I think some fish are smarter than others. My goldfish got depressed when it's tank mate passed away. My daughter had picked up the fish at the country fair. It even laid next it the other fish when it was dying. The last fish stopped eating and got skiddish. Had to have my daughter go get another goldfish from a friend who had the same fish from the fair to keep the remaining fish company.
Great video , and I totally agree. I do it for the main reason of less maintenance . That's really a matter of opinion on which looks better. Personally I do not think it looks better at all and I had gravel for years in my tanks. I got tired of the vacuuming and it just doesn't look nearly as good as the years go by . I got gravel because that's what people do when they first get a tank , when I would be interested in doing is putting flooring in possibly. I think it looks great regardless. I do decorate it . You also have more room in the tank gravel takes up a lot of volume.
I love bare bottom tanks. I have both a planted tank and 2 bare bottom. The bare bottom tanks are sooooo much cheaper to upkeep!!! And I love love love the way they look in my living room. The fish are easily visible and the tank isn't overwhelmed with decor, gravel, and plants. Very modern look that goes well with just about any room you decide to put it in.
Please forgive me if i missed anything here. I was only able to film and edit this video today. (been a BUSY week!) Here is my fan page: facebook.com/UaruJoey Here is a video where i go more in depth about rays and bare bottom tanks: ua-cam.com/video/UhGWKDI8qn8/v-deo.html
+The king of DIY Thank you for your Videos!! This inspired me to enter the hobby last 2 years ago and gravitate me to get my first dicus soon!! All the love xx
Gravels play a very important role for the development of the beneficial bacteria colony in a fish tank which on long run does most of the job of cleaning/ detoxifying ammonia- nitrite . For bare bottom aquarium it's mostly depends on the fish keeper to do more frequent and regular water changes where as with a highly built beneficial bacteria colony with all those gravels the aquarium does most of the work itself.
I’ve had a bare bottom tank for 2 years and only do a water change when I need to put water bakk in the tank You don’t have to do a lot of Water changes
From a purely tank husbandry standpoint bare bottom is superior (Unless you have fish that forage) because dirt cannot build up. One video complained about your tank looking dirty and having to work harder, but the dirt is always there,,,you just can't ignore it now,,out of sight out of mind. You can siphon out all of the debris and use a magnetic algae scraper to prevent build up like with the sides. As far as appearance goes you can spray paint the bottom, use ceramic tile or even use a sheet that looks like gravel
I never really had the reason of having a bare bottom tank explained to me. I love the aqua-scaped look but to be honest I personally like the large 1 fish or 2 fish tanks bare. It really emphasizes the focus on the fish and gives it more of a stage affect. Thanks for putting up this great informative video!
I just switched to a bear bottom. I have a 55 gal, tank and I can’t keep up with it. Everything was getting out of control. So I broke it down and started from scratch. Much easier to maintain now. The fish didn’t complain about it yet lol.
I guess for me, it all depends on the tank. I've seen a handful of Asian arowanas in my time, and every single one of them has been in a big, open, empty, bare-bottomed tank. I think they'd look odd in anything else. Big showy cichlids, like flowerhorns as an example, just destroy aquascaping anyway, and it's not really worth it to invest the time in painstakingly scaping it just to have some big lumbering oscar wreck it all. But for fish like angels, discus, and dwarf cichlids(because at heart, I am a South American cichlid guy), I like seeing some aquascaping. I want to see the shy little Apistogramma species spying on me through some plants, or the Crenicichla making his home under that piece of driftwood. The only species of fish I have any interest at all in keeping that I'm on the fence about is freshwater rays. I really appreciate the ease of cleaning that comes with bare bottoms, but because my eye would be drawn to the bottom anyway and watching rays flit about in the sand is so interesting, I think I would get more enjoyment out of keeping them on a bed of soft sand, maybe with a few large rounded boulders for interest.
I have bare bottom aquariums. They are soooooooo much easier to maintain. I started out with black sand bottoms. They always housed extensive amounts of fish feces and extra food that would dissolve into the water leading to poor water quality. Since I switched to bare bottom tanks, it's been 100 times easier to maintain.
@@coachdee3554 Ornament type fish; Flowerhorn, Arowana, Goldfish, etc. Any schoolfish type like guppies, archerfish, cichlids, etc. are best with a planted aquarium.
I just put my betta in a ten gallon tank recently with a filter and heater. I made sure the filter is above the water enough to agitate the water like a waterfall so that the surface stays moving. The bottom of the tank is lightly strewn with glass beads of mixed colors so that the bottom of the glass tank shows through. I really like the look of it being like a mirror on the bottom peeking through gems. I find it mysterious actually. It was done by accident because of how they move easily around sliding on the bottom and because I just didn't have the right amount to cover the bottom completely. Then there's the decorative items because kids lol. Not a lot but we have a sunken ship, Spongebob himself and his home, a shark, and a diver looking at a treasure chest. I might take out a couple items though because even that's too much. He's real happy coming from a temporary three gallon I had him in and then finally into a ten gallon now with lots of stuff to look at. I'm so proud because I really wanted to do better by him. He's a pleasant fish and I appreciate his company in my home. It's the least I can do to give back lol.
