Titanic sinking was in many ways the end of an era. A peaceful, hopeful era. Like with the collapse of the Twin Towers, the (Western) world would never be quite the same again.
I loved learning about it in history and the certain arguments about who’s fault it was. But enough about that. The titanic has always been something I come back to and read about. A historical a event that shook the world
@@timonsolusI can’t even think of a reply lol accept that I agree and I was only a few months old when 9/11 happened but it was an event that changed the world
Something that sends chills down my spine is the moment the ship was fully submerged. Witnesses said it was just pitch black and all you can hear is screaming and the twisting metal below the water. Just thinking about that monstrosity being so huge that you can hear it underwater freaks me out for some reason.
This will sound awful, but I've always wanted to hear that sound. The ocean is huge and that you can still hear its cries underwater is crazy. Like, what the f*ck. What would that sound like. Also, to think about all of that darkness, the scotland road, as it fell in obscurity, the water having completely filled it... insane. My mind cannot comprehend it. The whole ship really, you know? Every room shrouded forever and filled with cold, unforgiving liquid, plus all of its little substances. What would it feel like to have stayed inside the Titanic and be able to survive the pressure? What would it feel to live in such a ship ghost and to experience its free fall?
There were reports of a loud boom or explosion in addition to the iron being bent and twisted as well. Likely the stern imploding shortly after sinking
18:43 Stream start 55:52 Iceberg collision 1:18:49 Lifeboats preparation 1:51:40 First boat going down 3:17:10 Last boat launched 3:30:55 Breaking in half 3:37:42 Dissapearing under water 3:39:07 Animation end
6 minutes breaked in half, I don't understand why. Titanic broke up in 2:18 AM amd fully disappeared only 2 minutes after that. Why the creators decided to do the breaking up so long?
@@armenianmapper3168 THG have always been very liberal with the timeline. In this animation they have the forecastle deck going under at 1:45, when that was the time that just the well deck was flooding.
This whole OceanGate tragedy has reminded me that the queen of the seas still down there and obviously still claiming souls. How the tragedy ended reminded me of the beginning of the Cameron movie when Brock says, "These windows are 9 inches thick and if they go, it's sayonara in two microseconds.“ So I had to watch the scene again and the Titanic got me back. Right now, I'm sitting here building the Titanic Lego set, with over 10,000 pieces and listening to this live stream. And I just wanted to let you know that right now there's no place I'd rather be and there's nothing I'd rather be doing. Keep up the nice work!
It’s achieved somewhat of an otherworldly status. It has become a legend. We love that boat and are morbidly curious/struck by the amount of life lost aboard such a magnificent piece of engineering and opulence.
Arrogance and the beilef by Stockton rush that his submersible Titan was far more advanced than any other deep sea submersible which he also quoted carbon fibre is far stronger than Titanium or any material .... Anyway titanic isn't on the north Atlantic seabed by a accident titanic sank because of arrogance by the belief that she was unsinkable and would spot the dangers that lie ahead .... Same applies to oceangate and the sub standard submersible titan ... Anyway cool live stream of titanic sad I missed it oh well I'm here anyway 😂
Thanks lots to the Titanic Honor and Glory's team for the incredible job that they provide. Titanic will live as long as it animates our hearts. Go on, Titanic fans, let's pass on our passion !❤
witness account from a danish survivor - "I shared a cabin with three other young girls, two English and one Swedish. We went to bed early on April 14th because third-class passengers had to leave the deck by 10 pm. We woke up to a bump after half an hour, but quickly fell asleep again. At 12:30, there was a knock on the door, and my uncle said, "You better put on a coat and come up to the deck"... so I put on my coat over my nightgown and went up to the deck. We had hit an iceberg and there was music in the first-class salon. There was no panic, not even when the lifeboats were lowered, no one was in a hurry to get into them, women and children went into the boats first. Once we were in the water and a good distance away from the Titanic, we could still hear the orchestra playing. One person said it was the hymn "Nearer My God to Thee". I didn't know it as it is an English hymn. There were six crew members rowing the lifeboat. The sea was completely calm like a mirror. We were surrounded by other lifeboats, and there were many icebergs around us. The disaster happened before anyone expected it. With horror, we heard an indescribable noise and screams from a thousand voices coming from this giant ship, it split in two, rose towards the sky, and disappeared. We sat petrified and watched it all happen, what was worse than the screams was the silence that followed, it was terrible." - Carla Christine Nielsine Andersen-Jensen
Imagine sitting in the lifeboat, Titanic gone beneath the cold Atlantic water and people screaming in distance.. and then the silence takes over, until there is no sound out there except water bouncing against the lifeboat. I am glad that the Olympic was far away from Titanic's sinking. Seeing Titanic's identical sister arriving at the spot where her sister Titanic went down just a bit earlier would have given the survivors a very severe traumatic experience.
