This and That: Team Tutberidze vs. Angels of Plushenko (Sofia Titova, Alisa Dvoeglazova, Yelim Kim)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 260

  • @ameliadettwyler514
    @ameliadettwyler514 3 роки тому +82

    TIME STAMPS
    SCANDALS/SUSPENSIONS
    0:30 - John Zimmerman suspension
    2:05 - Morgan Ciprés scandal: Vanessa James, end of career
    4:14 - Ciprés scandal: quite convoluted, no clear report
    7:57 - Definition of suspension, abilities for those who have been suspended
    10:19 - Ciprés scandal: rink management, coaches, who’s responsible
    11:00 - Ciprés scandal: new kind of discipline, less accountability in the past
    13:28 - More rink accountability, compared to education protocols
    15:13 - Russian coaching video
    RUSSIA
    16:26 - Novice girls: perception as children?,
    17:17 - Russian novice skating system: very developed and progressive
    19:15 - Sofya Titova: great jumps, questionable music
    20:31 - U.S. novice: unsuccessful is better
    21:02 - Russian Advanced Novice intensity
    21:30 - Titova: controversy, robbed of the title like Plushenko
    23:13 - Rigging scores: Titova?, adult skating
    24:09 - Titova: making the federation an enemy
    25:21 - Sportsmanship: U.S. philosophies and aversion to inquiries
    26:26 - Inquiries in gymnastics and figure skating
    27:40 - Children and parents unable to calm down, stabilizing role of a coach
    29:14 - Johnny Weir getting robbed, Gallina’s policy of not talking back
    30:32 - Interacting with judges
    31:42 - Aliona Kostornaia: criticism of leaving Eteri, owing Plushenko
    32:37 - Plushenko: Kostornaia owing him, needing a star for AofP
    34:09 - Overall impression of novice girls
    34:46 - Tano/Rippon arms, technique, Dudakov
    36:48 - Alisa Dvoeglasova’s centered quality
    37:35 - Lyubov Rubtsova’s jumps
    38:00 - Nikolai Kolesnikov
    38:16 - Arseny Fedotov: no Axel, great skating
    39:45 - Lack of choreographic creativity from Danii G
    KOREA
    42:53 - Korean ladies
    43:41 - Jun: pressure, coaching, costume
    45:44 - Timidity: gentle music, pastel costumes
    46:11 - Dave’s costume, the color purple
    48:28 - Liza, Muppets, offensiveness
    52:37 - Eunsoo Lim: rotations, energetic
    53:10 - Motivation for performing during COVID
    53:52 - Dave preparing for adult nationals: COVID, difficult program
    1:00:07 - Eunsoo Lim: beautiful quality
    1:00:38 - Yelim Kim: power and strength, beautiful jumps, flutz
    1:02:05 - Haein Lee vs Young You
    MISCELLANEOUS
    1:04:25 - Aliona Kostornaia/Danii G’s Billie Eilish program
    1:05:22 - Billie Eilish, Apple TV/TV+
    1:06:31 - Jason Brown 4S
    1:07:05 - Mikhail Kolyada 4S
    1:07:20 - Worlds!

  • @S80-r1o
    @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +43

    "Attention evil freaks!" is an iconic quote by mama Titova that I will now be using in every situation

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +6

      We all really need to.

    • @walterwyte01
      @walterwyte01 3 роки тому +9

      Great quote, in Russian it sounds even more insulting and hostile :-) Novice winner Alisa Dvoyeglazova is another russian skater with funny, speaking for themselves surnames - Two-eyed Alisa. Some other examples include Sofya Samodelkina - Self-made Sofia and less complimentary like Alexandra Trusova - Cowardy Sasha and Maiia Khromykh - Lame Maiia

    • @albinok21
      @albinok21 3 роки тому +6

      @@walterwyte01 good, that you've not mentioned Samodurova:-)

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +2

      @@walterwyte01 tarakanova has an unfortunate surname too

    • @denalihedgehog
      @denalihedgehog 3 роки тому +2

      @@walterwyte01 i also love translating figure skating last names of Ukrainian origin, like Mikhail The Christmas Celebration, Tatiana The Hair Heat and, my favourite, Tatiana The Evil Mermaid.

  • @alexjannik4249
    @alexjannik4249 3 роки тому +29

    Dave, the transfer window rule only applies to national team members, which receive the funding. Sadkova isn’t one, so she can switch whenever she wants. Besides, even if she somehow was one, she didn’t have a coach or a school prior to Eteri, she got coaching through Skype and was effectively coaching herself, notice how no school is mentioned when she skates. So there was no school or coach for her to transfer from. The reason they kept her region (Maryi El) when registering her for competitions is because that was the only way for her to make these nationals.

  • @Plaspos
    @Plaspos 3 роки тому +72

    I desperately need a second “parent’s tournament” to go along with the main contest at worlds.
    Team Russia:
    Trusova’s dad
    Zhilina’s mom
    Titova’s mom
    Aliona’s mom
    Team America:
    Vincent’ Mom
    Alysa’s Dad
    Team China:
    Nini’s mom
    Team Kazakhstan:
    Tursynbaeva mom

    • @Melissa-yr7fm
      @Melissa-yr7fm 3 роки тому +5

      And somehow, Nini’s mom still come on top! Momma doesn’t come to play...

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому +8

      The parents of the skaters who left eteri are vilified as much as the skaters themselves... which of course is part of the propaganda. Actually both Tursynbaeva and her mother have been nothing but sweet and appreciative of eteri. Which did not save them from being used for one-time point and then discarded with a back injury which will restrict movement for a lifetime.

