Heres some pairings to add confusion to the mix. Ashara had a baby with Brandon which was Jon. Rhaegar and Lyanna had a baby which was Daenerys. Aerys and Rhaella had a baby that which was stillborn. Ned baby swaps Silver haired Dany (couldnt pass off as his own bastard), with Asharas dark haired Jon (could pass off as his own bastard), Ashara fakes her death and baby swaps silver haired Daenerys with Aerys and Rhaellas baby just before Whilem Darry heist. We need more baby swaps in our theories :)
Have you done a video speculating about the House Dayne words/house motto? I’ve seen some interesting theories like “Fallen & Reborn” (their words in the online game), “And now it begins” (Arthur Dayne’s supposed last words), or even something from the Nights Watch Oath like “the light that brings the dawn” (or sword in the darkness, etc)? I am a big fan of Houses that choose an aesthetic and commit to the bit and the stars/meteor/big sword aesthetic is simply iconic to me so I hope the house words align LOL
i do have a house dayne video on here but i’ll be honest in that when i discuss the speculation i admit that i honestly have no idea 😂 like i could speculate but i don’t feel like i have enough information from the text to make a prediction that someone else hasn’t already
I wouldn't be mad if Ashara Dane turns out to be Jon Snow's mother. Her and Liana might be a double bluff by George. If she's not, I reckon that she faked her death and there's some magic shit with house Dane, that she for some reason needed to show Ned at the tourney (like, you need to keep Jon safe and maybe get him to go to the night's watch when he's old enough for big bad winter reasons) that she also needed to fake her death to go do something about. Or she's Ashara Reed now, whichever.
Nope. Im still on the team Athur Dayne & Liyana. Got an active slap bet on it and Im 95% sure Im gonna get slap but I am committed. No specific reason, I just like chaos. Also algorithm thingy and "D&D only skim the books" on my stonehead. Cheers.
This gets a bit convoluted. I'm not saying it's right, just something to consider. If you don't think the parallels in the story are relevant then this will make even less sense. I'm going to skip over the Jon parent bit, unless you're interested. We'll focus on the Ashara side of things. There are several things to consider, all of them her connection to Elia as a handmaid. Remember Elia was told she'd die if she had a second child. Imagine you're Rhaegar and Elia, two of your besties are Arthur and Ashara. Assuming you had a plan for three kids and it was looking very shaky, who would offer help and who would you ask for help? A little girl from the north or someone you see every day? You're probably going to want to save your wife but maintain the illusion she had the last one or two. You just need someone to secretly have the baby while Elia remains in bed for months feigning pregnancy. Who would you ask, who would agree? Ashara may well be the mother of the real Aegon (and thus fAegon). What about Dany? There are many more suggestions that Rhaegar at the very least is her father, like the HotU vision where he looks at her and says there will be a 3rd. She is compared more often to him than anyone else. If Ashara was in Starfall or ToJ hiding a second pregnancy for Elia it would make sense. It's not the only possibility, but it would work. There's also the chance Elia fled KL for a different reason. She was "dishonored' by Aerys. This would fit Selmy's lament. He couldn't protect Ashara the way he wanted because he was KG. Then of course there's Lyanna and Jon. There is very likely a reason that GRRM put a Targaryen born of 2 generations of incest, and 3 three Lannisters (Tywin married his cousin). It would only make sense if he were foreshadowing when he then tells us Rickard married his cousin. The best answer for Jon's mother has always been Lyanna, however I believe romantic idealism has blinded readers for years as to who his father is. At this point you should be able to figure out who that is.
Heres some pairings to add confusion to the mix. Ashara had a baby with Brandon which was Jon. Rhaegar and Lyanna had a baby which was Daenerys. Aerys and Rhaella had a baby that which was stillborn. Ned baby swaps Silver haired Dany (couldnt pass off as his own bastard), with Asharas dark haired Jon (could pass off as his own bastard), Ashara fakes her death and baby swaps silver haired Daenerys with Aerys and Rhaellas baby just before Whilem Darry heist. We need more baby swaps in our theories :)
i think i may have lost the will to live reading these 😂 but thank you for your service 🫡
N + A = J is my absolute favorite ASOIAF theory, but i know it isn't true by the biggest evidence of all: Cersei think it's true, so it must be false
a great point 😂
Cat believes it true also
The way Liana and Ashara haunt the narrative!