Hi Joey, have you ever thought about giving the bottoms of your tanks a background like on the back of a tank? Blue, frosted, some attempt at making a sand-look or whatnot? Seems like it might look really cool, while retaining the benefits of the bare bottom.
You are awesome dude. Just starting a new 520 L tank and want Ray's. Bare bottom, you've given me a lot to think about. Building my sump thanks to you and am very pleased with it so far. Keep up the good work.
I have sea sand in mine that I washed over 10 times looks like the sea but in my fry tenk nothing but two plants to hide in but love bear bottom tenks because you can see where all the dirt lies and clean it more effectively then with gravel it also scratches the glass
Reasons for me in keeping a bare bottom tank is due to the fish I keep, Goldfish, as they are very messy. Maintenance is a snap as others have mentioned. Hospital / Quarantine tanks should never have any substrate as it provides cover for any diseases that the fish is carrying. And then there is the time spent sanitizing it after use. The fewer stuff to clean, the better.
yo.. i successly re seal my aquarium and made a new one using window glass, just a litlle one for sump, but it was a big success for beggining and make me want to build more, everytime i go now i look for a neglected glass on the yard .. haha,. (the sump) i have to re-glue it because it was leaking on the first try, but the reseal aquarium is was succes from the first water filling test. just like to let you know i am following you guys.. diy life style inspired and mentored by the king of diy... i planed to keep big pet fish and plants on different tank so i can learn both world aquascape and fishkeeping. i life in south east asia btw.. cheers
I've never seen a bare bottom tank I liked until I saw your arowana tank-great minimalist aesthetic, everything is black except the fish. Can't see the edges or corners or anything behind the tank... it's great! I'd be temped to do similar one for discus if I had the space.
For SW tanks...BB is the only way to go. You take a lot longer to go through the uglies but once Coralline Algae starts to grow on the bottom its not bad at all. Maintenance on a BB is so much easier and quicker. Since I am a SPS Junkie and my tanks require high flow, its very rare I have to vacuum crude off the bottom in a low flow area.
I think that bare bottom tanks are clean classy and puts the focus on the fish. Aside from a planted, flooded forest tanks, and African cichlid tanks, bare is the way to go
My bottom is bare bottom (no substrate) but I have plants standing on rocks (in a rectangular transparent case)... also some wood for Anubias (but not too many) I also have a 3D background and I still think that all I have in it looks good ! I can still keep a Iow maintance aq. and even if it doesn't look great (as others do).. it's not bad either !
I recall a friend who had a big, mostly white and grey, calico fantail goldfish in a tank with an undergravel filter. He did not know about canisters and sumps and probably couldn't have afforded one anyway. Anyhow, this setup was okay most of the time, but the fish was constantly pushing the sand around as goldfish will, looking for food. Every few weeks, this fish would push all of the gravel over to one side of the tank or the other. This would cause the water flow to bypass his biological filter and he would get a huge ammonia spike causing red streaks to appear in the fishes fins. Then he would panic and call me over to move the gravel back do heavy water changes to get rid of the excess ammonia. I didn't know it at the time, but if that fish had been in a bare tank with a sponge or an external biological filter, we would have no problems and the fish would have had a much happier life. What I am trying to say is that for some fish, a bare tank is the best choice. For others, substrates and planting is a better choice. You have to decide based on the needs of the fish that you chose to keep.
do you have an episode on the acrylic thickness etc? what im seeing online available local to me is maybe 1/4 inch at most. awesome channel. I am somewhat new to this hobby and you are definitely motivating me to do my own stuff.
Another good reason is if you have rocks or gravel or any substrate your fish will swallow it, if they can fit it in there mouth and that could kill them.
This was the truth you preached here Joey. I just transitioned from a Dirted Planted Aquarium to a bare bottom, and I am LOVING it!!! My filters are almost always clean, water changes and maintenance are a breeze, and my discus can reach all the food that falls to the bottom of the tank. They couldn't do that before with the carpeting dwarf sag I had. I think all my discus set ups are now destined to be bare bottom, however, I may keep 1 display planted tank. Great video on a touchy subject Joey
Italian Supreme I started off with a planted discus tank, with much success, but lately I just got bored of it and tore it down. Check out some of my vids and you'll see
I do 8 out of 14 tanks bare bottom just for the fact I keep very messy fish. A range of goldfish (commons, comets, shubunkins, sarasa, wakins, moors, fantails, ryukin, oranda). Only reasons I went bare bottoms with them is 1: gravel is ugly and 2: the fish kept eating the sand. They actually started to poop sand. Besides the odd breeding mop I toss in the tanks are bare. Even one of my bettas has bare a bottom. Just because I rather his coloring and features be the focus. He does have a cave and some plants but other than that nothing else in there. The common plecos, yoyo loaches, cory cats and tetras all have sand but I hate the sand as well. Plecos keep playing in it which throws it into the filter. Cories don't look all that great against it. Yoyos need it to feel safe.
