Exploring Southern Indian States' Revenue Dispute with the Center
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лют 2024
- In the recent development of the revenue dispute between southern Indian states and the center in India, this analysis seeks to delve into the matter from a financial perspective. The analysis is based on the amount of revenue each of these states generates through various channels such as manufacturing, taxation and other ways and how much of it is then distributed back by the center. The discussion then proceeds into the politics surrounding this issue. A particular emphasis is placed on Karnataka, where it is highlighted that of every rupee that is sent to the center, only 15 paise is returned. The descriptor focuses on the complaints of southern Indian states, the mechanisms of revenue generation, and the current state of revenue distribution in India. #IndiaRevenueDispute #SouthernStates #Center #FinancialLogic #Taxation #RevenueGeneration #Karnataka
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today UA-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va2A...
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
South India controlled population which north didn’t do .. we r suffering bcoz of north India policies ..
population is not just a paramter, there are other parameters as well, 87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
Population control policy will be in place soon
@@hariharana6285 india is union of states while karnataka is not a union of districts bro so think before saying wrong infos
@@cgma9 Karnataka is also a union of districts only, so why my tax rupees is going to some other districts in karnataka when the road of my colony is full of pot holes. This type of logic is very absurd and will ultimately lead to civil un rest and may be civil war which will destroy what every progress which south has achieved. Or you want that like last 1000 years when India was not under political unity when people from other countries came and plundered us you want to re live those same times
@@AnIndianify first thing karnataka is not union of districts, districts are divided based on population and area. Second every part of Karnataka is developing gradually unlike North and South. Third you don't belong to Karnataka, clearly you are from north. Civil unrest is not possible in civilised south India. If this tax division keeps on increasing You will see this leading to breaking of the nation in future like soviet.
As someone from Karnataka, I pay ITR in lakhs every year even though going with financial turbulence, at least I'm happy that our Bihari engineerings and politicians showcase bridge collapse every year and makes us entertained, no words to explain that satisfaction.
Why tamilian and kanadigas fighting for water can u explain it?
@@HiraLal-nj3wphow it is related to the current issue can you explain??... Btw that issue is bcz of the drought, both the states face water crisis and it's obvious that they fight for their water needs
What is this ya,think wisely we are indians
@@nationfirst19943 I'm a proud Indian, but there is no state in India today that is developed and every state is putting effort to improve itself even after 75 years, we too have poor people, bad infrastructure and remote villages that are indeed need of financial assistance.
I'm pointing out the extreme length of corruption in Bihar. This state had always been a cradle baby of central though it's still struggling is solely due to corruption and backward mindset of the society
No financial help can ever fix this state in any way, unless president rule is applied in Bihar for the next 20 years so atleast the next generations develops the modern mindset
@@darkl777 understood bro.But what we can do,vote only give answer
It’s evident from long time that south is and was more developed than north and it’s also to be noted that BJP hardly ruled in South 😁
But the south bjp leaders thinks otherwise..projecting their north ideologies here and sadly it is getting traction.
True..south is developed but have to live with this govt because they give more money to north.
So should be people of North India now say they don't want to use the good and services that are produces and designed in North Indian states. Yes we have to accept northern Indian states has a lot of messy states it has a lot of problems but saying this eat our revenue don't makes 100% logic.
Maxine..a fair allocation is the demand.Doesn’t it sound reasonable ?
Ohh what about 60 yrs congress rule?
I would recommend Railway officials in north states to strictly collect money who travel without ticket.
It helps to make good amount to spend states.
If they give education to North,this can be reduced.
It can be easily managed if some people don't bark in speaks that poor people are harrassed by govt. Or simply privatise railways.
do you say the same thing when chennai contribute much more to state budget but get way less back, this is a stupid argument
@@user-tk8ye6mi6u even education is a scam there. IF you appoint any committe to look into that scam, the committee will become a scam. If you appoint any judges to look into the committee scam, the judge itself will be scam-ridden. North India is scam infested. They are rabies.
States in the south are getting a stepmother treatment from the centre in all aspects even other grants,relief for calamities..etc.
The entire disbursement is politicized. Look at state of trains running in kerala.All old bogies are moved there. Central schemes are lacking...
are u from telangana?
@vsr3777 minerals? like what? What does South lack in that North provides? Water? What does the North provide South with? Labourers? One can only understand the foolishness of depriving ones own of employment opportunities as sadistic pleasure...your Godi/Shah Jahan dont provide employment, South does...u want to cut off the root of prosperity in this nation, go ahead, lets see how South and North evolve over next 1000 years..u will suffer and squeal..we let political/financial capitals sit amidst ur regions...and still u feell that we are indebted to North? Go look at the mirror and introspect the lack of knowledge and the IT cell stooge u have become
@@vsr3777south kerala karnataka lot of water and same deccan. South independent
FCKING spinless BJP cut all powers & finance of states and dont allocate any funds to Non-BJP states, they cut the GST collection share, cut approval for external loans for states, cuts FDI of states through all means.. Rascal Modi had openly asked Planning Commissions to cut & reduce funds to States as stated by ex-head of Planning commision .. Federalism at its worst.. South should unite to protect our interest else after delimitation we would be forced to get independence from BJP Bharath. Thanks to AH Rahul Gandhi South is also going to suffer why dont he resign from politics . 80% of South would any way vote out of BJP but from entire North if Congress managed to get 70 seats BJP can be over thrown but this can happen only if RH leaves out of politics and give way for a PM face.
We will except everything what you said, my only point is we need fret equalization.
Also all the minerals which comes from northern states like jharkhand or odisha, they will not sell to all the developed southern states. Let southern states import it from outside. We will see how many industries can survive in southern states. You will buy cheap coals from jharkhand but can't compromise when it comes to tax share.
What a hypocrisy.
I feel so bad that karnataka is getting 15 paisa for every rupee, even Andhra is getting approximately 1/2 of amount, which is slightly better than karnataka and Tamilnadu.
Maharashtra gets 7 for that matter and has no issues functioning... Freebies come at a cost of economic ruin and no one has to be an economy major to figure that out.
@@ShinRai1090 Maharashtra is concentrated on decentralisation, just like Tamilnadu, where development doesn't constrain only in one place,where if you see Karnataka, Only Bengaluru City was way more developed than other cities of Karnataka. While, Maharashtra has 3 metro rail connectivity and a Robust local train system in Mumbai, Karnataka has only 1 metro rail system.
Freebies also provide by Maharashtra govt to their citizens. Most of the projects in Maharashtra were sponsoring by Central govt (Bullet train project, Delhi Mumbai Industrial Corridor etc.,). But, when comes to South, most of projects were conducted either by PPP (Public Private Partnership and Both Centre and State govt, where Centre role is minimal,compared to state ones).
