Indian soldiers are incredible in their handling of this.. resolute.. firm.. yet calm. China is clearly trying to test our resolve to uphold our sovereignty. They'll realize soon that all Indians would fully support whatever action our Army takes. Eid Mubarak to all
Nitin, if you link this with statements coming out of Nepal, you realise that it is a larger game plan. Probable reasons could be India's growing proximity with USA and now the probability of reducing trade with China under pressure from USA. Add to this the reports that western companies trying to exit China may set base in India. China may not want India to encourage that. Hence the indirect pressure to behave.
Precisely. I doubt China intends to do anything that can be considered major. This is a case example of a warning. They have also done this several times with Taiwan and Vietnam among others, at great expense to diplomatic power.
Thanks for your views Sir. Whenever I need some honest & unbiased views on India's military and strategic engagements.. I always look for Nitin Gokhale's twitter account. A youtube channel makes it more helpful to understand your view points.
Nitinji, appreciate you work. Pls give us actual insights of various border treaties India had with China pre and post independence and its relevance in ongoing border disputes between two countries. I know it would be lengthy topic to discuss but will help to understand facts and reasons behind these tussles.
@stratnewsglobal: Yes. It was difficult to make out the map. I understand it was to show the topographical difficulties but we can't understand the where exactly these places you mention lie spatially
Which is the software used for showing the topography? Is it Google Earth or something else? And Thank you for the excellent analysis sir of where the standoff has happened.
@@swapnilkapadia Doesn't look like it.... I use Google Earth through mobile and it doesn't look like this at all...is it the desktop variant of Google Earth?
Thank you very much. StratNewsGlobal is the place to be to look out for authentic information or news with regards to strategy, international affairs, defence etc. Please keep posting great contents...
Great Video....Keep It Up. Even Defence Ministry Follow You On Twitter. So, There's No Doubt About It On Your Analysis. & Tagged Them In. your Suggestions About Security & Defence. They'll Listen You Or Atleast Approach You. Thank You Nitin Sirji For Amazing Information & For Visualization. & I Want To Tell The Folks Here You Should Follow Him on Twitter & Read His Past Thread & Specially On This Issue. He Explained It In A Very Good Manner. Next Topic You Should Cover : China Will Impose National Security Law In Hongkong. So, What's The Options Left For Hongkong To Get Rid From This Moron CCP.
While China is open about the taking anti India stance at international forums e.g. the issue of Masood Azhar why is it that we are not able to do a tit for tat. I understand China is a global power much larger our size in economy as well as military power. If a small country like Taiwan can stand against China then what factors stop us from talking openly about issues that bother China e.g. Hongkong protests, supporting Taiwan and Tibet, no free press being available. The same is the case with Turkey, why can't we talk about Kurdish issues which bother them and ensure these countries are kept at bay and they think twice before taking anti India stance at various forums with the fear that India will bring out topics which will bother them.
Nitinji, a very informative and in a very nutshell discussion on a very complicated boundary dispute between India and imperial China. China did not believe in 'Macmohan line boundary'. But they agreed the same Macmohan Line in case of boundary with Burma. In fact India had no boundary with China. China is an aggressive nation, a Imperialist nation, gobled up Tibet which was a soverign country. India should recognise exile Tibet government as a separate soverign Nation government. And discurd one china policy.
Please enlighten about Henderson Brooke's report on 1962 war which was kept under wraps for 50 years and a book on this war by Australian journalist Neville Maxwell.
It was fabulous sir ! Thank you so much. One request though, could you please get some expert to talk about why this is happening frequently, discuss thought process in military about this, possible solutions so as to get some more knowledge. People are really unaware about this issue. Thanks again!
I think some topics to be discussed are --- (1) India Nepal issue (2) Indian forces defence budget rationalisation due to the pandemic and how it affects armed forces warfighting capabilities. (3) Performance of the current CDS and his disagreement with (1) AIR FORCE over (a)handing over Apaches to army, (b) number of MMRCA to be bought, to be bought in staggered manner or to buy in a single order. (2) With navy over buying INS VISHAL or not.
The discord between the two Nations was well summarised and narrated. China happens to be our arch rival and constantly creating nuisance. It has to be dealt with fiercely and to be annihilated so as to the Stone age shattering its dream to become the world's super power. This is the oppurtune moment to real it a lethal blow and once India starts retaliates there are other adversaries of China waiting to pounce on it in the South China Sea with the help of America.