What about beneficial bacteria? I've heard some keepers say that bare bottom tanks can have issues with water quality, because there are fewer surfaces available for nitryfying bacteria to grow on, and that having substrate greatly increases the amount of good bacteria in the tank. Is this true?
@@danielcrespo802 Of course you do, the question is whether it's going to be sufficient to handle the tank's bioload, especially with an internal filter where the surface of the media is quite small.
Morganna Well a think it depends the needs of each tank, for example, I have 3 goldfish on a bare bottom tank And my filter is a canister so I have a lot of space in it for biological filtration and it works well for me, I haven’t had any issues.
I love bare tank keeping. but over the years I started to appreciate tanks with substrate. and also light colored substrate in my black colored tanks will brighten up better than black base.
love the vids joey. I can tell you put a lot of hard work and thought into them. their very informative and full of great tips and how 2s , I also really like your newer vids with the family....its fun watching your hobby tastes evolving over time.........keep it up king of diy
Now upfront, I really like planted tanks. That said, there is another good reason why some big tanks don't have substrate... cost. If you want good planting media (Amazonia, Eco Complete etc.) the cost of the substrate can easily exceed the cost of the tank, filter, and heater (combined), and this cost ratio (equipment to the substrate) only goes up the large the tank.
Job well done Joey, I watch your videos all the time and I guess I never actually realized that you were bare bottomed all of that time. I guess you are keeping better stock than I am. I usually have something in the tank, just to help the beneficial bacteria have a home other than a filter. I've had to many filter failures to risk crashing a tank.
love the videos man every time i try something new for my tanks i go right for your channel I've learned allot built lol and on my budget it's important i really appreciate what you do
One of my bettas isn't doing good in a divided tank chewing his fins to pieces, but did really well in my 2 gallon hospital tank. So we're going to try out a bare bottom tank to see if he improves.
Great coverage on all aspects of this topic. I think it helps people understand why people set up tanks the way they do. Gaining an appreciation of different styles instead of just turning your nose at them reactively. I like planted tanks for my own aesthetic, but your arawana tank shows how a bare bottom can actually enhance the viewing experience. Ok... That last sentence would only make sense to another fish keeper and not make it sound soooo wrong.
Kind of like living in a empty home because you don't like cleaning then the car goes because you don't like vacuuming the inside and filling up the gas tank then the grass in the garden won't stop growing so grass goes....., I think i will use a bit of sand maybe not
I agree that large tanks actually don't need to have a substrate since who likes to vacuum a large tank that you're unsure if you really clean the substrate because you can't see the detritus below. In smaller tanks I think it's much preferable since it's the opposite of what I've said.
i think you should do a build for the people that want to do everything diy like a small 2ft tropical tank with 2 pipes a syphon and return with a small homemade external filter like myself some people love making everything themselves instead of buying a external filter like if a part brakes then there paying 20 dollars for a new piece and its a pain ... just a idea and videos on how to treat water and get good oxygen rates and some aqua scape like have a tank just for showing how to and what to use when aquascaping just would be cool to see
I bare bottom for my goldfish since they are so messy and it makes keeping them clean easier and faster. I'd rather be able to clean fast and have marbles the fish can play with and kick around for enrichment.
Started from bare went to substrate and finally went back to bare, much easier fishes are fine with or without them their totally fine swimming eating and growing nicely.
Interesting looking back, after the incident with Buddy. In this video you tell us how you prefer no drift wood or other items that the fish could bump into, get spooked and possibly injure itself. I subscribed to your channel shortly before you started building the 2k tank. I wonder if it was your own doing, or were viewers persuading you to scape that one? You were correct in this video. I think it would be good to see you do perhaps an update video on barebottoms and edit in a short clip from this vid, and tell everyone to keep fish in the appropriate environments. You have the knowledge. I just picked up my 4th tank yesterday, with fish. One 10" oscar, 2-12" plecko's, and 2 other cool smaller fish, dont know the species yet. They survived the 45 minute ride from Modesto, ca in a 5gal bucket, hooray! But now I'm trying to learn how to set this tank up. Poor guys are in a 30g holding tank for the moment. The previous owner was using 2 canisters. I have one sump in use, love it. I want to set this up with an awesome sump, but trying to decide between a wier, silent overflow box or those nice overflow pieces from custom aquariums, like in your racking system?? Would be fun to have you be a part in this one. Thanks for being here!
Joey, if you could turn back time, would you have left the 2000G tank bare bottomed. I suppose you just have to take a chance and hope your fish wont do crazy things. Sorry again about Buddy
Kinda ironic cuz the fish that's behind him, he actually did put a piece of wood in the tank and he swam around a lot one night and hit the wood injured his swim bladder and then died
I went bare bottom but I painted under the bottom of the glass with very light beige and created a spackle effect so now it looks like there is sand at the bottom of the tank . I do miss the mirror effect .
can my medium size goldfish live healthy in a bare bottom 2ft tank ? a have a huge sponge filter and some plastic plants and an airstone blowing decent amount of bubbles
Sorry if I missed the answer to this elsewhere, but I was curious if your Asian Arowana likes plants? I guess I just feel as if the fish would want something to swim through and/or a little something to look at and interact with. I understand the possible dangers of harder decorations such as driftwood, just curious about plants that may be native to this fish's natural habitat in the wild. Love your videos by the way and I enjoy the interesting things I learn :)
Great video! A bare bottom tank sounds very appealing due to maintenance. Everything in my aquarium is currently covered in brown algae. How will removing the decorations and the substrate affect the biofilter? I have a hob filter.
