The fact that most of the comments are 15 years ago is somehow heart warming. It just made me remember that life is a short journey and we live in our diffrent ways but end up the same.
This is the most honest and purest thing I've ever seen in all my years of film making. I love you for making this! Thank you so much, my eyes are lightened from burden and cried of course the Lord's tears. SS & DM
I have been coming back to this video for more than a Decade. It wrecks me every time, it’s so beautifully expressive. Nine years ago, when I was crying in the bathroom myself (the vigil in my sisters hospice) it came back to me again and again. It was painful and comforting.
i fell in love with this song the first time my friend made me listen to his ipod. A sister of mine almost died of caner, that's why I love this song so much
The imagery and story telling behind this film really breaks through the production limitations. In all honesty I thought this was going to be chintzy, but it really comes together with one of my favorite songs to create a very moving experience. Thank you for this.
My dude, I only heard this song recently and I was looking to see if there was a music video for it. Well done, you exceeded everything I expected to find
Thank you Jordan for this video. I just discovered this song and it touches me profoundly. Your video is delicate and sweet and fits the song so well 🙏 it gives me hope
That is the Best way that anyone can put the emotions of this song into A video, and i am not a very emotional guy and i teared up because of the video. you did absolutly amazing and hope you do more, ill give it a 20 out of 10 and 110% amazing
Man I love this song, im pretty much thiking about making a video like this, but yours is your awesome. I think you could act better, but the scenery is incredible, and it goes with the idea except thatI think that when she runs away, its more like a sad thing, still awesome. Maybe one day ill make something like this
The fact that most of the comments are 15 years ago is somehow heart warming. It just made me remember that life is a short journey and we live in our diffrent ways but end up the same.
Definitely wasn't expecting such well-made video when I clicked on this. Really good job!
This is the most honest and purest thing I've ever seen in all my years of film making.
I love you for making this!
Thank you so much, my eyes are lightened from burden and cried of course the Lord's tears.
SS & DM
I have been coming back to this video for more than a Decade. It wrecks me every time, it’s so beautifully expressive. Nine years ago, when I was crying in the bathroom myself (the vigil in my sisters hospice) it came back to me again and again. It was painful and comforting.
it is indeed such a beautiful video
All the years I’ve listened to this and you really nailed the images in my head.
Anyone who has memories of a loved one they lost. Really hits home.
Breathtaking and inspiring, brought me to tears a few times. You are a very talented filmmaker, keep up the good work.
this is amazing. exactly how i pictured it.
This is an amazing song, and you did a fantastic job doing it justice.
I just discovered this song. It's such an emotional song, definitely my new favorite song, can't stop listening to it.
I'm crying... This song, the cinematics... My memories... 😭
Brilliant Work dude, thank you so much
My favorite song. This video is so emotional
i fell in love with this song the first time my friend made me listen to his ipod. A sister of mine almost died of caner, that's why I love this song so much
great music video, i hope Sufjan saw this
This is my favourite song of all time, cant believe I’ve never seen this before
The imagery and story telling behind this film really breaks through the production limitations. In all honesty I thought this was going to be chintzy, but it really comes together with one of my favorite songs to create a very moving experience. Thank you for this.
This is beautiful
My dude, I only heard this song recently and I was looking to see if there was a music video for it. Well done, you exceeded everything I expected to find
The video beautifully and perfectly fits the song!
This is incredibly well made! I will never not cry while listening to this.
amazing... loved it!
Thank you Jordan for this video. I just discovered this song and it touches me profoundly. Your video is delicate and sweet and fits the song so well 🙏 it gives me hope
Incredible. So well done! Loved it!
You made my day....thank you.
That is the Best way that anyone can put the emotions of this song into A video, and i am not a very emotional guy and i teared up because of the video. you did absolutly amazing and hope you do more, ill give it a 20 out of 10 and 110% amazing
This is so well done. Lovely.
Really well done video
amazing
Great job
When I first heard this song, I instantly thought of that story.
Oh my god you are amazing! More people need to see this. Just...how? How did you do this? So awesome.
Bravo Mr. Carbtree. :)
Man I love this song, im pretty much thiking about making a video like this, but yours is your awesome. I think you could act better, but the scenery is incredible, and it goes with the idea except thatI think that when she runs away, its more like a sad thing, still awesome. Maybe one day ill make something like this
Love this!
I Cried. Anyone Else?
Every time!
EmileBea1 A share think it's... #4...??? hahaha i lost count!?
At FOUR??? yeah. Sufjan Stevens, I particularly like this video- the 'story'.
Beautiful & sad and the music & lyrics arranged together so well! Ty for sharing ! I loved it entirely!
EmileBea1
That is exactly what I would say about it too.
Yw !
:)))))
EmileBea1
;}}}}}
I liked this video cuz there's no I love it button
Man
The Fault in Our Stars...anyone?
Yeah lil to late but yeah
it should have been as Sufjan wrote it...two boys.
Wrong song, this one is about a girl. It's even that way on the musical