Yuval Noah Harari & Ian Bremmer at The 92nd Street Y - March 2024
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лют 2025
- Watch Yuval Noah Harari's conversation with author and @GZEROMedia founder @Ian_Bremmer - in front of a live audience at New York's 92nd Street Y. Their discussion covers Harari's new children's book, 'Unstoppable Us, Vol. 2: Why the World Isn't Fair', the power of stories, disruptive AI, the war in Gaza, and questions from the audience. Filmed on 3 March 2024.
#UnstoppableUs
___________
Subscribe to Yuval's Channel, where you can find more captivating content! @YuvalNoahHarari
Stay connected with Yuval Noah Harari through his social media platforms and website:
Twitter: /harari_yuval
Instagram: /yuval_noah_harari
Facebook: /prof.yuval.noah.harari
UA-cam: @YuvalNoahHarari
Website: www.ynharari.com/
Yuval Noah Harari is a historian, philosopher, and the bestselling author of 'Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind' (2014), 'Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow' (2016), '21 Lessons for the 21st Century' (2018), the graphic novel series ‘Sapiens: A Graphic History’ (launched in 2020, co-authored with David Vandermeulen and Daniel Casanave), the children’s series ‘Unstoppable Us’ (launched 2022), and the forthcoming ‘NEXUS: A Brief History of Information Networks from the Stone Age to AI’ (2024).
Yuval Noah Harari and his husband, Itzik Yahav, are the co-founders of Sapienship: a social impact company specializing in content and production, with projects in the fields of education and storytelling. Sapienship’s main goal is to focus the public conversation on the most important global challenges facing the world today. Learn more about Sapienship: www.sapienship...
Yuval Noah Harari speaks internationally and teaches at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. On this channel you can see his interviews, lectures, and public conversations with prominent leaders and influencers - including Mark Zuckerberg, Natalie Portman, Christine Lagarde, Anderson Cooper and Jay Shetty.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
As a Muslim, I find Professor Yuval Noah Harari truly impressive! Your ability to explain complex topics such as history, philosophy, and current conflicts in an understandable and balanced way makes you an inspiring voice in our time. Your views provoke thought and help to better understand different perspectives. You are a great human being.
❤
He is not impressive he a joke
He's not impressive he's a joke
Thank you for exisiting, Yuval. You have made my life rich even in these horrible times. Rich with peace and understanding.
Yuval is a very dear man, may we have many people like him.
I am what you wish.
Thank you for this brilliant discussion. ❤️
Discussion? Monolog you mean. Brilliant? Mediocre should I say.
@@robertvanslooten9475Der Typ ist immer noch vollkommen verrückt! Hat sich in den letzten Jahren nichts bei ihm geändert, außer, daß er ab und zu sehr populistische Friedensbotschaften sendet. Doch kaum kommt KI ins Spiel, dreht er wieder vollkommen ab! Hacking your emotional System ist seine Faszination, da vergißt er seine salbungsvollen Friedensworte.😂
Wow, Youval what an inspiring mind you possess! Hopefully, you will inspire future generations and help propel humanity forward.
Not a single name drop
The capacity to distill historical detail-about revolutions, state budgets, humanity’s distant past-into its essence is astonishing
Harari’s intellect is unique and beautiful
If this is not the most profound and thoughtful views we have heard on current state of humanity,l don’t know what is! Love this guy! Finding analogies and correlation between Apple Vision Pro and theology, acknowledging our follies and how we behave in public vs private and concern for sentient beings! Wow!
Sentient beings like our fellow animals, aka our fellow Earthlings. Like Yuval, you sound like a fellow vegan.
@@someguy2135 not exactly a vegan but as Yuval says "Vegan-ish"...its very hard being a vegan given the use of butter, ghee as an ingredient in most of the vegetarian dishes that are part of an Indian cuisine. But one keeps trying to upgrade from vegetarian to veganism in the future!
