Winged Eyeliner Stamp | Does It Work? | REAL Test
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 жов 2024
- A winged eyeliner stamp tool that's supposed to make winged eyeliner easy ... does it work? Real first impressions and trials!
Where did I get it?
Wings Cosmetics: WingedEyes.com
MY EASY METHOD FOR WINGED EYELINER
• How To: Winged Gel Eye...
MORE EASY WINGED EYELINER TIPS & TRICKS
• Easy Winged Eyeliner T...
What Am I Wearing?
Lips: MAC Myth + NARS Turkish Delight lip gloss
Eyes: Stila Bliss
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
S N A P C H A T
zabby.babe
I N S T A G R A M
ZabrenaXO
T W I T T E R
ZabrenaXO
F A C E B O O K
ZabrenaXO
S N A I L M A I L
235 Apollo Beach Blvd., #214
Apollo Beach, FL 33572
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
Thank YOU for watching!
XOXO!
Z
Hmmmm I'm wondering if they say not to use waterproof liner bc it dries quicker?? No clue but it would be amazing if it worked. I know me, I would get way too frustrated trying this tool. So a big thumbs up to you for trying again and again 👍🏼
Well, ya can't say you didn't try! I really don't like the way it looks at all. The shape is just off. I agree with that, and what you said about practicing. The way I started was just to do the tiniest little wing out. Then, I just extended it over time. I also think taking close up pictures of my eyes helps me to see where I'm going wrong. You definitely get an A for effort on this one, girlfriend!
Maybe try while closing the eye you're working on? Like you would while applying eye shadow. This way you won't blink. I dunno. Could be good as a guideline though. I have really hooded eyes with my left eye more hooded and downturned than the right, so I can never get the wings to look right.
That was Exactly what i was thinking
That's honestly what I was thinking as well. I think this deserves a retest
The logistics of this thing are just off, you can't make a flat stamp of something that has to be pressed on a curved bone, and also the middle of a squishy eyeball lol.
thank you. From the time I saw it I knew it wouldn't work, not to mention that 3 types of stamps cannot fit the eye shape of thousands.
+1
Mitchell Wiggs it's not really flat
Exactly person
She actually used the whole tool wrong! She was never meant to load makeup on the entire thing. Just stamp the outside. Wing. She screwed up this whole video.
love how she does an honest opinion some UA-cam guru's try a product once or show that they hate it before they even use the product or tool. whereas, zabrena used it more than once to show an honest opinion well done 😘
thanks for taking one for the team, Z!
I love the new Beauty Blender Liner Designer! I work at Sephora and it took me a long time to learn to do wings (on myself and clients) so the little tool definitely helps! You can do your liner, a wing, cut crease, brows, carve out brows, nose contour, lip edges (filling and shaping with concealer), and protect your skin when doing mascara on upper and lower lashes. I've tried lining with gel, pencil, and liquid liner and all applications have come out crisp. Those are the uses I've found so far, but I'm sure there are more! It is only $16 and it comes in the cutest case!!
Thank you for purchasing and demonstrating this product for us. It is so helpful when deciding whether something is worth the expense. Awesome job as per usual.
Agreed. I know I can trust Zabrena when she says something is good or not good. I stay far away from things she "can't recommend" Have a great day XO
+Dena Mcclure I agree. It is nice that she saves us from spending money on useless things.
Could part of the application problem be that the waterproof eyeliners drys more quickly than regular liner?
Ah! Could be!
***** 😎
Yea that could definitely be part of the problem
Oh that's an idea. Good thought.
That’s exactly what I was thinking.
This looks like something good for beginners to use as a guideline. I would use gel loner then go over it with liquid.
2 reasons I can think of off the hop as to the "why" on no waterproof product: 1) They dry too quickly to allow you sufficient placement time on eye, and 2) They may stain/harden the apparatus.
Thanks for the info! I'll save muh dough! What does it look like if you stamp a card?
The stamp does give you a good guideline at least.
Omg yes I was thinking the same!!
