HPG Mountain Serape Vs HELICON-TEX Swagman Roll

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 163

  • @MrPVaSoldier
    @MrPVaSoldier 5 років тому +16

    Perfect timing on the video.
    I was debating between these 2 bags. Thanks

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      Your welcome! I hope it could help! My main gripe about the Tex is the lack of neck zipper, we often use quilts so the narrowness isn’t the biggest deal but not being able to vent the neck especially while wearing a pack is a pain!

    • @royhurley7572
      @royhurley7572 4 роки тому

      I'm also thinking of one of these two. I already have some Hill People gear and am very happy with it. (recon chest rig).

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Both well made units! Will compliment most kits well

  • @matthewconner6195
    @matthewconner6195 4 роки тому +3

    I really appreciate a review from a fellow tall person.

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ 4 роки тому +4

    My buddy has the HPG and I have the Swagman. I'm pretty happy with the Swagman roll. My main purposes for it are to wear around camp and to keep in my day-bag/PSK. It's great for that! I only use it as a bag in emergencies, most of the time I use the great-coat function.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      It does fill that niche perfectly! Thanks for chiming In! People’s decisions are aided by experienced opinions:)

  • @donaldlerolland4449
    @donaldlerolland4449 2 місяці тому

    I’ve been debating on these two. Thank you for the video.

  • @havensoutdoorworld3656
    @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +10

    I’ve been informed that the Hpg is not compatible with usgi poncho as a liner however the helicon fits well. So if that’s your intended purpose go for the swagman!

    • @windmag5510
      @windmag5510 4 роки тому

      Yep

    • @bigg4089
      @bigg4089 3 роки тому

      Helikon do a very good reproduction usgi poncho. I've never owned a real usgi one, but it's way lighter than my '90s era issue HM forces green poncho. So good in fact I've now bought a second one for the missus to go with the swagman she's getting for Xmas.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  2 роки тому

      Nice! I love it too Buddy and am looking forward to the chilly weather to use it again!

  • @reiver3419
    @reiver3419 3 роки тому +4

    Helikon is a polish company

  • @allseeingI5
    @allseeingI5 4 місяці тому

    As a big person, I appreciate this review!

  • @omblackwell1183
    @omblackwell1183 5 років тому +3

    Thank you very much for your excellent reviews of both items.
    In fairness to the Helicon-Tex Swagman Roll, the reason for its narrowness is that rather than being designed as an outer bag, it is meant as an inner bag to a larger (and winter weight) sleeping bag. Give it a larger width and it would not slip inside.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      Thank you for your gd advice! That would definitely be the best option with that bag but I have found that unless your sleeping with boots in the bag that a rectangular foot box with no baffle leaves my feet always feeling chilly.

    • @mateuszwisniewski3877
      @mateuszwisniewski3877 3 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 You can use the drawstrings on the Swagman Roll to tighten it in the feet. Makes a difference for one's chilly feet (I've tested it a week ago).

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому

      Excellent tip! Taking up dead air space helps a lot!

  • @MRCOCAINECITY1
    @MRCOCAINECITY1 5 місяців тому

    Fantastic video it helped me make my decision

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 місяці тому

      I am grateful buddy! They are both worth the cost and I’m sure you’ll enjoy!

  • @bereantrb
    @bereantrb 5 років тому +4

    If I recall correctly, I think the tabs are designed to connect to a military rain poncho, just like the classic liner. Very helpful review; I was intrigued when I first saw the Swagman but I don’t think this type of item compliments my kit very well.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      thank you for pointing that out! We do our videos on the fly and I do forget to mention certain points sometimes:) I have not used it in that manner but you are correct on its design intention.

  • @bodhi974
    @bodhi974 4 роки тому +2

    I liked the way you presented both. You even said if “you” had to choose which one you would go with. While I like the width of the HPG I find more utility with the Helikon. Great video.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Thanks brother and I appreciate you chiming in! The Tex is top notch :) just pulled ours out for some long anticipated fall use!

    • @bodhi974
      @bodhi974 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 enjoy. I know as soon as I can order mine I will be out there using it to it’s fullest.... here’s to the outdoors!!!!!

