Nice, there were some new ones on me in there! A small correction: that wire attached to Kenobi’s light sabre in the original fight was for a motor; they tried a few different methods throughout the first movie, but in this shot they spun the blade and the light is coming from behind the camera, reflecting off it makes it appear to be lit. As an aside, and because I’m bored and have the free time, here’s all I recall about the original light sabre blade effects : They reflected the light that well by using a special highly reflective tape, which at the time was normally only reserved for use in front projection trick shots where a pre-filmed scene would appear behind the foreground actors by projecting it from the same angle as the camera filming it. Here it was simply reflecting a bright white point of light placed directly behind the camera lens, making it appear to glow in-camera. In the shot where we see Luke trying it for the first time, they stuck it onto a flat blade (the use of a practical blade is why the shot jumps a little as he switches it on, they had everyone freeze, a stage hand attached the blade to the hilt, then continued the scene, after cutting out the middle part it appeared to ‘magically’ turn on), but having noticed that this produced highly uneven lighting as the blade moved around, on the ship they tried a combo of a round stick, or using no on set blade at all and adding it in later by hand, which meant a blade could be seen to extend or retract without a cut but also made life very hard for the animator trying to imagine where the blade should be, which was highly evident in the original film seen in cinemas, before all the remasters. For the final boss battle fight they tried a ‘stretched 3 sided pyramid’ shape which spun, for 2 reasons, one they needed them to hit each other without bending too much or breaking, and two, the shape and the spinning meant a more even fatter light along the entire blade from base to tip at any angle, due to how the light played along the sides as it span, even when it was not entirely centred in the shot, which was much needed for a fight scene with two blades at either side of the screen. It also gave them a natural ‘fizz’ which, in combination with the later added colouring, that vibrates frame to frame due to being hand animated, then became the preferred look for the whole franchise, as it particularly suited the concept of a ‘laser sword’ by making it appear more volatile and ’alive’ than a still blade, and with the added sound effects it all finally came together. As mentioned in post production they were added to with hand animated coloured glows drawn over the original practical blades by matching them to the rear lit reflective glows, but full screen flashes were added in too (matched with sound effects) each time they touched to give them a much needed sense of ’dangerous power’, and now of course with all the CGI replacements this gives a much more consistent look over all the movies, but originally how the blades first appeared pretty radically altered shot to shot as the effects team tried to pin down the best way to achieve the desired effect, and even now you can still tell that the first blade seen is distinctly flatter than all the rest of the shots. Thank you for coming to my TED talk.
The Gonk droid isn't the only one that experiences pain. Throughout the Empire Strikes Back, C3PO feels pain and fear. In the prequels, all the separatist droids felt pain and fear also.
In Empire Han never had a jacket on in the freezing chamber. The close ups have his shirt in shadow making it look much darker. My friend and I analyzed this over and over back in the 90s. I haven’t compared the remastered version, but if it was digitally lightened up it was to avoid confusion that people thought he was wearing a jacket.
3:18 Not only that but at some point after operating on Anakin, giving him the ability to breathe and walk and use his arms.... OK... At some point after that but some point before restraining him to the table, someone has gone "WAIT.... He needs a cape.... make sure it's black and almost touches the floor".
When Han is lowered into the Carbonite freezer, his hands are cross-bound at the wrist in front. When the slab is pulled out, they are untied and held wide apart.
One of the most glaring inconsistencies in Empire was the statement Luke made about the Imperial walker's armor being too much for their blaster, go for legs and the tow cables, then upon the walker falling down, one of their ships swoops in and blast it causing a massive explosion.
