About the Bullgator heart attack, that happens when the Legendary animal leave his area or is no longer available, that happened to me while hunting a white Bison and it suddenly died when Bounty hunters spawned in.
@@kevinator0097 the boring gameplay, the realism that makes it more boring and the story is bad written and the guns literally suck rdr1 solos this walmart knockoff.
During the Rhodes bank heist, you can shoot the dynamite Charles has just set up. This will kill Charles, but strangely enough it won't cause a mission fail or give you a wanted level. After this you will be prompted to use the detonator and the mission will continue as usual. However, once you've cleared out all the safes, the game will softlock and you'll be unable to progress. You'll be unable to access the weapon wheel so the only way to escape is to manually reload the last checkpoint!
If you go off script, you fail the mission, it’s that simple. Rockstar hates it when you walk 2 feet away from the mission area or do anything against the objective because they love not having creative missions
Nah there allot missions that actually reward for going off script i only found out about them on my 5th playthrough. The ones that do not allow are setting up a story or setpiece.
@@John-996plenty of secondary missions in which you are required to follow the script. Last time i played a week ago i was doing the forst mission of the foreman who asks you to find who is stealing money. I find him, he runs away, i hogtie him in order to give him to the foreman. But apparently that foreman knows what i have done from a hundred yards away, and starts shooting at me for trying to deliver the guy who was robbing him. Or that mission in which you are forced to give the fugitive with a family to the police even if there is dialogue about letting him go away. Game is great but has a huge problem in that the script is tyrannical, you move too far from where you are supposed to be or try to play differently and you pay for it.
@@Moonlightking3 the reason for that is the amount of actions R* allows you to do does not correlate with an equivalent amount of options in missions. GTA suffers less from this simply because the actions you can take are very limited. If they ask you to "take care" of someone your only option is to kill them, if the story requires you to kidnap them then it'll be a cutscene because there is no way to kidnap people in GTA.
That’s because there are only a limited number of cutscenes that they filmed. It’s really not that hard to figure out. You need the cutscenes to progress the story. This is some extremely petty bitching you are doing here.
I love this game but damn, rockstar had a script for you and didn't like it when you deveated, there were so many missions, like your example with the train, where I thought I could do something clever to make the mission more exciting or easier and rockstar just straight up NOPED me every single time, was really depressing, it gives the illusion of a large game with free choice but was incredibly linear when it came to story based missions.
didnt even know that you didn't have to shoot the rope Sean was hanging from. in both playthroughs i instinctively shot it thinking it was the only way to get him down
I'm going through this shit in the epilogue, basically I did a lot of shit in Blackwater, so when John has a mission to take Abigail to take photos, the game crashes because the city is in Lockdown because of me, The guy taking the photos isn't there, and if I purposely fail to skip the checkpoint, it just keeps loading infinitely
can confirm this still works 11/29/2023 (on xbox latest version).. Took me many attempts but it finally worked. I did it in chapter 2, used a springfield rifle with a long scope, even after helping the lady in valentine. patience is entirely necessary for this to work, i almost gave up because of how long it took .. Overall, was it worth it? Probably not.. but I already completed the game once so decided why not just do it on the new playthrough. Below, are some helpful tips that I think worked for me -when i saw someone else riding up as im about to shoot, i killed him, BUT as the guys horse was riding up to the lady, JUST as i killed it the glitch ended up working after 3 hours of trying .. i guess it triggered the running animation at the perfect time or something, not sure but thats what worked for me -making a new save when it wouldnt work -consistently reloading game -staying scoped in with the rifle
Arthur: Dies when Dutch pushes him (this will happen when you try to take a photo in Dutch’s tent) Trelawny: **Gets shot 7 times** **gets up** “A pleasure as always, gentlemen” **proceeds to get on the horse just fine**
i accidently triggered the woman at 8:15 by standing there and thinking "is this a trap or should i really help her" and i decided i should help and in that second she started to be pised off i felt so bad
Thank you for more evidence that RDR2 is not Rockstars golden child. The game had a lot of flaws compared to previous titles, mostly surrounding missions and how linear you were forced to play.
There actually alot mossions with loads of Freedom but RDR2 is still the best open world work to date. The Warriers is the best hand to hamd combat game, Maxpayne 3 their best shooter and Manhunt is their best stealth game. RDR2 takes elments from all their games and which why i think its their best overall work nothing is flawless but the few flaws RDR2 has are minor and could easily be fixed in most cases.
