New York Giants 2024 Draft Grade | PFF
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 кві 2024
- PFF's Sam Monson and Steve Palazzolo grade the New York Giants 2024 NFL Draft Class.
Interested in working at PFF?! Check out our openings: pff.com/jobs
📲 Download the PFF App: apps.apple.com/us/app/pff-fan...
✅ Subscribe to PFF+: www.pff.com/subscribe
📧 Join our newsletter: forms.gle/maqTaBKcmdPR5Vma6
🏈 NFL/NCAA Player Grades: www.pff.com/grades - Спорт
remember part of the giants draft was the edge rusher they traded the 2nd round pick.for.
Absolutely!!!
Brian Burns
No it was not. They traded for Burns, he is getting a hefty contract - no comparison to a draftee, they just included the draft choice as part of a trade agreement. Don't compare trades to draftees. I am not suggesting btw that it was a bad deal, but its comparing apples to oranges.
All Giants fans need to watch this so they can stop fighting each other. Most toxic fan base lately. GO BIGblue
Go Blue? You're a Wolverine fan?
@@TheCruzan26 big blue baby. Good catch
@@Cwildyoutube BIG BLUE!!! Let's hope DJ stay healthy this year.
What PFF says isn't Bible lol.
It really is lol I've never seen anything like it.
Nobody is talking about Dante Miller out of S. Carolina. We got him in FA, and was one of the fastest players in FA AND in the draft. Homie is Ivy League smart, ran a 4.28, & benched 28reps. Nothing to sneeze at. My guess is Tracy jr is 3rd down back, and Dante and Singletary split carries
I have a feeling that either miller or Tracy will be designated to special teams before the start of the season
Turbo!
Nabers could be our Ceedee
14th with an A-, im a giants fan but we gotta be a bit more harsh with the grades if half the league is an A-
Giants made the best pick in taking Nabers. They have a lot of needs and taking a QB this early would be unwise. Giants prior to Nabers had a bunch of #3 WRs….
Wandale is border line number 2
I think Hyatt has a WR2 ceiling, but he’s obviously not there yet.
A great draft. This rebuild will take a little more time, but it is being done right. Just remember that the only team to win a Super Bowl in the last four decades is the New York Giants. Before this decade is over, it will be five.
I hope you are right. We average a SB per decade so....
Look most NFL teams their owners are totally crazy and have no chance of winning. New York Giants is one of those teams. You know right off the bat you don't have prayer of winning the Super Bowl.
Like a good Naber, Louisiana State Farm is there
GoBigBlue! 🔥💪🏽
Factor in Burns we spent our second rounder on him and 150 mil 😅
The thing that excites me for the next season is that we've at least bolstered our offensive line and got a bunch of depth there. We got "baby cakes "Junior imagine how pissed off his daddy is
Im surprised,Sam never gives the GIANTS anything other than thumbs down
If Nabers won the Biletnikoff award like he should have then the Giants would have drafted the last 2 winners back to back…i thought they drafted well this year especially if you add in Brian Burns to the 6 draft picks which you have to consider on some level.
shouldve taken haynes over phillips in the third and it would've been a perfect draft
Giants needed a corner. OG has plenty of competition between FA signed and younger players
i would have added troy franklin
We wisely did not take an offensive lineman. We have too many young guys -- Ezudu, Neal, Schmitz -- to figure out as it is. They were wise to get some older, good players to balance out the youth. We are not winning a championship next year. Let the offense line come into view and draft a complement next year. Same thing with defensive line. We have players that need snaps to see what we have. We have a tough schedule. I think we win 9 or 10 games, compete for playoff spot, maybe miss out but finish the year strong on a good year from Daniel.
