I'm very new to this community, so my choices were based just on what i could find on UA-cam search. When i revisit this topic or something similar next time I'll ask my community and do more rigor for sure. Thanks for the comment and constructive feedback
@@WhatCanIPlay. Sorry, I didn't really mean it to be criticism. Just goes to show how different our YouTUbe algorithms can be! But yeah, I do recommend that channel. :) Also Board Games in a Minute.
The legend him self! I had you in my list but couldn't find your 2023 specific games. I plan on doing similar concept but with alot more rigour for games of all time soon, I hope I can include you. Appreciate the support!
and to clafiy i mean top 10, since your guys video was top 3 i found it hard to manipulate the data to work with out skewing, something i aim to get better with in time.
You're welcome, I find it hard to just know what is good as everyone has vastly different opinions so this was made just so I understand trends better. Glad you liked it
Each commentator on the 9 youtube channels made a top 10 list, 1st place got 10 points and 10th place got 1 point. Every mention got an additional point. The full dash and data is on my website in description. Thanks for asking.
sorry i havent seen that, one but its totally possible its been done before. not an original idea, just how i do my own personal research for things.@@Ian-R-Wilz
@@WhatCanIPlay. Interesting, many have Hegemony as their number 1. Also many people have said that Apiary is quite mediocre. Very interested to try 3 ring circus
1. Why are some content creators chosen? You left out some big ones, though you say “I looked at all the UA-camrs” with some caveat that doesn’t apply. Maybe these are the channels you prefer? So it’s kind of biased and not comprehensive, but that’s what your caveat should be. 2. I thought your video would be more data driven, but the majority of your video is just reusing clips from other channels - did you ask their permission? Is permission required? That should be addressed in your video. 3. I would recommend BGG to be included. Seems like a good second step.
Hey, thanks for your comment. 1. Firstly, I'm very new to the board game community and for that I'm learning alot, something I do with everything is use data to inform me, so as with all my videos so far it has been answering a question I want answered, then I do the research into it. So put simply, I may not know of all the youtubers, I simply used youtube search and search for top 10 board games of 2023, and went from there, I started this back in December and was well aware new youtubers made their videos, I was chasing some to try include all, but frankly I stopped. If some day this channel takes off and I have a community and help I assure you more rigor will be applied. So it's a factor of time , resources and well since I didn't really expect it to get some traction bit of me just wanting to get it done. 2. As for permission, it's covered under fair use, if I had to ask for permission this video would never have come out. Ideally I would have been able to present the data and give my opinion on them, but I have not played them, so the video felt empty not giving some thoughts on each game, that is why I choose to include their thoughts. Again as I learn and get better at this whole UA-cam thing I wish for a different end product, maybe even a collab with them giving me a new unseen clip reexplaining their thoughts, but something like would be a massive undertaking and well frankly someone with my following would not be taken seriously if I were to approach. As for using BGG. Everyone has access to that resource I wanted to provide a new data set, as I value word of mouth recommendations from trusted sources. I appreciate your feedback, and I'm listening. I too want these videos to be better, but unfortunately I have a lot to learn both about boardgames, data manipulation, editing and youtube. I'm not an expert in any of these, just above average and capable at it. And that's the niche I'm trying carve out for my self. I hope if you come back 1 year from now you would notice improvements on all fronts.
Games that we love too play over and over again in my group are framework, dragonkeepers, saint petersburg, its a wonderful world, rebuilding seatle, san juan, gizmos, space base, jump drive, stone age, lords of waterdeep, hadara, trails of tucana, splendor duel, scout, five tribes, ticket to ride, five tribes, parade and caesar's empire. I think these are great gateway games that are still enjoyalbe for most gamers that I know. Welcome to the hobby.
In my opinion some of the best games of 2023 are: Thunder Road Vendetta Dune Imperium Uprising Unmatched Adventures Tales to Amaze Pirates of Maracaibo World Wonders Forest Shuffle The Witcher Old World has to be the most boring, ultra slow and long, expensive game I have ever tried and already after the 2nd play we sold it, totally not worth the time and money.
This is why I made the list everyone has different opinions, whilst this list is only 9 channels and about 15 different opinions, its crazy how they differ so much. This is why I love data, it whilst the underlining metrics are subjective when you wash it with more data sets, you get some stand outs. I hope in future as my channel grows i can increase the data sets to my community and beyond.
Possibly, then by your assumption this list has more rigor behind it as it would combine their amount of plays giving a more rounded view. But totally understand, as I grow I would love to increase the size of my dataset with community input.
This is a cool idea for a video! I'm shocked you didn't include ThinkerThemer, though.
I'm very new to this community, so my choices were based just on what i could find on UA-cam search. When i revisit this topic or something similar next time I'll ask my community and do more rigor for sure. Thanks for the comment and constructive feedback
@@WhatCanIPlay. Sorry, I didn't really mean it to be criticism. Just goes to show how different our YouTUbe algorithms can be! But yeah, I do recommend that channel. :) Also Board Games in a Minute.
@@biyukun thank you!
Hey some compilations here! Neat idea! Liked and subbed!
