Student suspended for recording teacher
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лис 2024
- A St Lucie County student says she was suspended this week for trying to defend a classmate
◂
WPTV NewsChannel 5, Local News Coverage You Can Count On. South Florida, Palm Beach County, Treasure Coast breaking news, weather and traffic.
WPTV is South Florida's top-rated television station, covering Palm Beach County and the Treasure Coast.
For more download the WPTV mobile app:
iPhone: bit.ly/iOS-wptv
Android: bit.ly/wptv-and...
that mom is raising a good kid, that teacher needs to be fired
So does the principal
But the problem is they're not! I don't want to be a Teacher! Especially these Days !
Teachers don't get fired on the stop unless they do something like really bad, this prob isn't enough
She did and the suspension was lifted on the girl. The principal tried to hide and not answer emails from the school administrators.
Period
School suspended her because they don’t like that she’s standing up for herself and classmates
@jessica Cloud9 The teacher was continuously bullying her students. Let alone the fact that the girl got suspended for trying to do the right thing.
But aren't they doing the same thing. They must have cameras. They are videoing kids all day, but yet when the little girl records the conversation, not the teacher he conversation, she get in trouble. They are just stupid and hypocritical
School doesn’t like standing up for people instead you tell the teacher and by when you get to the teacher the kid is beat up
Yup. I was beat up on school grounds and the principal just blow it off. I was even abused in the classroom by the teacher and the students.
@@janetwoodville3643 Should of threaten to call the police on the school, for endangerment of children.
SHE WAS 11 she did better then most teachers in her entire school even the principal
she didn’t even no she’s not 14, 11 that was probably her 2 phone
kudous awoke i lost six braincells reading that
Super happy and sad Person she’s probably 16 now
jonas switzer wrong comment?
Peach ASMR Sorry about that. Must have been auto correct. But the teacher WAS fired.
I’m a retired teacher and a classroom should NOT be a place where privacy is promoted. Classrooms should have cameras rolling at all times. If you’re doing your job you shouldn’t be afraid to have camera rolling. Children need to be protected and parents should have the right to know what is going on
Plus it is also very helpful for teacher’s protection too.
False allegations have hurt many a teacher’s reputation.
So cameras in classrooms should be a must!
Perfectly said. Teachers and children should be protected. One bad teacher gives the rest a bad name as well.
And a teacher being drove to protect themselves from say high school kid antagonizing them should be considered as well.
@ dona' little fawn
Camera footage isn’t the only reason why phones are normally banned during school hours. It’s also b/c it can be used for other inappropriate stuff. Like adult videos, cyber bullying, distraction from their academics, and cheating on tests. If she’s told not to record, she needs to follow school policy! Period!!
Yes for real, you said my words.
Torey Hayden did this all the time. Great books she wrote.
👍 maybe this is the Answer, Good Teacher's shouldn't have a problem with that
“The school said the video was illegal.”
Do you know what else is illegal?
*Bullying. A. Child.*
Actually that's not illegal
@Tekkadan Reborn show me the law that says bullying is illegal
@@adamthers1881 verbal abuse and harassment u happy now
Blackmail
@@shom924 all the time
In my school some girls were being sexually abused, and the principal acted like this was only a joke.
In the end, the principal, 3 teachers and 2 inspectors got fired
the district should get nuked
Home Depot AKKTK TMQTA collateral damage
@@movedon-deadchannel2685 Welcome to Brazil
Wait, who fired the principal? The principal themself?
Miss Flower The school principal has his own boss.
"You think they would believe a student over a teacher?"
that is so true omg
Keegan Gidley ikr
Keegan Gidley they would never believe students I'm a student my teachers have lots of things us and they get away with it it's unfair and its makes us not want to learn and be a school as it's not safe and fair us
I had this one terrible teacher in 4th grade. I tried telling my parents about her but they thought I was overreacting. Then one day I broke and cried for 2 hours straight, keep in mind I was 9 or 10 at the time. Only after that did they actually believe me.
Turns out what she was doing violated school policy so she got demoted to teacher's assistant the next year.
nicole robinson is it on ur channel?
Keegan Gidley right
"She thought she was doing the right thing." She was doing the right thing. Sometimes the right thing breaks rules put there to protect bad people.
Depends on the situation. So all we know, the kid was probably being defiant and the teacher must’ve rightfully scolded her and gave her a fair consequence. We don’t know the full story.
@@amylee8969You don't insult an 11 year old when you're a professional with power over them. It's an abuse of power and unprofessional.
@@amylee8969 And exactly what evidence do you have for this situation in which the student was "defiant" that you made up? None... Do you always make things up and believe yourself? Good luck with that mentality working out for you.
A student who would sneak a video of a teacher is probably a student who has been in trouble before and is seeking revenge.
@@joeshithragman3264 And we have yet another person making up their own narrative and believing themselves...
Schools: Spends hours and hours of teaching how bullying is bad
Also schools: Suspend student for reporting bullying
Exactly smh
Ikr
Teaching how to abuse authority. Timely.
The American school system in a nutshell.
@@jaymoreno4016 Check the suicide rate in Japan just from school bullying. And that is just a fraction compared to the bullying from the teachers.
"Expectation of privacy"??? YOUR TIME WITH THE CHILDREN OF OTHERS IS NOT PRIVATE.
bang on
Especially in a PUBLICLY FUNDED setting.
@@microtasker wherever I believe lmao.
Incorrect. You run the risk of violating the privacy of other students who receive special education accommodations.
@@user-br1cc3ek2i However, the privacy of the other students is not the issue at question. It's clearly stated that the teacher's privacy is what's been violated. Yes, that is semantics, but semantics are important in court.
They suspended the wrong person. She's a brave girl, I'm proud of her.
Randy Stevens if I recorded my teachers I would get suspended
@@samanthamartin9254 Well I'll be, when I was in school, we didn't have the technology you kids have today.
@@randystevens1690 Not everyone is a kid btw.
@@AleroaTheAlta Where did that come from?
@@randystevens1690 "You kids have today."
This sweet kiddo essentially stood up for another student who was being bullied, and for that the school bullied her.
In the teacher's judgement, the teacher was motivating the student. Different kids need different kinds of motivation. That kid recording probably didn't have the same temperament as the kid she thought was being bullied. She may have ruined an opportunity for the teacher to reach the kid in a way that would only work for that kid.
