youkyung definitely would be. maybe mina. i'm not sure about choa though, since she developed a lot of mental issues (depression, anxiety, and insomnia), but that could have been due in part to the strict idol requirements.
I know your comment is 6 years old, but a lot of idols (maybe not the newer ones) are classically trained and learned lots of instruments. They just don't play as a band.
@@jamesgazeley wow is that true?! that's damn sad tho, classically trained only to be wasted, i don't mind pop idols but that sucks if you're forced to abandon your chops you've worked hard for years, all the musicians need to fight back and start a revolution lol
Fnc should make this kind of girl band instead of dancing girl group which is almost everyone doing it, girl band who play instrument is a way more cool..n can be ayes caching since "none in kpop girl band play instrument" (I'm not really sure about this XD)
thita arema Hey I feel pretty much the same as you about kpop Idols playing their own instruments.I've been searching for and waiting for someone to come along...and now that I finally found them, I'm in love. I can't believe I missed them so completely till now. But I do love the girl kpop singing/dancing groups with all of my heart, but this is indeed w-a-a-a-a-a-a-y cool too. And I would add (gulp) that this tips the scales a bit, in favor of actual musicians.
I agree with you. Me, myself i only know singing/dancing girl group and it's kinda boring now because there are so many girl group debuting every year and doing the same thing. And it is my first time seeing girl group in a band and i find it cool and amazing. Hope to see AOA Black again. =)
Ja Vhenthnh You know, I think that the new group CLC plays as a group. In fact I almost can say it as a fact.They have videos showing them playing in public places as a group.Do a search on Sorn and it will lead you to them. They are/were as good as AOA Black.
Jimin and Choa are unfortunately not playing the guitar. Or I shoud say, whatever is they are playing is not what we're hearing because they're all over the place and not playing the right chords at all. I think that's why they had to let this concept go, but again the drummer and bassist are awesome. Awesome guitar solo at 2:47 that nobody onstage is playing :)
Sad, but true. I don't listen to a lot of other live band performers like CNBlue or FTIsland, but does having the backtracks or something like that normal? I would assume they would play it in case some thing went wrong with the audio/connections/instruments. This still sounded great nonetheless :)
Raxengun having a back track is fine but it shouldn't be your instrument. I think this is just a case of a pop group pretending to be a band. Choa isn't a guitarist so it's more of a prop for her. Jimin can play guitar though.
+Pradigy Musicman them if they playing the guitar, the guitar solo is true that not playing, is that jimin of so much practice suffered an injury and has trouble playing one solo of this magnitude, I think that's why AOA Black have not made their comeback for 3 years to that pass the injury,They are not a "fake band" sorry for my english, my language real is spanish XDD
Milagros Cruz choa cant play guitar. Jimin can play guitar chords I've seen her do that. However she obviously can't and did not play that solo. As a musician who has performed for over 8 years on stage i can tell when someone can't play.
I've been wondering if there's any other girl group like Wonder girls, I'm so happy to learn that they play too, especially since it's my favourite song of theirs :D
I love these girls and they are friggin talented as can be, but GODDAMN do they need to work on balancing their sound. Holy crap you can barely hear the guitars. Its the Yuna, Mina and Youkyung show out there. I guess a dress rehearsal wasn't a thing?
Ai nói bài này mà không live thì lỗ tai có vấn đề... K biết nghe thì đừng cmt... Nhà FNC ban nhạc nào chơi cũng mở nhạc đệm hết nhe b... Nên khi nghe nó giống giả lắm, bass phải banh lỗ tai mà nghe riêng ms nghe đc, còn trống thì gõ nhẹ nó cũng ra tiếng rồi, sao mà giả được :)))) FNC k cho AOA black comeback vì không nổi nhe.. Năm 2014 ra 3 bài hit ngta ms biết AOA là ai.., 2012-13 hỏi ai cũng k biết vì họ chỉ thích nhóm nhạc thôi... =]]]
I think nobody messed up. :O It was a "change key" i think with like broken chords (not sure witH the term). It's done by some just so the song would be unique. Lol. Explain much? But yeah. \m/ I think they did great. 그치? :3
The live mixing isn't good, the guitars are drowned but you should still be able to mark the sound on each upward strum -- at least Jimin's guitar which sounds darker here. I find it hard to make out ChoA's guitar though.
I'm pretty sure this is a fake live instrument, the drums and bass isn't convincing. Take a closer look on how they play the instrument against the sound it produce.
I love these girls and they are friggin talented as can be, but GODDAMN do they need to work on balancing their sound. Holy crap you can barely hear the guitars. Its the Yuna, Mina and Youkyung show out there. I guess a dress rehearsal wasn't a thing?
Mina killed this... She's really good
Probably that was ChoA's happiest time as a band. As we can see how happy she was in the performance.
I wonder if Choa and Mina would still be with them if they kept the band aspect of AOA
Maybe... but already had plans to disband aoa black.. that is why youkyung left..
youkyung definitely would be. maybe mina. i'm not sure about choa though, since she developed a lot of mental issues (depression, anxiety, and insomnia), but that could have been due in part to the strict idol requirements.