The legend him self! I had you in my list but couldn't find your 2023 specific games. I plan on doing similar concept but with alot more rigour for games of all time soon, I hope I can include you. Appreciate the support!
and to clafiy i mean top 10, since your guys video was top 3 i found it hard to manipulate the data to work with out skewing, something i aim to get better with in time.
Thanks for putting this together 😊 I'm subscribed to most of them but it's hard to remember who liked what😅
You're welcome, I find it hard to just know what is good as everyone has vastly different opinions so this was made just so I understand trends better. Glad you liked it
I enjoyed your video. thanks
Glad you enjoyed it! I'm thrilled this video is doing well. Thank you
How did you calculate the overall rankings?
Each commentator on the 9 youtube channels made a top 10 list, 1st place got 10 points and 10th place got 1 point. Every mention got an additional point. The full dash and data is on my website in description. Thanks for asking.
@@WhatCanIPlay. similar to what did for Dice Tower overall top 10.
sorry i havent seen that, one but its totally possible its been done before. not an original idea, just how i do my own personal research for things.@@Ian-R-Wilz
@@WhatCanIPlay. it wasn’t a video I just did it on my own and sent them the results. Was hoping maybe they would do something short with it.
@@Ian-R-Wilz thats so cool. I tend to make more videos that use data, happy to have you apart of the community you fellow data lover :)
Hegemony: Lead Your Class to Victory was the best game if you ask me, but I also havn´t played all the mensioned games.
That game came in 24th spot according to my data I calculated
@@WhatCanIPlay. Interesting, many have Hegemony as their number 1. Also many people have said that Apiary is quite mediocre. Very interested to try 3 ring circus
1. Why are some content creators chosen? You left out some big ones, though you say “I looked at all the UA-camrs” with some caveat that doesn’t apply. Maybe these are the channels you prefer? So it’s kind of biased and not comprehensive, but that’s what your caveat should be.
2. I thought your video would be more data driven, but the majority of your video is just reusing clips from other channels - did you ask their permission? Is permission required? That should be addressed in your video.
3. I would recommend BGG to be included. Seems like a good second step.
Hey, thanks for your comment. 1. Firstly, I'm very new to the board game community and for that I'm learning alot, something I do with everything is use data to inform me, so as with all my videos so far it has been answering a question I want answered, then I do the research into it. So put simply, I may not know of all the youtubers, I simply used youtube search and search for top 10 board games of 2023, and went from there, I started this back in December and was well aware new youtubers made their videos, I was chasing some to try include all, but frankly I stopped. If some day this channel takes off and I have a community and help I assure you more rigor will be applied. So it's a factor of time , resources and well since I didn't really expect it to get some traction bit of me just wanting to get it done. 2. As for permission, it's covered under fair use, if I had to ask for permission this video would never have come out. Ideally I would have been able to present the data and give my opinion on them, but I have not played them, so the video felt empty not giving some thoughts on each game, that is why I choose to include their thoughts. Again as I learn and get better at this whole UA-cam thing I wish for a different end product, maybe even a collab with them giving me a new unseen clip reexplaining their thoughts, but something like would be a massive undertaking and well frankly someone with my following would not be taken seriously if I were to approach. As for using BGG. Everyone has access to that resource I wanted to provide a new data set, as I value word of mouth recommendations from trusted sources. I appreciate your feedback, and I'm listening. I too want these videos to be better, but unfortunately I have a lot to learn both about boardgames, data manipulation, editing and youtube. I'm not an expert in any of these, just above average and capable at it. And that's the niche I'm trying carve out for my self. I hope if you come back 1 year from now you would notice improvements on all fronts.
Games that we love too play over and over again in my group are framework, dragonkeepers, saint petersburg, its a wonderful world, rebuilding seatle, san juan, gizmos, space base, jump drive, stone age, lords of waterdeep, hadara, trails of tucana, splendor duel, scout, five tribes, ticket to ride, five tribes, parade and caesar's empire. I think these are great gateway games that are still enjoyalbe for most gamers that I know. Welcome to the hobby.
I might have to give these a look, as this community grows ill be looking to you guys for recommendations so this is awesome, thanks
In my opinion some of the best games of 2023 are:
Thunder Road Vendetta
Dune Imperium Uprising
Unmatched Adventures Tales to Amaze
Pirates of Maracaibo
World Wonders
Forest Shuffle
The Witcher Old World has to be the most boring, ultra slow and long, expensive game I have ever tried and already after the 2nd play we sold it, totally not worth the time and money.
This is why I made the list everyone has different opinions, whilst this list is only 9 channels and about 15 different opinions, its crazy how they differ so much. This is why I love data, it whilst the underlining metrics are subjective when you wash it with more data sets, you get some stand outs. I hope in future as my channel grows i can increase the data sets to my community and beyond.
UA-camrs are overrated. They’ll play a game twice and never again chasing the hotness. Shame on you
Possibly, then by your assumption this list has more rigor behind it as it would combine their amount of plays giving a more rounded view. But totally understand, as I grow I would love to increase the size of my dataset with community input.
@@WhatCanIPlay. my comment of more sarcasm than anything lol
@@shortydancer fair
Dear Lord, seeing all those leftist board game, reviewers made me ill