In 1911, He Ended The Autocratic Monarchy That Had Ruled China For More Than 2,000 Years
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- China's first President Sun Yat-Sen and military commander Huang Xing lead the revolutionary Wuchang Uprising in a bid to put an end to the reign of the Qing Dynasty.
#themovierecap #moresubscribers #moreviewers
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This is an excellent movie. 0:30 Not Malaysia, but British Malaya. More specifically, this took place in the island of Penang. 0:55 Sun is pronounced as "Soon".
His full name is Sun Yat Sen, aka Sun Chong San, aka Sun Wen.
Tang is pronounced as "tongue".
dont expect anglos to pronounce other names correctly
the movie itself mistakenly wrote British Malaya as Malaysia as well
This is also a recap which is being read to you by a text to speech program. Its meant to read text and it probably wasn't created with accent and language in mind. By my understanding it is reading from an English dictionary, so it uses English pronunciation from said dictionary.
🤡🤡🤡
Its a text to speech program mate…
Sun YatSen was disappointed with western power(British empire, France, Japan)refused to abandon their privileges over China in 1920.
He admired "Valdmir Lenin" because he overthrown the Czar monarchy and won the Russian civil war. Sun wrote a letter to Lenin to seek military assisstances from the Soviet Union. After Lenin died in 1924, Josef Stalin took over the task of assisstance China. Sun died in 1925 and "Chiang Kai Shek" took over the leadership of the Chinese Nationalist party. One thing many people did not know was Josef Stalin had great influences over the Chinese Nationalist party & Chinese Communist party!
Stalin was Nationalist China's biggest backer during the Sino-Japanese war until the Americans joined the war.
Dr. Sun Yat Sen was not satisfied with the social inequalities of the U.S. and U.K. and wanted for China a system with some elements inspired by socialist thinkers but then the over-all framework still based on western models. Today his economic idea could be compared to "social democracy" you see in Nordic countries a.k.a capitalism with strong social welfare. But CCP I am sure has re-written history already to say Dr. Sun Yat Sen was devoted communist.
@@rangergxi Sure! After the Nationalist army& airforce runs out of hardware in the war of attrition, Soviet weapons & warplanes were introduced in 1938. A communist country supplying weapons to an anti communist country(China) to fight another anti communist country(Japan). It was,strange enough but it was the history.
Stalin's strategy has gained big as the third party benefited from the Sino Japanese war.
Chiang Kai Shek's own son was even in the Red Army at some point
@Aka Aka Sun Yet Sen being a believer of liberal democracy isn't mutually exclusive with receiving supplies from the soviet union. You would be surprised by the amount of times politicians prioritized practical needs over ideology (refer to realpolitik).
American: Desperately want to joins any revolution.
that's one of their source of income, war.
@@Davidson134-c7q their source of income come from them doing Imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism enforce through colonialism.
maybe they had oil
I give you like for your love of nagants
@@theoriginalrudeboy2916 China definitely had oil.
An end to autocratic rule? President Xi says, "hold my beer".
*monarchy*
Ma Boi Sun Yat Sen really wanted a free, democratic, China, with a system that is somewhat a mix between British & American constitutions.
@@ReySchultz121 yea this guy just doesn't know enough
do you know what the "auto" part of "autocrat" stands for?
@@ReySchultz121 No, Mr. Sun didn't want neither British or American emulation, he wanted a self-determine republic as united China. Under 三民主义。
6:53 They put the german flag there which was not yet in 1911😂
To be fair, that tricolor flag is already adopted even since before the Kaiserreich.
But yeah, considering the time (this was _near_ the first world war), they should've use the Kaiserreich flag
that tricolor was already a thing in those times but it wasnt used, the flag used for germany was the black white red but that tricolor was there even before the funny kaiser came in to power
@@Barri2410 German Empire Flag* The Kaissereich one is Alt History but a goddamn good flag
That was a mishap !
Man, I can’t wait for the sequel “1912”
You mean "1949"?
You're a bit late, I think the sequel, 1911 6(that is, 1917) came out already
No, this is the prequel of 1917.