Mina left because of bullying
tbh they didnt need Jimin here or anywhere lol
@@shienbabex1341 proof? 😀😀😀 it is already proven that Mina have an issue
damn Mina owned the bass! :3 I'm in love
Why to the begin she dont play the bass but i can here the bas?
@@dermuller6005 slappin da bass mon!
im happy that they played Moya Live. :)
Bring back AoA Black! They are so unique as a band. As a dance group, they're excellent too, but harder to distinguish from all the rest.
that bass line is so pure damn! that's mina for you guys!!!
Yuna looks so happy playing the piano
Mina and Choa looks so happy here :)
Choa is sooo cute and have such a beautifull voice!!! 😻 😻 😻
How much talent and beautifulness!! They're perfect!! 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️
that bass tho daebak
Real musiciens Real Singers Real Artist!!!
ChoA is so beautiful
Who is the bassist ? she looks so cute and awesome playing that base guitar. :)
+erven Adalla That's Kwon Mina
민아언니 베이스 너무 좋다..
Wow mina the bassist❤️
impressed,these girls can play instruments.You don't find that in kpop
i miss this sub unit TT
@@hf_makapan FTIsland, Wonder Girl, CNBlue,N. Flyling, Day6, Marmello and The Rose
@@hf_makapan Marmello and Wonder Girls is Girl Band
I know your comment is 6 years old, but a lot of idols (maybe not the newer ones) are classically trained and learned lots of instruments. They just don't play as a band.
@@jamesgazeley wow is that true?! that's damn sad tho, classically trained only to be wasted, i don't mind pop idols but that sucks if you're forced to abandon your chops you've worked hard for years, all the musicians need to fight back and start a revolution lol
Mina
Why to the begin she dont play the bas but i can here the bas?
베이스치는 민아 왜이렇게 좋냐
Fnc should make this kind of girl band instead of dancing girl group which is almost everyone doing it, girl band who play instrument is a way more cool..n can be ayes caching since "none in kpop girl band play instrument" (I'm not really sure about this XD)
Well, I think your argument dose not work in Korea.
이상우 Too bad but it really dont
thita arema Hey I feel pretty much the same as you about kpop Idols playing their own instruments.I've been searching for and waiting for someone to come along...and now that I finally found them, I'm in love.
I can't believe I missed them so completely till now.
But I do love the girl kpop singing/dancing groups with all of my heart, but this is indeed w-a-a-a-a-a-a-y cool too.
And I would add (gulp) that this tips the scales a bit, in favor of actual musicians.
I agree with you. Me, myself i only know singing/dancing girl group and it's kinda boring now because there are so many girl group debuting every year and doing the same thing. And it is my first time seeing girl group in a band and i find it cool and amazing. Hope to see AOA Black again. =)
Ja Vhenthnh You know, I think that the new group CLC plays as a group. In fact I almost can say it as a fact.They have videos showing them playing in public places as a group.Do a search on Sorn and it will lead you to them.
They are/were as good as AOA Black.
mina is my bias :D
They are great playing musical instruments.... let em continue this style which looks so cool and more classical.
AOA Black 그립다........
Reminds me of a cartoon back in the 70s called Josie and the Pussycats.
Curtis Seebaran Yes!!! I still remember watching that in the 90s tho. :)
이때도 아오아언니들 노래했는데 💓 잘돼서 기분져아여
i just love the way jimin rapps ♥
La voz de JI-MIN es unica
this is the true kpop idol. i swear. they are so good 😞
Daebak. We need AOA in any form to come to Australia! Just come with CNBlue next time ladies...... or alone, they won't mind. Great upload, thanks
Min A nice>
finally live, they really play
이 날 너무 좋다
Still my fave!
초아 노래 심하게 잘부르네👍
여자밴드는 처음 봤는데 나도 밴드부로써는 잘한다. 솔직히 여자가 밴드를 하는 것은 처음 봤거든요. 역시 AOA 저 AOA팬입니다. 나도 밴드부로써 더욱 열심히 해야지!!!@
민아랑 초아 보러 왔어요
AOA playing live is ♥ :D
MOYA... 😊(💖)
Jimin and Choa are unfortunately not playing the guitar. Or I shoud say, whatever is they are playing is not what we're hearing because they're all over the place and not playing the right chords at all. I think that's why they had to let this concept go, but again the drummer and bassist are awesome. Awesome guitar solo at 2:47 that nobody onstage is playing :)
Sad, but true. I don't listen to a lot of other live band performers like CNBlue or FTIsland, but does having the backtracks or something like that normal? I would assume they would play it in case some thing went wrong with the audio/connections/instruments.
This still sounded great nonetheless :)
Raxengun having a back track is fine but it shouldn't be your instrument. I think this is just a case of a pop group pretending to be a band. Choa isn't a guitarist so it's more of a prop for her. Jimin can play guitar though.