    • @stulochealthdesipad4020
      @stulochealthdesipad4020 3 роки тому +14

      @@evamasters5028 Tursynbaeva mom reputation was not made by the russian, it was the north american who said that bcs of their coaching situation with Brian Orser.

    • @stsin7
      @stsin7 3 роки тому +1

      Don’t forget Lipnitskays mom 😅

    • @DeepSeas..
      @DeepSeas.. 3 роки тому +8

      You really left out Nathan’s mom? She and Vincent’s mom would fight to the death if put in the same room

  • @MrChaseBlue
    @MrChaseBlue 3 роки тому +9

    Thank you for posting all the Olympic Ice videos!!! Please post them from the other olympics if you have them. I’ve really enjoyed the discussions. :)

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +1

      They only did Olympic Ice for 2006. There was another version in 2010 that was not nearly as good.

  • @emilieleroux2595
    @emilieleroux2595 3 роки тому +28

    I loooove TSL on sunday evening ! Love you both Dave & Jonathan !!!

  • @haniakorecka8934
    @haniakorecka8934 3 роки тому +25

    Moment of appreciation for vases that keep changing behind Jonathan

  • @clcamden6489
    @clcamden6489 3 роки тому +1

    you’re always up on time as soon as i get out of my sunday shift, most consistent thing in my life tbh ✨❤️

  • @angelalaurent2324
    @angelalaurent2324 3 роки тому

    Dave-I laughed so hard at your mention of that solo ice dancer just sailing along in your practice video because I noticed her before you mentioned her in your segment, and I thought whaaaaat is that? Too funny! Loved this segment.....as always, you and Jonathan are amazing! You will certainly look heavenly in any Matieu Caron costume (can't wait to see it!). Let's go Worlds!!

  • @dkeinow
    @dkeinow 3 роки тому +16

    Russian figure skating drama on a lazy afternoon with a bottle of wine. I love it!

  • @ColonelGreen
    @ColonelGreen 3 роки тому +41

    In a better world, the judging controversy in Vancouver would have been Plushenko’s absurd PCS in the free skate.

    • @marianasan2148
      @marianasan2148 3 роки тому +1

      THISSSSS

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +2

      100%

    • @zb6070
      @zb6070 3 роки тому +14

      Both Evan and Plushenko's pcs in the short and long. The idea that Daisuke and Stephan were not light years ahead in PCS is the true emergency

  • @S80-r1o
    @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +22

    sportsmanship in russia is very... varied.... most of the skaters are pretty modest in interviews, and are upset at themselves when they fail, but ofc you have exceptions like Katsalapov, Plushenko, Slutskaya, Medvedeva, and of course professor Koslovskii and his iconic "get in line!" moment

    • @efimkrivov
      @efimkrivov 3 роки тому +1

      What do you mean as sportsmanship speaking about plushenko?

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +10

      @@efimkrivov he is a sore loser/arrogant like the other skaters i named :)

    • @FK_loving
      @FK_loving 3 роки тому +4

      @@efimkrivov don’t even pat attantion to such people. Of course Hanyu was wrong thinking Plushenko is a god of figure skating. This unknown person who perhaps started watching FK yesterday (otherwise had watched what “loser” could do) of course is right. In his or her head.

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +6

      @@FK_loving you ok? do you know what the term "sore loser" means? and I bet hanyu would be very disappointed about his supposed idol's man-child behavior if he knew about all of this posturing and whining

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому +5

      @ S 80: "Sore loser" for speaking up and standing for themselves? For not allowing the system to completely crush them and turn them into "single use cups?"
      I have noticed that people who kiss butt and suck it up the most, usually have the hardest time watching someone who stands up and fights. It is very painful for them to watch someone with balls win, while they have folded themselves to a spineless cushion to make the big boss's butt feel comfortable 🤣🤣🤣

  • @maria375s
    @maria375s 3 роки тому +1

    Love TSL on Sundays, thank you Dave and Jonathan!!

  • @alexjannik4249
    @alexjannik4249 3 роки тому +7

    Regarding arms aloft: Valieva on Channel 1 cup said it is harder for her to jump with arms aloft, so it isn’t necessarily making it easier for her. Tutberidze seems to like to teach complicated stuff at young age, so that they learn it that way and wouldn’t have to mentally prepare themselves for making the jump harder. Like how Kostornaya started learning 3A solely with that insane entry and only did it with that entry every time.

    • @arthurtheaardvark13
      @arthurtheaardvark13 3 роки тому +4

      I find that hard to believe... she looks like she couldn’t land anything without her arms above

    • @feyanormorfol2457
      @feyanormorfol2457 3 роки тому

      @@arthurtheaardvark13 Rippons make your jumps ungrouped, so it's much more difficult. It works even for single jumps.
      And it's much more dangerous, since you can't break your fall with your arm.

    • @MsRumex
      @MsRumex 3 роки тому +1

      Well, sure she would say that jumps with hand up is harder))) she would have to be very very stupid to admit that it's helping her))

    • @feyanormorfol2457
      @feyanormorfol2457 3 роки тому

      @@MsRumex How it "makes it easy", since it lifts the center of gravity higher and makes the whole structure less stable?
      It's these basic physical laws.

  • @sparkl121
    @sparkl121 3 роки тому +12

    Korean skaters (especially with Junhwan, with all that pressure of being the top man in Korea) have had it rough in terms of training- I mean, Jun was skating in mall rinks at times. The lack of both quality ice and rink time is ridiculous in Korea.

