this saddens me. sex really do sell, and aoa proved it. no im not a hater, i actually love aoa and knew them from miniskirt and like a cat. and then i learned this aoa black and wow, they really do have talent. they are playing the instruments live and its sounds so pure and real. its just that people dont appreciate this kind of thing compared to the sexy aoa. i would choose this rockband over the other. i wish more people would appreciate this kind of stuff. mina's bass is killing me though 😎😍 help!
You look at mina and she looks like a quiet little pipsqueak, and then she picks up her bass guitar and starts playing and suddenly everything you thought about the world is wrong
she's making music with a new band now! they're called 'banduni' and they have some pretty great songs (she also has her drum cover channel which is really cute)
I am forever mad at how underrated AOA black was treated until they finally dissapeared quietly. Choa looked like she enjoyed performing with her guitar a lot😭
How many K-Pop (or any Pop) groups could even form a sub-unit like this and actually sound good? It was a unique concept and it really deserved more life than it got.
So happy to hear them perform with live instruments, although I think the mixing can be done better, the bass & keyboard seems to be more prominent than guitar, and I don't hear Choa's guitar as well. Choa's vocal is amazing as usual and Jimin is so serious :)
no offense, but you can clearly hear and see them playing the guitar in the second chorus 1:54(Choa) and 2:07(Jimin). Don't just listen and watch the video but also pay attention on how they play the instruments. :) Well, for the mixing.. I dunno know, maybe it was just how the sound was captured for this video or as you have said "bad mixing". hahaha For me this video is more than enough.
hrbrt14 I'm not saying that they are not playing but the guitar sound for the most part is kinda drawn out by the bass sound. Usually bass is the lowest sound and hardest to pick up in live band, but here it's overshadowing the 2 guitars. That's why I said it's bad mixing, not their fault though.
10 років тому+1
For me I like the bass to be wide in the mix.. but not drowning out the Guitar sounds.
+hrbrt14 1:54 that's Jimin. You can clearly hear Choa's guitar at 0:25, 0:28 and 0:32. The guitar sounds starting at 0:39 is Jimin's. She's the lead guitarist. Choa's the second guitarist so it's harder to pick up the sound of her guitar.
she wanted to be lead everything that when someone gets attention she starts hating them....specially if she thinks they dont deserve the attention lol
단순히 섹시컨셉의 댄스 걸그룹인줄 알았던 AOA가 밴드 퍼포먼스가 가능한 뮤지션인줄 7년전의 두 라이브영상을 보고 처음알고 충격을 금치못하고 있으며 AOA자체를 다시보게 되었습니다. 일본 Scandal 저리가라할 카리스마를 가지셨는데 아쉽습니다. 근데 get out은 이 영상이 단연 최고네요.
초아: 투과력 있는 보이스, 기타 백킹 유경: 탄탄한 기본기와 화려한 드럼 연주 유나: 초아 같은 투과력은 없지만 여린 음색의 탄탄한 보컬과 건반 서포트 민아: 안정적인 베이스 연주, 기존에 악기를 다루지 않았음에도 불구하고 기타: 랩을 하고 기타를 메고 있지만, 리드 또는 리듬 기타의 역할을 수행하지 못해 밴드 사운드가 비게 되는 주요원인, 밴드 내에서 최소 한 사람의 몫 이상을 해내는 다른 멤버들과 달리 70~80% 정도의 잉여
awesome as ever!! the bass was more louder sometimes but it's fine and and it's really clean. and jimin's playing really well! she's awesome!!!! i really love her rap
AOA has technically 2 subunits called AOA Black and AOA White. AOA White has 7 members who dance and sing. AOA Black has 5 members (4 members who are also part of AOA White and 1 members who is known as a "1/2 angel" because she's only in the band as the drummer) who play together as a band.
@@sonnimonni2482exactly.. What I mean by rock is not the classic heavy hard rock. It is the much lighter version of rock.. But what I'm trying to point is that for me, AOA is better as a band concept than a dancing girl group
Pinky Lam she's playing the hell out of that bass, that's kinda what happens when other musicians aren't playing very loud. Choa is strumming a string so yea she won't be heard.
Good performance but can barely hear choa's guitar the keyboard and bass shadows the guitars, I'm so happy to say that, haters! yep! They do play instuments live! Wew in your face!!
