What I loved the most about this podcast is that you never once harped on the Muslim card . In India we are all Indians first !! Our religion is our personal business
Dar wasnt the first or only one to cook books. That is the underlying reason of IMF's distrust. What IMF fears ( and what China, Russia, EU, Japan, Saudi Arabia fear ) is that what Dar promises will be torn up by the person who succeeds him. This is not without precedent in the history of populist politics. And in present market situation, where money supply is being starved, if the political elite get their hands on so much money, what is to stop them to divide the money up amongst themselves, flip the govt, and say that we will not honour these terms because they are inhuman ( basically, populist politics, using people as a shield ). And if they do that and get away with it, with the IMF, they will try to repeat with other lenders too. its not Dar. its Darr.
The politicians and elite don’t love their land and people. If you did that, you will work nonstop for the common man. In Pakistan, government is not about service and sacrifices. Almost all in ruling class think they are doing a service for the country by running the country. Fundamentally, the common man on the street has NO one to care for him at the state or federal level.
China not interested in helping Pakistan. Pakistan stole $26 billion from China, plus 20 of their Chinese operated power plants in Pakistan closed because they Chinese were not paid. This lead to a recent blackout in the country.
Dar talks a lot and one who talks a lot has no substance it is all posing big when you are nothing. Dar has multiple sky scrapers in prime locations of Dubai and his sons have a fleet of ten most expensive cars including Ferrari, Rolls Royce , BMW, Mercedes etc, Dar must be accounted for his wealth accumulation and investment in Dubai. Dar is a fake financial guy who nothing about finance and I am not surprised if IMF kicked his ass.
I am Indian engineer not economic background.....my question is if you put constraints in the market by shutting shops after a certain time. there will be an extra cash to the common man and will be an artificial inflation in future. Can anyone from economics background confirm or deny my this understanding ??
Dude Pakistan isn't joining India. Now give up and stop being salty. India isn't competing with China. It's competing with Africa. No country takes India seriously because it's not a beacon of success
Sorry to say as I don't want to hurt common Pakistani...but how come getting loan be a reason to be happy ...it's a shameful situation for a country ...
All this is because of Jinnah. Nehru wanted to implement land reforms and did. Jinnah took advantage of this and made powerful alliance with Muslim Feudals(Hindu Feudals were screwed but Muslim Feudals went to Pakistan). Jinnah welcomed them and promised them their wealth will be respected. You won't find a single speech from Jinnah against Zamindars/Feudals. Pakistanis today are suffering because of this folly. You can thank Jinnah.
I am from Pakistan . I agree with you Mr. Jinnah and his party All India Muslim League is established by Britain Empire to counter Indian Congress party .When the British Empire feel the India National Congress was out of their control and the Congress party demands British rullers to leave India and gives complete independence to Indian peoples but the All India Muslim league was supported British rullers and British rullers used All India Muslim League to weaken Congress party and shows the Indian Muslims were never supported Congress and never demand independence of India . The muslim league was the party of British loyals muslims majority of them were held the title of SIR from British rullers for their loyality. The All India Muslim league demands the separation of some part of India to gave a name of Pakistan with the support of British rullers. The British rullers fully cooperate with All India Muslim League to support for their demand of separation not independence Muslim League never demand of independence in its politicial history and always cooperate British rullers because the British empire needed a base camp against the rising power of Soviet Union and the new country was used to base camp against Soviet Union Rissia and its allies . The decision of divided India was taken in London Britian not in India and not for the demands of Ondia peoples. Thanks.
@@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386 Either you are too young or naive... reality is all this religion language culture all these disputes are just baseline fodder for public underline game and intent are purely power politics and interest
Agree, Pakistan was just a case for the esteemed lawyer which he wanted to win and he successfully did. He was not a visionary leader which he is celebrated to be!
@@abhaypatel4292 I am too young and naive? Only a moron would say that to another living being on the internet just because they disagree. Religion is a belief system. This belief system determines what beliefs are true and what is not. In any system there are winners and losers that emerge. In Islam everyone eventually loses. You are confusing the transient winners as the engineers of the system. The system evolves as a consequence of the axioms of the belief system. You confuse the tree leaves for the root.
You two are fantastic! I am glad you are thinking of how to improve Pakistan! The social order too is disintegrating! Thank you! Getting Economy back to shape is easier than the Social fabric! Too much dose of Islamism!
it appears there's literally no plan in pakistan to deal with current economic mess. India should prepare and plan for serious unrest in pakistan and border security. cant predict how large overreligious population without growth opportunities will behave.
