As you know by now chad these were our local lads neighbours lived near us, n how proud we are of each of them here in our streets, now on this our rob stunning voice is wonderful n a real blessing to us we loved them as cheeky chaps n bit nawty boys but always so sweet n charming. N so gifted U see n hear. Fabulous northern normal guys in every way, humble n just so nice, blessed now heavenly angels of the highest level of acclaim. God given words he later said from his garden , anyways thank you U play n hear wat we already knew, wow they amazing. We like the end of the rainbow song that was sung to our poorly rob as he passed over. ❤❤❤❤ God it hurts still missing themxxx
Yes, You not only heard the songs Robin sang, you also felt them! The emotional deliverance combined with Robin gorgeous voice is indescribably beautiful!! This is one of my very favorite songs. Notice how intense Robins voice starts getting towards the ending... Almost crying out the lyrics! #Chills😍
Robin said that much of this song was ad-libbed, which to me adds to the stunning nature of his talent. Not only that he, Barry and Maurice were writing immortal hits like Words and To Love Somebody when they were just teenagers -- but that Robin could go into the studio and essentially write this gorgeous song as he went, recording it in a single take.
Thanks, Chad! You really get the BeeGees. I wasn’t a big fan in their disco days, but a few months ago I started down the rabbit hole and am still there. They were unique and brilliant, and exploring their music is a wonderful trip. I’ve watched quite a few of your reactions and you express many of my own opinions. So glad I found your channel!
Robin continued to do this song. I think he did it in 1997 One Night Only Las Vegas show. And it still sounded fantastic. I don't know how anyone can listen to it without their eyes watering up.
I remember Robin singing this in Wembley Stadium, London. The entire show was amazing but when he stepped forward and began this one you could have heard a pin drop as everyone was just enthralled.
I was fortunate to be at the concert at Festival Hall in Melbourne in 1974, saw the Bee Gees again at the Tennis Centre in Melbourne in 1989 and then saw Robin perform at the Palais in Melbourne, one of the last concerts he did before his unfortunate passing. Thank you for taking me back to revisit those most wonderful, glorious times
Sweet sweet Robin with his amazing voice….born in 1953 I grew up with their music and still after all these years I find myself watching them on UA-cam before I go to bed…. they accompanied me throughout my life…
Me, too! Born in '53. This wonderful group (and Robin especially) have gotten me through some really rough days. I really don't think I could ever get through the rest of my life if it weren't for my daily dose of Bee Gees!
Very much the same,for me.Born in ‘51,and loving them,since the first time I heard Robin’s voice,I love them all,of course,and they are my time for bed group. Usually Too much Heaven.
Oooh 1974 in Melbourne. Mr Natural tour. Robin is just wonderful!! This song fit him perfectly. Yes, you hit on the solemnity. The vibe is real. Mo even left him alone for this one. 💞
What a giant hole there would be,in the world,if the Bee Gees hadn’t existed.I just hope they knew how much they were loved,by their fans,and that Barry still does.💘🇬🇧
Love this concert Melbourne 74.... Robin sang lead on this song beautiful! He also sang I can’t see anyone and my favourite I started a joke ❤️ He was truly amazing. This is the best of Robin...Love him Always and Forever “ The voice” ❤️🙏❤️
Oh, Robin !!!! He sounds like an angel ascending to the skies. That vibrato is so powerful an instrument. Thanks, Chad. This one really touches me. Much love.
I really needed this tonight. Robin’s performance was angelic. I saw Bee Gees live in early 70s. Robin actually wore this same shirt. I cherish my memories
How beautiful. This is the song that finally made me a long-life Bee Gee fan. I remember hearing it somewhere and was immediately overwhelmed. I haven't heard it for ages after that. I didn't have the record, but when I heard the song again after years, I felt the same as I did then. This unique voice, the melody and of course the lyrics; esp. “ cause love to me is life and I live you”) I read somewhere that the first recording in the record studio was so good that it was fully used for the release. Only the orchestra was added. Brilliant talent as its best. Thank you Chad for this reaction!