Joey I have a question hopefully you can answer, my favorite fish is a Colombian Catfish. The minute I saw it in Walmart I fell in love with it so I decided to do a research about the fish. I cannot conclude if I should put one in a complete salt water or a brackish water tank, I would love if you could answer this question and help me clarify as I love how these fish look
So Im keeping smaller, MUCH smaller tanks then youself because Im not good at building, but Ive heard that nitrites/nitrates get higher in bare bottom tanks because there is more bacteria in substrated tank for the N cycle. Like you could probably go longer without water changes if you have substrate. Now Ive just got guppies/BN plecos breeding, and im curious to your thought.
Hey joey have you ever seen a 3D background on the floor of the aquarium. Because that’s what I’m getting ready to do. A thin universal rocks background on the floor and a rock wall on the back. What do you think?👍🏼👍🏼
All I needed to know it’s OK if it’s OK to make a bare bottom aquarium because I’m planning on getting a gram just for Molly and I feel like it would just be easier to clean the tank if it was bare bottom and now I know it’s OK that’s all I need to know
here's one. show pleco tanks that seem to be spotless?!?! It's a trick right? They have to be filming posy cleaning right?! Can there be a way to evacuate the constant flow of pleco poo? no right? They will often say, "the flow blows it right into the intake" but come on... your thoughts?
+Jef B (808fishkeeper) totally possible. Circulation in a bare bottom tank is everything. It might not blow it all directly to the intake, but keeps it suspended long enough to eventually be sucked up.
What about the fish having no stimulation whatsoever, just swimming back and forth, wouldn't they like a smooth rock tunnel to explore? They won't get ripped up by that.
Hi joey!!!hope you don't mind me asking, but do you have a job? Or is UA-cam your job? Just a. Quick question, hope you don't mind. As always, amazing video. Also, please keep us updated with the drop off acrylic tank!! Anyways, will it be saltwater or freshwater? Lol. Looking forward to future videos.
I put some background wallpaper under the tank. It looks cool from above, but invisible from front. Screw gravel, I hate cleaning it
me too
Oh that's a great idea. Completely agree with you.
Lazy. You should stop keeping fish honestly.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
My red devil literally got into a severe depression when I removed the substrate. I had to put it back on in 2 days. He even stopped eating.
I think some fish are smarter than others. My goldfish got depressed when it's tank mate passed away. My daughter had picked up the fish at the country fair. It even laid next it the other fish when it was dying. The last fish stopped eating and got skiddish. Had to have my daughter go get another goldfish from a friend who had the same fish from the fair to keep the remaining fish company.
Whenever i see the king of diy uploaded a video i get so excited... Especially after work. They are so relaxing and yet informative
Great video , and I totally agree. I do it for the main reason of less maintenance . That's really a matter of opinion on which looks better. Personally I do not think it looks better at all and I had gravel for years in my tanks. I got tired of the vacuuming and it just doesn't look nearly as good as the years go by . I got gravel because that's what people do when they first get a tank , when I would be interested in doing is putting flooring in possibly. I think it looks great regardless. I do decorate it . You also have more room in the tank gravel takes up a lot of volume.
I love bare bottom tanks. I have both a planted tank and 2 bare bottom. The bare bottom tanks are sooooo much cheaper to upkeep!!! And I love love love the way they look in my living room. The fish are easily visible and the tank isn't overwhelmed with decor, gravel, and plants. Very modern look that goes well with just about any room you decide to put it in.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
Please forgive me if i missed anything here. I was only able to film and edit this video today. (been a BUSY week!)
Here is my fan page: facebook.com/UaruJoey
Here is a video where i go more in depth about rays and bare bottom tanks: ua-cam.com/video/UhGWKDI8qn8/v-deo.html
+The king of DIY Thank you for your Videos!! This inspired me to enter the hobby last 2 years ago and gravitate me to get my first dicus soon!!
All the love xx
What happened to this arowana?
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
Gravels play a very important role for the development of the beneficial bacteria colony in a fish tank which on long run does most of the job of cleaning/ detoxifying ammonia- nitrite . For bare bottom aquarium it's mostly depends on the fish keeper to do more frequent and regular water changes where as with a highly built beneficial bacteria colony with all those gravels the aquarium does most of the work itself.
I’ve had a bare bottom tank for 2 years and only do a water change when I need to put water bakk in the tank You don’t have to do a lot of Water changes
@@user-ek8cg7tm5s how long did it take for your beneficial bacteria to build up ?
You just have to compensate for it by doubling your filtration.
Instead of one sponge filter, add one more.