  • @MissFit29
    @MissFit29 3 роки тому +13

    The pairs medal result in the 60s had to do with the West German pair signing a professional contract before the Olympics. I think the Canadians (Debbi Wilkes?) went to silver and the American pair (the Josephs) went to bronze. The West German silver medals were reinstated 20 years later. But these were the days of Avery Brundage in the IOC and he was absolutely ruthless when it came to athletes who could be perceived as professionals and not amateurs. (edited for corrections)

    • @casandraleff4462
      @casandraleff4462 3 роки тому +2

      Kilius and Baumler were the West German skaters.

  • @vilmanord30
    @vilmanord30 3 роки тому +3

    If i understand the elements part of russian novice competitions correctly there are two parts the steps and spinns part where they skate a short version of a program with only steps and spinns but no jumps etc. The program is judged only on the elements performed but not PCS. The second part is the jumps part here they perform one solo jump and one combination and they get two attempts at both where only the highest scoring attempt is counted. (Thats why some skaters will change the jumps between the two different attempts. They might play it safe in the first attempt and if that goes acording to plan try some more difficult jump the second time.) In the end the total score for the jump, jump combo, spinns and step sequence are added up and then multiplied by two (so that it has approximately the same weight as the short program in the final score).

  • @atiz4073
    @atiz4073 3 роки тому +8

    41:50 Elena Kostyleva, the silver medalist in Younger Age is an Eteri student. She also transferred recently (but was coached by Eteri once before as well, I think). She's also an incredible talent at only 9 years old. She actually won both the Short and the Free but lost the competition because of the Elements segment.

  • @S80-r1o
    @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +16

    "If I go to hell, at least I'll be with all my friends :3" the "if" isn't necessary Morgan xxxx

    • @evanperilstein5308
      @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +1

      Unfortunately, there might not be a hell. There might not be any punishment or repercussions for people who get away with bad stuff in this life.

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +3

      @@evanperilstein5308 that goes without saying

    • @evanperilstein5308
      @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +1

      @@S80-r1o A lot of people 100% believe in hell, so I wouldn’t say it’s obvious. I mentioned it to point out how unfair life is. There is currently a movement to make criminal justice about rehabilitation rather than punishment, but we should still try to punish people for their bad deeds in case there is no hell.

  • @leasampson7753
    @leasampson7753 3 роки тому +8

    Have also started to think that rippons may assist in quick rotation when using certain jump techniques

    • @benbailey159bb
      @benbailey159bb 3 роки тому +3

      They do. It's like when you do a cross-toe spin, raising your arms up increases your rotation

    • @evanperilstein5308
      @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +1

      Rippons make the body more aerodynamic.

  • @nightowly8845
    @nightowly8845 3 роки тому +7

    Love the Krigor mug. So tasteful and subtle. Hold it higher! ⭐️❤️ 😃

  • @mikeokubo7061
    @mikeokubo7061 3 роки тому +3

    Can someone tell me the back story with the Pogorilaya’s abusive coach thing??

  • @arianagrymski2692
    @arianagrymski2692 3 роки тому +2

    34:30 “a LITTLE bit of the Valieva tug in the combos?” Maybe like a LOT?? 🤣🤣🤣

  • @jessicabruni2535
    @jessicabruni2535 3 роки тому +5

    Dave, you’re so lucky to be working with Galina. Wish you the best with your programs🤞🏻🌟. Thank you both for your great videos.

  • @bookreader7506
    @bookreader7506 3 роки тому +21

    The level of FS!
    Other countries: Talking about the National teams
    Russia: Talking about the novices... 😎

  • @amberelibrennan
    @amberelibrennan 3 роки тому +2

    A recent judging change request that I remember is 2013 Canadian nationals where Alaine Chartrand’s 3Lz+1Lo+3S was judged as a sequence (seq) & not a combo & that was the differerence between 3rd & 4th. Once that mistake was fixed she won the bronze instead of Amelie Lacoste.

  • @ddjr6673
    @ddjr6673 3 роки тому

    Great coverage yet again. Perfect blend of journalism, knowledge and laid back humour. Thank you so much.

  • @Cooltiger28
    @Cooltiger28 3 роки тому +9

    FUN DAY Sunday. !!! Love Dave & Jonathan. TSL

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +1

    • @walterwyte01
      @walterwyte01 3 роки тому

      In Russian top sport edition "Sport-Express" they printed an article titled "American Expert Criticized Choreographer Gleikhengauz" quoting Jonathan's skepticism of some of Danny G's choreo details. Though the journalists covering FS columns in this edition are known for their proPlushenko-antiEterian approach and are suspected to be on payroll of Plushenko family, it was still funny to find Jonothan's expertize from this video there :)

    • @Cooltiger28
      @Cooltiger28 3 роки тому

      @@walterwyte01 I agree. I love Plushenko. I am not a big fan of Eterie any more i feel that she is making convey of young ladies only last for two years and then gone. Look at Medeveda and Zargeotva. They both have injuries' and I do not like how they are not using there legs to take off instead using there core.

  • @dkeinow
    @dkeinow 3 роки тому +11

    When is the Eteri show anyway? I am interested to see Kostornaia skate as well.

  • @evanperilstein5308
    @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +10

    I do think the rippon stretches the body and makes it more aerodynamic, thus quicker rotation. I'm willing to bet that once Valieva goes through puberty and is no longer a stick with no hips or breasts, she will no longer be able to do the 3A.