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Yessir! Enjoy it:)

  • @jdendure8134
    @jdendure8134 4 роки тому +3

    Good review. I found these a number of years ago. I prefer the Swagman for its versatility. Those tabs are actually for hanging under a hammock as an underquilt. I'm a small guy and generally use it as just a summer bag in sleeping bag mode. On backpacking trip the ability to wear it as an additional jacket is great and a feature I didn't think I'd use but I've probably used more then any other.

  • @Hockeycoho
    @Hockeycoho 4 роки тому +3

    Great review, covered lots. I went with the Helicon Tex Swagman as it fits me better and I like the pocket. great for camping and motorcycle trips !

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks buddy I’m glad it could help! It will last you a long time and is perfect item for vehicle emergency bag! It’s always better to have it and not need it:) having an extra piece like this can be the difference between misery and comfort!

  • @bearman000ify
    @bearman000ify 3 роки тому

    Great job on the review!
    It was very helpful to me.
    Still preparing for whatever is coming our way.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому

      Thanks brother! It’s really the only reason we do it :) being prepared provides a sense of security that I felt was necessary also! Good luck to you!

    • @impermanenthuman8427
      @impermanenthuman8427 3 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 major war coming late 2025 - early 2026, expect a sudden attack on US and UK, particularly if a war breaks out between north and South Korea and US uses any size nuke including ‘tactical’ to protect the few American troops in South Korea, once any nuke is used it will set off a chain reaction resulting in Russia and/or China attacking US and UK suddenly and hard and nukes should be expected, another lesser likely trigger could be any kind of nuke used against Iran, either way ‘Total War’ is approaching

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому +1

      Yes it has felt like we are on the brink now for a decade or so:( let us hope that we as humans kind find a way to evolve past such archaic behaviors and to avoid cataclysmic action for the benefit of our race and for our Mother Earth! I try to walk with no fear of death but I have lived much life already. It is for the children of the world i am scared. I pray for wise and compassionate leadership and still try to stay positive despite my angsts. “ hope for the best but prepare for the worst” peace brother!

    • @impermanenthuman8427
      @impermanenthuman8427 3 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 agreed 👍🏻 although I think at least a power grid hack or possibly an EMP will be used against US and UK, if western countries lose power for any length of time it will prove to be our biggest weakness imo

  • @brawndothethirstmutilator9848
    @brawndothethirstmutilator9848 2 роки тому

    The HPG liner is interesting. Made in the USA is always a plus. I have the Swagman Roll. Besides lining my rain poncho, I keep it as part of my minimalist sleep system and put it in a waterproof bivvy bag and it goes with my emergency kit.
    I’m kind of a broad guy through the chest and shoulders and it’s on the narrow side for sure. What I do is zip one arm outside. I feel trapped with both arms zipped into bags anyway. I’ve made a separate sleeve warmer that I slip my free arm into and I’m good to go.

  • @Saintgrove4life
    @Saintgrove4life 9 місяців тому

    Thank you

  • @Gabriel-Akaisha
    @Gabriel-Akaisha 3 роки тому +1

    In that swagman u resemble a gnome such a pointy hood! Looks tight

  • @BearClawAK47
    @BearClawAK47 5 років тому +3

    I hope HPG watches this video. If the could add some of the features of the swagman like a full zipper and the fastex buckle they would unstoppable. One thing you did not mention is that the swagman is waterproof. This would also be a great feature.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      I agree! They are a worthy addition especially on a family trip when you never know who will get chilly when:) hopefully they will continue to evolve and put out a gen 2 version! I do not think either is waterproof however just resistant but will test and post results soon. If I remember correctly my shoulders soaked through at about 30 mins. During steady rain. Maybe my dwr coating has began to wear ?

    • @NostalgicLink
      @NostalgicLink 4 роки тому

      It's not waterproof, but the Apex insulation keeps its warmth went wet, so maybe that's what he meant? I just bought a Swagman. The box and site both say it's water resistant, due to a DWR coating.
      My issue is I'm only 5'7", 150 lbs... The "one size fits all" doesn't really work for me, which is a bummer...
      I mean, it goes over me, but the cinch buckles to make it a poncho/overcoat can't cinch down enough to keep in place very well.
      I'm not sure I want to keep it.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Thank you for that information and your opinion! It is correct the synthetic insulation is much warmer than down when it gets wet. I have seen what you are describing as well with the looser fit on smaller individuals. The benefit of your size is it will definitely fit a 40-50 degree bag or quilt inside and take your comfort rating below freezing to make a more versatile system. I find it most practical to wear when static around camp or in tree stand or glassing etc. definitely to much dangling fabric for tight bushwhacking scenarios! They have their place as an addition to your regular gear but I wouldn’t tuse as a substitution!

