Mini Cooper JCW: Is It Better Than A Fiesta ST?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 112

  • @stu1944
    @stu1944 4 місяці тому +5

    I've had both and currently have my JCW and its waaaayyy better than my ST ever was,build quality is 1000% better than in the Ford

    • @Madmini67
      @Madmini67 4 місяці тому +1

      This is what persuaded me to go with my 2016 cooper s , really liked the fiesta but as soon as i sat in the mini it was in a different class interior wise 👍

  • @ZappBranning
    @ZappBranning Рік тому +11

    The auto is superb if you put it in manual mode but still drive in auto the gears go right up to the red line it’s simply superb if you know how to drive it 😊

    • @90skidnomo
      @90skidnomo 10 місяців тому

      I agree!! This was the only car that has given me the smile and feeling like a kid. The gas was 1.4gbp when I had it and I always drew it in the city like a go cart. You can’t drive it like a normal car. Fuel consumption was the worst though at 13.5 average in the city!

    • @TailoringTalkMagazine
      @TailoringTalkMagazine 5 місяців тому

      I totally agree @zappbranning … I love mine… it does exactly what I demand of it and the handling is crazy in a very good way 😈

  • @Sparky-fv7fu
    @Sparky-fv7fu Рік тому +12

    Love my JCW. It’s an absolute hoot to drive and I came over from an M240i. It sticks to the road like s#+t to a shovel. Test drove a auto and agree with you Tim….. hence why I went manual, so much better and it still auto blips on the change down.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +1

      Ah glad to hear mate! Manual must feel epic!!

    • @matthewthompson507
      @matthewthompson507 Рік тому

      I was debating going from a cooper s to a 240i- how come you went the other way? How do they compare?

    • @mandismith89
      @mandismith89 Рік тому +5

      @@matthewthompson507 240i is dull compared to the mini and you will regret it, get a jcw instead :)

    • @Mark-rt6fy
      @Mark-rt6fy Рік тому +4

      @@matthewthompson507 240 has 1000lb extra fat, there's no way to compensate for that handling wise

    • @40kMuses
      @40kMuses Рік тому +1

      It’s the grip to the road for me…❤ and the twin turbo in sport mode ain’t so bad either…

  • @robb2520
    @robb2520 Рік тому +6

    Just come across both your vids on the JCW. Nicely presented reviews. I am considering a JCW and this has helped make up my mind. Great little car 👍

  • @leehouston5436
    @leehouston5436 11 місяців тому +3

    My brother bought a JCW and I laughed at him . After driving it I’ll admit it’s a fun little car

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  11 місяців тому

      😄 never judge

    • @leehouston5436
      @leehouston5436 11 місяців тому +1

      @@TimWilliamsHD it’s not fast , it’s not masculine, it’s not pretty … but it was fun

  • @140379ben
    @140379ben Рік тому +6

    test drove one a few weeks back and ordered one straight away, hoping to collect beginning of july :)

  • @Mike-hc3nn
    @Mike-hc3nn Рік тому +5

    Nice review fella need more of this. 👍🏻

  • @masidafloofyboi9960
    @masidafloofyboi9960 Рік тому +2

    I absolutely love your review of this car! I own a JCW myself and I can say you are exactly spot on with this car! Def subbing! Keep it up man! ❤

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      Thanks dude! Got another mini coming September so stay tuned for that one!

  • @Yes-um2xq
    @Yes-um2xq 10 місяців тому +2

    I like how you said this car gives you so much confidence and that’s true:-). Thanks man:-)

  • @thomashowson7393
    @thomashowson7393 Рік тому +4

    ive watched alot of reviews in my time on youtube and you make a good watch a can see you on topgear one day my mate

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +2

      Thanks man, what a great comment to wake up to!!

  • @thereallotharmatthae
    @thereallotharmatthae Рік тому +3

    Legend. You’ve got a great attitude. Enjoyed the review.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      Thanks dude, hope you’re weekend is going well!