During the Bespin when Luke hits Vader and sparks fly from his shoulders, if you slow it down you see he hit him straight in the neck. A few seconds later when Vader cuts down those antennas they clearly used a shorter stick for the lightsaber blade to "go through" the antenass, but th4 VFX crew only rotoscoped the short stick and didn't extend it so that it appears that the saber reaches the antennas.
at 17:37 the second lightsaber on Darth Vader's belt was explained in the book as Luke's lightsaber...While hiding from Vader, Luke rolled his saber out on the floor before saying "I will not fight your" and Vader picked it up and after the sister comment, Luke used the force to grab his lightsaber before attacking Vader
5:02 You can literally see the dirt falling from her clothes as she gets up. Yes, it was a mistake, but one they had already spotted, and tried to fix "in movie".
I noticed the switched lightsabers goof in the trailer for Episode III but I thought “That’s just a bad edit in the trailer. There’s no way it’ll be like that in the movie.” But then I sat there on opening day cursing under my breath.
I have to say my favorite duel is the Crouching Jedi, Hidden Yoda duel between Yoda and Count Dooku. For a near 900 year old being Yoda sure is a nimble bugger. Why did we change Narrators 21:00 minutes into the video?
There’s a visible mistake in your actual video at 27:30 , in the last shot of the walker you can see the stick coming up through the floor pushing the back leg that causes it to fall over 😉 Bill George told me that , and he was the one who pushed the stick!) 🙀 And the “I know” jacket was never there all shots were just the shirt, it’s been bebated since the 80s but debunked via many sources etc then as you say lightened for the recent versions
I wouldn't call Leia knowing her mother was a kind and caring woman a continuity error, as she's given to Bail Organa, someone who personally knew Padme and the kind of character she was, as shown in Kenobi little Leia ain't dumb she probably figured out she was at the very least adopted and asked about her parents, Anakin most likely left a sore spot with Bail on account of him murdering the Jedi and causing Padme's death so never spoke about him, whereas why wouldn't he talk about his friend to his friend's biological daughter?
The AT-AT's are not a mistake. The AT-ST's, just like real ground troops protecting armor, are there to protect the flanks. And yes I do know tanks have turrets but, yes, ground troops are deployed to protect armor. If there is a mistake, it was the Imp's in there arrogance, not deploying airpower.
@@taylorbarker616Not a hobby when dealing with a monetised channel who are farming ad revenue from schmucks. It then becomes a duty to call out bad content.
@@13thcentury “You're wrong, Leia. You have that power too. In time you'll learn to use it as I have. The Force is strong in my family. My father has it...I have it...and...my sister has it.” -Luke She was also able to hear Luke from Cloud City with no training. I like a good nitpick, when it’s not mean spirited, and this video is certainly not being mean spirited. I don’t agree with this one though.
Oh, THOSE mistakes. I thought you were talking about remastering the original trilogy that ruined Star Wars, the entire prequel trilogy, and Bob Iger ruining The Last Jedi (2019).
In Empire Han never had a jacket on in the freezing chamber. The close ups have his shirt in shadow making it look much darker. My friend and I analyzed this over and over back in the 90s. I haven’t compared the remastered version, but if it was digitally lightened up it was to avoid confusion that people thought he was wearing a jacket.
Not giving water to Jar-Jar almost adds to the Darth Jarr-Jar theory.
Nice, there were some new ones on me in there! A small correction: that wire attached to Kenobi’s light sabre in the original fight was for a motor; they tried a few different methods throughout the first movie, but in this shot they spun the blade and the light is coming from behind the camera, reflecting off it makes it appear to be lit.
As an aside, and because I’m bored and have the free time, here’s all I recall about the original light sabre blade effects :
They reflected the light that well by using a special highly reflective tape, which at the time was normally only reserved for use in front projection trick shots where a pre-filmed scene would appear behind the foreground actors by projecting it from the same angle as the camera filming it. Here it was simply reflecting a bright white point of light placed directly behind the camera lens, making it appear to glow in-camera.
In the shot where we see Luke trying it for the first time, they stuck it onto a flat blade (the use of a practical blade is why the shot jumps a little as he switches it on, they had everyone freeze, a stage hand attached the blade to the hilt, then continued the scene, after cutting out the middle part it appeared to ‘magically’ turn on), but having noticed that this produced highly uneven lighting as the blade moved around, on the ship they tried a combo of a round stick, or using no on set blade at all and adding it in later by hand, which meant a blade could be seen to extend or retract without a cut but also made life very hard for the animator trying to imagine where the blade should be, which was highly evident in the original film seen in cinemas, before all the remasters.
