Jack White - Boarding House Reach ALBUM REVIEW

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Listen: • Jack White - Ice Stati...
    Jack White's Boarding House Reach is his most unorthodox stroke of genius since going solo.
    Buy this album: amzn.to/2GbPhQV
    More rock reviews: • Rock Reviews
    ===================================
    Subscribe: bit.ly/1pBqGCN
    Official site: theneedledrop.com
    TND Twitter: / theneedledrop
    TND Facebook: / theneedledrop
    Support TND: theneedledrop.c...
    ===================================
    FAV TRACKS: CONNECTED BY LOVE, WHY WALK A DOG?, CORPORATION, ICE STATION ZEBRA, OVER AND OVER AND OVER, RESPECT COMMANDER, GET IN THE MIND SHAFT, WHAT'S DONE IS DONE
    LEAST FAV TRACK: HUMORESQUE
    JACK WHITE - BOARDING HOUSE REACH / 2018 / THIRD MAN / EXPERIMENTAL BLUES ROCK
    9/10 www.theneedledr...
    Y'all know this is just my opinion, right?

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @bsparks
    @bsparks 6 років тому +3765

    So Jack White gets a 9 but Jack Black gets a 5? We see what you're getting at fantano...

    • @qdominika7253
      @qdominika7253 6 років тому +34

      Ben Sparks oh god 😂

    • @0412lennon
      @0412lennon 6 років тому +34

      Jackie brown got 110th street

    • @Moneyman-33
      @Moneyman-33 6 років тому +47

      Now this is a good meme. But when did Jack Black get a 5?

    • @oo2666
      @oo2666 6 років тому +119

      and jack jew got a NOT GOOD

    • @hoodedstreetmonk352
      @hoodedstreetmonk352 6 років тому +2

      Holy shit

  • @theguitarzebra7826
    @theguitarzebra7826 6 років тому +537

    This album seems to be the result of Jack throwing away all of the limitations that have defined his career thus far. Instead of limiting himself to 8 or 16 tracks on a reel, he embraces Pro Tools. Instead of sticking to traditional instrumentation, he embraces synths and programmed drums. Boarding House Reach, to me, sounds like the genius of Jack White’s mind flowing completely freely without any self imposed restrictions, which is something we haven’t seen yet.

    • @SarahCrookall
      @SarahCrookall 6 років тому +12

      Agreed. 100%

    • @ian_5184
      @ian_5184 4 роки тому +4

      @@ArchKnight28 It's the former.

    • @rollingon5566
      @rollingon5566 4 роки тому +3

      its like the opposite of what musicians normally say about limitations, in a way, it reminds me of kid A in the respect that its really different

    • @gutterbaby8382
      @gutterbaby8382 4 роки тому +1

      I absolutely agree! Jack White has already given us all of the standard garage rock and blues rock we need, we should embrace this new and exciting sound.

    • @addisonpilliard4668
      @addisonpilliard4668 3 роки тому +1

      It’s literally the opposite, he recorded this on an A-track in a studio apartment in Nashville, the album is called boarding house reach because he invited some people over to do backing instruments and said “please excuse my boarding house reach” when he went to reset the recorder.

  • @MagickFlavour
    @MagickFlavour 6 років тому +3829

    Anthony Fantano: Lazaretto wasn't experimental enough.
    Jack White: hold my whiskey.

  • @BlankRami
    @BlankRami 5 років тому +490

    It's like when Radiohead came out with Kid A, everyone was like wtf at the time but through out time, it stood up and became a favorite.

    • @1needBycRidezzz
      @1needBycRidezzz 4 роки тому

      Great take👌🏻😁👍🏻

    • @hippiecheezburger5457
      @hippiecheezburger5457 4 роки тому +17

      Kid A as an entire work is a masterpiece

    • @eliohhh
      @eliohhh 4 роки тому +22

      @@hippiecheezburger5457 how can you say something so controversial yet so brave

    • @visualspark6308
      @visualspark6308 4 роки тому +2

      Fluppy it’s true though

    • @ThatShittyGamer
      @ThatShittyGamer 3 роки тому +9

      I loved it immediately honestly but I get the analogy and it definitely makes sense. It is way more left field than anything he's done solo but I always knew he was a weird dude.

  • @DerangedManiac12
    @DerangedManiac12 6 років тому +659

    Jack White and Jack Black should do a collab to ease racial tensions.

  • @gutterbaby8382
    @gutterbaby8382 4 роки тому +98

    This album is gonna be considered a game-changing important album in ten years. It's such a grand, futuristic, eclectic and unpredictable listening experience, and Jack has completely broken the mould of what a blues rock album can be.

    • @cheekybananaboy3361
      @cheekybananaboy3361 2 роки тому +6

      i feel like everyone has forgotten about it/never really knew it existed in the first place

    • @ratonman
      @ratonman 2 роки тому

      @@cheekybananaboy3361 pretty much

    • @lemontonk
      @lemontonk 2 роки тому

      I really enjoyed this album when it came out but no this albums a lot more niche than you’re making it out to be. Can’t say many people remember it now in December 2021

  • @prototype102010
    @prototype102010 6 років тому +136

    I love hypermisophoniac because it's supposed to be hard to listen to. Misophoniac means a hatred of a sound, like nails on a chalkboard or something. So I think it just fits so well.