Ashara being everywhere in the walls is hilarious, and I am choosing to believe it's true. 😂
Ashara is obviously Jon’s father, Rhani!
obviously! how could i have missed this?! 😂
IT'S SO OBVIOUS!
My tiktok just told me it's not available anymore 😭 glad to see you over here!
Donal Noye pulls Jon to the side and tells him to check his privilege.
Have you done a video speculating about the House Dayne words/house motto? I’ve seen some interesting theories like “Fallen & Reborn” (their words in the online game), “And now it begins” (Arthur Dayne’s supposed last words), or even something from the Nights Watch Oath like “the light that brings the dawn” (or sword in the darkness, etc)?
I am a big fan of Houses that choose an aesthetic and commit to the bit and the stars/meteor/big sword aesthetic is simply iconic to me so I hope the house words align LOL
i do have a house dayne video on here but i’ll be honest in that when i discuss the speculation i admit that i honestly have no idea 😂 like i could speculate but i don’t feel like i have enough information from the text to make a prediction that someone else hasn’t already
that young Dayne is Edric Dayne, also known as Ned, the Lord of Starfall and the head of House Dayne in the books
I wouldn't be mad if Ashara Dane turns out to be Jon Snow's mother. Her and Liana might be a double bluff by George. If she's not, I reckon that she faked her death and there's some magic shit with house Dane, that she for some reason needed to show Ned at the tourney (like, you need to keep Jon safe and maybe get him to go to the night's watch when he's old enough for big bad winter reasons) that she also needed to fake her death to go do something about. Or she's Ashara Reed now, whichever.
I can no longer access my tik tok, ran to UA-cam and followed Rhani first
my first TT to YT follow too
I think we will never really know who his mom is
Ashara is NOT Howland Reed's wife, Ashara IS Howland Reed /jk
Nope. Im still on the team Athur Dayne & Liyana. Got an active slap bet on it and Im 95% sure Im gonna get slap but I am committed. No specific reason, I just like chaos. Also algorithm thingy and "D&D only skim the books" on my stonehead. Cheers.
This gets a bit convoluted. I'm not saying it's right, just something to consider. If you don't think the parallels in the story are relevant then this will make even less sense.
I'm going to skip over the Jon parent bit, unless you're interested. We'll focus on the Ashara side of things.
There are several things to consider, all of them her connection to Elia as a handmaid. Remember Elia was told she'd die if she had a second child. Imagine you're Rhaegar and Elia, two of your besties are Arthur and Ashara. Assuming you had a plan for three kids and it was looking very shaky, who would offer help and who would you ask for help? A little girl from the north or someone you see every day? You're probably going to want to save your wife but maintain the illusion she had the last one or two. You just need someone to secretly have the baby while Elia remains in bed for months feigning pregnancy. Who would you ask, who would agree? Ashara may well be the mother of the real Aegon (and thus fAegon). What about Dany? There are many more suggestions that Rhaegar at the very least is her father, like the HotU vision where he looks at her and says there will be a 3rd. She is compared more often to him than anyone else. If Ashara was in Starfall or ToJ hiding a second pregnancy for Elia it would make sense. It's not the only possibility, but it would work. There's also the chance Elia fled KL for a different reason. She was "dishonored' by Aerys. This would fit Selmy's lament. He couldn't protect Ashara the way he wanted because he was KG.
Then of course there's Lyanna and Jon. There is very likely a reason that GRRM put a Targaryen born of 2 generations of incest, and 3 three Lannisters (Tywin married his cousin). It would only make sense if he were foreshadowing when he then tells us Rickard married his cousin. The best answer for Jon's mother has always been Lyanna, however I believe romantic idealism has blinded readers for years as to who his father is. At this point you should be able to figure out who that is.
Ashara is only mentioned once in Ned POV chapters and that one mention is from Cersei
Ashara = Lyanna lets go
Are you going to create original content or its just the back up for short videos from tt?
definitely making original content! i just dropped the first episode of my podcast on here!
@@rhanialam thank you for answer! I just saw thw live it was great! Definitely waiting for more! Good luck!
Doesnt the daynes have 2 castle starfall and high hummage or something
The day the Tik tok died 😢I found Rhani right away because he is funny and entertaining and I love the song and GOT