Not even recently...when seeds were first added, they broke bedrock. You could place a dirt block under bedrock, make it into farmland, then when you would plant seeds on it it wpuld break the bedrock above. And that was in alpha or beta.
The most reliable height is to have the bedrock like 5 or 6 blocks above the propagule, it kinda forces the tree to grow a tall varient and the root will still break it, found this out on my own trying to make a mangrove tree farm.
@@ShuckleShellAnemia Why the hell do you want to get yourself into the void mate? The reason we tried to go through or even break bedrock is to get on top of the nether world we already have voids at the end anyways
@@natalie6811 Even since Alpha versions, you could plant large oak trees or spawn nether portals in such a way they would overwrite the bedrock. I think the oldest bedrock breaking exploit was when hoes were introduced to Minecraft. It was quite hilarious: you had to place a block of dirt under a block of bedrock, till that block which then created a farmland block (15/16 of a normal block height), in that tiny gap you just had to click with the seed and as the seed gets planted, it would overwrite the bedrock at the top.
It's Mojang's own fault. And it's the same phenomenon that's leading to all these videos showing how to cheese the Warden Mojang: "This is Minecraft, a game without rules" Players: 🏃 🏃🏿♀️ Mojang: "Okay, there's one rule." Players: proceed to find myriad ways to break said rule Mojang: "I don't know what I expected."
When you think about it, roots in real life can exert a tremendous force. They can break asphalt roads, concrete pavements and sometimes even solid rock. In this way, Mojang should keep it as a feature :D Jokes aside, even if they fix that bug, new types of exploits will always be found. It's an almost never ending battle.
How helpful is breaking bedrock from the bottom anyways? It can basically only be used for breaking the nether ceiling, and we already have a million ways to do that
@@aguyontheinternet8436 We have a bunch of variations of tnt-piston ways to do it. Propagules would be much nicer so you don't have to get 20+ cps to break bedrock with piston heads, which (I believe) is also only possible when you're above the bedrock layer.
New world generation stuff usually tends to be able to break bedrock (By new, I also mean changes, because I've seen igloos that have been able to break bedrock) Edit: Wtf are the replies Also, Zeroth (0th)
Plants being able to break bedrock after you bone meal it in the snapshots will always be a tradition now ig. It would be shocking it would be if they added like this that cant break bedrock at this point
This doesn’t seem surprising as a button can hold up gravel, diamonds break on cactus and a pixel of water can save you from breaking your legs Edit: ur replies are making me lose braincells
Man grew a tree and, It was been grown, On the first day of this land, To no suprise of many, It had teared itself throught, The undestructible, unobtaniable, Resting rock of the worlds, Known by another name as, Bedrock.
Not like there is any real use for this, because the only place where you can put stuff below Bedrock is the Nether, where trees won't grow. Very interesting find regardless.
This would be be interesting if this would stay but we all know that this will probably be fixed and need to use the ender pearl trick to get on the nether roof
Why do I think this happened with Seeds, Bamboo, Dark oak, Moss, Dripleaf already? This has happened so many times that I think mojang intentionally does allow bedrock to break in snapshot until full release, only for Nether farm builders’ disappointment.
This is exactly how I work as a developer. First I make sure that the program does what it is intended to do, then AFTER that, I fix some minor bugs and start the bug tracking. Is the fastest way to get something working as least in it's minimum.
Well before 1.16 use tnt piston trick and when 1.17 and 1.18 we use cauldron snow powder and now we have magroove tree in 1.19.I wonder what happen in Minecraft 2.0
Plants are always the strongest thing in minecraft. You can literally drop 100 anvils on a single flower and have all the anvils break while that flower remains perfectly healthy.
PhoenixSC is the ultimate tester and coder of the Minecraft community, and not only am I amazed at what he finds, I'm amazed that he can make something as complicated as Propagule to Magrove Tree growth understandable. Don't stop doing what you do Phoenix, because it's excellent!
It's always the simplest things that are forgotten in coding and game development. It's the reason why basically every update, there is a new way to break bedrock, and then it instantly gets fixed. In terms of fixing this, you could make a blacklist of blocks, that roots cannot replace, instead of doing a bunch of different checks. But this is Mojang, they probably are fixing it, or have fixed it by now.
the mangrove trees being suspended up in the air like that looks like a insane looking giant tree spider and imagining it walking around the world terrifies me
I hope it stays this way….Most people dont realize the reason you want a hole in the netger ceiling is so a beacon will work……Its a big deal. Very cool
Phoenix, you can actually automate tree production, and it's ridiculously easy too. Just have a redstone timer firing dispensers filled with saplings and bone meal.