  • @macpdm
    @macpdm Рік тому +1

    A good review. With a decent level of critique. I just bought a cooper S 2.0 countryman. And I’m really impressed with how it drives.

  • @thurstonlebruh
    @thurstonlebruh Рік тому +2

    It’s a lot better in terms of quality and overall feel

  • @JohnCarlyle
    @JohnCarlyle Рік тому +1

    Regarding the steering wheel buttons, that's why I went with an LCI1. Great review, superb presentation.

  • @tameracingdriver
    @tameracingdriver 5 місяців тому

    Nice review! I've had mine for a about 9 months now, it basically rained for the first 6 months so I never really got to know the car, recently I've discovered the traction button and the effect it has on the drive, which was way more dramatic than I was expecting. It really wakes the car up as you say, and I love it now.
    Incidentally, I've got the manual and it's huge fun, I'd definitely have it over the auto as a primarily weekend/hoon car. Auto rev matching is really fun and effective and no real issues with the gearing but I believe it is still quite short, but I like that as you can really use the gears.
    Most people seem to get them remapped, as far as I know mine isn't, however, the amount of power seems about perfect for the car I reckon, and there have been a few cases of piston damage resulting in a blown engine. The car has thumping midrange punch, and is about as fast as you can realistically use on the road without risking a custodial 🤣

  • @basedshirtsuk
    @basedshirtsuk Рік тому +4

    Considering a JCW, maybe I should go for the manual :)

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      I would if it’s you’re into more fun and don’t have to do loads of inner city miles

  • @MacLaw3084
    @MacLaw3084 11 місяців тому +3

    The fiesta st is fun but i’d spend the extra for the JCW, or just settle for the S.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  11 місяців тому

      Need to try the fiesta…this felt tad underpowered for an auto…

    • @GarroLegionofOne
      @GarroLegionofOne 11 місяців тому

      If you have the money definitely buy the JCW over the S, you will not be disappointed!

    • @MacLaw3084
      @MacLaw3084 9 місяців тому

      @@GarroLegionofOne Yeah. I have an 06 S but it’s basically modded to be a bit better than the jcw. I’ve also owned a Focus St; fun but not mini fun.

  • @Manu-Official
    @Manu-Official Рік тому +3

    Not my kind of car, but when I see one on the road I know the driver is having fun. Also seen some moving as if really not stock, I was surprised to see that stock does only 6 seconds on the 0-60. Mpg seems about right, would probably get 50 out of town and driven gently (but you don't buy one for that)

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +2

      Yes mate, it’s a great hoon! Mpg still surprises me till this day 😆

    • @mandismith89
      @mandismith89 Рік тому

      would be quicker to 60 but its fwd and struggles with grip

  • @petecroxford3277
    @petecroxford3277 Рік тому +1

    That was very good review, and I must say a honest one I’ve got one and I love it to bits looks like you enjoyed that as I do when I get in mine nice one buddy 😃😁🤣🤣🫶🫶👍👍

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      Thanks for watching mate, please like and subscribe!

  • @marvj8816
    @marvj8816 Рік тому +2

    Honestly, the car is really fun as is on the streets, but it needs a limited slip differential for spirited and track driving.

  • @bimmerflex5526
    @bimmerflex5526 Рік тому +1

    Very nice review Tim. Rapid mini you have there. Nimble, responsive, easy to park up. But… it’s your M4 content we adore more! Eh.