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +2

      Her chest has kicked in months ago

    • @evanperilstein5308
      @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +3

      @@chocolateperfume752 She is only at the beginning of puberty. She doesn’t have hips yet.

  • @Askhat08
    @Askhat08 3 роки тому +15

    Sofia's accusations are false btw, her jump cascade was 7 seconds before the bonus zone. Hello from Russia!

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +2

      It is a comment timing error and something to learn from.

  • @chocolateperfume752
    @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +14

    "Titova proclaimed she was robbed just like her coach evgeni plushenko at the Vancouver olympics "😂😂😂 u guys know how to spice it up

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +1

      titova didn't proclaim anything, her mother/yana/pluskenko did

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому

      @@S80-r1o ik.... I'm quoting what they wrote in the description box

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому

      @@chocolateperfume752 why did you edit your comment to add quotations after i replied sksksksk

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +5

      @@S80-r1o well yeah, so I don't get another reply saying the same thing

  • @michaelcraig666
    @michaelcraig666 3 роки тому +4

    As usual, I think you two got all the serious stuff correct, but your banter game was in a higher gear: the Moscow Chuckie Cheese bit was inspired! "No ranch dressing!"

  • @kellymoran7001
    @kellymoran7001 3 роки тому +10

    the Russian novice drama is next level! such a close comp between titova and dvoeglazova. titova was clean but her movements are extremely rushed and unpolished. i find her a bit frantic to watch and wish she would hold her positions. even though dvoeglazova fell on her quad toe, she is still a much more skilled skater and had higher levels on her spins. i think the result is fair - it’s been sort of unbelievable to see Plushenko put the corruption in this novice competition on the same level of his (arguably deserved) Olympic defeat. but that’s why we love Russia 🙂

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +5

      He is so perfect for this level of drama.

    • @benbailey159bb
      @benbailey159bb 3 роки тому +12

      Plushenko moaning that he didn't win annoys me. He lost by 1.43:
      A) He didn't bother doing a three jump combo and if he had, if he'd just put a 2Lo on the end of one of the combo's then he'd have won.
      B) He only did five types of triples. If he'd done a 3F instead of the 2A then he'd have won.
      C) He chose to only do one 4T, he could have done two, if had he'd have won.
      D) He chose to put only three jumps in the second half for the bonus, if he'd done five like Lysacheck then he'd have won.
      He has no one to blame but himself!

  • @biggestgymfan7230
    @biggestgymfan7230 3 роки тому +35

    I really think they should ban quads in novice why does a 11-12 year olds need to do quads

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому +16

      I completely agree. Even at junior level quads are questionable since the female skaters will unlearn and relearn them post puberty, not to speak of the toll on the bodies of these young skaters.

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +11

      I think we may very well see that they are not sustainable and only injure the skaters.

    • @iris7484
      @iris7484 3 роки тому +4

      yep the "career peak at 16" is becoming a self fulfilling prophecy.

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому +8

      "They don't need to last past 15. The Russians seem able to delay puberty until then." Exactly. The question is if the sport would survive this approach, not the Russian skaters, who will not understand that they were disposable cups, groomed for one season of glory before being discarded. Not to speak about the tens of kids, who wreck their health, but are not strong enough or lucky enough. Are you interested in watching a sport in which a 15 wins only to be replaced by the next 15 year produced in the same factory? Skating a program they don't understand, like Bolero? I am not.

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +1

      @@lindaleighton lol describing certain someone, huh? I genuinely don't understand this obsessiveness with zagitova's life and her retirement, but I often find it coming from ppl from a certain fandom🙄. It's up to u, if you've lost motivation or don't find it worth doing anymore there's no point in continuing

  • @S80-r1o
    @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +18

    Daria Sadkova is the one to watch for next season imo

    • @vicserra2485
      @vicserra2485 3 роки тому +1

      And you are sooooooo right¡¡¡ idc about novice placements, Valieva in novice never wins but at that moment was very clear she have STAR potential and with a little work she was gonna be amazing, this is the same with Sadkova, her jumps are hugeeeee, much much better than all the oher novice, in juniors 2 more years she is gonna be a star

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +2

      @@vicserra2485 well, sadkova's jumps are still pretty sketchy, but they have improved soo much since she left mari-el already, can't wait to see what happens with her over the summer

    • @fsmilka8021
      @fsmilka8021 3 роки тому

      @@vicserra2485 you're funny. Kamila won almost everything in novice

    • @vicserra2485
      @vicserra2485 3 роки тому +1

      @@fsmilka8021 Nop, there are 3 big articles that talk about Valieva winning 1 event and losing 4 o 5 because her inconsistency, thats the reason she change coaches to Eteri

    • @HalsLWWY
      @HalsLWWY 3 роки тому +1

      Funny enough, Daria reminds me of Kamila too. Down to the power pull between jumps

  • @maryloureiff6489
    @maryloureiff6489 3 роки тому +1

    Oh..good to hear that MD is doing preview.
    of Worlds..

  • @B___T985
    @B___T985 3 роки тому +4

    LOL-ing at "The Beetlejuice Team." 😄

  • @stulochealthdesipad4020
    @stulochealthdesipad4020 3 роки тому +6

    Lol no, korean would not change their selection to world. It was the foreigner fans whom all made a fuss about it. If you have been following Korean skating much, you would know they are very strict with all their domestic rules and decisions.Even Yuna Kim can't get away from it, let alone YY. Nats for World team selection is a final decision, the ranking comp result is used for 4CC team selection (which didn't happen this year) and as an additional factor to decide the national team, those who would get the funding and be allowed to use their National Team rink. After all Korea doesn't have much good quality rinks, unlike other countries like Japan.

