Let's Build an Encoded Multi Item Sorter
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 бер 2021
- In this video we'll design an encoded multi item sorter capable of drastically improving sorting speeds for all of those pesky item types that you don't need a large storage for.
Storage Tech Archive, a place where you can find all kinds of storage tech solutions:
/ discord
World Download:
www.mediafire.com/file/qrws1b...
Second Channel where I post my Music:
/ @artism6843 - Ігри
Absolutely love these in depth technical videos
same
0:18 I love the arrangement of TNT and pressure plate :)
It’s a built‑in self‑destruct feature.
its official. cubic is now a storage tech guru
Going to have to be if we are to find the right design for Scicraft when we update.
@@cubicmetre :)))))
@@cubicmetre is scicraft planning to update to 1.16 or 1.17?
@@martinzhang6936 1.16
@@brandynamite3022 1.17 mango said it in his streams
This kind of Redstone explanation video is so helpful in understanding how Redstone and minecraft in general works. Please make more of these videos as they help a lot.
Even as a total redstone noob, I found this video very entertaining and could follow along quite well. I always wanted to have a storage like this on a survival server and now I know what design to use. Thank you!
I love how you always break down complicated redstone contraptions and ideas to make them accessible! Every time I watch one of your videos I can feel my brain cell count doubling, from 2 to 4.
Sadly mine stays at one
If it keeps doubling, just watch 35 more videos and you will have the amount of brain cells the average human has
@@spicybaguette7706 I love exponential growth
Yes I am with you. Yes I appreciate you going through it piece by piece. Really really really really really valuable. You are a legend. I really appreciate the time you spend building these videos. It may take me more time to watch than it takes for you to make because I rewatch them so many times.
Oh wow, I appreciate how much you value my time.
This is why I enjoy redstone. There's always more than one way to accomplish one's goals. Especially when a new update presents a new thing.
Well done!
You got me subbed from randomly finding your villager matrix video and I've been enjoying your other ones also. :)
Honestly, really appreciate the wonderful explanation to how everything works, I really don't like when people build stuff and don't explain what they're doing or how it works. Its refreshing to have less of the block by block building and an actual detailed explanation as to how it works and the mechanics of how it actually works.
Your videos are so incredibly informative. I've been learning so much about different game mechanics by going through these in-depth videos.
for the last couple years i've been working on a compact comparator based redstone computer, which i finished last year. However my knowledge of redstone dates back to 1.5-1.7. To see how far we've come and how much there is to learn inspires me to try and use this sort of redstone to make a much more compact redstone computer. i don't think i'll be able to, but you give me hope. thank you
This really is a well done video with just the right amount of detail. I really appreciate you going through some of the common gotchas. I think I'm going to have to play with this design.
Loving this kind of videos! I do appreciate all the work behind the scenes ;)
2:12 "Within every random block of redstone components there is a" DRAGON EGG.
(the dragon egg is at 25, 13, -40 in the world download)
These videos are awesome for someone who doesn't understand all going behind the scenes. I'm now hoping for a vid combining the bulk storage with this multi item sorter
I'm loving this video style especially with you going over what you've learned and how to show it to your viewers! Keep it up :)
Great video as always, a lot of great info in this, also your scene transitions are seamless. You can tell you put a fair bit of work into your vids.
This is some of the most helpful stuff I've seen on the platform
i love this channel. hope you keep making these kinds of videos. really helps to learn how to make these sorts of things.
saw the previous 2 videos on the topic, thought "this is cool but very overkill for most of my storage" & started looking into multi-item sorters.. ofc this is one of the first results. beautiful. Earned a sub for that one lol
Storage tech is so addictive, as soon as u have a working system u always want something better, faster and more reliable.
I literally haven't finished my first storage system and now I want to make this.
Love this type of video, it helps me understand storage tec way better I was annoyed by some hopper order location al dependency before and knowing this makes me happy about it
I love the "Let's build" series, keep it going!
This is incredible. Thank you Cubicmetre!