Absolutely beautiful singing from this beautiful man. I love this song. This gives me chills to watch him sing this. I don’t care what video it is of him. I just love Robin Gibb ❤️❤️
So gorgeous and emotive - only Robin's unique voice could achieve the spiritual undertone. I feel, over the years that Robin's true talent was sometimes quashed because of the use of Barry's falsetto on most songs....But oh how I love the BeeGees - I still cry when I think of Robin and Maurice no longer with us. 😥
Sim Robin muito foi ofuscada por aquela voz sem graça , sem sal , sem qualidade a voz de Barry .Aliás pra mim Barry foi sem graça em tudo . Robin se quisesse poderia ter uma carreira solo , já Barry não porque Barrry sem Robin é muito sem graça pro meu gosto . Imagina essa música cantada sem bateria e sem guitarras e sem nenhum instrumento ? Seria o céu aqui na terra .
A comparison to liturgical music is not silly at all. His voice was that of an angel. He put his soul and his heart into his music. Isn't that what religion is supposed to be, giving your soul and your heart? That's precisely what Robin did. He could raise simple words and a melody to a spiritual level. He was "The Church of Robin" encapsulated in an ethereal voice. His wife said he was the most spiritual man she ever knew. By giving his heart and soul he could reach out and touch ours. A tremendous rare gift for him to give and for us to receive.
In an interview with just Barry he was saying how people on TV would make fun of his voice. He said they did it because it was easy to do but no one ever made fun of Robin's voice because it couldn't be done. His voice was so unusual and couldn't be duplicated. All I know is if I hear a song from Robin it will me stop in my tracks. If you read anything or listen to any interviews by Robin you will hear about his spiritual thoughts. In fact he's buried in the church yard across the road from his Premberly estate which a deep and rich history of religion and spirituality since before the days of Joan of Arc.
Simply put - brilliantly sung. When I get to heaven I am sure angels will sound just like his voice. There is no one alive that can sound like him. I miss you so much Robin. Rest in peace.
Instant CHILLS!! Wow, Robin's voice....this song is a very moving one. Then again, Robin's voice is just so soothing! Thank you Chad, for bringing all these songs I have never heard. At least I can say at 53 of age I have heard a BIG deal of these beautiful ones songs! Peace and Love
This song sends chills down my back. Robin is at his best here, and the lyrics are amazing. I remember Barry talking about how Robin had this dark, yet almost spiritual side, and the songs that he sang lead on reflected that. But this song has a line in it that I think is pure poetry. "For love to me is life, and I love you." Then he follows that profound thought with, "Then I wake up. Then I grow up.' Wow!
I love this song! Its just so beautiful. The album version was recorded in one take and Robin improvised some of the lyrics on the spot. The line, "For love to me is life, and I live you" expresses so much depth of feeling in so few words. Those words and Robin's vocal is absolutely captivating.
One of my favorite concerts😍 THE ENTIRE THING IS PURE ENTERTAINMENT...BEE GEES AT THEIR BEST, STRONG❤ Robins voice is angelic, but his sound is only this way within the group, I never thought it sound the same by himself, even this solo...is within the group. To think they sing their own words...from the ❤
Angelic is the perfect word to describe Robin’s voice. This song reminds me of my friends & I putting our hand to one ear whenever we sang BeeGees songs as kids in the 1960s/70s.
Chad, thank you for giving me a pick for this weekend's marathon and thank you for your wonderful reaction to one of my all time favorites! I thought you would enjoy this song and I truly believe that you did. What an amazing weekend it's been already and I'm so looking forward to what you have in store for us next. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
Pure brilliance, what we get here! Their live-concerts as well as most of their albums always took so much profit out of leadvocals by Barry and Robin or sometimes Maurice, but he's been the one, bringing in their trademark, three part harmony at his best. Fourtimes, I've been visiting Bee Gees concerts, once only Robin on his Magnet-tour. So I'll tellya, the true magic was the three of them!
Thanks so much for doing one of my favourite songs. I think that Robin's voice and emotion in his performances was at its peak in this era. I'm still puzzled as to how he went from this extremely emotional style to wearing dark glasses and standing still grasping the microphone stand later in life. His voice was always amazing though, whatever the era.
@@juanita6479 - I think that was part of it. The HAIR was a vital part of his persona regardless of the style, length or colour. The fact that he often changed the style indicated that was part of his self image. The guy, to me at least, gave an aura of insecurity (certainly not deserved) and when those beautiful locks disappeared it must have been devastating to him. As someone once said, "If the hair fell out of your dog, would you want to pet him"!