I remember watching a wifies video talking about how bedrock was broken. He said if knew trees were added, they would likely break bedrock. And here we are
Every time they add a new growable plant you can basically guarantee they accidentally made it able to break bedrock
Coincidence?
I THINK NOT
Coincidence
@@Rose-jj5mq There are no coincidences
Edition and block
i was about to instantly comment the same from just seeing the title
Recently every new block feature seems to break bedrock. Like how moss did at first.
Lol
Not even recently...when seeds were first added, they broke bedrock. You could place a dirt block under bedrock, make it into farmland, then when you would plant seeds on it it wpuld break the bedrock above. And that was in alpha or beta.
@@IrisGalaxis That’s really cool I didn’t know that
No, Wardens do NOT break Bedrock Edition. He was talking about the block, NOT the edition.
@@mayoactual2065when did he say bedrock edition
The most reliable height is to have the bedrock like 5 or 6 blocks above the propagule, it kinda forces the tree to grow a tall varient and the root will still break it, found this out on my own trying to make a mangrove tree farm.
Not the most useful height though, as bedrock layer is typically only the bottom 3 layers of the y coordinate
@@ShuckleShellAnemia what about nether?
@@ShuckleShellAnemia Why the hell do you want to get yourself into the void mate? The reason we tried to go through or even break bedrock is to get on top of the nether world
we already have voids at the end anyways
@@monke4044 for fun.
@@monke4044 for maximum spawn rate y=1 mob farms
At this point it's just to be expected that new plants break bedrock at first.
not really a surprise, they always leave out bedrock whenever something does this
Fr though every time lmao
Every update has a new way to break bedrock including snapshots
Maybe that was a feature
@@dragon-du6ew of course every update breaks Bedrock, it’s the buggiest version!
🤔
Any new growth mechanic they introduce always breaks bedrock. Every single time. You’d think they’d have a complete solution to that by now
I feel like it might be an inside joke by now that they don't bother checking for bedrock until after the first snapshot of a new feature
the block or the minecraft edition
@@aguyontheinternet8436 eh either or
free advertisement XD
Maybe they like to give us false hope that they don't know about it and we can get away with it
Everything new that grows can break bedrock 💀
Always.
Thats what i was thinking
No not really, but it seems like every new tree mojang makes they forget to make it not break bedrock
@@Arvl.
Time for exploiting this before they patch it
@@Arvl. moss
Remember when bedrock was known as the 'unbreakable block'.. now everybody is just breaking it in many different ways
I do not remember when it was known as the unbreakable block, I remember when simple 4x4 trees were its weakness.
@@natalie6811 Even since Alpha versions, you could plant large oak trees or spawn nether portals in such a way they would overwrite the bedrock.
I think the oldest bedrock breaking exploit was when hoes were introduced to Minecraft. It was quite hilarious: you had to place a block of dirt under a block of bedrock, till that block which then created a farmland block (15/16 of a normal block height), in that tiny gap you just had to click with the seed and as the seed gets planted, it would overwrite the bedrock at the top.
It's Mojang's own fault. And it's the same phenomenon that's leading to all these videos showing how to cheese the Warden
Mojang: "This is Minecraft, a game without rules"
Players: 🏃 🏃🏿♀️
Mojang: "Okay, there's one rule."
Players: proceed to find myriad ways to break said rule
Mojang: "I don't know what I expected."
Now its just the "unmineable block"
Remember when everyone called gold ingots butter before it got old
When you think about it, roots in real life can exert a tremendous force. They can break asphalt roads, concrete pavements and sometimes even solid rock.
In this way, Mojang should keep it as a feature :D
Jokes aside, even if they fix that bug, new types of exploits will always be found. It's an almost never ending battle.
yh, but not with bedrock.
How helpful is breaking bedrock from the bottom anyways? It can basically only be used for breaking the nether ceiling, and we already have a million ways to do that
hey, as long as it only works vertically, I'm happy
@@aguyontheinternet8436 We have a bunch of variations of tnt-piston ways to do it. Propagules would be much nicer so you don't have to get 20+ cps to break bedrock with piston heads, which (I believe) is also only possible when you're above the bedrock layer.
@@arjunreddy9908 getting above bedrock is super easy with a ladder and ender pearl though
With great trees comes great power even if it's for a few snapshots most of the time
Here we again my friends, for another episode of,
When Minecraft itself breaks the rule.
are you a sheep?
@DON'T Ok.