This is what we Tamilnadu were saying for the past 50 years. You people slept very well.
@@jeevanprasad1211 these projects you mention are infra and development and not freebies... We dont have free tickets / water / electricity etc... And we don't even need those since we know how it damages economy.
@@jeevanprasad1211 Rightly put!
the biggest fear of southern states is delimitation which will be a death blow to political representation in central
Some South chutiyas are soo intoxicated in Modi nasha, that they are unable or unwilling to understand what’s gonna happen after Delimitation is done, what happens to us if we don’t get our taxes equally back. They just wanna do Modi Modi and Hindutva…
Don't act so stupid. Every political party says that when they are not in power.
@@Maxine842 first of all read about delimitation process then comment . Then we come to know who is stupid
South voted for Indira. Their political choices are questionable and good if their representation goes down
@@user27455 North are voting for Gobar and gaumutra! It’s better we remove devolution of tax concept and take our tax money completely back and develop our states. Why the eff should we help these illiterate voters who can’t vote to a party which develops their state?
The crux of the problem is a lack of accountability of those states which are getting a lion's share of the pie. Yes. Allocate more funds, they need it. However, there seems to be absolutely no accountability of where the money is going because youth from these states still continue to travel out of state for better prospects. How long is this going to continue? The general lack of accountability in these states is taxing those who are performing well and that is the problem.
@@vsr3777 firstly, I never called Kerala No.1.
Secondly, I am talking about allocation of funds, not debts. Two different economic parameters. Too bad if the youth are running away, despite additional spending by the state govt on top of allocated funds.
Kerala gave education to their children, so they are capable to reach and survive any part of the world. They have wings hence they can fly
@@manuv6095You give wings but can't form a nest or provide a ecosystem for food and sustenance. Don't think bad, I'm from Andhra, we also face the same situation, we have no Capital city, no industrial base and no vision from our local politicians. All the youth from Andhra can be found where Mallu youth can be found because the home provinces failed in providing opportunities miserably.
Fools. This North south divide isn't a BJP construct. It is there right from 1947. Lazy North Indians
@@vsr3777 The students going our kerala is much smaller than Gujarath panjab andra telngana karnataka and tamil nadu. even when population is considered its much less
Ambedkar mentioned it earlier this kind of discrimination, he suggested to have second capital in South India and also mentioned northern states will over dominate as they have masses (number of MP seats). BJP is exactly doing same, they are showing Stepmotherly treatment where they can never win,
There is no incentive to give even a penny to south. People vote for Congress/left there and are rightfully given less
@@user27455 Are you not, boy! And you're getting to enjoy South's money so please be kind.
@@Sainthosh_ all money in south is generated by employees/ workers of the north. While kannad lungis and tamil lungis fight over water and the Indian state has to intervene
@@user27455why can't the north generate money in their own states? Though we have water dispute its a separate issue
@@ptpagalavan i seriously doubt the so called literacy numbers of the south. Proper northern states like Himachal, Haryana, Uttarakhand are much more prosperous than south, despite being landlocked. In the west, Maharashtra, Gujarat are as well. It's only UP and east India that's lagging, but they do contribute a lot to the nation in terms of army enrollments. The south was artificially industrialized by khangress by taking mineral wealth. Look up freight equalization policy
Im getting doubt whether he is MP of Uttarpradesh or Karnataka?
Modi he tho mumkin he
Do not bring politics. This is a genuine argument. How long will these guys ask for doles
Its not about doles. Karnataka is getting back only 15% of the central GST taxes it collects and sends to the central government. Do you think this is fair?
No votes, no money. Next comes reducing the number of MPs in South because they were better at managing population growth while the BIMARU states were prolific produces of babies not wealth, but they provide most votes for BJP
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
@@hariharana6285 Bengaluru is not developed on their own, river water is taken from karnataka, state taxes and policies benefit bengaluru and its in Karnataka for a reason. Most of the good infra is being constructed is around Bengaluru. Flyovers, roads, drainage systems etc. Remaining places also pays state levis for the development of city. Atleast 40 percent to 50 percent of benefit is returning back.
In case of coming to south states, getting 15 cents per rupee is pure devils job compared to others. I am not from Karnataka but I feel for them because we need to also see north karnataka. may be finance commission should reevaluate how its calculated.
Its been decades but still we are encouraging UP, Bihar, MP with their policies and people. No improvement or hardly any improvement. Should it continue decades from now. I am ok with North East because of the terrain and difficulty but other states should not encourage.
Gujarat doesn't have much but still see they improve a lot compared to other states.
Mumbai alone is better than every sambar state😂😂
@@johnnykillsallahrandirasul9763 then don’t take money from Sambar State. I am still Indian and I want to be in united India but southern states should be treated fairly.
@@JK-iu8rq cry chamcha🤣
It's time for south to stand up and ask its share or be independent. North India is new East India Company of India.
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
Back then banglore was built by the taxes of other places of the karnataka and also many people from other places of karnataka have worked hard to built banglore and still working in bangalore bcz it's their capital city.. Banglore is made by all kannadigas and later on people from other states moved there
@@hariharana6285btw what's the contribution of up and bihar to banglore???... Btw we aren't asking complete share of over taxes.. Banglore infra is so horrible , why can't they fund to improve infra by the same taxes?? And North people degrade banglore for it's infra by taking up their taxes
@hariharana6285 ariharana6285 your argument makes no sense.
#1 ..All Karnataka people are Kannadigas. Bangalore is part of Karnataka and whatever Bangalore brings in it should benefit Kannadiga's and the state first and then the rest.
#2 this applies to Maharashra too. I am not singling out that federal government (now controlled by BJP) need to make whole only for Karnataka. All BJP run states are not making a noise because all decision making is centralized and run by PMO and state leaders have no voice.
#3 All previous governments and planning commissions were fair and it made sense for the first part of independent India to share resources for collective prosperity. Did the poor states utilize the opportunity to develop their our NO, they squandered the wealth created by southern states and Look at Bihar, UP ,MP the uplifting of people is pathetic. You know why because they are entrenched is caste and hindutva which blinds them to look past those in the direction of development. On the contrary even southern states have caste but look how we put state first in developing cities like Bangalore, Chennai , Trivendrum and Hyderabad.
#4 , past governments have not given any free money to southern states because they feel for us. They have invested in southern states because at the time of independence southern states are already educated and are progressive to hold the newly build nation on their shoulders . There should be limit to the holding the burden. How long we should prop up poorly run states and this newly defined federalism which is against the True Federalism where all decision making is Centralized by a dictatorial Center.