Zabrena, some of the posts say only the wing should be used. I think this calls for a retry. 🤔
Zabrena: "Hi gorgeous!"
Me: *gets shy immediately* >w
Ms Ma'am, this is what I Love about your channel... HONESTY!!! 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
+Carol Creamybee Woot! Thank you for your kind words, Carol! :)
You have to use gel. I am assuming the reason you can't use waterproof is because it dries too quickly. Using the eyeliner that you are using it dries too quickly. Also, keep your eyes closed... that way you don't blink?
same here, used both gel and liquid eyeliner, the gel was way worse
I hadn't thought of that! I was thinking you can't use waterproof because it might not come off the stamp.
Gel takes longer to dry in a lot of cases, so it will create something that will stamp. Now a days, everyone has the pens because they are easier and more convent, but for this tool, gel is the best bet.
Thanks for testing out this product. But I was on the website and it says that you are not supposed to use waterproof and also on the instructions it says you are to put the eyeliner on the wing and not the whole stamp and simply roll it on there per Wings*Cosmetics
Zabrena maybe you should try it with a cheap non waterproof liquid eyeliner
i just bought these and i absolutely love them. they do recommend only applying the eyeliner to the wing and then finishing out the on your lid. I would definitely try that and then maybe the problem with blinking wouldn't create so much of a problem.
I just wanted to take the time to thank you. By watching your videos, I have been able to do my bridesmaids makeup last year. The year before that my best friends wedding. Your channel has truly educated me on make up. I love your frugal Fridays, historical makeup, and high end vs. drugstore. Moreover, the fact you live in Florida, with the humidity, really tells me about the wear of a product. I live in Florida keys. Super muggy and extremely hot down here. We don't have Saphora, Ulta, or Mac... absolutely nothing. All we have is Kmart. Your review videos make if easier to shop online. So, Please continue the awesome work. I just wanted to take the time to say "I appreciate your mission for beauty and thank you again."
Kyra
+Kyra Alejandro AW! That's amazing, Kyra! Thank you so much for taking the time to say this and I'm so humbled the videos have been able to help you! :) xoxo!
I saw the creator of these explain how they work. You're only supposed to put eyeliner on the winged part
Hey. Could u send me that info from the creator. I actually like this tool. But could use help.
Maybe if they had a thinner applicator like you said and they actually gave you like a liquid eyeliner in the stamp form where you stamp it into the pan and then your eye? lol it's interesting but does seem like it takes more time, it's seems like when people try to come out with things that is supposed to be a shortcut it ends up taking longer haha
Why is no one using gel eyeliner!!
That's what I was thinking
Same. Why? Liquid dries too fast
Unfortunately, this is just another one of the many makeup gimmicks out there! 😕
+Lindsay Cariad Yep! :/
Lindsay Cariad
I agree! This didn't work for me at all. I tried different eyeliners and nothing. Very disappointed.
Beauty Horder try gel. I have one n it works for gel n don't do the whole tool jus the wing
What a flippin pain in the ass! and then ya probably gotta wash those dang things everyday! nooooooooop! no way! lolol ,you are the best tester ever!
+Tully Soulliere LOL! ;)
I am going to have a look at our house, but the last few weeks, but the problem with 1 ujhfhjhxkdbb jxjjnjjjfjdjjff jfifnfbhffvjf jfkbfjkfkdkbfjf nmrkfjbfhfifjkfnfjfjjfjfjfbjfuffjiffhhfjfjfjhfhfjfufhufhfvfvfhjfhfhfjjfhffvvfhfjjffbffbbtbtbtbrbbtbtbrbt r rnrbrb
Actually they are very easy to clean
Consistent and useful videos. I still can't believe you don't have atleast a million subscribers. Keep up the good work beautiful. 👍🏻
I wonder if a gel liner would be a better option. You could lay down a thicker amount of product and the drying time is slower. Just curious
+shdwstrm I was thinking about this. Gel liner is naturally drier than liquid liner (think about looking at it in a pot). You might be able to layer it more but it could end up just as patchy.