@@fionamunro3381 Really? Think about it, whose judgement is more likely to fit the situation, a teacher who chose that profession to help kids or a kid who whose goal is to "get the teacher in trouble." I'd bet two bits that the kid didn't record out of altruism but instead did it because the teacher has been correcting her bad behavior and she got mad about it.
@@joeshithragman3264The mental gymnastics is crazy in you, apply for the Olympics. But seriously the amount of creative liberties you took in order to make the teacher seem "justifiable" (even in your imagined context this makes no sense) is bonkers, literally all your evidence is "they are a teacher so they would never".
@@BookedNotes Gee, maybe coaches who don't yell at one kid should never yell at another kid. Reality of teacher/student relationships must evade you. Bless your heart.
I just got bullied by UA-cam.
Her statement said it all. “You think they’d believe a student over a teacher?” Children are NEVER listened to when they bring real wrongdoings and issues to light.
@Beaverish Buck Teeth Was that recording a lie!?
@Beaverish Buck Teeth Ok redditor.
@Beaverish Buck Teeth yeah maybe your kids. In reality most well behaved kids with good parents don't just lie for fun. If your kid constantly lies/ makes stuff up that's a fault in your parenting
Children today arent the children we adults grew up around, they can be very clever and merciless!
@@latlelat4200 from a kid’s POV a situation can be viewed differently; it doesn’t mean that the kid is lying, but the stories sometimes lack credibility.
This is why kids have depression and anxiety
Not only taht
Also the bullying
“All the kids are depressed”
@@Sweet_Spiirit not all kids
@@codyboothe2310 commonly all are kids
Teacher: ~bullies children~
School: ~ignores~
Student: ~records for proof~
School: *OH HELL NAW I GOTTA SUSPENDED HER*
Like make it make sense 🙄
The bottom line is.. The school got butthurt for being exposed to its recklessness, so they decided to suspend the student that exposed the school for endangering not only the lives of the students but of their loved ones that they come home to, their Mother, Father, Siblings, especially their elders who are more susceptible like Grandma or Grandpa. Also anyone with a weakened immune system. Shame on the school for being reckless and Shame on the school for thinking it was okay for suspending her!!! Furthermore, because she got suspended by the school, it only makes people see the school for what it really is by trying to coverup its recklessness and trying to get into the student's head as well as other students by suspending someone the school thought they could scare others but failed!!!
THE TRUTH CAN NEVER BE SILENCED!!! SAFETY FIRST!! THE SUSPENSION WAS NOTHING BUT PSYCHOLOGICAL WARFARE!!! FOR THE STUDENT!!
The Student did everything right!!! and Nothing Wrong!!! Nothing!!!
Her actions only saved/prevented future potential others who could have gotten sick
by the spread of the virus. Also, there should be no school in these troubled times.
Literal censorship
ScHoOl: *YOU DID NOT JUST DO THAT*
@@jimthegatormantwopoint0 I swr!
The 11 year old has more morals and maturity than the actual teacher 🤦🏼♀️
Kids bullying others and threatening others: suspended for a day
Kids recording a video: suspended for 5 days
most of the time they don’t even get suspended just detention or not even in trouble!
lemon gloss yeah Ikr
lemon gloss Ikr
My brother bullied his teacher and only got 1 day
Kids recording a video of a teacher making fun of a student and pretty much calling them fat: the student gets suspended for 5 days while the teacher gets nothing
A child who reported a teacher for abusing a student get suspended something is really wrong with this situation
Dawn Dayton I just can't seem to put my finger on it
No the student got what she deserved!
No you're wrong that goblin brat deserved to be suspended
Schools are jacked up. 😂
That’s how schools maintain reputation, suspend some white girls so all they’re suspending aren’t just black people
So they punish the kid who didn't bully anyone but the teacher is fine telling a 5th grader she's fat like her mom and will drop her?
Wtf.
Wtf is right!
This country is seriously messed up
If that lady had told my child that I would’ve dropped her
Jenifer Clark ikr
@@stacyeandrew2 Wow must y'all bring race into everything 🙄🙄🙄
Punishing someone for exposing a teacher’s terrible behavior is what’s illegal!
They never believe students over teachers!
Izzi Myz me niether
Izzi Myz yeah😡🙄
Izzi Myz IKR
Izzi Myz So true once I Got called out with my friends for Bullying This girl But we never even did it nobody believed us and we got in trouble 😑
Izzi Myz ikr like they never listen to what kids have to say
there shouldn't ever be an "expectation of privacy" in a PUBLIC school that tax payers pay for... im sorry but that little girl had every right to do what she did
No. She literally didn’t. You legally can’t record a conversation that you aren’t involved in, as well, any conversations between a teacher and another student are protected under FERPA. She was violating the 4th Amendment Rights of everyone in that room. Doesn’t matter if tHe TaXPaYeRs PaY FoR iT. You can’t legally record a conversation without the consent of one of the people directly involved in the conversation regardless of whether you are in public or not.
@@rockerprincessSteph What the hell are you talking about? If you are in public and ask not to be recorded your in public! Have you not learned anything from the riots? As for FERPA a teacher told a child she was going to hurt said child-- what about the right of that child?
@@rockerprincessSteph this instance shouldn’t count considering what the teacher was doing. If a teacher is verbally and/or physically abusing students and the school isn’t doing anything about it, then that protection should be revoked.
Don't say sorry for being right Mizzy
@@rockerprincessSteph There are times when the law doesn't technically work in favor of what is actually the right thing to do.
why??? THE STUDENT DID THE RIGHT THING!
cause they are in love with bullies
Teachera these days
AllyQueenBlackpink exactly
Umm becuase they are kids is what adults think.......that's sad
because you can't have your phone in class
The same energy as "You filmed a kid getting hit and abused by their parents in their house but since it's private property and they didnt consent your the one getting arrested"
Teachers: "Stand up for others Don't be a bystander!"
Kid: stands up for others
Teacher: "Wait, that's illegal!"