People should remember India was formed as country not born from the beginning as one. We are loosely built neighborhood with common religion pre-British era. So called Hindu nationalist gonna to history and claim what they want selectively but why not acknowledge that if a nation can be put together on common ideas and it can also decide to move away if those common ideas are becoming so distant for its spirit.
Last Nations divide not because of just resource but also sentiments. In 75 years of Independence India has 1 south India prime minister who started the reform. We deserve MORE and we will have more and take more.
All South Indian politicians should be united in this
Define South India. The main question is if Chandra Babu and Jagan will raise this partially useless issue?
Lol ! Dumb ....and fortunately people like me from the south don't bite this bait.
This good idea for South india
@@jjrtaaasas Again, define so called South India.
Also we also want the kool aid you DMK people have, what is that?
I will close all of this nonsense debate with the iron hammer. The moment south stops playing the race card of being dravidian first and start being the indian second thats the moment you guys get to make the rules. After delimitation you have to get your act together or you won't be able to get out your state and go to Delhi
Mr.tejasvi Surya is speaking in BJP'S interest,& not in Karnataka's interest.he is BJP MLA ,so supports each & every centres decision
👌👌👏👏💐
I am from delhi and i am against this dividing the country.. But the questiin js genuine why states like bihar is gettinf money from hard earned money from southern states....? This is compleye injustice.... Bihar choose a minister like nitihs and expect tk get free fund? Better they vote properly rather than expect free money from other states
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
@@hariharana6285stop Spamming this bs everywhere you are just making it obvious that you are a it cell agent
@@hariharana6285 87% are lost your mind😂😂😂
Not bihar. UP IS the biggest problem.
@@coconutpunch123UP is improving... But Bihar still in the pit
The road in front of tejasvi surya’s office in jayanagar Bangalore is not fixed since a year. Can’t expect more from this lad
Ask khangress government in your state
@@rajeshbobba3851 the MP of Bangalore south is from BJP, MLA of jayanagar is from BJP. Beat that friend 😀
I am from Hyderabad, Telangana. Its disheartening to see the Tax fund devolutions favoring BIMARU states and South being given step motherly treatment. If such narrative continues for long, even a staunch nationalist wishing unity would favor separate countyhood for South. On top Northies come here and brood in a way favoring their state people making a mockery of localites and forgetting that they are parasites relying on the wealth of Southern States. Facts sting but they are as they are!!
Even after contributing this much money to north and some eastern states, it's ok till some extent, however spitting by chewing red pan on moving train or bus after reaching in south in intolerable, also some criminals activities, however they are hardworking agree but lack of hygiene by this migrant workers are intolerable.....
Telangana only gets 21000 crores. Meanwhile UP gets 2 lakh crores 😪
True...Bihar and UP are getting 10 % and 17% tax share.Time has come for a separate country for South.Then only North people will understand the importance of South India hardwork.After seeing data,this is very sad for South India....after giving 27% to these two states ,still there is no development there... Politicians are doing corruption...
Opposition agenda of divine and rule ..guys don’t get swayed with it
Let it be a data driven discussion only
UP is significantly bigger than Telangana. @@coconutpunch123
Tejasvi Sruya is the perfect example of a leader BJP wanted to come from south India who can prick their own eye with their own hand, who are termed traitors if done same act at national level.
Agree. I am from Karnataka. He is a disgrace to Karnataka. Being a Kannadiga he is shamelessly speaking against the interest of our state.
For them party and posts are first.. their state is second.
If you want Tejas to your state welcome no use waste body😂
just he is bhramin and santhoshi who spoiled karnataka bjp on mla election his selection..tejasvi is neither ABVP RSS BJP worker directly promoted bcoz he is bhramin
Being a kannadiga I’m proud about his words….if everything is distributed equally y don’t it could be done based on constituency wise and major issue is hindus pay 97% of the tax and compulsively hindus should get everything what they pay
We also want to ask the same question to state government, why Bengaluru gets less state funds even after paying more than 60% taxes and generating 70% revenue of whole state. Still we have big infrastructure issues in a global city.
Same Bengaluru pays highest tax to centre why don't you ask them
Is metro put in Bangalore or other districts you dumb ass
He is countering the question which you have just asked. People were not asking this question. If you ask then they will also ask. It's illogical for the states who can ask this idiotic question. If you have a family with four children, you need to feed all of them irrespective of how much they each make. @@channabasavachannabasava1183
Bangalore gives 34% revenue not 60% dont be over smart after Bangalore belgavi gives more revenue its north part of karnataka we not made population like up bihar ok 😂
Bihar and UP consumers are the real people paying tax for the goods made in South India. May be the huge consumer base of the North Indian states start banning products made in South India. Odisha and Jharkhand should stop sending coal, limestone and iron ore to the power plants,cement factories and steel plants of South India. Heck if they withdraw all North Indian people from going to work as factory workers there, those factories will shut down as there are no locals there who would work in such low wages. If electricity costs increase from the current 5-7 rs per unit to around rs 100 per unit in the non coal production states, everyone will go bankrupt at once within a single year. Forget your tech hubs of Bangaluru Or Hyderabad, no tech without NTPC (coal).
If this continues we may see a populist South Indian leader arguing for a separate nation
Karnataka, TN, Kerala, AP, Telengana and Goa along with Lakshwadeep and Andaman and Nicobar Islands may breakaway.
South India should be a separate and independent country
Bihar is a dump , no need to waste so much money on that state, instead centre should reward more to states which is giving money so that more revenue will come from them.
I am sure you will have the same idea about rich paying taxes, "poor people are dump, no need to spend so much money on them, state should give more benefits to the rich so that more taxes can be collected. " How about that?
@@rickycool6083No answer.This is Khangress tactic to divide India into South and north for Power. Cowards .
His reply: Noooouuuu 😂@@rickycool6083
Read dump as in "Local government is trash and doesn't care for its people", of course developing other states is also important but not at the cost of crippling the contributor. I think they don't want their tax money go to building a bridge which will be collapsed in less than an year @@rickycool6083
@@rickycool6083good one
We southern States completely deceived by Centre... Even at the time of disaster..... This distribution among states should not be wide variation
What is your source of information whatsApp Or Facebook
I will close all of this nonsense debate with the iron hammer. The moment south stops playing the race card of being dravidian first and start being the indian second thats the moment you guys get to make the rules. After delimitation you have to get your act together or you won't be able to get out your state and go to Delhi
Staring from the bottom , list of neglected south Indian states are Kerala, tamilnadu, Karnataka, Telangana who contribute taxes but don't receive the adequate share. There is no point in the federal system if you are deprived your rights . Unite and find solutions.
No, the West Indian states also contribute much more. And if that's the case, then Bengaluru should get the most and not the rest of the state. That logic must apply thoroughly or not at all.
first learn economics then start putting in the comments. the way you just posted shows how naive and immature your understanding is .
what if eastern states stop supplying the natural resources required to run the industries in south?what if they had refused to supply essential oxygen during covid??