1984
@@foundationgamer9771 Ah, 1911 73, one of the movies of all time.
My grandpa YUEN-Ming ( he actually having 5 different names to avoid the assassination from the Ching Dynasty) while he was in USA as the chapter secretary of Louisiana’s United Association working with SUN Yet-San . After the successful building of the Republic of China , he retired and his name been inducted into the Dr SUN Yet-San memorial Hall among the 40 top officers . He passed away in 1962 in GuangZhou , China at age 84 . His ash , permitted by the Chinese authority and transported to USA In the 80’ together with my grandma’s . My parents and my own family were the escort for the process .
Very interesting. Thank you for this information
Why transported his ashes and your Grandma's to USA?
"Mao Tsetung" was a soldier of the Chinese revolutionary army in November 1911, a month after the outbreak of the revolution and he was a volunteer.
Mao later joined the Chinese Nationalist party (KMT) and became a minor official in early 1920s, he knew "Chiang Kai Shek"(CKS)in the party. The Chinese communist party (CCP)was actually the leftwing(Farmers,Workers,Intellectuals) of the Nationalist party(KMT), CKS represents the right wing of KMT (Wealthy people,landlords, religious people). The CCP & KMT were like two nasty brothers always fighting at home, fighting to get the heritages and properties left by their grandfather.
This is an irony!
The kmt(in Taiwan) today is ironically extremly pro Mainland China and want a reunification more than every other party, dispite being the biggest enemy of the ccp in history
Mao Zedong, the founder of the People's Republic of China 🇨🇳.
Mao went to Soviet Union for arms to overthrow RoC, founded Chinese Soviet Republic with Stalin's face on its currency, advocating for each province to declare independence from RoC to dissolve RoC. He later thanked Japan for invading China, saying without it, CCP couldn't have overthrown RoC. Are we just going to ignore those parts?
@@zilun you are a clown 🤡
@@zilun Myths!
Anyway the 38 years of history of R.O.C. in mainland China was chaotic and run by warlords, that period was just a stop gap from monarchy to a people's republic, I don't think that it was worth to comment!
6:52 The modern German flag (Black-Red-Gold) was used, in place of the Second Reich flag (Black-White-Red), which should have been used.
there was another german empire that used the flag, but i think in this case they got the german empires confused,
@@-hiro-5995One was lead by a descendant of Queen Victoria and one was lead by an Austrian painter
@@TheDoctorFromArknights no no, there was a german empire before the 2nd reich
@@-hiro-5995 The Weimar Republic?
@@TheDoctorFromArknights this one en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Empire_(1848%E2%80%931849)
The original Republic of China. Now they are in 🇹🇼.
*🇨🇳
its actually koumintang, both are china
ROC is Chinese not Taiwanese
PRC is China, ROC is Taiwan
Two armies that fight each other is like one large army that commits suicide.”
First time I saw when Jackie Chan was firing a pistol instead fighting with "Kung Fu" in movie!
He's used a pistol in a lot of films.
To be honest Sun Zhongshan had a very weird thinking, his idea was "As long as we adopt the western ways, all our troubles will be gone!" And yeah look at the Western ways now.
This Is demostration
Very decepcionable that Monarchy has not restored
communism is also "western way"
@@lagrangewei Mayormente por eso es inconcepible que lo tenga,que vuelva la China Imperial
the idea was founded during the early 20th century, and is very different in context with the modern day Western ideologies we seen today
not to mention pre-war Japan also adopted the same vision and modernised themselves, then we got the prosphorous Meiji era (in which is also the era of Japan Sun Yat-sen admired and based upon)
without the so called "adopting the West", Japan and China would've been the second and third India
nerd comment here but the Qing dynasty only ruled form 1644 to 1911 but china did have a monarchy for over 2000 years
It is not about dynasty, it is about system used to be in China for 3000 years
yeah dumbass not the ruling house
and which differences does it cast upon..how you SHOULD live your life ?..