Is there special dialogue if you rob her with the horse on top of her still? Surely there is, right? I really need to do a “low/no honor” play through, just to experience all the unique dialogue undoubtedly placed throughout the game. It’s been over two years straight of playing only this game, and I’ve yet to do it. It’s just so hard for me to make Arthur a bad boah. 🤷🏻♂️
recently when I was just free roaming and doing my usual mayhem I ended up by Fort Wallace (on the right hand side) and there was a soldier out side and there was a GATE OPEN, he was just about to go in and I rushed in through the open gate! It was great, I had a good old time massacreeing all the soldiers, then I went into a storage place and unfortunately in my haste I shot some ammo and that was the end of me! I was having such a good time aswell. The epilogue is great aswell. Just got to where John has built a new house.
@@brotherfoller yes, when I played the first game as Arthur, Im putting game back on, for some reason my progress was never saved and I also mistakenly deleted epilogue ( Id not completed epilogue) anyway Im reinstalling game and playing again.
I got RDR1 for christmas and im grateful but im still looking forward to getting a new TV so i can play RDR II again Im glad i can see the events of what happend after RDR2 but still RDR2 is basicly the real RDR1 but you know how rockstar games is, W video. edit: idea what if you make swanson invincible when the train comes?
@@Beer_Me No Mary Linton. They have a history. Quite frankly after all Arthur did when he saw the truth of Dutch, he deserves something. It's Micah and Dutch that needs to die, Arthur did a lot of bad things but he made up for some of that maybe I just want him to live maybe I'm thinking it's that simple and being naive. Someone deserves redemption in this world maybe in a story we could make that happen
@@seauryakumar nah Mary is a b. Mary Beth or Sadie would be way better for a man like Arthur although with Sadie he probably would never be able to escape the violent life.
No, but it is possible to shoot a horse in the leg and there is a chance that a person will get stuck under it, I did not come up with it, it is really possible
All this does is show how restrictive RDR2's core gameplay is, like the game just straight up failing you for going off script, or imposing another limiting factor to stop you. but good video none the less.
Depends on the missions some allow you to go of script and reward you for others fo not. Hell many story games like Witcher 3 just have you follow red foot prints giving the player loads of freedom does not always work for good story telling.
@@John-996 I wouldn't necessarily disagree with you. However RDR2 has one foot on the freeroam/player choice boat and the other on the rigid don't go off-script storytelling boat and sometimes those boats are not going in the same direction. Bank Heist in Valentine is a prime example, player gets a choice, but it makes no different to the outcome either way. And the game does this a LOT. Its not that not having a choice is always a bad thing, but presenting the player with the illusion of choice when there isn't one, is.
I hate how this game makes you use a controller, and if you dont do the exact right thing at the exact right time, it fails you. Just make a movie cow pokes 😂
Just had another thought. I wonder if there is unique dialogue from storekeepers if you inspect items with no money. It would be cool if it didn’t happen immediately; it would only happen if you kept loitering in the store without paying. Also, I wonder what the dying mauled stranger would say if you aimed a bow with small arrows at him, if he’d say “that won’t kill me!” or something similar. These boahs done thought of damn near everything!
Trelawny taking 7 bullets to the chest only to immediately get up and say “a pleasure as always, gentlemen” may be the hardest thing I’ve ever seen
Bros in shock.
He might be the strange man
That's because he's secretly strange man.
2:07 Wow, Trelawny must've taken a lot of potent health cure tonics before this mission.
that special
Took several shots and just walks away wearing a fancy hat? Trelawny = Strange Man confirmed.
Trelawny having level 10 health
Nah, it just proves he’s the Strange Man.
Trelawny is immortal
Good work , sir. It gladdens my heart seeing a UA-camr continuing the fine tradition of subverting video game mission scripts.
2:08 well that proves it, Trelawny is the Strange Man.
2:07 trelawny's literally immortal holy shit
@@portugeese_man_o_war because his a strange man even does not failed mission :d
2:10 is the proof that Trelawny is the STRANGEMAN
2:07 proof Trelawny actually IS the mysterious stranger
2:06 Damn Javier and Trelawny turn into Superman 💀
7:50 He probably will earn much more by saying "give me all you're cigarette cards 💀
4:47 Arthur’s not mad, he’s just confused
I like how the dialogue still makes sense
2:07 I guess this proves hes the strange man.