Even than that, who cares about a bot spaming comment like this
@DON'T bot tf
New world generation stuff usually tends to be able to break bedrock
(By new, I also mean changes, because I've seen igloos that have been able to break bedrock)
Edit: Wtf are the replies
Also, Zeroth (0th)
First
Second
Third
Fourth
Fifth
Everyone: Bedrocks are indestructible in survival mode
Phoenix SC: *And who decided that?*
Not like it wasn't destructable before this glitch...
@sitiy 15 ok and
ik this is a joke but it was destructible even before this
@@KeaneJ123 cry about it
@@Satzy the bot i was talking to deleted it's comment, it was probably programmed to make me look bad
Plants being able to break bedrock after you bone meal it in the snapshots will always be a tradition now ig. It would be shocking it would be if they added like this that cant break bedrock at this point
mojang: *does anything*
pheonix: *this update will break minecraft*
🤣🤣🤣
Always all do
Thats why they are snapshots
mojang really went crazy with those new "weak" blocks
@violet💫 stfu bot, nobody cares anyone who made this bot, pls get a better job with your programing skills
aha
Bedrock: I fear no man, but that thing...
*Mangrove trees*
Bedrock: It scares me
😂
Anything growable: exists
Bedrock: My time has come
'Mangrove trees will break bedrock' how many times do we need to teach you this lesson, old man!
Name a more iconic duo than bedrock breaking and trees
Caves and fear
Plot twist: The Mangrove Tree was actually in Creative Mode the whole time
Everything returns to nature in the end
This doesn’t seem surprising as a button can hold up gravel, diamonds break on cactus and a pixel of water can save you from breaking your legs
Edit: ur replies are making me lose braincells
plus water in hell with evaporate immediately but placed in a conductive metal cauldron and it won't
Not to mention that lava can be inside a bucket and can drip onto the bucked but the bucket cant survive touching the lava
Hello
And squishing too many living creatures can create extreme kinetic energy
@@chwaterchearthchfirechair8254 True lmao
Reminds me of the days giant spruce trees broke bedrock.
Imagine seeing mangrove trees everywhere after you finally succeeded break the nether roof
Bedrock: I am indestructible
Mangrove Trees: *Let's put that to the test, shall we?*
Bedrock: **sweats profusely**
If MoJang doesn’t patch this I can see this being used as a new way to get to the Nether Ceiling
Tnt: *used to break bedrock
Mangrove tree: "Im about to end this man's whole career"
Man grew a tree and,
It was been grown,
On the first day of this land,
To no suprise of many,
It had teared itself throught,
The undestructible, unobtaniable,
Resting rock of the worlds,
Known by another name as,
Bedrock.
in real life tree roots wedge apart solid rock so its not too far fetched
seeing if it breaks bedrock is the first thing to test whenever a new item is added
By irl logic, plants can literally break concrete to grow.
I do actually hope that they never patch this lol
this is due to roots wedging apart the rock, causing it to crack and separate, exactly like what happened in this video.
Not like there is any real use for this, because the only place where you can put stuff below Bedrock is the Nether, where trees won't grow. Very interesting find regardless.
"you have enough variation to cause some problems"
I love that line.
You know, you would think by now they thought of this already
Reminds me of when dark oak saplings could break through bedrock
Mangrove trees do be lookin both kinda intimidating & fascinating not gonna lie
Everyone time they add a new plant, that works
(e.g.: bamboo, dark oak. etc.)
Mojang: Adds new growable stuff (Dripleaf and Mangrove)
Bedrock: *chuckles* I’m in danger
This would be be interesting if this would stay but we all know that this will probably be fixed and need to use the ender pearl trick to get on the nether roof
Not surprised because Bamboo also breaks bedrock in 1.14
Phoenix is really the news caster for new stuff coming up
Every tree breaks bedrock upon release, it’s like mojang don’t understand after each time they add a tree
Lesson:Bedrock may be indestructible
But Plants are INFINITE power
*Who knows a normal looking tree could be this strong!*
I swear I see you you everywhere
Why do I think this happened with Seeds, Bamboo, Dark oak, Moss, Dripleaf already? This has happened so many times that I think mojang intentionally does allow bedrock to break in snapshot until full release, only for Nether farm builders’ disappointment.
mushrooms
@@TiaNeedsSleep is that it? I’m sure to have forgotten few hundreds or so.
This is exactly how I work as a developer. First I make sure that the program does what it is intended to do, then AFTER that, I fix some minor bugs and start the bug tracking. Is the fastest way to get something working as least in it's minimum.