+Pradigy Musicman : Actually Yuna is also playing the keyboard
+Pradigy Musicman them if they playing the guitar, the guitar solo is true that not playing, is that jimin of so much practice suffered an injury and has trouble playing one solo of this magnitude, I think that's why AOA Black have not made their comeback for 3 years to that pass the injury,They are not a "fake band"
sorry for my english, my language real is spanish XDD
Milagros Cruz choa cant play guitar. Jimin can play guitar chords I've seen her do that. However she obviously can't and did not play that solo. As a musician who has performed for over 8 years on stage i can tell when someone can't play.
진짜 레전드노래다
I miss this so much :(
AoA..... 😊
여자 밴드 부럽고 멋있다
the audience is way too passive. since its a live performance not like the music charts show. they should rock out with the music
I've been wondering if there's any other girl group like Wonder girls, I'm so happy to learn that they play too, especially since it's my favourite song of theirs :D
AOA debut like a band and dance group in 2012, they are the first band girl group.
aoa black 🤩🤩🤩😚😚
AOA 2020
Mina , Choa , Jimin and Yuna ..
youkyung..
yuhakroe _ yeah drummer
she' s being inactive for a long time..
yuhakroe _ now , she not in aoa anymore
I like Chaoa
beautiful girls
that girl looks like a live anime.
Jimin's good
!
omg Ji Min
It isnt fake. they can play.
나쁘지않구먼 다시 이걸로도 해줬으면좋겟다
before Jimin and Mina conflict
Yuna's playing right? and it's so cool!!
Love love love jimin
I love these girls and they are friggin talented as can be, but GODDAMN do they need to work on balancing their sound. Holy crap you can barely hear the guitars. Its the Yuna, Mina and Youkyung show out there. I guess a dress rehearsal wasn't a thing?
Uh at around 2:50, who is playing the guitar solo? xD It's not Choa or Jimin, their hand movements are both playing rhythm.
Lolz, I'm also trying to look for the one playing the guitar solo =)
Neither of them did sadly, that's part of the backing track :(
ken k
Nah definitely the backing track. I can see where you're coming from but Yuna's just playing piano on the keyboard (:
***** /facepalm Mina plays Bass
It was keyboard's sound
Jimin is gorgeous. At least in the outside...
지민씨 랩하실 때 리듬 감각좋공~~~ 난 이때부터 알아봤지롱
they should have a comebackkkk
Ai nói bài này mà không live thì lỗ tai có vấn đề... K biết nghe thì đừng cmt... Nhà FNC ban nhạc nào chơi cũng mở nhạc đệm hết nhe b... Nên khi nghe nó giống giả lắm, bass phải banh lỗ tai mà nghe riêng ms nghe đc, còn trống thì gõ nhẹ nó cũng ra tiếng rồi, sao mà giả được :)))) FNC k cho AOA black comeback vì không nổi nhe.. Năm 2014 ra 3 bài hit ngta ms biết AOA là ai.., 2012-13 hỏi ai cũng k biết vì họ chỉ thích nhóm nhạc thôi... =]]]
I didnt know they could play :O
I'm a guitarist and non of that playing is real. maybe the drums and key board. But i also play bass and her hands are not on the right frets.
They might be goint to be separated
노래하는 초아누나 보고싶다
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
응! 뭐야? 완전 데이식스 걸밴드판인데 왜 계속 밴드를 안했지? 곡컨셉을 잘못잡았던건가?
rip band concept
so sad that the drummer is out from the band 😢
Did Yuna mess up?
***** I thought it was Yuna that messed up? Eh oh well this was an awesome performance, glad we saw a good vid of them playing live.
I think nobody messed up. :O It was a "change key" i think with like broken chords (not sure witH the term). It's done by some just so the song would be unique. Lol. Explain much? But yeah. \m/ I think they did great. 그치? :3
다 잘했는데 2분40~3분0초까지
기타솔로 비스무리하게
있던데 왜안치고있었지?
하긴 안무까지하려면
힘들수도..
랩하고 안무하고 다하려면 헷갈리고 힘들어서 그랬을꺼같아요
랩은 당췌 뭐라그러는지 알아듣질 못하겠네.. 겁나빨라가...ㅋㅋㅋ
I can tell Mina and Yuna are playing... I don't hear anything that matches the strums of either guitar
The live mixing isn't good, the guitars are drowned but you should still be able to mark the sound on each upward strum -- at least Jimin's guitar which sounds darker here. I find it hard to make out ChoA's guitar though.
choA is not following the chord changes
I'm pretty sure this is a fake live instrument, the drums and bass isn't convincing. Take a closer look on how they play the instrument against the sound it produce.
Fake? Go compare this to their prerecorded performances, this is definitely live. You can see the cords connected to their instruments.
It's live musicyou moron. Stop make your self stupid!
The bass looks like fake. I can be wrong though.
i can barely hear the guitars
EliteCitrus you nerd probably dont even know how music instruments are supposed to sound like if you can even make such a comment
Daebak. We need AOA in any form to come to Australia! Just come with CNBlue next time ladies...... or alone, they won't mind. Great upload, thanks
I love these girls and they are friggin talented as can be, but GODDAMN do they need to work on balancing their sound. Holy crap you can barely hear the guitars. Its the Yuna, Mina and Youkyung show out there. I guess a dress rehearsal wasn't a thing?