Of course not, sexy dancing is... well, sexy. :) But I have to say, I first heard about them because of Miniskirt and then Confused. I liked it, but I didn't give them too much credit in terms that they seemed to be just some cute faces among the torrent of k-pop artists out there today. However, I started digging out some stuff on them and, when I found, for the first time, them playing live, I was so impressed! They aren't just a bunch of beautiful faces shaking their booty like in those 2 first songs I mentioned -- they can also play their own stuff! That's when I started taking them more seriously and appreciate them for the true artists that they are. :) (Ps.: Don't get me wrong, I don't mean that those who can only dance are less worth artistically or anything like that -- it's just that when you see multi-talented people like them, it really blows you away -- weil, me, at least!)
![[#나혼자산다] 고강도 운동 클라이밍이 취미?! 피지컬 갓벽 지치지 않는 에너자이저 설현🔥 | #김설현 #배우 MBC240209방송](/img/n.gif)
유일한 걸밴드가 될수 있었는데...참 아깝다 그나저나 민아가 젤 놀랍네그냥 예쁘게만 생긴줄 알았는데 베이스 대박~!!!
저도 놀랬네요..베이스....
베이스 잘하는듯
Mina's bass's so amazing!!
I don't mind that the bass is so loud, get to hear Mina more
That bassist
That's Mina for ya~ :D
dunno what's better, the fact that they're wearing Confused costumes while playing instruments, or the fact that they're ACTUALLY playing instruments
this saddens me. sex really do sell, and aoa proved it. no im not a hater, i actually love aoa and knew them from miniskirt and like a cat. and then i learned this aoa black and wow, they really do have talent. they are playing the instruments live and its sounds so pure and real. its just that people dont appreciate this kind of thing compared to the sexy aoa. i would choose this rockband over the other. i wish more people would appreciate this kind of stuff.
mina's bass is killing me though 😎😍 help!
You look at mina and she looks like a quiet little pipsqueak, and then she picks up her bass guitar and starts playing and suddenly everything you thought about the world is wrong
han gyujin's 😢 😔
유경이 드럼 치는 모습 언제 봐도 멋지네요🤗👍
The whole band is incredible! Mina such a good player.
thats how it is supposed to be, i mean the bass.. hell yeah..
I want them back! YOU HEAR THAT FNC! WE WANT AOA BLACK BACK!!!
+sophia dls theyre suppposed to make a comeback later this year
Julian Ka Really?! I'll look forward to it
Was there an official statement or is it just rumors? I hope its true because I live for AOA black
I feel bad for Youkyoung, basically gets dumped for the AOA sexy dance concept.
Yuna is so talented
she's making music with a new band now! they're called 'banduni' and they have some pretty great songs (she also has her drum cover channel which is really cute)
I am forever mad at how underrated AOA black was treated until they finally dissapeared quietly. Choa looked like she enjoyed performing with her guitar a lot😭
How many K-Pop (or any Pop) groups could even form a sub-unit like this and actually sound good? It was a unique concept and it really deserved more life than it got.
I like Youkyung's whole demeanour while playing.
We need more Mina + Bass!
AMAZING congrats AOA Black I'm waiting for your comeback soon, I love them, this is daebak
100프로 생라이브임.. AR안깜 .. 대박 아이돌밴드가 생라이브라니.. 진짜 대박이 아닐수 없다
MinA play bass guitar so well 🥺
I hope someday I have chance to see her play it again.
Where you all right
Choa is so super talented. Mina rocking the bass
So happy to hear them perform with live instruments, although I think the mixing can be done better, the bass & keyboard seems to be more prominent than guitar, and I don't hear Choa's guitar as well. Choa's vocal is amazing as usual and Jimin is so serious :)
no offense, but you can clearly hear and see them playing the guitar in the second chorus 1:54(Choa) and 2:07(Jimin). Don't just listen and watch the video but also pay attention on how they play the instruments. :) Well, for the mixing.. I dunno know, maybe it was just how the sound was captured for this video or as you have said "bad mixing". hahaha For me this video is more than enough.
hrbrt14 I'm not saying that they are not playing but the guitar sound for the most part is kinda drawn out by the bass sound. Usually bass is the lowest sound and hardest to pick up in live band, but here it's overshadowing the 2 guitars. That's why I said it's bad mixing, not their fault though.
For me I like the bass to be wide in the mix.. but not drowning out the Guitar sounds.
+hrbrt14 1:54 that's Jimin. You can clearly hear Choa's guitar at 0:25, 0:28 and 0:32. The guitar sounds starting at 0:39 is Jimin's. She's the lead guitarist. Choa's the second guitarist so it's harder to pick up the sound of her guitar.
our angels really did a great job with live instrument!
always support them :D
yeahh live instrument and mina so cute
Korea no. 1 girl group band
Drummer rocks! Yuna wow!
Youkyung is the drummer
rapper as lead guitarist too? how awesome is that.