👌🏾👌🏾✅
Rome was not built in a day
He went to Chicago
Im Glad That Rome is in Chicago. Nabers is our Number,1l@@debo4jc
The TE might be good... cannot see Waller returning
Nubin ran a 4.59 off of surgery and was injured during the season… I don’t know and 4.5 range was too slow for safety
Instead of the running back or linebacker they could have gone after an OL or DL but overall I'm pleased with the draft. The first 4 seem like they will get right into the lineup and contribute and even the last two could def. contribute this coming year. Every pick is solid and these guys are gonna get better. Just like i felt about the draft last year pretty much.
Giants signed 5 OL with experience, if they drafted a rookie that wasn't going to start, they were going to have to waive them and allow other teams to take them. That's on the OL and DL. They also have 2 DL that showed promise last year and still on their first contracts.
@@franknoneofya9585 I am well aware of what we did in "free agency" lol, we are talking about the draft. I wish in the draft they had tried for an offensive or defensive lineman but I did also say I'm fine with what they did.
I feel that after drafting a WR they should have not taken a TE but they should have taken OL. Rookie contract, draft deep in OL. Seahawks got Chris Hayes in 3rd. @@franknoneofya9585
Same thing I was going to say
They didnt like the guys that were there or they would have taken one.
Nabers is a lot to handle so the talent stops mattering if his off the field troubles follow him. Add to that the fact Drew Lock and Daniel Jones inspire zero confidence and this could get ugly.
Good draft but the elephant in the room we still have DJ….
If instead of Phillips they'd gotten Christian Haynes i'd think it was perfect
Me too. Haynes or Beebe.
Huge misstep in my view, but what do I know ?
Couldn't agree more. I don't love Phillips at pick 3.
@@mikec6733 both are overrated.
Some Talkin' Giants fans in this post+replies.
I actually think Nubin will stand out more for the giants this season than Nabers. But Nabers is a monster....but daniel jones cant throw well past 20yds. Hes trash. Really hoping Locke takes the starter spot
I have lost 0 faith in Jones. I still think he's an elite QB. Playoffs here we come! I hope Nabers lives up to the hype bc if he does oh boy!
be prepared for a let down
@@Iunches here we go another fair weather fan!
*I would've preferred that the Giants drafted an edge pass rusher instead of the tight end, but other than that, a pretty damn good draft. Now they just need to perform.*
We just signed one over free agency we addressed bigger question marks on the roster
nah i really like the TE pick considering waller might retire in a year. Johnson has great deep threat potential as well as good route running and separation, which we struggle greatly with. Having a TE that can reliably get open is such a good pickup.
@@MidtownMeezus#39 = Burns
Burns will have more of an impact on the Giants than any second round pick.
A-
The problem with the Giants not getting the QB that they wanted and thought highly about, is that they may not have the opportunely to acquire a franchise QB in the draft for who knows how many years to come. And what they are going to be running Daniel Jones and his limited skill set out there and try to win with a QB that has not over five season been able to put points on the board, elevate any player on the team, or remain healthy. Good luck with that. Brilliant schemes by coaches to hide the weaknesses of a QB can only work for so long, until the league catches up to that game and makes adjustments to shut the things that he can do down.
Can you define a “franchise quarterback”? Is Justin Herbert and why…he has led his team to nothing. Is Trevor Lawrence and if so why? Love how that phrase is tossed around.
Giants offered this yrs 1st, next yrs 1st and this yrs 47th pick and Pats turned it down. I got Drew Lock as QB1 this yr 😂
Thank God the Pats turned them down.
Daniel Jones will have a great year in 2024.
@@cybersanta1413 I hope that you're right.
From what I understood, the Pats WANTED this year’s 1st, next year’s 1st and this year’s 47th pick… which is what the Giants (wisely) declined.
@@eskemeldgaardkrogh4145 That seems to be a much more likely scenario.