idiot nerd alert
@@ersendal2466 Better than what it is now
In real life if that bullet would’ve hit the pocket watch. The bullet would’ve spalled and he would have had shrapnel in his through and he would’ve died. Or the bullet simply would’ve went straight through it, older guns especially Chinese guns in 1911 (Chinese guns in 1911 were the equivalent to European guns in the 1840s) older guns were like 20-30 caliber!!!! Basically what I’m saying is he would’ve died no matter what. Even if the watch stopped the bullet and tha td a big if. The watch would’ve destroyed his sternum and it would’ve punctured his heart or lungs!!!
who gives a shit about the watch
🤓🤓🤓
I actually doubt it considering that the Qing Dynasty was phasing out her practically ancient guns at the time, plus in the said scene we don't even see any of their antiquated guns. All of them are Hanyangs!
Could it be ricochet shell that hit the watch?
Older guns were actually like .60 cal
My founding father 🇹🇼
Dr Sun Yat-sen, founder of the Republic of China. It was founded after the Hsinhai (Xinhai) revolution, which ended the monarchy.
He is founder of modern china.
@@Harthorn yes he established a great country and he called it republic of china
@@ebonymaw8457 indeed.
actually he ruined everything,go read more dude,dont believed in any shit that commies told you
Mao TseTung & Chiang KaiShek were born in final decades of Qing empire, Mao was born in 1893, Chiang was born in 1888. Both of them bear the concept of an empire when they were young and that influenced them of how to run a nation. Both were ruling their own republic but in fact they were emperors, a big one and a smaller one. Chiang achieved the Generalissmo status in his island but Mao achieved a status like "God" and inspired around the world.
The 1911 revolution was the beginning of China's 40 years of chaos, it was ended in 1953 after signing the truce in Panmunjon, Korea. Mao Tsetung was the final victor of this grand duel, he ruled the mainland China & Tibet in one piece!
you are talking about some chu han contention
You talk like China was peaceful before 1911.
Sun modernised China enough to almost barely defend itself against further colonial incursion (apart from the Japanese invasion)
Is it true the statement "If Jackie Chan is in a movie it's PRC propaganda."(?)
no he did hollywood propaganda for years like rush hour
@@daeseongkim93 he only care about his career, back then in 80's he also protest about Tiananmen in Hongkong, when china grew financially and as a powerhouse of a chinese movie company he will do his best not to annoy mainland china government, he do not care about any propaganda that include in western movies and Chinese movies especially that is produced by a communist
Respect to those who fought for freedom and died for their country
It's the same now, Monarchy is replaced by another version of autocracy.
Many did and look at the racism that occurs today…
@Jericho Kilmanja A lot of people around Xi want him gone, just like Putin but nothing has happened.
@@niweshlekhak9646 but they don't worship white 😂
@@humansarecrazybeing5730 they never did to begin with. In fact, they saw themselves as superior to white people which was also why the Qing fell.
I think that time Malaysia are still refer as British Malaya
I wonder what would he think about the results of his struggle. Would he think the new regime he helped by removing the old one was better?
Makes me wonder, what should we do, to not make things worse.
They won but at what cost 😂 replace one tyrant with another
Just like many revolutions, it’s a never ending cycle
All because Sun gave Yuank Shikai, sometimes things can't end peacefully
Malaysia didnt exist until 1963
British Malaya. Still somewhat known as Malaysia or the Malayas
Africans all over the world can learn from this movie and understand why we will always be treated like shiiiiiit until we unite.
Hey its our chinese homie jacky chan
Yes, the only movie he starred that has no kungfu fighting!
Very interesting but what’s the film?
Simonline🏴🤔
All that effort straight down the gutter when yuan was given the position of president, he later even proclaimed himself to be emperor
Yuan was not wrong over this, the people in China has no idea about what is a "Republic" and a nation without a king!