Love your videos! Could you do a Battle of the Drugstore False Lashes video
yes I like that idea!!
I thought EXACTLY what you thought...if YOU can't do it then I don't have a prayer. Loved that you did this Z...you are going to save so many people money on a pipe dream! Love you girlfriend! xoxox Mary
+Glitzy Fritzy I try! :) Love you lady! xoxoxo!
finally!! no sponsored rubbish selling me their crap, just a real human who actually bought her own stuff. i like that, Good one!
This seems so gimmicky. We all have different eye shapes and sizes and are not all the same. I personally can not wear a winged eyeliner at all as my eyes are simply too small and too hooded to pull that look off. So these stamps would never work on me lol. Thanks for testing this out Zabrena!!! 💕💕💕
+Sissi Nuthman That was my other thought with this one, too; what about the different eye shapes?!
I feel like everyone's eye shape is different therefore everyone's wing is going to be at a different angle. So this product is kinda silly to me lol. But thank you for trying for us. You're the best! 💖
May I suggest trying it with a gel liner? It wouldn't dry so fast, you would probably have more time for placement and get all the product actually onto the eye so maybe you wouldn't have to fill it in.
Maybe if they were a little softer and curved a bit to fit your eye shape... more like a sponge. They still could be used as a guide...
I think despite its flaws, for someone like me who is visually impaired, this would be a great tool. Because of my vision, or lack of it, I tend to be heavy handed and this would at least give me a starting point. Where can it be purchased? Love your videos!
+Donna knight good point!
Me too! Almost blind so this would help.
Hey zabrena, just letting you know that most waterproof mascaras contain wax and the wax tend to stick to rubber so maybe that's why it was so patchy
In the video I saw on Facebook. Apparently you're suppose to just stamp the wing part
The waterproof liquid eyeliner's consistency causes it too dry too quickly which is why you are having to move so quickly. Thank you for the video!!
I wonder if you could use eyeshadow on the stamp? To get the angle right? Then trace over with the liquid eyeliner, and stop where you like. Then clean up. Hmmm... Great video :)
I loved your commitment and determination to make it work lol.
+SweetLillyMoon LOL! I was committed! ;)
It makes me wonder if you need to use a gel or pencil liner instead of a waterproof since you said it tells you not to use it so that probably has a big difference in the end result. Following directions is key. Do you think if you close your eye to apply it so you don't blink moving the product on your eye would make a difference? Also so it isn't so dramatic, you don't have to color the whole stamp, it can be done thinner to get a less dramatic look. I have never used it nor do I own it but it just makes sense to me to adjust to get the look you want. But hey I never handled it before so who knows how it would work out
That just looks like more trouble than t's worth. Loved watching your other 2 videos on winged liner. Great tips. My problem is I do a way too dramatic wing! I'm used to doing winged liner for stage. So... yea, lots of drama. I think I may try some of your tips.
I think it looked nice, the 4th time. Coloring it in obviously helped. That shape looks nice on you. 😊
technically you use the CORNER of the tool not the whole thing
Exactly
I saw another first impression video of this product and there is actually 2 versions of the stamp, a regular wing and a dramatic wing. You have the dramatic one here. But she also had trouble with the application and they quick drying part of it.
Maybe if you keep your eye closed?. I'm not expert on eyeliner. (No sarcasm)
she said no sarcasm
+reg2916 sometimes I type things and it come out offensive.
Kandi, that's exactly what I was coming on to comment. Why would you continue to try to do it on an open eye, if it makes you blink? Also, if it's not working with waterproof eyeliner and the directions specifically say not to use waterproof, maybe try regular :)
I wonder if the non-waterproof stuff would have gone on easier? Perhaps the waterproof reacts with the rubber to dry it out. I do agree with you about the blinking- if something was coming at my eyes, my first reaction would be to blink and step back! I reckon a bit of practice or sticky tape!! :)
+anamikaa That's what I was thinking regarding the waterproof formulas. The non waterproof formulas are probably more wet so they may transfer better. Waterproof formulas always seem to me to be a little drier.
can you do a in depth talk thru tutorial on winged eyeliner? I can never do it right :(
But coffee first has an amazing in depth tutorial on winged eyeliner. It helped me TONS I could never do it either until I watched that video.