Teacher: THIS IS A AVENGERS THREAT
@@mortalkombat4641 wait what? 😂😂
@@00Rr704 that school allowed a teacher to bully a student. Kid did right thing.
so ture tho
So let me get this straight: the kid is suspended but the teacher gets zero punishment? America, America, America🤔
“I thought I did the right thing”. Yes, she did. The girl deserves an award, the teacher needs to be fired. *Period*
Yes!
I know, but I’m the best in my class
@「bruh」 That shouldn’t matter. The point is the girl is amazing and a hero. Why you focusing on a word that a good chunk of people say? 🤦🏾♀️
@@kareno1456 it's not criminal behavior.
@@kareno1456 of course your name is karen
Isn't bullying against the law as well?smh.
Serena Cappello I hate ppl
Kayla Collins |-/
Kayla Collins |-/
Serena Cappello man I wish
Serena Cappello no
They should fired who suspended the student!
What a smart, acountable kid. She's gonna be great human being while she grows up.
She's a great person already. Unlike the grown ups in her school.
Well Said.
God Bless.
@@carmellewis2466 Yeah, you're right
@@amh7427 thanks!
Or cynical and spiteful after being victimized by the corruption and injustice ingrained in society at such a formative age.
"When exposing a crime is treated as committing a crime, you are being ruled by criminals." -Edward Snowden
LMAO......that quote is NOT from Snowden. Many have said it over the years before Snowden including the hacker group Anonymous. Snowden is a coward and a criminal. Snowden knew what he was doing was a crime which is why he ran.
A criminal who exposes other criminals is still a criminal - Myself.
@@joshmoats7981 but when the system only seeks to punish the rat. The quote is true
@@joshmoats7981 Dude, look at your pic, you're an edgy try hard poser.
@@GODsSPECTRE When the quote is used by a criminal themselves it becomes hypocritical.
@@joshmoats7981 I'm sorry but the law isn't always black n white. There are some gray areas. Just ask all those politicians who expose those gray areas as loopholes to profit from. Its just a way for them to circumvent the law. Which should be illegal. And what would have happened if the teacher did drop that student and this girl videos it and had proof? Then what? Was her act still illegal? When you catch the system doing wrong with intent, then the system will tell you your wrong for catching them. Snowden is a patriot of the people and our constitution. He knew what would happen. I agree he should have stayed here and fought even if he lost. He may have been a patriot, but he was a coward to leave and not deal with the corrupt system that would have seen him locked away behind bars forever. But there's a reason they didn't go after him. Its cause he knew more than he let out and it would have all came out in court if they allowed a trial. Countries trade prisoners all the time. You can't tell me they wouldn't trade someone to Russia for Snowden if he really was a traitor? Come on...
"I will drop you"
"I wonder what your mom looks like"
Teachers can now threaten to assault students and insult their parents, but a student is the one who gets punished for exposing them
Sickening
She'd find out what this Mama looks like.
They are even violent to children.
Some teacher!
This is when you file a law suit against the school board and the principal.
As someone who was mercilessly bullied throughout my grade school career, I can atest to what a teacher bullying you feels like.
I've had a good few and it's makes you feel a different kind of hopelessness verses being bullied by your peers. Like there's no where to turn at that point... since these are the people who should be protecting you.
I know exactly how you feel. Most of the teachers and staff would join in on bullying certain "lightning rod" students, I was one of them targeted. What made it worse is that some of the staff and teachers were related to the bullies and would work together to torment students, while those kids continued to act horribly and get away with it. I got so many detentions in third grade because the guidance counselor was related to my worst bully and he'd go running to her(he constantly threatened me with a Swiss army knife but she said it didn't count as a threat because it happened on the bus).It was a hard lesson early in life that this world is full of injustice. Being ganged up on in a such a toxic environment as a kid by an entire grade and adults gave me so much stress that it caused long lasting psychological damage. It took me 15 years to be somewhat functional again without getting anxiety and panic attacks in public. I hope you, and everyone who suffered from such meaningless cruelty are able to heal.
“The video is illegal”
Also the teacher threatening assault: “I will drop you”
Show me on this doll where the words hurt you
Don't blink.
Words like that hurt children’s self esteem. Imagine the person who’s in charge of you threatening your physical safety everyday . If it were a babysitter they’d be in jail.
What an idiot ur....u only saw 1 small part....u didn't see what lead up to it!!
When I was borne ,the only one you could go to jail for threatening was the President of The United States of America.
What a lowly state this country has apparently fallen to .
B O
she did the right thing.
It is still illegal. Still the right thing though. An if I claim I didn't know murder is illegal does that mean I should be let go
Isabella M Turnbull yes she did
Isabella M Turnbull yeah
Brian McAuley Yeah, if you use it the wrong way.
Brian McAuley the First Amendment overrides the law!
It's sad when the 11-year-old does the right thing and the teachers are the ones that are corrupt
I really hope that they sued the school for that!!
The teacher deserves a suspension, and so does the principal for blindly supporting a colleague.
What if majority of 11 year Olds r good people. But after 17 years old brainwashing and forcing a child to be a bad person, they start to actually be a bad person
Dogma
DID. YOU NOT HEAR MISS
"YAH.right IN THE BACK GROUND
BEING NEGATIVLY SMART TO THAT
TEACHER. LIKE A PART OUT OF THAT
MOVIE "TO SIR WITH LOVE"
I guess the lesson here is, the teacher who bullied was employed by the school: ergo, take the recording to the police. Even if the school is against a teacher acting this way, it's an embarrassment that they hired someone like this...this young lady absolutely did the right thing. And the recording is NOT against the law: the expectation is clearly stated in the name PUBLIC SCHOOL!!!
The student who was “bullied” by the teacher was clearly a trouble maker who was defiant and probably bullied other kids.
No teacher in their right mind would yell at or intimidate a well-behaved and respectful student. If a student was called out by the teacher, they were clearly asking for it.
@@amylee8969 no respectable teacher worth a damn would ever bully or yell at a student PERIOD!
The teacher went after her friends mother’s looks. She should be fired
no, not in today's culture BUT if all the parents who had a child in that school had them transferred then you can't have a school with zero students so they CLOSE the school!!! Problem solved...
@@maxwellmarsden7273 did i lose a brain cell? what does this mean?
@@MeriqulimStudios-MerrickRector if ALL the parents take their children out of this school THERE IS NO USE FOR THE SCHOOL so the people working there need to be moved or let go... Make sense yet???
