Ukraine will 'become untenable' for Putin as air defence fails to stop attacks | Chip Chapman
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- The failure of Putin's S-300 and S-400 air defences has put Crimea at risk for Russia says Maj. Gen. Chip Chapman speaking to Kate Gerbeau on Frontline.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
What Russia has done to Ukraine and to its people and CHILDREN is beyond horrific, devoid of any and all morality, humanity, and empathy.
What about what the US and Ukraine have done to the Ukrainian people? Are you unaware of that also? Is it intellectual dishonesty or simply stupidity? Gullibility and naïveté still hold too many people hostage.
On the contrary, comparatively speaking, Russia has waged this military conflict in one the most _humane_ ways possible.
@@livingtribunal4110 😂
@@livingtribunal4110 Stolen 10,000+ Ukrainian children to Russify them? Attacked civilian district heating plants adjacent to the flats they heat and thereby killing civilians with their inaccurate weapons (AS-4/KH-22, Shahad), attacking domestic natural gas supplies and power stations to terrorise people with hypothermia, damaged 1500 civilian medical facilities, committed atrocities such as beheadings and castration on POW, shelling cities to obliteration like they did in Chechnya where they killed 250,000 civilians in the two wars, using White phosphorus on cities? Russia started this war, they cheered Putin on. All the deaths from this war are on Russia.
@@livingtribunal4110🤯
General Thank you for your insight and for your beautiful service.
Never mind Putin, Russians have to stand up to their regime and just go home.
Never happen. Most Russians are too poor to travel outside of Russia and don't know how poorly they live. The Russian people have been brainwashed.
To be fair most are conscripts who would be shot if they desert
To i jeste bio cilj zapada,zapad se malo prevario.Rusija nije Libija,Irak,Sirija,Srbija..
Zapad je u panici zbog saveza Rusije i Sjeverne Koreje.😂😂
@@tariredom7615Oh how nice, another one of Putin’s useful fools. Shrilling for Putin and not even getting paid. 😂😂
But they won't. They are zombified sheeple who have never known freedom of expression and democracy. Living in a vile dictatorship is normal for them. So they close their eyes, ears and minds to what's going on around them and just hope it doesn't impact them.
A pleasure to listen to UK general Chip Chapman❤🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Kate Gerbeau is such a good interviewer 🙂
She is a real pro at what she does. She actually lets her guest respond in full to her questions. Very rare indeed these days. I hope she teaches journalism somewhere. It is much needed. Bravo, Kate!!
Shabo
Quite comprehensive analysis! Masterful moderation to enhance it! Thanks for sharing, indeed!
Kind of like how Zelensky was a comedian....and turned Rusha' into one big joke☺
please STOP the headline introduction. its unnecessary and irritating.
I’ve learnt to skip it but yes I agree 🤷♂️very annoying
Very very irritating.
Agree wholeheartedly!
Agree
Totally agree
Russian Cities should have a taste of what Ukrainian Cities have gone through !
maybe then Putins people will actually realise/accept that there IS a war being waged and the destruction caused by their motherland !
Lovely thought
ah like the Americans who push war in the world it is tmps that its change
Osjetili su Rusi u Ukrajini,svakodnevno bombardovanje Dombasa od 2014-2022i onda je Putin rekao sada je dosta.😂
Tražili ste gledajte.
@@tariredom7615disregarding the fact that what you say didn’t actually happen the way you’d love to believe, there would have been no conflict in the Donbas if not for Russia’s fomenting of tensions in Ukraine in the first place
Bomb Moscow,st Petersburg and transnistria
@@doge8825 ignore him, serbs like him are still upset that the west helped Kosovo gain independence. People like him only speak Serbian, but think they have all the objective information and the west is engaged in mass propaganda
Vote Democracy Never Autocracy in America 💙 🇺🇸 🙄!!! Ukraine is so courageous and want Democracy....
So... don't vote since both parties are autocratic despots?
The only way to preserve democracy is to vote against the party of open borders, censorship, weaponizing the legal system.
Trump was the first to give Ukraine weapons. He stopped Putin's pipeline 'Nord Stream 2'. Biden resumed it. Even now, Biden isn't allowing Ukrainians to hit targets on Russian territory, while Russia bombs every place in Ukraine.
Zelensky said 'you're helping us not to lose but you're not allowing us to win'. He's talking about Biden!