I feel like this would work much better with a gel liner, you should try!
for me it is wonderful gonna shape my sponge like a wing and see if it would stamp better..and I like the wing shape it gives ..all I have to do is touch up and go..I can't draw a good wing twice and trying to get it to look good is harder to me than using this as a guide and then adding to it to make it look sharp and precise
I've watched her videos and I've found if you line your top eyelid before applying the wing with the tool, that's how you do it. Loading the corner of the tool and rolling up, not loading up the whole tool with eyeliner and expecting it to turn out perfectly. My are on their way in the mail. (:
Yeah just get an angled eyeliner brush...I have the pointy kind too...I prefer gel or cream liner pots and also the pens, but the brush gives you the most dramatic effect, pens are easier to use if you're new I'd assume.
water proof likely has an oil like base which wrecks the material its made from.Thanks for the review idk if I could make that product work.
The advantage I could see is that both your wings would be the same length. I would like to see a do over with non waterproof eyeliner. It might not dry as fast. Also, I imagine eye shape could play a factor. I can say, your candid review is refreshing.
Thank you for this video, I just saw this on Sephora and was going to order it. I cannot do the wing liner and was hoping this was my fix.
Why don't u try it as a stencil? Like put it a teeny bit higher, then draw against it...
Hi, Zabrena. Never commented, but I've watched your videos for awhile! Not sure if anyone else suggested it yet, but I wonder whether it would work if you just put product on the wing instead of the whole applicator? That's always the hard part for me anyway!
Hiya! Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment! So nice to see you! :) There were some other commenters saying the same thing, that might work better!
I have the Beth Bender Beauty eyeliner stencil and I give it a 7/10. It takes some practice but much less than learning free hand.
You could try starting with your eye already closed to avoid the blink, and I'm sure you could put liner just along the edge and not all the way to the tip of the winged portion, if you like a thin line and not such a dramatic wing.
Even with all that said, there's still a small gap between the liner and your lash line (small, but noticeable). And after all that work, you STILL had to go in with the eyeliner and line to the inner corner and fix the rough spots.
I agree with you-- practice, practice, practice! You don't need a fancy tool (that only does half the job, and doesn't even do that very well!) if you just give yourself a lot of time (and grace) to learn to do it right free-handed.
Your eye color is so unusual and beautiful!
Did you try it with your eye closed and the other open? That's how I do mine now, so I feel like that would have worked better. Seeing your fourth try, I really want this because my hands shake so it would help me get a crisp wing like THAT omg *heart eyes*
I saw a "how to" video on this product by the creator, she explains that it is t be used for the wing only. You line your eye like you normally would, then you use the tool to add the wing.
omg I love yor additude so much, i don't know, something about you just makes me feel better haha. subscribed!
I think a gel liner would be best bc it doesn't set so fast and you can kinda have some time before it dries on the stamp.
sadly no, I tried it with gel and gotten an even worse outcome, it really just is a shitty product.
I love you Zabrena!🌹Please keep your videos coming!!👑
Thank god, an honest review on a new product and you tube, relatively new subbie xx
just watched your video! your eyes are so pretty!!! they remind me of snow flakes and they are really so pretty! love the blue
Great video! I think it's silly not to use regular liquid eyeliner when most of them are useless, they run off so easily! Thanks for your review. You are always so helpful and honest. Love it😍
It says on the website to only apply the liner to the wing and not the whole stamp. This also gives you more control on the placement of the wing so it doesn't look so dramatic.
I already love you just because of this video!
your honesty is great and you speak as if we are your friends very casual! (:
What do u use on ya eyebrows because I'm ginger and I don't want brown brows
Hi! I have a full list of my favorites coming up in Monday's video :)
use the milani brow fix kit in light
Hands down, the only method that works for me with winged eyeliners I learned by pixiwoo.