@@deepaknautiyal7956 If you Google the question "Is Yuval Noah Hariri vegan," you will see mixed answers. I think he says that he is "veganish" to avoid sounding like he believes in religious like dogma or taboos. If you go to his UA-cam channel, he is clear about what he thinks of the cruelty of the dairy industry in a video about that subject.
@@someguy2135 yeh I guess he definitely a vegetarian but not fully a vegan, flexitarian vegan if that’s a thing. But yes his deep concern for sentient beings is well documented even in Sapiens. More people should read it!
@@deepaknautiyal7956 If you watch his video about the cruelty of the dairy industry, it is hard to believe that someone as logical and self reflective as Yuval could ever buy and consume dairy products. Once you value the feelings of sentient beings, that should hold true for other animal products as well. There are some animal products that probably don't increase the demand that leads to cruelty and needless killing of sentient individuals, but as far as I know that list is limited to oysters, and possibly other bivalves. Maybe he consumes them.
Yuval is a remarkable human. Why can't our leaders in politics be like Yuval? Well-educated, deep thinker, ethical, compassionate, honest and forward-thinking.
👏 🙏 🤝 👍 so true . . . but he puts them under immensely pressure and soon they have to v a n i s h (hope so)
Are you joking?? He’s a classic puppet of the deep state.
all politician know..but they not follow it because materialistic
👏
Because sadly he is a sioniste
Excellent discussion. Thank you both.
I am big fan of Yuval Noah Harari as he helped me a lot to get to know about our history... Reading his books is really privilege... My kids is really gonna love his new book... All the very best for your new book & it is going to be next success in your bucket....
Brilliant discussion. The interviewer asked excellent questions.
Yuval is a genius.
My Dad always told me that "You should put your brain in gear before letting the clutch out on your mouth". It has helped me with focusing the mind on what you actually want to say and also stops you jumping in with something you might regret saying.
😂@@DavidBrynjolfson
Good advice for Yuval who supported genocide last fall and is now trying to rewrite his own history. He is a con artist.
@@DavidBrynjolfson I hear drugs may help, but the crack rocks keep getting stuck between my teeth. What were we talking about? Any who, flowers are best planted in the Spring. The frog has a yellow flower.
@DavidBrynjolfson Same, sadly my clutch and driveshaft could need a repair, but my gearbox is still in prime condition.
Yuval..i really like to listen to you and you are a great, brilliant and different person in the world. When you said the key messages is that's humans created the world in which we live so humans can change it and I definitely agree with you.
Now, we talk about the political system, not teaching bioscience. Without democratic systems, anything can be damaged by the ideological dictatorship.
All of our bioscience students know what you are talking the creatures revolution history
@@IcebergHo-q6k firstly you didn't understand what I was said and secondly I know very well that this is not possible without democratic system and another thing any leader of a political system is a human being so I was said that human can change it. So think deeply before speaking.
Please be careful.
Wow, guys. Are we electing not to proofread our comments? Or is english a secondary language to yall? If you guys truly see Yuval as an inspiration, you might try searching for his speech regarding the "useless class", which I do believe you (as well as most of is) would qualify in his opinion. To summarize it, he is an associate of the board of the World Economic Forum. He climbed to fame by spouting radical malthusian and plutocratic ideologies. The sub-elite citizens of the globe have been essentially deemed as "worthless" among him and his other millionaire/billionaire goons. Thats the TLDR of the "passive eugenics" and other authoritarian agendas promoted by those pigs. Or to put it simply, they want a large portion of the world to be eliminated.
@@modera.torrent_ He's a good storyteller. I read his first three books with pleasure. He has some interesting comparisons. However, I like his thingkings about what he calls a worthless class, very doubtfull. In the first place, because it't very derogatory to a certain group of people. In the second place, because it's wrong to call them worthless. They keep being worthwhile, because they are consumers. In this consumption society they are necessary to keep things going.