Sadly, any country exiting China can not come to India due to lack of Infrastructure and due recent India move to scrap labour laws will make it illegal to invest in India by ILO.
What happens if shots are fired? Will this develop into a serious conflict? Which countries will support india under these circumstances? Please cover this scenario in your next program.
China seems to be not interested in correcting the lac border perception. They are more interested to claim Arunachal as Sth Tibet. If China not interested to resolve the perception difference, then we go by our perception, as simple as that
What happened to SNI ? It was a good platform. We were regular watchers. I think you have to diversify your subjects. Not many people are interested in strategic issues only. More will watch if you diversify your subject.
Allow indian army also to deliberately enter into areas clearly inside Chinese territory occasionally.... This is the best way to ward off future transgressions.... The best way to handle a bully is to let it taste it's own medicine....
Why doesn't India build a fence on their border, China is only creating trouble in settled areas to move the goalposts and when it settled it feels like a victory to india, but china then takes advantage and pushes their luck and takes some land from the genuinely contested areas.
Respected Nithin A. Gokhale Sir , We Want Comprehensive Analysis Of Indo - China Relationship In Following Manner In Upcoming Shows May Be In The Form Of Series Because Their Are No Comprehensive & Serious Intellectual Debates Happened In India Viz-a-Viz China Unlike In Pakistan's Case :- 1. From 1914 Simala Trilateral Agreement Between Britsh India , Tibet & China To 1962 War . 2. From 1961 To 1976 In Which Diplomatic Relations Between India & China Were Cut Offed & Emphasis On China Becoming A Nuclear State In 1964 After Nehru's Death & Leading To 1974 Pokhran-1 . 3. From 1976 To 1993 Including Mr Rajiv Gandhi's Visit To China In 1988 . 4. From Border Peace & Tranquility Agreement In 1993 To 2020 Which Has Been Able To Manage The Border & Not Resolved The Border . 5. Is Their Any New Mechanism Or Modest Vivindi Going To Takes Place To Finally Resolve The Border In Short To Medium Term Because Management Of Border Has Reached Its Zenith Through Peace & Tranquility Agreement , CBM's & SR Process .
My dear India brother! May the rood Lord bless you and keep u and your family and give you many, many years of life, health and wisdom: My question is this. I believe that you will agree with the fact that Israel-India relation have gone through distinct periods. • the Pre Kargil-War, • the Kargil-war and Specifically Israel initiating a massive transfer of precision bombing laser guided bombs and bomb conversion kits and other precision munitions which the Hindu and Seekh warriors used to beat back the terrorist.* * Israel ignored the threats of glacial b launched against it by every so called Israel to abandon India. And under some heavyweight pressure форугвnot sent Aid, you believe that ‘99 Brie with the US Nrith
Sir Please make a video on the possible international Picture of INDIA and CHINA, if at all a full scale war broke out. How the world countries possibly react and how equations change post war. Many predict that China will be split into different countries at sometime in the future, is it a possible post war scenario. How much can INDIA actually trust US ? Will US remain a mediator if war happen. Lots of doubts .... Did AUSTRALIA gained INDIA's confidence in shortest span of events????
Similar to China, why don't India enter their territory and say it's ours. Why this defensive? I mean why ? Are they on our side of the territory or on their side right now?
It was in very lucid language to understand the issue. Can you please make video on why India does not take hard action on terror launch pads accross LOC like using bhramos and other cruise missile or else launching airstrikes like Israel does, why not neutralise them before they cross border.
What is the use of using dolam when none other than China calls it that and audience include everyone except Chinese. If you wanted to highlight you could have introduced as doklam also known in China as dolam, not the other way around. Seems you are also getting paid by china
Will the current China Policy of the Americans change course in case Donald Trump is not elected for a 2nd Term.
4 роки тому
this is about India behavior - go and ask USA to help you - now. this is the message that china wants to send you. do more taiwan, investigate covid-19. hong kong blah blah blah China is not going back now.
4 роки тому
@keshavan veera ragava yes ask for USA arms - increase the defense budget 3 fold to blance the power of China.