    • @saturatedneowax
      @saturatedneowax 5 років тому +7

      it has so much personality it’s great

    • @cheekybananaboy3361
      @cheekybananaboy3361 2 роки тому +2

      funny thing is i absolutely loved it from first listen, it was my stand out track. thats when you know your brain works differently lmao

  • @UncleDamfee
    @UncleDamfee 6 років тому +600

    I'm sure this would have gotten a NOT GOOD if his name was Jack Black.

    • @alistair7981
      @alistair7981 6 років тому +9

      uncle damfee But jack black makes great music - Tribute was an awsome song.

    • @alistair7981
      @alistair7981 6 років тому +4

      Seehorn Actual sadly not it was just a tribute 😂

  • @HectorEPagan-ld8bf
    @HectorEPagan-ld8bf 6 років тому +216

    Pitchfork: 4.7
    Tony Fantano: 9
    IN TONY WE TRUST

  • @Angels510
    @Angels510 6 років тому +1223

    You gave Jack White a 9 but DAMN a 7? WOOOOW Jack isn't even that good of a rapper...

  • @rckkatansky5783
    @rckkatansky5783 6 років тому +2162

    Album: Experimental __________
    Fantano: 10/10

    • @mikelanzafame3401
      @mikelanzafame3401 6 років тому +302

      Frederick Core lol , I feel like I could record an album of noise from a construction site and Anthony would give it a 10 because it’s “glitchy” and “abrasive”

    • @jayvee4020
      @jayvee4020 6 років тому +25

      +Mike Lanzafame Kid Cudi already did that

    • @SoldierOfMetal6
      @SoldierOfMetal6 6 років тому +130

      He's given plenty of other experimental albums bad scores if you actually paid attention you would've known that

    • @crazyluigi6664
      @crazyluigi6664 6 років тому +15

      *9/10

    • @rckkatansky5783
      @rckkatansky5783 6 років тому +40

      standalonecomplex967 its a joke

  • @cameronstackhouse635
    @cameronstackhouse635 6 років тому +252

    "It's January 2018 and I feel like I've already heard one of the worst songs of the year"
    >puts connected by love in the best tracks
    >decent to strong 9/10

    • @PBCollects
      @PBCollects 6 років тому +47

      Funny enough, in that Track Review he put "King's Dead" as one of the best tracks, and then when the Black Panther album came out, it was listed as a least fav track.

    • @arempy5836
      @arempy5836 6 років тому +9

      Motherfuckers want him to change his mind on DAMN but can't do it on a jack white track?

    • @GuysOfFilm
      @GuysOfFilm 6 років тому +2

      Did this with Streaky off Death Grips new album. Said it was meh/not that great, then put it in the best tracks when the album dropped

    • @johnwayne7201
      @johnwayne7201 5 років тому +12

      GuysOfFilm he explains in the vid that the song works in the context of the album but not as a single, hence the change. Also, that is why a lot of people believe the album is name YOTS because of how many damn singles there were, and how much better they sound in context.

  • @artvjon
    @artvjon 6 років тому +1196

    AND THEY SAID MY SCORE WAS TOO HIGH
    I'm actually excited to see you praising this so much though, holy shit that makes the Jack White fanboy in me explode with happiness.

    • @michaelvessel4604
      @michaelvessel4604 6 років тому +11

      Same here, John.

    • @shrimpfriedizzy
      @shrimpfriedizzy 6 років тому +85

      yeah but you put humanz on your top 20 albums of last year so....

    • @cantascoglu257
      @cantascoglu257 6 років тому +17

      Isobel Lunn I was really disappointed with it at first, especially since I was a big Gorillaz fan but it slowly grew on me. Similarly, this is what happened with Plastic Beach as well so maybe it’s just me.

    • @artvjon
      @artvjon 6 років тому +99

      Wow Isobel, it's like you would...invalidate someone else's opinion because you don't agree with it?! How reasonable of you!

    • @jakeadams1009
      @jakeadams1009 6 років тому +55

      ARTV You get too much shit from some of Fantano's fans tbh

  • @gravymuztache8108
    @gravymuztache8108 6 років тому +1441

    “Fans of this artist might be alienated by this new sound they’re experimenting with.
    10/10”

    • @Number9Robotic
      @Number9Robotic 6 років тому +143

      Yeah, he's made it clear the score is how much *he* likes an album.

    • @hubblebublumbubwub5215
      @hubblebublumbubwub5215 6 років тому +71

      Nines
      wow thanks for the information i used to think the scores were just random numbers

    • @mattordiway1955
      @mattordiway1955 6 років тому

      Hubblebub Lumbubwub
      This made my day man...:’)

    • @Number9Robotic
      @Number9Robotic 6 років тому +20

      @Hubblebub Lumbubwub I say that because a lot of people assume the scores are like an objective score, one that he thinks should be the applicable score for everyone in his audience. There's a big distinction.

  • @rohanmehta8148
    @rohanmehta8148 6 років тому +260

    Fantano looks happy.Good for him.

  • @ByeByeDeadName
    @ByeByeDeadName 6 років тому +45

    I’ve never given a Jack White album a listen before, so I finally gave this one a shot. And I really fucking loved it. Glad to hear Fantano enjoyed it as well.

  • @Sonylombax
    @Sonylombax 6 років тому +257

    Pitchfork: 4.7/10
    Anthony Fandango: 9/10
    CAN SOMEONE TELL ME WHAT MY OPINION ON THIS ALBUM IS PLEASE?!?!?!

    • @enjoshi-godrez8775
      @enjoshi-godrez8775 6 років тому +90

      pitchfork is a fucking cantaloupe compered to antony's watermelon 10/10 status.