In the third place, because in the assessment of historical events, he shows partiality. I don't think that a good charateristic for a historian. In the fourth place, because he neglects to mention that we're still hunter-gatherers. Hunter-gatherers of possession/property.
I think him very overrated
This was an hour well spent listening to an intelligent person, interviewed by another person who appreciates and respects that intelligence.
an excellent observation
@@ricklarson392 I agree (generally)... I only put the thumbs down to earn me some more 'Twix' from Elon... (Oh, excuse me, 'TwiX'....)
Do you actually understand what you are saying?
You’re kidding me…. Are you aware that he plans to eliminate most of the global population, place robots in the rules of the workforce for every job on the planet, and when he was asked what they would do with all the humans left on the Earth he said that in his book, the best thing they could come up with, was to just keep them medicated on drugs of all sorts based on what they liked and worked for them and give them video games it would not surprise me at all if Klaus Schwab ended up being the antichrist and Yuval Harari, the false prophet
Do you know who this guy really is??
#Harari is exceptionally brilliant in this conversation 👏 👌
Thank you both. It was an enormously productive discussion for me personally perhaps millions may feel the same way I did. How wonderful.
Enormously productive? Misleading in some ways should I say, though I think that not Harari's intention.
Wow, as always great philosopher living exactly in times he should 🤝🏻🌞🙏🏻
Thank you Yuval, for sharing such inspirational thoughts with us all!
We need more people like you Yuval , in the public sphere and in personal relationships. 😊
A discussion between two of the most brilliant minds alive today. What a treat.
Love this man and how he thinks! YAAY for peace and enlightenment on the planet if we just let go of our obsessive attachment to the past and present and just relax, let go and wake up and create a better life of peace and love for everyone! 🙏💖
Hi Yuval, it is good to know that you practice Vipassana meditation and also a vegan. I am also a veganish and practice Vipassana. There is hardly have anyone in my life so far who shares the exact same thinking that I do. By listening to you and reading your books, I feel I am not alone and not wrong. I'm following right direction. Thank you Yuval❤
His clarity is extraordinary! Thank you so much for sharing! Michael
I love you Yuval Noah Harari. You are the best creature on our planet. Wish you more enlightenment ❤
What a great man with a great mind and soul
Like always, astonishing, attractive and mind blowing speech by Yuval.
Take care 😘❣️
Much love and care from SINDH ..🌹😊
You're surprising me.
lol
Loved this, spoke a lot of sense and resonated a lot. Thank you both.
I love when Yuval spoke about they can get over the pain and fear if leaderships make the right decisions (speaking about Israel and Gaza). That pain seems like it will last forever in the moment but can and often subsides. What it takes is time ❤️ 💙 💜
I have been following Yuval, especially areound AI, for nearly a decade as our family works on Gaia's Seed. I sent this link to friends and family today and all of them.... all of them saw the connections. warmed my heart. Now that we are publishing Vol. 2 its easy to show people why we focused on the tween and early teen audience. We call the audience focus 9-15+... the plus is to encourage all adults to read it alongside their kiddos.
Cheers
I love this man! His books have given me answers and an understanding of our species unmatched by any others…He is the Carl Sagan of human history, explaining complex issues in such an efficient and effective manner.
Me too, I respect him, he is brilliant and genius, his thoughts are unique, I admire his discussions.
Read my reactions and think it over.
Yes, he is a very good and clear storyteller and sometimes an eyeopener. His interviews however cause shadow images.
Unless he supports a genocide!
@@HaDi-p1x he supports a less populated earth. considers most as useless eaters.
Thanks for what you do ❤
“I am also trying to take good care of my mind”. ❤👍🏼
I love this man ❤️❤️❤️❤️
And you know WHY ? IQ (aka intelligence ) makes you "s e x y" !
I always learn something new from Noah Harari. He's brilliant and insightful.
"The augmented reality of angels and gods" absolutely spot on.