Really surprised it wasn't a failed mission
About the Bullgator heart attack, that happens when the Legendary animal leave his area or is no longer available, that happened to me while hunting a white Bison and it suddenly died when Bounty hunters spawned in.
2:06 proof Trelawny IS the STRANGE MAN (2023 new lore NO CLICKBAIT)
MrBossFTW will make an 8 minute video 😭😭 lol
i love this when artur says the hell wrong with you when mike shoots wall
fun fact: rdr2 is actually the most worst game
@@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCE and you are the worst guy
@@kevinator0097 maybe but its true lol
@@FEDERALBEREAUOFIMCOMPENTRNCE why?
@@kevinator0097 the boring gameplay, the realism that makes it more boring and the story is bad written and the guns literally suck rdr1 solos this walmart knockoff.
During the Rhodes bank heist, you can shoot the dynamite Charles has just set up. This will kill Charles, but strangely enough it won't cause a mission fail or give you a wanted level.
After this you will be prompted to use the detonator and the mission will continue as usual. However, once you've cleared out all the safes, the game will softlock and you'll be unable to progress. You'll be unable to access the weapon wheel so the only way to escape is to manually reload the last checkpoint!
I don’t remember any Rhodes bank heist in the game?
@@CraigTheBrute-yf7no your broke ass didn't buy the special/ultimate edition then
@@fedyx1544 i can’t afford electricity
I'm pretty sure there isn't Rhodes bank heist...
@@MrTimPL there is
2:42 Damn Sean probably had a cervical injury 💀
That ending tho
4:40 Proof that Micha has schizophrenia 💀
absolutely love these series! keep it going partner
hurted to see micah got rescued :c
Stop train while saving swanson is smart
Lmao the ending got me 🤣
If I’m being honest, I didn’t even realize that you could cut down Sean until my second play through. I just always shot the rope
Shooting the rope is one of the challenges to get gold on this mission
You're actually supposed to shoot Sean down in the mission where you save him. It's one of the things you have to do for a gold medal.
1:28 Don't worry Reverend, whe have all day 😂
Gator wasn't got heart attack, he just can't leave Bayou and got invisible sniper on him. 😅
man, the Legendary Bullgator's running gait is nightmare fuel
If you go off script, you fail the mission, it’s that simple. Rockstar hates it when you walk 2 feet away from the mission area or do anything against the objective because they love not having creative missions
Nah there allot missions that actually reward for going off script i only found out about them on my 5th playthrough. The ones that do not allow are setting up a story or setpiece.
@@John-996plenty of secondary missions in which you are required to follow the script.
Last time i played a week ago i was doing the forst mission of the foreman who asks you to find who is stealing money. I find him, he runs away, i hogtie him in order to give him to the foreman. But apparently that foreman knows what i have done from a hundred yards away, and starts shooting at me for trying to deliver the guy who was robbing him. Or that mission in which you are forced to give the fugitive with a family to the police even if there is dialogue about letting him go away.
Game is great but has a huge problem in that the script is tyrannical, you move too far from where you are supposed to be or try to play differently and you pay for it.
@@Moonlightking3 the reason for that is the amount of actions R* allows you to do does not correlate with an equivalent amount of options in missions.
GTA suffers less from this simply because the actions you can take are very limited. If they ask you to "take care" of someone your only option is to kill them, if the story requires you to kidnap them then it'll be a cutscene because there is no way to kidnap people in GTA.
That’s because there are only a limited number of cutscenes that they filmed. It’s really not that hard to figure out. You need the cutscenes to progress the story.
This is some extremely petty bitching you are doing here.
@@The_Bigot then the reward for creative gameplay should be not having to watch their high-school-creative-writing-class loquacious cutscenes.
RDR2 is the only game that got me so sucked in that I didn’t try to break the game every mission
Really man! I thought Arthur would get heart attack 😂
2:06 Trelawny is the strange man confirmed?!
7:07 each time he's stopping im getting a small heart attack
You're like the whatever57010 of rdr2 with these videos. I love it
8:48 If you wonna do a disonorable playtrought, do this:
5:48 This is how it look's when we don't play as Arthur.
0:32 Lawmen's are everywhere these days 💀
Trelawny late 7 bullets to the chest lmao that’s crazy
I love this game but damn, rockstar had a script for you and didn't like it when you deveated, there were so many missions, like your example with the train, where I thought I could do something clever to make the mission more exciting or easier and rockstar just straight up NOPED me every single time, was really depressing, it gives the illusion of a large game with free choice but was incredibly linear when it came to story based missions.
