Reality About Hypersonic Missiles I Where does India Stand I Air Marshal GS Bedi I Aadi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- Reality About Hypersonic Missiles as being seen during the use by Russia. Where does India's Hypersonic Missile program Stand?
#hypersonic #missile #india #deftalks
DEF Talks is a space for clear cut discussions on important subjects of current affairs of the world with a prime focus to the Indian Subcontinent. I cover issues related to conflicts, Geopolitics, Military Strategy and Foreign Affairs.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @deftalksbyaadi
Do support me by clicking "Thanks'.
Connect With me and Interact
EMAIL: aadiachint@gmail.com
TELEGRAM: t.me/deftalksaadi
LINKEDIN: DEF TALKS BY AADI ACHINT
TWITTER: / aadiachint
Copyrights owned. - Розваги
I thought was having fair knowledge of the hypersonic but the way MG Bedi explained from start and accelerate through each step on aerodynamic and simple analogy is amazing. Literally a crash course on spoken knowledge for anyone to know the subject and it’s warfare applications. Thanks for impressive post. Keep Rolling more posts 😊
Rocker Science so simplified , Sir Ji you may Please take Classes for budding science students especially who’s interested in Physics and material science engineers 🙏
Salute Air Mashal G. S. Bedi for his deep scientific knowledge. Thanks Aadi for inviting such a great soldier of our Air Force.
BEAUTIFULLY EXPLAINED BY AM Bedi
Bedi Saheb ek Mahaan Scholar hain!
👏❤👏
Jai Hind! ❤🇮🇳❤
Just an explanatory Comment - Scramjet - SC - Supersonic Combustion - ramjet. Flow behind a normal shock wave, normal to the surface that is perpendicular, is always subsonic. As the speed increases the shockwave starts to become oblique. Flow behind an oblique shock wave can be supersonic. Hence, in scramjet the flow behind an oblique shockwave, which is supersonic, is used for combustion. Thanks
Wonderful.
Now I can explain about hypersonic technology to kids.
It was a wonderful science class. Thank you sir.
Amazing KT by Air Marshall GS Bedi sir....thank you very much......and kudos to Aadi--now your Vlogs have quality content.....maintain this standard.
Young intelligent air marshal well explained
GS BEDI SIR KUDOS ,LEVEL HEADED EXAMPLES
Dear Air Marshal ,
You are not only simply beautiful but amazing extremely Excellent.
Simply Thank you very much.
Excellent....very lucid and technical at the same time. thanks
Excellant explanation about the ramjet and scramjet technologies and all other terminology associated with it by Air marshal sir!
Awesome Explanation 👌
Very Educative. Insightful
Thank you Sir !! Warm Regards
Extraordinary. Only a person who understands the subject well can explain in such simple terms and analogies
Great session - listening to Air Marshal G.S.Bedi 👍
Superb explanation for common public! 👍
Thank you Sir!
Supersonic missile need to be switched to hypersonic mode at the intercepting range at the target.
Kudos and thanks Mr. Adi to bring specialist and on the job person to interact and educate us about reality excluding unnecessary tamasha. Pure knowledge.
So informative Bedi sir. Very rare that we see such people having so much authority on the subject.
Thank you Adi sir.
Amazing clarity expressed with passion. Thank you Air Marshal. Look forward to hearing more !!
This man was my first station commander
JAI HIND, SIR
🙏🙏🙏
Great job Sir a very complex science is explained in easy to understand for the layman's.
Air marshal saheb, thanks for a very understandable and coherent presentation. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Complex issues explained easily for common people like me. Thanks
Very lucidly explained by AM Bedi. He is a master in heat engines . India should invest heavily in this research to make a headway.
Great things explained in a very simple way. ❤❤❤
Very interesting, informative discussion ! Even for science students, it is very intricate.
Aadi I appreciate and love your every intellectual analysis. Thanks for inviting such a great intellectual.