While much of this is over my head, it was incredibly interesting and I now have a much better understanding of MISS's in general. Thanks for the great vid!
Fantastic video, this is getting me excited about new storage tech
This feels like mechanised sleight of hand. Superb work mate
Hey cubic, yes I love when you do this videos. I learn so much red stone, thanks for your hard work !
I learned so much. The way you are explaining is very intuative Thanks!
Redstone walkthroughs are literally the best!! 👍😁
I love your videos. They’re so informative. It’s great to watch and pretend to understand what’s going on 🤣
Nice concept and video.
Caveat to other viewers: "Scaffolding trick" means "Will NOT work on Bedrock"
I really like this type of videos. You are explaning everything really nice in details, but at the same time it is not hard to follow.
this is, exactly what I was looking for, but its going to take me a long time to figure out how to implement it in the very specific use case I'm working on
I have watched this video many times. I really do like it. Has inspired™️ me to make my own concept at an mis, thank you, cubic
ngl, this is the first video where I finally understood the concept of a multi-item sorter, which before was like magic to me...
I'm sorry but how do you only have 4.5k subs you are a literal genius gg!
i like this kind of video where you go through redstone project in detail
Thanks, I also enjoy making them when I have the time.
this is awesome dude, well done
Damn this is almost singleplayer survival friendly! I love your work
This is really cool!
It's a shame that it's not completely silent, and it does feel like it would be laggier than normal multi-item sorters, plus it's a lot larger. But it's still such a fascinating contraption, and the concept is genius.
I built two multi-item sorters before, Maizuma Game's and Rapscallions. Maizuma's was slow when sorting a little bit of a lot of items, and Rapscallions was very fragile (At least when I was using it on a server), I had to be very careful about chunk loading, and even had to slow the intake of items because it would clog up (I asked the server admins about it and they said that that the server was run on Paper, which handles hoppers slightly differently).
I love this type of videos showing the entire procces. GG
Love this kind of videos... Great explanation for a Redstone noob
You are so underrated dude. My finance has zero interest in the technical side of the game, but your videos get me so excited I end up talking to her about them all the time.
Can you maybe do a video where you apologize on behalf of us more techy minecrafters to our partners?
Explain the mechanism step by step but not just show the machine, love this kind of video so much! keeping on!!!
Commenting for the algorithm, I love your videos!
Love your video's man. This one looks almost single player friendly. Question, does encoded mean using shulkers?
Shulker boxes are "encoded" to a slice of the storage system every time it sorts a box. The encoding is some arbitrary number system which is dependent on the number of slices. Technically this system is Hexadecimal encoded because there are Hex + Deci = 6 + 10 = 16 slices. But if you had more slices the number system would technically be different.
Inserting box from the Hermitcraft server XD... Thanks for the nice video. Good explanations :)
If I could give this video a thousand likes I would, literally in awe you haven't blown up yet.
How dont you have more subscribers??? I have searched for that kind of content for a long time now
i’m not gonna lie i like watching your videos when i’ve just woken up and i don’t know shit
I can see this video motivating the community to make this type of system even better and compact, oh boy, we are witnessing history being made
Like rapscallisons 1wide tillable one
I love thease type of videos, if you could make more I like to learn
This is the second time this week you've revolutionised item sorting!
Also, this might be a bit of a stupid question, but wouldn't it be possible to tile the box splitters by 1 by having two rows of them facing each other? (something like Rapscallion's multi item sorter: ua-cam.com/video/EZh6Npg_UIw/v-deo.html ) Unless those box splitters are directional, of course.
I did consider just having two rows of themhowever then you would need hopper spam the connect them to the dropper lines and they add a heap of bulk to the system. I'd much rather wait to see Data's 1wt solution.