@ This is your perception , Can you prove what is wrong with PM Care fund ? When public money was looted openly in numerous scam during UPA scam , where were you ? Nehru Gandhi family made fool of India . Today Raibarelly , Amethi falls under most backward district of UP . During congress regime corruption was rampant . Even sonia & rahul are on bail in national trust scam. By criticizing Modi , you think you are a straightforward person. In fact you are Modi hater . Here in this channel issue is Indian China conflict but here also you seems to enjoying & siding with pakistani who are spreading false news of India weakness . You are not deshbhakt , but a tout with fake id.
Indian soldiers are incredible in their handling of this.. resolute.. firm.. yet calm. China is clearly trying to test our resolve to uphold our sovereignty. They'll realize soon that all Indians would fully support whatever action our Army takes. Eid Mubarak to all
اللہ کرے آپکے فوجیوں کا یہ ردعمل کشمیر کے مسلمانوں کے ساتھ بھی ہو وہاں تو وحشی جانور بنے ہؤئے ہیں
Eid Mubharak Bro. JAI HIND
Waqas Khan
Well said!
Nitin, if you link this with statements coming out of Nepal, you realise that it is a larger game plan. Probable reasons could be India's growing proximity with USA and now the probability of reducing trade with China under pressure from USA. Add to this the reports that western companies trying to exit China may set base in India. China may not want India to encourage that. Hence the indirect pressure to behave.
Precisely. I doubt China intends to do anything that can be considered major. This is a case example of a warning. They have also done this several times with Taiwan and Vietnam among others, at great expense to diplomatic power.
LAC - is something like cease fire line...
As aksai chin itself is indian land under chinese occupation since 1962..
Thanks for your views Sir. Whenever I need some honest & unbiased views on India's military and strategic engagements.. I always look for Nitin Gokhale's twitter account. A youtube channel makes it more helpful to understand your view points.
FYI: Google Maps has the Galwan River listed as the Gallowan River... And Google Maps has the DSDBO Road listed as the SSN Road.
This channel deserves more attention. An excellent explanation of the current situation at the LAC
nice summary of the situation. 12 minutes well spent.
That's how you present facts.....zero sensationalism, pure professionalism 👍
Next Simply Nitin : Nepal border issue
Nitinji, appreciate you work. Pls give us actual insights of various border treaties India had with China pre and post independence and its relevance in ongoing border disputes between two countries. I know it would be lengthy topic to discuss but will help to understand facts and reasons behind these tussles.
One Suggestion... Pls do not keep map in Satellite mode, it's hard to look at & understand.
@stratnewsglobal: Yes. It was difficult to make out the map. I understand it was to show the topographical difficulties but we can't understand the where exactly these places you mention lie spatially
Thanks Nitin for very simply and nicely narrating the on-going as well as perennial issues between India and China. Please keep feeding.
Which is the software used for showing the topography?
Is it Google Earth or something else?
And Thank you for the excellent analysis sir of where the standoff has happened.
google earth
@@swapnilkapadia Doesn't look like it.... I use Google Earth through mobile and it doesn't look like this at all...is it the desktop variant of Google Earth?
@Altruistic's Unknown Facts Thanks
Sir please do a video on recent thread on satellite images of 80 tents....
How about compulsory military training of school pass outs and two years of service along loc
sir , want to know about india China land dispute in Uttarakhand.
Nitin, Can you please shed some light on what is happening ant Depsang?
Nitin Ji request you to invite Tibetan speakers/historians who can provide more inputs on the boundary issue
Thank you.
Thank you very much. StratNewsGlobal is the place to be to look out for authentic information or news with regards to strategy, international affairs, defence etc. Please keep posting great contents...
Excellent analysis......!
Great Video....Keep It Up. Even Defence Ministry Follow You On Twitter. So, There's No Doubt About It On Your Analysis. & Tagged Them In. your Suggestions About Security & Defence. They'll Listen You Or Atleast Approach You. Thank You Nitin Sirji For Amazing Information & For Visualization. & I Want To Tell The Folks Here You Should Follow Him on Twitter & Read His Past Thread & Specially On This Issue. He Explained It In A Very Good Manner.
Next Topic You Should Cover : China Will Impose National Security Law In Hongkong. So, What's The Options Left For Hongkong To Get Rid From This Moron CCP.