Excellent interaction
GS BEDI sir my idol type found 😊
Bedi sir ❤you are the best ❤ I have heard it 3 times already . Fantastic ❤
You are very kind Sir !
Inspiring for science students ❤
Quite interesting subject it should be placed rather in stages shoingprecisly graphically thanks for today's informative classification
Well explained 😊❤
Thank you Air Marshall Bedi.
Super explanation 👌👍🙏
Thanks 🙏🏼
A slow moving drone requires basic computers and sensors. A guided artilary shell requires highly enforced electronics and sensors that makes it too expensive and too complicated. Also a fast moving projectiles has a definite path making it easier to predict its trajectory and possible to intercept...
Great explanation as usual by Bedi sir always clear
Many countries are researching but only couple of countries are having cutting edge break through.
👍👍👍
Excellent presentation of supersonic and hypersonic technology with simple examples. My salute to Air Marshal Bedi sir. Lucky are the ones who got his mentorship in Airforce.
Research in Metallurgy and materials science play a vital role in development of these technologies.
RudraM-2,3 are both hypersonic missiles.
Love such type of knowledge
Radars have angular sensors and have limitations at the vertical. A missile entering vertically into radar can escape detection.
Materials and thermal conductivity play a vital role in this technology
Please rename the Air Marshal. He is Professor Bedi.
This man illustrate all things in very lucid way. And due to hindi....common man also understand
"Reaction time should be less that Resident time". Air breathing missiles could not have been demystified better. Thank your Air Marshal Bedi for once again, succinctly and beautifully explaining technological concepts.
The only question that flashed my mind and went unanswered relates to the operational time of the Scramjet engine. Air Marshal cited the different time spans the Russians, Chinese and us (Indians) have operated the Scramjet. Is Scramjet a "once and done" operation in the entire trajectory of the missile?
Thank you very much for your interest and endorsement Sir, deeply appreciate that. By definition, air breathing engines should be controllable, like a normal jet engine. Problem with scramjet in weapons is that, one you’ll lose it with the weapon anyways. Secondly, since the weapon once accelerated to hypersonic, one wouldn’t want to decelerate it now hence can’t come off this regime. This would be possible say in commercial applications, where one has to land back. X-15 a manned mission was tested for this. But for commercial applications, the technology will have to improve to longer duration operations. As of now, it’s been tested to max 600 secs. Hope this answers some of it. Please feel free to ask further if any doubts. Thanks and Regards
@@gurcharanbedi204
Please allow me Sir, to start with, by thanking you for your service to the nation; actually continuing service through your post retirement appearances on channels like Def Talks with Aadi. Listeners like me greatly cherish the information and views shared by 'practitioners' like you; bringing to the table immense background knowledge, clarity and depth on matters discussed on this channel.
I, therefore, feel greatly honoured to receive your personal response to my unanswered query. And yes, it absolutely did answer my doubt. Expendability of all missile components notwithstanding; the second point of not wanting to decelerate was very interesting. Makes me ask a rather amateur question, why not? Mid-course maneuverability imparts considerable survivability / lethality to an aggressor missile against Air Defence systems. Wouldn't variable velocities enhance it? But that is a rhetorical question and you've already cited technological challenges at longer duration operations for Scramjet.
Meanwhile another statement you made in the episode in relation to the race for hypersonics among major nations caught my attention; "The US is in an entirely different race". My acquired knowledge through different forums and open sources suggests that the US primarily fields sub-sonic missiles; but equipped with Stealth capabilities and electronic countermeasures. And it is the Stealth Technology that carries as much enigma as it attracts hype. As with any technology, Stealth too comes with its own Pros and Cons. Unless you've already done an episode demystifying Stealth; I hope you and Aadi consider it worthwhile putting together one for the benefit of the listeners on this Channel.
Once again, thank you for your very valuable service and it is an immense pleasure listening to you distil complex technological concepts into easily understandable and digestible morsels.
Warm Regards.