Du Harari, j'en ai et relu avec grand plaisir. Bremmer m'était inconnu. Je l'applaudis virtuellement.
This is genius.Everyone needs to hear this.
Now, we talk about the political system, not teaching bioscience. Without democratic systems, anything can be damaged by the ideological dictatorship.
All of our bioscience students know what you are talking the creatures revolution history
Agenda 2039
We can handle anything but ourselves.
I think, compared with in a distant past, we aren't more developed. We got more complicated.
I don't believe in revution. In a revolution nothing changes in essance. It only goes on in a different way.
Wonderful and insightful! Thank you for making this talk happen.
Ian Bremmer = amazing humour, and he put it all into this interview. Very entertaining, and at the same time candid subjects.
Knowledge make our life better. If we just could grasp the ideas of this man, we can end all international and national conflicts. One can love his country, believe in his religion and appreciate his culture, while loving other countries, respect other religions and and interact with other religions.🎉
Knowing everything doesn't make you happy.
1:03:19 very inspiring reason behind his meditation practice. Taking care of his mind, the same way ppl take care of their bodies. It reminds me it's important to do both ❤
I loves this, lots of interesting topics!❤️
Such a great man! Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
All of the world’s leaders need to be sat down and forced to listen to this guy over and over and over and over and over and over…until they get it.
Nope. That is the last thing that World leaders need to do.
This guy's progressive batscheet crazy ideas are highly toxic, leading to the fall of humanity.
So enjoyable to listen such a knowledgeable and balanced talk. I also admire the ease with saying 'I don't know', 'I have no idea' without a shame. This attitude distinguishes intellectuals from the others.
Yuval, you are my hero! I wish you ran the world!
Deepest respect and admiration from this 72yo ex-Muslim.
😂😂😂😂😂yeap because you are sheep, 🤑🤑
He's an evil, sick individual. He doesn't believe in humanity and wants us all gone. Listen to him talking about what they're planning to do under the 4th Revolution.
Yuval, you are such a gift to humanity. One of the most refreshing speakers in a very loooooong time. Thank you for everything.
Harari has no compasion for the terrorífic situation of the Palestinians? He has not questioned his own goverment for having the Palestinians in guettos with hardly any rights?
“People are confusing politics with therapy.” - I am going to steal that turn of phrase. Such a great discussion.
Ugh we don’t need religion. People need a place to live in peace. We can have love without religion. Ask little girls you grown-a men. The crusades. Culture and cults.
Discussion? It has been a monolog.
@@robertvanslooten9475 Harari delivered good extended answers, while Bremmer gave good pointed questions and then got out of the way to let Harari talk. That’s the way these sorts of events should be. Nothing is more frustrating than when the questioner tries to be the responder as well.
Politicians need therapy because their decisions affect the lives of millions.
"Politics is the entertainment department of the arms industry" (Frank Zappa)
It is path breaking and insightful.
After a long time, I am listening to Yuval. As always he is a great communicator. If things are as bad as he says, the future is scary.
This is just everything every human being needs to understand in one video
Good evening Yuval and Ian
After two, three years of paying attention to our history and politic more than I ever did.
I remain wee bitty terrified but no longer shocked....progress? not really....!
We are going to require a St AI that's for sure. Thinking sooner, than initially thought.
Some stories do need writing, I certainly have a few to reflect and correct upon....story short!😀
Starting with Simple Trauma All-together INFORMED.
Our people, our knowledge, wisdom, information does need protecting.
Sanity sensemaking brain gym, thankyou for this.
Truly appreciate Yuval's work, too.
💜
A genuinely intelligent person, with intellectual integrity.
big fan of both of them. yuval is absolutely brilliant. Far, far ahead of all of us. His brain works different and from another level.
Yuval is such an inspiring, charismatic, outstanding human being✨✨✨
In which way?
@@guylenner1729 The question was meant ironically, because I Iike Harari very overrated.
Puke!