While China is open about the taking anti India stance at international forums e.g. the issue of Masood Azhar why is it that we are not able to do a tit for tat. I understand China is a global power much larger our size in economy as well as military power. If a small country like Taiwan can stand against China then what factors stop us from talking openly about issues that bother China e.g. Hongkong protests, supporting Taiwan and Tibet, no free press being available. The same is the case with Turkey, why can't we talk about Kurdish issues which bother them and ensure these countries are kept at bay and they think twice before taking anti India stance at various forums with the fear that India will bring out topics which will bother them.
Nitinji, a very informative and in a very nutshell discussion on a very complicated boundary dispute between India and imperial China. China did not believe in 'Macmohan line boundary'. But they agreed the same Macmohan Line in case of boundary with Burma. In fact India had no boundary with China. China is an aggressive nation, a Imperialist nation, gobled up Tibet which was a soverign country. India should recognise exile Tibet government as a separate soverign Nation government. And discurd one china policy.
Please talk about minesar in tibet, which was a part of India.
Fan of Nitin Gokhale sir's analysis.
Video on Aksai Chin please and possibilities of India reclaiming the territory.
Kindly show/talk about inhabited and uninhabited area in these disputed regions. Thanks
Great video. Just discovered this channel loved your explanation.
Please enlighten about Henderson Brooke's report on 1962 war which was kept under wraps for 50 years and a book on this war by Australian journalist Neville Maxwell.
Please give a talk about Nepal India dispute regarding the border
Please make video on india Nepal border issue
Nepal is irrelevant, RAW start lobbying for Communist OLI government departure btw Nepal is integral part of India.
Thank you
Very neat explanation. Short videos 10m and less are always welcome. 👍
It was fabulous sir ! Thank you so much. One request though, could you please get some expert to talk about why this is happening frequently, discuss thought process in military about this, possible solutions so as to get some more knowledge. People are really unaware about this issue. Thanks again!
Excellent.
Can tibet be a integral part of India in near future?
And what is the strategic view of tibet in policy makers minds.
Thanks sir
Hello Nitin sir..
Do a program on daily basis...for defence and strategic matters.
I think some topics to be discussed are ---
(1) India Nepal issue
(2) Indian forces defence budget rationalisation due to the pandemic and how it affects armed forces warfighting capabilities.
(3) Performance of the current CDS and his disagreement with
(1) AIR FORCE over (a)handing over Apaches to army, (b) number of MMRCA to be bought, to be bought in staggered manner or to buy in a single order.
(2) With navy over buying INS VISHAL or not.
Thank you for the video sir. Its very informative
Thank you Nitin Sir🙂
Well explained...
Why u don't Mention that India defeated China in 1967 at Sikkim ??
The discord between the two Nations was well summarised and narrated. China happens to be our arch rival and constantly creating nuisance. It has to be dealt with fiercely and to be annihilated so as to the Stone age shattering its dream to become the world's super power. This is the oppurtune moment to real it a lethal blow and once India starts retaliates there are other adversaries of China waiting to pounce on it in the South China Sea with the help of America.
A very good explanation
Sadly, any country exiting China can not come to India due to lack of Infrastructure and due recent India move to scrap labour laws will make it illegal to invest in India by ILO.
What happens if shots are fired? Will this develop into a serious conflict? Which countries will support india under these circumstances? Please cover this scenario in your next program.
Solution: Send in the army of tourists. They want the land not the people.
China seems to be not interested in correcting the lac border perception. They are more interested to claim Arunachal as Sth Tibet. If China not interested to resolve the perception difference, then we go by our perception, as simple as that
solution give tibet as a gift to the world as a spiritual santuary .China cannot argue against God they would look silly , God is bigger than china .
What happened to SNI ? It was a good platform. We were regular watchers. I think you have to diversify your subjects. Not many people are interested in strategic issues only. More will watch if you diversify your subject.
Allow indian army also to deliberately enter into areas clearly inside Chinese territory occasionally.... This is the best way to ward off future transgressions.... The best way to handle a bully is to let it taste it's own medicine....
India should abrogate the treaties with china and support the independence of Tibet...
Sir I recently read your book on 1965 war
Why doesn't India build a fence on their border, China is only creating trouble in settled areas to move the goalposts and when it settled it feels like a victory to india, but china then takes advantage and pushes their luck and takes some land from the genuinely contested areas.
Non Alignment!
Where Does It Get Now ?