    • @peytonstein8616
      @peytonstein8616 6 років тому +94

      Pitchfork didnt review the album, it just took pot shots at Jack Whites career.

    • @awookieandagerman
      @awookieandagerman 6 років тому +50

      about a 6.85/10 if you ask my calculator

    • @koen5177
      @koen5177 6 років тому +12

      I hate it, you can borrow my opinion if you want.

    • @wh8twh8t30
      @wh8twh8t30 6 років тому +9

      This album made the melon's mind melt and he just gave it a 9 cuz el no comprendo

  • @guitarmatt94
    @guitarmatt94 6 років тому +43

    I actually think this was the perfect album for jack white to make at this point. Experimental, funky and most of all interesting. It was just about time to change it up for him imo. Really dont know why pitchfork hated it and some other reviewers were calling it 'off the mark.' Like, thats pretty much the point of a jack white album, to be a bit odd and avante garde.

    • @sycko8
      @sycko8 5 років тому +2

      Don't ever listen to Pitchfork unless it's a 10, 9.8, 9.7, 9.6 or 9.5 review!

  • @hubblebublumbubwub5215
    @hubblebublumbubwub5215 6 років тому +128

    Started on the worst tracks list now we're here

    • @davyanilhaq2465
      @davyanilhaq2465 6 років тому +16

      Started on the worst tracks list now the whole tracklist fucking here

  • @whatname8952
    @whatname8952 6 років тому +359

    i hated this album but not anymore! thanks melon.

  • @MultiYoutubuser
    @MultiYoutubuser 6 років тому +1164

    Tfw fantano gave jack white and judas priest the yellow

    • @cstubbssubs7746
      @cstubbssubs7746 6 років тому +23

      Unutente Acaso jack white album is good

    • @Dismoeyy
      @Dismoeyy 6 років тому +1

      CStubbsSubs i think so too

    • @imeowmeowkat
      @imeowmeowkat 6 років тому +103

      TFW he gives good albums good scores

    • @MultiYoutubuser
      @MultiYoutubuser 6 років тому +55

      Yeah I like both albums too, I just find it weird that such artists have dropped such good records at this point in their career

    • @jonte3132
      @jonte3132 6 років тому +8

      my dad met anthony

  • @michaelcristoferi6845
    @michaelcristoferi6845 6 років тому +41

    having not listened to anything of Jack Whites since the White Stripes I was incredibly surprised and impressed with this album!

    • @wangson
      @wangson 6 років тому +7

      Take a listen to Blunderbuss...some great piano songs there.

  • @Rishiyisus
    @Rishiyisus 6 років тому +512

    Top 10 plot twist of anime for sure

    • @thoamssssss
      @thoamssssss 6 років тому +9

      Rishi el paisano
      Top Ten Best Anime Melons

    • @juancalle4369
      @juancalle4369 6 років тому +5

      It wouldn't be a plot twist if you read the manga.

    • @taiosmalls
      @taiosmalls 6 років тому +1

      Just about everything in Kangoku Gakuen.

  • @TyTheRegularMan
    @TyTheRegularMan 6 років тому +309

    WHO'S WITH ME

  • @knapsack9223
    @knapsack9223 6 років тому +1373

    seven melon army

    • @moresoduh
      @moresoduh 6 років тому +5

      Knapsack oh hey I know you. Ben and your remix of Lamb was unreal. All love - cherishh

    • @TheMuse260
      @TheMuse260 6 років тому +5

      Im gonna fight em off

    • @knapsack9223
      @knapsack9223 6 років тому +1

      Christopher Mosby love u chris

    • @sadgiraffe1914
      @sadgiraffe1914 6 років тому +1

      Seven Nation Melony

    • @jasonwalsh8281
      @jasonwalsh8281 6 років тому +1

      666

  • @omarmickelson1204
    @omarmickelson1204 6 років тому +22

    I literally gave this a 9 in my mind last Friday, when I first heard it.
    When I first saw the yellow flannel in the thumbnail, I didn't think much, but when I saw the length of the video, I kind of leaned back in my seat and went "oh crap, it's happening."

  • @zackbuschmann9005
    @zackbuschmann9005 6 років тому +48

    Anthony you gotta bring back the tree intro. You know you want to.

  • @blastedmcgraw152
    @blastedmcgraw152 6 років тому +112

    Great review. This album is the best thing Jack has done since the White Stripes days. I haven’t had an album hit me like this in a while. Feels like I’m listening to some truly new music. Here’s hoping this album is the starting point of a new creative streak.

    • @jeanlucbergman479
      @jeanlucbergman479 6 років тому

      It's shitty blues rock. Nothing new about it.

    • @crazyprayingmantis5596
      @crazyprayingmantis5596 6 років тому

      I'd rather slowly push a glowing red hot skewer into my ear than listen to this again.