@@yasiraftab9880 when situation go out of hand when people are just frustrated with inflation and joblessness no one can predict.. History has proved it again again.. French revolution ,Russian revolution. Whole empires collapse .... 1 year ago no one could predict people storming Sri Lankan presidents house . President was lucky that he had fled already .. Situation are similar in Pakistan .. We hopefully wish everything will be back on track in Pakistan but if it doesn't then consequences will be far more worse
Shriraj Agashe mea toa bolta hu made in india ka under auto tureet machine gun banao boder line cross karna pea auto fire hojaya . best boder security aganist zombies
Shriraj mala vattay apan kahich karayla Nako . Fakta khel baghava . Try karava ki hyancha deshat ajun kasa chaos vadhvu shaku . Ani he konich india madhe nahi yenar . Bdw uzair is in india currently.
Greetings from New Delhi....Another wonderful episode. Congratulations. My limited point is ...The Pakistani politicians /establishment have such a bloated ego that they will not trade with India at any cost. India does not need Pakistan. Pakistan needs India. Trade with India is the need of the hour. And with a little bit of luck if they can manage rupee trade with India, Pakistan will be well on its way out of the crises.
Pakistan doesn't need India. India's been thinking about that since independence. Why are you Indians so insecure. Honestly get it through your head. Pakistan doesn't want anything to do with India.
Pakistani people do discrimination based on religion, color,culture,money,power,education and Language. How your political system and police system be good? Long as you have money or power it doesn't matter how you get people will respect you. That is Pakistani culture.
Bhai pair toh khoon ki nadiyan na beh jayein. But aise haalat mein your advice is totally reasonable and understandable. Let's hope things improve for the common people of Pakistan.
If the programe is in English more people would uderstand. I personally do not understand any Indic language but I suspect something valuable is being said.. In passing, on a purely Pakistan Islamism: Pakistan cavorts with the largest, most powerful idolatrous and atheistic state in the world and allows it to gain influence and financial profit from PaKistan. Allah will certainly chastise Pakistan as is being done now until this Pak-China relationship straigthens out and Pak stops supporting athesism and idolitry.
Brilliant and insightful. Would like to point out that lack of credibility started with Imran when program went of track THREE times. In Dec 2019, 2nd tranche wasn't approved (it is wrong to say pause was due to COVID since this predates COVID), April 2021 where PTI reneged on the agreement one day after receiving tranches 2,3,4,5 and also changed the finance minister and finally in Feb 2022 when barely a couple of weeks after receiving the 6th tranche PTI reneged and instead of increasing prices as per agreement, actually reduced prices. Disagree with Miftah's so called helplessness as FM. Manmohan Singh in 1991-96 period is said to have had a typed resignation letter in his pocket. He was clear that he wanted the role only if he was empowered. Very sad of course that as PM he did not show similar intellectual integrity and turned a blind eye to a lot of stuff simply so as to continue getting the power and prestige of being PM of India. Mind you in December 2017 when Miftah depreciated currency from 105 to 110 he said that rupee was absolutely correctly priced - something he knew was false. Eventually by the time he left in May 2018, he left it at 115 which was still highly overvalued. At that time SKA was PM and unlike Shehbaz Sharif had totally empowered Miftah. But he did not let rupee find its value. If coyrse correction had started in October 2017 when Miftah first became SAPM and then FM, the serious CAD situation of June end 2018 could have been averted. But he did not do that. Miftah may not be financially corrupt since he is independently wealthy. But he has been willing to not speak up, if that gave him the power and prestige of the FM post.
@@blackrockorange Pakistani economy is a very good case study for economics students. Even in our semester we got an assignment for countries with severe circular debt and vicious cycle of financing problems and since Pakistani economy is the perfect example so it is really insightful. Good day 👍🏻
@@blackrockorangeit is the best entertainment for Indians who have experienced 1000 cuts of your corrupt evil army elites. We are eating Popcorn and enjoying Pakistan's gradual demise and disintegration. Karma is a bitch!! Justice for innocent victims and minorities in East Punjab and Kashmir.
@Football-Pundit A patwari brain is worse than a donkey brain. A 6.5% growth economy which happened in Imran Khan's tenure is bad but a negative 2% growth and an economy that has defaulted in wonderful under PDM.
@Football-Pundit Patwari logic. Dollar 179 Rs bad under IK Dollar Rs 300 good under Shebaz. Petrol Rs140 bad under IK Petrol Rs 300 good under Shebaz... mashallah what a brain.
Imran Khan zindabad. Throw this important government, call for fresh elections. And bring Imran Khan with better mandate. He will solve all problems of the country.