@@juanita6479 - Well dang, why didn't he consult you? LOL!!!! I hate to malign anyone but it seems their father was not a particularly loving person. Robin said in an interview (2002) his father was a man to be feared, not loved. Hugh lived vicariously through his sons because he was a failure personally and couldn't make ends meet. Many parents do that, some in a kind sensible manner, some otherwise. What father would call someone with a magical voice a "bleating Billy goat" to their face and tell them to shut up? That Billy goat made them millions. To give him credit, he did push his offspring to succeed. The problem is, at what cost?
@@juanita6479 - Mo also said he never hesitated to say "I love you" to his children because his own father never did! Adam and Sam adored him. Who didn't?
This is a great song by Robin. Really enjoyed the reaction. I never made the link to the gospel, I guess here in the Netherlands they sing in a different way.
I don't necessarily think it's a gospel type of sound. I just think it's solemn and could be thought of as spiritual. Mr. Natural has some more of what I would call a gospel sound - "Give a Hand Take a Hand" is one. Oh that's a good one.
I swear. Robin is one of the few artists that can make me cry. My friends are not surprised! Because I’m a crier, lol but c’mon! Robin is amazing. Period. Thank you. Oh! And a suggestion. Have you heard Alone? Off of their Still Waters album.
Hello, Dorothy, and thanks for your feedback! Great news! I've covered the song "Alone", and if you're interested in watching my reaction, here's the link: ua-cam.com/video/fXO8kP0vI88/v-deo.html
I love this performance. So many of the songs done at this concert were awesome, Chad you should watch the whole thing just because it is good 👍 😀 😊 Some of the songs you've already reacted to were done really good at this concert.
Robin's sweet voice is remarkable, his voice is so smooth. I love the Bee Gees they are the best. Chad your reaction is very sweet!! If you want to hear a great rock and roll by the Bee Gees it's absolutely great. The song is...To Be or Not to Be please consider reacting I think you will love it as well as others.
About the religious "feel" of the song -- many of the Bee Gees songs made reference to God, as does the final line of this one, "The sun will shine if just for you and the Lord" (although another artist made a cover changing and diminishing the close). As others have said, the Hither Green train accident in which Robin heroically helped the injured and dying added spiritual depth to his singing. And of course he lived in a 12th-century former monastery, within sight of the churchyard where he is buried.
Yes, Chad, I can certainly see why you got the Gospel vibe from this. The guys went to a parochial school for a while early on, so you may well be on to something. I know this song always touches me when I hear it and I couldn't venture to even guess how many times that's been. At least hopefully now you have a different feeling about wishing the group had utilized Robin's voice more especially now that you've gotten into a few more of the earlier songs - and there's a lot more yet to go. 😊 Great reaction. ❤
I once saw a piece where Barry made a trip back to their old school. He remembered how they were kicked out of the choir, because they would create their own harmonies.
I believe it was Mo. Barry went into the assembly room and started singing "All Things Bright and Beautiful" like he was 9 years old again. The teacher with him said they still sing the song, but not as beautifully as Barry.
![[REACTION] Bee Gees - Medley (Live in Melbourne, 1989)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VCRZVBE3r_M/mqdefault.jpg)
![[REACTION] Bee Gees - Medley (Live in Melbourne, 1989)](/img/tr.png)
*_FOR MY FULL BEE GEES PLAYLIST, FOLLOW THIS LINK BEFORE MAKING REQUESTS:_* ua-cam.com/play/PLSnNE4tdNL-rR68vDdLHlOD-HXQ_vHUHE.html
As you know by now chad these were our local lads neighbours lived near us, n how proud we are of each of them here in our streets, now on this our rob stunning voice is wonderful n a real blessing to us we loved them as cheeky chaps n bit nawty boys but always so sweet n charming. N so gifted U see n hear. Fabulous northern normal guys in every way, humble n just so nice, blessed now heavenly angels of the highest level of acclaim. God given words he later said from his garden , anyways thank you U play n hear wat we already knew, wow they amazing. We like the end of the rainbow song that was sung to our poorly rob as he passed over. ❤❤❤❤ God it hurts still missing themxxx
N chad love you love Ur channel n.love U love our locals. We used to know🫂😇🫂😇🩵🩵🩵🥰🥰🥰
In my opinion, the best male vocalist ever!!!! Such heart and soul, just amazing.
We should never ever compare !! but ur right !! CHEERS!!
I am 63 years old and I have been in love with the Bee Gees since I was 11. No one can harmonize like those brothers.
