about both

    • @NatLegal-f9z
      @NatLegal-f9z 19 днів тому +1

      @@iamtherealElite What about literally all war crimes possible ( Alongside all imoral things ! )

  • @Siphonicsea36
    @Siphonicsea36 Рік тому +145

    I honestly prefer Kaiserreich. Kaiserredux can be fun but I like having a WW2 between the Entente and Reichspakt vs Internationale and Moscow Accord. Rather than The Greater Liberian sphere vs The Lichtenstein pact

    • @Mattef22
      @Mattef22 Рік тому +7

      You've got it right not to mention that many kaiserredux focuses have bugs

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому +6

      Well... At some point - I can agree with you.

    • @Angelcynn-x9m
      @Angelcynn-x9m 7 місяців тому +2

      Thanks for this suggestion im going to try to have a game of The Greater Liberian Sphere vs Lichtensteinpact

  • @AverageSyrianGeneral
    @AverageSyrianGeneral Рік тому +212

    I personally love kaiserredux more than kaiserreich simply because kaiserredux adds more content and more cursed paths even though kaiserredux is poorly optimized.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +16

      Yep, exactly bro

    • @Legacy1283tr
      @Legacy1283tr Рік тому +8

      Yeah ı choose kaiserredux to but my PC says NO basicly.

    • @Aidenaman
      @Aidenaman 8 місяців тому +1

      It also brings back the past good stuff

  • @Monkeyowner69124
    @Monkeyowner69124 8 місяців тому +12

    Here to sum it up for you
    Kasierriech
    -Good paths for major countries
    -explains lore to you
    -Very good optimisation
    -less laggy
    -not that many unnecessary countries
    Cons
    -Other countries don’t have good focus trees
    -Less countries
    -not that many fun focuses
    -important countries not having focus trees
    Kaiserredux
    -Fun weird cursed focus trees
    -More countries
    -More focuses for even more countries like Afghanistan and even texas
    -more options for focuses
    -more ideologies
    Cons
    -Laggy
    -poorly optimised
    -Some countries don’t even sever purposes but just cause more lag (cmon you added sikkim this country dosent do anything)
    -

  • @pomernguy1835
    @pomernguy1835 Рік тому +75

    Thanks for your opinions about both modifications, I like hearing what people have to say about Kaiserreich and Kaiserredux! On the topic of updates: Kaiserreich will soon realase an update for the Left Kuomintang and Kaiserredux will soon have Ukraine updated.

    • @ozark7834
      @ozark7834 Рік тому +1

      I've played KX Ukraine already

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +9

      Really want to compare ukrainian re-work in both of modifications

    • @llama7720
      @llama7720 Місяць тому

      Bro is AI

    • @pomernguy1835
      @pomernguy1835 Місяць тому

      @@llama7720 What are you talking about?

    • @llama7720
      @llama7720 Місяць тому

      @@pomernguy1835 just jokin😃
      Your comment was oddly "official" and polite, just like an AI made comment.

  • @danworks9559
    @danworks9559 Рік тому +72

    While kaiserredux does have a lot more updates then kaiserreich, I feel like they are shoddily put together leading to it running like shit while with kaiserreich the updates feel a lot more cohesive and things run a lot better. Also, I feel the paths in redux are more hit or miss with some being pretty balanced while others are just too overpowered and not challenging.
    Ps, do you have any proof that they deliberately deleted any pro Russian content for Ukraine because I can’t seem to find any proof from anywhere that the team did that.

    • @AntiFurry927
      @AntiFurry927 Рік тому +5

      Canada update recently was amazing and great performance but I do have a really good processor

    • @jellybelly841
      @jellybelly841 Рік тому +13

      in kr, old ukraine gameplay had a pro-russian path, but since Putin launched SMO, they took very pro-ukrainian position, thats why they deleted from russian rework, a crisis mechanic between russia and ukraine

    • @kinggwyn3056
      @kinggwyn3056 Рік тому +6

      ​@@jellybelly841hmmmm that was never even a thing in the rework

    • @danworks9559
      @danworks9559 Рік тому +4

      ⁠​⁠​⁠@@jellybelly841but they said the coal crisis mechanic was removed because said it didn’t work well, how was that related to their pro Ukraine position?

