Falling Out With The Dissident Right, Alex Kaschuta
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 вер 2024
- Writer, mother, and podcast host @AlexKaschuta joins me to speak about the deviation of internet discourse over time, motherhood, and a bit about Romanian history from post-Soviet influence to European Unionhood.
Find her work at
www.alexkaschu...
x.com/kaschuta
x.com/aksubver...
Support this channel:
www.paypal.me/...
cash.app/$benj...
www.buymeacoff...
Find all interviews on spotify: spoti.fi/3px5WnK
/ benjaminboyce
Join me on alternative video sites:
odysee.com/@Be...
www.bitchute.c...
rumble.com/use...
And on Twitter @BenjaminABoyce
That’s alright, I don’t expect the ladies to have genuine convictions. Opinions seem to be more of a social tool for most of them.
Oh man and there you go with the negative generalizations of an entire gender. At this rate there won’t be any women on the right in a year or so. Guys this misogyny has got to go because if it doesn’t you can only expect to keep losing ..
@@brianmeen2158 Read it again: most. It is a generalisation - but those are useful - and it’s not even an outright negative one. It’s a fairly neutral observation, so let’s not get emotional about it ;) it is certainly *not* misogyny.
@@Vingul the biggest problem is you lack self awareness. You don’t realize that your posts make you come off as a bitter incel
Type. How you can’t see this is truly baffling to me .
@@brianmeen2158 Gender isn't real. You're a lib.
@@brianmeen2158 the women you're talking about aren't even on the right, that's the point
How can we be so negative when we haven’t even tried? No one said this was going to be quick or easy. I don’t mind people being critical but out right negativity is infuriating.
Katizcha gives the current operators and “minds” way too much credit for keeping the trains moving. The key grunt workers are usually apolitical and will stay. The issue is the malign political operators embedded into the permanent bureaucracy. They need to be removed. Why aren’t you giving us a chance to do this? You’re judging it before it even hatches.
I listened to Alex's interview with RFH and was very disappointed. The man-hating is ridiculous and anyone who can't see it is beyond ridiculous. Men today treat women many orders of magnitude better than 2 or 3 generations ago, while women now treat men far worse than before. I still go out a lot because I country-swing dance and see it all the time. 100 women in a club chasing after literally 4 guys and ignoring the other 100 guys. It's reached a point of absolute absurdity.
What a strange example of mem being treated badly. Because women aren't chasing them?
@@racs9606 Women rejecting 96% of men because of extremely picky shallow reasons is not a strange example in my opinion.
@@samuelspiel8855 It's a waste of energy to get mad at the women for not choosing you. You're better off either doing your best to join the 4%, or get laser-focused on finding your ONE person who is a good fit for you (and accept that she may not be in what you consider the top 4% for women, but that doesn't matter because she's beautiful to YOU).
@@racs9606how much do you want to collapse society and how fast? It’s getting kind of fast now.
When RFH is on Twitter, she writes long, gushing fanfics about women putting their sons in sperm camps. When she went on Alex's podcast, she clutched her pearls about extremism and talked like Jordan Peterson. Alex not calling her out on that incongruity was pretty painful.
Alex Kaschuta sounds more gobal socialist than dissident right.
Yup.
These people constantly try to infiltrate movements on the right.
Women
@@mark4asp no doubt
@@soulfuzz368 you do realize you need women in your movement right? Women are very much needed for very obvious reasons .. come on guys, wake up
Lol. A decent married woman with young kids doesn't want to be called a "whore" online by hoards of nihilistic boys who think they're being "based & edgy" and you call her a global socialist?
Your movement is disappearing up its own meme hole.
I checked out too when I wasn't prepared to placate resentful boys masquerading as men.
Grow up.
Mother's birth the world.
Alienate them and you have no movement.
It's not feminist not to want to be treated like trash.
always a huge pleasure to see retuning guests on your channel. development is a liberating, purging even, thing.
1:17:27 - One of the things I keep in mind with the "realpolitik" of red pill content... it's like Ayn Rand. It's a piece of the truth, but it's not "The Truth!". I'm not so sure what's so hard about holding that in your mind. A lot of the better female creators in the space report very similar things to Alex here, and it's disheartening to me.
I don’t mind this shift now that I’ve heard her vocalize it.
She recognizes how the good observations the DR are solid, but both trickling to low IQ takes and also not holistic.