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
Same happens to Gujarat and Maharashtra. Why aren't you including these states too. Looks like it doesn't suit your agenda. Reality is most of our shares goes to North-east especially Arunachal Pradesh to build Border military infrastructure.
Can the minutes of the meeting of the finance commision made public.
Correct me if I'm wrong. So if a state has no population control and the ruling party makes no effort to reduce poverty, they get more money?
We as southern people helping by contributing more money to poor states like UP, Bihar but what up and Bihar people doing early marriage before 18 and produce 4 to 5 childs per family. So Bihar and up people always below proverty clause until they restrict girl marriage age to 21 and child policy should be not more than 2
the money is not distributed not just on population, there are other paameters as well
@@hariharana6285all parameters are to be respected except the 2011 population
Do not come to varanasi then !!
@@vsr3777 You are not understanding point. It is not about BJP or Congress. The points you pointed out are so silly. Everyone knows the reasons why south state is more developed than north. So, don't tell reasons. Prior or post-Independence every region has constrains let it be south or north. It is not like that south people had gold mines and developed very easily. More or less, everyone is exploited by British empire equally. But south people worked hard to get to better position. Every state has cheap labor and moreover south people are buying metals from north states by giving money. They are not taking them freely. Coming to Indian army, even south people are also in army and protecting borders. Most of PSUs in south are because of infrastructure they have not because of sensitivity as you quoted.
Ultimately everyone contributing to Indian economy let it be North or South. The important topic is why North states did not develop in 75 years of independence where south states growth increased tremendously. Let it be any reason but still how many years it will continue. For example, in a family there are 2 brothers, one is little bit weak, and one is strong so strong brother started feeding weak brother. Weak brother eating without doing any work, but the point is how much time he feed him until he became strong after that he will earn, and he must feed himself. But if he asks strong brother to feed him. How he will feed he have to also develop at the same time.
The south people only concern is North state also should also develop like south state but how it is possible? it is not possible by giving hard earned south people money to north state. Centre should keep some stringent rules to these states and see every possible way to develop north states. If the fund given to north states not utilized properly what is the use in giving them. If the same funds given to south states. South states can develop more.
If south people, ask about money don't see it as a protest and make south Indian traitor. Every state has right to ask there share according to constitution.
Hope you understand. I don't want to hurt anyone sentiment it is only my view.
you do know UP is richer now than every South state right?
Iam a proud Indian from Tamilnadu. A heavy tax payer working woman who also earns for my rest of India. Divise politics is dangerous. Weaker child gets moms care. But, question is: How bihar and UP are using this money? If not for development, thats a huge matter of concern.
They’re buying bull dozers and building temples 😂😂
@@kkvjkumar i know Ram temple received huge whooping donations. Building temple is not bad, But, what about education, healthcare, women security. There is so much to it
@@madhubala7975 have you or know of someone personally that donated for Ram temple? If not, it is what it looks like 😂
@@kkvjkumar UP doesn't have coastlines, or much of the heritage infrastructure that TN or many other states have. They have to develop tourism in some manner, & religious tourism is one way. Why wouldn't the state govt want to flaunt that?
@@kkvjkumar UP doesn't have coastlines, or much of the heritage infrastructure that TN or many other states have. They have to develop tourism in some manner, & religious tourism is one way. Why wouldn't the state govt want to flaunt that?
If all the medias talk sense without taking any side, the politicians will fail in their gimmicks.
👌👌👏👏💐
When chart is made, it should have the details of all states. So that we can understand.
How much do Gujarat and Maharashtra get vis-a-vis their contributions ??
Maharashtra gets 7 and Gujarat 31 for every 100, Arunachal Pradesh around 4300
Maharashtra gets lowest and gujarat almost equivalent to southern states
Gujarat gets similar Percentage of Southern states.. even lesser than Kerala. Arunachal Pradesh gets highest percentage 4300%..
May be to Integrate Arunachal Pradesh into India and to build Border infrastructure to defend against China.
Please compare tax contribution of these states vs payback. Gujarat tax contribution is 93000 crores but gets 30% where as Karnataka tax contribution is 2.1 lakh crores , 2nd highest after Maharashtra.
They are getting less than average but they getting plenty of grands and central projects
GIVING 45% WEIGHTAGE TO EQUITY IS CLEARLY UNFAIR. OF COURSE BACKWARD STATES SHOULD GET MORE, BUT THAT SHOULDN'T BE OF SUCH WEIGHTAGE. BACKWARD STATES THEMSELVES SHOULD GET THEIR ACT TOGETHER & SHOULD COLLECT MORE REVENUE FROM DIFFERENT AVENUES.
Infact those backward states are backward becoz of the poor governance and also developed states like tamilnadu is giving job opportunities for those Bihar, orrisa, assam,UP, MP state people
Backward state is backward because you chutiyas vote for caste
We south indians suffering because of our efficiency... If we are inefficient like Bihar and UP we will get more.... 🥴
how does state send money to center
Is CGST being called as giving money to center ? Or states are giving from SGST part ?
Even the English raj did not loot the south Indian states, the way the Hindi raj has looted 😢
Where is Gujarath, why it is not shown, that is the issue
Pm of gujrat
Gujarat gets 31 paisa for every rupee they contribute. Less than Telangana and Kerala.
@@iqs_quommore than Tamil Nadu and Karnataka 😂
@@AI12321 One of the reason could be that there is no liquor revenue in Gujarat. If liquor was not banned in Gujarat then even by conservative estimates it would benefit 15K crores a year as tax for the state.
Gujarat is also investing heavily to lure Software Industry in the state. In less than a decade Gujarat will also be an IT and Finance Hub just like the Southern States.
@@AI12321 I will close all of this nonsense debate with the iron hammer. The moment south stops playing the race card of being dravidian first and start being the indian second thats the moment you guys get to make the rules. After delimitation you have to get your act together or you won't be able to get out your state and go to Delhi
Is this only devolution of taxes or does it include grants and all other devolution from centre.
I am from Tamilnadu and i can understand this division of funds as this is the only means by which an underdeveloped state like Bihar or UP can grow . But what concerns me is the difference of 0.17 paise to 7 paise , which is huge .. This is why it is getting politicized...
Totally agree but does it go to the people and not politicians pockets.
Bro it's not 7 paise UP gets. It is 7 rupees. Can you believe the real difference now?
how is this so difficult to inderstand if one guy makes 5,00,000 rs and other make 20,00,000 rs guy 1 will not pay any taxes but guy 2 will pay a lot in taxes so the ratio of assistance recived buy both guys is asronomical difference.