Giants are a bad football team. They need to build their team. However, this was one of the best QB draft class and will be for a long time. Giants really missed out
It will take 4 years to see how great this class is or isn't. Cutlets won more games than Beyce Young & Anthony Richardson last year so does that me Young & Richardson were bad picks?
didnt they say the 2021 QB class was going to be great too? now look at them 3 years later lol
@@codyb988 no body that knows what they're talking about ever said that. Only the idiots on ESPN and shows said bs like that and they say all kinds of bs for views and ratings. Chris Simms never said so either
@@usuhbi but arent you listening to the people on those shows to back up your point of this being one of the best QB draft classes and will be for a long time? The 2021 Class started off the same way with the first 3 picks as QB then followed up with 2 more going in the top 15. Therefor its safe to say that the scouts/coaches/GM agreed that there were 5 worthy QB to go in the top 15. These people get paid big money to be experts and the analysts on tv seemed to agree with them prior to the draft happening. Anyway, i think you might have missed the whole point of the comment. The point was simply to say nobody ever really knows for sure that this past draft class is the best QB class or will be for a long time. Only time will tell and according to the the Giants this was a 3 QB class and the other 3 werent worth the 6th pick since they went with Nabers instead of a QB.
How on earth do you know they missed out….can you assure me that Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye, etc are going to be terrific?
Can't block or tackle for decades NY Tankers tank yet another draft with useless junk 😅
Instead of Theo Johnson they should drafted a RB
theo johnson is an athletic freak with high upside. he was a great pick
Tyrone tracy is a good prospect. We’ll be good
We got Dante Miller he wast the fastest undrafted free agent in that class he got the skills just need to turn up at camp we got depth at that position really Gray/Stacy jr / we gonna see come week 1
Despite what many believe, the Giants do not have on their roster an elite, game changing Edge Rusher, and they desperately needed one. They have in Kayvon and Burns, two undersized pass rushers, with Kayvon disappearing for games at time, and he often sacrifices the outside to gain an inside tract to the QB, allowing big plays when the pocket collapses and the QB turns the corner that Kelvin just left unmanned. Perhaps the Giants are thinking two mediocre edge rushers = one Elite Dominant Edge Rusher, but the two together do not equal one Reggie White, Richard Dent, Smith, LT, etc...
Terrible take.
@@Too-WavyyBut entirely accurate. My uncle is a super NFL scout for Tampa. We discuss these issues in detail. He informs me that if the Giants were to explore trading Daniel Jones, he would be shocked if any team offered more than an inconsequential late round draft pick, as his skill-set more closely aligns with that of a career back-up rather than an elite QB, and Kayvon is often manhandled by offensive linemen out-weighing him by 60-80 pounds, completely neutralizing him. I respect his opinions because he knows football certainly as much or more than I and most people ever will. It is also factual that Kayvon goes quarters at a time without making any major impact on the defense. He has 11.5 sacks last season, with 6.5 of them coming in three games against the lowly Commanders and NY Jets. Than means in 15 others games he had a combined 5 sacks. In the two games against Philly he had Zero sacks and a whopping three tackles. Against Dallas he had another Zero sacks, and 1 tackle over two games (no existent presence). I am sorry if you don't like to hear the facts and the truth, but being better informed is the way I always intend to walk through life.
Spencer Rattler
Woulda been nice. High upside
He would have handled having Daboll throwing his tablets at him on national television way more calmly then Jones. Yep, he would have been the perfect personality to be coached by Daboll.
The Giants aren’t going anywhere with Daniel Jones. Saquon led them to the playoffs and when Daniel Jones faced a real defense in the playoffs he wet the bed.
that is not even remotely true. RB do not lead a team anywhere.
PFF is ass
The NFL sacrificed running backs, glad I grew up in the 90s
Next Bavaro? When I see him drag 5 49er defensive players downfield with brute strength, then I would believe that. Til then, he is possibly a good player the NYGs needed to draft a little early to fill a need. If Waller retires this is, if he returns it was a pick that could’ve been a really good guard unfortunately. He basically forced NYGs to make next years pick, this year. Dude should have had his mind made up by the draft.
bro he was joking
Still a good pick whether Waller stays or not. How many snaps do you really think he will take for the Giants? Not many if any in my opinion. Theo is 6’6” 260! Worst case scenario he’s like an extra lineman who can run and catch.