    • @SamKreinberg
      @SamKreinberg 3 роки тому +2

      It’s not that the amount of competitions is wrong, it’s just doing competition two weeks before worlds is stupid. How the skaters are supposed to peak?

    • @stulochealthdesipad4020
      @stulochealthdesipad4020 3 роки тому +4

      @@SamKreinberg i think it is pretty much a well known fact, that KSU is pretty incompetent and doesn't really use their common sense lol.

    • @Essylte
      @Essylte 3 роки тому +3

      @@stulochealthdesipad4020 No wonder Korean skaters have to find foreign training. KSU should know that they can't produce another star like Yuna unless they change their ways. Many Korean skaters who have foreign coaches can't do their usual regiment, what with the restrictions and lack of access to ice rinks. If Yelim manages to stay in the top 10, there will be at least 2 spots next year. But with the competitors coming to Worlds, don't know if she can stay inside the top 10. Thanks a lot, KSU!

  • @JoshuaFazeli
    @JoshuaFazeli 3 роки тому +4

    I have zero confidence in any governing body at this point.
    Why the USOC didn’t enact a SafeSport after Kristy Henrich died of her eating disorder or even the Yurchenko injury from Julissa is disgusting to me and the fact that Al Fong is STILL coaching actively in the US is absurd and disgusting.
    Yes, I get it, people have been abused in various sports for years even before this, but what is it going to take to get some accountability and consistent justice and proper training for these environments?
    Side note: SafeSport in Russia is a Twitter bot post, shot of warm Stoli, and a backhanded compliment as Tarasova whips you severely with her fur coat.

  • @Анна-л4ъ3ц
    @Анна-л4ъ3ц 3 роки тому +8

    You haven’t timed, but I did as well as many other fans, sooo Titova was early by 10 seconds, so the jump not having a bonus is absolutely correct, as it was still first part of the program. So all the screaming and comparison of Olympic results with this competition is absolute absurdity to me🙈 should we all buy a timer for Plushenko, so they can time the program properly?⏱⏱⏱

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +1

      Lol I can't with his IG story caption about him being robbed at the olympics...just like titova!

  • @Rachel-rs7jn
    @Rachel-rs7jn 3 роки тому +5

    Do we know why Silvia has not been suspended? It seems she knew about it at the very least.

    • @DSQueenie
      @DSQueenie 3 роки тому +4

      That’s why they need to release the details so there is no speculation.

    • @Rachel-rs7jn
      @Rachel-rs7jn 3 роки тому +4

      @@DSQueenie Yes, you're right. I'm wondering if this is USFS just throwing them (and themselves) a bone so they don't lose all their students.

    • @embeth446
      @embeth446 3 роки тому

      Yes. Release the details. Perhaps they’ll say John was the one pressuring the victim to keep quiet, but Silvia is his wife for crying out loud. There’s no way she didn’t know everything that was going on.

  • @biggestgymfan7230
    @biggestgymfan7230 3 роки тому

    Will be the highlight of this Sunday for sure

  • @MrSk8ingfan
    @MrSk8ingfan 3 роки тому +4

    When did Christine Brennan EVER go to bat for Michelle? She was pretty obviously anti-Michelle at both Olympics and even when there was a pretty easy reason to support Michelle (e.g. 2002 Worlds), she would give some lame-o excuse like "oh, I wasn't there..."
    For all the transparency she had brought on the sexual abuse allegations in skating, I wouldn't say that she's very been fair to skaters and she's certainly never stuck her neck out for skaters who really and truly deserved the win... 🤷‍♂️

  • @chocolateperfume752
    @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +4

    This has got nothing to do with the topic, but I was rewatching some of trusova's recent skates, and idk if it's just me, but she seems to somehow struggle with her jumps? I know she's being praised for having a more polished jumping technique than others, and she does, but it takes her a little longer to jump (without any transitions basically) and her landings are often not balanced and effortless. I think it's one of the reasons she often falls. It just seems as if she struggles, I hope they're working on that

    • @iris7484
      @iris7484 3 роки тому +2

      I mean, she's always fallen a lot. She's at that critical age as well... I don't speak from experience but I would guess that has something to do with the long buildup. Not to mention her coach is from an era where a huge build up to a quad is fine, so he might be focusing on getting it done and getting the BV.

    • @baaa9531
      @baaa9531 3 роки тому +2

      she’s been injured since november

  • @lindaleighton
    @lindaleighton 3 роки тому +26

    Typically I could not care less about Novice, and yet here I am... invested.

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +5

      Same here!

    • @joedeon85
      @joedeon85 3 роки тому +3

      I’m all in these little novices are good and kinda good to see even last place is just as competitive as the novice ladies in the us lolz

  • @annann6741
    @annann6741 3 роки тому +3

    Fedotov is future Olympic champion 🥇

  • @fotomagrol
    @fotomagrol 3 роки тому +14

    The sad part of this competition is the childs are been used against 2 egooo adults. Period. If they would bee moore mature and profesional would be moore focuss on develop a good skating program bouth schools, focusing on tje technique, athlete development a good enviroment for students and parents and coaches...but I gueess their ego and been number 1 is moore important.

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +1

      Very well said.