  • @tsholojrgaelejwe5854
    @tsholojrgaelejwe5854 Рік тому +3

    Comparing a JCW to a ford fiesta is wild business when I’m smashing both Golf R’s and S3’s without any tunes 😭😭😂😂😂

    • @40kMuses
      @40kMuses Рік тому +1

      Fiesta can take a siesta…

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      😂

    • @deadsheep1559
      @deadsheep1559 Рік тому

      Siick car.. I've got a spag leg, so JCW on mobility sound goooood to me 😂

  • @Hayden-jn5vb
    @Hayden-jn5vb Рік тому +3

    Could you compare it to a clubman JCW which has 4 wheel drive system.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      We don’t get that in the UK as far as I know man

  • @thomaswalker1258
    @thomaswalker1258 Рік тому +3

    Really good review. Looking in the market for a car like this at the moment. What is better a JCW or a Cooper s for the money

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      I’d say JCW so no regrets, depends how much is in it too in regards to price difference

  • @teggsy2165
    @teggsy2165 Рік тому +1

    Get a manual Cooper S like my 2015 Mini and tune and mod the air induction ect,no drama coming out of the JCW Mini here if it's piped into the cabin .Pop Pop POP?

  • @samuelhebberd6831
    @samuelhebberd6831 Рік тому +2

    We need some POV drives of the M4!

  • @peterselers
    @peterselers 4 місяці тому +1

    4:45 since years ago this car has the option of dynamic suspension, but is no adaptive. So, your feelings in sport or eco should be the same as the suspension does not change.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  4 місяці тому +2

      This one does. It is an optional extra when buying it

    • @peterselers
      @peterselers 4 місяці тому +1

      ⁠@@TimWilliamsHD this cannot be, the DDC option was fully removed in 2020-2021. You can simply check that in Internet, dynamic suspension is for free and is the same in any driving mode!

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  4 місяці тому +1

      @peterselers 😄 this one definitely had it mate..maybe it was register later but it was a mini press car so it had every option possible

    • @peterselers
      @peterselers 4 місяці тому

      @@TimWilliamsHD the LCI2 gen never had it. But in any case, new lci2 are now soft in sport mode because do not have the sport, nor DDC but have the new suspension. And you said right this is a 0 extra cost, as is not more expensive item than mounting the sportive one

  • @milandekkers2795
    @milandekkers2795 10 місяців тому +1

    I love the review. I prefer the new steering wheel over the older one. Thicker feel and the buttons don’t annoy me. Also the gearshifts feel quite beefy and punchy (different software?) nonetheless class review but love my JCW in all aspects.

    • @milandekkers2795
      @milandekkers2795 10 місяців тому +1

      Maybe one I don’t like, the fake typical BMW interior sound that is present in Sport mode

  • @roblanger5546
    @roblanger5546 Рік тому +4

    Great review Tim - I feel a bit torn at the moment, I have an M140i which is ace but I think the JCW would be more fun, albeit less power. What would you do?

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +2

      Totally different car to be honest, I’d have the 140i for power but at times the power outdoes the car, JCW is perfect in terms of power and chassis balance tbf

    • @bokiNYC
      @bokiNYC Рік тому +3

      You can always tune the JCW - I have DervTech Stage 1 tune on my '19 manual JCW and it's loads of fun, much better than stock power. I bought Wavetrac LSD for it, can't wait to install it.

    • @roblanger5546
      @roblanger5546 Рік тому +1

      @@bokiNYC thanks buddy thats useful to know 👍

  • @alisonsmith3817
    @alisonsmith3817 Рік тому +3

    Ran 1 for 2 years
    Great engine and decent auto box
    The steering is not great little feel and notchy
    I found when pushed on high speed corners it feels floaty
    I run a stage 1 golf r at the same time
    Miles better, planted more
    Drove a fiesta st mk8 and prefer it over the mini in every way,,
    Looking at both worlds and buying a puma st as think would be great
    Only 1 problem puts me off it’s a ford

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +2

      Brands are becoming less important nowadays man, more about individual products and what they can do I’d say..got a i20n coming soon what do you think of those?