You are supposed to apply only the wing part not the lid pard on the stamp I think
Thanks for the realness cause no matter how many videos I watch on how to create the perfect winged I'll never get it right :/ Wish someone would create the perfect tool cause the struggle is really lol
+LatinJerseyGirl I hear ya!
Wow you made it work so much better with water proof eyeliner than other people did with a non water proof eyeliner lmao props!
OMG is that your natural eye lid color it's so gorgeous!😱😄 if not what's the eyeshadow?! I really want a color like that.your eyes are pretty too☺️😚
I think it's good so far as length...where to stop and start. general shape..you can fill in. I would get it.
+amy fletcher yeah for someone like me the general outline I could trace and fill in would be helpful.
Thanks so much for being our guinea pig. Thanks for your honesty
they do two types. dramatic and more casual. maybe the waterproof eyeliner dries uo too fast?
Even if used correctly and it somehow works out on the first try, doesn't this waste a lot of product as is? That dried up residue left on the stamp itself would be enough for one more full application, at least, and with some eyeliners, making what little product is in it last is already a challenge. Not to mention the cleanup, having to trace it over to make it look even, and the fact that you can't really see what you're doing while you're doing it... Naah. Quirky, fun to try out once, but gimmicky.
I don't think I will bother. Thank you
Apply with your eye closed, only use the wing, and use gel or non-waterproof liner. Waterproof liners tend to dry much, much faster than non-waterproof. It is also just a guide, and you go over it with your liner when you are done. I actually love this thing haha.
Never heard of this tool. I do like the dramatic wing but it does look hard😍😜
Thanks, Zabrena! I'm a new makeup user, and you just did me a HUGE favor!
liquid eyeliners dries instantly, can you try with gel?those are creamy and wont dry fast . let me know if it worked out 😘😘
This looks like more trouble than it's worth, especially when you have to clean it everyday and go over the eyeliner again by hand. It's faster to just apply the eyeliner like we've always done. Anyway, thanks Zabrena for testing it out for us. Once again, you've given us another great video. Hugs :)
Thanks for your amazing vids Zabrena. I always learn something valuable from each and every one ( this one included ). You rock Zabrena!
+Carolyn Mathews Woot! Thank you for watching, Carolyn! :)
I feel like you could probably put product on ONLY the wing and it might work out better, especially since most of us struggle with the actual wing itself. That being said, the shape of the wing would still have to be what you like for this to be good.
LOVE YOUR VIDEOS! You really understand what a viewer wants to see
Oh no Zabrena! I ordered mines a few days too early!!!! Thx for the awesome video!
Zabrena, you doll! What is that gorgeous eyeshadow combo you're wearing?
What if you used the gel eyeliners that are out there maybe that would work. Would you be willing to do a video showing the use of the stamp with different types of eyeliner?
I know that this is an old video, but on the off chance you kept these wing stamps, you should get maybeline's master graphic eyeliner. It it really thick, it looks like a marker, and it doesn't dry like every other liner I've tried on those stamps did. Also I only fill in the wing part, not the whole stamp. I just use it as a guide, then fill the rest out by hand. the stamps took some getting used to, but now that
i have the hang of it, my wings take like 30 seconds
I make my liquid eyeliner look like crap all on my own, I don't need a little tool to do it, lol! Thanks for being a trooper, Zabrina! :)
What product and colour do you use on your eyebrows? It's such a struggle finding brow products for redheads 😩
thanks for trying this out. you're a doll!
The things you do for us,Zabrena 😂😂😂 Thank you!
I think the only reason why they say not to use a waterproof eyeliner might be so that if the user messes up, it'll be much easier to clean? Just a thought!
Thank you for your willingnesd to be a guinea pig! I appreciate how well you give an unbiased opinion. X&O's
I definitely think I'll be skipping this tool if I come across it. Thanks for the review.