For the final boss battle fight they tried a ‘stretched 3 sided pyramid’ shape which spun, for 2 reasons, one they needed them to hit each other without bending too much or breaking, and two, the shape and the spinning meant a more even fatter light along the entire blade from base to tip at any angle, due to how the light played along the sides as it span, even when it was not entirely centred in the shot, which was much needed for a fight scene with two blades at either side of the screen.
It also gave them a natural ‘fizz’ which, in combination with the later added colouring, that vibrates frame to frame due to being hand animated, then became the preferred look for the whole franchise, as it particularly suited the concept of a ‘laser sword’ by making it appear more volatile and ’alive’ than a still blade, and with the added sound effects it all finally came together.
As mentioned in post production they were added to with hand animated coloured glows drawn over the original practical blades by matching them to the rear lit reflective glows, but full screen flashes were added in too (matched with sound effects) each time they touched to give them a much needed sense of ’dangerous power’, and now of course with all the CGI replacements this gives a much more consistent look over all the movies, but originally how the blades first appeared pretty radically altered shot to shot as the effects team tried to pin down the best way to achieve the desired effect, and even now you can still tell that the first blade seen is distinctly flatter than all the rest of the shots.
Thank you for coming to my TED talk.
The Gonk droid isn't the only one that experiences pain. Throughout the Empire Strikes Back, C3PO feels pain and fear. In the prequels, all the separatist droids felt pain and fear also.
In Empire Han never had a jacket on in the freezing chamber. The close ups have his shirt in shadow making it look much darker. My friend and I analyzed this over and over back in the 90s. I haven’t compared the remastered version, but if it was digitally lightened up it was to avoid confusion that people thought he was wearing a jacket.
Why does no one acknowledge Han's disappearing handcuffs as he's frozen in carbonite?
If your truly out of ideas, then I'll add the vader scene where he stops talking, but the actor is clearly talking.
3:18 Not only that but at some point after operating on Anakin, giving him the ability to breathe and walk and use his arms.... OK... At some point after that but some point before restraining him to the table, someone has gone "WAIT.... He needs a cape.... make sure it's black and almost touches the floor".
When Han is lowered into the Carbonite freezer, his hands are cross-bound at the wrist in front. When the slab is pulled out, they are untied and held wide apart.
One of the most glaring inconsistencies in Empire was the statement Luke made about the Imperial walker's armor being too much for their blaster, go for legs and the tow cables, then upon the walker falling down, one of their ships swoops in and blast it causing a massive explosion.
During the Bespin when Luke hits Vader and sparks fly from his shoulders, if you slow it down you see he hit him straight in the neck.
A few seconds later when Vader cuts down those antennas they clearly used a shorter stick for the lightsaber blade to "go through" the antenass, but th4 VFX crew only rotoscoped the short stick and didn't extend it so that it appears that the saber reaches the antennas.
It does matter if it’s sequels
2:15
😊
THAT'S ME!!!
YES 🥰, I'm in a WhatCulture video, awesome
at 17:37 the second lightsaber on Darth Vader's belt was explained in the book as Luke's lightsaber...While hiding from Vader, Luke rolled his saber out on the floor before saying "I will not fight your" and Vader picked it up and after the sister comment, Luke used the force to grab his lightsaber before attacking Vader
at 7:00, that scene only had a tauntaun arm striking Luke
Switching lightsabers i did see and i could never figure out how it happened at first
5:02 You can literally see the dirt falling from her clothes as she gets up. Yes, it was a mistake, but one they had already spotted, and tried to fix "in movie".
I noticed the switched lightsabers goof in the trailer for Episode III but I thought “That’s just a bad edit in the trailer. There’s no way it’ll be like that in the movie.” But then I sat there on opening day cursing under my breath.