@@cubicmetre Yeah, that's probabably better
you know, with an encoded item sorter, you could actually feed batches of items to smaller, simpler sorters such that this system works with INCREDIBLE speed for sorting individual items. my guess is (for practicality) eight item types per silo, and batches of five silos together forming a hallway of forty individual item silos
Wait, for multi item storage, as long as the items don't despawn you should be able to do a snaking pattern for multiple item sorters per line, and have each sorter lead into a hopper line which is connected to the chests. I understand that this is slow, clunky, and makes each chest line at least 2 blocks wide(might be ways around that last bit)
10/10 thanks for the great video
Yes. Keep making this vids.
Well now I have a new favorite multi-item sorter. It almost feels a shame to actually build a storage hall as with the rate of progress atm it would be outdated in a week.
I like your funny words magic man
7:08, bro, this part literally had me dying and have no idea why lmao.
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but what resource-pack are you using? I've noticed you have arrows on some blocks. Or is it a mod? Anyways I love in depth videos like this! GJ
The texture pack is vanilla tweaks, it lets you customise a range of things including redstone components.
What are you talking about? I absolutely need bulk storage for my lightly weathered waxed cut copper stairs
Thats one of the best categorized MIS i'v seen.
Does it work on 1.20?
I'll be able to check that on this sunday.
gonna have to study this video like 3 times before i begin to understand it
I hear you. Worth it though!
how does this man only have 4.5k subs...
Ilmango has used seapickles for water-stream alignment. Might be better for those sharp angles.
cubic: "Who needs bulk storage for everything?"
me: ME for no good reason other than because I want to
Thank you mr m3
Hi! Is there a chance there's one item missing in the overflow item filter? The storage of the world download was not working for me, and then I noticed it had 18 items on the last filter instead of 19, so I put one more and it seems to work good now
Thankyou so much! The world download wasn't working for me either and I was about to give up thinking it just didn't work in 1.18. But then I saw your comment and I found the hopper that was missing an item and now it works perfectly.
"If something can go wrong, it will go wrong"
-Cubicmetre 2021
Brilliant!
Hey @cubicmetre
quick question. Is there any necessity to have two filter items instead on one?
I modified your awesome design to sacrifice speed for reduced complexity, like replacing the piston bolt with powered rails. However the minecart wasn't fast enough and always sucked up both items. That's when i realized i can also use only one filter item instead of two. This would create a hole when it gets sucked up, but the item can only go back to it's original spot anyways.
In case you're interested what i also did.
boxes will first go through a box merger, creating shulkers with only one item type before being sent to the multi sorter. Therefore i could get rid of the whole item sorting in the back and sending the boxes straight to unloaders, which makes it possible to make the whole thing 1 wide tileable.
This is amazing! I want to build this but it looks way to complicated for me.
This is what i searched for holy shit. Redstone God be like. :D
2:05 "We are the Borg. You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile."
I think Terri Ryan is trapped somewhere in that cube aswell...
If only there were someone like you in bedrock
"to start with..." *shows borg cube of incredible redstone* i guess im out then xD
and with water streams...shouldn't you only need a single corner to align items to one side (the first wall they collide against)?
Just wondering, the leftmost hoppers/chests never get unlocked and put the dispensers continuously on, and makes that slice unusable. Any fixes for that?
I don't think Michaelangelo said that. Just saying...
Awesome video!
Tick warping for one hour isn't verifying that it works. Especially with gaussian random momentum. I had contraptions like that break after 100 hours of ingame time and more. Also I believe in your design where you show inter slice interactions there is a 2nd mistake with the shulker dispensers
Obviously forgot to praise the whole video as usual. Good job cubic
I've obviously stress tested these systems off camera for much longer time periods to verify that they work. Also you can never be certain that something is reliable. Only less and less uncertain of it's reliability the longer it runs for. Because the gaussian random momentum only ever has a +y component placing a block above the box makes the box breaking 100% reliable.
@@cubicmetre do i smell bayes theorum?
@@cubicmetre are you using carpet extreme behavior?
20:00 I spat my coffee XD
where funny?