Ukrainians are dying for want what America has, and Americans are voting for what Russia has..The irony
Most Ukrainians are dodging the draft. Only a small part of the Ukrainians is courageous enough to fight for their country. The rest are either fleeing or hoping that others will fight for them so they won't suffer from the genocide Putin is going to inflict on their country.
The most corrupt country in the European region definitely does not want democracy 😂
Mom Kate chepao and James Hansen are the best interviewers, journalists of Times radio, and you invited one of the best military and political analyst, really amazing and fascinating much, great podcast as usual, I appreciated mama kate.
Russia will soon know the cost of acting as a Gangster state.
Think WW 2 this will never happen the guy is just waffling. Hot air. The west is finding out already
How long do you suppose that will take? Another 2 years?
@@DavidGitongawriter longer the better…I doubt the Russians general staff has even looked at a calendar.
Russia's top already knows the cost it had to incur.
@@shaddapforever please explain…
Imagine in 1942 the allies being afraid of Germany and Japan losing the war. That's how soft the west has gotten.
The allies had very strong concerns about germany losing the war. Before but obviously especially after the attack on the Soviet union.
US involvement in the European theatre was to ensure post war power balance.
Look for Atlantic Charta
As someone who wholeheartedly supports Ukraine and wants us to do more to support them; we did not have to consider the risk of nuclear war in 1942. We do need to make cautious decisions, but not get caught in a state of paralysis either.
@@Boghopper9999 The US, UK, and NATO caused the destruction of Ukraine.
Took the US just over two years before it decided to join the allies in WW2
It’s probably because of basement noise makers like u. Coca-Cola and pizza general. 😅
What Putin has done reminds me of the scene from the Wizard of OZ when the curtain gets accidentally pulled back and you see an old man working the OZ machine.
Everyone got a look up Russia's skirt and it is smooth as a ken doll.🙃
I'm still laughing at what a joke the rushin' army is😂
I like your turn of phrase.
What is Putin has done reminds me of the invasion of Iraq.
Finally the times has had the professionalism to give the name of their interviewing jounalist (whom they usually ignore). Compliments to Kate Gerbeau.
Excellent reporter, crafted questions designed to inform and not bolster the interviewers ego. First rate.
She da best!!
Thank goodness Kate is back and the two school kids that have been on here of late are back at school
My favourite Times interviewer. One of the best.
She’s the best! She actually lets the guest talk and develop thought. The questions are well crafted, she doest’t ask damn “what about” questions. Well done Kate.
A russian soldier on leave was found dead in st Petersburg with an axe in his back with an attached note saying thanks for your special military operation
Kate Gerbeau is one lovely woman.
Agreed
Agreed, and knowledgeable, and she doesn't interrupt.
We have a hogfarm one of our pigs we have named Putin!
Poor Pig!!!
My wife had a pair of inseparable turkey toms, one all white, the other was bronze, that would patrol the farm, taking turns gobbling at anything that moved. We called them Presidents Biden and Trump.
Svinja te napravila.
@@tariredom7615American speaking Russian 😂 troll.. 🐽
in are polish household we have toilet plunger - vladimir poo tin.
Putin for prison 2024
Excellent interview and knowledgeable guest.
We hear this for 2,5 years, still Russia is grinding forward as they do in each war. Give Ukraine everything they need to end it and recover their territory as recognised in 1991.
......if Ukraine was to reoccupy Crimea, it would put them into a very powerful negotiating position
There won´t _be_ a Ukraine by 2026
Liberating Crimea isn’t about improving Ukraine’s position in peace talks. It is about collapsing support for the Russian regime, thereby causing the full Russian withdrawal from all of Ukraine.
@@blazunlimited Crimea will never be ruled by any regime in Chicken Kiev, ever again!
@@blazunlimitedwell in that case you’re losing hands down. This guy is no expert.
@@blazunlimited Quite right.
The war is returning to where it was in September when Ukraine destroyed Russia's Black Sea Fleet.
Chip Chapman is an insightful and articulate speaker. Well done 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
The kerch bridge is coming down .
Eastern Ukraine will become Russian Federation forever
@@eyaklen4804is a Chinese bot.
@@eyaklen4804 😂
Then so will the Dnipro dam in response.
@@Jimmy-ye3wg is a 3 week old Kremlin kleptomaniac bot.
What is more shocking is the mostly ineffective Russian air defense. Over the last month Russian air defense has simply collapsed.