I have to say my favorite duel is the Crouching Jedi, Hidden Yoda duel between Yoda and Count Dooku. For a near 900 year old being Yoda sure is a nimble bugger. Why did we change Narrators 21:00 minutes into the video?
There’s a visible mistake in your actual video at 27:30 ,
in the last shot of the walker you can see the stick coming up through the floor pushing the back leg that causes it to fall over 😉 Bill George told me that , and he was the one who pushed the stick!) 🙀
And the “I know” jacket was never there all shots were just the shirt, it’s been bebated since the 80s but debunked via many sources etc then as you say lightened for the recent versions
28:15
Did you ever think Leia was talking about her mother Organa? As in, not knowing she was adopted?
No because her and Luke were clearly talking about their birth parents
I always preferred to believe that, but then the Obi-Wan show tells us that Leia knew from a young age that she was adopted. 🤦🏻♂️
I wouldn't call Leia knowing her mother was a kind and caring woman a continuity error, as she's given to Bail Organa, someone who personally knew Padme and the kind of character she was, as shown in Kenobi little Leia ain't dumb she probably figured out she was at the very least adopted and asked about her parents, Anakin most likely left a sore spot with Bail on account of him murdering the Jedi and causing Padme's death so never spoke about him, whereas why wouldn't he talk about his friend to his friend's biological daughter?
It doesn't bother me.
The AT-AT's are not a mistake. The AT-ST's, just like real ground troops protecting armor, are there to protect the flanks. And yes I do know tanks have turrets but, yes, ground troops are deployed to protect armor. If there is a mistake, it was the Imp's in there arrogance, not deploying airpower.
um...Rey's fruit thingie remains the same...not bread...are you guys running out of ideas?
Biggest mistake is starting a star wars channel, running out of ideas so you just have to repeat the same things over and over and over!
Do you do anything other than post negative comments on these videos? There are better hobbies…
@@taylorbarker616Not a hobby when dealing with a monetised channel who are farming ad revenue from schmucks. It then becomes a duty to call out bad content.
@@13thcentury or get a fucking life?
@@13thcentury who’s the bigger schmuck, the schmuck who watches, or the schmuck who posts a comment that inherently boosts the video?
@@taylorbarker616 worst troll ever
Leia has the force. Her remembering Padmé really isn’t an issue. Even us regular humans remember the most unlikely stuff.
Leia has zero training in the force, and has shown zero abilities in the force (outside of fan fiction)
@@13thcentury
“You're wrong, Leia. You have that power too. In time you'll learn to
use it as I have. The Force is strong in my family. My father has
it...I have it...and...my sister has it.” -Luke
She was also able to hear Luke from Cloud City with no training.
I like a good nitpick, when it’s not mean spirited, and this video is certainly not being mean spirited. I don’t agree with this one though.
@Meushell She heard him, because he was literally projecting his thoughts to her.
ROTJ clearly implied she knew her mother.
ROTS is a retcon
@@13thcentury My opinion differs from yours.
@@Meushell I can't agree with you, or we'd both be wrong.
Why does he start to talk funny half way through the video? Ruins it completely..
Probably thought it is "exciting"
@@13thcentury It is really strange, and obviously done on purpose. So yeah, you might be right. 😁👍 ❤
Biggest mistake is the narrator's voice 😂😂😂 learn how to speak correct my dude. 😂😂😂
IS this HOW you TALK in EVERYDAY conversaTION LOLZ
Oh, THOSE mistakes.
I thought you were talking about remastering the original trilogy that ruined Star Wars, the entire prequel trilogy, and Bob Iger ruining The Last Jedi (2019).
In Empire Han never had a jacket on in the freezing chamber. The close ups have his shirt in shadow making it look much darker. My friend and I analyzed this over and over back in the 90s. I haven’t compared the remastered version, but if it was digitally lightened up it was to avoid confusion that people thought he was wearing a jacket.