    • @ManuelGarcia-vh2vg
      @ManuelGarcia-vh2vg 3 роки тому +18

      Tutberidze did not say anything. In this case the problem was the mother and Plushenko. They keep this fight when it should be over.

    • @nycgtl88
      @nycgtl88 3 роки тому +12

      @@ManuelGarcia-vh2vg shows their desperate need to produce a champ especially now that Alena left. At least TT shows some professionalism and have the titles to back it up. For someone like Eteri to take all the 💩, I give her credit, her athletes have developed, can't say the same for Plushenko

  • @BillyWhaler
    @BillyWhaler 3 роки тому +7

    Eunsoo looked good. Stamina not exactly there yet but more strength and confidence than recent performances.

  • @evanperilstein5308
    @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +3

    It's sad that skating is a sport of sucking up to outsized egos, but that's also life itself, unfortunately.

  • @DSQueenie
    @DSQueenie 3 роки тому +3

    24:52 idk maybe it’s AoP trying to build their power.

  • @AndxxNatalie
    @AndxxNatalie 3 роки тому

    So excited for world's and so excited for Meagan's expertise!

  • @stepheng905
    @stepheng905 3 роки тому

    Hi David I will subscribe and smash that like button if you can tell what happened to Evelina Pokrasneteva. Was so hoping to see her skating again after pandemic but Ilya is now with someone else

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому

      I am not sure if I am familiar with this skater. But I love that you are holding such a thing hostage for a response. Bless.

  • @MrsLeila92
    @MrsLeila92 3 роки тому

    I think Jonathan is talking about Olympics 2002 in Salt Lake City where Berezhnaya/Sikharulidze shared the gold with Sale/Pelletier

  • @amberelibrennan
    @amberelibrennan 3 роки тому +5

    In Canada I have competed in some element competitions, but it wasn’t competitive levels it was from senior bronze to gold (starskate levels), & you’d do 2 jumps, 1 jump combo, 1 spin & 1 spiral sequence. Whatever level you’d compete at would tell you which jumps and what spin you’d do. I loved competing in element competitions ☺️ You could also repeat an element if you messed up or you know it could be better, but if you did it really well you didn’t have to.

    • @amberelibrennan
      @amberelibrennan 3 роки тому +1

      Would be cool if they added it into the Olympics. Also, I competed in interpretive which is fun cause you just skate to a song you love & show your interpretation to it. Nowadays you need one stsq, one spin & one chsq; no levels are given for them tho (I think) just goe. Would be harder to add that to the Olympics, but it would still be interesting.

    • @slipperyhardandcold7740
      @slipperyhardandcold7740 3 роки тому +2

      @@amberelibrennan In some competitions, interpretative is when the competition committee selects one song, each skater listens to it and then composes and skates their choreography

    • @amberelibrennan
      @amberelibrennan 3 роки тому

      @@slipperyhardandcold7740 improv haha I competed in that twice before haha it’s fun

  • @Essylte
    @Essylte 3 роки тому +5

    I don't care to watch novices, but to hear that one of Plushy's students claiming "I was robbed!" at some child competition is really...childish. It shows her age, and now, she's welcoming RusFed to further mark her and Plush down more. Not a good look. Haven't heard much from Vanessa James, but since both she and Cipres have retired and are no longer skating together, well, their careers have already been over, right? Cipres needs to be thoughtful of his former partner and take responsibility before Vanessa's reputation gets smeared because of him. Not sure the level of her knowledge is of the situation, but hopefully, she keeps her distance from him for a while and he can fix himself. The Muppets Show was great, guys. Watch the one where Prince featured on there. It's hilarious. Tanos and Rippons? I thought that these were no longer getting marked with high GOE in international competitions, but in Russia only. Why would Valieva need to use the Rippon to get the 3A around? Sound suspicious, like she can only use her arms to jump. Not a good example of textbook technique. If anything, Tutberidze and the team should do what Plushenko does: show the girls videos of Yuzuru Hanyu doing the 3A. Nathan Chen is the textbook all quad jumper; they would do well to show him to them, too. It would be nice if Yelim Kim manages to get South Korea 2 spots for Worlds and Olympics next year, if not be on the podium. It's sad, but I imagine she and Haein being 9-10 at this rate...

    • @DeepSeas..
      @DeepSeas.. 3 роки тому +2

      Well, she *was* robbed. LOL And this is where the over-scoring starts and makes the Eteri skaters invincible. If you don’t put your foot down now, you’re truly screwed once juniors starts.
      This isn’t only a Russia thing btw. Alyssa Liu was over-scored since she was a novice and the over-scoring continued until she was the two-time U.S. champion.

    • @bookreader7506
      @bookreader7506 3 роки тому +4

      No, she wasn't. Her that claimed jump cascade was before the bonus zone. She was so hurried and did not hit the music.

  • @edichkalimonoff878
    @edichkalimonoff878 3 роки тому

    Я пропустил, или они про Садкову ничего не сказали?

  • @S80-r1o
    @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +7

    silvia fontana is going to worlds with kevin and mae-berenice.... yikes

    • @DSQueenie
      @DSQueenie 3 роки тому +4

      What do you do if you’re them? They are obviously blameless but on the other hand I know I’d be looking for a new coach.

    • @davinyu7889
      @davinyu7889 3 роки тому +1

      @@DSQueenie it is way too late for Kevin to switch if he expects to do well and secure qualification to the olympics. he needed to do it when the pandemic hit. he flourished under this coaching team. it might not be that easy to replicate that success elsewhere.