Totally understand. I am 67 and fell in love with them when I was 13 when they were on The Ed Sullivan Show.
Me too
I understand how you feel. I'm 63 and I fell in love with that beautiful songbird in 1969. I was 9. Thanks to my mom buying a beegees album
Robin and his emotions sure come out here. Beautiful Chad❤
That iconic voice! There’ll never be another.
That 1974 concert was awesome. Robin has the voice of an angel. Effortless and rare. Happy we had him as long as we did
This song is beautifully sad and superbly done by Robin with a direct line from his heart to ours. Tears flow everytime...
Robin’s voice is hauntingly beautiful 🎶 there will never be another Robin 🎶🤩
My favorite song! With beautiful Robin singing lead. Thanks so much Chad.
His voice is so lovely and unique. So emotional. He draws me in and just melts my heart. Fabulous!!!!!
One of my favourite concerts Melbourne 1974.... Simply stunning vocal by Robin ❤️❤️❤️
The way Robin’s voice rose above the crashing percussion,and guitars,is so uplifting.And the strength of his vibrato is wonderful to hear.
I have to add this I don’t think I’ve ever seen anybody sing a song with as much emotion and depth and feeling as he did. Oh my goodness!!
And just like that… you are hooked! And love them forever ❤❤❤
Robin’s voice was loud, trembling and intense. Full of vulnerability and emotion. It was truly a gift.
Yes, You not only heard the songs Robin sang, you also felt them! The emotional deliverance combined with Robin gorgeous voice is indescribably beautiful!! This is one of my very favorite songs. Notice how intense Robins voice starts getting towards the ending... Almost crying out the lyrics! #Chills😍
#Chills every single time. ❤️
Bravo !! Bravo!!! The one & only Bee Gees !!!
Incredible lyric: "Love to me is life and I live you". A 17 year old wrote that.
Robin said that much of this song was ad-libbed, which to me adds to the stunning nature of his talent. Not only that he, Barry and Maurice were writing immortal hits like Words and To Love Somebody when they were just teenagers -- but that Robin could go into the studio and essentially write this gorgeous song as he went, recording it in a single take.
I never get tired of listening to Robin. I love the songs that he takes a lead or has a solo part in.
I agree with you.
Thanks, Chad! You really get the BeeGees. I wasn’t a big fan in their disco days, but a few months ago I started down the rabbit hole and am still there. They were unique and brilliant, and exploring their music is a wonderful trip. I’ve watched quite a few of your reactions and you express many of my own opinions. So glad I found your channel!
Robin continued to do this song. I think he did it in 1997 One Night Only Las Vegas show. And it still sounded fantastic. I don't know how anyone can listen to it without their eyes watering up.
I can see where you get the gospel sound to this song. It’s very haunting but I love that it honors Robin’s voice.
I remember Robin singing this in Wembley Stadium, London. The entire show was amazing but when he stepped forward and began this one you could have heard a pin drop as everyone was just enthralled.
I was fortunate to be at the concert at Festival Hall in Melbourne in 1974, saw the Bee Gees again at the Tennis Centre in Melbourne in 1989 and then saw Robin perform at the Palais in Melbourne, one of the last concerts he did before his unfortunate passing.
Thank you for taking me back to revisit those most wonderful, glorious times
This is my favorite Robin solo. Just stunning.
Robin's voice had an opera sound to it. I loved the harmonies at the end.
Sweet sweet Robin with his amazing voice….born in 1953 I grew up with their music and still after all these years I find myself watching them on UA-cam before I go to bed…. they accompanied me throughout my life…
Me, too! Born in '53. This wonderful group (and Robin especially) have gotten me through some really rough days. I really don't think I could ever get through the rest of my life if it weren't for my daily dose of Bee Gees!
Very much the same,for me.Born in ‘51,and loving them,since the first time I heard Robin’s voice,I love them all,of course,and they are my time for bed group.
Usually Too much Heaven.
Patty-I was born in 50 and have been listening to them since I was 17. Robin was always my favorite and still is. His voice sooths me.
Robin's voice always gave me chills.
To quote Mo, Robin had the voice that touched your heart.