  • @stevecochrane9657
    @stevecochrane9657 4 роки тому +2

    Just because it’s US made does not make it better nothing like an unbiased review

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      You’re right buddy! For me it’s a personal choice to try to find local manufacturers to support since there are so few these days:( so basically if the specs are similar and there is a USA made option i usually will go that route. It’s surprising how often you have few choices! Shoes are a good example all the way to kitchen appliances. I do agree with you and I think arcteryx is a great example where the quality and attention is as good as it gets! I love my alpha parka and rho tops:)

    • @stevecochrane9657
      @stevecochrane9657 4 роки тому

      Havens Outdoor World fair enough I can see where you are coming from. Now after corona I will always buy local and try to avoid Chinese products we should have pride in our countries and our products it’s a pity more of us in the U.K. 🇬🇧 don’t think like this

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      It does seem like a responsible patriotic thing to do buddy. It does bother me that in order to be competitive in pricing we are often forced to cut jobs and outsource over seas. I do understand the reasons but I feel it is important for every country to have manufacturing jobs available. Peace to you and yours brother!

  • @scottseverythingoutdoors462
    @scottseverythingoutdoors462 4 роки тому

    Cute dog! Thanks for the video!

  • @michielsaman7368
    @michielsaman7368 4 роки тому

    I like em both.. still not sure what to buy yet! Also thinking about that norwegian jerven bag..

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      I do too:) haven’t heard of that Norwegian bag but will check it out

    • @michielsaman7368
      @michielsaman7368 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 theres plenty video's of it here on UA-cam.. please let me know what you think about it

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Will do buddy!

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      I Checked out the jerven bag and it seems solid to me! 1lb heavier but I bet it is more waterproof than the Tex and hpg? By the sound of the fabric combined with the inner Mylar type layer it may be 100% waterproof? The down side to that is of course breath ability. Without seeing it in person I would guess it’s superior as a shelter/bivy from elements especially in static situations but may not be as gd as active insulation layer/breathable? Looks strong and well made as well as thoroughly tested, primaloft is good insulation as well so I wouldn’t hesitate to give it a try if your in the market for such a piece:)

  • @impermanenthuman8427
    @impermanenthuman8427 4 роки тому

    Nice to discover the HPG option 👍🏻

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому +1

      Solid company for sure! I Love their many chest rigs for all sorts of outdoor activitIra.

  • @Jakelol1980
    @Jakelol1980 5 років тому +2

    How tall are you?

  • @mfish7
    @mfish7 5 років тому

    Thanks for the review. What's your shoulder width?

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks buddy, we just measured 20” shoulder width

    • @mfish7
      @mfish7 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 Thank you so much for getting back to me on that. I'm 5'11" with about 17-18 shoulder width. I think I'll pick one of those up in the summer. I like the full zip on the Helikon more than the extra width on the HP for drafts in mid temperature use. Also, I think the Helikon supports the attachment of a military spec poncho. Does the HP support it too?

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      Your welcome! I think you will be happy with the Tex! It is a versatile good quality garment and will serve your purposes and size very well. The hpg serape does not have tabs or grommets at corners for directly attaching to poncho.

  • @bigg4089
    @bigg4089 3 роки тому

    Good review but you missed the fact the swagman can be used as a hammock underblanket

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому

      Correct! I did miss that one! I rarely use my hammock and have not used it that way but the corner tabs do make it ready to go! I have used my kifaru woobie that way so familiar with the technique. Thanks for chiming in!

  • @glock-hm3ro
    @glock-hm3ro 4 роки тому +1

    Rasta Far I !!! Jah Bless! One Blood/One Love! Great video brother

  • @P.J.Thompson
    @P.J.Thompson 3 роки тому

    What is the problem with sawing in Poland? I'm talking quality wise not politics

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому +1

      Nothing at all brother! I just think supporting your countries economy and manufacturing is appropriate when possible:)

  • @blacksheep6821
    @blacksheep6821 4 роки тому

    Nice review of the features. Thank you.