Thanks once again. It’s a pleasure to indulge with inquisitive minds. See, as of now it’s the rockets that accelerate the missile or boost glide vehicle to hypersonic where scramjet would kick in. Now if you want to come off it, either you’ll need another stage of rocket or a ramjet to kick in - both would increase the weight and adversely affect the performance without much gain. Trick is to have manoeuvrability at hypersonic speeds. Sure we can do an episode on stealth. Thanks for the suggestion. Warm Regards
@@gurcharanbedi204
Crystal clear, Sir! Every product is a very fine balance of factors as weight, volume, performance, output and not to forget, costs.
Very gracious of you to indulge my curiosities. Look forward to a continued privilege of access to your deep experience and expertise through this channel.
Jai Hind.
Super questions sir. I must say I am proud to have you as a part of this channel.
can you ask AM Bedi How the R 77 compares with Aim 120 C?
Sir drdo has also tested HSTDV for 600sec as per one presentation made by drdo at IISC banglore. There we got to know that first test was of 20s and letar test was of 600+ sec.
Probably if they said so, but not to my knowledge !!
@@gurcharanbedi204 I have pic from that presentation that drdo made at IISC.
@@gurcharanbedi204 actually now the project has been classified. As earlier publications were done for signaling.
Probably !! Thanks
V interesting and engrossing. Chinese hypersonic will they really function?😂
❤😊
Just hope either english or hindi.
Specific heat is highest for water so to raise the same temp more heat is needed to raise hence that medium has more heat content
Exactly, and that’s because it’s denser than air !
As an example, to raise the per capita income by $1 in India will need much more money than in the UK !!
@@gurcharanbedi204 bcz the basic GDP like specific heat is an important deciding factor
Thanks for your interest !
@@gurcharanbedi204 loved the discussion. In fact your mention of plasma made me look up the fourth state of matter and right now am reading up on Bose Eistein condensate.
🙏🙏🙏👌👌
Aadi, you oughta interject less than you do. You should let AM Bedi speak more rather than cut him off to add your bit in between. Other than that great show brother!
Thank you Aadi and Air Marshall Bedi for an educative session. I really learned a lot 🙏
WEATHER WARFARE . 😏
What did he say ??
I tried Captions, I tried 0.5 speed, I gave up. 😔
Air Marshal Bedi should consider teaching profession
Wow.. very few people understand this physics and aeronautical engineering and even fewer can explain it in layman’s terms. Bedi sahab is at an amazing level at both.
I am new to your channel and love it but pls do not make long durations more than 30 minutes.Speed baraani parthi
Time bro
Sour 🍇? I lost the interest in the conversation right after I heard that guest believes patriot missiles interjected hypersonic missiles . Needs better expert.
He said probably as reported.
Fair enough, a bit judgemental though ! Always something to learn, will try harder next time to meet the criteria :) Thanks
@bhadreshsolanki5505 the speaker may not always say what you want to hear !! Please learn to respect others" point of view, like he just did it.
@@gurcharanbedi204 my point was simple. Patriot being only supersonic upto 2.8mach, can intercept hypersonic that by definition goes with speed of more than 5 mach simply is not true. And as an academic and expert that should be obvious. Sorry if you felt it was judgmental.
@@shubhamkumar7189 sour 🍇 comment was about the title. Hypersonic is the next-generation technology and calling it a hype because 🇮🇳 doesn't have it today is sour grapes kind of title.
If it had it , it would be like- Hypersonic missiles 🇮🇳 has it even though super power 🇺🇸 doesnt.. wouldn't you agree...😊
Indian stuff is causing havoc in Ukrain.
Itna aasani se meri teacher samjhati toh aaj I would have thought of becoming an aerospace engineer..Now I know IAF personnel its not just about fighting but knowing indepth technical knowledge
Even layman can understand with such explanation...thnxj
Waste of money unless you package it like USA we are working on hypersonic for stealth planes Russia and China are all long range big and expensive and probably less than 50 % will even work 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Nonsense.
You won't understand this buddy. Stick to your book. Earth is flat.