Oooh 1974 in Melbourne. Mr Natural tour. Robin is just wonderful!! This song fit him perfectly. Yes, you hit on the solemnity. The vibe is real. Mo even left him alone for this one. 💞
What a giant hole there would be,in the world,if the Bee Gees hadn’t existed.I just hope they knew how much they were loved,by their fans,and that Barry still does.💘🇬🇧
Love this concert Melbourne 74.... Robin sang lead on this song beautiful! He also sang I can’t see anyone and my favourite I started a joke ❤️ He was truly amazing. This is the best of Robin...Love him Always and Forever “ The voice” ❤️🙏❤️
Oh, Robin !!!! He sounds like an angel ascending to the skies. That vibrato is so powerful an instrument.
Thanks, Chad. This one really touches me. Much love.
I really needed this tonight. Robin’s performance was angelic.
I saw Bee Gees live in early 70s. Robin actually wore this same shirt. I cherish my memories
Thank you Chad. In this clip, Robin's not only singing but also vibrating love energy to the audience. He is a magnet for love.
Incredible. My Lord that was gorgeous.
How beautiful. This is the song that finally made me a long-life Bee Gee fan. I remember hearing it somewhere and was immediately overwhelmed. I haven't heard it for ages after that. I didn't have the record, but when I heard the song again after years, I felt the same as I did then. This unique voice, the melody and of course the lyrics; esp. “ cause love to me is life and I live you”)
I read somewhere that the first recording in the record studio was so good that it was fully used for the release. Only the orchestra was added. Brilliant talent as its best.
Thank you Chad for this reaction!
Easily an utterly beautiful ballad sung by a beautiful, one of a kind beautiful voice. ❤
So beautiful!!!! Robin's voice is like no other on this Earth. Goosebumps.
Robin 最高ーーー！
Absolutely beautiful singing from this beautiful man. I love this song. This gives me chills to watch him sing this. I don’t care what video it is of him. I just love Robin Gibb ❤️❤️
When Barry released his album of duets, he did an AMA Reddit live thread. I asked him which song best showcased Robin's voice, and he said this one.
Robin at his best
He was always at his best no matter the style but his ballads....WOW! Untouchable.
Robin Gibb - a distinctive, exquisite and truly unique voice that went forever quiet way too soon...💜
Fan-friggin-tastic!! geez, i'm so glad you finally did this one! I just feel like it's Robin's best Solo, lead vocal!
The crowd roars their love,when Robin sings💕
i never get tired of hering Robins voice...such a loss..
One of my absolute favorites of Robin's songs where he is leading.
So gorgeous and emotive - only Robin's unique voice could achieve the spiritual undertone. I feel, over the years that Robin's true talent was sometimes quashed because of the use of Barry's falsetto on most songs....But oh how I love the BeeGees - I still cry when I think of Robin and Maurice no longer with us. 😥
I agree with your whole comment. I wish Robin and Mo were still with us. Thankfully we still have their music.
Sim Robin muito foi ofuscada por aquela voz sem graça , sem sal , sem qualidade a voz de Barry .Aliás pra mim Barry foi sem graça em tudo . Robin se quisesse poderia ter uma carreira solo , já Barry não porque Barrry sem Robin é muito sem graça pro meu gosto . Imagina essa música cantada sem bateria e sem guitarras e sem nenhum instrumento ? Seria o céu aqui na terra .
My thoughts exactly!!!
So much soul in his voice, brings chills to a person.👍👍😎
Robins voice was sheer perfection every note . Never again will we ever witness a voice like that again
Beautiful!
A comparison to liturgical music is not silly at all. His voice was that of an angel. He put his soul and his heart into his music. Isn't that what religion is supposed to be, giving your soul and your heart? That's precisely what Robin did. He could raise simple words and a melody to a spiritual level. He was "The Church of Robin" encapsulated in an ethereal voice. His wife said he was the most spiritual man she ever knew. By giving his heart and soul he could reach out and touch ours. A tremendous rare gift for him to give and for us to receive.
Perfectly said Susie Q perfectly said perfect
In an interview with just Barry he was saying how people on TV would make fun of his voice. He said they did it because it was easy to do but no one ever made fun of Robin's voice because it couldn't be done. His voice was so unusual and couldn't be duplicated. All I know is if I hear a song from Robin it will me stop in my tracks. If you read anything or listen to any interviews by Robin you will hear about his spiritual thoughts. In fact he's buried in the church yard across the road from his Premberly estate which a deep and rich history of religion and spirituality since before the days of Joan of Arc.
Robins home was The Prebendal. Premberly is a fictitious place.