Question - Why is Pakistan so desperate to avoid the default. Why can't they do a organised default like Argentina? Pakistani debt is huge and they will keep struggling, it is better to a default and start over. The key would be to avoid chaotic default like SriLanka.
This interest based economy must end. Sood ka nizam haram hai. We should stop paying these usurious interests to these dirty international money lenders.
You people are miftah apologist. Yes he is from karachi as you both are and you have kinship but still. The man doesn't know what he is doing. Why do they have to change the government in the first place it was 1.5 years left. If 10 rupee subcidie on petrol was given why not removed in April. Why in May. And petrol price were high then but they fall for quite some time now. Don't lie. Don't do selective journalism.
Best program since ages about reality of paksistan economy by true patriotic people. Keep it up.
What I loved the most about this podcast is that you never once harped on the Muslim card .
In India we are all Indians first !! Our religion is our personal business
Excellent you guys..!Hope some day people like you are in policy making in Pakistan... keep it up
So Dar was cooking books what credibility does Dar has in front of IMF. I think lMF doesn't trust finance minister Dar.
Dar wasnt the first or only one to cook books. That is the underlying reason of IMF's distrust. What IMF fears ( and what China, Russia, EU, Japan, Saudi Arabia fear ) is that what Dar promises will be torn up by the person who succeeds him. This is not without precedent in the history of populist politics. And in present market situation, where money supply is being starved, if the political elite get their hands on so much money, what is to stop them to divide the money up amongst themselves, flip the govt, and say that we will not honour these terms because they are inhuman ( basically, populist politics, using people as a shield ).
And if they do that and get away with it, with the IMF, they will try to repeat with other lenders too.
its not Dar. its Darr.
Uzair sb is correct in his assessment of the ruling class and its policies which may lead to unforeseen consequences!
The politicians and elite don’t love their land and people. If you did that, you will work nonstop for the common man. In Pakistan, government is not about service and sacrifices. Almost all in ruling class think they are doing a service for the country by running the country. Fundamentally, the common man on the street has NO one to care for him at the state or federal level.
Have you guys China is completely silent in the last 4 to 5 months
It isn't their job to save Pakistanis from themselves.
China not interested in helping Pakistan. Pakistan stole $26 billion from China, plus 20 of their Chinese operated power plants in Pakistan closed because they Chinese were not paid. This lead to a recent blackout in the country.
Old guns need to fired and bring new blood to change pakistan economy.
Very much needed. In addition Army needs to stay in the barracks.
Dar talks a lot and one who talks a lot has no substance it is all posing big when you are nothing. Dar has multiple sky scrapers in prime locations of Dubai and his sons have a fleet of ten most expensive cars including Ferrari, Rolls Royce , BMW, Mercedes etc,
Dar must be accounted for his wealth accumulation and investment in Dubai. Dar is a fake financial guy who nothing about finance and I am not surprised if IMF kicked his ass.
True about Dar. Equally true about Shaukat Tareen and Asad Umar.
Ali Khizar🙏👏👍🏼❤️
I am Indian engineer not economic background.....my question is if you put constraints in the market by shutting shops after a certain time. there will be an extra cash to the common man and will be an artificial inflation in future. Can anyone from economics background confirm or deny my this understanding ??
Islam will save you. Pakistan ka matlab kya?
La ilah dol dila
This kafirs are saying of capitalist economy which is based on interest payments so no to interest and save pakistan
Quran is food for soul(Mullah)
@@deepeshbajpai8543 Koran is medieval Arab shit.
this fellow can be excellent prime minister for pakistan
Try asking the chineese about the 30bn dollars that they lent to you be restructered?😢
Dude Pakistan isn't joining India. Now give up and stop being salty. India isn't competing with China. It's competing with Africa. No country takes India seriously because it's not a beacon of success
Sorry to say as I don't want to hurt common Pakistani...but how come getting loan be a reason to be happy ...it's a shameful situation for a country ...
I am shocked to see that pakistan has been borrowing from IMF . REFER ARTICLE AGONY AUNT in dawn
All this is because of Jinnah. Nehru wanted to implement land reforms and did. Jinnah took advantage of this and made powerful alliance with Muslim Feudals(Hindu Feudals were screwed but Muslim Feudals went to Pakistan).
Jinnah welcomed them and promised them their wealth will be respected. You won't find a single speech from Jinnah against Zamindars/Feudals.
Pakistanis today are suffering because of this folly. You can thank Jinnah.