Yup I was gonna say the same. Getting bigger filter would solve that. I kept everything in bare tanks lol
Bare bottom is lifeeeeee
It's prison life if you're a fish xD
From a purely tank husbandry standpoint bare bottom is superior (Unless you have fish that forage) because dirt cannot build up. One video complained about your tank looking dirty and having to work harder, but the dirt is always there,,,you just can't ignore it now,,out of sight out of mind. You can siphon out all of the debris and use a magnetic algae scraper to prevent build up like with the sides.
As far as appearance goes you can spray paint the bottom, use ceramic tile or even use a sheet that looks like gravel
I put my betta fish on bare bottom 5 gal tank, he is happy swimming freely.. no issues.. I just symphon everyday the poops..
I never really had the reason of having a bare bottom tank explained to me. I love the aqua-scaped look but to be honest I personally like the large 1 fish or 2 fish tanks bare. It really emphasizes the focus on the fish and gives it more of a stage affect. Thanks for putting up this great informative video!
+DebTim A CANADIAN Girl I think it looks amazing for display fish if done correctly.
It might be visually pleasing for you, but what about the well being of the fish itself?? How would you feel like living in a bare bottom aquarium??
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
I just switched to a bear bottom. I have a 55 gal, tank and I can’t keep up with it. Everything was getting out of control. So I broke it down and started from scratch. Much easier to maintain now. The fish didn’t complain about it yet lol.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
I guess for me, it all depends on the tank. I've seen a handful of Asian arowanas in my time, and every single one of them has been in a big, open, empty, bare-bottomed tank. I think they'd look odd in anything else. Big showy cichlids, like flowerhorns as an example, just destroy aquascaping anyway, and it's not really worth it to invest the time in painstakingly scaping it just to have some big lumbering oscar wreck it all.
But for fish like angels, discus, and dwarf cichlids(because at heart, I am a South American cichlid guy), I like seeing some aquascaping. I want to see the shy little Apistogramma species spying on me through some plants, or the Crenicichla making his home under that piece of driftwood.
The only species of fish I have any interest at all in keeping that I'm on the fence about is freshwater rays. I really appreciate the ease of cleaning that comes with bare bottoms, but because my eye would be drawn to the bottom anyway and watching rays flit about in the sand is so interesting, I think I would get more enjoyment out of keeping them on a bed of soft sand, maybe with a few large rounded boulders for interest.
meh, look like cheesy hospital tanks
I did my first bare bottom aquarium yesterday :)
I have bare bottom aquariums. They are soooooooo much easier to maintain. I started out with black sand bottoms. They always housed extensive amounts of fish feces and extra food that would dissolve into the water leading to poor water quality. Since I switched to bare bottom tanks, it's been 100 times easier to maintain.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
@@coachdee3554 Ornament type fish; Flowerhorn, Arowana, Goldfish, etc. Any schoolfish type like guppies, archerfish, cichlids, etc. are best with a planted aquarium.
@@adamxiong1817 thanks for replying...I wanted a cichlid, but ok
I just put my betta in a ten gallon tank recently with a filter and heater. I made sure the filter is above the water enough to agitate the water like a waterfall so that the surface stays moving. The bottom of the tank is lightly strewn with glass beads of mixed colors so that the bottom of the glass tank shows through. I really like the look of it being like a mirror on the bottom peeking through gems. I find it mysterious actually. It was done by accident because of how they move easily around sliding on the bottom and because I just didn't have the right amount to cover the bottom completely. Then there's the decorative items because kids lol. Not a lot but we have a sunken ship, Spongebob himself and his home, a shark, and a diver looking at a treasure chest. I might take out a couple items though because even that's too much. He's real happy coming from a temporary three gallon I had him in and then finally into a ten gallon now with lots of stuff to look at. I'm so proud because I really wanted to do better by him. He's a pleasant fish and I appreciate his company in my home. It's the least I can do to give back lol.
Never knew why people do this. I always thought it looked bad, but Defintly some valid reasons to do it.
Hi Joey, have you ever thought about giving the bottoms of your tanks a background like on the back of a tank? Blue, frosted, some attempt at making a sand-look or whatnot? Seems like it might look really cool, while retaining the benefits of the bare bottom.
You are awesome dude. Just starting a new 520 L tank and want Ray's. Bare bottom, you've given me a lot to think about. Building my sump thanks to you and am very pleased with it so far. Keep up the good work.
I have sea sand in mine that I washed over 10 times looks like the sea but in my fry tenk nothing but two plants to hide in but love bear bottom tenks because you can see where all the dirt lies and clean it more effectively then with gravel it also scratches the glass
Reasons for me in keeping a bare bottom tank is due to the fish I keep, Goldfish, as they are very messy. Maintenance is a snap as others have mentioned. Hospital / Quarantine tanks should never have any substrate as it provides cover for any diseases that the fish is carrying. And then there is the time spent sanitizing it after use. The fewer stuff to clean, the better.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
yo.. i successly re seal my aquarium and made a new one using window glass, just a litlle one for sump, but it was a big success for beggining and make me want to build more, everytime i go now i look for a neglected glass on the yard .. haha,. (the sump) i have to re-glue it because it was leaking on the first try, but the reseal aquarium is was succes from the first water filling test. just like to let you know i am following you guys.. diy life style inspired and mentored by the king of diy... i planed to keep big pet fish and plants on different tank so i can learn both world aquascape and fishkeeping. i life in south east asia btw.. cheers
I love bare bottom tanks. I've transitioned all my tanks to bare bottom except my planted community and I'm happy with them.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
I've never seen a bare bottom tank I liked until I saw your arowana tank-great minimalist aesthetic, everything is black except the fish. Can't see the edges or corners or anything behind the tank... it's great! I'd be temped to do similar one for discus if I had the space.