@Pham Melody they expelled the girl for 5 days it said so my solution was if ALL the parents found another school for their children that would leave this facility lacking of a reason to remain open!!!
Along with every 12 year old on Xbox live
She "thought" she did the right thing.
No girl, you DID the right thing.
Exactly
If the teacher was white she would've gotten bounced.
Yes she did
Regardless of what people keep posting, she did the wrong thing. She shouldn’t even have a phone in school, she made a bad decision
Which costed her a week off. If it was a job , she would have been terminated .
Sweetheart you did THE RIGHT THING. If a black student recorded a white teacher doing that, you would be hailed a hero. Be proud of your suspension you DID the right thing.
SHE DID DO THE RIGHT THING!!
Ikr
Moonlight78 _xoxo YEAH!
Ikr !!!!
Jessica Jones Dude isnt bullying a big problem in all schools and Teachers take action when it comes to bullying its like the teacher isnt a teacher at all
Bullying hurts your feelings what about hurting the teacher's feelings instead maybe that jerk will hang herself when you gay "You lesbian now go cry"
Moonlight78 _xoxo Exactly
It should never be illegal to film a teacher, ESPECIALLY in the classroom.
Yeah no, you don’t get rights to privacy when you’re with our children.
Damn right! That should be the issue pursued here.
Straight up facts.
Your kids go there?
@@brettmastema7056 They're saying that when parents send THEIR children to another place, school, where it's FILLED with other adults that the parents might not even know, the school shouldn't say they have the right to privacy when they have CHILDREN THERE. Underage children. Ya know how many sexual abuse and death and abuse happens in school to children and they get told not to tell because it's "private?" Private my a$$, you're job is to teach and PROTECT the kids, not do whatever the hell you want. You don't get to have privacy in a school when you're in charge of caring for *SOMEONE ELSE'S CHILD*
I still say she needs a lawyer. Most states if one person in the room knows its recorded its legal.
As a teacher I absolutely applaud this little girl for doing what she did.
Be careful, your union is probably monitoring your comments. They will put you on detention. ;) That said... * Applause * to you!
Seems you have missed your calling.
Yep I’m with you. We as teachers should always treat our students with the respect we expect from them.
You applaud her for breaking the law?
yeah even a teacher saying this was wrong
"Do you think that they'd actually believe a student over a teacher?" yikes.
The worst part is that she's right, which gives her a bigger reason to record evidence in the first place
Sad, but true. The only real mistake the girl made was trusting another teacher to "do the right thing". Never trust cops, teachers or school leadership to "do the right thing" because they will always default to covering themselves from any legal exposure. ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS take your recordings to the local media and anonymously expose these people for their bad behavior. That's the only way for any real change to happen. Public pressure from media exposure and reporters asking questions will cause the school to "act" and fire the teacher just to show they are "doing something". Otherwise, they will do nothing at all and will punish the student who is providing the information by hiding by a misrepresentation of a terribly vague law that was only meant to protect the privacy of people in bathrooms and dressing rooms. It was not meant to be used to "protect" people behaving badly in a public setting, like those instructing a room full of students.
The mother instinctively knew the school's treatment of her daughter was wrong and did the right thing by going to the media. Try to imagine for a moment how history would have been changed if the young girl who recorded the criminal actions of Derek Chauvin killing George Floyd had instead handed over her recording to a local police station instead of directly to the media.
Love the student helping a fellow student. bad decision by the school district.
No place should be more public than children’s classrooms. What teachers teach and say to children should be open for all to see and hear, especially the parents
Right its called public school for a reason
I urge parents to check out Freedom Learning and facilitate a healthy educational environment AT HOME!!!
Agreed.
I mean if she did by their logic... if she got the teacher permission to record then she would have no proof... if its a good reason and proof then why not lol also let me guess... bully a kid is okay but record for proof is not wtf
You're 7 years late mate.
That’s heartbreaking. She did the right thing by exposing this bully. Sounds like the school is just trying to cover it up.
The school is now the bully!
She was fired. No covering up is being done. take off your tinfoil hat
@@Wylie288 Please provide a link as evidence that is true. And when did they fire this teacher, after public pressure forced them to? Also, when a young child is suspended for 5 days that sends an extremely strong message to the children that reporting teachers is not permitted.
The world Bully is so abused in American. Everyone in the US is now a cry baby karen.
@@Wylie288 obvi your feelings are hurt… lol
Oh my gosh, that little girl did the right thing, she didn't deserve that.
I totally agree, I hope the teacher reads this.
I agree too
Illegibly? We heard her bullying 🙄There is NO EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY IN A “PUBLIC” SCHOOL! And there NEVER Should be! Why would you Want to protect Bad Teachers teaching kids how to bully!
"You think that they would actually believe a student over a teacher?"
*My girl is out here asking the real questions*
How can you legally record a cop but not a teacher 🤦♂️
Suhh Sebas Read about copyright laws. Teachers have copyright on their lectures. Do some homework.
its different if its not a lecture rather a talk-down with excessive use of humiliating and degrading language.
xynmo If you think you’re being treated unfairly, you should go complain to the principal. The rules are very clear regarding the use of cameras, etc. Don’t break the rules.
If the teacher treated unfairly a student, the teacher should be penalized.
@@eebbeerrttpp If you want to cite US state or federal law, then cite the applicable statute specifically. If you don't know the law that well, then don't pretend you do. The only possible defense here was the one the school made--that there was an expectation of privacy. Unless there is relevant case law specific to classrooms in the state, I think that is a dubious argument.
Reflected Miles Fool, not everything is about laws. There are also rules and legal agreements and contracts. Read about copyright laws before opening your filthy mouth, idiot.
Funny how the anti bullying goes out the window when it’s proven that it’s one of them that is guilty.
Bloody hypocrites
Jig a boo justice- only in the USA
Especially when the teachers are doing the bullying. Trust me, I've had two and one of them doubles as a Guidance Counselor.
That's why I don't ask for help. I just deal with it myself. If I have to I 'bully' them back, if you will (I never have had to do something of the sort as forced karma, and I hope I never have too), self defense or tell them off verbally. If that doesn't work. Oh well. I'll work it out 🤷♀️
Bet she votes democrat
You did do the right thing!