Jimin is the gifted musician of the group. Seems like she does a lot of producing / songwriting.
she wanted to be lead everything that when someone gets attention she starts hating them....specially if she thinks they dont deserve the attention lol
well, it's not like she's playing amazing solos haha
Choaaaa really really love your voice on this part
보고싶다 초아야
초아가 보고 시퍼요. AOA블랙일때 최고였는데....
이거 노래 너무 좋은데. 계속들어도 좋네요. AOA밴드 다시보고싶네요..
베이스가 미쳤다 ㅜ ㅜ
단순히 섹시컨셉의 댄스 걸그룹인줄 알았던 AOA가 밴드 퍼포먼스가 가능한 뮤지션인줄 7년전의 두 라이브영상을 보고 처음알고 충격을 금치못하고 있으며 AOA자체를 다시보게 되었습니다. 일본 Scandal 저리가라할 카리스마를 가지셨는데 아쉽습니다. 근데 get out은 이 영상이 단연 최고네요.
초아: 투과력 있는 보이스, 기타 백킹
유경: 탄탄한 기본기와 화려한 드럼 연주
유나: 초아 같은 투과력은 없지만 여린 음색의 탄탄한 보컬과 건반 서포트
민아: 안정적인 베이스 연주, 기존에 악기를 다루지 않았음에도 불구하고
기타: 랩을 하고 기타를 메고 있지만, 리드 또는 리듬 기타의 역할을 수행하지 못해 밴드 사운드가 비게 되는 주요원인, 밴드 내에서 최소 한 사람의 몫 이상을 해내는 다른 멤버들과 달리 70~80% 정도의 잉여
근데 이거 지민 논란떠서 그런게 아니라 진짜 그럼ㅋㅋ
초아 기타소리가 들라니ㅏ요ㅠㅠㅠ저 왜 잘 안들리죵
김윤정 기타 백킹은 주로 코드를 짚기 때문에 볼륨을 작게 해요. 잘 들어보면 코드 치는 소리 들려요.
@@BulletTaxi001 아하 그렇군뇽ㅠㅠ콘서트 영상 보면 간간히 들리는데 여기서는 너무 안들려서 적어봤습니답! 들리긴 들리는군뇽!
잉 제기준엔 지민 기타치는거 딱히 부족함 없었던듯.... 기타소리 잘들리는디 음 안틀리고
I remember that I love this song back then.
초아 노래하는 모습이 그립네요. 돌아와요
Youkyung is so cute haha
awesome as ever!! the bass was more louder sometimes but it's fine and and it's really clean. and jimin's playing really well! she's awesome!!!! i really love her rap
choa is really great as a rocker voice lol
Still watching and loving this band version of aoa... I want to see you again as a band aoa! :) love you guys!!!
다시 밴드의 모습으로!!!!
뒤늦게 알아서 아쉽고 미안한 무대네요... 욕심이겠지만 다시 보고싶다
악기 연주하면서 노래하고
볼때마다 멋지다💕💕
초아는 롹밴드 보컬인 게 어울린다.. 김윤아 버금갈 수 있었는데 다시 돌아와줘!!
QWER가 대세가 된걸 보고 AOA블랙 라이브 영상 생각나서 또 와봄.. 안타깝고 아쉽기도 하네요.. 저비주얼들과 실력으로 지금 활동 했으면 어땠을까 하는 생각이네요
베이스랑 드럼소리 소리 좋당 기타소리 너무 안들려
유명균 이거 핸드싱크 아닌거에요?
@@JOjh1025 밴드 라이브예여 핸드싱크 아님
Imagine mina playing bass again
초아 일류가수다
Thanks for the HD uploaded AOA band performance! That's so cooool!
The prettiest bassist in the world
sure but for the money, Tomomi of Scandal is the prettiest bassist in the world
쵸아언니 너무 보고싶다ㅠㅠ
AOA has technically 2 subunits called AOA Black and AOA White. AOA White has 7 members who dance and sing. AOA Black has 5 members (4 members who are also part of AOA White and 1 members who is known as a "1/2 angel" because she's only in the band as the drummer) who play together as a band.
음악방송에서는 핸드싱크만 나와서 라이브 안되는 줄 알았는데 생각보다 잘했었구나.. 아쉽네
진짜..볼때마다 울고싶다..
Jimin is so serious . hahahaha xD
i seriously love AOA Black wayyyyyyyyyy more...............
live instrument !!!!
but.. bad mixing
whatever always love them
The drummer rocks!
Wow they are so cool
Especially jimin.....