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +2

      Bro, about the first part - yeah, maybe. But on the other side - without some buffs you can't play some countries ( Alaska and other stuff ), so it's just made to be funny, and it's constructed really good, because in most of combinations - AI won't reach those pathes

  • @thehost568
    @thehost568 Місяць тому +8

    Kaiserreich: Realistic paths
    Kaiserredux: Re-established the Mongol Empire

  • @farmonxqc9370
    @farmonxqc9370 Рік тому +32

    I just like kaiserreich because it feels more realistic, you can take it seriously. Although it does not have a lot of content compared to kaiserredux, kaiserredux has content that for all countries that makes your game to unpredictable to take seriously. So if you wanna feel like you are playing in a world where Germany won world war 1, play kaiserreich. If you want to explore as much content as you can in a world where Germany won world war 1 then play kaiserredux

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому +1

      Kaiserredux is like - when you're tireds enough of Kaiserreich realism and scripts - it's time to act!

    • @farmonxqc9370
      @farmonxqc9370 11 місяців тому +1

      @@Mikhail_Poltavskiy Well I am havn't played Kaiserreich the longest so I understand if you would prefer redux if you have played Kaiserreich for so long

    • @Cannibal_Holocaust
      @Cannibal_Holocaust 3 місяці тому

      @@farmonxqc9370 Kaiserreich feels totally unrealistic when you try playing small countries... In Kaiserdux you can pick totally insignificant country, and it has detailed historical events and characters...

  • @taserrr
    @taserrr 6 місяців тому +5

    Well I can understand their choice of not having a pro russian path if they don't want anybody to roleplay Ukraine joining Russia.
    Hoi4 has chosen to completely avoid atrocities within hoi4 even though they had a massive effect in the war. Germany had around 10 million slave labor to work with, building various things as well as working in factories. So historically speaking the game should have a ton of events for construction speed but reduced population, increase rebellion etc. but I think most people can understand and respect their choice. And that's about events that happened 80 years ago.
    As we speak today Russians are still committing war crimes in Ukraine, executing civilians, moving citizens to work in camps and stealing babies to increase their population at home. So I can understand why they're doing it.

  • @vemmotheshitt9678
    @vemmotheshitt9678 Рік тому +18

    Kaiserreich is a good mod but I am a kaiserredux enjoyer 💪

  • @TheFrustratedHistorian
    @TheFrustratedHistorian Рік тому +7

    Regarding your comment about Kaiserreich only having two updates this year, the day after this video was posted, Kaiserreich released “Blue Sky, White Sun”, which reworks the Left Kuomintang.

  • @andreatocchetto6992
    @andreatocchetto6992 Рік тому +18

    I usually play kaiesserich however like you said it's practically becoming an alternative vanilla version. Every playthrough is the same, practicality the only think that change the resoult of some of scripted civilwars such as the Spanish one. Of course sometimes you see half of the world changing ideology or faction steamrolling the othe factions. However if I'm not wrong before was imprevedibile, the fun thing of this modification was the imprevedibility of the whole senario. Also you have a focus tree for Buthan and not many comuntries more involved such Azerbaijan, Philippines.

    • @andreatocchetto6992
      @andreatocchetto6992 Рік тому

      Also i very like seeing you commenting the Ukrainian update and maybe some context from us timeline, I think it would be very interesting.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому

      Kaiserreich still has it's own unique charm, so i understand you :)

  • @ProfessionalKGBAgent
    @ProfessionalKGBAgent Рік тому +7

    I like KRX more because of content, replayability and updates also is more fun. People say its memey (its) but it adds more fun which what matters to me

  • @nono_Hoi4
    @nono_Hoi4 Рік тому +13

    Yeah I can agree with your points imo
    a mod that takes place in the past should not be influenced by Modern events
    (TBH why take yourself seriously with realism and ''Realistic focuses'' by removing crazy paths in a map game of all things) Now time to wait for a KX Canada video/ Ukraine KR video
    hope you are doing well Poltavskiy

    • @what-uy7go
      @what-uy7go Рік тому +2

      as the developers said, the removal of the pro-Russian path is more a gameplay choice - Russia being able to take Ukraine/get it on its side with 0 opposition makes Russia more overpowered than it already is.. not to mention it just straight up ruins the Reichspakt's eastern front

    • @nono_Hoi4
      @nono_Hoi4 Рік тому +3

      @@what-uy7go Compared to other ''game ruining'' paths for another side Its like a medium bad but not the worst thing to deal with
      (no way to make the Ai the best thing ever)

    • @what-uy7go
      @what-uy7go Рік тому +2

      @@nono_Hoi4 what are some other game ruining paths? Besides the "get annexed by Russia" path for Ukraine which is thankfully gone now, Kaiserreich was and is a pretty balanced game.