Well before 1.16 use tnt piston trick and when 1.17 and 1.18 we use cauldron snow powder and now we have magroove tree in 1.19.I wonder what happen in Minecraft 2.0
"Breaking Bedrock with a flower"
I swear. Every single time there’s a new tree…
What is it with Mojang and implementing things that break bedrock? Next thing you know, goats are gonna lead to a way to break bedrock
Phoenix: Don't watch this Kingbdogz
Him: I watched it
E
E indeed...
E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E.E
@@VoidCode I was actually first but I forgot to leave a comment and remembered to a month later
nooo why did you release this we could've broken so much bedrock
1 view and 15 comments lol
Lag
maybe if minecraft gave us a way to break bedrock this wouldn't be such a problem all the time
Now everyone is going to talk about this and 2 weeks after this video is going to be fixed
Idk if it’s gonna be patched seeing as the TNT trick to break bedrock has been around for awhile. Hopefully MoJang won’t care enough lol
New Minecraft update makes the game more realistic by letting plants erode rocks?
lol
Moss: "Who are you?"
Mangrove Propagule: "I'm you, but I can grow tall"
Meanwhile Bedrock: *nervous sweating*
I mean, paper beats rock
Honestly I was really expecting another sus joke, like the 'rare' tree is an amogus or some dumb shit.
every time a thing can grow up get into the game, it breaks the hardest blocks to break
Why is it that every time new plant gets added it breaks bedrock last time it was moss
literally every time minecraft adds a growable plant:
phoenixsc: time to break bedrock
New Minecraft Trees
mangrove
Seems like every new plant life that can be grown using bonemeal can break bedrock when first added
Pretty sure you can grow all the saplings with a block directly above them actually. I recall hearing that in a video I watched about tree growth
Why does every new tree breaks bedrock
DONT TELL THEM!
People who like getting on the nether roof: heh... *You just made our power stronger*
every update since 1.17 adds a feature that (at least temporarily) breaks bedrock
Plants are always the strongest thing in minecraft. You can literally drop 100 anvils on a single flower and have all the anvils break while that flower remains perfectly healthy.
PhoenixSC is the ultimate tester and coder of the Minecraft community, and not only am I amazed at what he finds, I'm amazed that he can make something as complicated as Propagule to Magrove Tree growth understandable. Don't stop doing what you do Phoenix, because it's excellent!
It's always the simplest things that are forgotten in coding and game development. It's the reason why basically every update, there is a new way to break bedrock, and then it instantly gets fixed. In terms of fixing this, you could make a blacklist of blocks, that roots cannot replace, instead of doing a bunch of different checks. But this is Mojang, they probably are fixing it, or have fixed it by now.
There already is such a thing, but someone at Mojang forgot to add bedrock to the list of stuff that the block can't replace.
Bedrock: *exist*
Mangrove:imah end this man whole career
The reason on why it work is because Grass type are super effective against Rock type
You got a point.
the mangrove trees being suspended up in the air like that looks like a insane looking giant tree spider and imagining it walking around the world terrifies me
At this point, every new feature can break bedrock in some way when it's first added
Plants vs zombies sequel
Plants vs bedrock
I am always on UA-cam right when he uploads!
1:03
Can't really wait to see amongus shaped root in pheonix's subreddit
The title isint even a question it’s just a fact
lol now we can beack bedrock with trees again
That broke bedrock edition
Bedrock players have two powdered snow bucket with cauldron.
Bedrock:nothing scares me
Bedrock:but that thing. . .
Bedrock:it scares me
I hope it stays this way….Most people dont realize the reason you want a hole in the netger ceiling is so a beacon will work……Its a big deal. Very cool
Phoenix, you can actually automate tree production, and it's ridiculously easy too. Just have a redstone timer firing dispensers filled with saplings and bone meal.
Dude Hide this video from Mojang... We want this in the game
Nice! good to see another bedrock breaking method!
All I'm thinking is how difficult tree farms will be with those.
I remember watching a wifies video talking about how bedrock was broken.
He said if knew trees were added, they would likely break bedrock.
And here we are
practically every new tree breaks bedrock, this began way back
I love how a lot of bedrock breaking methods are just trees/big shroom
For some reason, the video showed just a random photo that I have never taken instead of the actual video
neither bugs or glitches but features that has a rare chance of happening to limit the op'ness of it
What a beautiful tree, I think it’ll make worlds look a lot nicer by default
Well, you could probably break the other bedrock even more easily with propugules!
Now the tree is just gonna have a bed rock clock in its trunk
Monjang: (adds mangrove trees to minecraft)
Bedrock: my time has come!