I share the same view on both. As you see politicians and bigger names start incorporating its ideas and analyses, it is going to get dumber. I wouldn’t leave something like that over that change, but I can understand if it is just getting boring if you feel like you are on a loop of the same talking points. Most political commentators do this online where they drift off from theory crafting and just start talking current events to stay relevant. If you have a passion for exploring new ideas, this will be a struggle for you.
While it has a lot of great ways to look at the world, I find it is still ultimately poisoned by materialist analysis. By that, I think is where I was picking up with her “gods made out of the truth”. People relying on truth coded strictly in the very machiavellian power analysis are going to fall into the same pitfalls that the moderns such as the communists have run across; making political systems/projects built around these observations lack all humanity and are bound to fail in its hubris as a result.
I personally think this is where things like actual faiths such as Christianity fall into place. It seems very alien to the ideas like Spengler, Yarvin, Land, or Francis, but it is paramount to them working at all as it has a certain transcendent character to it. Less a system of materially organizing human society as much as a very human connection to divinity that sparks the meaning and purpose the society is set out to accomplish.
Maybe this is late night rumination for me as I was painting while listening to this.
I will say, if we are going to lean on Schmitt here, Alex is “Friend” as far as any good faith actor on the DR should be concerned.
I think as these ideas capture more of the mainstream, you are going to have more people concerned with other things than power politics. They will also be put off by the turbo autism that is a lot of the DR. But if more people like Alex can dive in and step out without becoming some grifting “I need to de-radicalize” influencer, that is a massive W as far as I care.
Not everyone needs to be in a hive mind and plenty of people want space. People like Alex wanting to get out while still respecting a lot of the people and ideas involved is exactly the kind of stuff that I see as successful.
And I'm sure her re-productive self had nothing to do with "wanting to get out"
@@russellambrosini5344
I’m not sure what that is supposed to mean tbh.
This isn't a fashion trend it's an attempt to regain a strong true animating politic. I find this attitude of "ugh the plebs are getting access to the ideas of my niche and giving me the ick." Is shallow political hipsterdom. Yes stupid red pillers and performative misogynists can be a bit extra but that's always been part of the ideology and aside from it's less optical aspects is a necessary adjustment to the an era dominated by weak browbeaten men.
@@treesurgeon2441
Having shit optics does this kind of stuff. While I think her more important angle is the trouble with a based managerial class not very clearly forming. I might disagree with her takes on it, but I can still appreciate the sentiment as authentic.
Ideas do have a certain amount of hipsterdom to it for many people. People deep diving into them and then see them as kind of dogmatic repetitions when no praxis materializes.
I would say it is a shame to see her go, but she also doesn’t really seem openly hostile. More that she seems to have run out of gas to keep it going while there are also obnoxious unoptical people berating her to boot.
I don’t need everyone that isn’t in my niche ideaspace to be categorized as enemies. While people getting burnout is hardly worthy of me declaring as apostates.
The feminist arc is lame
Feminism is lame in general
Guys, numerous other influential women on the right are very close to giving up for the same reason as Alex. I am the furthest thing away from being a sjw but there is way too much misogyny in certain spaces on the right at this point. We need women in the movement for obvious reasons.
@@brianmeen2158 who are we talking about Lauren Southern?
A lot of these female influencers were never pro RW, they were always just anti LW
Not the same thing
@@chadofamerica I’m not talking about Lauren but two other well known women on the FR .. I’m simply saying the toxic anti-woman rhetoric has to go! If it doesn’t then you deserve to lose
@@brianmeen2158 the LW is literally destroying western Civ with hordes of orcs,
But please, a couple RW anons shit posting about roasties & single moms is the real issue
Come on man, this is childish
Alex got a few negative and uncouth comments on twitter about a couple of her views and all of a sudden, she became a fellow traveler with RFH.
It's ok though, people get burned out in this space. It's far easier to take steps back into normie centrist world and live your life while things keep getting worse.
I listened to Alex's interview with RFH and was very disappointed. The man-hating is ridiculous and anyone who can't see it is beyond ridiculous. Men today treat women many orders of magnitude better than 2 or 3 generations ago, while women now treat men far worse than before. I still go out a lot because I country-swing dance and see it all the time. 100 women in a club chasing after literally 4 guys and ignoring the other 100 guys. It's reached a point of absolute absurdity.
@@samuelspiel8855You wrote this identical comment twice under the same video?
*** Edit: I found a third. Three times. ***
@@devin_3875 so what?