The best interview of Yuval I've seen... great job Ian!!! "Sapiens" is my Bible. I am amazed how little we know about ourselves. Yuval teaches us about the stories that we didn't know are stories... that we created, and therefore can change. For the first time, I understand what he says about giving your mind a break from social media... I'm finally understanding that I've outsourced my memory to Google without realizing it... the flood of information I get is wonderful, but it is impossible to memorize it all... and it's easier to just Google it when I (constantly) forget... what I just learned yesterday. But... this interview was a gem from social media.
Harari is also telling stories.
"Sapiens" is too simplistic ... but his HOMO DEUS is an amazingly intelligently predictabilistic 🙂
You will be better of with any edition of "Goofy" or "Donald Duck"
Yuval I LOVE your brain!!! :) My hero. This is awesome. I have your books on audio when driving, and it is such a delight to listen and learn how it gets me to think and motivates me to search for more knowledge and to study more in any topic, really. Please keep coming up with more content.
As usual, super smart, faire & humble !
Great discussion!
Monolog should I say.
He’s fantastic✨🌏💚
I agree. He has great fantasies.
Gret interview, thanks!!! If only more political leaders around the globe listened, to what he has to say, world would have been a much safer place for humans.
We are incredibly fortunate to live in Yuvale's era. His intellect and wisdom possess the potential to bring healing to the Mother Earth. ❤
„Humans making good decisions, building good institutions, formulating and believing in hopeful beneficial stories, ideologies“ 17:41
Recipe for the 21st century I want to live in. it’s hard but not impossible.
Yuval is awesome
Thank you Yuval 👍
I already watched this conversation 3 times. Yuval Noah Harari is one of the most important intellectual people of our times
So far i find myself agreeing with Yuval!!!!🙃🙏
Absolutely worth listening to. I thought that I would listen only for one minute and ended up listening the whole interview.
Thats nothing compared with reading his famous books ! Just DO IT !
Fabulous discussion. Thank you for the brilliant insights and perspectives
WHAT A BRILLIANT MIND ! ❤
Amazing interview.
Dr. David Hawkins MD and PhDz book on power vs force, the hidden determinants of human behavior is profound
Such a GREAT comment ! I own some of his books ! Life and game changer !
Fantastic!!!
Protect Yuval at all cost
He is an agent of German leftist.Don't worry they will protect him at all costs
Now, we talk about the political system, not teaching bioscience. Without democratic systems, anything can be damaged by the ideological dictatorship.
All of our bioscience students know what you are talking the creatures revolution history
At all costs?
@@robertvanslooten9475 LOL! you know what that comment means .. Clearly you just need some attention - There you have some . You're welcome! Poor baby ....
Go live with him he's a Dictator. I stand for freedom.
The right side of UA-cam 🙌🏿
Love and exitment when l hear that brilliantty expousure out of this world "genious", thanks very much l really engoy it!!!!
2 of my favourite speakers together.... awesome
History is the representation of events. Harari is speaking about the causes and consequencies of the events.
So appreciate a grown up conversation
Extremely interesting conversation. Thank you to both of the gentlemen.
Having ppl like Mr. Herrari in our times is a big boon. We don’t need to follow anybody else !!
0:00 Introduction
0:54 Discussion about Yuval Noah Harari's book Unstoppable Us and the role of stories in human life
3:25 Yuval Noah Harari talks about nationalism and religion and how they can be positive or negative forces in society
11:22 Discussion about the beginning of stories and how they are created
15:12 Yuval Noah Harari talks about the importance of questioning stories
18:22 Yuval Noah Harari talks about AI and how it is the first technology that could take power away from humans
25:22 Discussion about the speed of development of AI
28:12 Yuval Noah Harari talks about the vulnerability of democracy and finance to AI
32:22 Yuval Noah Harari talks about the importance of taking care of our minds and how social media can be addictive
39:22 Yuval Noah Harari talks about the importance of free speech and privacy
45:22 Q&A session and audience interaction
Ty
Yuval's books and talks should be made mandatory reading and listening in high schools and universities.