Maharashtra is the largest contributor...!!
Shinde sir is so innocent that he doesn't modi is stealing projects from MH. Fadnavis is a criminal who kept quiet when IFSC was diverted from Mumbai to gift city.
And what does maharashtra get lollipop 🍭 Thank you centre we will always remember this 😌
6.13 to 6.32....your share have increased even if marginally...looks at your southern neighbor Karnataka and be more empathetic please😢😳🥺🙄
@@vijayrangarajanramakrishna318What about Haryana bhai gdp per capita top5 Mai hai hme kya milta h so bhi batado
Beautiful explanation by reporter thanks from Tamilnadu
I am from Bangalore (accha Kannadiga) - born and bought up in Bangalore- Karnataka. I am fine with it because I am a Indian first and Kannadiga next. I want whole of India develop and generate trillions of dollars in GDP. We Kannadigas are determined to reach $3 Trillion economy by Karnataka alone. If politicians dont screw it up, startup ecosystem we are currently working hard on will enable and hopefully will generate $3 Trillion by my state alone in 10 years. Thats the goal we are working on in our state. Share the sentiment of all Kannadigas that we will happily contribute our very best to India's growth.
I am not at all surprised we in Karnataka only get 15 paise back. BJP thinks we are an easy state to bag within nothing in return as in real leadership. Congress as usual is full of corruption and could not give two hoots about easy going Kannadigas. Like it or hate it, I actually agree with the Southern bloc on this one.
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence, so stop ur dravidian cancer, i am from south we are indians first
40% commision by ur bjp was not corruption???? Let's remain dumb like this so tht union govt b it cong or bjp will.keep screwing us front and back 🎉🎉🎉
@@hariharana6285Telanagana gets onky 21000 crores meanwhile UP gets 2 lakh crores. Is this fair?
Stop this loot. Time is up. We cannit tolerate this anymore
@@hariharana6285 Coz Bangalore is capital of Karnataka and it is expected to earn more for states. Maharashtra silent cox of BJP . Next time it will join !
FCKING spinless BJP cut all powers & finance of states and dont allocate any funds to Non-BJP states, they cut the GST collection share, cut approval for external loans for states, cuts FDI of states through all means.. Rascal Modi had openly asked Planning Commissions to cut & reduce funds to States as stated by ex-head of Planning commision .. Federalism at its worst.. South should unite to protect our interest else after delimitation we would be forced to get independence from BJP Bharath. Thanks to AH Rahul Gandhi South is also going to suffer why dont he resign from politics . 80% of South would any way vote out of BJP but from entire North if Congress managed to get 70 seats BJP can be over thrown but this can happen only if RH leaves out of politics and give way for a PM face.
People who thinks logical , understand we the people of karnataka is not against any other state is getting more ... How ever we are asking simple question why are we getting 15 paise but contrubuting 100 paise ... The statistical distribution is unfair .... So people of karnataka is frustrated .... BJP is not taking seriously , In todays session as well the question was diluted .....
What is the logic behind giving useless freebies.
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
@@hariharana6285 Well said bro. People have to understand the cheap tatics of Khangress
Largest share of Karnataka's GDP comes from Bangalore. Most MNCs come to Bangalore not just for workforce from Karnataka but because they get access to blue and white collar workforce from across India. Many start-ups in Bangalore are founded by North Indians such as Ola, Oyo, Flipkart, Practo etc. Many of my north Indian friends from top IITs or IIMs have started their businesses or are working in Bangalore. Not to mention GoI established many institutions of national importance like ISRO, IISc, NCBS etc in Bangalore. They should exclude cosmopolitan centers like Bangalore, Mumbai etc before showing these graphs.
@@hariharana6285karnataka is not union of states like india so your shitty bjp logic will not work here😂😂😂😂😂
What about population of different states.
The best person to be in panel is Mr.. Palanivel Thiagarajan . He will not only decode but will also give solutions by getting crux .. like him several learned economists reformers are in India . But they should not be silienced for political motives.
Finance commission should look at the rest of Karnataka excluding Bangalore as a data point.. I am sure, it will be similar to MP, UP, Bihar (may be slightly better)
0.15 vs 7.. Only idiots like this person will justify this sort of discrimination and injustice among states.. His own govt came to power and did nothing to rectify.. He is indirectly promoting slavery..
That's thier state matter... Try to improve under performing state
@@DineshKumar-vd5dhohh thn, under performance of North states is also their state matter
@@sharathbyalasi5172 from their state money?look We are in 75th year of independence.. Still the state like UP n Bihar wants more money for their development? Then Who is to be blamed? Just for the sake of population? They ll choose leaders for just caste and population and move to South india for wage work saying no development. Grow up man. Think wise!!!
U not seen karnataka Ha ha🤣🤣 mysore ,Mangalore, hubli ,dharward,belgavi are more developed than up,mp,bihar capital of these state
Please research how much people from UP Bihar and Rajasthan contribute to the GDP of the Southern states and then put into the parity then talk about the data.
That again boils down to job opportunities, decent pay which those states failed to provide
Is the percentage of amount given through Direct taxes taken into account?
How about the cess collected by the Federal Government? Is the share of State GST released in full and within a reasonable time?
Who appoints the Finance Commission members?
Yes..so called Constitutional bodies in India have all been played/toyed with and made puppets in the hands of Godi/Shah...
Just one question. My tax liability for this year is around 4 lakhs. where can i come to protest so that all 4 lakhs is only spent on me?
All South Indian states have better social and physical infrastructure which enables them to draw skilled population from underdeveloped states, the moment these people step in places like a Chennai or Hyderabad or Bengaluru, they pump in more funds from their home states, thereby pumping up the economic activity in these areas...so the Southern States are already on a auto driving mode...the polity also needs to rationalize these factors as we're federally structured
Still do you think it's okay for us to get only 12 to 13 rs. for every 100 rs we pay...here in karnataka 200 districts are in drought and nearly half of them are facing severe drought we have water scarcity please at least give as 20 percent OF WHAT WE PAY
@arcaakvira-jb4zp the basis of distribution still remains to be Nehruvian socialism and nothing has changed much there...
@@jitmick NO.. it change in last finace commision because they change the population data from 1971 to 2011. that's the main issue.
pump in more fund from their home states? what funds are you talking about? Do you have any data points to show the movement of funds. Wouldn't it be logical that they send the money back to their home states after making a living in the southern states. Indian diaspora pump money back to India not the other way around, the same logic would be logical.