I am from Pakistan . I agree with you Mr. Jinnah and his party All India Muslim League is established by Britain Empire to counter Indian Congress party .When the British Empire feel the India National Congress was out of their control and the Congress party demands British rullers to leave India and gives complete independence to Indian peoples but the All India Muslim league was supported British rullers and British rullers used All India Muslim League to weaken Congress party and shows the Indian Muslims were never supported Congress and never demand independence of India . The muslim league was the party of British loyals muslims majority of them were held the title of SIR from British rullers for their loyality. The All India Muslim league demands the separation of some part of India to gave a name of Pakistan with the support of British rullers. The British rullers fully cooperate with All India Muslim League to support for their demand of separation not independence Muslim League never demand of independence in its politicial history and always cooperate British rullers because the British empire needed a base camp against the rising power of Soviet Union and the new country was used to base camp against Soviet Union Rissia and its allies . The decision of divided India was taken in London Britian not in India and not for the demands of Ondia peoples. Thanks.
@@asadaziz6429 You believe in the two nation theory because Islam is a two nation theory. Don’t blame Jinnah. He just did what Islam expects of him.
@@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386 Either you are too young or naive... reality is all this religion language culture all these disputes are just baseline fodder for public underline game and intent are purely power politics and interest
Agree, Pakistan was just a case for the esteemed lawyer which he wanted to win and he successfully did. He was not a visionary leader which he is celebrated to be!
@@abhaypatel4292 I am too young and naive? Only a moron would say that to another living being on the internet just because they disagree.
Religion is a belief system. This belief system determines what beliefs are true and what is not. In any system there are winners and losers that emerge. In Islam everyone eventually loses. You are confusing the transient winners as the engineers of the system. The system evolves as a consequence of the axioms of the belief system. You confuse the tree leaves for the root.
You two are fantastic! I am glad you are thinking of how to improve Pakistan! The social order too is disintegrating! Thank you! Getting Economy back to shape is easier than the Social fabric! Too much dose of Islamism!
What a failed state of affairs.
Army subsidies have not ended. That alone will save the economy.
it appears there's literally no plan in pakistan to deal with current economic mess. India should prepare and plan for serious unrest in pakistan and border security. cant predict how large overreligious population without growth opportunities will behave.
You are exaggerating the situation
@@yasiraftab9880 no at all friend , best case scenario is imf bailout with tax increase and even higher inflation than now.
@@yasiraftab9880 when situation go out of hand when people are just frustrated with inflation and joblessness no one can predict..
History has proved it again again..
French revolution ,Russian revolution.
Whole empires collapse ....
1 year ago no one could predict people storming Sri Lankan presidents house .
President was lucky that he had fled already ..
Situation are similar in Pakistan ..
We hopefully wish everything will be back on track in Pakistan but if it doesn't then consequences will be far more worse
Shriraj Agashe
mea toa bolta hu made in india ka under auto tureet machine gun banao boder line cross karna pea auto fire hojaya .
best boder security aganist zombies
Shriraj mala vattay apan kahich karayla Nako . Fakta khel baghava . Try karava ki hyancha deshat ajun kasa chaos vadhvu shaku . Ani he konich india madhe nahi yenar . Bdw uzair is in india currently.
Greetings from New Delhi....Another wonderful episode. Congratulations. My limited point is ...The Pakistani politicians /establishment have such a bloated ego that they will not trade with India at any cost. India does not need Pakistan. Pakistan needs India. Trade with India is the need of the hour. And with a little bit of luck if they can manage rupee trade with India, Pakistan will be well on its way out of the crises.
Pakistan doesn't need India. India's been thinking about that since independence. Why are you Indians so insecure. Honestly get it through your head. Pakistan doesn't want anything to do with India.
Sir where to invest money in pakistan ?
Pakistani people do discrimination based on religion, color,culture,money,power,education and Language. How your political system and police system be good? Long as you have money or power it doesn't matter how you get people will respect you. That is Pakistani culture.
I suggest every one keeps a handgun at there house . Practice 2nd amendment like in US.
Also grow a beard like in Afghanistan
😆
that is already happening!! all the rich ppl have bought pakistan !!
Bhai pair toh khoon ki nadiyan na beh jayein. But aise haalat mein your advice is totally reasonable and understandable.
Let's hope things improve for the common people of Pakistan.
Don't you have till now
$130 billion debt.
First you stop drinking tea on air. What is the need to drink tea in such short programs. It shows your level of seriousness.
We were drinking coffee not tea sir. Coffee communicates seriousness.