  • @hellsbellsmichelle
    @hellsbellsmichelle 3 роки тому +14

    I feel for Vanessa. She's a victim in this too. This has ended her career.

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +21

      Unless she did know... Then, it becomes more complicated.

    • @avg18
      @avg18 3 роки тому +2

      @@TheSkatingLesson exactly! has she ever said anything about this situation?

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +3

      @@avg18 nope, and she only distanced herself from morgan once people started calling her out for still being pals with him

    • @MrChaseBlue
      @MrChaseBlue 3 роки тому +6

      @@TheSkatingLesson she was competing for the olympics to try to win a medal. I don’t blame her if she did since it happened at the most inopportune time. Why should she suffer for this? I don’t blame her for not saying anything. She’s not the perpetrator here.

    • @MrChaseBlue
      @MrChaseBlue 3 роки тому +4

      @@S80-r1o she can still be friends with him. Jeez people need to leave her alone. It’s not like he murdered somebody.

  • @benbailey159bb
    @benbailey159bb 3 роки тому +1

    Half way through and I sooooo hope you're going to talk about what Yana said about the posibility of Zagitova going to Plushenko and it all depending on if he accepts her or not!!!

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +2

      I did not see this yet. I will check it out 🤣

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому

      This is a rumor started by a youtube channel. When someone recently interviewed Rudovskaya, they referred to that rumor and asked her if Zagitova will be joining AofP. Yana avoided answering, but used the opportunity to say that they learned a lesson with Kostornaia and will be much more careful accepting students in the future.

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +6

      @@evamasters5028 I think you're far behind. There was a whole "scandal" months ago, when team tutberidze published yana's conversation with alina, inviting her to join AOP. That's why the interviewer asked her will alina join the camp, because it was already discussed

    • @evamasters5028
      @evamasters5028 3 роки тому

      Of course these are recycled old stories. Your comrades love faking extra drama, helps them with the views😜

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +5

      @@evamasters5028 just a genuine advice get off the internet for a while....you're not making any sense

  • @olgas6520
    @olgas6520 3 роки тому +2

    Yes, bottle and battle sounds the same for me, I mean, I have to spend hours practicing my ear to hear the difference. 🙄

  • @laurenaustin1953
    @laurenaustin1953 3 роки тому

    Dave you are right on: Liza is in Muppets Take Manhattan. At Sardi’s. And the old Muppet Show is not THAT offensive. I watch it with my 6 year old 🤨

  • @celiareed1402
    @celiareed1402 3 роки тому +4

    2002 Salt Lake City Olympics: pairs scandal with Sale and Pelletier of Canada and Berezhnaya and Sikharulidze of Russia.

    • @efimkrivov
      @efimkrivov 3 роки тому +6

      Scandal was totally made by canadian scandalists

    • @celiareed1402
      @celiareed1402 3 роки тому +4

      @@efimkrivov Your comment makes no sense. The French judge, Marie-Reine LeGougne, was implicated. She blamed her actions on pressure by the French federation official, Didier Gailhaguet, who allegedly cut a deal with the Russians. Don’t rewrite history.

    • @MsRumex
      @MsRumex 3 роки тому +3

      @@celiareed1402 well there also was the story about Gailhaguet trying to be elected ISU president and after this "scandal " he was excluded from
      ISU and could not challenge Cinquanta. Judge LeGougne also had her interests. First of all she was very very experienced judge, so she should have been able to withstand this kind of pressure. On the other hand she wanted to get Gaihaguet position, so this scandal did give her the chance to candidate for it. Anyway all players there weren't innocent and did get something out of this situation.

    • @celiareed1402
      @celiareed1402 3 роки тому

      @@MsRumex Good points! Gailhaguet was just recently forced out again due to a sexual assault scandal!

    • @FK_loving
      @FK_loving 3 роки тому +4

      Exactly! The world should know how one of the greatest and gracest pair in figure skating Berezhnaya Siharulidze was humiliated in OG and was equalled to skaters who were forgotten by the world as soon as OG finished.

  • @bakedpotato6653
    @bakedpotato6653 3 роки тому +3

    Seems like you guys (or at least Jonathan) are finally accepting that Kolyada will not be winning over Nathan lol. His scoring at Challenge Cup proved that his inflated domestic scoring won’t hold up internationally. He’ll be fighting for third at Worlds, but he has a lot of competition for that bronze medal.

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому +4

      He is a great skater and has made tremendous improvements. Ice is very slippery. It will be a very interesting competition.

    • @bakedpotato6653
      @bakedpotato6653 3 роки тому

      @@TheSkatingLesson I agree that he’s a great skater, but he lacks a champion’s mindset and fight. His own personal competitive history does not suggest that he would be the one to prevail while the other top men all falter on multiple quads each.

  • @tj205bama
    @tj205bama 3 роки тому +2

    This is hard to watch and listen to

  • @feyanormorfol2457
    @feyanormorfol2457 3 роки тому +10

    Plushy: *whining about losing with a 4T to the athlet without 4T in 2010*
    Plushy: *whining about his skater's losing to the athlet with 4T*
    Double standarts or bipolar disorder?

    • @vegorov180
      @vegorov180 3 роки тому +3

      What are talking about? Dvoeglazova fell on underrotated quad. She not only never landed 4T, but never rotated 4T.

    • @feyanormorfol2457
      @feyanormorfol2457 3 роки тому

      @@vegorov180 Titova didn't even try it, lol)

    • @MsRumex
      @MsRumex 3 роки тому

      @@feyanormorfol2457 so what? It's one thing to do it right (at least rotate it) and totally another not to manage even this.