    • @nono_Hoi4
      @nono_Hoi4 Рік тому

      @@what-uy7go ... CSA Joins the third international when the civil war ends cucking the entire Entente and reichspakt
      clearly the most important one: ALBANIA JOINS AUSTRIA AND GAME RUINS THE WORLD

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      Will play as Canada in Redux for Sure + i'll record Secret Path of Ukraine in the Kaiserreich

  • @scyobiempire4450
    @scyobiempire4450 2 місяці тому +1

    i like the lore direction of Reich but i prefer playing Redux
    it has more “ahistorical” options and the 2ACW is way better as well as the Autonomist path for the UoB and Bolsheviks in Russia, Alaska and Argentina

  • @themackie2763
    @themackie2763 Рік тому +7

    Kaiserreich Team didn’t give Ukraine a pro Russian path because they said it would tip the balance in favor for Russia too much. Which doesn’t make any sense because if the Belgians, Dutch, or Swiss flip to syndicalism, Germany usually loses.

    • @danii8168
      @danii8168 Рік тому +2

      Syndie Czechoslovakia unification as Bohemia breaks Germany, for whatever reason either the focuses are strong asl or the ai can’t handle that front once you invade them during the Weltkrieg

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  8 місяців тому +1

      But it's logical

  • @TahockiMapper
    @TahockiMapper Рік тому +7

    Kaiserredux was nice till they delete goebbels for no reason

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +5

      well… it was a reason. Content was deleted due to the copyright :(

    • @TahockiMapper
      @TahockiMapper Рік тому +6

      @@Mikhail_Poltavskiy oh sory, i though it is like in tno where devs delete funny paths because they are incorrect and edgy

  • @trashboat4020
    @trashboat4020 Рік тому +10

    Me personally I love Kaiserredux. It's paths are not as realistic as Kaisereich but it's way more fun in my opinion and it has so much more content.
    I love KX❤

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Me too! And every single game is a unique one!
      U can't even know what da hell will happen in the next campaign!

  • @Mashkator
    @Mashkator Рік тому +4

    Bro forgot to say "And Hello my dear bruders" 💀

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      So Hello My dear Brudaaasssss* :D
      It's a unique thing for campaigns :D

  • @koneser8197
    @koneser8197 Рік тому +10

    I overall agree with a lot of your criticism towards Kaiserreich but I think Redux's has a lot as well to have in mind. Of course I like both the mods but I cna clearly see issues with them, a long time between updates for KR might be bothering but remind yourself that their stuff is suppose to be 100% polished, with even unique mechanics and GUI which can be very hard to implement. As for the amount of content and updates that KX recived this year while being extensive doesn't provide the same campaign depth like KR, focus trees tend to focus around similar path designs and don't usually differ between eachother outside of bonuses and formables which can be cool.Performance wise KX modders probably need to strangle with optimisation since they release so much additional stuff which further burdens the mod, but I hope they will fasten it up in the future. Overall you have good points and I would still favor KX over KR but still it seemed like you focused mostly on KR problems.

    • @ranger_savage8406
      @ranger_savage8406 Рік тому +1

      I wouldn't say that adding senate mechanics (for example) in the decisions tab would make KR better perse. A lot of the depth of the game comes from outside of the decisions menu nad has to do with the actual warmaking and industry balancing. I personally get annoyed when a mod adds some cumbersome mechanic that only plays out in the decisions menu, but if you FAIL said minigame in a menu you can lose your entire playthrough (Looking at you TNO)

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому

      Thanks for your comment! Your point of view is good too!

  • @alexanderkolchak1
    @alexanderkolchak1 Рік тому +9

    Focus icons describe which one is better obv.

  • @Snqwy
    @Snqwy Рік тому +42

    If Kaiserredux isn't the textbook definition of quantity over quality then I don't know what is

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +12

      well, but Kaiserreich isn't a quality for the past few years...

    • @alexanderkolchak1
      @alexanderkolchak1 Рік тому +21

      Kaiserredux is both quality and quantitu

    • @Snqwy
      @Snqwy Рік тому +8

      @@alexanderkolchak1 Play Kaiserreich Ukraine, as an example, and then Kaiserredux Ukraine. Take the time to notice just how little flavor Kaiserredux presents you.

    • @konuralpsansalyasar8982
      @konuralpsansalyasar8982 Рік тому +5

      @@Snqwy the rework just came today actualy...

    • @Snqwy
      @Snqwy Рік тому +3

      @@konuralpsansalyasar8982 In that case, experience that content for yourself and come back to me with your opinion on it. Even better, how about you try a campaign in both mods and tell me which experience you think is generally more fulfilling and fun.

