Impact Of FCRA On Those Helping Poor : Kapil Sibal, Harsh Mander, Colin Gonsalves | Discussion
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 бер 2024
- #livelaw #kapilsibal #supremecourtofindia #law #legal #lawstudents #lawyer
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
This video is an intellectual property belonging to LiveLaw Media Pvt Ltd. Any unauthorised usage of this video/script in any format is prohibited and will be subject to prosecution.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
A very good discussion was held taking the issue of restrictions imposed by the current regime on NGOs and consequences thereof on the life of marginalized sections of Indian society👍
As a couple, my partner and I were donating money to one global NGO called World Vision which carried out some charity work in India. We were sponsoring education of a girl child called Laxmi from Rajasthan for good 4 years. Then one day all of a sudden we got assigned another child in Africa. Over the years we had developed a bond with the child in India. Although we had not met her in person, we saw it as way of giving back to our country. Upon investigation we were told that some FCRA rules were changed and it was becoming difficut to get money into India. We were very disappointed. I can only imagine how disappointing it must have been for Laxmi and her family. She had access to good education and probably nutritious meal but her chance at all of this was taken away by this government. Although our dontation is still going to a girl child, and she too is a sweet kid but the government should not engage into all this red tape. I am very dissapointed the Supreme courts have held up the governments point of view. And if they permit political dontations by foriegn organizations then they should permit donations in this case too.
Why don't you give the same money to Laxmi in your city , why go all the way to Africa , Europe or Usa to reach someone in Rajasthan,if you are living in India 😂
@@magusnmuse - such a stupid response !!
@@sekharkc1 what about Laxmi in Rajasthan? Chandru ? Why call her stupid
These are true heroes of our country but nation celebrates Virat, Dhoni, and other Bollywood actors who are just money minded and this clearly shows our minset that we r sick people
A small ngo in the northeast receiving not even 3k a month and serving very poor segment of society in the northeast lost its fcra license arbitrarily without information and poor family lost their children’s education because of the same! Thank you for the discussion!
Very nice and meaningful discussion.
Irony is that an obscene reel or video gets lakhs of views but few can dare to listen to these learned man.. Hats off to these learned men... Aur desh ka to bhagwan hi malik h
Very interesting talk by Colin Gonsalves and the answers put up by the questions by Kapil Sibal.
Very nice useful discussion...
Very pertinent issues… thanks for speaking for us the NGOs
Great discussion on a topic not many speak on. Thank you for shedsing light on this issue where Ngos are being targeted
Very meaningfull
Too good
Legal help needed in Jaipur do anyone advocate exist in Jaipur to help helpless
Modi has replaced the NGOs by distributing 5kgs of free fortified plastic grain per month .
Yes, chronic use of medicine can be toxic
In conclusion, money flowing into these people's pockets have stopped. if all the money goes to the poor and are well tabulated, there won't be any problems ....
Helping the poor and educating them to bring awareness of their rights is a fundamental rights of the citizens and these honest NGOs are doing great work which is being curtailed for no reason by the present central leadership which means they don't want the poor to become rich and wise since they will question the Government . This is the most serious issue challenging the country.
All the honest citizens of the country irrespective of their religion caste and creed and status should come together to protest against this kind of injustice happening in the country
@@manoharb3238 we do it , we regularly contribute to Tribal Girl education in our family in our state Karnataka, we also avail tax break from it , it's a win-win , it's a Indian NGO, started , financed and run by Indians , legitimate & legal ! Trust me right thinking citizens are no longer funding Kapil Sibal /Harsh mander... So this lofty Bhajan from Zero Loss Theory Sibal
@@manoharb3238 they are involved in conversions and political funding in disguise of charity…if it has been pure helping poor..they would not have been crying here..logics
I am truly dismayed and dejected by the tone and tenor of this very thoughtfully conceptualized discussion. The mood seemed so sombre, serious and sulky. The long faces and the words were depressing to hear. Why is the speakers feeling so dejected.
Have we reached a nadir? If senior Advocate's of our Supreme Court sees the strangulation of funds to our NGOs in such a bleak manner, it means the FCR Act and the rulings have a created a regime where NGOs are feeling restricted and even throttled.