    • @mandismith89
      @mandismith89 Рік тому

      puma st get boring after 2 weeks like all fords

    • @alisonsmith3817
      @alisonsmith3817 Рік тому +1

      @@TimWilliamsHD yes not been in an i20n yet but always gets good write up,, I’m a decorator so always opt for an estate thus golf r estate
      I use to run a caddy van for work and an m2 for my Sunday car but found as the work got busier never went in the m2 so sold up
      At least this way I have to go in the r

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      Yes the r is a great car, video coming on that too next week, got the golf r 20th anniversary

    • @alisonsmith3817
      @alisonsmith3817 Рік тому +1

      @@TimWilliamsHD sound job Tim always watch your video as good content

  • @David-ct7lu
    @David-ct7lu 7 місяців тому +1

    keep doing more of these

  • @soda5730
    @soda5730 Рік тому +1

    Great review, thanks Tim. Did you drive down 'Cooper Sale' Lane on purpose? :)

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +1

      Haha thanks and er, yes course I did hahaha

    • @soda5730
      @soda5730 Рік тому

      @@TimWilliamsHD :)

  • @firstnamesecondname5341
    @firstnamesecondname5341 Рік тому +1

    It needs a manual, the thought of an automatic on a mini 😩.. and now sadly you can’t get a full spec car with a manual 😢

  • @peterthwaites5891
    @peterthwaites5891 Рік тому +1

    Great car IF it had the manual gearbox... Problem is if i was buying one i`d also want a sunroof and that is now only available on the confugurator when you spec it with the premium plus package which comes as auto only... so i`ll stick with my Abarth 595..

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому

      Yes seems like the manual is the way to go, just can’t win with spec then 😆

  • @owenrackham5963
    @owenrackham5963 8 днів тому

    I love Minis and I own a 2013 R56 JCW, but the fact that this car does not have a mechanical limited slip differential fitted from factory is shameful. Even the fiesta ST which is ballpark half the price of this car comes fitted with one, albeit in the optional performance pack. Its my one gripe that lets this Mini down!

  • @stephanesilvaa
    @stephanesilvaa Рік тому +2

    closing the door on the glass 👀

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +1

      Haha did it on purpose to trigger my wife who does that all the time

  • @PhonesOnaDailyBasis
    @PhonesOnaDailyBasis Рік тому +2

    Stage one this car. get around 295hp

  • @bogdanbreus8700
    @bogdanbreus8700 22 дні тому

    regular ppl : Mini Cooper
    uk accent ppl : Meyney Cupah

  • @cass96100
    @cass96100 Рік тому +1

    Get the gearbox tuned

  • @roymilla6636
    @roymilla6636 Рік тому +1

    They probably faster than Fiesta ST stock on stock

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  Рік тому +1

      I’ve got a i20n so I’ll be reviewing that soon!

  • @Ghrolz
    @Ghrolz 11 місяців тому +2

    Get the gearbox mapped, problem solved.

    • @TimWilliamsHD
      @TimWilliamsHD  11 місяців тому +1

      Should be good out of the box but though surely

  • @goranmekota7540
    @goranmekota7540 Рік тому

    ACC is camera only - works better on low speed, but can have issues on higher speeds compared to a radar (or a combination of both ideally )
    If it is the new adaptive chassis it is a "passive" setup that should be always on, no the previous en that changed stiffness in different modes.

  • @bogdanbreus8700
    @bogdanbreus8700 22 дні тому

    regulal ppl : over
    uk accent ppl : öyvah

  • @zerocochrane1713
    @zerocochrane1713 Рік тому

    and 0-100km/h ?

  • @ENGBriseB
    @ENGBriseB Рік тому +2

    Keep it Manual mate it's a MINI.

  • @sprocket-YT
    @sprocket-YT Рік тому +1

    2:17 pointless take you get a manual & if you want more punch buy a used one & get it dam tuned!

  • @colors6692
    @colors6692 5 місяців тому

    Who the hell would pick a fiesta over the mini😂😂😂😂

    • @adambowman1812
      @adambowman1812 2 місяці тому

      Someone who has driven them both.

    • @janlala1710
      @janlala1710 Місяць тому

      @@adambowman1812that person would have to be insane.

  • @petercoyne8300
    @petercoyne8300 10 місяців тому

    Yeah just put it in manual mode your literally shifting it yourself too short