Bro if Tua had the weapons Herbert did he would have put up equal numbers. Herb has elite traits and size and Tua has elite anticipation and accuracy. At this point in their careers if you asked who is still getting better I’d say Tua
@jonathandill5529 both what? Keenan is awesome and mike williams when healthy is really good td target. And herbert had the best rookie year until stroud.
Stop capping 😂😂😂 herbie had mike williams keenen allen and eckler to start his career oh it was sweet those couple of years for the bolts who tua had? Flores ,to co-offenencive coordinators in eric studsvill and george godsey and weapons like devante parker and brian hartline who are not in the league anymore but now you want switch places no let's see what type of player he is now facing adversity and the media on your back constantly like tua has.
Herbert has more physical talent than Tua and has a ceiling to be an elite QB in the NFL, like Mahomes and Allen. Tua does not have these physical gifts, but there have been elite QBs that didn't have them, e.g., Drew Brees. If one were to swap them, with the current rosters of both teams, Miami would be a serious contender, no matter the weather or other external factors. However, I think it is unreasonable to assume that the current iteration of the Dolphins would have come to life if they had drafted Justin Herbert in 2020. Given Herbert's rookie year success and good numbers thereafter, who is to say that Brian Flores wouldn't have remained as HQ for another year or that the Dolphins would have gotten Tyreek Hill? My point is that the current version of the dolphins is a product of drafting Tua in 2020 and starting to build an ecosystem around him after two years of not helping him at all, really. It will always remain a hypothetical, but I believe if Herbert would have been the Dolphins QB for these two years, Mike McDaniels wouldn't be the HC and Tyreek Hill wouldn't be WR1 in Miami, as the circumstances that led to him being hired wouldn't have been there. TL:DR Herbert on today's Dolphin would raise the ceiling of this team. But drafting Herbert in 2020 most likely wouldn't have led to the current iteration of the Dolphins. I like the current iteration of the phins and I think they are quite well setup for long term success with that coaching staff etc, so in the end I'm happy about the Tua pick.
Herbert had a better offense with Ekeler, Allen, Williams, and Palmer and still couldnt do nothing. Tua only had Parker, but his defense was better. Swapping them on draft day wouldn't have made a huge difference. You cant talk about any what if's after that because the situations wouldn't have went the exact same way and Tyreek said he went to Miami to play with Tua, so if Tua was on the Chargers, then I think Tyreek would have went there.
Bro if Tua had the weapons Herbert did he would have put up equal numbers. Herb has elite traits and size and Tua has elite anticipation and accuracy. At this point in their careers if you asked who is still getting better I’d say Tua
Tua has the best wr in the league.......
@@joh6629
Didn't herbie had both to start his career?
@@joh6629 No one called Tyreek the best wr until he got to Miami
@@Justino754 lol
@jonathandill5529 both what? Keenan is awesome and mike williams when healthy is really good td target. And herbert had the best rookie year until stroud.
If Herbert went to dolphins Miami would have multiple SBs
At the very least win a couple of playoff games.
Stop capping 😂😂😂 herbie had mike williams keenen allen and eckler to start his career oh it was sweet those couple of years for the bolts who tua had? Flores ,to co-offenencive coordinators in eric studsvill and george godsey and weapons like devante parker and brian hartline who are not in the league anymore but now you want switch places no let's see what type of player he is now facing adversity and the media on your back constantly like tua has.
Herbert has more physical talent than Tua and has a ceiling to be an elite QB in the NFL, like Mahomes and Allen. Tua does not have these physical gifts, but there have been elite QBs that didn't have them, e.g., Drew Brees.
If one were to swap them, with the current rosters of both teams, Miami would be a serious contender, no matter the weather or other external factors. However, I think it is unreasonable to assume that the current iteration of the Dolphins would have come to life if they had drafted Justin Herbert in 2020. Given Herbert's rookie year success and good numbers thereafter, who is to say that Brian Flores wouldn't have remained as HQ for another year or that the Dolphins would have gotten Tyreek Hill?
My point is that the current version of the dolphins is a product of drafting Tua in 2020 and starting to build an ecosystem around him after two years of not helping him at all, really. It will always remain a hypothetical, but I believe if Herbert would have been the Dolphins QB for these two years, Mike McDaniels wouldn't be the HC and Tyreek Hill wouldn't be WR1 in Miami, as the circumstances that led to him being hired wouldn't have been there.
TL:DR Herbert on today's Dolphin would raise the ceiling of this team. But drafting Herbert in 2020 most likely wouldn't have led to the current iteration of the Dolphins.
I like the current iteration of the phins and I think they are quite well setup for long term success with that coaching staff etc, so in the end I'm happy about the Tua pick.
Herbert had a better offense with Ekeler, Allen, Williams, and Palmer and still couldnt do nothing. Tua only had Parker, but his defense was better. Swapping them on draft day wouldn't have made a huge difference. You cant talk about any what if's after that because the situations wouldn't have went the exact same way and Tyreek said he went to Miami to play with Tua, so if Tua was on the Chargers, then I think Tyreek would have went there.
Name the pro caliber WR/RBs during Herbert’s Oregon years…….
None I Agree , Alabama would have been undefeated if Herbert was the Qb
@@2VSBROTHER Mr. Hypothetical man strikes again