@KarunaRajagopal stretches of land parcels from right from Silk Board to KR Puram and to Electronic City will give you testament of how the migrant community contributes towards the state exchequer, go to any car/ 2-wheeler showrooms and see the number of migrants taking possession of their vehicles, if you happen to pass by Hosur Main Road in the morning, see the teens emerging out of the numerous mess of SG Palya and walking towards the Christ College, they have contributed significantly towards the economy and congestion around the area...the reason Bengaluru's more cosmopolitan is because of the migrants, it's the same principle that works with Singapore and Dubai...you may want to visit these places if you still need a 'data point'
But what is the incentive for states like Bihar to improve fiscally ? Phokat mein khate raho? They need to make these time bound and there must be KPIs or else this will go forever
I will close all of this nonsense debate with the iron hammer. The moment south stops playing the race card of being dravidian first and start being the indian second thats the moment you guys get to make the rules. After delimitation you have to get your act together or you won't be able to get out your state and go to Delhi
You are talking like the CEO of a multinational company even though you are not wrong. But, I do not think that this will happen in India because we have many poor people. How will they ever come up ?
Can some explain how does distance from richest state become a parameter ?? Everything other parameter make kinda sense
Problem with the devolution formula is it has unfairly given big 45% to equity and not considered revinue generating factor at all.
If equity reduced to 25% and 20% given to Tax generation, formula might be corrected.
Hade the state government distributing the same resources with each district.
if u research more, northeastern states gets more money then up bihar, but they wont talk about north east because NE don't provide that much political benefit in terms of seats to care about lol
Bro they r border states
NE states are small states
Even if they get more
Over all their amount is very less
But look at Bihar 7 rs man 😮😮😮
How far is this justifiable
Not only south Maharashtra and gujarath are also contributing more
How long Bihar is going to get more money yet they do nothing
NE needs special treatment for sure due to too much neglect from the past. But yes Bihar and UP will need to be restrained. I am use BJP will do well in getting Bihar and UP on track if they get to govern for next 15-20 years in these states. They will fix it.
@@xyzabc162 Bihar is a landlocked state, but it is a key reason why Indian labor is competitive against China. Bihar itself has limited potential, because it has no ports. Congress is trying to oversimplify this and it is wrong.
@@rajv9921 Your thinking is wrong. Bihar is landlocked and next to another populous state like WB. That's why this looks bad, but they are one of the key reasons behind our labor strength versus other nations. We can't be oblivious.
Last I check Maharashtra gets back the least even lower that Karnataka. How come its not on the list?
They are happy about what they are getting, if they fight then they come to this list
Look at Maharashtra buses absolute garbage😂 they don't pay salaries properly😢😢 look at Vidharbha and maratawada they look like African areas!! Highest farmers suicide are in Maharashtra!! If you don't ask it is your problem!!
Coz BJP gvmt !
I think it's because the reason tax money is high in maharashtra is solely because of billionaires there like Ambani etc from Mumbai 😂 . Many are in poverty there.
Have you taken as to who gives Steel, Coal, etc.
Just curious: the finance commission is an'autonomous body'. Who appointed its members? Somebody does, unless FC membership is determined by birth.
One question that always comes to my mind. For so many years when UP and Bihar have been receiving so much funds why isn't there much progress. Are the funds not used for development of those states?
Don't worry about UP, it is going under going a rapid development in the current Yogi govt and won't receive funds as such in next 4 to 5 years.
UP is developing fast... Thanks for supporting us.. we will return back soon..
And don't ever compare UP to Bihar now.. story is completely different now
@@pavanchitranshwe would be happy if UP and Bihar develop...but the only news we get from UP is religion fights and temples etc and also so many r@pe cases , murders etc....we don't see any news about development there. Only religion.
@@razee7869 biggest mobile manufacturing units..lagerst film city in making.. maximum number of airports in state.. maximum number of expressways.. first rapid rail operational... maximum number of cities with metro rail.. UP in December become second biggest economy crossing tamilnadu..Temple was our pride and we reclaimed it...South remained Original.. because all attacks by invaders were faced by north..
Shame on central government and part of people who like to eat others money 😡😡
Central govts have indirect influence on finance commission too, unlike the MP tejasvi explained. Please be rational to your own people
Can we have the same discussion on kashmir before and after article 370??
You guys are putting the fuel to the fire. You should also show whole India into perspective & that Maharashtra also comes in to picture... then the draught hit districts come into picture & you need to discuss in lines with building up the nation...🙏
Expecting north south division soon
Yes Maharashtra is largest contributor to the taxes in the country, but they don’t make huge and cry
So what.. injustice is injustice stfu
That's not true. Many companies are registered in Mumbai but have factories in the South. And their revenue & taxes are registered in Mumbai.
Exactly many times when regional Maharashtra parties have come to power they have put forth this concern, but they are usually in alliance with either BJP or Congress. That's why they don't go till Delhi to protest and refrain just to press political statements.
Because they get all of their money back
Maha got bullet train freight corridor
Cences not done how can they determine papulation
Same to the state wise revenue generated from few districts only but state will distribute to non generate districts also. If you devollute like this there also same figure will display. Then how can you generalized this issue.
What is the ratio till 2014 . This is congress divisive politics in any case if karnataka & TN has industry and factory. Bihar and other state can also ask why the industry and factory are there more not in northern state
you ask your state government on what they are doing to bring in industries
@@sindueugin9339 It is center govt policy which bring industry as they run the foeign policy whoever pre 1990 india has a closed economy but domestic industry and most of the PSU industry were created in south india
Why? Because of the geography so it doesn't mean all revenue generated by it belong to south only. Make intelligent argument because dividING is always COMES naturally to khangress as they want short term gain
South must go Independent Country. That's the only way to go Forward. We can have a system like EU or UAE
Not a great Idea ....
Please don't get emotional
@@alfrednavamoneyjebakumar1977usa federalism
Draft your plan and send to centre 😂
FCKING spinless BJP cut all powers & finance of states and dont allocate any funds to Non-BJP states, they cut the GST collection share, cut approval for external loans for states, cuts FDI of states through all means.. Rascal Modi had openly asked Planning Commissions to cut & reduce funds to States as stated by ex-head of Planning commision .. Federalism at its worst.. South should unite to protect our interest else after delimitation we would be forced to get independence from BJP Bharath. Thanks to AH Rahul Gandhi South is also going to suffer why dont he resign from politics . 80% of South would any way vote out of BJP but from entire North if Congress managed to get 70 seats BJP can be over thrown but this can happen only if RH leaves out of politics and give way for a PM face.
This fellow Tejaswi is representing Bihar and UP while being elected from Karnataka
Is it not a fact that for coal, steel, etc. rates were paid on the basis of freight adjustment policy framed by Nehry
I am from Haryana. And I am with the people of Karnataka. They should get justice. Why Bihar is poor even after 75 years of independence. Even after they are one of the largest state in terms of population. Because they voted for the bloody caste. Not for the development of State. Even now they want caste census to do more politics on the basis of caste😮. My State also gets 0.23 rupee for every 1 rupee of taxation.