Robin was very Spiritual IMO
My god, that song had me holding my breath. Its so deep i was afraid i would miss the lyrics from loud breathing.🎶🎶🎶🎶😍😍😍 great pick chad💞💞
Simply put - brilliantly sung. When I get to heaven I am sure angels will sound just like his voice.
There is no one alive that can sound like him. I miss you so much Robin. Rest in peace.
OMG. Chad, what a beauty of perfection, from Robin.
almost every day I try to sing this song. I really feel the joy of this song. really idolize bee gees
Instant CHILLS!! Wow, Robin's voice....this song is a very moving one. Then again, Robin's voice is just so soothing! Thank you Chad, for bringing all these songs I have never heard. At least I can say at 53 of age I have heard a BIG deal of these beautiful ones songs!
Peace and Love
This song sends chills down my back. Robin is at his best here, and the lyrics are amazing. I remember Barry talking about how Robin had this dark, yet almost spiritual side, and the songs that he sang lead on reflected that. But this song has a line in it that I think is pure poetry. "For love to me is life, and I love you." Then he follows that profound thought with, "Then I wake up. Then I grow up.' Wow!
I love this song! Its just so beautiful. The album version was recorded in one take and Robin improvised some of the lyrics on the spot. The line, "For love to me is life, and I live you" expresses so much depth of feeling in so few words. Those words and Robin's vocal is absolutely captivating.
"Love to me is life and I live you." Sigh.
One of my favorite concerts😍
THE ENTIRE THING IS PURE ENTERTAINMENT...BEE GEES AT THEIR BEST, STRONG❤
Robins voice is angelic, but his sound is only this way within the group, I never thought it sound the same by himself, even this solo...is within the group.
To think they sing their own words...from the ❤
One of my favorite songs, love Robin’s voice!❤
Saw them perform this in the early 70's, what a beautiful song and I became a life long fan. Thanks for playing it Chad
Another brilliant song from the truly amazing Robin … thank you Chad ❤️
Robin The Voice!
Simply incredible.
Vibrato mais belo q já habitou esse mundo . Que outro homem tinha uma voz com esse vibrato ? NENHUM . Robin I love forever ❤
I’m in love, again!❤
Simply gorgeous… and oh yeah, he sings good too.
Angelic is the perfect word to describe Robin’s voice. This song reminds me of my friends & I putting our hand to one ear whenever we sang BeeGees songs as kids in the 1960s/70s.
ROBIN GIBB . forever in my heart
Beatiful song , he is very british
Thanks Chad for this video
Chad, thank you for giving me a pick for this weekend's marathon and thank you for your wonderful reaction to one of my all time favorites! I thought you would enjoy this song and I truly believe that you did. What an amazing weekend it's been already and I'm so looking forward to what you have in store for us next. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
Ditto.
I totally agree
Robin at his best, lovely.
Pure brilliance, what we get here! Their live-concerts as well as most of their albums always took so much profit out of leadvocals by Barry and Robin or sometimes Maurice, but he's been the one, bringing in their trademark, three part harmony at his best. Fourtimes, I've been visiting Bee Gees concerts, once only Robin on his Magnet-tour. So I'll tellya, the true magic was the three of them!
Amazing the poetry in his voice 😘
Thanks so much for doing one of my favourite songs. I think that Robin's voice and emotion in his performances was at its peak in this era. I'm still puzzled as to how he went from this extremely emotional style to wearing dark glasses and standing still grasping the microphone stand later in life. His voice was always amazing though, whatever the era.
I don't get that either. His demeanor changed drastically. Why? He was a balladeer and perhaps was not comfortable with up tempo songs?
@@juanita6479 - I think that was part of it. The HAIR was a vital part of his persona regardless of the style, length or colour. The fact that he often changed the style indicated that was part of his self image. The guy, to me at least, gave an aura of insecurity (certainly not deserved) and when those beautiful locks disappeared it must have been devastating to him. As someone once said, "If the hair fell out of your dog, would you want to pet him"!
@@juanita6479 - Well dang, why didn't he consult you? LOL!!!!
I hate to malign anyone but it seems their father was not a particularly loving person. Robin said in an interview (2002) his father was a man to be feared, not loved. Hugh lived vicariously through his sons because he was a failure personally and couldn't make ends meet. Many parents do that, some in a kind sensible manner, some otherwise. What father would call someone with a magical voice a "bleating Billy goat" to their face and tell them to shut up? That Billy goat made them millions. To give him credit, he did push his offspring to succeed. The problem is, at what cost?