Yes and especially women will get burned out in this space because in certain spaces on the right - there is a lot of red pill anti-woman rhetoric. We can only expect to lose more women from
The ranks if this continues
@@devin_3875 so what if he did. Is it untrue?
I hadn't seen the term "Alt-Right" in at least 5 years.
They kept trying to use it on the wrong people, so like racist it's a discredited term.
@@amyb.6368 Yes, labels are extremely inaccurate and unjust unless the subject accepts that particular label. Not a fan of labeling people as such or such. That's why I love Paul VanderKlay's channel.
@@amyb.6368 Who or what did the term apply to, initially? I’ve only heard it as a dumb slur.
@@devin_3875. Richard Spencer created a movement and it was labeled “alt right”..
@@brianmeen2158 Thanks!
the funniest part about the last few months of tantrum throwing about this topic has been none of the women kvetching the loudest about the "repeal the 19th" snark are even american
Fickle, they are.
Darling according to who? I don't even mean any disrespect, but ive never heard of this gal.
“There is no market for the solution”. I both get what she is saying but isn’t this what Jordan Peterson talks about? That market appears endless.
The difference between men's memes and women's is unreal. JP talking about duty and responsibility while women chant songs about 6'5 and trust funds. I still go out a lot because I country-swing dance and see it all the time. 100 women in a club chasing after literally 4 guys and ignoring the other 100 guys. It's reached a point of absolute absurdity.
@@samuelspiel8855 I regained my appreciation for women after spending some months in Thailand and Philipines, it kinda flipped the game on its head for me after I got back home aswell.
@@samuelspiel8855 Three times. Three times you posted this comment under the same video.
Nice shirt, Benjamin.
My wife has fun dressing me
@@BenjaminABoyce 🙂 That's sweet .
Looking good there Boyce. Hawaiian shirt, close-cut hair.
White Boyce Summer!
Boogaloo Boyce.
I read the comments first and thought this would be some disaster conversation, but Alex was cogent and reasonable throughout 🤷♂️
I've been following both of you since your very beginnings. I'm actually crying over the end of this video, like when my girls lost their virginity, like seeing my first granddaughter begin puberty... what was will never be again! 😭 And yet it is also so beautiful to see you both growing up.
Great interview, thanks!
Love Alex, been listening to her podcasts for years! Wow for the third kid!
I’ve followed both of you for a while and appreciate your honesty in pursuing truth. While listening to your conversation, the following verse comes to mind: That which has been is what will be, that which is done is what will be done, and there is nothing new under the sun. Is there anything of which it may be said, “See this is new”? It has already been in ancient times before us. There is no remembrance of former things, nor will there be any remembrance of things that are to come by those who will come after. Ecclesiastes 1:9-11
I have had the same problem with the DR. They don’t talk about many things and I find that revealing. Some have tried to explain why this is and they boil it down to”there is no point unless we go full premodern.” I find that idea ridiculous. It simply will never happen and is not a way to move into the future.
I appreciate the aesthetic critiques though.
The fact that they cannot find any kinship with any republic sympathizers is just too much and it all feels like I’m just waisting my time with them.
It will inevitably happen. Either we'll do it, or we'll get replaced by Muslims who already have a wildly successful and currently rapidly expanding, pre-modern culture.
The West had no future under post-modernism. The birthrate has been below replacement for 3 generations. We're coming to the point where we either do drastic and awful things, or we die quietly.
It's an online movement, as such it navigates towards unrealistic impracticable positions and extreme hypocrisy in how people live IRL. IMHO internet movements should only be used for entertainment and gaining some ideas but should not be confused with involvement with real life where everything is totally different and way more complex.
0Hp only nuked his account 5 days ago and she's already countersignaling. She could lose some weight
0Hp?
Seems I remember Ms. Alex from quite a while ago, so will be good to catch up
Yeah no.
Came here to read the comments, I don't think I'm gonna listen to this. I'm out after her RFH interview.
The DR was quite a vibrant, revolutionary space 3 years ago that I enjoyed participating in even as a lurker, but standards have fallen and have overall been degraded intellectually due to poor incentives on social media.
I have some ideas for the new rebranded name of her podcast. How about
Freedom Got a AK, or
Ka$ch Rules Everything Around Me
or maybe
Active Kaschuta
That third baby is pretty awesome (definitely easier!) and it’s wonderful to have your babies close in age as they grow.