But But But we don't want justice in the form of deviding my beloved nation.
87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence
BR is suffering because of WB. HR has the GJ ports on one side and NCR on the other. That zone is rocking! UP also taps into GJ ports and NCR, but it also has its industries and huge temple economies of Ayodhya, Varanasi, Vrindavan, etc. BR is stuck in the most populous region, where port states themselves are either failed (WB) or underdeveloped (OR). OR is now finally picking up and its ports industry will lift not only OR but also BR, CG, and JH. India really needs OR to compete head on with TN.
@@hariharana6285what is the reason?
Karnataka has western ghats in the western states where we cannot do cut the forest for development
We have semi arid land in the north Karnataka where we are pushing for industries but we need infrastructure for water.
ONLY the western ghats states and the north east KA semi arid states get more revenue from BLR
Southern Karnataka districts are ALL prosperous.
All we are saying is we donot want 50rupees for every 100 rupees we send, atleast make it 25rupees
@@vsr3777 You are right, but you jumped past the 1857. The British made it a point to destroy UP-Bihar during that period. It was a punishment for the independence struggle. 100 million Indians died within 40 years, mostly in that region.
As a Tax Payer I get nothing back. So states are better off
True 😂
We taxpayers are not getting anything while they fight for our tax money for themselves
@@unknown.m.eare you dumb?? You are getting subsidies , government schools , hospitals , roads , railways etc.
Providing more money to North India is somewhat okay for the betterment of the country... But the intolerable thing is the lecturing of bhakths to learn from UP...
Which states want to join south india?
No more. Existing states are enough for south india.
I'm from Telangana I want to know about MH n GJ
maharasta gets 7 for every 100 and gujarath get 31 telangana get 49.5
@@hariharana6285 I do not understand this north south divide when west is getting equal low in return
@@AbhinavBadagouniarey neekendhuku ra Guj/MH gurinchi..IT cell 10 paisa wale...Adani/Guj contractors ki veltundi paisalu ani..
@@shravankailasa8894 evadu ra it cell... Stats telsukoni matladu... Ollu onchi pani cheyyi pukatla paisala kosam wait cheyaku
@@AbhinavBadagouni pichi nayala IT cell ga..10 paisala kosam comments vesevadivi neekenti ra ivani stats chepali..mooskoni Kashmir Files, propagandas movies chusthu bathikesey ra bewarse
13:10 Most important point. If resources are to be divided on the basis of which state contributes how much. Then in all industrialised states major source of revenue is from few cities only. Like Bengaluru, Chennai, Mumbai, Pune, Kochi, Surat, Hyderabad, etc. So by this logic even within these states no revenue earned out of these cities should be spent at other places.
Is there any end to this *parochialism* ?
But the people working in those cities are people from the same state but from different cities. And also overall these states show development with the tax they get. But UP and Bihar is not showing any development. All money is taken up by corrupt politicians and used to even buy other politicians using money.
@@razee7869 These large cities of industrialised states are filled with people from all over India especially UP and Bihar. Second who said that UP and Bihar have not shown any development, see their growth rate in last 15-20 years. Third money is used by politicians everywhere and more so in south India, listen to Prashant Kishor on this who has worked with parties from all over India.
@@AmalTanIf Bihar and UP are showing development signs from 10 to 15 years do you think they require such a large share even now? Doesn't that contradict your own logic?I think Andhra Pradesh here in south which has poor development signs needs a much more share than what they have been allotted.
@@sreenathjimmy245 States are allocated funds according to FC formula, which apply to all states. Nothing arbitrary there.
@@AmalTan Then how come Bihar and UP which booming in development gets more share than AP. AP is worse when it comes to development and infrastructure. If the FC formula is true then I think it should have been reflected in share allotted results. People need more transparency in the allotment process and need to track all those parameters. Until then this dispute keeps on continuing which breeds nothing but more hatred among us Indians.
Not Just Revenue issue.
The southern states don't even have appropriate representation in the Lok Sabha also we are entirely ruled by Northern political parties and leaders. We want equal Representation in Lok Sabha
Suggestions for fairness:
1. It is time that all revenue whether it is in the Cess form otherwise are included for devolution. The BJP government has cleverly used the loopholes to increase central share over what the finance commission would have envisaged.
2. It is better if the central share is restricted to 50%. If it can't be done overnight, it should start at 60% and reduce to 50% over next two finance commissions.
3. No state would get less than 25% of the taxes it contributes, at the lower end. Which means 1/4. Similarly, no state would get more than 4 times of what it contributes at the house higher end.
4. With the above as the premise, let the finance commission arrive at a devolution formula. If there are excess funds, after the above devolution, all states should get a certain percentage increase uniformly, in the excess funds. If there is a shortfall, vice versa.
Dr K Sham Sunder
Tejaswi is cool in smashing out all arguments-mark of a learned man.Finall anchor resigns and says Ok....OK....OK.
He is a fool. Ask hime to read the statements of Modi as Gujarat CM.
Man, we are not 'cribbing'. We are claiming what is rightfully ours.
Why there is no talk upper badra project? Why no money for this?
It is bad logic, Chhatisgarh, Bihar, UP and other belts hold most of the natural resources. So technically if a power plant is in Tamilnadu, Karnataka etc. they get subsidised coal from these states through coal India and other minerals. Now that power is sold to TN public at higher rates, which results in better tax collection. Hence, when distribution happens it reflects in skewed distribution.
Y can't they built same plant in Bihar itself .it bcz of failure to controll population . Don't bring this false notion in people
@@vsr3777 to become self sufficient in all those aspect , we have to have our own policy that u don't leave. When I am paying 100 rupayee to central can't they give atleast 30 rupayee. Tell ur north Indian to controll population and increase literacy rate. Even north karntaka is poor. Karntaka has to utilses it's income on them also.
No idea about Tamilnadu power charges. Go and check power charges of Tamilnadu which will be less than most states.
Tamilnadu is not getting coal from north, it is getting from Indonesia and it also has neyveli. Foolish idiotic comment knowing nothing. For homes in Tamilnadu 100unit of power usage is free for all from last 20years
@@Sk43072 TN Wt. Avg. Power cost Rs 3.77 per unit, Gujarat Rs 3.66 per unit, MP Rs 1.77 and Maharashtra 2.31. Go check for yourself. People from TN worship their filmstars and politicians like God, at least other parts of the country are sensible enough to take calls on whom to vote. One family is ruling TN for now more than half a century and people still believe in what these guys promise.
Y couldn't they build the plant in Bihar....