For SW tanks...BB is the only way to go. You take a lot longer to go through the uglies but once Coralline Algae starts to grow on the bottom its not bad at all. Maintenance on a BB is so much easier and quicker. Since I am a SPS Junkie and my tanks require high flow, its very rare I have to vacuum crude off the bottom in a low flow area.
bare bottoms are easier for maintenance but are not a good look. pros and cons for both.
It looks great with my goldfish but maybe it's because the fish are just beautiful and it helps put the focus on the fish.
yogosans14 aquaiurms with plants and dirt is much more appealing the human eye in my opinon.
MasterAquatics with tropical fish yes. But goldfish look better in a bare bottom IMO and they eat up plants anyways.
I think that bare bottom tanks are clean classy and puts the focus on the fish. Aside from a planted, flooded forest tanks, and African cichlid tanks, bare is the way to go
Is it posible for me to take out all the sand out of my aquarium
I'd wondered about the bare-bottom tanks; now I can see why you do that. BTW, and totally of-topic, you have a perfect "narrator's voice." :)
My bottom is bare bottom (no substrate) but I have plants standing on rocks (in a rectangular transparent case)... also some wood for Anubias (but not too many)
I also have a 3D background and I still think that all I have in it looks good !
I can still keep a Iow maintance aq. and even if it doesn't look great (as others do).. it's not bad either !
Perfect!
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
Have a new 150 acrylic coming.Time for pots , a few pieces of driftwood and a B/B !
I recall a friend who had a big, mostly white and grey, calico fantail goldfish in a tank with an undergravel filter. He did not know about canisters and sumps and probably couldn't have afforded one anyway. Anyhow, this setup was okay most of the time, but the fish was constantly pushing the sand around as goldfish will, looking for food. Every few weeks, this fish would push all of the gravel over to one side of the tank or the other. This would cause the water flow to bypass his biological filter and he would get a huge ammonia spike causing red streaks to appear in the fishes fins. Then he would panic and call me over to move the gravel back do heavy water changes to get rid of the excess ammonia. I didn't know it at the time, but if that fish had been in a bare tank with a sponge or an external biological filter, we would have no problems and the fish would have had a much happier life. What I am trying to say is that for some fish, a bare tank is the best choice. For others, substrates and planting is a better choice. You have to decide based on the needs of the fish that you chose to keep.
Awesome video. I've never done bare bottom tanks before but will give it a try for me next one
do you have an episode on the acrylic thickness etc? what im seeing online available local to me is maybe 1/4 inch at most. awesome channel. I am somewhat new to this hobby and you are definitely motivating me to do my own stuff.
Another good reason is if you have rocks or gravel or any substrate your fish will swallow it, if they can fit it in there mouth and that could kill them.
Any one just watching the blue fish in the background!! Haha (is it an Arowana)
This was the truth you preached here Joey. I just transitioned from a Dirted Planted Aquarium to a bare bottom, and I am LOVING it!!! My filters are almost always clean, water changes and maintenance are a breeze, and my discus can reach all the food that falls to the bottom of the tank. They couldn't do that before with the carpeting dwarf sag I had. I think all my discus set ups are now destined to be bare bottom, however, I may keep 1 display planted tank. Great video on a touchy subject Joey
+Maurice Aquariums Agreed, when it's something like discus especially. Bare bottoms are fantastic. Always wanted to do a planted discus though.
Italian Supreme I started off with a planted discus tank, with much success, but lately I just got bored of it and tore it down. Check out some of my vids and you'll see
I feel alot of fish need / enjoy substrate , plants and rocks/ hiding caves. Do your fish ever seem bored ?
I do 8 out of 14 tanks bare bottom just for the fact I keep very messy fish. A range of goldfish (commons, comets, shubunkins, sarasa, wakins, moors, fantails, ryukin, oranda). Only reasons I went bare bottoms with them is 1: gravel is ugly and 2: the fish kept eating the sand. They actually started to poop sand. Besides the odd breeding mop I toss in the tanks are bare. Even one of my bettas has bare a bottom. Just because I rather his coloring and features be the focus. He does have a cave and some plants but other than that nothing else in there. The common plecos, yoyo loaches, cory cats and tetras all have sand but I hate the sand as well. Plecos keep playing in it which throws it into the filter. Cories don't look all that great against it. Yoyos need it to feel safe.
What kind of fish do you suggest is the best fish for a bare bottom tank?
a very explicative video - Just loved it ! thank you for the wisdom !