Could you be more specific
Well, that's the Rockstar formula since what, GTA 2?
Either I missed this or you missed this, but in the first train heist, if yoy just stand still, the train actually just goes arround the entire map
dude shoots the thing then thinks it dies from a heart attack, when really it just bled to death from chasing you for a mile with an open wound.
I didn’t even know you could let Sean down with a knife. I always used the bullet.
Damn One glitch can change the dialogues into different meanings 4:40
So Trawlany really is the Strange Man those Lawmen couldn't kill him even with a Million Bullets
I have literally never seen the “Day” version of Spines of America. No wonder it’s called that! 😂
didnt even know that you didn't have to shoot the rope Sean was hanging from. in both playthroughs i instinctively shot it thinking it was the only way to get him down
Lawman -- Singular
Lawmen -- Plural
Lawmens -- Pluraller
2:15 confirms Josiah is the strange man
I'm going through this shit in the epilogue, basically I did a lot of shit in Blackwater, so when John has a mission to take Abigail to take photos, the game crashes because the city is in Lockdown because of me, The guy taking the photos isn't there, and if I purposely fail to skip the checkpoint, it just keeps loading infinitely
Well the theory of Trelawney being the strange man isnt so dumb after all!
this proves that trewanly is the strange man
Trelawny with that level 4 body armour
Plot twist ....
That was also in the script
Wait? Theres actually an interior in Skinnys house? 😭 I always wondered what Micah was doing in there 😂
Yep
That gator just up and dies thats funny
I think the gator dies on a long run now because you used to be able to let it follow you to camp
2:07 Trelawny is strange man confirmed
This is something my intrusive thoughts always wanted to do. And I do, do them. (Sometimes)
Where can i find ur outfit thr one ur wearing in game
we not gonna talk about how he has the tiger striped mustang as arthur?
0:35 didnt you know? They have 'messenger' to alert the law.
2:05 Stormtrooper in disguise
Trelawny is the best side character by far, lmfao
i found that lady under the horse and accidentally stopped the prompt to help her so she did it herself and then got mad at me
Im sure nobody ever misses Micah lol.
2:06 trelawni is bullet proof 💀
not Trelawny still being alive after getting shot like 6 times with a rifle
can confirm this still works 11/29/2023 (on xbox latest version).. Took me many attempts but it finally worked. I did it in chapter 2, used a springfield rifle with a long scope, even after helping the lady in valentine. patience is entirely necessary for this to work, i almost gave up because of how long it took .. Overall, was it worth it? Probably not.. but I already completed the game once so decided why not just do it on the new playthrough. Below, are some helpful tips that I think worked for me
-when i saw someone else riding up as im about to shoot, i killed him, BUT as the guys horse was riding up to the lady, JUST as i killed it the glitch ended up working after 3 hours of trying .. i guess it triggered the running animation at the perfect time or something, not sure but thats what worked for me
-making a new save when it wouldnt work
-consistently reloading game
-staying scoped in with the rifle
Arthur: Dies when Dutch pushes him (this will happen when you try to take a photo in Dutch’s tent)
Trelawny: **Gets shot 7 times** **gets up** “A pleasure as always, gentlemen” **proceeds to get on the horse just fine**
2:13 Finally his the streng man
i accidently triggered the woman at 8:15 by standing there and thinking "is this a trap or should i really help her" and i decided i should help and in that second she started to be pised off i felt so bad
Should’ve tied the girl that was stuck under the horse up and left her to be trapped again
Life is not meant to be scripted, hence why I am HERE
They just teleport if I win.
Lore of RDR2 - If you go off script 4 momentum 100
bla bla bla
Thank you for more evidence that RDR2 is not Rockstars golden child. The game had a lot of flaws compared to previous titles, mostly surrounding missions and how linear you were forced to play.
There actually alot mossions with loads of Freedom but RDR2 is still the best open world work to date. The Warriers is the best hand to hamd combat game, Maxpayne 3 their best shooter and Manhunt is their best stealth game. RDR2 takes elments from all their games and which why i think its their best overall work nothing is flawless but the few flaws RDR2 has are minor and could easily be fixed in most cases.
Is there special dialogue if you rob her with the horse on top of her still? Surely there is, right?
