@@Shiltz Singing (in my opinion) is like a sport. There’s never been a top level athlete ever who’s always been 100% and there’s never been a top level singer who’s always been at 100%. The fact that we expect singers to sing exactly the same at 50 as when they were 20 is insane. Do we expect Shaq to throw down on the court again to prove himself?
Selena Quintanilla Perez never had an off day with her singing and even on her quote on quote off days. She still brought it! For example there was one time Selena had a really bad cold and a terrible Sore Throat and she felt like extreme 💩 and her father coaxed her into the Studio and she sang her song Siempre Hace Frio and she totally nailed it! It was beyond incredible! Selena has and always will be the greatest female singer and biggest female legend of all time! There will never be another like her ever again!
I can't believe Ariana was sliding flat on that sus note but still managed to belt a perfect G5 at the end 👏🏽 to be fair, in that era, Scooter was making Ariana perform EVERYWHERE. Also she killed those falsetto notes too
The Ariana clip is when she used to do show after show after show. Just press 24/7. And she said that doing that made her tired all the time so she just drops album’s whenever now.
i noticed sometimes the "easier" song is to sing, the tougher it is to sing, plus your diet is crucial, plus not every song is for everybody, are you tired, stressed out, in pain, so many things have to align for somebody to sound their best live, i wish more people understood this
Most of time its because of technical problems though, I believe when you sing exclusively your own songs several times per month it gets really hard to mess it up. Unless you have a really hard repertoire helped by professional recording programs to shape your voice like some talentless singers out there, you'll only mess it up when youre tired, sick or with technical problems.
Ariana uses a tonne of breathiness and she was doing below instead of above. That would be why she was flat the entire time. I do this ALL THE TIME without noticing
@@imjustsuperiorrr "I don't care if I song off key, I find myself in my melodies. I sing for love, I sing for me. I shout it out like a bird set free" - Sia
the way the video u used shows the artists when they were young and only started their carriers. i mean, it was ariana's first music carrier year and she probably was too excited. love u
I think it's kinda cute. We can see that stars can also be insecure, that they are human, not robots with tones of autotune or backing tracks to cover their mistakes. Definitely a great video for all amateur singers and professional beginner. You can make mistakes and still become a great, famous singer
i saw the Ariana performance live and it didn’t seem as bad live but trust she was defo tired she had a whole week of interviews in both uk and in europe previous to this not to mention she was sick aswell and literally left to the airport straight after his and still met us even tho she legit was tired af and about to miss her flight 🥺
Honestly... Did that many times with "adrenaline", "exhaustion" it's difficult in the moment to control a out of control energy. Excited about messages in passion...But like you calmly stated... They're "moments" okay, enough ".
There was a time when I was 12, when I know that I can resonance an G5, and then i became obsessed in hitting those note, and now I strained those note,because my voice got really tired, and now I only support D5s
Perfect evaluation of all performers. I would agree with you on every single one. Please can you do leona lewis new recent Christmas songs one more sleep cheers
She has shit days like everyone else. Mainly due to poor technique. That breathy shit gonna fry her vocals she won’t be singing the same 10 years from now.
She was tired from promoting. She said in an interview years later that during that album rollout, she broke down in tears in her garage because she was so tired from doing all that promoting. Her voice was a wreck
2:26 I partially agree, but I know for me (as a vocalist) once I lose my tonal center (which isn’t often) it’s really hard to get back on because I know I’m off but can’t find tonic.
@@jahnbritten8212 I have respect for her as a person but never for her music. It's more than enough to respect her as a human being more than a singer which she clearly isn't doing a good job.
I love what you do.... but can you do me a favour.... Can you do some songbirds from the 60s who are no longer with us.... I would like to hear you critique Kathy Kirby... the best British singer of all time....
The Ariana one wasn't that bad, other than the high notes... She sounded a little tired and went for a lower harmony, but it wasn't too bad. (The high part she lost it)
7:24 Camila's vocals were actually pretty good besides that. She was probably overwhelmed and nervous because she couldn't hear herself and didn't remember the right key so she just sang it in the wrong key.
Ariana's sounded like an autotune issue for me, especially on "everyDAY" the fact that she hit the note then instantly went flat, almost electronic-like
I like your reaction videos, but a few weeks ago you said you were stopping them as you'd fallen into the trap of so many other 'reactors'? Did you change your mind?