    • @franciscobaltazarlabranago6248
      @franciscobaltazarlabranago6248 5 років тому +5

      @@jeanlucbergman479 Sounds like you haven't listened to the album

    • @GuysOfFilm
      @GuysOfFilm 5 років тому +3

      @@crazyprayingmantis5596 jesus I pray you don't stumble upon anything actually experimental. If left field blues rock makes you want to harm yourself maybe just stick to listening to fucking Radiohead or something

  • @heyvsoucejobahere6763
    @heyvsoucejobahere6763 6 років тому +78

    WAS COMUNISM EXPERIMENTAL???? 10/10

  • @VaginaRecords
    @VaginaRecords 6 років тому +86

    Im just happy that finally we have a divisive album. People love it, people hated it. I really love this kind of work, particularly
    in this particular era of social and influencer where everybody seems to tag along the dominant opinion

    • @silentforum616
      @silentforum616 6 років тому +1

      BVRecords it was never a divisive album before this review haha. He is the first person to say it’s great. 😂

    • @jakeadams1009
      @jakeadams1009 6 років тому +1

      Silent Forum It is a divisive album though 😂😂😂

    • @VaginaRecords
      @VaginaRecords 6 років тому +4

      Nme give 10 to this album. If you look in metacritic there are plenty magazine who love it, like american songwriter telegraph and others

    • @tinyrick2921
      @tinyrick2921 6 років тому

      I loved it too dude. Jack White is generally a hit or miss to me, especially in his solo career, but I do love this album. He seems here like 'I don't give a fuck this time, I mean not at all, I'm gonna make the craziest fucking music I can make', and it works, because it's just so damn good, which won't necessarily work with lots of artists.

    • @SarahCrookall
      @SarahCrookall 6 років тому +2

      Yes, and not even because it's 'divisive,' just for the sake of being divisive. It's really refreshing to see an artist push themselves especially where White is at in his career. Plus a bunch of other stuff.

  • @jjkkmmmmjjib
    @jjkkmmmmjjib 6 років тому +304

    "Experimental" when I see dis word, I already know melon likes it

    • @DorianTwist
      @DorianTwist 6 років тому +9

      Kucik this is true, but there are plenty of things that are experimental that are absolute trash. Have you ever heard of a vortex called Bandcamp? .... enter at your own risk.

    • @stupidnonmovingcartoon3662
      @stupidnonmovingcartoon3662 6 років тому

      Dorian Twist How about Goreshit? He's on bandcamp

    • @jamessderby
      @jamessderby 6 років тому

      except when it's young fathers

    • @kfarg1
      @kfarg1 6 років тому

      Pumpjetskii experimental paradigmism

  • @RULERofCERTAINthings
    @RULERofCERTAINthings 6 років тому +36

    while this review is great Jack already said that reviewbrahs review was the only one that matters

  • @THEOfficialGopleJ
    @THEOfficialGopleJ 6 років тому +305

    review the school of rock soundtrack

    • @linusf
      @linusf 6 років тому +11

      Was your thought process Jack White --> Jack Black --> School of Rock?

    • @THEOfficialGopleJ
      @THEOfficialGopleJ 6 років тому +9

      Linus yes

  • @hoopla9120
    @hoopla9120 6 років тому +19

    By the way melon, Humoresque was a piece Al Capone wrote while in Alkatraz. Jack got a hold of it at an auction so in my opinion it plays in with the weird and dark and mysterious theme of this record. The song itself doesn’t fit in with the theme but the story of it surely does.

    • @hoopla9120
      @hoopla9120 3 роки тому +1

      @@miguelenes6556 he wrote the melody, Capone put lyrics to it.

    • @VethoRinga
      @VethoRinga 2 роки тому

      @@hoopla9120 He didn't write the melody. The melody is taken from Dvorak's piece titled...
      "Humoresque".

  • @aggressivebabooneyes2200
    @aggressivebabooneyes2200 6 років тому +350

    didnothony expectthistano

  • @craw_daddy97
    @craw_daddy97 2 роки тому +4

    Rock fans: WE WANT SOMETHING NEW. ROCK IS DEAD, THERE’S NOTHING ORIGINAL OR GOOD ANYMORE
    Jack White: Here you go
    Rock fans: 3/10

  • @realitybites_
    @realitybites_ 6 років тому +369

    wtf i love this album now

    • @guitarmaniac004
      @guitarmaniac004 6 років тому +109

      Yeah I know. I thought this album was garbage but then anthony said he liked it so I like it now too

    • @alexfuentes2653
      @alexfuentes2653 6 років тому +15

      The album does grow on you. Give it another shot

    • @carlonj.govender8920
      @carlonj.govender8920 6 років тому +16

      changthony opinionano

    • @JapaneseModernist
      @JapaneseModernist 6 років тому +1

      It did grow on me after seeing the score anthony gave

  • @SophiaPasta
    @SophiaPasta 6 років тому +140

    Your review is irrelevant. Reviewbrah has spoken.

    • @pyrobison2002
      @pyrobison2002 6 років тому

      Sophresh i think i’ve seen you there

  • @BajaFrecuencia
    @BajaFrecuencia 6 років тому +742

    well, that was unexpected

    • @danpulka
      @danpulka 6 років тому +8

      meh, Fantano is coming off more and more of a try hard with alternator agendas in his reviews than anything lately.

    • @aR0ttenBANANA
      @aR0ttenBANANA 6 років тому +8

      +Dan Pulka care to elaborate?

    • @hippiecheezburger5457
      @hippiecheezburger5457 6 років тому +3

      aR0ttenBANANA96 I thought it was a great album for jack white I'd say, against his own standards is why it's good but I wouldn't say it's one of rock musics finest albums or anything like that

    • @danpulka
      @danpulka 6 років тому +4

      sure, just trying to get views and come off edgy/differing than whats generally accepted. he's coming off more and more contrived with his reviews imo. he rated that David Bryne album well, which is pretty laughable. He caught Bryne live a bit before his review which I think had more to do with his rating than the album's quality itself. this album wasn't great either... I mean a fuckin 9? lol.

    • @danpulka
      @danpulka 6 років тому +8

      exactly. this could be good by Jack White's standards, but that isn't saying much. This album was OK at best. Will be largely forgotten by summer.