@@juanita6479 - Mo also said he never hesitated to say "I love you" to his children because his own father never did! Adam and Sam adored him. Who didn't?
New subscriber here. Love the BeeGees. Thanks so much!
One of my favorites
I loved your reaction to this Chad.
Love this one.
In questa voce ci sono tutti i generi musicali. grandi Robin e fratelli.
grazie Chad sono i migliori del mondo
Grazie Chad x il tuo apprezzamento. Robin e fratelli sono da UNESCO
This is a great song by Robin. Really enjoyed the reaction. I never made the link to the gospel, I guess here in the Netherlands they sing in a different way.
I don't necessarily think it's a gospel type of sound. I just think it's solemn and could be thought of as spiritual. Mr. Natural has some more of what I would call a gospel sound - "Give a Hand Take a Hand" is one. Oh that's a good one.
I think that is my favorite of Robins work. Very beautiful! Thank you for this review!!!
I swear. Robin is one of the few artists that can make me cry. My friends are not surprised! Because I’m a crier, lol but c’mon! Robin is amazing. Period. Thank you. Oh! And a suggestion. Have you heard Alone? Off of their Still Waters album.
Hello, Dorothy, and thanks for your feedback! Great news! I've covered the song "Alone", and if you're interested in watching my reaction, here's the link:
ua-cam.com/video/fXO8kP0vI88/v-deo.html
I love this performance. So many of the songs done at this concert were awesome, Chad you should watch the whole thing just because it is good 👍 😀 😊 Some of the songs you've already reacted to were done really good at this concert.
Absolutely 💯 gorgeous 😍 ❤ 💕 luv you Robin.💦RIP had a voice of an angel 😇
Robin's sweet voice is remarkable, his voice is so smooth. I love the Bee Gees they are the best. Chad your reaction is very sweet!! If you want to hear a great rock and roll by the Bee Gees it's absolutely great. The song is...To Be or Not to Be please consider reacting I think you will love it as well as others.
What a beautiful song from my favourite group
Never heard this one and I thought I had heard their music.
Patty-Chad, there's nothing wrong with that. Robin had the ability to sing like he was in a gospel choir. Warms my heart.
Uau!! Que voz fantástica de Robin Gibb! Linda canção! Todos os aplausos pra esse artista incrível!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤
One of my favs... thanks... love it!
Great reacreaction to this song Chad, I agree with you 💯😉
About the religious "feel" of the song -- many of the Bee Gees songs made reference to God, as does the final line of this one, "The sun will shine if just for you and the Lord" (although another artist made a cover changing and diminishing the close). As others have said, the Hither Green train accident in which Robin heroically helped the injured and dying added spiritual depth to his singing. And of course he lived in a 12th-century former monastery, within sight of the churchyard where he is buried.
Para mi la voz sexy, Hot, dulce, profunda, tenía todo Robin Gibb para cantar lo que quisiera
Sir Robín Gibb Patrimonio de la Humanidad
I think you're very astute. I used to sing in my church choir, and yes, this is very akin to the kinds of hymns and music we would sing for services.
On that concert there's a Song you should react. "Road to Alaska"
I love this song. Always have.
When you said I realized why I like Robin 's version of frist noel so much .
Yes, Chad, I can certainly see why you got the Gospel vibe from this. The guys went to a parochial school for a while early on, so you may well be on to something. I know this song always touches me when I hear it and I couldn't venture to even guess how many times that's been. At least hopefully now you have a different feeling about wishing the group had utilized Robin's voice more especially now that you've gotten into a few more of the earlier songs - and there's a lot more yet to go. 😊 Great reaction. ❤
I once saw a piece where Barry made a trip back to their old school. He remembered how they were kicked out of the choir, because they would create their own harmonies.
@@jamihede4440 - I thought it was Mo that said that. LOL
I believe it was Mo. Barry went into the assembly room and started singing "All Things Bright and Beautiful" like he was 9 years old again. The teacher with him said they still sing the song, but not as beautifully as Barry.
@@janicetrimmell6897 No. This was with Barry alone. It was after his brothers had gone.
@@jamihede4440 Okay, maybe so. I'm sure they all talked about it at different times.
Un gran cantante y super musico los numero uno