I am not stopping to vocal coach reactions, I am just adjusting what I react to. Rather than rushing to react to all the stuff that just gets views, I am trying to focus on Quality rather than quantity. Musical Theatre Monday, Tribute Tuesday / Compilations, Songs I love to sing Thursday, New Music Friday and Vlog or Cover sunday. I will still add WTF, and Vocal Battles in, plus general reactions from time to time. x
Jessie j it’s like she took something she shouldn’t have...katy couldn’t hear the backing... Ariana was kinda in the key but a bad vocal from her... xtina just tried a weird ad-lib... Gomez girl is just a terrible singer.
WAIT! the selena gomez I can explain! They took down the original version of that performance from copyright reasons and the person who uploaded the new version had to chage the pitch!
I started loving This Is How We Roll by 5H when Camila left and Ally took her part making that verse 10000 times better. Ally actually can reach those high notes so effortlessly.
@@michaelthoel6199 Nope, Ally is fun. The way that she dances, she paints a look upon your face! She must've come from the sun, you wanna take her through the park!
@@rydbthatsme I'm a big fan of Christina and she's amazing but the very high falsetto was flat, it happens. There is nothing wrong in admitting it. There was nothing to harmonize with.
K, so, many of these have nothing wrong with them. And I know this isn't Georgina's video, it's someone else's. The "yeaah, it's a party in the USA" lines from Jesse's performance, she was doing a different melody line. It was on key, it just wasn't the same melody line Miley does in the studio version and we're all so used to hearing. Why she decided to do that instead of the main line? Idk. Other parts in that same performance were definitely not excusable and just messy, but that, which is highlighted as a wtf moment is not a wtf moment. Katy's "losing the key" thingy. No. She did a different line. It's like every time a singer does something different from the studio version they're losing the key and they're now tone deaf. She did mess up the "change" run tho. That was just messy. She was never singing in a different key, though. Didn't hit the notes correctly, but never lost the key. Her aim was in the right place. Ariana was tired, yeah. Just tired. Again, though, never lost the key. Missed some of the notes, but was aiming to the right place. Also, maybe bored of the song? Xtina was waaay flat on the last note, everything else was good. Once again, Selena didn't lose the key. She was just off the notes, but she was aiming for the right places. She's just not good with technique and couldn't move around and hit the notes well. Also, what Georgina said about the sound. That's directly responsible for her not hitting the notes well too. You may be aiming for the right place but if you can't hear what you're doing, there's no way to know if you're actually getting there or not. Rihanna didn't mess anything up. I think it's more the quality of the video being shit and her stylistic choices being strange to say the least, rather than her *COMPLETELY LOSING THE KEY* as the video title suggests. Last one I love how she still remained on key, but was just out of time, and seeing their dynamic no stage, picking up her mic pack and how they hand it from one to the other till it reaches her, it's awesome.
5:53 selena gomez : there's no issue with her vocals actually, she can't sing. That's it. 90% autotune she is. Still can't sing. But i love her music anyways 😂
@@axelamarillas2402 What performances of hers are perfect and awesome? I have never seen one by her that is better than creeping into average. She seems like a super sweet person and I like her music a lot, but she is not a good singer. In most of her performances, she has heavy pitch correction, jumps from flat to sharp all the time, has a loud backing track, has her mic volume low, and so forth.
@Venusaur, She can sing. Here you go again! You feel the chemicals kicking in! It's getting heavy and you wanna run and hide! You wanna run and hide! *nostalgic music*
The Selena one was pitched down loads in her defence, I’m guessing to avoid copyright so the original audio wasn’t actually that bad. You can find the original on UA-cam :)
Some of Selena's vocals really make me cringe and I can't help it omg
4 роки тому+9
that was pitched down for copyright reasons. her voice in that performance was on key. in this video doesn't even sounds like it's her voice because of what i said above
@@chrisflan257 another hater goddamn people are really starting to make hating as a hobby good for you 👍🏻 I hope you come back to your senses if you have any ❤️
4 роки тому+2
@@chrisflan257 bro then check it out, i'm not unrealistic. that was a really good performance of 'same old love'.
Even the best singers have an off day. They'e only human after all.