An incredible evening! Thank you THG team for putting tonight's remembrance and recreation together. It goes down in my book as one of the best live-stream experiences I have had on youtube!
I have watched these since I was a little kid. I now know how much of a impact it has had on my life. Truly a beautiful animation they just keep getting better.
It's so great to see one of the popular channels finally get the fourth funnel's collapse correct! The funnel canting up in the water perfectly explains Dillon seeing it cant toward him not when when the stern righted, but rather "When she went down." And also why he later doubted whether he even saw it fall. It also perfectly explains why several people - Jack Thayer, John Collins, Ida Hippach, Edward Buley, George Crowe, etc - thought that the fourth funnel went underwater still standing, as it would already be difficult to see, but then submerge only a few seconds later. Much of an improvement!
@@eddieroskelly1826, I absolutely agree! The collapse of the the fourth funnel (or rather lack of anyone except Dillon seeing it) happens to be one of the most overlooked elements of them. I think it's just a desire to stick to familiarity, but hopefully this video will spread the idea and what survivors actually saw. I'm hoping to get across the importance of witness testimonies in my updated survivor account animation series that I will start soon.
I agree! Seeing as the stern settled back during the break up (rather than a dramatic fall) I can’t think of a reason why the fourth funnel would have fallen with the guys wires holding the funnel in place.
A stunning new animation, and great to finally see some new interior flooding animations which were truly chilling. The improvement in the water quality on previous animations is fantastic. It was interesting to see that at the end, the fourth funnel does not collapse when the ship breaks up - and the entire stern section seems to stick up at a very high angle before the final plunge similar to the '97 movie - in recent years I thought it had been agreed that this did not happen and such a high angle was ony reached in the last few seconds.
Amazing work lads. That end sequence was rather horrifying, actually brought a tear to my eye! Can't begin to imagine the horror of the last 20 minutes or so.
I think this is the first time I felt the raw horror of the final moments in a real-time. I think all the real-times - this, Titanic Animations, OASOG/Tom - are good and have their own strengths. But this was the first time I felt the scope.
You can't really hate Titanic Animation's one. He built the model, by himself, in just about one year (THG can't finish one in ten with multiple people being paid), hand-animated every single person (their whole body moves) and did the rendering too.
Thank yall for another wonderful stream. This always pays the respect to those who have passed on and giving one of, if not the most detailed telling of the events that occurred
I walked through Project 401 the other night for the first time and was like a kid in a candy store. Your projects are historically groundbreaking. The fact I could explore an early 1900’s ship I’ve loved my entire life as if I was there is so immensely surreal. Thank you so much for doing what I dreamed someone of doing forever. Letting me live the dream of experiencing that great piece of engineering.
There are a bunch of real time sinking videos, but I think this is my favorite because the animation is the best and the narrators are terrific. You guys really did a great job. It must’ve been a lot of work. It’s a tragic event, it’s hard to be excited about it, but this is just such a great record. RIP to all those lost.
One of the most haunting animations of the final plunge I've seen since I started watching these anniversary livestreams in June of 2020, I was actually startled when the glass dome shattered and water began poring in from above, even though I knew it was coming the animation of it left me in shock. Well done all of you 👏🏼
i honestly did not expect you guys to straight up recreate some of the 1997 movie shots in this animation and it honestly put me a smile, this was such a good animation, my only complain is that Harold Bride who fell under collapsible B was not recreated (at least, i didn't saw him)
111 years had passed, and Titanic is STILL remembered for her tragic fate (likely because of the 1997 movie), even though there actually were disasters worse than it, such as the forgotten but deadly Wilhelm Gustloff sinking, which had over 9000 deaths compared to Titanic's 1600+. Graphics are a nice improvement compared to the original video.