Found your channel today and subscribed today 👍 very informative video, thanks. 🙂
What about beneficial bacteria? I've heard some keepers say that bare bottom tanks can have issues with water quality, because there are fewer surfaces available for nitryfying bacteria to grow on, and that having substrate greatly increases the amount of good bacteria in the tank. Is this true?
Obviously on your filter media you have mechanical filtration and biological filtration so you can have a bare bottom tank.
@@danielcrespo802 Of course you do, the question is whether it's going to be sufficient to handle the tank's bioload, especially with an internal filter where the surface of the media is quite small.
Morganna Well a think it depends the needs of each tank, for example, I have 3 goldfish on a bare bottom tank And my filter is a canister so I have a lot of space in it for biological filtration and it works well for me, I haven’t had any issues.
I love bare tank keeping. but over the years I started to appreciate tanks with substrate. and also light colored substrate in my black colored tanks will brighten up better than black base.
We don't have a tank set up that way yet, but I really love the look of it. It's simple and classy and showcases the fish :)
I must of missed this video.wow Joey my respects to you. thank for the link amoment ago. from LA California
You are awesome man!! All the way from South Africa!!
love the vids joey. I can tell you put a lot of hard work and thought into them. their very informative and full of great tips and how 2s , I also really like your newer vids with the family....its fun watching your hobby tastes evolving over time.........keep it up king of diy
Now upfront, I really like planted tanks. That said, there is another good reason why some big tanks don't have substrate... cost. If you want good planting media (Amazonia, Eco Complete etc.) the cost of the substrate can easily exceed the cost of the tank, filter, and heater (combined), and this cost ratio (equipment to the substrate) only goes up the large the tank.
Job well done Joey, I watch your videos all the time and I guess I never actually realized that you were bare bottomed all of that time. I guess you are keeping better stock than I am. I usually have something in the tank, just to help the beneficial bacteria have a home other than a filter. I've had to many filter failures to risk crashing a tank.
love the videos man every time i try something new for my tanks i go right for your channel I've learned allot built lol and on my budget it's important i really appreciate what you do
One of my bettas isn't doing good in a divided tank chewing his fins to pieces, but did really well in my 2 gallon hospital tank. So we're going to try out a bare bottom tank to see if he improves.
Great coverage on all aspects of this topic. I think it helps people understand why people set up tanks the way they do. Gaining an appreciation of different styles instead of just turning your nose at them reactively. I like planted tanks for my own aesthetic, but your arawana tank shows how a bare bottom can actually enhance the viewing experience. Ok... That last sentence would only make sense to another fish keeper and not make it sound soooo wrong.
Kind of like living in a empty home because you don't like cleaning then the car goes because you don't like vacuuming the inside and filling up the gas tank then the grass in the garden won't stop growing so grass goes....., I think i will use a bit of sand maybe not
Awesome video as always Joey. Keep up the good work.
I agree that large tanks actually don't need to have a substrate since who likes to vacuum a large tank that you're unsure if you really clean the substrate because you can't see the detritus below. In smaller tanks I think it's much preferable since it's the opposite of what I've said.
I watched this so many times over because in doing schoolwork on it
Very useful.... Sir plz make some video for 4 feet fresh water aquarium bottom fish waste filtering system....
I'm looking forward to the new planted tanks and smaller fish videos!!!
i think you should do a build for the people that want to do everything diy like a small 2ft tropical tank with 2 pipes a syphon and return with a small homemade external filter like myself some people love making everything themselves instead of buying a external filter like if a part brakes then there paying 20 dollars for a new piece and its a pain ... just a idea and videos on how to treat water and get good oxygen rates and some aqua scape like have a tank just for showing how to and what to use when aquascaping just would be cool to see
Another great video Joey!
I bare bottom for my goldfish since they are so messy and it makes keeping them clean easier and faster. I'd rather be able to clean fast and have marbles the fish can play with and kick around for enrichment.
Started from bare went to substrate and finally went back to bare, much easier fishes are fine with or without them their totally fine swimming eating and growing nicely.
Can you talk about filtration for aquariums without substrate?
Can you make a video on how to transition from freshwater to saltwater/marine. Thanks~~~
Bare bottom = cleaner water
Nice video bro!!!! Cant wait to see the new videos coming bro keep the great work up!!!
can fish "feel" bored?
Interesting looking back, after the incident with Buddy. In this video you tell us how you prefer no drift wood or other items that the fish could bump into, get spooked and possibly injure itself. I subscribed to your channel shortly before you started building the 2k tank. I wonder if it was your own doing, or were viewers persuading you to scape that one? You were correct in this video. I think it would be good to see you do perhaps an update video on barebottoms and edit in a short clip from this vid, and tell everyone to keep fish in the appropriate environments. You have the knowledge.
I just picked up my 4th tank yesterday, with fish. One 10" oscar, 2-12" plecko's, and 2 other cool smaller fish, dont know the species yet. They survived the 45 minute ride from Modesto, ca in a 5gal bucket, hooray! But now I'm trying to learn how to set this tank up. Poor guys are in a 30g holding tank for the moment. The previous owner was using 2 canisters. I have one sump in use, love it. I want to set this up with an awesome sump, but trying to decide between a wier, silent overflow box or those nice overflow pieces from custom aquariums, like in your racking system?? Would be fun to have you be a part in this one. Thanks for being here!