Thx God they are not always perfect
It's great. I like seeing famous people slip up. Not because I think it's funny but because it reminds me that they are human!
@@Shiltz Singing (in my opinion) is like a sport. There’s never been a top level athlete ever who’s always been 100% and there’s never been a top level singer who’s always been at 100%. The fact that we expect singers to sing exactly the same at 50 as when they were 20 is insane. Do we expect Shaq to throw down on the court again to prove himself?
Selena Quintanilla Perez never had an off day with her singing and even on her quote on quote off days. She still brought it! For example there was one time Selena had a really bad cold and a terrible Sore Throat and she felt like extreme 💩 and her father coaxed her into the Studio and she sang her song Siempre Hace Frio and she totally nailed it! It was beyond incredible! Selena has and always will be the greatest female singer and biggest female legend of all time! There will never be another like her ever again!
She said it when she was surprised to see Katy in the video, it shows that even vocalists with INCREDIBLE voices like Katy can make mistakes.
Poor Ari. I can only imagine how she felt during that performance.
It happens to everybody DAHling.
We're humans.
She was completely over worked in 2014 :/
Really she hit highest note
@@Heroliesinyou I agree
@@Heroliesinyou Lol, read that comment in Mariah Carey's voice😂
I can't believe Ariana was sliding flat on that sus note but still managed to belt a perfect G5 at the end 👏🏽 to be fair, in that era, Scooter was making Ariana perform EVERYWHERE. Also she killed those falsetto notes too
The Ariana clip is when she used to do show after show after show. Just press 24/7. And she said that doing that made her tired all the time so she just drops album’s whenever now.
Hearing jessie singing like that is so weird cuz she is such a good vocalist
Maybe we are just uses to Miley's version, which is perfect in my opinion
you ever went to karaoke and tried to sing a song you know is not for you? 😂
Well we can let her off seeing as she wrote it 🤪 she is still the best.
Poor Ari, she sounded so tired
She was probably sick .
She sounded like that for most of 2014. she was probably so exhausted from so much promotion and press for her album that year
@@kanishkganti7643 She was def tired, she still sings good even when she's sick.
@@jonathan56150 yeah back in 2014 Ariana performed a hell a lot around the world
I think she was sick here. It’s okay we’re all human.
That Ariana performance was in the time when she used to be everywhere around the world and perform in every tv and award show possible 😆
Wow xtina using melisma and riffing even in that Falsetto
i noticed sometimes the "easier" song is to sing, the tougher it is to sing, plus your diet is crucial, plus not every song is for everybody, are you tired, stressed out, in pain, so many things have to align for somebody to sound their best live, i wish more people understood this
I LOVE KATY, THE VOICE CHANGE EVERY YEAR 😍😍😍
Truly…her voice have improved since her witness era
Christina did an amazing job
I like when singers have these moments they prove that they are really singing
I agree and i find it lovely, it proves that they don't want achieve perfection everytime, it's just simple
Most of time its because of technical problems though, I believe when you sing exclusively your own songs several times per month it gets really hard to mess it up. Unless you have a really hard repertoire helped by professional recording programs to shape your voice like some talentless singers out there, you'll only mess it up when youre tired, sick or with technical problems.
Ariana uses a tonne of breathiness and she was doing below instead of above. That would be why she was flat the entire time. I do this ALL THE TIME without noticing
Yes xtina 🔥
I'm guessing that because Jessie J wrote party in the USA that she probably had a different vision of how it would sound that stuck with her... Maybe.
that still doesnt mean she would sing off key lol 😭..
@@imjustsuperiorrr "I don't care if I song off key, I find myself in my melodies. I sing for love, I sing for me. I shout it out like a bird set free" - Sia
i LOVE YOUR ENERGY , sometimes i'm not even interested in the video you're reacting to but still watch it because of you
Love the blue, makes your eyes pop
You're handsome 👍
I’m glad you are not afraid saying what’s on your mind. Bravo coach keep it up. ❤️❤️❤️
the way the video u used shows the artists when they were young and only started their carriers. i mean, it was ariana's first music carrier year and she probably was too excited. love u
I think it's kinda cute. We can see that stars can also be insecure, that they are human, not robots with tones of autotune or backing tracks to cover their mistakes. Definitely a great video for all amateur singers and professional beginner. You can make mistakes and still become a great, famous singer
Rihanna you needed me wasn't the start of her career though she just lost the tune
Please don't ever stop making videos, they really make my day! Also I will be taking you up on your critiquing soon so thanks again!