How then is our Right to serve our fellow human beings or our wildlife ensured by the Parliament or the Judiciary, if the Executive will use the Machivelian technique to subdue free movement of idea's and service's to the larger society.
Are we then moving towards a totalitarian state? Or are we already reached that point? I shiver to ask this questions.
NGOs also act as a tool of political interference. Govt. should not allow subversion of the political system at the hands of foreign powers.
Helping the poor and the downtrodden doesn't amt to interference in the govt functioning
@@manoharb3238 they are involved in conversions and political funding in disguise of charity…if it has been pure helping poor..they would not have been crying here..logics
Our history is full of Amichands Jaichands.
First the Courts must ensure they implement RTI… and declare their own assets we will distribute the illegal/ undeclared money to the 5% minorities you are referring too
You dont need to go far to service the poor Sibal sahab charity should begin at home
Ya.ya.mere.pitaji.no.one.strang.
Systemic change would mean there wouldn't be people dependent on the charity of people unfairly more privileged than them. Sad that all these accomplished people sitting together won't talk about it, won't work for it, won't find the provisions in the law that ensures social justice
I had four maids from Jharkhand and Chattisgarh, all Christians
What was percentage of Christians 8-10 decades back in Manipur and now
Ya.ya.
Can this effort influence 5% population? Sir, please draw a method that can reach the common man. Herd mentality is still dominant in India. Or pray the Judiciary 'don't ignore the tears' of the poor and marginalised.
At one point of time RSS frontal organisations like VHP were biggest recipients of the foreign funding. This government very well knew that the money could be used against them as well and they are scared!
So you think they are crying for their own pocket?
@@ShaktiMan-dv3jd no they want to deny to their opponents
They have not submitted the purpose and for which funds are spent
WHAT IS RELIGION TO A HUNGRY CHILD?
East India company was NGO-rightly pointed out
Kapil sibal, s theatrics reminds me drama "Yes, Prime Minister "of yesteryears.
His leading querries results in liberal critism of Modiji government, let him compare with Congress days
A failed state in Pakistan the HC as well SC orders has great integrity and respect but in India nobody doing so especially states and central government responds is pathetic .
Acha y dont u go there then
400 paar
NGOs end up in conversion
Kapil, Fight free cases for poors
He will indeed fight for bangladeshis …
Mr Sibal , I don't agree with you on most things ...But i like this initiative of yours ... I hope you bring all kinds of diverse voices for the discussion ...It should not be a one sided discussion where everyone agrees with your view point ....
All hardcore Anti Establishment ,anti Govt & hard core communists & supporters of religious conversions
How many of you fight cases for marginalised people?
All of them.
@@jhakku1401 none…Kapil Sibal charges fees in crores, Motilal Nehru too charged high fees in his days…which Indian poor can afford it?
Kapil sibal ,sunlow 0 is not zero
Very good decision by the government
Foreign countries will not fund without their wasted interest. Common sense. Jewish Adage--There are no free meals in the world.
they are involved in conversions and political funding in disguise of charity…if it has been pure helping poor..they would not have been crying here..logics
Halping poor ??;give away your 50 cent property to poor people.
The funds are being misused for conversions. Can this be controlled?
Any proof?? Please bring out.
@@Jrjen369 Kapil Sibal charges fees in crores, Motilal Nehru too charged high fees in his days…which Indian poor can afford it?
@@Jrjen369there were several videos and the perpetrators were deported in assam … perhaps your news coverage doesnt cover NE states hence u missed such cases repeatedly happening
'Abki Baar, 400 Paar
What donation are given by these four people at personal level?
Jai Modi
Your commitment towards selfish goals whilst projecting selfless charity as your life purpose, is hypocrisy of astounding proportions. Kudos to your persistence and preserverance towards selfish goals man. Keep it up.
They expose themselves….. when they share the frame with the man who claimed Rama was a fictional character, Article 370 is illegal
Money is the bait to get somebody converted
Is _6000 crores a big money? Why not generate in India
Great suggestion.... So why not give the ideas to generate money in India as per ur suggestions!!!!
So many kaminas in one frame😂