I do believe I wrote "get that drift wood out of there Aro's are jumpers" RIP Buddy
What about floating plants they really wouldn't do much harm and they would help filter the water and add a little bit of naturality?
Joey, if you could turn back time, would you have left the 2000G tank bare bottomed. I suppose you just have to take a chance and hope your fish wont do crazy things. Sorry again about Buddy
ey thanks for all the info you give man cool vids too keep up the good work 👍👍
Planted tank and smaller fish? Wow you hinted at your fish house this far back!?!
Kinda ironic cuz the fish that's behind him, he actually did put a piece of wood in the tank and he swam around a lot one night and hit the wood injured his swim bladder and then died
I went bare bottom but I painted under the bottom of the glass with very light beige and created a spackle effect so now it looks like there is sand at the bottom of the tank . I do miss the mirror effect .
can my medium size goldfish live healthy in a bare bottom 2ft tank ? a have a huge sponge filter and some plastic plants and an airstone blowing decent amount of bubbles
JoE as long as the tank is bigger than 10 gallons
Jack Golden ouh , it is more that 10 gallon so i should be safe
Sorry if I missed the answer to this elsewhere, but I was curious if your Asian Arowana likes plants? I guess I just feel as if the fish would want something to swim through and/or a little something to look at and interact with. I understand the possible dangers of harder decorations such as driftwood, just curious about plants that may be native to this fish's natural habitat in the wild. Love your videos by the way and I enjoy the interesting things I learn :)
Great video! A bare bottom tank sounds very appealing due to maintenance. Everything in my aquarium is currently covered in brown algae. How will removing the decorations and the substrate affect the biofilter? I have a hob filter.
thank you for a informative video. I want to try this. :)
have you ever thought about keeping a Dovii? you like big fish and big tanks. it's a perfect match
Joey I have a question hopefully you can answer, my favorite fish is a Colombian Catfish. The minute I saw it in Walmart I fell in love with it so I decided to do a research about the fish. I cannot conclude if I should put one in a complete salt water or a brackish water tank, I would love if you could answer this question and help me clarify as I love how these fish look
I use bare bottoms with my Goldfish, they are so messy. bare bottom makes cleaning so much eaiser.
So Im keeping smaller, MUCH smaller tanks then youself because Im not good at building, but Ive heard that nitrites/nitrates get higher in bare bottom tanks because there is more bacteria in substrated tank for the N cycle. Like you could probably go longer without water changes if you have substrate. Now Ive just got guppies/BN plecos breeding, and im curious to your thought.
Hey joey have you ever seen a 3D background on the floor of the aquarium. Because that’s what I’m getting ready to do. A thin universal rocks background on the floor and a rock wall on the back. What do you think?👍🏼👍🏼
Another great video, thank you
When your fish was little was he expensive ? Maybe a better question is when do they start to go up in price ?
nice video
Sir you are awesome! Love your videos!
All I needed to know it’s OK if it’s OK to make a bare bottom aquarium because I’m planning on getting a gram just for Molly and I feel like it would just be easier to clean the tank if it was bare bottom and now I know it’s OK that’s all I need to know
Wooo what a beautiful arowana tank . Did you put a black flim in background and sides or what.
My fish committed suicide from the bare glass bottom so sad
I have a beautiful fish and I don’t know what she is. So you know if you could help identify what kind of fish she is ? I want another one so bad
I love the Arowana
haha if you have Brown Algae with no reason on a old tank, that's not easy haha
Great thought joey
here's one. show pleco tanks that seem to be spotless?!?! It's a trick right? They have to be filming posy cleaning right?! Can there be a way to evacuate the constant flow of pleco poo? no right? They will often say, "the flow blows it right into the intake" but come on...
your thoughts?
+Jef B (808fishkeeper) totally possible. Circulation in a bare bottom tank is everything. It might not blow it all directly to the intake, but keeps it suspended long enough to eventually be sucked up.
i only use bare bottoms for fairy shrimp
Any leads on how to get an Asian arowana? Great video! I feel the same! Water n fish that's it!!
What about the fish having no stimulation whatsoever, just swimming back and forth, wouldn't they like a smooth rock tunnel to explore? They won't get ripped up by that.
Not all speices get stimulation out of decorations.diffrent speices have different needs
@@briannaharter4411 What stimulation? there's nothing there. There must be something they would like.
@@i8dpie they can see out of the tanm,they get food,ECT.
You don't need decorations for stimulation.
@@briannaharter4411 okay we'll just agree to disagree
Good explanation
have you ever tried to breed arowana? love the videos keep it up.
damn dude that arrowana is enormous
Hi joey!!!hope you don't mind me asking, but do you have a job? Or is UA-cam your job? Just a. Quick question, hope you don't mind. As always, amazing video. Also, please keep us updated with the drop off acrylic tank!! Anyways, will it be saltwater or freshwater? Lol. Looking forward to future videos.