If the programe is in English more people would uderstand. I personally do not understand any Indic language but I suspect something valuable is being said.. In passing, on a purely Pakistan Islamism: Pakistan cavorts with the largest, most powerful idolatrous and atheistic state in the world and allows it to gain influence and financial profit from PaKistan. Allah will certainly chastise Pakistan as is being done now until this Pak-China relationship straigthens out and Pak stops supporting athesism and idolitry.
His diagnostics are spot on but solutions provided by him are at best stupid.
COYG!
Brilliant and insightful.
Would like to point out that lack of credibility started with Imran when program went of track THREE times.
In Dec 2019, 2nd tranche wasn't approved (it is wrong to say pause was due to COVID since this predates COVID), April 2021 where PTI reneged on the agreement one day after receiving tranches 2,3,4,5 and also changed the finance minister and finally in Feb 2022 when barely a couple of weeks after receiving the 6th tranche PTI reneged and instead of increasing prices as per agreement, actually reduced prices.
Disagree with Miftah's so called helplessness as FM. Manmohan Singh in 1991-96 period is said to have had a typed resignation letter in his pocket. He was clear that he wanted the role only if he was empowered. Very sad of course that as PM he did not show similar intellectual integrity and turned a blind eye to a lot of stuff simply so as to continue getting the power and prestige of being PM of India.
Mind you in December 2017 when Miftah depreciated currency from 105 to 110 he said that rupee was absolutely correctly priced - something he knew was false. Eventually by the time he left in May 2018, he left it at 115 which was still highly overvalued. At that time SKA was PM and unlike Shehbaz Sharif had totally empowered Miftah. But he did not let rupee find its value. If coyrse correction had started in October 2017 when Miftah first became SAPM and then FM, the serious CAD situation of June end 2018 could have been averted.
But he did not do that. Miftah may not be financially corrupt since he is independently wealthy. But he has been willing to not speak up, if that gave him the power and prestige of the FM post.
Why are you on a Pakistani Channel?
@@blackrockorange Pakistani economy is a very good case study for economics students. Even in our semester we got an assignment for countries with severe circular debt and vicious cycle of financing problems and since Pakistani economy is the perfect example so it is really insightful. Good day 👍🏻
@@blackrockorangeit is the best entertainment for Indians who have experienced 1000 cuts of your corrupt evil army elites. We are eating Popcorn and enjoying Pakistan's gradual demise and disintegration. Karma is a bitch!! Justice for innocent victims and minorities in East Punjab and Kashmir.
Uzair Yunus opnely supports PMLN and is anti PTI.. You can look at his previous podcasts..
Maybe he eats biryani and beneficiary of corrupt system
@@zeeshanbutt3468 Yes for sure. I heard he takes money from PMLN strategic cell to spread their propaganda in USA
@Football-Pundit Spoken like a true patwari.
@Football-Pundit A patwari brain is worse than a donkey brain. A 6.5% growth economy which happened in Imran Khan's tenure is bad but a negative 2% growth and an economy that has defaulted in wonderful under PDM.
@Football-Pundit Patwari logic. Dollar 179 Rs bad under IK Dollar Rs 300 good under Shebaz. Petrol Rs140 bad under IK Petrol Rs 300 good under Shebaz... mashallah what a brain.
Imran Khan zindabad. Throw this important government, call for fresh elections. And bring Imran Khan with better mandate. He will solve all problems of the country.
Question - Why is Pakistan so desperate to avoid the default. Why can't they do a organised default like Argentina? Pakistani debt is huge and they will keep struggling, it is better to a default and start over. The key would be to avoid chaotic default like SriLanka.
How can this happen......it's unbelievable
Every thing is possible in pak 🙏
Dar has damaged the economy much more than Mifta. Shahbaz Sharif has been a total disaster. Very sad state indeed 😢
Someone in this podcast had broken screen. Initially I thought it was mine
Certainly Ali Khizar is best in his communication about the problem but one thing is clear your rupee will weak for a long time.
This interest based economy must end. Sood ka nizam haram hai. We should stop paying these usurious interests to these dirty international money lenders.
@@blackrockorange lets go back in your CAVE
@@deepeshbajpai8543 Deepu bhai, I am just trolling Paxtan
Ali Khizar sb opinions are like Diwanay ka khwab !
Feel sad when I watch patriotic Pakistanis going through this economic crisis of their country.
You people are miftah apologist. Yes he is from karachi as you both are and you have kinship but still. The man doesn't know what he is doing. Why do they have to change the government in the first place it was 1.5 years left. If 10 rupee subcidie on petrol was given why not removed in April. Why in May. And petrol price were high then but they fall for quite some time now. Don't lie. Don't do selective journalism.