Been joining James' lives since 2020 and found you through him. I'm so glad you have this up since I didn't watch it live (though I had it on mute to enjoy the animation, it was stunning). All of your guys' work on this is phenomenal.
I loved the way you showed the sinking. As a titanic fan for life. Im glad that people 111 years later we are still honoring the lives that were lost. May there story’s never be forgotten
The best part for me was the showing of the californian and the view it could have had of titanic. Thank you so much for this. I wondered my whole life how it could have looked. Keep it going
Incredible work, and it keeps getting better and better every year. Already looks this great, imagine what this might look like five years from now or two years from now.
Thank you SO MUCH for this! I'd never realised so much time passed before the first distress call was sent or the first lifeboat was lowered. Also didn't know that Land of Hope and Glory was one of the pieces played by the band. Thank you!
God lads, ye did an amazing job with this, there are so many fantastic eery shots used , love the overhead shot looking down as the bridge goes under, and that distant shot after the break up is very eery.
Thanks again THG team for another year of amazing work. The only feedback I can think of (because everything else is perfect ; ) ) is that the sound is kind of low. That's all. Looking forward to next year!
Thomas Andrews was the Harland and Wolff naval architect who inspired me to become a naval architect and shipbuilder. You wonder what was going through his mind when he was spotted running up the grand staircase 3 steps at a time? We do flooding calculations to make sure that the ship does not sink below the margin line. So, as you say, once he knew how many adjacent compartments were flooded, especially in the forward part of the ship, the only uncertainty in his mind was how long it would take to sink. Fortunately the design of the watertight compartments meant that the ship stayed on a relatively even keel which enabled most of the lifeboats to be launched even very late in the disaster. Ships with longitudinal watertight bulkheads like the Lusitania and Titanic’s later sister Britannic tended to capsize if damaged from a collision or from one side. This made it difficult or impossible to launch the boats and speeded up the sinking. Surprisingly this was serious problem for the much more recent Costa Concordia. If she had been designed like the Titanic she would probably have survived! So Titanic was a good design when you think about it, but she was run by people with staggering hubris. Smith was very experienced with ice conditions and he and his senior officers knew there was a risk in running at full speed in the conditions could see and feel. So why did they take such an unnecessary risk? I guess we’ll never know for sure but there are plenty of theories. Titanic will never be forgotten by naval architects, but it seems the unfolding events you illustrate and describe make sure that it will never be forgotten my human civilization. We’ll done guys! We need a new movie. The 1998 Titanic was so disrespectful, more like a romantic romp than a serious attempt to conjure up the passenger’s and crew’s experience. The film totally misses the nightmare aspect of the final plunge because Cameron has no subtlety and no poetry just noise, action, lights like his other action movies. It also misses the reported experience of people in the water and on the boats after the sinking. It’s a hugely important aspect of the story so much so that you could ditch the first half of Cameron’s movie and follow the survivors story through to the morning rescue and even through to the events in New York when various actors got hold of the story. What do you think.
I stayed up all night to watch it, as I live in the uk, with the time difference it can make it heard to watch the yearly ones from the USA but I thought this year I would do it I am so pleased I did very well done
I'm the great great nephew of Thomas Jubilee Mayzes, my great Grandfather's Brother. He was a stoker, (fireman). He survived the incident. Assumed to have been on lifeboat three. We surmise that his shift was probably over, and so he was assigned to assist passengers onto lifeboats... Then helped crew the #3 as a matter of duty... He didnt live a very long life afterwards. I hope with all my heart that he was honorable and survived by legitimate means...
Amazing work! My 4 year old son really enjoys watching. He likes to reenact the scenes with his toy Titanic that we purchased from the Titanic museum ;he’s been 3 times so far!
I woke up early to watch your video. Do you know it was the day before Easter. Anyway I watched the video, it was so heartbreaking, words can't describe how you feel while watching her sinking, while watching more than 1500 people dying. I'm not sure if I can watch it again next year! Thank you very much for this video and for sharing this day with us. The video was amazing and full with all details. Titanic 111 year anniversary.