  • @gyffesme
    @gyffesme 3 роки тому

    Nice. I appreciate your comparing both. The Swagman's come up in price to $180 (as of today), and that tight head hole is unnerving.. and I'm a LOT broader through the shoulders than you, so that sleeping bag won't work, either. Thanks for posting this!

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому

      Your welcome buddy! I do feel that is a downside and I am narrow! Hopefully that will be updated on gen 2!

  • @6foot8jesuspilledpureblood82

    I'm happy to support any western country but top of the list is my own country first New Zealand 🇳🇿 a lot of my extra tall gear like bag and quilt i had made in NZ. But I also love to support America 🇺🇸 because USA is the home of freedom and a strong America is a strong west, if you live in any western country supporting USA manufacturers is good. I try to avoid supporting any enemy countries but you know when the dollars get really tight you might need to spend a few Yen 💴 lol. Jesus bless you bro, hope you will make more ultralight content in the future 🙏

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  Рік тому

      I believe your philosophy is sound brother! One day I hope to visit NZ! Its beauty has always enchanted me. I appreciate the comment and many blessings to you as well!

  • @Gabriel-Akaisha
    @Gabriel-Akaisha 3 роки тому

    Love that dog!!!

  • @HannibalsSurplusReviews
    @HannibalsSurplusReviews 4 роки тому +1

    Would you consider this a jedi knight tactical cosplay robe something?

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      I think that fits well and probably even says that on the swagman stuffsack somewhere!:)

    • @HannibalsSurplusReviews
      @HannibalsSurplusReviews 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 fyi I'm not a starwars nerd I just think it's funny that these robe style woobies are popular, but not the perseverance survival woobie hoodie jacket...

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      I hear you:) they aren’t the best at any of their jobs but can save a little weight and pack space if utilized correctly.

    • @HannibalsSurplusReviews
      @HannibalsSurplusReviews 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 if weight is your problem just get a MSS sleeping bag the black or green one!

  • @chrisbellette9181
    @chrisbellette9181 3 роки тому

    My ears pricked up at your height! :) I'm 6'7" too.

  • @BearClawAK47
    @BearClawAK47 10 місяців тому

    For me, quality and design, not country of manufacture, is what i base my purchases on.

  • @allenwatkins4972
    @allenwatkins4972 2 роки тому

    6"7'? Wow!!

  • @MovementDrifter
    @MovementDrifter 4 роки тому +1

    you sound a lot like Theo Von

  • @itcsmount6504
    @itcsmount6504 2 роки тому

    I am viewing this video while draped in my Hil People Gear Serape. I have tested both HPG and Helicon-Tex and very much prefer the HPG unit. The Swagman has a great design, a total rip-off of HPG, but the quality is, well, Chinese. Take a great design, make it out of cheap fabric, thin insulation, and problematic zippers, and you have the Swagman.
    The HPG Serape is light but pretty bulky. It reminds me of a thick woobie. The fabric is rip-stop. It is by no means waterproof, so add a poncho to your gear, and a ground pad if you intend to sleep in it. It's a summer weight sleeping bag, but add a blanket and you can sleep well.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  2 роки тому

      Thank you for your insight! I do agree and with the exception of the helikon weighing around half pound less I would almost always grab the hpg.

  • @vietadvisor6781
    @vietadvisor6781 4 роки тому

    Might be good but I can't hear you

  • @OssyTK
    @OssyTK 4 роки тому +1

    Helikon is a Polish company.

  • @joeyjones9041
    @joeyjones9041 4 роки тому

    Ouch, that price is outrageous. I believe I'll stick with the regular military issue poncho liner.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      It seems steep and is high for a synthetic blanket,but cheap compared to the price of a good jacket and quality sleeping bag. I had a hard time finding a genuine issue woobie a few years ago new or used! Must be in short supply these days!?

    • @joeyjones9041
      @joeyjones9041 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 i hear that man, i have some Helikon gear myself, they're both quality brands

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      They do seem to be! I have had the helikon windshirt and the hpg og kitbag and both have proven to be durable and well designed. Love some issues gear too! Ecws level 7 made by wild things is amazing gear!