  • @wickedhyperstyler
    @wickedhyperstyler 2 роки тому +8

    02:30 - Connected by Love
    03:53 - Why Walk a Dog?
    05:44 - Corporation
    10:49 - Abulia and Akrasia
    06:21 - Hypermisophoniac
    07:14 - Ice Station Zebra
    08:02 - Over and Over and Over
    10:17 - Everything You've Ever Learned
    09:03 - Respect Commander
    10:32 - Ezmerelda Steals the Show
    09:50 - Get in the Mind Shaft
    05:15 - What's Done Is Done
    11:11 - Humoresque

  • @rckkatansky5783
    @rckkatansky5783 6 років тому +611

    ITS THE FUCKING YELLOW, COOD B A 12, COOD B A 12

    • @Ignore14
      @Ignore14 6 років тому +18

      A 12 CLASSIC!!!

    • @vladimirklizschko9337
      @vladimirklizschko9337 6 років тому +13

      i love the danny brown review. Sometimes i just watch that shit for the "COOD B A 12" at the start

    • @TrevorGarford
      @TrevorGarford 6 років тому

      this is really cool. i love it.

  • @73Fluxx1
    @73Fluxx1 6 років тому +13

    Jack White finely delivered the album that matches his public persona.

  • @pun2kw8
    @pun2kw8 6 років тому +210

    when the first single dropped I expected a red flannel

  • @andrewchesser3823
    @andrewchesser3823 6 років тому +12

    Hypermisophoniac is suppose to annoy you and be really weird, that’s basically what the word means. So yes he did go overboard but that’s the point.

  • @plainsongz
    @plainsongz 6 років тому +492

    lol Connected by Love was on "Worst Tracks" just a month ago and now it's on fav tracks.

    • @spero360
      @spero360 6 років тому +97

      Solid Snack probably cuz it's now put in context

    • @plainsongz
      @plainsongz 6 років тому +6

      Alexander Lively yeah it really is great with context

    • @stephenowen3383
      @stephenowen3383 6 років тому +5

      Solid Snack watch the video

    • @Boooooognish
      @Boooooognish 6 років тому +12

      He’s done this a few times

    • @thrownstair
      @thrownstair 6 років тому +19

      Think he did this with Hand It Over from the new MGMT album. Didn't like the single, but liked it with context.

  • @MattieCooper10000
    @MattieCooper10000 6 років тому +9

    This review of Jack White's new album is the best thing to happen on Earth in the past 24 hours.

  • @Venenoso
    @Venenoso 6 років тому +1090

    Review my dad’s pull out game

  • @alimustafa4923
    @alimustafa4923 4 роки тому +4

    y'all arguing about pitchfork or needle drop did the better review, but we all know that there's only 1 review that matters...

    • @aclyte2679
      @aclyte2679 3 роки тому +2

      I still remember when I got the notification two years ago. A review, but not from who I expected 👀

  • @dawsonhicks5929
    @dawsonhicks5929 6 років тому +376

    9?!? A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one!

  • @bitchfuckmeeee6873
    @bitchfuckmeeee6873 6 років тому +177

    So i have this theory: You know how a lot of porn addicts develop odd fetishes and move onto more hardcore stuff to satisfy their needs? I feel like Anthony has listened to so much music the only thing he can really enjoy is experimental music, even if it sounds like shit.

    • @xXDylanPriceXx
      @xXDylanPriceXx 6 років тому +73

      don't kink shame him

    • @bitchfuckmeeee6873
      @bitchfuckmeeee6873 6 років тому +25

      It's OK, I'm a sick fuck too. I have a melon fetish.

    • @Blazing234
      @Blazing234 6 років тому +7

      I wouldn't say that man. For example I went through a huge pop music phase. Now I love nothing but experimental. Before my pop music phase I was listening to lots of experimental folk n stuff like that.

    • @bitchfuckmeeee6873
      @bitchfuckmeeee6873 6 років тому +22

      Yeah I'm being hyperbolic, I just thought it was a funny analogy. Anthony loves a lot of simplistic shit too, (Lil Boat 2 and Lil Pump) he's into a wide variety of songs, he's way more open minded than I am when it comes to music that's for sure.

    • @crazyprayingmantis5596
      @crazyprayingmantis5596 6 років тому +3

      Think you might be onto something, this album is fucking terrible calling this trash experimental is an insult to real experimental albums, this is just plain lame trying to be experimental but failing

  • @dejota5392
    @dejota5392 6 років тому +56

    Man oh man i'm feeling a 10/10 coming this year

  • @dirkardostevergreen4827
    @dirkardostevergreen4827 6 років тому +3

    A lot of people will hate this album but I think it's destined to be a cult classic. Kudos to Jack for going above and beyond.

  • @invm2631
    @invm2631 6 років тому +71

    Goddammit Melon, you didnt have to give him a 2 for being a pale sadboi

  • @ToddHenkelprofile
    @ToddHenkelprofile 6 років тому +3

    This review is spot-on. On first listen, the record sounded foreign. The songs are creative. They grow on you (still getting better and better). Now they follow me around the house (humming the melody accompanied by some air guitar). My favorite album this year.

  • @morganflowers9360
    @morganflowers9360 6 років тому +43

    *Whitethony Stripestano*

  • @Sebvibevanse
    @Sebvibevanse 6 років тому +31

    Boarding House Reach is this year's Atrocity Exibition

    • @GuysOfFilm
      @GuysOfFilm 6 років тому +1

      So... Album of the year?