@@jagdpanther2224 I don't mean to belittle the efforts of the Tongmenghui and Sun, they toppled a century old monarchy system and brought the first ever republic to rule over the central kingdom and that's an impressive fact enough; however, it really is a shame that despite all the time Sun spent in Hawaii studying the American democratic system and his time spent in other western democracies like the English parliamentary system, the revolutionary group in its entire still fail to view the importance of the separation of power, only viewing it as important as a side foot note... As such, what Yuan said is indeed correct; however, it doesn't excuse his actions to intentionally exploit that loophole. Not only so, that man has been power hungry and shrewd ever since his early career, Yuan was the damn general that betrayed reformist Emperor GuangXu and sided with the greedily incompetent conservatives led by Cixi. He not only broke his promise to the emperor to help him, he betrayed and basically ended the Qing as the 100 days reform as well as the subsequent other reforms are thrown out after GuangXu's house arrest and later assassination. Without the reforms, the Qing never stood a chance against the later rebellions and 8 nation alliance, they also were never able to transition smoothly into a English style constitutional monarchy, which was a proposal supported by GuangXu. These actions are likely why I'll always view Yuan as a dark stain in Chinese history.
@@SuperMan-pd3kg Thanks for your comments.
I think General "Yuan" was right to betray the Manchurian empire, that has ceased a civil war at that time and bloodshed. The Manchurian empire was corrupted and hopeless. The Han Chinese just despise the privileges granted to the Manchurians since 17th century. About "Dr.Sun YatSan" he spent many years in US. or British Hong Kong but he was disappointed that tge European powers and Japan refused to give up their special privileges in China, especially Britain keep trading opium in China. "Sun" became an admirer of Lenin and the Soviet Union in 1920s and seeking the Russian's help, he became an autocratic leader but he died not long later in 1925. I hope the above will help your understanding of China in early 20th century.
And then the communist one party autocratic rule came.
Chiang Kai Shek was the fore runner of the "one party autocrats" !
@@jagdpanther2224 That's Also true... After all, his family conducted the white terror era in Taiwan. But, they finally did give up, with pressure from U.S on adopting democracy.
@WAFFLE123 The Nationalist party (KMT) sent two gangsters on behalf of the party to murder a Chinese American author in USA, that angered Ronald Regan and thats why the Chiangs family gave up the political power to appease the Americans. Not because they are willfully want to have democracy 🙄
@@Harthorn It was because the murder of a Chinese American author in 1984, that angered the US government. The Chiangs gave up the political power was an appeasement to USA rather than willfully accept democracy, Chiang's son caught a big trouble!
@WAFFLE123 I didn't say KMT love democracy, I said they gave it up with pressure from U.S.
Amazing explanation my friend.
Thank you! Cheers!
@@themovierecapofficial come to my Instagram
This is q good movie summary, but now I really would like to see the whole movie
He didn't end it.
Treasonous subjects forced him
How did they find a guy that looks like Sun yat set to that extent?
Lol, really 'end of autocratic rule'.
.......... Chiang kai shek
5:50 She was not the mother of Puji
No monarchy had ever ruled all of China for more than one thousand years, let alone two.
let's name a kid as an emperor what could go wrong right?
Flogging eunuchs for fun
lmao
Apparently they didn't learn anything despite having meticulous historical records about dynasties that fell because of the same bullshit, like the Han dynasty.
Empress CiXi has nothing better to choose but naming Pui Yi (The child emperor) to succeed he throne!
Lol china is still autocratic
China still today is auto cratic
Democratic?
@@LSG_Squadron omg do some research idiot
Yes and has been since 1949 .
@@danielthompson7575 Bullshit
@@danielthompson7575 Republican era China has never been democratic after 1914, Yuan ShiKai after he became president. He disbanded the parliament and destroyed the constitution. And soon becomes an emperor, however his choice is fairly unpopular even his allies so he abdicated in 1916. Then China enter the warlords era. Sun Yat-Sen has declared that China will have a one party state until the reunification of China. However, he died of cancer during the process. And then Chiang Kai-Shek, took power and becomes a dictator.
I tell you one thing. China under his control would be far worse than Mao
and replace with worst dictators ever
These aren't the communists
@@IKARIUM but the nationalist did most of the fighting against the Japanese so they where weakened when they fought the communists
Who? Joe Biden running the world's biggest autocracy...yes sure, worst than ever!
