I like your trio a lot musically, It’s pretty and fun, although it’s stylistically different from the Schubert parts. But that doesn’t bother me. I kind of like things that do that. You should have added the bass trombone because Schubert did use it in the bars he scored.
In the Main part it is very similiar as Schuberts sketches are very detailed. Here I tried to stress maybe more the dynamics of this movement ( for example in m. 4). But the Trio is very different as from Schubert we know only the theme
I will say, with this and the 4th movement I noticed your F# timpano was an octave too low, as in the original symphony it's a high F# timpani. I know it sounds better lower to be honest, but I do feel like to fit in more it should probably be at that range.
Das ist wirklich sehr sehr schön.
Great job!!!
Complimenti Gerd!
I like your trio a lot musically, It’s pretty and fun, although it’s stylistically different from the Schubert parts. But that doesn’t bother me. I kind of like things that do that. You should have added the bass trombone because Schubert did use it in the bars he scored.
Thank you, I was too late aware of the bass trombone but I did use in the Finale , also according to Schubert's score
Can you explain where and how this is different from the Newbould or Carragan reconstructions?
In the Main part it is very similiar as Schuberts sketches are very detailed. Here I tried to stress maybe more the dynamics of this movement ( for example in m. 4). But the Trio is very different as from Schubert we know only the theme
I will say, with this and the 4th movement I noticed your F# timpano was an octave too low, as in the original symphony it's a high F# timpani. I know it sounds better lower to be honest, but I do feel like to fit in more it should probably be at that range.
I had checked it with the higher #F, but it just didnt sound well
Warum nur zwei Posaunen?
Yeah the bars Schubert orchestrated have three