    • @user-dy2nh8zn4b
      @user-dy2nh8zn4b 5 років тому +1

      @@GuysOfFilm naw. He'll probably pick either KSG or YWGWYW

    • @GuysOfFilm
      @GuysOfFilm 5 років тому +6

      @@user-dy2nh8zn4b I say he'll pick Daughters. He seemed to have a way more visceral reaction to it

    • @user-dy2nh8zn4b
      @user-dy2nh8zn4b 5 років тому +1

      @@GuysOfFilm fair. I'm just praying my boy Scott Mescudi gets redemption in the eyes of Antoine Fantoine

  • @stealthsuit58
    @stealthsuit58 6 років тому +173

    Over and Over might be the best fucking rock song i've heard in the last 5 years. I can't get enough of it.

    • @kanji6376
      @kanji6376 6 років тому +16

      Probably my least favourite song off the record ironically.

    • @jordimelis4463
      @jordimelis4463 6 років тому +10

      I know right? what a fucking banger, cant stop listening to it

    • @TheDiagnoser
      @TheDiagnoser 6 років тому

      and respect commander

    • @noahbeal4555
      @noahbeal4555 6 років тому +5

      Really? That was by far the most boring track imo

    • @b0jang
      @b0jang 6 років тому +4

      Just sounds like a Rage song to me

  • @eddietruett
    @eddietruett 6 років тому +73

    My jaw dropped when I saw the gold flannel, holy shit. I thought it could be a 3 honestly

    • @cstubbssubs7746
      @cstubbssubs7746 6 років тому +4

      Eddie Truett is that because you expect artists to make the same record over and over again so you never have to accept change?

    • @eddietruett
      @eddietruett 6 років тому +34

      WTF lol...no it was more to the fact that he hated the original single and B-side and this album is getting extremely polarizing reviews like Pitchfork gave it a 4.7 and I honestly was expecting Fantano to follow suit. Why the fuck would you make that assumption based on my original comment?

    • @cstubbssubs7746
      @cstubbssubs7746 6 років тому +31

      Eddie Truett Yeah my bad man honestly I made that assumption because a lot of people are just trashing this album purely because they aren’t used to experimentation, and because you said “I thought it could be a 3” I assumed that’s the score that YOU thought it deserved.

    • @beanbagvevo
      @beanbagvevo 6 років тому

      NUT

    • @brectangle
      @brectangle 6 років тому

      Eddie Truett is the gold flannel supposed to mean something?

  • @mateuslopesteixeira6653
    @mateuslopesteixeira6653 6 років тому +55

    I can't believe the melon gave the music a 2/10 and the cover art a 9/10

    • @peytonstein8616
      @peytonstein8616 6 років тому +10

      I couldnt believe he bumped the score up because he had White in the name

  • @joecool811
    @joecool811 6 років тому +7

    This video made me SMASH those like and subscribe buttons, much like Jack White SMASHED this album. Happy to see one of my all time favorite artists get the praise he deserves 🎸🤘

  • @foxmouth9380
    @foxmouth9380 6 років тому +284

    Is this a meme review

  • @fireproofline
    @fireproofline 6 років тому +2

    One thing to appreciate about Jack White is his dedication to incredible sound quality by mastering his albums beautifully. We need more Jack Whites in the industry.

  • @whtemale6522
    @whtemale6522 6 років тому +6

    0/10: 0
    1/10: 0
    2/10: 0
    3/10: 3
    4/10: 3
    5/10: 4
    6/10: 7
    7/10: 12
    8/10: 10
    9/10: 3 [ Ion - Portal ] [ A.A.L [AGAINST ALL LOGIC] -2012 - 2017 ] [ Jack White - Boarding House Reach ]
    10/10: 0
    Not good: 2
    ( Fall Out Boy - Mania )
    ( Wendy's - We Beefin?)
    Custom scores:
    [ Dime-a-dozen ] /10 (Lil Skies - Life of a Dark Rose) 5/10
    [ Solid ] /10 (Ravyn Lenae - Crush) 7/10
    [ It's solid ] /10 (Gucci Mane - El Gato: The Human Glacier) 7/10
    [ Disappointing ] /10 (Kero Kero Bonito - Totep) 5/10
    [ Lukewarm ] /10 (Rejjie Snow - Dear Annie) 5/10
    [ notbad ] /10 (Remo Drive - Pop Music) 6/10
    "Controvertial"
    [ Lil Yatchy - Lil Boat ] 7/10
    [ Young Fathers - Cocoa Sugar ] 6/10

    • @takki3942
      @takki3942 6 років тому

      Polish Vodka the custom scores are confusing af

    • @yomommagay300
      @yomommagay300 6 років тому

      Polish Vodka nah lil skies is 3/10

  • @matthewfeatherston8982
    @matthewfeatherston8982 Рік тому +2

    Boarding House Reach, Jack White's Pinkerton moment where the critics hate it, but the album ends up being influential as hell

  • @fryry72
    @fryry72 6 років тому +35

    As a huge jack white fan im surprised by how much the melon liked this thing... I enjoy it more and more with every listen but idk if its a 9 yet. The pitchfork review was super obnoxious about how left field this album was and was basically the reveiwer being pretentious about how jack white is pretentious.. The guy gave it like a 4.8 or some shit?? It wasnt that bad

    • @samhighley8112
      @samhighley8112 6 років тому +1

      Yeah when I first listened it was a low 7 but now I have it as a decent 8. Don't know if I could give it a 9 though

    • @fryry72
      @fryry72 6 років тому +1

      Sam Highley im sitting at about the same spot.. At first i wasnt sure because it lacks a lot of songs you can "just listen to" but as an album it is super interesting and brings a lot to the table

    • @g0rtmany0lk
      @g0rtmany0lk 6 років тому +1

      First time I heard it I gave it a REEAAAALLLY light 8, but after a second listen I'd give it a decent 8, leaning a bit short on a strong 8. Hopefully, it might grow on me EVEN MORE on my subsequent listens.