Please make tutorial on this storage system
“Using entry level redstone computing”
my brother in christ, what the hell is a piston vault 😂
insane
YES
As of now, is there a fix to make the storage one wide? I did a bit of looking on the discord and couldn't find anything. Thanks
There has been a lot of development since this design. Boyenn glotz and raffq made an entire parallel entity item sorter with a variable set that is far superior. As for the multi item sorting capability people have been working on better designs.
@@cubicmetre thank you I really appreciate the feedback. I'll do some more digging and see what I could come up with. Thanks!
I'm confused and I like it
I think I'll stick with a couple hoppers and rest one dust lol
the sorter in the world download breaks for me as soon as I put an unsortable item like stripped birch in there - is the download broken?
Yeah the design in this wdl is not the final solution, I think I pointed out the issues with it.
would it not be easier to use soul sand rather than piston and block to drop the minecart down while keeping a solid block above the single item unloader?
The soulsand would need to be driectly above the rail for that to work, however thats where the shulker box needs to be placed.
On the world download I run in the second frustrating issue on the shulker unloader . Is there an alternative sorter available : I can't place the block in a other order since I don't now in Wich order you place them the first time ...
Sorry for the English language I am not English
Ah, you need Boyenn's first item unloader which is 1wt and much more reliable.. His video for reference:
ua-cam.com/video/125LUiq2MBA/v-deo.html
The version he made had a slight issue where boxes could get lost when broken. He made a fix which I have here:
www.mediafire.com/file/onjry92x0pwo2k9/first_item_unloader_boyenn_v2.litematic/file
Add that to your system and it should work fine. This video was a proof of concept which simply isn't reliable so I probably should not have release a wdl in hindsight, sorry for your inconvenience.
Thank you for that answer it work fine now
But I recently run in a hash map tick priority issue in a piston crafter. Do you found a solution to this kind issue ?
@@loickbf1225 You can try locating the affected hoppers and changing their configuration so that their tick priority does not matter. If this is not possible then the only alternative is to break and replace the hoppers in the correct order every time you try to use the machine.
@@cubicmetre I found a way for my contraption by making it way slower
If something can go wrong... it will go wrong. Murphys Law - ALL THE WAY!!!
Non Stackable items or 16 ones wouldn't work right? Or could u reduce amount of glass placeholders to make it work
You obviously cannot sort stackables, instead they will send the box to an overflow which removes the unstackable. for 16 stackables you can just adjust the threshold of the chest by tweaking the amount of items in it.
can you try to find a way to sort totems out in a raid farm
An allay could probably do it in 1.19
Can you do an autocrafter for sea lantern, i tryed to do that but i can not
Hey cubic, fellow Australian here hoping you'll read this,
I'm in the process of designing my own version of a multi item encoder for a larger binary encode storage system however I'm having trouble pulling only one item from a shulker box with a hopper minecart. I have experimented with different timings including the exact same set up used at the start of your video including multiple different orientations and locations however I am still only able to pull exactly 2 items. Do you have any advice?
Are you using a piston bolt or a powered rail? Hoppercarts pull an item every gametick so you need to move them a block every gametick or they will pull multiple items from each inventory. A powered rail moves the cart at 0.4 blocks per tick and so the cart will sit on each block for roughly 2 ticks pulling 2 items. So what you need to do is use a piston bolt to move the cart 1 block per tick.
Hey@@cubicmetre,
Thank you for your response,
I actually am using a piston bolt however this shouldn't matter as I am referring to the system you showcase at 3:37 in which the hopper minecart is stationary. I'm using the exact same timing as you're system in the exact same orientation yet the hopper minecart always pulls two items instead of one.
On a less important topic, whereabouts in Australia are you from.
How can you move only one item from a container to your inventory like in 2:25 and how can you get chest previews like in 2:30 ?
Masa's mods such as tweakeroo and itemscroller, essentials for any technical player.
Will this break due to chunk loading/unloading?
Pretty much anything can break if you unload it while it's running, what's important is how something breaks when unloaded. Worst case scenario for this system is the minecart gets stuck somewhere.