i saw the Ariana performance live and it didn’t seem as bad live but trust she was defo tired she had a whole week of interviews in both uk and in europe previous to this not to mention she was sick aswell and literally left to the airport straight after his and still met us even tho she legit was tired af and about to miss her flight 🥺
I came here so early, there's no comments to read yet 😂 love the video, I do not sing but watching your videos is interesting
Honestly... Did that many times with "adrenaline", "exhaustion" it's difficult in the moment to control a out of control energy. Excited about messages in passion...But like you calmly stated... They're "moments" okay, enough ".
'OK... thanks Rihanna'
At least she tried 😂😂😭😭
There was a time when I was 12, when I know that I can resonance an G5, and then i became obsessed in hitting those note, and now I strained those note,because my voice got really tired, and now I only support D5s
Sounds like a party in the USA in 2020.
this comment 🤣🤣🤣
Queen Georgina 😍 Love how your shirt matches your eyes!!
ariana now has a better technique in her singing and that performance she was exhausted and over worked unfortunately ☹️
Yea and in that year most of her performances of that song was like that when she eventually figured out
but that perfect falsetto in the end tho>>>> She's honestly an amazing vocalist
@@lennoxbonnie5210 even the G5 was good in that sustained flat F5
@@lennoxbonnie5210 of course
i remember this era of ariana. most performances during this time were awful (compared to her own standards).
Omg! I woke up at 5 in the morning for this
Havent seen your videos for some time but this light improvement! You look amazing 😍
I love watching all of your videos. They are so good to watch. One of the best reaction people out there.
LOL YAAAS THE TOY STORY BARBIE REFERENCE AT THE END. I got you😂🥰
Ariana was tired in that clip,she was performing that song for like the 9689542th time in the same week
Great Video! And your outfit with your eyes 👌💙
when you’re THAT off it’s usually almost ALWAYS from monitoring or not being able to hear properly because if the audio system
Katy Perry wasn’t the worst and at least she noticed.
Looking fab . Loved this video xx
True christina was good❤️😍
Camilasaaaa🤩😍
QUEEN👑
Perfect evaluation of all performers. I would agree with you on every single one. Please can you do leona lewis new recent Christmas songs one more sleep cheers
Definitely nothing wrong with Christina in my opinion 🤷🏻♂️
Periodt!
The high notes were completely off key
She be screaming 🤣
@@superMacaulay1 those high notes are not even in the original song 🙄, so technically she was not off key.
she sang the high notes in a different key. She's supposed to hit a G6 there but she did a F#6.
Early all the way from Australia, even though I'm supposed to be asleep 😂 love you Honest Vocal Queen
Ariana seems to be sick . Or I don't know then .
She has shit days like everyone else. Mainly due to poor technique. That breathy shit gonna fry her vocals she won’t be singing the same 10 years from now.
She was tired from promoting. She said in an interview years later that during that album rollout, she broke down in tears in her garage because she was so tired from doing all that promoting. Her voice was a wreck
@@rydbthatsme shut up. she was singing break free for the millionth time that week in 2014! Her technique is great
@@rydbthatsme Ariana’s been singing since she was little but she’s just gotten better through the years
She was so tired that year because scooter kept forcing her to perform and promote the album
Love u soo much 💞
The "Same Old Love" is pitched. If u pitch the audio high In edition, u can hear that Selena Is doing OK.
Her face and words throughout the first one 🤣🤣😂🤣😅😂
I love your videos 😃👏👏
2:26 I partially agree, but I know for me (as a vocalist) once I lose my tonal center (which isn’t often) it’s really hard to get back on because I know I’m off but can’t find tonic.
I like Selena as a person and an actress but God do I have zero respect for her in singing.
@@jamieslauren Rare album is boring tbh
Didn’t ask
Well I love her and you should have respect for her as a singer because she has lupus.
@@jahnbritten8212 I have respect for her as a person but never for her music. It's more than enough to respect her as a human being more than a singer which she clearly isn't doing a good job.