Sort of like the uranian army lol
@@lockk132 Dream on, Ivan!
Their army is collapsing, as well. It took a week to claim part of a city block in Vochansk. Russia's military has lost 534,000 soldiers to date--and Russian males are escaping their country any way they can. The ruble is shot, 1 US dollar is worth 90 Rubles. Their economy is falling off a cliff.
Great interview. Spot on, re: Give Ukraine what they need.
The proper management
They need people
@@andrewtlk Huh? Like Russia recruits Indians and Somali under false pretense?
Crimea was, is and should belong to Ukraine. 🙏Ukrainians. Ukraine can stop this madness man .
Since the truck bomb went off on the Kerch bridge setting a fuel train on fire on the rail bridge weakening it Russia has had to limit the weight of trains passing over it relying on ferries to transport heavy equipment. Russia has recently started to use the Kerch bridge more for logistics so taking it out soon would be advantageous.
the inability of Putin to stick to an agreement is the major problem....his agreement dance is sign and break, sign and break.
There is no possibility of an agrement with Putin or Russia itself. Both are totally untrustworthy both on the basis of history and character.
Ukraine will need NATO membership, that is the only guarantee.
Putins requrment for peace negotiations are 1 Ukraine to withdraw from Kerson, Luhanansk, Donbas and Zapporizia. 2 NATO withdraw from Eastern Europe and the Baltics (this weeks speech he demanded that) 3 That Ukraine be weakly armed 4 That the Government in Kyiv be changed to a pro Russian one (he calls this denazification) 5 That Ukraine never be in NATO.
Once Ukraine is weak he will invade again. No respect must be given to Russia for its 'sphere of influence' claims.
They would call it looking after their interests.
and putler the butcher's latest ploy is total disdain for UN resolutions related to NoKo
@@snmr1318 then maybe you can go and arrest him. Also this why learning real history is important?
Making false comparisons makes one look terribly silly.
Putin se pridržavao Minskog sporazuma.
Zapad je prevario Putina sa sporazumom samo da bi dobio na vremenu da naoruža Ukrajinu.
Merkelova je to javno priznala.
Više Rusi nisu naivni.
Tražili ste gledajte.😂
Chip Chap! That's not me being disrespectful, it's me being excited to see & hear this guy, especially after some of these more recent guests.....
I'm a bit disappointed in them only inviting Chit-Chat and not also General Gossip and not least Colonel Sanders who is especially good at roasting the Russian enemy when they chicken out.
Times Radio, thank you very much. It's a great pleasure to listen to your podcasts and your sound settings seem fixed. Thank you for that.
Thank you bot!!!
@@JohnnyWindyBoy I am not a bot. I am real person and I provided some feedback on their sound settings which they seem to have fixed, but you seem to be an anxious person making hasty conclusions.
Times Frontline sets the gold standard on conducting interviews. ❤️💙
Very informative... &. Well Done !!....(as usual)
Ukraine drones' done well, Russia tanks disappeared
Putin’s next parade has five tanks😂😂😂😂😂
Very interesting interview but I'm left with the feeling that I wish there were more Kate Gerbeaus in the world. To have a lovely lady like her on my street would be nice!
You do know she sleeps with black men, right?
There's lots of lovely ladies just like she is, you'd be surprised.
@@forttottenrocks Yeah but unfortunately not on my street. I married one but now I'm widowed. Very, very few unattached. Most are horrible.
Chip! The man!
Very good interview & host.
Slava Ukraini
Heroiam Slava
]\\
Vova should've stuck to driving Taxis because he's a useless President and an even worst wartime leader.
Not to mention the entire planet laughing at the Rushin' military😅
The word is worse, no worst.
@@dwighthuth1171 Vovchansk is free and Crimea is on fire.
Russia has so few S-500 systems it will be easy to take them out in Crimea. Allegedly only one is there that can be easily oversaturated.
possible in theory, but you think its out there by itself? i think such a location is likely to have the full range of russian air defense assets standing between those systems and the ukrainians.
@@operator9858most of the Russian assets have been deteriorated meanwhile. And the s-300 and s-400 have been proven quite ineffective. Crimea is exposed and eventually it will be cut off from supplies.
The analysts said that the Russian S-500 is only fabulous on paper. Seems the designers were pulling a Russian--swearing that their weapons were superior, while trying to avoid the consequences to turning over a handful of junk to the military.