"Get Up... Stand Up...
Stand Up For Yours and Other's Rights!"
There is a No zero school policy for bullying, violence, and abuse!
Teacher: I wonder what you mom looks like
Daughter: better than you
@Cody Actually the student could say I will be glad to introduce you to her.
Or better than your mother or wife. That would have been Savage.👌😂
Its bad to make comparison about others
And I oop
LMAO!!!!!!
A little girl wants to stand up for her friend and she gets in trouble while a teacher who threatens a student gets to roam around free? Who else thinks this is a messed up situation?
ME
Natty Doggie Me.
Having been in a similar situation, me
Me!
Natty Doggie ME
They punished the student because they knew it was gonna go on the Internet then court.
The school punishing her just made it 100% worse, this probably means they would lose money due to students leaving or not joining. So if they "knew" it was going to court, they wouldn't have punished her
WhyDoesGoogleLetYouHaveALongName L.O.L. hi
WhyDoesGoogleLetYouHaveALongName L.O.L. it JUST went on the internet now..
WhyDoesGoogleLetYouHaveALongName L.O.L. Yep
Mr. Pig
They need to put cameras in the class room and see what these evil teachers are doing our children
@Paul Hebert
If you think that all kids are completely innocent angles, I’m assuming you’ve never seen a child let alone worked with them🤔
fake@@amylee8969
This little girl is a HERO in my eyes!!!
YES!! YOUR RIGHT! I DONT UNDERSTAND WHATS WRONG WITH THE SCHOOL WORST SCHOOL EVER THE PRINCIPAL SUSPENDED HER FOR DOING SOMTHING RIGHT!?!?
Heroine.
@@TallSilentGuy delete your comment please
no
I’m the best girl in my class
She’s a brave young girl. Good for her. Natural advocate.
Yes. More likes.
Just another spoiled kid.
@@pauldonohoe3646 No, she’s not. She’s trying to help people.
@Alex Stewart yeah, whatever. People like you just can't see the wood for the trees.
@Alex Stewart yours too mate
If “I will drop you” isn’t a threat, I don’t know what is.
@Jack Stucki
What's that mean?
@Jack Stucki um i’m sorry h u h 🤠
@@m.d7632 he’s being racist, that 6 letter word he’s referring to is the n word with er. He’s not funny.
@@tinyte5668 literally nobody is being racist noob
She could argue I ment from my class.....
The obnoxious idea of "an expectation of privacy" in a classroom with minors being held beyond their will needs to be tossed out, obviously.
She was suspended because she got proof on an abusive teacher. Typical. You did the right thing, sweetie.
And we would be having so much fun while out on suspension!
The teacher was not being filmed, her audio was just being recorded. The Phone was up against the kids shirt, not pointing toward the teacher!
TheWaterFlipper Jr. That's true
TheWaterFlipper Jr. YOU ARE RIGHT..THEY NEED A LAWYER NOW.OR MABEY WE CAN TELL THEM THAT
TheWaterFlipper Jr. Maybe she did record, but since privacy reasons couldn't play it
TheWaterFlipper Jr. it was blurred you idiot
Shouldn’t have phone is class. And it’s illegal to record people even in public without signed consent. In schools teachers need to sign off.
'i will drop you'
GET THAT TEACHER FIRED.
(*edit*) TYSM FOR 1K LIKES OMG-
Imagine threatening to drop a 10-12 year old kid. 💀
@@succurin8541 She meant dropping a letter grade
@@CryptoScammers.DoNotSendMoney I doubt that lmaooo.
weird how the story kind of glossed over the content of the recording. That's a big deal
@@CryptoScammers.DoNotSendMoney NO- LMAO
The student just wanted to keep everyone safe, she did nothing wrong
she recorded on her celphone the teacher being mean so in the eyes of every school that is a not good thing to do so you get expelled while the teacher still working at the same school without further warnings.that is how every school works.rarely some teachers are fine and do the right thing in some schools but that will be mostly the 1%
@@ColdNovRain the teacher in this video was fired
@@rixyz7013 how so sure you assist to the exact same school?based on personal experience the teacher is always defended no matter what.
They need to have cameras in school rooms.
I absolutely agree. This student should be commended for her actions, not punished.
Recording a government employee while they're on the job is never illegal.
Try doing that in most courtrooms today. Doesn't fly.
@@leelitchfield8370 she was not in a court room ,though they should be open to public recording too,just because they choose to enforce injustice does not make it right or legal
@@newdogatplay Except for family court, to protect the children. Those are invariably closed courts, just the prosecution, defense, witnesses and family members. Oh. And the Jury. But yeah. Other courts? Cameras the whole 9 yards.
@@leelitchfield8370 in ANY court room unless it is a closed hearing (and even then sometimes) people may record if they are involved somehow with the case. the courts themselves are recording for records which maybe obtained as public record. the records being available publicly therefor there is no expectation of privacy.
@@Soovdedthegoat A public school is public.
I'm so confused. How is bullying a child and telling them that you're going to drop them, LEGAL, but recording the adult saying that to the child is ILLEGAL??
IM SO LOST ABOUT THIS
Welcome to the land of law and politics
Most states require consent from the other party to be recorded OR there needs to be a disclaimer of some sort most often in the form of a sign saying you could potentially be recorded. Otherwise any evidence obtained is obtained illegally and therefore not used. They would have been better off getting all the kids accounts on the incident and take it from there. Not saying its right just helping clarify things.
@@jimmy-jermz4469, so the George Floyd recordings were illegal? How about recordings of someone breaking into your house? Did you ask the burglar if you can record him first? 😅
@@bryaneverett9850 right on!
TAKE YOUR CHILDREN BACK PEOPLE. ONE OF MANY BIBLICAL TEACHINGS DISREGARDED.
@@bryaneverett9850 it is the law a burglar can sue you if you shoot them in a state that has shitty gun laws
This happened to me in Martin County FL, in 5th grade back in 2005, i brought a voice recorder to school to show my mom that our teacher was yelling and cussing at us all. This teacher was very sharp and harsh to us. My mom brought it to the principal to show them her cussing rant & they told me i could get sued for violation of privacy and merely switched me to a different teacher's class for the remainder of the year. Way to make a kid feel like those in power are standing up for the bully. This is a real problem.