    • @feyanormorfol2457
      @feyanormorfol2457 3 роки тому

      @@MsRumex So that.
      1) Firstly, don't bring up whining about the undervaluation of 4T in Vancouver , since your skater is unable to jump it at all, and her competitor tried it at least.
      2) Second, if Plushy exalts difficulty... He should shut up even more so. Because Alysa D. executed the most difficult FS and got the highest TES.
      At the very time Titova was only 3rd in FS and with 3rd TES. (But with highest PCS, what an irony!)

  • @abbibrophy7671
    @abbibrophy7671 3 роки тому +8

    The US is just bizarre you love shows like dance moms where abuse is rife (and not limited to the coach) strictness is not always abuse and coaches learn how to motivate some yell some don't, some humiliate and some abuse verbally isn't it better to talk with your feet and just change coaches

    • @Frooti.loopz23
      @Frooti.loopz23 3 роки тому +1

      Because dance moms is fake, none of the drama is real

    • @DeepSeas..
      @DeepSeas.. 3 роки тому +4

      @@Frooti.loopz23 The abuse was real, especially against Chloe and Nia. Editing changes narratives, but the abusiveness of Abby was more than just manipulation by producers.

  • @Littlemoefam
    @Littlemoefam 3 роки тому

    Dave, be sure to stay at the Royal Park when you come to adult nationals!

    • @TheSkatingLesson
      @TheSkatingLesson  3 роки тому

      Thank you for the recommendation!

    • @Littlemoefam
      @Littlemoefam 3 роки тому

      There’s no better local place to stay, and it’s super close to the rink. I’ll buy you a fancy dinner!

  • @evamasters5028
    @evamasters5028 3 роки тому +23

    Regarding TItova's mother and Plushenko disputing the scores - I think in Russia you have to go on the offensive or be trodden on. Also Plushenko is probably the only one who can stand to the eteri cult now, the rest of the coaches are paid by the federation and they can lose their jobs (not unlike TAT who supported Medvedeva and Orser, and was removed from her commentator job, and Ted hired). Speaking about it and also continuing to have top athletes is the only way he may eventually succeed. I think a lot of coaches and possibly judges privately agree with Plushenko, but would never go on the record fearing retaliation. Plushenko and his skaters are definitely taking a risk, but sometimes the risk of not taking the risk is even bigger.

    • @vicserra2485
      @vicserra2485 3 роки тому +8

      Thats gonna be imposible to happen because Plushenko needs her students do very well and start winning and thats not happening, even if Sasha win worlds is like "yes but Kamila wasnt there" and next year Eteri will sweep podiums again.... Next generation is gonna be Kamilas, next Akatyevas, next the Eteris novice because they win and idk how thats gonna change
      Trusova really needs to medal in worlds but if she choke and leaves AoP, Plushenko is done as a coach

    • @S80-r1o
      @S80-r1o 3 роки тому +11

      why were none of sofia's 5 (yes, FIVE) blatant flutzes and downgraded combination called? not even going to engage with your tarasova victimhood narrative, but I find it very interesting how the judging fairness crusaders never apply their logic to their favourite coaches/figureheads (since plushenko doesn't really count as a coach lol)

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +12

      Lmao are u seriously "victimizing" tarasova? U don't need to worry about her, she's a legend there and pretty much no one can control her. Since u so kindly care about those poor kids and how they're abused by eteri (which I applaud u for) seems like you're forgetting tarasova speaks whatever she wants and publicly shames and trashes those same kids u worry about. Oh and she's medvedeva's biggest supporter ever, after her failure at the olympics she trash talked alina on TV, and just recently, aliona. So believe me when I tell you I genuinely don't understand your logic here sweetie

    • @Rachel-rs7jn
      @Rachel-rs7jn 3 роки тому +7

      I have to agree. Russia got all up and arms when their skaters started actually getting underrotation calls they deserved, and it worked. The judges backed off. I think if Plushenko stayed quiet, the status quo of "Eteri wins all" would just stick.

    • @chocolateperfume752
      @chocolateperfume752 3 роки тому +5

      @S 80 "tarasova VICTIMHOOD narrative"....ikr, when I read that I was like is she for real🤦🤦 but then I remembered I read elsewhere some of her comments and she's a hardcore medobot

  • @mcal2984
    @mcal2984 3 роки тому +1

    Titova already turned 12

  • @anaelivillarreal8830
    @anaelivillarreal8830 3 роки тому +3

    Yasss TSL time with tea on the side ... Bluberry matcha

  • @Chastaken
    @Chastaken 3 роки тому +1

    Kevin and Mae should be underscored at Worlds. The are not guilty but they supported them and looked away. This could be the real punishment, silvia and john deserve to lose all their top athlets.

    • @evanperilstein5308
      @evanperilstein5308 3 роки тому +5

      That’s a terrible idea. It would be unethical. Two wrongs don’t make a right.

  • @arthurtheaardvark13
    @arthurtheaardvark13 3 роки тому +2

    Why is the Zimmerman team being dragged so hard when two teenage girls asked Morgan for pics in exchange for a pizza, Morgan found that funny and complied with their request (against better judgment given their age, but it’s not like the pics weren’t solicited), and the girls got their pizza (I’m assuming they were more than pleased with what they got out of this very strange deal?). And then the kerfuffle only began when the parents found out and started sharing the girls for asking in the first place? I’m so confused.

  • @npcarney
    @npcarney 3 роки тому

    Yay!!!