Speak about That , What's Ur Thought Process In This Regard'g !
Good reporting
Can you please verify report of economic times "massive buildup"(bunker) At galwan region in finger area(bet finger 3&4)
Ref: manu pubby tweet/report
Great
Good very enriching vdo
Respected Nithin A. Gokhale Sir ,
We Want Comprehensive Analysis Of Indo - China Relationship In Following Manner In Upcoming Shows May Be In The Form Of Series Because Their Are No Comprehensive & Serious Intellectual Debates Happened In India Viz-a-Viz China Unlike In Pakistan's Case :-
1. From 1914 Simala Trilateral Agreement Between Britsh India , Tibet & China To 1962 War .
2. From 1961 To 1976 In Which Diplomatic Relations Between India & China Were Cut Offed & Emphasis On China Becoming A Nuclear State In 1964 After Nehru's Death & Leading To 1974 Pokhran-1 .
3. From 1976 To 1993 Including Mr Rajiv Gandhi's Visit To China In 1988 .
4. From Border Peace & Tranquility Agreement In 1993 To 2020 Which Has Been Able To Manage The Border & Not Resolved The Border .
5. Is Their Any New Mechanism Or Modest Vivindi Going To Takes Place To Finally Resolve The Border In Short To Medium Term Because Management Of Border Has Reached Its Zenith Through Peace & Tranquility Agreement , CBM's & SR Process .
Tibet was an independent country China grabbed it. So was the case of Sikkim, India grabbed it. Both are big fish.
Salami slicing...
Now or never...
If They want to show their strength to world they should have gone to Philippines or Malaysia not India....MESS WITH THE WRONG GUY....
My dear India brother! May the rood Lord bless you and keep u and your family and give you many, many years of life, health and wisdom:
My question is this. I believe that you will agree with the fact that Israel-India relation have gone through distinct periods.
• the Pre Kargil-War,
• the Kargil-war and Specifically Israel initiating a massive transfer of precision bombing laser guided bombs and bomb conversion kits and other precision munitions which the Hindu and Seekh warriors used to beat back the terrorist.*
* Israel ignored the threats of glacial b launched against it by every so called Israel to abandon India.
And under some heavyweight pressure форугвnot sent Aid, you believe that ‘99 Brie with the US Nrith
Sir Please make a video on the possible international Picture of INDIA and CHINA, if at all a full scale war broke out.
How the world countries possibly react and how equations change post war.
Many predict that China will be split into different countries at sometime in the future, is it a possible post war scenario.
How much can INDIA actually trust US ? Will US remain a mediator if war happen.
Lots of doubts ....
Did AUSTRALIA gained INDIA's confidence in shortest span of events????
Similar to China, why don't India enter their territory and say it's ours. Why this defensive? I mean why ?
Are they on our side of the territory or on their side right now?
It was in very lucid language to understand the issue. Can you please make video on why India does not take hard action on terror launch pads accross LOC like using bhramos and other cruise missile or else launching airstrikes like Israel does, why not neutralise them before they cross border.
Can you talk about Turkey's engagement with ISIS?
What is the use of using dolam when none other than China calls it that and audience include everyone except Chinese.
If you wanted to highlight you could have introduced as doklam also known in China as dolam, not the other way around.
Seems you are also getting paid by china
Please make video on chinese choke points,where India can choke china in this game.
Will the current China Policy of the Americans change course in case Donald Trump is not elected for a 2nd Term.
this is about India behavior - go and ask USA to help you - now. this is the message that china wants to send you.
do more taiwan, investigate covid-19. hong kong blah blah blah
China is not going back now.
@keshavan veera ragava yes ask for USA arms - increase the defense budget 3 fold to blance the power of China.
@ to kick at back of paid anti Indian agents - like you.
@ This is your perception , Can you prove what is wrong with PM Care fund ?
When public money was looted openly in numerous scam during UPA scam , where were you ? Nehru Gandhi family made fool of India . Today Raibarelly , Amethi falls under most backward district of UP . During congress regime corruption was rampant . Even sonia & rahul are on bail in national trust scam. By criticizing Modi , you think you are a straightforward person.
In fact you are Modi hater . Here in this channel issue is Indian China conflict but here also you seems to enjoying & siding with pakistani who are spreading false news of India weakness . You are not deshbhakt , but a tout with fake id.