@@johnalfiel.limpio675 Tasteless
You could make a whole netflix series out of JLO out of key notes
with 10 seasons and spin offs
not this comment omg im dead
@@karenwalker8682 hahahahha and even throw a memoir on it
I liked it cause I can't haha it or heart it lmao
We don't know her though.
😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹
Do the ear monitors allow them to hear themselves or just the music?
I like this concept !
Camilaaaaaaa 😍😍😍😍
Katy Perry seems to have been having a 'moment' from 2005 to 2020
You’re so uninformed, she’s a far better vocalist than most of her pop peers...
Love u Georgina
Christina Ate that, she always has haters💯
Big facts👏🏼
Katy did great
I love what you do.... but can you do me a favour.... Can you do some songbirds from the 60s who are no longer with us.... I would like to hear you critique Kathy Kirby... the best British singer of all time....
Epic video and great thumbnail
The Ariana one wasn't that bad, other than the high notes... She sounded a little tired and went for a lower harmony, but it wasn't too bad. (The high part she lost it)
Why the video of Selena is edites? The real one sounds so different
7:24 Camila's vocals were actually pretty good besides that. She was probably overwhelmed and nervous because she couldn't hear herself and didn't remember the right key so she just sang it in the wrong key.
Come on ariana fails are someones' dreams
no she sounded horrible she can't sing
@@BritneyHIAM lol she’s famous and you’re not
I freaking love these types of videos because it shows they're just humans and it makes me appreciate them even more!
I love you to react to Adam Lambert if you haven't already 🥰
That moment that you never find Beyoncé in videos like that ! The Queen of vocals !!!
You aren’t looking🤣💀
Yes, she even didn't have a single worst performance,, 😌omfg
Facts
Even the best make mistakes 😂
Isn’t needed me exactly like that at the end of the song?
Not as pitchy and out of tune. I don’t think she can sing that part well without studio help
Selena whisper talks she don't sing haha selena can hav several seats
No need to attack her for it. She still makes bops.
ok boomer let the actual vocal coach speak
Is georgina or regina?
Shes name)
Ariana's sounded like an autotune issue for me, especially on "everyDAY" the fact that she hit the note then instantly went flat, almost electronic-like
It's called not being able to hold the note
@@VALENSlO stfu watch any of her other performances
what’s the Christina agulera song
"What a girl wants"
What a girl wants live “remix”
Yeah Katy was off key but it wasn’t that bad. She made a technique to kinda hide the hearing issue
Ummm.... Was Ari ok?
selena never lost her key lol she never had it in the first place
OMGGGG GURLL THE ROAST
The shade 😂
I screamed 💀💀💀
And you never had the success she had
She has lupus so respect for Sel
Yay
I like your reaction videos, but a few weeks ago you said you were stopping them as you'd fallen into the trap of so many other 'reactors'? Did you change your mind?
I am not stopping to vocal coach reactions, I am just adjusting what I react to. Rather than rushing to react to all the stuff that just gets views, I am trying to focus on Quality rather than quantity. Musical Theatre Monday, Tribute Tuesday / Compilations, Songs I love to sing Thursday, New Music Friday and Vlog or Cover sunday. I will still add WTF, and Vocal Battles in, plus general reactions from time to time. x
@Richard Max McHalliwchester I agree the vocal battles are what drew me to her initially
Jessie j it’s like she took something she shouldn’t have...katy couldn’t hear the backing... Ariana was kinda in the key but a bad vocal from her... xtina just tried a weird ad-lib... Gomez girl is just a terrible singer.
😂
WAIT! the selena gomez I can explain! They took down the original version of that performance from copyright reasons and the person who uploaded the new version had to chage the pitch!
so after all these years we're still acting delusional
Then it would also change the pitch of the instrumentation too....it’s not an explanation
Selena seriously sounds like a random girl singing kareoke
Xtina was not even that bad
I started loving This Is How We Roll by 5H when Camila left and Ally took her part making that verse 10000 times better. Ally actually can reach those high notes so effortlessly.
Too bad she’s so boring that no one wants to see her hit those high notes
@@michaelthoel6199 Nope, Ally is fun. The way that she dances, she paints a look upon your face! She must've come from the sun, you wanna take her through the park!
Ariana is still a very good singer. We all make mistakes but we evolve.
Arianas worst is some peoples best
I disagree, her worst one is completely out of tune
It’s to early for this 😂
Nothing wrong with XTINAS whatsoever.