I am crying... I can't help feel sorry for all those lost souls, and their families that had to get over this tragedy. May God bless them all. Thank you again for showing us the Titanic in all her glory and his she died. Love from Mexico City.
Beautiful work. From what I've seen, images on youtube, the ship is shown breaking apart above water. But from reports back then it went dowb whole and I believe these reports. Thank you for showing it this way.
In the animation is very good to see the correct break of the hull. The hull broke in just before and below of the 3rd Funnel, because below of the 3rd funnel were the boiler rooms 1 and 2 on the tank top and just behind of them was the high engine room.
A welcome novelty to see that all the portholes are not lit. I always thought that that made no sense. Ruth Becker said that all the lights had been on, but she can’t have been speaking literally.
3:37:36 Titanic cries out for her final time. "My passengers, I have tried my hardest to stay afloat. The time has come, I cannot hold it anymore, I'm too tired." It's almost like the ship snapping in half was like the ship was sacrificing it's heaviness just so that it could keep everyone out of the water as long as it possibly could. "Titanic wasn't just a ship... she had life." - Myself.
Cameron’s movie sinking is almost 90% to how honour and glory animated the updated sinking sequences. I always wondered if the officers just threw anyone on the lifeboats, women, kids and men would make it allot less chaos to fill those lifeboats
Yeah after many years of different theories applied, I was surprise to see that this one is closely resembled to Cameron's knowledge and the information they had at the time in 1995-1997 in preproduction of Titanic 1997, I'm looking forward to the next Titanic with James Cameron documentary and see if James have a new theory and put it into newest animation. I think Cameron's Titanic 1997 was almost correct, the only parts he wasn't aware of at the time, were the list, and didn't rise up to over 40 degree (stern rise) and the breaking in half happened in front of 3rd funnel, not inbetween 3rd and 4th funnel, so it is now like, back to being closer to the same as Titanic 1997.
I've said it before and I'll say it again; jaw-droppingly ASTOUNDING WORK went into this project, AND IT SHOWS!!!! TAKE A BOW, everyone!👏👏👏👏👏/5 Not sure if it would have been stopped or not, but if I was on that ship, I might have considered using a table as a floatation device (desperate times / desperate measures.)
Thank you so much for this amazing and sadly beautiful animation and your thoughtful, knowledgeable commentary. Those text boxes in particular were wonderful and welcome. All the work into researching and sourcing the music was sensational. Looking at the lifeboat statistics is quite shocking, to learn how under capacity all of them were - some incomprehensibly so. I would appreciate anyone putting me in the direction of any more specific work you have done on the lifeboats and who was in each one and what they did or did not do to try to help others. Or if this might be something you tackle in the future? Thanks for all your wonderful work!
Greetings from Berlin Germany. Late in the Night i realize, that the live Strem starts NOT at 23:40 GERMAN TIME XD so i tooked it to the next day GREAT WORK. I did not expekt to see the californian and the carpathia. Anyway off Topic: In the reason of you´r work i decided to take the sinking of the SS Atlantic in April the first, 1873, to play a little part on the Red Dead Redemption- Fanfiktion, that i am working on. No big Deal, but also by Sam, from Historic Travels, i choosed to give that Ship a little side faktor. Greetings from me Chris, watching your work from Berlin, Germany
I always love your walkthrough of the sinking each year. Though one slight criticism of this one is that there were a lot of monents where you guys were more focused on the animation rather than the events taking place, causing more events to be missed than in prior years
I ABSOLUTELY REALLY WHAT TO SAY THANK YOU TITANIC HONOR AND GLORY FOR EVERY YEAR FOR THE LIVESTREAMS FOR THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC EVERY ANNIVERSARYS I HAVE BEEN INTO THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC SINCE I WAS 5 YEARS OLD AND I AM 35 YEARS OLD I AM ABSOLUTELY PROUD TO BE PART OF THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC COMMUNITY
Depuis mon enfance l'histoire du Titanic m'a fasciné. Certainement par la beauté du paquebot, son peu de temps d'existence,les histoires qui ont entouré cette tragédie et la musique qui a accompagné son agonie
This was incredibly interesting I fell asleep through half only because of the time difference I struggle to stay awake but the whole program is just interesting I am a distance relative of a second class passenger jhon Henry Chapman his watch is in the Liverpool museum I've tried and tried to find more information but really don't know where to start from again extremely interesting
Do yourself a favor and turn off chat replay if you are watching this vod. What a bunch of entitled whiners. Great animation and I appreciate your commentary.