Run Russians run for your lives
As someone from the U.S., I really want us all to stop. All of us.
You would not say that if he had invaded Maine and kidnaped your children.
Just be grateful the fighting does not yet involve your children. Your comfort is at risk in the near future, unless you wake up.
GREAT guest, great insight.
God! I love Kate. ❤❤
Love your interviews.
When you allow all these men to leave Russia, then where are these people who will rise up against their government?! It has always seemed to me to be insanity that we would allow any Russian people who don't like what's happening or don't want to fight, to find refuge. How many millions have escaped now that could have added mass to the opposition?
Brilliant reporter. Welcome back.
Excellent interview about the present situation and insightful comments about what now needs to be done
Outstanding interview
very good analysis thank you, hi from turkey
Слава Україні! 💙
Героям слава! 💛
Да уколись что ли чем? Тебя тупо колбасит
@@gwinbleys1586 Not as slow as you apparently are.
And another great interview! The RF is grinding down. His Axis supporters are turning away! Will it end soon! Stay tuned... 🙏🙏
Slava Ukraini 🇬🇧 ♥️ 🇺🇦
I like Kate Gerbeau, she asks some right questions. At the 25:15 mark Ms. Gerbeau asks the question, "How is the Ukrainian conscription, training of new soldiers coming along?"
The air superiority battle, which is more an artillery contest, could be used by Ukraine. Instead of shelling tree lines, they might plant explosives in prime locations the Russians want, then could retreat and blow that line after the enemy reinforces it's position. Keeping the Russians busy while nibbling at the reinforcement and protecting the Ukrainian forces.
Take you come from the same school of thought as Chip.
Chip is one of the world's elite knowledge of warfare modern and old . I take his word as gospel
I strongly disagree. Chapman is chiefly responsible for transforming the UK military into a hollow force. It will be a surprise to no one inside defence that a senior US general has told Ben Wallace, the defence secretary, that the British Army is no longer regarded as a tier one force and is barely tier two, alongside the likes of Germany, Italy and Belgium.
Why play a bit of the interview at the beginning, then we hear it again a few minutes later? So annoying!
“Always seek to gather word about your enemy and his disposition but beware and never accept information from anyone named Chip” - Sun Tzu
Why don't these experts just say: Too little - too late !!!
It's not necessary that the systems are not working but probably more to do with the people using them.
Nah… Nothing Russia does works well. Some things may be barely adequate but in a direct competition with the best there is they lose.
Territories don't become "untenable" - *Ideas* do - like the notion of *occupying* a territory.
👎
The difficulty I have is really knowing if Europe/NATO has enough strength.
😆 wow
Just for information: The USA has delivered ONE Patriot system to Ukraine. Although they have at least 60. Germany has delivered 2 out of 7 existing systems and bought an additional system that will be delivered directly to Ukraine.
I've missed Chip's Bee pillows...
Great aren't they? Those ones Chip has are from Marks and Spencer.
Cushions 😊
Yes indeed!
WASP confirmed 😂
They fired 11 ATACMs . One got through . This is the man who said the Ukraine offensive would succeed in taking back Crimea
USER ID @user-ft2bt9kw7x IS A DUD ACCOUNT, THERE IS NO INDIVIDUAL BEHIND THIS ACCOUNT. EXPECT THIS ACCOUNT TO BE SPREADING RUSSIAN LIES AND OTHER SUCH NONSENSE.
Thank you guys 4 not mentioning Poland's help 4 Ukraine🎉🎉🎉🎉
God Bless Poland and Ukraine !
The orcs hordes are out tonight again. 😂
💙Slava ukraini 💛🇺🇦🇺🇸
I can't see how Russia is going to defend its heating/electricity infrastructure in the upcoming winter. Ukraine can get support from allies; Russia need to manage that on it's own.
This is a joke, right?
Ukraine will be too busy scrambling to replace its own as the entire population is literally without electricity and gas supplies when their facilities were destroyed beyond repair.
what you just said is nonsense
@russellspeed1693 What is the joke? There has been at least one oildepot/refinery strike per day the last 40 days. The Russian airdefence is not only useless but being actively targeted, but the energy infrastructure is even more dispersed. When the oil infrastructure has been worn down, Ukraine will switch to hit energy during the fall/winter.
@Jimmy-ye3wg I don't say Ukraine won't have a harsh winter, but the war is existential for them. Please explain why the Ukrainians can't target Russian energy infrastructure if their own is damaged?