Are you people serious? It was flat as a pancake. She was going for a G6, and she was literally a semitone below the target pitch.
@@xtinafan06 she harmonized she didn’t lose the actual key or pitch.
@@rydbthatsme I'm a big fan of Christina and she's amazing but the very high falsetto was flat, it happens. There is nothing wrong in admitting it. There was nothing to harmonize with.
The one who made that video must be a very shady person LMAO
K, so, many of these have nothing wrong with them. And I know this isn't Georgina's video, it's someone else's.
The "yeaah, it's a party in the USA" lines from Jesse's performance, she was doing a different melody line. It was on key, it just wasn't the same melody line Miley does in the studio version and we're all so used to hearing. Why she decided to do that instead of the main line? Idk. Other parts in that same performance were definitely not excusable and just messy, but that, which is highlighted as a wtf moment is not a wtf moment.
Katy's "losing the key" thingy. No. She did a different line. It's like every time a singer does something different from the studio version they're losing the key and they're now tone deaf. She did mess up the "change" run tho. That was just messy. She was never singing in a different key, though. Didn't hit the notes correctly, but never lost the key. Her aim was in the right place.
Ariana was tired, yeah. Just tired. Again, though, never lost the key. Missed some of the notes, but was aiming to the right place. Also, maybe bored of the song?
Xtina was waaay flat on the last note, everything else was good.
Once again, Selena didn't lose the key. She was just off the notes, but she was aiming for the right places. She's just not good with technique and couldn't move around and hit the notes well. Also, what Georgina said about the sound. That's directly responsible for her not hitting the notes well too. You may be aiming for the right place but if you can't hear what you're doing, there's no way to know if you're actually getting there or not.
Rihanna didn't mess anything up. I think it's more the quality of the video being shit and her stylistic choices being strange to say the least, rather than her *COMPLETELY LOSING THE KEY* as the video title suggests.
Last one I love how she still remained on key, but was just out of time, and seeing their dynamic no stage, picking up her mic pack and how they hand it from one to the other till it reaches her, it's awesome.
Agreed.
Not the honest vocal coach talking about people being off key 💀 have you heard her studio version of don’t call me angel?
"Licken Linda"?
Did I miss something?
“Listen Linda” the viral disrespectful brat meme
Rih performance was right after she finished the Anti Tour. She was exhausted
Jessie J is WAY BETTER now. In fact she's better than everyone in this video. Also she wrote the song for Miley so it's hers to butcher 🤣
I was cringing so much watching while Jessie was singing 😬
5:53 selena gomez : there's no issue with her vocals actually, she can't sing. That's it. 90% autotune she is. Still can't sing. But i love her music anyways 😂
U deaf? She has perfect and awesome performances, it's your problem if u only focus on her bad performances, don't blind yourself
@@axelamarillas2402 What performances of hers are perfect and awesome? I have never seen one by her that is better than creeping into average. She seems like a super sweet person and I like her music a lot, but she is not a good singer. In most of her performances, she has heavy pitch correction, jumps from flat to sharp all the time, has a loud backing track, has her mic volume low, and so forth.
@Venusaur, She can sing. Here you go again! You feel the chemicals kicking in! It's getting heavy and you wanna run and hide! You wanna run and hide! *nostalgic music*
The Selena one was pitched down loads in her defence, I’m guessing to avoid copyright so the original audio wasn’t actually that bad. You can find the original on UA-cam :)
Ameeeee
Some of Selena's vocals really make me cringe and I can't help it omg
that was pitched down for copyright reasons.
her voice in that performance was on key. in this video doesn't even sounds like it's her voice because of what i said above
@ copyrights reasons 😂😂 catch yourself on. It’s was Selena, there was no copyright infringement
Stop hating find a hobby loser 🙄
@@chrisflan257 another hater goddamn people are really starting to make hating as a hobby good for you 👍🏻 I hope you come back to your senses if you have any ❤️
@@chrisflan257 bro then check it out, i'm not unrealistic. that was a really good performance of 'same old love'.
Cant ever understand what ari says anyway mind🤔
🤣🤣🤣 Ikr. Ariana Can'tsing I likes to call her
@@johnnoble908 ...
I call her No Enunciana🤣
Such a shame 🤣🤣🤣