    • @joeyjones9041
      @joeyjones9041 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 i bought the Helikon Tex Patriot Fleece Jacket and Women's Cumulus Fleece Jacket for my wife today, i have the Helikon Gen3 ECWCS levels 1 and 2. I'm searching for the military issue Gen3 ECWCS level 6 gore tex for myself and my wife. It all is daily wear but really it's part of our bug out clothing.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      Nice! Let me know how you like those jackets! For me it’s always a task to find correct lengths:( I was able to score a pair of level 6 gore bottoms a few years ago and they are definitely solid and have served me well. Unfortunately they are desert digital pattern but the price and long size were right!

  • @jbojm9
    @jbojm9 5 років тому

    Good review.

  • @surgery6862
    @surgery6862 4 роки тому +1

    Cute pup lol

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      He says thank you:) he loves to sleep down in the bags. Great little foot warmer!

  • @deanoboland
    @deanoboland 3 роки тому

    👍👍👍

  • @Logan-pc1lm
    @Logan-pc1lm 4 роки тому +2

    when reviewing products where the product is made is not the end of the story. Quality, features, size and weight and how it gets its specific job done is what makes a product great for the consumer. Not where it was made or designed. :face palm:

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      I do agree, and would not let the origin of a product be the only reason for purchase:) however if all else is equal quality I personally will choose USA manufacturing first. Both these garments are excellent quality and I tried to inform potential buyers of that fact.

    • @bigg4089
      @bigg4089 3 роки тому

      Made is USA or not is a non-issue if you're not American

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому

      Not necessarily. Some manufacturers like the quality control so really depends on what your looking at but I do agree that it is less of a factor if it’s not made in your home country:)

  • @natashaball316
    @natashaball316 3 роки тому

    Helikon-Tex is polish.

  • @xxfaction6xx
    @xxfaction6xx 3 роки тому

    Good stuff man, Thanks

  • @viciousKev
    @viciousKev 5 років тому

    Watch out for that dog

  • @ayyildizimayyildizim
    @ayyildizimayyildizim 5 років тому

    The leş

  • @Janko630
    @Janko630 4 роки тому

    Hey Mouldy Locks, get yourself a microphone because your audio sucks!

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  3 роки тому +3

      It’s the way god made me brother:) I will try to find a cheap microphone option to enhance the sound. We never wanted to be tv stars just trying to help in people’s research. Picture is worth a thousand words they say:) do you have any simple mic options you like?

  • @rogerbeckner6419
    @rogerbeckner6419 4 роки тому

    #1.....I can barely hear him.
    #2.....Tiny dog.
    #3....Looks like my corner crack dealer.
    No thanks. .36 into it and you lose.
    Sorry.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +2

      Sorry we have no computer or fancy filming gadgetry. Just doing the best we can with iPhone 6.:) hoping to just help someone somewhere.

    • @rogerbeckner6419
      @rogerbeckner6419 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 OK, .....Just me and my outlook and problems with life and people.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому +1

      You having a tough time buddy? I’m just a nature loving outdoor guy who is lucky to find some peace in the woods. I feel so grateful for that outlet

    • @rogerbeckner6419
      @rogerbeckner6419 4 роки тому

      @@havensoutdoorworld3656 Will not burden you with my problems. Yes,.........to find peace in the woods. That is the best thing. It is all I have left now. 63 years and everything has changed. It is hard to trust and listen to the younger crowd. So many are full of methane. Most friends are older because of same beliefs and upbringing. Hard to find younger people with same outlook on life and living.
      Also had a few Wild Turkey and Coke while reading these posts. Sorry if I was rude.
      It is just that so many of you young people seem to think you have all the answers. Heck......I'm 63 and still don't have the answers and am still looking.

    • @havensoutdoorworld3656
      @havensoutdoorworld3656  4 роки тому

      I hear you buddy and I can relate! My oldest son is 15 now and I find myself thinking the same thing! What I tell myself is that passion and knowledge don’t necessarily come from age even though many must! Thanks for the apology too buddy that means a lot. I don’t looks like my neighbors or peers and get cold shoulders many times in my community until I initiate kindness and respect:)