Opening content 10/10 🐔🐤🐣🐥
Alex is always insightful.
If you think there is no market for the solution, maybe it's because you don't have the solution. But this seems like a crazy idea to certain political and social analysts.
Repeal the 19th is trending on Twitter. There's a solution. It's palatable to normal people. (Well, men, anyway) And the ruling class is too out of touch to go near it.
Never heard of her ever
Persuasive
not missing anything
58:20 With all due respect Ben this is a bizarre and nonsensical observation. We should all know by now that "woke right" is a neocon and liberal rhetorical jab designed to create false equivalency. Hoe math isn't part of the DR and the comparison between the two is lazy.
I’ve said as much that “woke right” is a lazy categorical jab. But I still like giving the devil its due, as much as I personally regret it.
istg every time ben talks about women’s issues these days, the incels come out in full force
“what do you mean you don’t like the obvious misogyny in the online right?” 😭💀
nobody of any value uses the word 'incel'
I dunno, she has her kids, seems to be raising them well, and is getting out of politics. Even if she is “getting away” from the DR, she’s already done its prescriptions, so does it really matter?
This is what i'm thinking
This ep pretty much expertly sums up where this whole rock 'n roll supergroup has been, and somewhat suggests where it might be going next.
However personally, I still can't rly follow or understand politics too much, at least not without getting that slurpy-brain-freeze feeling.
Please tell us about the little hen and her chicks that opens your video 😍
the intro seems like an awkward initial meeting at a bar
That’s what I’m going for. Good ear!
I'm remined why I cancelled this channel.
Never heard of her. I see on her channel she's clipped a bunch of people sort of big in vaguely right-of-centre politics on Xitter.
Don't know if you can have a 'falling out' with a movement that's barely ever heard of you.
Can I get an early life check?
She doesn't have an early life.
@@carlotapuig did she sprout from the ground fully grown like an uruk-hai?
@@SamTheEnglishTeacher She's Romanian, no early life
@@SamTheEnglishTeacher
Purely Romanian
@@goyonman9655 ah yep so just check your pockets if she bumps into you
Right wing woman is an oxymoron. The most right wing thing a woman can do is stop talking.
And post birth worse.
a good fight online is an oxymoron. go touch grass, champ.
That's why the right wing needs to be replaced by traditional conservatives.
Amazing that her romanian accent is less than a regional US accent. Shows the globalization of the American headspace.
On the why would they hate it part,it's why most normies on left and right hate ppl like Pinker,common enemies unite us more than common friends
This lady is so cool. I wish we were neighbors so she could be a good influence on my normie wife
Romania mentioned!
Good conversation. Respect to Mrs. Kashuta, people evolve. I do wonder where, exactly, the evolution began. I remember her seeming visibly irritated at this fella stating that "her stunning beauty was s significant factor in her success".
1:20:46 Apparently you won't get in trouble with HR at your Company "because the ideas are echoing in normie land." LOL! I call BS on that. In your exit interview. Clip this and let them hear it. You'll get your job back. Ben said so. It's normie land stuff.
Judging by the comments section, your audience hates to see a woman complaining about sexism on the alt right.
I don’t know your experience with the algorithm and who comments on what content, but my experience is that “my audience” is heavily variant depending on who the guest is and how an interview is framed by the title and thumbnail.
immaculate timing
Really? Why?
From one grift to another
What’s the solution?
Ho Rebellion
Good discussion. I know of several other women on the far right that are very close to just giving up on the movement due to the rampant misogyny in certain spaces. Come on folks, we need to do better
The 'Dissident Right' is just another online echo chamber, the same as all the others.
Of course it is
Of course.
I'm sure YOU'RE the sensible liberal.
@@mattl8774 butthurt I called out your little echo chamber? 😆
@RandomAussieGuy87 he is right though. You probably are in a liberal echo chamber somewhere.
I mean, everyone whose been alive between 4000BC and 1800AD agrees with them, so, wouldn't the current regime of propaganda be the echo chamber?
10:00
Chicken mske great house pet
I want the chicken haha.
Yea the DR is dead
Interesting to see the various breeds of toxic commenter that get pulled to Benjamin’s channel, depending on the guest.
Cute baby chickens! I wonder if the cats are interested?
That sounds like far-left political-correctness to me
@@user-oh3gz5vq3o No, that’s not accurate.
@@user-oh3gz5vq3oAnd lame far left.
@@devin_3875 fgt
What a shocker. Not