Why?
@@MrAndrew535so people are are aware of what he’s planning
Such a mediocre thinker…
They would be if God wasn’t going to mess all his and the globalists plans up. Oh well 🤷🏽♀️ 😆😆😆
Αα@@EdRomero312
Superbbb❤
Brilliant insights
Spot on! Humans are fighting for differences of their imaginary stories. 1:38
They're fighting because it's the sin nature. Wicked humans fight because they're at war with God.
3And even when you ask, you don’t get it because your motives are all wrong-you want only what will give you pleasure.
4You adulterers!a Don’t you realize that friendship with the world makes you an enemy of God? I say it again: If you want to be a friend of the world, you make yourself an enemy of God
@@livefree316 God does not exist
@@emma-lv7hnIf you say that god doesn't exists, you know as much as someone who says that god exists.
@@robertvanslooten9475 you can't compare knowledge ("know as much as someone...") by one phrase people use. Why would someone know as much as someone else?
You tried to write some wisdom? You failed
You see in your answers how and why they fight about their stories.
Wow, I love him ❤ 🇦🇫
good work
Such a fresh flow of wisdom, intellectual integrity, knowledge and depth!! The best possible spokesman for Liberalizm, even though some peopel are deaf to listen to Israelis as legitimate humans nowdays.
What Yuval says is what the Hindu tradition is all about. The stories of Indian mind, the puranas, the itihasas, the Ramayana and mahabharatha. But all the stories may have elements of fights but unequivocally sends the message of values, character.
What a fascinating conversation! Two great thinkers with a sense of humour…
I share Harari’s sentiments. I remember a conversation soon after 9/11 where I said something to the effect of “it’s all downhill from here”. Looks more and more like I was correct.
Different people may have different dates in mind about the beginning of WWII. For people of Czechoslovakia it would be the annexation of Sudetenland in September 1938. For Austrians it might be even earlier than that, in March 1938. While technically not ‘wars’ these events allowed annexation of a neighbouring territory under the threat of war. And they were enabled by the cowardice of UK and France governments.
9/11 and the subsequent invasion of Afghanistan set in motion a chain of events that has weakened the US, strengthened China, and gave Russia an idea to annex Crimea. Again the cowardice of western governments allowed it to go unpunished. And so here we are. In the midst of WW3 without most people giving it any thought.
Conversation? Most of all a monolog should I say. Great thinkers? 😂 Sence of humor? Yes, the interviewer.
Eliminate the lies, you eliminate the hate. Without hate, you get peace & prosperity.
Fan of Ian!
AMAZING
I've conceptualised a theory called "tool theory" that is built on the principle that everything humans create, whether in their minds, or with their hands or with both, for whatever purpose, is a tool. It dawned on me in my garden. This conversation adds more validity to it.
If you read Yuval's first book, Sapiens, then you will see that he gets awfully close to what you just mentioned. Somewhere in the earlier chapters, he talks about the first tools and codevelopment of language. Yes, it's quite likely that all the words and stories we tell ourselves are tools we carry around in our heads. What's more, they're like tools that can change our own stories and the stories of other people around us. Yuval Harari calls the transformation from regular apes to thinking apes the Cognitive Revolution. It happened around 120,000 to 70,000 years ago. We're not sure exactly how it occurred. Perhaps it was a slight rewiring of our brains. I think it had something to do with the rewiring of our brains and the use of fire. As we got warmer and our brains changed slightly, we were better able to spend the time around nice, warm fires and begin describing the world to each other in very old languages.
“The Bible is a good book, but it’s not the only book”
Love it. 😊
Two of the most insightful and valuable minds.
Bremmer praised murdering innocent Israelis recently.
Bremmer is a public member of Hamas.
Do you know so few people?
Genius😊
😢
The worst enemy of love is ego.
Brilliant