  • @ro-uq2uu
    @ro-uq2uu Рік тому +21

    Kaiserredux is a lot more developed, kaiserreich has some heavy limitations on their focuses due to realism, while kaiserredux has lots of focuses, choices, secret paths, etc. While both are a good mod I feel like kaiserredux is far more better gameplay wise alongside content wise

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Bro, content in KX is endless, because while you play of the paths - they will develope a ton of new XD

  • @Ziafiz
    @Ziafiz 8 місяців тому +2

    ngl kaiserredux is better then kaiserreich because kaiserredux has more funny paths and every nation has a focus tree and I barely played all the nations yet

  • @iratepirate3896
    @iratepirate3896 Рік тому +2

    I like both for different things.

  • @andreinatache6965
    @andreinatache6965 Рік тому +9

    Bro woke up today and said:
    ,, Imma spit some facts"
    Very good video, detailed and well explained!

  • @mariosvourliotakis
    @mariosvourliotakis 25 днів тому +1

    I prefer Kaiserreich for being more "realistic". Kaiserredux is fun if you wanna fuck around a bit, that's fair. Updates are slow, yes, but its literally free mods, arguably better than the base game, so we are in no position to complain too much...

  • @BlueisJay
    @BlueisJay 6 місяців тому +2

    I definitely like Kaiserreich. Kaiserredux is only usually (imo) liked because you can do really insane stuff. Kaiserreich is serious and more grounded in realism, like you can play as the German empire and win the 2nd and 3rd weltkriegs. you can play as a revolt in a racist American revolt and create a giant mega state that supports a sun god. Now, very different examples, but it shows the content you are getting.

    • @Cookinlikesanji
      @Cookinlikesanji 2 місяці тому

      So you can do base game hoi4 or have actual fun

    • @BlueisJay
      @BlueisJay 2 місяці тому

      @@Cookinlikesanji you have never played kaiserreich, almost every nation has custom content. Hey, even Yucatán has content

  • @-helpergamming-4163
    @-helpergamming-4163 10 місяців тому +2

    i would LOVE to play kaiserrreduc more, but it isnt just that it runs slow (it does) is also that it haves a lot of crashes and the saves get corrupted by no specific reason. (even TNO is lighter)
    also i tought the same about ukraine, the natpop path focus tree is like: "we are ukraine we are ukranie!; lets claim territory that was never ours and still be the good guys! slava ukraini!"

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  9 місяців тому

      I wanna get a better PC too to record videos faster and better :)

    • @scyobiempire4450
      @scyobiempire4450 2 місяці тому

      for real, so many of my saves corrupt in 1937 for no reason
      early ACW? corrupt
      no ACW? corrupt
      observer mode? corrupt
      loading a save game? entire naval tech tree is replaced with missing icon icons

  • @inerael
    @inerael 6 місяців тому +2

    Hey in my kaisereich game i pla ycombined syndicat of america and i only have the tree of commonwealth (no more Union of socialsit ameercia) is this because of war in ukraine that they remove that ? Because i saw in a old video someone playing USSA , i think i'm gonna try Kaiseredux to play it if it is . :)

  • @nhatminhnguyen2041
    @nhatminhnguyen2041 Рік тому +1

    The Communard in KX was buffed insanely in terms of manpower, whereas the KR weaken them a lot :((((

  • @rastin5209
    @rastin5209 4 місяці тому

    I love Kaiser Redux too much but with the time of playing 6years in Kaiser Redux I can play a full 4 playthroughs in vanilla

  • @ozark7834
    @ozark7834 Рік тому +8

    We have the perfect chance to compare Kaiserreich and Kaiserredux right as both of them have done Ukraine reworks. That could be a very interesting video

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +2

      Bro, that's a great idea for the video! I'll do it for sure!

    • @xZxOxVx
      @xZxOxVx Рік тому +1

      The most boring nation to play hoi lmao

  • @Cookinlikesanji
    @Cookinlikesanji 2 місяці тому

    Kaiserreich and Kaiserredux are like Vegas and Atlantic city.
    One has more rules. The other is more fun!

  • @1111kila
    @1111kila 7 місяців тому +1

    I hate Kaiserreich now, as they are trying to play it safe making paths more "realistic"(in an already very unrealistic universe setting), which just makes it unfun to play. Kaiserredux on the other hand have more "wacky" paths, which is extremely fun.