    • @guitarmatt94
      @guitarmatt94 6 років тому

      It was a solid 7 at least imo, Idk why fantano is creaming over it so much but its definitely better than bitchforks review.

    • @hypetrained
      @hypetrained 6 років тому

      The emotional and aesthetic chaos is something that is something you either love or don't. Understanding his vocal performance on Connected by Love is really part of it

  • @potemkincitylimits8079
    @potemkincitylimits8079 6 років тому +10

    YES ANTHONY MY DUDE!! I loved this thing on my first listen, but knew it wasn't going to do well amongst critics, so I'm glad you bucked that trend and shone some light on why this thing is so goddamn clever!

  • @ianleblanc9111
    @ianleblanc9111 6 років тому +147

    WHAT ABOUT JACK BLACK

    • @alceedus
      @alceedus 6 років тому +6

      auto music he’s a great singer tbh

    • @ianleblanc9111
      @ianleblanc9111 6 років тому +17

      I agree, Jack Black's voice is really nice and I think he could be a great folky singer if he were to work on stuff like Richard Dawson's projects and not cornball of the year kids choice awards stuff

    • @fraoulduke
      @fraoulduke 6 років тому +7

      White privilege :(

    • @ianleblanc9111
      @ianleblanc9111 6 років тому

      Uhm actually LOL a little bit

    • @ewegenia
      @ewegenia 6 років тому +2

      auto music Y'all still talking about him? He killed himself way back in 1932, and y'all still talking about him. Nice.

  • @DoughnutFoundation
    @DoughnutFoundation 6 років тому +188

    Darudethony - Sandstano

    • @oscar278
      @oscar278 6 років тому +8

      DoughnutFoundation hey, 2014 called and said they want their meme back

    • @joex-mn4we
      @joex-mn4we 6 років тому +5

      Mudd Yeah, use 90’s humor, very coherent.

    • @gsawce3687
      @gsawce3687 6 років тому

      good post

    • @moraine_view
      @moraine_view 6 років тому +2

      Originalthony Commentano

  • @botanicus2921
    @botanicus2921 6 років тому +14

    Anthony seems like a cool guy.

  • @beefyboi64
    @beefyboi64 6 років тому +3

    I absolutely love how divisive this album has been. Thats how music should be. The artist should express his conviction even to the disdain of others. Im feeling an 8.5 on this one. I really love it.

  • @yimonozi
    @yimonozi 6 років тому +12

    I feel like this is Jack's strongest album since the end of the White Stripes

  • @aceinthehole1222
    @aceinthehole1222 6 років тому +2

    Didn’t think a 9/10 was coming after his track review of “Connected by Love.”

  • @LocallyConstantDuck
    @LocallyConstantDuck 6 років тому +272

    What is Pitchfork smoking

    • @omarmickelson1204
      @omarmickelson1204 6 років тому +49

      Exactly. They have no CLUE what they're talking about anymore.

    • @gabrieljunod6617
      @gabrieljunod6617 6 років тому +2

      Daniel Pezzi what did they give it?

    • @gabrieljunod6617
      @gabrieljunod6617 6 років тому +2

      Alternative Fact Thanks.

    • @greylepoard
      @greylepoard 6 років тому +33

      Mr. Revan are you sure about that? their bnms this year are: Mount Eerie (white male, indie rock), Soccer Mommy (white female, indie rock), Nicolas Jaar (white male, electronic), SOBxRBE (group rap), US Girls (white female, pop), Car Seat Headrest (white male, rock), and CupcakKe (black female, rap).
      IMO the only 2 that fall under 'SJW hype' are cupcakke and maybe the US Girls album but it was legitmately good. thought Soccer Mommy's album was meh but the rest of them are decent picks

    • @benjaminperez6756
      @benjaminperez6756 6 років тому +29

      knee-jerk reaction after reading Jack's last name

  • @martincisternas4889
    @martincisternas4889 2 роки тому +2

    When this came out, i wasnt able to appreciate the potencial of the album. Now, with a lot of listenings later, genuinely like it a lot.

  • @lukeberrie3942
    @lukeberrie3942 6 років тому +31

    A NINE?! Mushthony Shroomtano back at it again

  • @GuitarbenderS
    @GuitarbenderS 6 років тому +1

    According to Wikipedia: "Misophonia, literally "hatred of sound", was proposed in 2000 as a condition in which negative emotions, thoughts, and physical reactions are triggered by specific sounds." So yea, people who suffer from it have a bad time. That's the point of the track.

  • @shadyweeze
    @shadyweeze 6 років тому +19

    Solid album. Love me some Jack White

  • @chadzagunis331
    @chadzagunis331 6 років тому +1

    Jack said he broke his rule about only making music that he can play in concerts.....and it paid off

  • @phaznac
    @phaznac 6 років тому +32

    You are the only person I've seen saying really good things about this album.

    • @isaaccastro4846
      @isaaccastro4846 6 років тому +5

      Have you listened the album?