I was bullied by my 2nd grade teachers so I understand how that feels. This student did very well.
I was bullied by a second grade teacher as well back when they could paddle you.
my grandmother had decided that she was gonna sit in class, getting permission from the principal, to see any difference. She acted more professional with her in the room, but she did it for a couple days to see what the kids say. Everyone in my grade was so thankful and even some teachers next door thanked her, as the school politics prevented any change. She didn't teach again next year at our school and she was horrible.
I was bullied too. I’m now in 8th grade and I don’t take squat from teachers anymore
Soft
bruh same my 5th grade teacher bullied everyone thinking back i should have told my mom
I had an abusive teacher in 6th grade. If a student did ever as much as take a breath she would give a major referral. One time I remember this kid was correcting her because she gave the wrong answer, and she grabbed him from the neck and threw him out the classroom. I hope she got fired, but when I ended middle school she was still there so I don’t know what happened to her.
How old was she?
4th Doctor Jelly Babies idk she was in her early 40’s
@@v06261 what grade are you in now?
In 8th grade, I had a math teacher who was a true bully. She was very mean (not just strict...strict teachers can be nice, like Professor McGonagall) to students she looked down on. I was a hard-working student who always did my best, but math wasn't my strong point. This teacher treated me with disdain, as if I weren't a person worthy of respect. Middle school is a critical age too, where students focus on self- and peer-acceptance. It's a delicate period of change. She was also mean to other students for different reasons, but she seemed to hate me because I wasn't like the smarter students (this was probably my low socioeconomic status showing, which I wasn't aware of at the time). She didn't even have any of my siblings, so her meanness didn't stem from prejudice against my family either. I hated her because she made me feel horrible about myself. This is in contrast to my amazing high school math teachers, who were non-judgmental and nothing but supportive of students who were struggling in math. For that reason, I was more motivated to do better in math and even started to like it.
4th Doctor Jelly Babies 10th
My daughter went from a bright loving sweet girl to a sobbing anxious nervous child, because a teacher was bullying her. We finally found out but my daughter is 27 and still deals with severe anxiety. High praise for this little girl.!
@@gypsytreasures3856 sounds like ur dumb LMAOO
@@gypsytreasures3856 facts
@@gypsytreasures3856 it doesn't work like that for everyone
@@gypsytreasures3856 you're basically encouraging bullying. Wtf is wrong with you?
@@gypsytreasures3856 Yeah sure but bullying from a teacher infront the whole class? someone alot of people look up to?
11 year old already know what abuse is. Well done child.
“No bully zone”, yeah right
Yeah why is it that bullies are protected while the victims who are being bullied are the ones getting suspended and charged?
gianasmp3 like bullying doesn’t go on yeah right!dreadful conduct!truth is bulling always has and always will happen!fair play to the girl for recording it!
Sometimes teachers are the worst bullies a child will encounter
The teachers at my school favor the bad kids and racist to Mexicans
And how was the teacher disciplined? If the children can’t record, then maybe they should have cameras in every classroom!
I'm all for cameras in the classroom
I too vote for cameras in the classroom. And they should be on 24/7.
Excellent idea
Kids in the classroom have a right to privacy even if the teacher doesn't.
even if they did they'd just protect their own and refuse to release the evidence of faculty wrongdoing
So the NSA can record all our phone calls, emails, etc., but this girl can't record her teacher, especially if she is harassing a student? Wow
i love this comment
+Cosmic Giraffe and so do I
they should make this recording a legal acception beacause its only reasonable
So true
+ethannitro817 pure irony and that teacher had no right to do this
This is insane. Omg. Horrible horrible teacher, school, county, n state. Disgusted!!
If you are a teacher, YOUR “bad day” can ruin a child’s entire student career! Be aware of your words! They hurt more because they come from someone who is suppose to be their teacher, role model, and the person who they should look up to and feel safe with!
Brianna should've minded her own business.
@@theTruthSeekerishere shut up
@@theTruthSeekerishere I hope you have no children because if you do I hope cps is involved
I agree with you 100%. I had a teacher in Junior High School that said many mean things to me and belittled me in front of my other classmates. I’ve never forgotten how cruel she was to me
@@krellman7 Man got PTSD from that
"Expectation of privacy" -imagine criminals using this as a defense in court when their criminal activity is recorded on cctv .
It is used all the time... it's called the fourth amendment. Many charges end up being drop or dismissed due to warrants not be obtained.
They do and that's not even the worst defense criminals can use to get out of trouble...
There is no expectation of privacy in a public school.
@@mariaweston5477might wanna check the laws in Florida. Florida is a two-party consent state meaning both parties have to consent to being recorded. So technically the child did commit a 3rd-degree felony.
I don't know if a court would agree with the expectation of privacy. The school may claim it and have a policy, so the suspension may be legit, but I don't know if the law would back them. I think any evidence against would/should be taken seriously. She isn't a cop, she can't violate someone's rights.
WHY WOULD THEY SUSPEND THE STUDENT
LPSShinyCrystals ikr
Jay Raylee I guess that's fair..
Shiny Crystalz she broke the fourth amendment
Shiny Crystalz sounds like something my old education centre,DPRK would do
Shiny Crystalz irk WHY WOULD THEY GOSHHH
I had a 4th grade teacher I just hated going to her classroom. Math was my least favorite subject & I didn't understand a lot of it. This teacher didn't hide who her favorites were. They were the smart kids that never asked questions and always raised their hands. She made it obvious she had NO patience for me. It was my most miserable year of school, by far. The following year I had the sweetest, kindest, most patient teacher I had ever had. Best school year ever & I actually enjoyed learning math. Won second place in the class spelling bee that year with my best friend, who won first place. Those 2 years of grade school were like night and day, different. Many people have no idea how much a teacher can influence how you learn or don't learn. How miserable they can make learning for you. Many teachers may have good intentions but, truly should not be allowed to teach children anything because they should not be teachers!
@ Wyonative08
What kind of classroom environment was your 4th grade class? We’re most of the kids difficult and descriptive? Cause if so, that could be why she was frustrated, stressed, and favored the kids who were well-behaved. No teacher likes to deal with difficult kids just like how no customer service worker likes dealing with a Karen.