  • @SnortingSpy1010
    @SnortingSpy1010 8 місяців тому +2

    I perfer KR because it wouldn't lack political power sometimes, but this video felt like you burned out on KR,like 2017-2021 is loonng,so it's ez to burn out,like ive played KR less than a month,i believe I'll burn out at some point too😆

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  8 місяців тому +2

      I've played Kaiserreich in total for 5 years, from fall 2017 right to spring 2023. That was way more than enough for me :D

  • @username-oz6gz
    @username-oz6gz 10 місяців тому +3

    i can't continue my campaign post 1942 in kaiserredux

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  10 місяців тому +1

      my pc can’t just normally handle them 💀💀💀

  • @edsheeranahmet6572
    @edsheeranahmet6572 Рік тому +3

    Nice to hear your thoughts on the mods. I play kaiserreich base just cause I enjoy the optimization, even though my PC isn't a brick, but I definitely agree that the optimization has come at a cost of playable variety and a dynamicism rarely seen in Hoi4. Thanks for the vid!

  • @Lavrushka0812
    @Lavrushka0812 Рік тому +3

    Кайзерредакс как будто уже делает заготовки на то, чтобы таймлапс в игре длился еще и после Вееельткрига. У Национальной Франции огроменное древо фокусов, и у США, у России нечто подобное есть, но поменьше. Ну а в кайзеррейхе тишина... Даже от реворка Украины не очень много смысла, потому что у кайзерредакса вышел свой реворк Украины, но он пока только на гитхабе доступен

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +2

      Да, последние годы Кайзеррайх разочаровывает очень сильно, а Редакс наоборот - стал в разы круче!

    • @Aaron-sl2kx
      @Aaron-sl2kx 11 місяців тому

      Потому,что кайзеррейх по своей сути ближе к оригиналу-он заточен на 1 большую войну всех полив всех,а редакс делает,что хочет

  • @someone2.043
    @someone2.043 Рік тому +1

    Isn't Kaiserredux just an expansion mod/sub-mod by the community for Kaiserreich? Or atleast isnt that how they started

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      it became a unique modification which at first based on kaiserreich and was just a submod

    • @swimmyswag
      @swimmyswag Рік тому

      Its its own seperate mod now

  • @deluca1031
    @deluca1031 Рік тому +3

    I agree with you on the newest Ukraine update, not that I disapprove it, it's the mere fact that whether or not they decided to fully focus on Ukraine due to recent events is out of my knowledge but I found it very biased. Especially on their channels where they are calling out the Russians for something, which honestly some are deserved but I think it started to get more generalizing but this is different topics. Opinions even on politics aren't supposed to be a direction of something such as a mod that everyone plays, even both Russian and Ukrainians.
    Oh yeah about the Russia rework, I have a feeling that they delayed it also due to recent events so there's that ? I really hope KR didn't go into that path that TNO fallen in with the whole raycist thing or something. Forgive my lack of knowledge as I didn't really follow the state of both mod development and all their shenanigans, I'm here to play the mod not to make war online xd

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  8 місяців тому +1

      Well at leastr Kaiserredux devs made it!

    • @deluca1031
      @deluca1031 8 місяців тому

      @@Mikhail_Poltavskiy Thank goodness KX Devs know how to differentiate things, from what I know, the recent KR update literally make Savinkov into litteral Mr. Hilt and that broke me inside.

  • @justorivarola
    @justorivarola Рік тому +2

    Kaiserredux is very complex but i prefer it a lot more than Kaiserreich, however as an argentinean, it sucks to see my country still have the same focus tree in both mods, i hope kaiserredux does something about Argentina but overall. Kaiserredux has had more updates and more content, and it gives me the freedom to play almost any country in Kaiserredux with a unique focus tree. Great video, i think we all wanted this but never asked for this because we wanted you to play other nations first, the videos have way better quality than before definetly .

    • @justorivarola
      @justorivarola Рік тому +1

      Kaiserreich was the first mod i played and i loved it, but now Kaiserredux has absolutely destroyed it in every way.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  8 місяців тому

      I'll probably play Argentian Campaign pretty soon!