    • @thewoat6589
      @thewoat6589 6 років тому +3

      phaznac eh it has several 8s and 9s. Even a 10 from nme. 74 on metacritic isnt too impressive tho

    • @54321FUCKYOU2
      @54321FUCKYOU2 6 років тому +1

      NME gave it 5/5 stars.

    • @GoldenPoopD
      @GoldenPoopD 6 років тому +2

      y’all know this is just his opinion, right?

  • @JP_517
    @JP_517 6 років тому +4

    Dude, I also heard "Connected" a couple of months ago and thought it was crap. Now I cant stop singing it.

  • @tinymusiccritic
    @tinymusiccritic 6 років тому +141

    It's not April Fool's yet Antony

    • @Dismoeyy
      @Dismoeyy 6 років тому

      He called u out in the beginning

    • @Maisara_br
      @Maisara_br 6 років тому +5

      What are u talking about!
      I really liked the album

    • @mairinkenny6638
      @mairinkenny6638 6 років тому +2

      ?? Jack White is fantastic.

    • @tinymusiccritic
      @tinymusiccritic 6 років тому

      Did he? Missed that... What an honour that would have been

  • @jaspermcadams
    @jaspermcadams 6 років тому +1

    "hypermisophoniac" is actually inspired by a medical condition called misophonia, where certain sounds are extremely upsetting for the person who suffers, sending them running for hills or even driving them to tears. So Jack decided to use sounds, instruments and gadgets that made extremely annoying sounds in hopes of creating something beautiful. However, he did say in a recent interview it still came out annoying probably :)

  • @ar-qu3lr
    @ar-qu3lr 6 років тому +6

    jackthony whitetano here the internet's busiest experimental music nerd

  • @Yottifferent
    @Yottifferent 3 роки тому +3

    It’s cool how Jack made his hair the clouds

  • @robbieschertz3726
    @robbieschertz3726 6 років тому +7

    Best part of the album, the Bass solo on Hypermisopheniac

  • @ethanrummel7638
    @ethanrummel7638 6 років тому +1

    Gets better with each listen I think is the key to this album. First time through it sounds random and chaotic, then after repeated visits, the order and genius amidst the cacophony hits you. I would say a soft 9, but still the best thing Jacks done in years.

  • @xprozombieslayer
    @xprozombieslayer 6 років тому +19

    Damn its a good year for music

  • @similost
    @similost 6 років тому +1

    Frank Zappa wouldn't be any more impressed by a new album! I can hear some of his influences in some of Boarding House Reach.

  • @harrisondykhoff
    @harrisondykhoff 6 років тому +7

    2 Things to get used to for the future in the comments:
    1. People getting angry at Anthony for having a different experience listening to the album, and for having different taste.
    2. People that said they hated the album at first talking about how much they love it now (keep in mind that it's OK for reviewers to change you're opinion on the album, as long as you actually go back to the album and GENUINELY ENJOY it more.)

    • @twod0ves
      @twod0ves 6 років тому

      Harry Dykhoff people have been doing this like since Andrew started reviewing

  • @saraharias1992
    @saraharias1992 6 років тому +1

    If I remember correctly Jack tried to put a song together out of sounds that are hard to listen to in hypermisophoniac. Misophonia is the hatred of certain sounds so if you think about its pretty fucking genius.

  • @phisheswonder
    @phisheswonder 6 років тому +4

    I think this album is super interesting. I’m seeing him in August and I’m looking forward to see how he performs these tracks live.

    • @graysonwing2946
      @graysonwing2946 5 років тому

      Saw him live 2 days ago and it was incredible! His drummer blew my mind.

  • @harryhollows4833
    @harryhollows4833 3 роки тому +2

    I just realise he uses a green screen and does not actually put the picture up :(

  • @iBullyDemons
    @iBullyDemons 6 років тому +3

    12:39
    He missed the opportunity to say over and over and over

  • @shayneoneill1506
    @shayneoneill1506 3 роки тому +2

    I kind of love what Jack white did with this album. He's deliberately breaking rules, and I think he's trying to open some doors to let weird shit back into the mainstream. Last time that truly happened was the early 90s and it transformed music for so much the better. We need to do that again, and I suspect thats exactly what Jacks wants too. He's making the most weirdest fucking wildness he can to say "Hey, stop making the same music everyone , try shit nobody else as done"

  • @mattunreal1262
    @mattunreal1262 6 років тому +4

    Put on closed captions to watch google turn "era Beck" into Arabic over and over and over

  • @cwebb128
    @cwebb128 6 років тому +1

    It's funny how Jack White and Julian Casablancas are releasing two of my albums of the year in 2018, both being crazy experimental, who would have thought? Less surprising with Julian because I loved Tyranny and he's been on this kick for a while. They both came out so retro inspired and now their new music is so much more out there and experimental. As a massive fan of both artists early 2000's output, I'm all for it. I wonder if they've heard each others new music and what they think of it, and if Jack was inspired by Julian at all.

  • @ComedyTheater12
    @ComedyTheater12 6 років тому +27

    This album sounds like if fred armisen was to make a band for a portlandia sketch. These are the songs he would make

  • @FancyTophatDude
    @FancyTophatDude 4 роки тому +2

    God i hope he keeps up this direction, it's like he just kicked his rock right back into being cutting edge and experimental and exciting.

  • @tomshrieve
    @tomshrieve 6 років тому +3

    I took me 3 listens through, but I love it so much. Actually I guess technically it was really the first time I had listened to it from start to finish. The vinyl sounds amazing.

  • @greenday48390
    @greenday48390 6 років тому +2

    "Corporation" reminded me a lot of "The Union Forever" from the "old" days