I really need to do a “low/no honor” play through, just to experience all the unique dialogue undoubtedly placed throughout the game. It’s been over two years straight of playing only this game, and I’ve yet to do it.
It’s just so hard for me to make Arthur a bad boah. 🤷🏻♂️
recently when I was just free roaming and doing my usual mayhem I ended up by Fort Wallace (on the right hand side) and there was a soldier out side and there was a GATE OPEN, he was just about to go in and I rushed in through the open gate! It was great, I had a good old time massacreeing all the soldiers, then I went into a storage place and unfortunately in my haste I shot some ammo and that was the end of me! I was having such a good time aswell. The epilogue is great aswell. Just got to where John has built a new house.
as Arthur?
@@brotherfoller yes, when I played the first game as Arthur, Im putting game back on, for some reason my progress was never saved and I also mistakenly deleted epilogue ( Id not completed epilogue) anyway Im reinstalling game and playing again.
What 5 years without a game does to a mf
6:50 People who say that he should bring it to Saint Denis.
👇
In the mission with Reverend Swanson being stuck on the bridge, can you shoot the train with dynamite arrows to blow it up?
What if you board the train in the reverand mission
How’d you get the Rare Rolling Block rifle in Chapter 2?
How does killing a conductor stop a train
I got RDR1 for christmas and im grateful but im still looking forward to getting a new TV so i can play RDR II again
Im glad i can see the events of what happend after RDR2 but still RDR2 is basicly the real RDR1 but you know how rockstar games is, W video. edit: idea what if you make swanson invincible when the train comes?
lol I just robbed the card collector and I’m seeing this great minds think alike haha
I wished Rockstar went off script and kept Arthur alive, let him live happily with Mary
Mary Beth maybe
@@Beer_Me No Mary Linton. They have a history. Quite frankly after all Arthur did when he saw the truth of Dutch, he deserves something. It's Micah and Dutch that needs to die, Arthur did a lot of bad things but he made up for some of that maybe I just want him to live maybe I'm thinking it's that simple and being naive. Someone deserves redemption in this world maybe in a story we could make that happen
@@seauryakumar nah Mary is a b. Mary Beth or Sadie would be way better for a man like Arthur although with Sadie he probably would never be able to escape the violent life.
@@seauryakumar Mary Linton was a needy ass. Mary Beth was a better match up for Arthur
How did you turn into Michah? 5:13
What if you kill everyone six point cabin before playing a social call
We need More rdr 2 script videos!
How did you make Micah's hair swept back in Strawberry jail? Pray do tell!
best Polish youtuber ever for sure!
2:38 I thought that’s it was supposed to go
is it possible to kill a horse and lay it on a person and they ask you for help?
No, but it is possible to shoot a horse in the leg and there is a chance that a person will get stuck under it, I did not come up with it, it is really possible
All this does is show how restrictive RDR2's core gameplay is, like the game just straight up failing you for going off script, or imposing another limiting factor to stop you. but good video none the less.
GTA is like this too. Well, i guess they never pretended it's an immersive sim
Depends on the missions some allow you to go of script and reward you for others fo not. Hell many story games like Witcher 3 just have you follow red foot prints giving the player loads of freedom does not always work for good story telling.
@@John-996 I wouldn't necessarily disagree with you. However RDR2 has one foot on the freeroam/player choice boat and the other on the rigid don't go off-script storytelling boat and sometimes those boats are not going in the same direction. Bank Heist in Valentine is a prime example, player gets a choice, but it makes no different to the outcome either way. And the game does this a LOT. Its not that not having a choice is always a bad thing, but presenting the player with the illusion of choice when there isn't one, is.
I hate how this game makes you use a controller, and if you dont do the exact right thing at the exact right time, it fails you. Just make a movie cow pokes 😂
Nah there are allot missions that give ypu freedom but its a story driven game. The open World has far more freedom then most games.
what happen if you help the woman stucked without a horse?
Sheesh, I haven't seen you in a while.
"Lawmen" is the plural form of "Lawman" 😉
ending🤣
Just had another thought. I wonder if there is unique dialogue from storekeepers if you inspect items with no money.
It would be cool if it didn’t happen immediately; it would only happen if you kept loitering in the store without paying.
Also, I wonder what the dying mauled stranger would say if you aimed a bow with small arrows at him, if he’d say “that won’t kill me!” or something similar.
These boahs done thought of damn near everything!
You should make a vids of ways to get stuff early or get stuff free similar to this kind of vid
whaa
First reply