  • @SpartanPZR
    @SpartanPZR Рік тому +1

    Bro sounds like lesnitsky from Metro Last Light

  • @HoffmanDead
    @HoffmanDead Рік тому +1

    I like kaiserredux more too because of wholesome chungus Prónay Pál

  • @Raidensreal
    @Raidensreal 11 місяців тому +1

    I can't get Redux to make it past 1939 In every game I play recently I always hit a crash to desktop that prevents me from progressing and it is getting really frustrating.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому

      Idk, try to re-install it, maybe try to clear the whole hoi 4

  • @tedbacon1283
    @tedbacon1283 Рік тому +2

    Base KR is better other than the ACW. KX is fun sometimes tho

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +2

      In ACW i guess that KX represents the whole political spectrum and views of the people better than in the KR ( of course without some specific things, but still )

  • @thatrandomguyontheinternet2477

    Reasons why I find kaiserreich more fun : Belgen samen sterk

  • @SSSFMKUltra
    @SSSFMKUltra 10 місяців тому

    Thanks for the video!
    I've played Kaiserreich it feels like a 100 years ago: there were Хрущёв in Urkaine, Goring in Mittelafrika, Makhno in France etc.
    One of my wierdest expirerences was: I've started a game of Ukraine, went down a pro-russian tree and I.... just lost the game...
    Like it was both fun and dissapointing. I felt sad seeing there is no pro-russian tree now in Ukraine.
    Всё-таки, исторически если предположить, то в Украине под немецким влиянием, то (особенно после чёрного понедельника) какой-то даже минимальный процент имел бы про-российские идеи. Согласен с автором, что удалять вполне логичное древо фокусов по соображениям современной политики -- это странно, да и делает количество возможных сценариев меньше. Ну и плюс мне авторы сказали, что поменяли старого правителя Ком.Франции чуть ли не по правилам кенсел-культуры (редактор КР-вики назвал его педофилом). Всё это странно, особенно учитывая, что игра про альтернативную вселенную всё-таки...
    Теперь, возможно, попробую KaiserreduX, хотя Kaiserreich всё-таки очень хорош и подарил очень много крутых часов...

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  9 місяців тому

      поверь, редакс для тебя станет словно глотком свежего воздуха, и вторым дыханием для данной вселенной :)
      наслаждайся !

    • @radon.drl.
      @radon.drl. 9 місяців тому

      Этот путь был просто бесполезным для игры, потому что в конце вас просто аннексирует Россия.

    • @SSSFMKUltra
      @SSSFMKUltra 9 місяців тому

      @@radon.drl. ну, во-первых, его можно было выставить боту, если строишь кастомный сценарий. во-вторых, он, может, и бесполезный был, но для иммерсивности подходил, + по ветке фокусов когда идёшь там был контент всё-таки, можно было прочесть историю

  • @clubpenguinmnmn1234
    @clubpenguinmnmn1234 Рік тому +2

    I'm more a fan of KX, totally not biased as a dev of KX I assure you.

  • @gutowsky
    @gutowsky Рік тому +2

    I gotta say, while I love Kaiserreich and Kaiserredux they have the same problem... a non realistic and honestly boring south america! Kaiserreich gave paraguay a lil something but outside of that they just fucked over Brazil and took away the cores from andalusia, which is realistic tbh

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +2

      I know and agree, but bro - nothing much has happened there ( well at least we have some fun in Caribbeans and Central America )
      in every single modification South America stays the same :D

  • @Robert-xx8jx
    @Robert-xx8jx Рік тому +4

    Redux is awesome but too much gb

  • @themaskedhungarian5156
    @themaskedhungarian5156 Рік тому +3

    I always liked KX more, just because of the sheer amount of great content. Like for France, Russia, Canada and soon, Ukraine. It obviouly runs worse because it has a lot more things in the mod than KR. KX is not for everyone and KR too

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Bro, just look on the russian mechanics with duma and senate! It's incredible!
      I want to look on the Ukrainian Rework in Redux too, and then - probably make a video comparing them!

  • @Hoi4291
    @Hoi4291 Рік тому

    Kaiserreich for roleplay and redux for memes and funni content

  • @_JamesMorrell_
    @_JamesMorrell_ Рік тому +1

    is the map texture in the mod or did you add it?

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      you can find a video about graphic mods on my channel. I uploaded it in September 2022, so you can find it :)

  • @bournettanmapping8762
    @bournettanmapping8762 Рік тому +4

    Kaiserreich 💪

  • @bill_gamer67
    @bill_gamer67 Рік тому +3

    I had a putln profile picture on the kaiserreich server and they banned me 😢

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +3

      One situation would be if your wrote smth like "ZOV" on the channel.
      But I guess that you didn't write anything like that - so it's a great cringe from their side. Freedom of speech, freedom of showing yourself - it's a ll about KR developers!