@@amylee8969 That's not true. No teacher goes into a classroom believing that all kids are going to be college bound sweethearts. I've heard of teachers who like the challenge of turning around a kid who is difficult. Teachers have different teaching styles and kids don't understand that - they only know if they like how the teacher acts or not, and not every kid will like a particular teacher.
I think that all kids have a few years of elementary school or junior high that they think were difficult
She did do the RIGHT THING. I dare a teacher tell my child “I will drop you”.
Sometimes "the adults" really are the crazy ones..
@@janetmcarthur5257 especially when it comes to our children , we might get a little crazy 😜
Every class room should have cameras in place so parents can see what is being taught to there children , lots of lunatic teachers out there now trying to indoctrinate our kids ,
@@maddog8274 If they want to see what's going on, let them schedule a visit. Perhaps you should read "1984".
I'd be going to that school and playing pick a hand with that teacher (Pick the hand I'm gonna slap you with)
“I will drop you”
“I wonder what your mother looks like”
Lord that lady does not need to be a teacher. She trying to sound tough and “grown up” to a child but ends up sounding like a petulant child herself. I hope she got fired.
The parent needs to drop that teacher...probably some SJW teacher....
moon sounds like a black lady
Concur trying to talk to she know she just ain't come across the right mother from them streets one of them gangster mothers that have come up in there and bang her straight in the mouth and drag out back into them streets in back into the school and then back and forth again jack up yeah let me shut it down because I used to be be one of them kind and then tell you now call the police or now matter fact apologize now what was that you were saying forgive me Lord because I used to be one of them kind but now I'm spiritual gangster fight for the Lord I'm no longer one of them Street gangsters I repeated the spiritual gangster fight for justice for what is right for every everything and everyone race Creed of color that that gets my goat going that's what old folks used to say in other words that stirs my pot 😡😤 bullying and then taking advantage of the lease and then talking about their mother well I have to go cuz Spirit of the Lord said pray for them for they know not what they do and Jesus is not only My All in All My my rock my provider my sword my shield My healer he's my vindicator he said vengeance is mine so grateful when you see evil and people like that you pray God we'll get them he said vengeance is mine he sees all he hears all and he knows all he resist the proud he hates so proud spirit but he loves to humble and kind heart all of you views that were for the little girl and rooting for her keep following the thing that's good keep having a kind heart and trusting in the the utmost high God in Jesus being a believer and always standing up for what is right in your life shy don't follow evil God bless you all for standing up for what is right and the truth cuz Jesus is the truth the way and the life 💫🕊️🙏😇
@@Zaa-up4hg I hate to say it but I thought the same thing....and a white student......no wonder the school wanted to shut it down
But filming the teacher, we got ourselves a Karenette.
Girl sacrificed 5 days in school suspention to catch an abusive teacher, that sounds like a good trade to me.
Subdude but nothing happen to the teacher so?
Subdude same
Subdude I would rather be suspended for a righteous and good deed than bad and unrighteousness deeds. That little girl didn't do anything wrong at all, she caught a bad teacher in her own bad behavior and unacceptable conduct. Students have a right to a safe environment. The teacher is being mean, verbally abusive, and is bullying- so what give that teacher any right to intimate or bully a student and making them bad? They have no right to disrespect students. The teacher is disrespectful towards students. It's the worst thing ever do. The teacher to remind herself of one rule that she should follow herself:. "Treat everyone the way you want to be treated." Otherwise wise treat one another with random acts of kindness, respect, and fairness. That teacher is being a bad example of her behavior and conduct when she expects kids to behave well and conduct themselves acceptably. Good teachers show positive examples of good behavior, conduct, fairness, respect, and fairness to their students. Good teachers except students for who they are no matter what their differences, weaknesses/strengths, talents, giftednesses, traits, or abilities are. That teacher should be reprimanded and lectured about how wrong bullying is.
i have been expelled and suspeneded many times.. i dont see how it effects people??
Subdude no it's not
That girl better become attorney General when she grows up
"I wonder what your mom looks like."
..................what is that supposed to mean?
Thats a question that teacher should have to answer to add hate crime enhancements.
I took it as she wants to fight her mom
I think it obviously implied that she expects the kid’s mom to be overweight. An insult.
she said "your the BIGGEST kid in class, but your acting like the smallest one" she is basically saying... if the kids big I wonder what the mom looks like
I heard I wonder what your mom would think
What about the teacher is she SUSPENDED?
Great question
Teachers can't be suspended, they can be fired lmao
@@jayeffmusic348 they can be suspended from there job for a while
JoshTheAnimator Of course they can be suspended. A teacher in my town was suspended recently for making a 9 year old kid stand on a table for an hour after getting the other kids to write criticisms about the boy on post it notes and put them all over him. Apparently the boy was disrespectful to the teacher.
@@jayeffmusic348 they can,lmao
Expectation of privacy in a PUBLIC school? I don't think so.
Greg Swallow Yeah, the door wasn't locked, so everybody could come in, meaning no privacy.
Greg Swallow yeah lol
It's a public school, not a private school.
BY your logic teachers could just take pictures and put them on the internet, or vise versa.
Robert Teachers are PUBLIC employees and must follow laws and rules designed for the protection and rights of the PUBLIC. Students, in a PUBLIC school, are the PUBLIC, not paid employees, and are there as required by law. If the PUBLIC school is not protecting the PUBLIC then the PUBLIC must protect themselves.
There should be cameras in the classroom to monitor not only children behavior but teachers as well. No expectations of privacy in public
That’s nuts. There’s NEVER an “expectation of privacy” when you’re with other people’s children. Places that are protected from video include the bathrooms and locker rooms - but even there, if threats are being made, an audio recording can be made.
Good point
I 100% agree!
YOU KNOW HOW GOVERNMENT SYSTEMS WORK, NEW RULES WITHOUT PROCESS!
If the teacher recorded the kid, it would be viewed differently.
Citizens have the RIGHT to record public officials in the PERFORMANCE OF THEIR DUTIES!!!
I think you're wrong. Would you kindly cite chapter and verse?
@@alfredlutz7258 not wrong . . Public schools are funded by tax dollars which makes them public employees . Which means they can not stop a free citizen from filming misconduct this is a constitutionally protected activity .