I mean, China went from dirt poor to the second strongest economy within a century. So it just depends on perspective.
ended monarchy,there comes communism,god why
It's interesting that she said don't make haste make peace
It reminds me of Catherine the Great saying if the peasants revolt then arrest the governor's
I thought he be a communist but in this movie , he is democracy supporter.
he is sun yat sen
Lol. Is that a joke?
Nope
U need to watch video again. Jackie is not mr sun
Nationalist*
Superb.
Must watch this movie.
And thus begins the rule of an autocratic republic
thats KMT and PRC,China during 1912-1928 was far better and more liberty.
@@wahaha918 Nonsense! The China in 1910s was divided by warlords and the the North has more than the South. Very much like Afghanistan in 1990s before the Taliban took Kabul!
@@wahaha918 China during 1912-1928 was still poor, and most of those warlords still wanted to unite China.
By 1926 most warlords united with Chiang Kai-shek.
In 1911 the ruling warlords of China were still united as chinese.
@@jagdpanther2224 China's warlords all saw themselves as chinese. Afghanistan warlords are all different ethnic groups fighting over separating from Afghanistan.
In 1920 China, Zhang Zuolin, Yan Xishan, Feng Yuxiang, Mao Zedong, Chiang Kaishek, Cai E, Chen Jiongming and the other warlords all saw themselves as chinese, they just fought over who should lead a united China nation.
@@wahaha918China during 1912-1928 was rampant with warlords, civil wars, banditry, political instability, anarchy and famines. "Far better and more liberty" my ass.
End of empirer rule but SUN YUT SEN GROUP KMT IS DESTRYOD TO GOES TO TAIWAN
So 1911 the hairs is different
Han people still hate the Qing Dynasty royals??
Why does he actually look like Sun
China is still autocratic. Now more than ever actually.
@Zack Smith source: every news outlet we have.
@Zack Smith Try Eastern and Southern before you come to a conclusion. Western too tho 🙃. Well those propaganda are also true. That recent attack on that author proves it 🙃.
I won’t mind autocratic imperial rule, due to my family lineage, but for most ordinary people today China is not as autocratic as before. In fact China is much better than imperial rule. Yes, today’s China is autocratic, but it is led by a leadership of engineers who were some what capable in running a nation. Imperial Chinese bureaucracy was a mixed bunch with nearly all high ranking positions both ceremonial and with real power dominated by those with the right lineage.
@Zack Smith One party dictatorship=Autocracy, are you allowed to criticise ccp in public ? i dont think so
Demorcraz are endless debates,quarrels,deceptions,strikes,
riots,social disobedience and people divided but without constructive actions!
Autocrat is action, solidarity and prosperity like China!
Nice to see Jackie Chan here. Thanks for recapping this.
He's a commies lackey!
Subtle CCP Propaganda
But isn’t the guy a founder of Taiwan
If anything, it's the opposite. Currently, the CCP chairman effectively rules as an "emperor" in all but name; that's one view from this movie. The idea that China had initially created protections for revolution vs. the incidents whereby the CCP had rolled out weapons against its own citizens' peaceful protest are a shocking contrast.
@@magnusthered4973 Actually, he’s considered a sort of father of the nation by both the CCP and KMT and is unique for having a high reputation and celebrations in both the mainland and taiwan.
@Zack Smith Tianeman Square, and the incidents on the same day this year with bank protests; kinda harrowing in similarity
Don't like this then don't watching it!
Sponsored by CCP
Don't like ? Don't watch it!
Sponsored by roc propaganda
And ccp
What does this movie have to do with the CCP? Do you study Chinese history?
Its 1911 but at the four nation bank is the flag of the german republic, which didnt exist at this point. 7 years to early
that is the german flag which existed even before the german empire was a thing, in those times they would had used the german empire flag but its wrong to say that flag is the flag of the republic only when it was a flag of a united germany but yeah the kaiserreich flag should had been used
@@raulisrael7342It was also used as a merchant flag, its somewhat accurate
From autocratic to communist dictator
Sorry I don’t see any change except the name
how is a person chosen and kept in check by delegates representing a country a dictator? you obviously know jackass about gvt in China!