  • @oligone9epic33
    @oligone9epic33 Рік тому +7

    REDUX NR 1! has the best paths

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      Especially in case of Russia
      don't forget about some unique mechanics, that KR doesn't have

  • @Piratewaffle43
    @Piratewaffle43 8 місяців тому +2

    I agree completely about Ukraine. Slava Ukraini!

  • @MikhailMyers
    @MikhailMyers Рік тому +1

    Another BASED video bruda. Kaiserredux feels more complicated, and is packed with content, but kaiserreich feels more simple but less content.

  • @user-kg2lp8jz2r
    @user-kg2lp8jz2r 5 місяців тому

    Depends on how much mental illness you want in your game

  • @johanneswitt5499
    @johanneswitt5499 Рік тому +2

    I would love a video about Kaiserreich Ukraine

  • @Daytemnesalo
    @Daytemnesalo Рік тому +1

    А я то думаю, какой то голос знакомый...

  • @Cat_DeGaulle
    @Cat_DeGaulle Рік тому +2

    The difference between the two is, a normal refined mod vs crack.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +3

      bro, kaiserreich became really boring and lack of content comparing to the Kaiserredux

    • @Cat_DeGaulle
      @Cat_DeGaulle Рік тому +1

      ​@Mikhail_Poltavskiy ya kaiserreich is a really well put mod, but it feels like every playthrough feels the exact same, and there isnt that many focus trees that are interesting. Witch is not bad but its just so boring. And a good thing about it is that it really dose feel like its own game and not a mod or something.
      But kaiserredux is a very expansive mod that will have so many different things happen each game. That makes it feel like a different playthrough each time. Their is so many funny things to do like the mongolian empire or just insane things that make it so fun.

  • @ghosts14_2
    @ghosts14_2 Рік тому +4

    I must say i hate meme Focus trees also Kaiserreich is better than i lov alternative History PS sorry vür bad Englisch im a German

    • @alexanderkolchak1
      @alexanderkolchak1 Рік тому +2

      Hello (sorry for bad englis i sold my wife for internet connection)

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Well, you can escape playing them + developers made them really good, cuz I didn't see AI reaching it

    • @ghosts14_2
      @ghosts14_2 11 місяців тому

      ​@@Mikhail_Poltavskiywhar do you i dont juse ai

  • @The1tera
    @The1tera Рік тому +6

    Need to see a review of Ukrainian trees

  • @jassen1924
    @jassen1924 3 місяці тому +1

    Kx is just buggy and weird honestly for me

  • @anvar_bitson
    @anvar_bitson 10 місяців тому +3

    Kaiserreich recently updated Russia but not as much unfortunately, and there's still no pro-Russian path for Ukraine

  • @AlexMitchell-ct8tt
    @AlexMitchell-ct8tt Рік тому +1

    What is the lore for kaiserredux

  • @LancerIHR
    @LancerIHR Рік тому +1

    As an average Kaiserreich enjoyer, the lack of balkanization in Italy and the addition of a Kuban state (the latter I find as a weird addition to the universe) is whats nopes me away from redux. Plus I heard it has terrible optimization. And honestly, who gives a damn about the Reich devs including their political biases in-game? It doesn't change much imo and I just play it for a fun alt history scenario

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Understand your position. Well, if you have a good PC - you won’t feel a lack of optimization, in most cases it’s a problem of old and medium PC. About some states - it’s complicated.

    • @superhond1733
      @superhond1733 10 місяців тому +1

      Wait- you havent even played kaiserredux?

  • @IRTERRAKOTTA
    @IRTERRAKOTTA Рік тому

    Sorry, what you use graphic mod?

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      i've got a video on the channel ( uploaded in September 2022 ) where i show all graphic mods that i use

  • @hungaryhippo7294
    @hungaryhippo7294 Рік тому

    I wish there was a way to speed up Kaiserredux, so poorly optimized.

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      I wish it was made too, but i guess that it's really hard due to the amount of content and mechanics...

  • @sahilhossain8204
    @sahilhossain8204 Рік тому +1

    Lore of KAISERREICH VS KAISERREDUX | HOI 4 | WHICH MODIFICATION IS BETTER? Momentum 100

  • @AmariFukui
    @AmariFukui Рік тому +3

    I agree wholeheartedly about Kaiserredux being better than Kaiserreich
    Screw Realism, Screw forcing your modern day politics into this game (Though Kaiserredux removed Goebells so they're slightly guilty of this too, yes Nazi's are bad I think everyone and their mother and dog knows this by now)
    The only thing keeping me from playing it over Kaiserreich is the shoddy optimisation, its just too slow and clunky to play but the paths are so much more interesting and off the wall, no concern for this stupid tedious realism thing that everyone is obsessed with like it matters in a game where you can core the entire world as an anarchist commune in the basegame

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  11 місяців тому +1

      But in fact - Kaiserredux "schizophrenia" it's just a real things, which weren't implemented in life. Thanks to this things - i got a lof new facts about our world!