베이스 살아 움직이네
bass is so loud but i like it lol
이런 애들을 벗겨서 외모로 줄세우기 하니까 당연히 밀리지 ㅜㅜ 악기연주할 때의 미모로 따지면 트와이스 이길 거 같네~ 노래 100번째 듣는 중. 아이돌 노래를 100번이나 듣는 경우는 없지 않어?
진짜 너무 멋져요오
No joking, AOA looks better as a rock band.. Not that they bad as a girl group, they're a great girl group but the rock band concept somehow just fits
maybe rock band is the general term but I don't think the music is rock in today's music, it's like is maroon 5 rock?
@@sonnimonni2482exactly.. What I mean by rock is not the classic heavy hard rock. It is the much lighter version of rock.. But what I'm trying to point is that for me, AOA is better as a band concept than a dancing girl group
They are so cool!AoA jjang=)there instrument is live
AOA Black please return!!
jeans plus sneakers plus casual outfit will be better for this kind of AOA performance, but still it is awesome!!!
Apik iki...
kandani..iki K-Pop lho. Gak semua K-Pop cuma gerak dan lagu lhoo
Nek gabung KAro Cn blue Keren Kali yo
they had to dance after that and there was no time so yeah
finally found one with plugged instrument!
퀸덤에서 진짜 벤드 한번만 보여주면 안 돼요ㅠㅠ? 민아랑 유경은 불으면 우정출연은 할 수 있는것 같은데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
우정은 개뿔..
@@user-li7pm5rl7v ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋ ㅁㅊ
초아 노래도 개잘부르는데 기타도 잘침 사기캐야
Their vocals tho!
omg that bass Mio! I mean Mina
I LOVE MINA!!!
me to
After all that happens.. I WANT TO SEE MINA IN BASS AND CHOA ON GUITAR.. AND MISS DRUMMER BACK
Although I like how the bass is loud (since I play bass myself) it kinda really drowns out the guitars D:
well, actually, more like we can't hear Choa's guitar
Pinky Lam i think they could turn the volume of the drums up slightly too
Pinky Lam she's playing the hell out of that bass, that's kinda what happens when other musicians aren't playing very loud. Choa is strumming a string so yea she won't be heard.
i still want them back 😭😭😭
Good performance but can barely hear choa's guitar the keyboard and bass shadows the guitars, I'm so happy to say that, haters! yep! They do play instuments live! Wew in your face!!
Aw a girl rock band looks really COOLLLLLLLLLLL. I like this new concept of Kpop from FNC. Won't people get tired of sexy dancing?
Of course not, sexy dancing is... well, sexy. :)
But I have to say, I first heard about them because of Miniskirt and then Confused. I liked it, but I didn't give them too much credit in terms that they seemed to be just some cute faces among the torrent of k-pop artists out there today. However, I started digging out some stuff on them and, when I found, for the first time, them playing live, I was so impressed! They aren't just a bunch of beautiful faces shaking their booty like in those 2 first songs I mentioned -- they can also play their own stuff! That's when I started taking them more seriously and appreciate them for the true artists that they are. :)
(Ps.: Don't get me wrong, I don't mean that those who can only dance are less worth artistically or anything like that -- it's just that when you see multi-talented people like them, it really blows you away -- weil, me, at least!)
OMGGGG so touching
와 오랜만에 보러왔는데
지금보니까 현AOA는 하나도 없고 5명 전부 전AOA네
아 밴드도 그립다
To all those people who think they don't play live. Well lookey here.
MINABOYS
Bad mixing? Blame it to sound engineering for this festival not to them:)
정말 잘 했네.. 좀 더 키우지. 얼마나 아까운 밴드냐.
I like both AOA Black band version and the dance version. If only they can perform both.
Reminds me of K-on somehow >
JIMIN CHOA
드럼치는 처자의 실력이 은근 쩌는데요
지민, 초아, 민아.. 너무 멋져.. 사랑해~~
민아 보러 왔어요
i'm back and back again here
겟아웃 영상중에 이게 제일 소름임
bad mixing but still a good performance! (ilu youkyung)
This is what AOA is DIFFERENT from any girl groups....
I love how focused and concentrated Jimin looks, adorable.
Jimin is so cute when she is serious and concentrating on her guitar playing :)
This didn’t age well 😂
@@magsisgayyour comment didn't
2018 7 8 ♡♡♡
That was so good!
omg Choa way sexier this way
Col. Fury can playing guitar cool boss nick
Goghjah cool right? nick fury as leader, there is anna and elsa too in the band....which girl group led by nick fury if it's not aoa?
it makes me want them to watch Alabama Shakes...