I know this will get no results now, but i hope 16 th finance commission in 2026 will rectify this mistake
Edit: if financial commission is responsible then why take credit for budget and schemes, give the secretariat the due credit then
Kudos to this MP for his logic nd knowledge 👏👏👏👏
Can you explain sgst and cgst of on
Right justification by surya
South should never be a seperate country. Inspite of all our differences we have many times more in common. Even if we split off we will eventually merge back in one form or another. However this problem is real, most people here on ground level feel we are getting way less than what we contribute. In Karnataka for example we have high taxes for liquor, vehicles, property tax etc and this on top of all the other taxes but then we dont see government doing back much for us, our infra is still shit, we don't have big investments for tourism, manufacturing, educational institutions etc even if we have crazy potential. Our economy mostly runs and thrives on private sector. Government has seen this and feels they can divert these investments because we are doing just fine but that doesn't change the public sentiments. Acknowledge this before pointing fingers
Don't think lightly of these Political leaders.
They already did similar and divide Andhra and Telangana by the same logic.
If it goes another 5 years you will see it really happening
45% is on equity; but there is nothing to incentivize solving the equity problem.
South Indian states are solving this problem year after year and getting lesser contribution back.
However, states such as Bihar and UP are getting the benefit and not solving the problem - this amount is continuously looted by the government, and the financial commission is incentivizing to not solve the equity problem.
In all the FCs 1971 censes was taken into account whereas for the latest FC 2011 CENSES was taken into account.
Tejaswi Surya is being naïve when he says the Finance Commission is responsible for the devolution....but most importantly it is the Government that decides on the weightage of the parameters for the devolution.....that is a policy decision and is not in the purview of the Finance Commission.,....but one thing, it is not the current Government that has done this...it merely followed the earlier policy....
you are wrong completely.the weightage is decided by an independent finance commission which changes weightage based on the recommendations of all state Govts-central govt is not involved
I think you are wrong here. The finance commission makes recommendations and the government accepts it.
yeah but the Central govt will not go against it otherwise the states will be mad,i dont know any instance of Govts going against it.infact Modi tried it in 2014 but had to back off.
Don’t make guesses. The fact is what it is. Mr. Surya states the fact.
@@reddyuta Nobody nominated/appointed by the Government through the President is independent...the EC is also independent in theory. Still, in practice, it does favor the Government regarding the dates of elections and other issues...it takes the advice of the Government....of all the CEC's only Seshan acted on his own and no one else...yes the state governments do not have any say in the matters of Finance Commission but they can always represent the issues to the central government....which in turn takes policy decisions and no one can deny that.....
In a federal system the centre or fed tries to distribute equitable amounts to level the field as such . The problem is the more successful your state is @ that moment in time , you are punished for it because you are taxed more yet get less in return. A classic case is Detroit in USA , it's hayday was back when entire u.s motor industry was based there , it pumped out millions of vehicles for local & international demand , yet today - it's a ghost town full of crime & filth , do it paid to uplift other states but in its time of need no taxes from other states went back to it. Had it had a emergency relief & support fund from its taxes back then it's state govt CUDA dipped in to readjust from the automobile shift. Perhaps that is what India must introduce per state b4 taxes go to centre a portion collected must be held by the state but managed by tax office , part of that amount every 5th year can b give back as a rebate , or for flood relief etc , a state must also be rewarded for population control programmes bec - 4 wives , divorcing oldest keep marrying young fertile girls dat r uneducated to produce more than 20 kids per family , don't pay maintenance for ex wives - that model must stop ! Equity will never be equal no where in da world is it such !
This is so sad and Unfair, I'm with South Indian brothers and Sisters, they are getting penalized because of their contribution to Union of India.
Highest contributor is Mumbai in taxes , what does it get in return ? No logic on this divisive agenda of India Today news channel
It is a government ,its not a bater system to give you what you gave. In a government rich states revenue can be shared to poor states so that those poor states can survive.
Simply Rich people contribute much tax to the government than poor people ,do you want the government to give the rich more in return by cutting subsidies for the poor. Same applies for states. State which contribute much should be given much in return is a stupid understanding of economy.
Problem is bro whether these states receiving the extra funds from centre are really using the money to the peoples development..?? This process of giving extra funds is followed from last many years now..but there is no much progress seen...how long will the states like karnataka ,tamilnadu ,maharastra,Telangana ,Gujarat help the other states like UP,Bihar,madya pradesh,rajasthan...this year UP tax revenue is 36000 crore but it received 1.87 lakh crore centre....Bihar tax revenue is just 7000 crore but received 95000 crore....they are receiving extra from what karnataka and maharastra sends.....Karnataka tax revenue 2.5 lakh crore but received just 37000 crore....
Think u are an idiot...we pay taxes not to give to north states ..north idiots will again vote for Modi and pay 150rs for petrol..
All the coastal states had looted and exploited the mineral rich resource of Bihar up chattisgarh without benefitting them , why don't you talk about the freight equalization policy, was a complete discriminatory policy.
this is one of the reason behind backwardness and poverty of these states
Nothing wrong in it
But how come Bihar get 7 times more money but no visible change ?
Where are this money going in Bihar
@@MrImran2091 87% of the Karnataka GDP comes from Bangalore, then why Karnataka govt. distributing to the rest of Karnataka, why can't u use it in banglore's development itself??? It is a congress divide and rule tactic, Maharashtra pays the highest tax and gets the least, they get 7 for every 100 they pay to center, but they dont cry like these people,that is why we r country, we are in a federal system, almost every country follows it, not just india, it is been followed since independence, even congress followed it and bjp is continuing it, the population of UP is 23 cr. Karnataka might be around 6 -7 cr., congress followed the same procedure since independence, if u have problem with only proper utilization of funds u would have asked for the proper utilization, but not for separate country, the same congress was been in power for more than 60 years it is congress mistake not BJP's
Good explanation of the problem in the beginning 👍
I am from bihar. My father pays a couple of lakhs in itr. Still me and my brother need to move out of the state for further studies and job😢😢. Although, Patna has progressed very much in road infrastructure. 😊😊
Kerala is playing the role of Keereli Achu in this debate. Hiding behind the success of other southern states like Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Telangana and demanding more money to cover up the elite capture of resources in the state. Direct taxes collected from Kerala are a pittance compared to it's neighbors.
So dumb
I reckon you are a right wing Malayali, ignoring the statistics shown in the screen & ridiculing the State.
You are keeleri achu, and governor another keeleri achu.😅😅😅
@@abymicheal1You are also a righr wing malayali.
True. The Kerala state government was initially claiming that they were only getting 25 paise for every rupee sent to center. 57% is not that bad considering that it is the duty of the centre to uplift all Indians and so spend more on the poor. But Bihar... Oh no.
you got tejasvi surya to comment on such a complex topic. lol