  • @caiden5855
    @caiden5855 Рік тому +2

    Kaiserreich has better italy

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      Nah, i don't think so.
      Plus - now KX has Sardinia, so there is no reason to Italy be better in the KR

    • @Mattef22
      @Mattef22 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Mikhail_PoltavskiyHalf of the paths don't work, they're meaningless and they're boring too

    • @Mattef22
      @Mattef22 Рік тому

      In kaiserredux

  • @Drowdowsky
    @Drowdowsky Рік тому

    а я думаю, голос знакомый..

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      хехехехехехехе

    • @Drowdowsky
      @Drowdowsky Рік тому

      ​@@Mikhail_Poltavskiyбуду теперь этот канал с русскими субтитрами смотреть , раз уж старый заброшен)

  • @Ich_mag_Lachs
    @Ich_mag_Lachs Рік тому

    Brasil is da best country in the entire World

  • @Ruzikun
    @Ruzikun Рік тому +6

    Kaiserredux it has better paths for countries

  • @naufaldzakie195
    @naufaldzakie195 Рік тому +1

    yeah, i agree if you have a better rig there are no reason to play kaiserreich instead of kaiserredux

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      Yep. When KX was uploaded - it wasn't as good as it its today, and Kaiserreich wasn't as bad as it is now, but in 2023, playing Kaiserreich except showing some secret pathes - hell no

  • @matteok73
    @matteok73 Рік тому

    Italian focus in Kaiserredux Is orrible

    • @alexanderkolchak1
      @alexanderkolchak1 Рік тому

      Tell me its north cuz if your talking about south ima punch you

    • @notfunky9013
      @notfunky9013 Рік тому

      there are like 4. Which one?

    • @alexanderkolchak1
      @alexanderkolchak1 Рік тому

      @@notfunky9013 theres two italy in redux

    • @matteok73
      @matteok73 Рік тому

      @@alexanderkolchak1 3 now

    • @matteok73
      @matteok73 Рік тому

      But Sardegna Is the same as kaiserreich

  • @radon.drl.
    @radon.drl. Рік тому +2

    I personally like Kaiserreich more than Kaiserredux because it is better optimized, the countries are better worked out, and the events look realistic, while there is some crazy going on in Kaiserredux.

  • @nikostsiantas4060
    @nikostsiantas4060 Рік тому

    also is it me or are the focus trees more good looking and you understand what each one does or what ideology is it

  • @ourBed
    @ourBed Рік тому +2

    KAISERREDUX >>>> KAISERREICH

  • @dallas9397
    @dallas9397 Рік тому

    i need this map mod...

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому

      bro, i’ve got a separate video on my channel about my graphic mods. Uploaded in September 2022

    • @dallas9397
      @dallas9397 Рік тому

      @@Mikhail_Poltavskiy thanks bro

  • @memelord5366
    @memelord5366 Рік тому +2

    Kaiserreich devs be like
    *removes fun and interesting paths that are fan favourites*
    kaiserredux: *makes fun unique paths and even let's you do an ancap ayn rand path which is funny as hell and enjoyable*
    The best choice is clear

    • @therealpooperandpee-er
      @therealpooperandpee-er Рік тому +8

      Imo, the content that KR removed didn't really make the game better in any way
      Don Kuban? Literally didn't have a focus tree
      Genghis Khan II? Was just an extremely bland path which had zero flavor and was basically just conquering everything and map painting
      if you wanna map paint, play vanilla

    • @Mikhail_Poltavskiy
      @Mikhail_Poltavskiy  Рік тому +1

      + they have fully castrated Russian Focus Treeline

  • @AlexFnafer
    @AlexFnafer Рік тому +1

    First

  • @lugiasimply6054
    @lugiasimply6054 Рік тому +1

    Redux!

  • @theseus0467
    @theseus0467 Рік тому +2

    old world blues superior!

  • @youtuberobbedmeofmyname
    @youtuberobbedmeofmyname 26 днів тому

    Kaiserredux's poorest feature is the balance. The game is seriously unbalanced now more than ever and has honestly too many paths.
    Kaiserreich has the opposite problems actually. It's too linear and has not enough interesting paths.