The problem with these interviews with these way back in time military guys or “global strategic” guys is that you can go back a listen to them over a year ago and absolutely nothing has changed.
always saying the same ,
How many times in the last 2 years?
Send in 007!!!
Thanks Baghdad Bob 😅
Excellent ... Just 3 points would be wordy of a mention ..
Status of the nuclear plant,
Potential impact of North Korea involvement and
The 'backdoor' involvement of China
Thank you ..
The more I listen to these so called experts the more I realise I made the right decision leaving the military... The invasion was not Puntin´s decision alone so how would Puntinś departure holt the advance?
Arthur Reti says that Russia is moving air defence units from the Finland and Baltic and Far East front. Is this true. If it was true it means that Russia is running out of air defence units
They've been losing 1 air defense system a day for the past month.
Read Crimea for Ukraine in the title.
World must be ended. Because fools are having power
Please debate this with Colonel Douglas Macgregor or former Marine Scott Ritter.
🇺🇦🇬🇧
Putin the greatest JOKE in history
Right next to Trumpty Dumpty.
Chapman's only demonstrated senior military skill was transforming the UK Army into a hollow force. It will be a surprise to no one inside defence that a senior US general has told Ben Wallace, the defence secretary, that the British Army is no longer regarded as a tier one force and is barely tier two, alongside the likes of Germany, Italy and Belgium.
How would you rated the Ukrainian army in Feb 2022 ?
Anyone know the benefit of not stopping Russia ?
Putin is more concerned about keeping the war going to save his own skin because if he stops now 1 million battle hardened Russians armed to the back teeth will come for HIM.
@@Nobody-You-Know The Russian sanctions are NEVER going to be lifted and Putin destroyed the Nordstream. Like a jealous lover he decided "If I can't use it , nobody can". I wish America did do it because that'd be cool thing to do and MISSION ACCOMPLISHED but they didn't.
There isn't one
Full employment in the West - 20 roubles a week, travel to Siberia and free shovel and cabbage allowance included.
They need to be stopped, put in their place and Dictator VP needs to go
Recruiting people 🤣
🥊🤜🥊🤜🥊🤜🥊🤜
I am looking for a Bearskin rug, I reckon I should be able to buy one from Ukraine soon - Slava Ukraini 🟦🟨
No pressure on Putin no progress very simple
I believe the failed General is commanding the kharkiv offensive, well, he's about to fail again
they might charge again
Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
I have Always noticed his throw Pillows Behind him, do they call him Chip Bumblebee chapman.🙃
"Big Stinger Energy" as the youths would say
I think it's the Manchester bee
22 Ukraine cities, Ukraine needs 22 patriot defense systems to sustain war and stop Russian knocking out power of Ukraine
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hold the emojis. The US is redirecting Patriot Missile Systems from other countries to Ukraine.
@@QuietRefl4378 Yeah, I am laughing 😆 because of that!!!!
@@LukVik Well, only one emoji this time. Maybe it wasn't quite as funny?
@@QuietRefl4378 Yeah, Russian bots 🤖 always repeats the same lies!!! Maybe Putin is out of cash 💵 to pay them and they don’t accept potatoes 🥔 as payment 😞!!!
How much analyzing must be done on a captured turtle tank? Perhaps a private can take a look at it and report to the Drone operators😂 jamming equipment aside, it's not a sophisticated piece of kit, at least not as of yet
What is a “marked time offensive”?
Picture the red coats in the 18th century marching to the front line to fight, and you've got the visual. Sometimes its called "quick march"
@@icu17siberia thanks!
Thanks, General Chapman, for your realistic, truthful analysis. Slava Ukraini!
😂🤣😂🤦🏽♂️🥴🤡
I saw the title and thought about Ben Hodges. Maybe next time.
S-500 systems (multiple vehicles) cost $2.5billion .......... ATACMS cost per missile $1.2m (ish). worth a missile or 10 if they can find it.
They've had the s500 in crimea since june 13, b/c everything else was destroyed obviously things change on a daily basis so I wouldn't be so confident while also being ill-informed
Would that fascist pro-Russian parrot happen to be Nigel Farage?
That it be my guess !
That would be most neo fascists... Including Trump..
Great interviews often! Please stop w/ the silly introduction (the pre-interview sample at the start). Just start the interview.