This is a violation of this young ladies civil rights . I violation of the 1st which is very serious.
@@codysmoot386 I don't think that's quite right. A "free citizen," whatever that is, can't do whatever he/she wants to do. For example, you can't walk into a classroom, just because you feel like it. A public school is public, but it is not a public place in the sense a public square is. The 1st Amendment doesn't apply in the classroom in the way it applies elsewhere. For example, I can give a student an F for incompetent work, and that student won't be helped by saying that, well, I'm violating his or her 1st Amendment rights.
@@alfredlutz7258 listen . What does a grade have to do with a student recording a teacher insult and threaten another student . Who is a child remind you. . .
The child is the extension of the adult in a public form . If teacher violates the child's constitution rights they are in turn violating the adults rights . .
The child heard something wrong . Took out the phone a recorded the teacher . 1 there is no expectation of privacy in a public place . .
2 it is a constitutionally protected activity regardless if it was a 11 years old in a class room . .
3 if they erased or deleted video that would be tampering with evidence as well witch is a crime .
So now the teachers and principles will be held liable in civil and criminal court ...
@@codysmoot386 I think all I said was that there are different kinds of public spaces. What you get to do downtown, you don't get to do in a classroom. I would want to see a specific reference to a law (or a court ruling) that allows somebody to record a teacher and then make that recording public. As soon as somebody here shows me that, I'll concede the point.
Schools don't care about the safety and well-being of their students. They don't even care about educating them. No, all they care about is attendance because more students in school puts money in their pockets.
When my great aunt died when I was in high school, my mother had to fight to let my school agree to let me go to her funeral which was during a school day! They asked her questions like, "How well did I know her?" and what-have-you. What the hell does it matter?! Blood is blood, but do schools care about that? No. One less student in class means a few less cents in their pockets. That's all they care about.
Heck, my US and Texas Govt. teachers in high school told their entire classes that all students were to them were paychecks. They didn't care if we were sick unless we were puking out lungs out, they wanted us to attend classes anyway.
WOO! You go, Mother!
Seven
Cruel
Hours
Of
Our
Life
Lin’s World seven?
That's actually a really good argument for alternate schooling, as opposed to public schools.
@CountryBeautiful I know how you feel. I was bullied a lot too, and no one did anything about it. Heck, honestly, if you're on the football team, you could probably get away with murdering someone right in front of the principal.
@CountryBeautiful wtf that's ridiculous I just pay 75c and 50c for a bag of chips but 1$ for icecream
The young lady did right. Why? There was verbal harassment that was being targeted at a student in the classroom. Teachers are there to teach, period. Teachers believe that they are Pandas and that anything they do, flies, and this is not so. Nov. 2022.
Teachers should never say anything they would not say in front of a parent.
Exactly.
Facts
Let's hope they don't talk to their parents like that
Amen. Talk to my kid like that and you're going to see what her momma looks like.
Word
That little girl has better judgment than those "teachers"
Yeah that's true
+Miguel Castro Agreed. Notice the reporters did not put their microphone in the principal's face, as they should have. They did not even name him/her, or the teacher.
Ikr
yea
IKR. She should be the teacher instead. Not that crazy woman
There is NO expectation of privacy in a classroom, a public setting. She needs to get her daughter a lawyer and sue not just the teacher, but also the school for the way they handled the situation.
@@magaman1402 it's not about the monetary compensation. It's about getting not just that teacher fired, but everyone who's responsible for this, and also clearing the name of her daughter, letting all her classmates, neighbors, or just everyone know that she was suspended for being a hero, not a villain.
Supreme Court decided this for long ago although it normally involves police. You are absolutely allowed to record a tax paid employee on public land. Teaches all employees of the state. And the school is paid for with tax dollars!
its a controlled setting if it was public parents could wander the hallways at will but in reality any non permitted personnel in classroom or playground can be cited for traspassing.
@@rev.jonathanwint6038 if you belirve that rev please go on the playground during school hours and video. I want to know how long it will take the cops to hual u off.
@@gdiaz8827 It doesn't have to be accessible to everyone for it to be considered "public" in terms of privacy. For example, Costco is a public setting even though only members can shop there.
Threatening students with threats of beating should be removed from teaching forever.
You DID do the right thing Briana. That teacher is a POS, and the school should be ashamed. These teachers are public servants, and they deserve accountability.
Should release recording and video to the community and show everybody what a bully the teacher really is.
@Jesus is LORD Jesus died and stayed dead.
Greg you said everything that needs to be said to clear this up for the girl, public servents does not have the right to privacy when on the job, the bathroom is the only place you can't record. I forcee a big court case that will be won by the girls family and hopefully both teacher and principal will be removed from ever teaching another child.
@@norberthofer5830 this report is from 2015
@@evieshore3270 Does it matter when the video was taken? The teacher and school were in the wrong.
Well, at least suspensions mean we have a break from hell
Natsu Dragneel hi natsu OwO
Omg I recognize you! You were on that one rob landes vid with anime openings
Yasssss
But we’re missing work and if we do after school activities we can’t do that during suspension. That’s what sucks
@@djuannalester4743 that's why it's called hell
Teachers don't like being held accountable for the awful things they say and do
then home school them or go to a private school!
@JASPER LAW HUI YAU Moe it is but children's brains are valuable. Be involved with them
RECORDED VIDEO OF ANY CLASSROOM WHILE THE TEACHER AND STUDENTS ARE PRESENT MUST BE DONE. we cannot afford another generation of children to be indoctrinated by these communist social traitors.
Neither do kids.
@JASPER LAW HUI YAU Moe 🤭
What, she did right thing mom said,
If the school says its illegal then I'm going to court over them taking pictures of me without my permission
Fanimation Animation they can if it's private
NinjaPig but it's not any student or parent can purchase them they can also display pictures on the school page and ANYONE who has access to the internet can see them. So no it's not private.
NinjaPig my school puts it on schools twitter
Sometimes at the beginning of the school year, your parents sign a waiver and somewhere on that is permission to take photos for educational purposes. At least that's what they do at my school.
lol in elementary the put my friends on the home page without them or their parents knowing. also what if a kid doesn't want his picture in the yearbook?