That's your own perspective. It's not just autocratic, it's transition from dying imperial monarchy to unified republic. It changed wholeheartedly become 2nd strongest country soon surpassing United States.
@@Andy0770 it's not a republic
@@ebonymaw8457 you want to sleep walking it's up to you.
There’s Taiwan serving as a reminder on how democracy could have worked out in China.
Is he Jackie Chan or am I being racist?
Lol
Well if you do not recognize him as Jackie Chan then you maybe a racist cause it's easy to see that he is Jackie Chan lol
@@kammmmal211 is joke just back fire 💪🏼😂 😂 that’s facts bru is impossible not recognize him
Both
Everybody is racist. Don't shame yourself about it
title please
1911
So Jackie Chan ended it all? lol
Yes you can stay that
7:09 banker banker banker
HAN vs QING... Suku han suku terlama n terhebat d china ... Dh 2 x china berhasil gulingkan penjajah yuan( monggol).. Qing(manchuria)... 😁
Han vs Manchu’s/Jurchen.
And no, the Yuan didn’t fell to the Qing but rather to the Han ethnic Ming dynasty.
first to comment
Does Qing dynasty and Manchu dynasty are same?
What’s the title of the movie.
God Save The King!
Stop acting as a slave. King George and Queen Victoria are long death, the indian people is free! Death to colonialism and imperialism!
You mean India chanting this after QE2 died? Yes, Indians always a slave of Britain, hahaha 😆
@@jagdpanther2224 really... and is that why they got rid of them....
@@va-ro They got rid of them in 1947 but quickly hugging the leg of the former master. A dog is always a dog, can't change that habit!
@@jagdpanther2224 Your version of history and reality is different than that of the rest of the world ...
Long Live Mao Zedong!
He's busy at the moment. 😈
@@haitolawrence5986 I hope your landlord increases your rent, if you even work.
The rebellion was not actually primarily a republican chinese uprising against monarchial rule but a han chinese nationalist uprising against the manchu rule the slogan of the revolution was ''kill the barbarian and drive them away'' sun and his han nationalists wanted to create a han chinese state and implement genocide on manchus he banned manchu languange and his soldiers commited genocide against manchus
It was a mutiny!
very true. sun was a han nationalist. Today Im manchu and Hakka who sun was. Hakka people always cause trouble for us lol
@@Willxdiana I mean Manchu messed up China with Qing dynasty tbh
@@Vampybattie not really they expanded to Mongolia and xinjiang and Tibet. They tried to act too Chinese to be accepted. Confucius screw them up
Manchus are Koreans.
Nothing really has ended. Autocracy is still there. Politically, not royally.
.
Hi
Propaganda
Don't like this then don't watching it!
Every movie has
Undertones of freedom
Homer Simpson hero in china
well this war was a very bad idea acording to me
Why?
Most boring recap I have ever seen. Movie(I haven't seen) seems more like a documentary.
But when qing dynasty it's not china
Biggest L in Chinese History
Just want to tell those who clueless about East Asia situations: don't you dare compare these valiant souls with those rebellious bastard in some places of China,Hong Kong and Taiwan.
hahaha CCP is the upstart and abortion (sponsored by the Marxist Lenin group) of the Chinese revolution by Sun Yat Sen...
You mean those soldiers compared to nowadays demonstrators?
50 cent party troll detected, CCP is worse than qing, qing atleast had some limits to its brutality while ccp commits genocide and organ harvesting
Those "Rebellious bastards" were sabotagers and they were sabotaging the society, they were all thugs must DIES!
@@Barri2410 There were no demonstrators ever, those people were thugs!
nah,all the revolutionary bullshit,Qing was not really that bad also.
Exactly Qing wasn’t that bad. Revolutionary bs
There are two idiots above this comment ^