All but one survivor who noticed the funnel claimed to see it submerge standing. Even the exception said that the funnel was in the water when it fell; pushed back by the rising water.
Great stream. Really enjoyed it. The audio levels were quite out of whack, especially when interior water shots were being shown. Maybe lower it for commentary version and as it is just for the animation video. I look forward to next year :)
Carpathia was not the only ship, that was coming to help Titanic. It was just the first. For example: Birma eventually reached the given coordinates at 7:30 am, but realised the position given by Titanic must be incorrect because of the large amount of pack ice in the vicinity; they were still 13 nautical miles from where Titanic actually sank. Birma's telegraphy room picked up messages from RMS Carpathia reporting that they had rescued Titanic survivors, and Birma offered supplies. The response from Carpathia was "shut up". - from wiki
I didn't like that they put in caption 'Carpathia was the only ship that rush to Titanic's rescue' Carpathia wasn't the only one. Many officers at RMS Olympic worked under Captain Smith when he captained RMS Olympic for full year before Titanic was ready for her maiden voyage and he was transferred to RMS Titanic, RMS Olympic wanted to come and rescue the lives onboard of her sister ship, but I'm not sure WHO but Olympic officers were told to NOT come and rescue Titanic and give them PTSD of being on identical ship to the sunken Titanic, which make sense yes, but Carpathia wasn't the only one that was coming to rescue, many other ships WANTED to come but they were either too far away or, in RMS Olympic's case, too identical to RMS Titanic. But big shame to the captain of SS Californian, closest ship just able to see the distress rockets and ignored it, could have rescued many more than 1600 lives loss.
Every time i see the sink i start to cry. Feel so bad for those people trying to survive in vain... anyway thank you for this accurate representation of a terrible moment in navy history.
Many thanks for the Livestream and new animation. Please make a Livestream in the next year again.The next year is interesting for a new live stream because: the next year has a number of the year interval, which can also be read in the year 1912 if the 9 is removed. The next year will be a leap year like 111 years ago, and the sequence of the weekdays will then be identical to 1912.
I just read that Harold Bride happened to know and be good friends with the wireless operator on the Carpathia, and his name was also Harold. Small world, especially back then.
![The Complete Story of Destiny! From origins to Shadowkeep [Timeline and Lore explained]](/img/n.gif)
111 years later and the world is still fascinated by Titanic and her story. Stunning animation, definitely one of the best out there.
Titanic sinking was in many ways the end of an era. A peaceful, hopeful era. Like with the collapse of the Twin Towers, the (Western) world would never be quite the same again.
I loved learning about it in history and the certain arguments about who’s fault it was. But enough about that. The titanic has always been something I come back to and read about. A historical a event that shook the world
@@timonsolusI can’t even think of a reply lol accept that I agree and I was only a few months old when 9/11 happened but it was an event that changed the world
The Titanic was a male ship.
@@WeatherHappens : No it wasn’t. All British ships are regarded as female.
Something that sends chills down my spine is the moment the ship was fully submerged. Witnesses said it was just pitch black and all you can hear is screaming and the twisting metal below the water. Just thinking about that monstrosity being so huge that you can hear it underwater freaks me out for some reason.
This will sound awful, but I've always wanted to hear that sound.
The ocean is huge and that you can still hear its cries underwater is crazy.
Like, what the f*ck.
What would that sound like.
Also, to think about all of that darkness, the scotland road, as it fell in obscurity, the water having completely filled it... insane. My mind cannot comprehend it.
The whole ship really, you know? Every room shrouded forever and filled with cold, unforgiving liquid, plus all of its little substances. What would it feel like to have stayed inside the Titanic and be able to survive the pressure? What would it feel to live in such a ship ghost and to experience its free fall?
There were reports of a loud boom or explosion in addition to the iron being bent and twisted as well. Likely the stern imploding shortly after sinking
There you go; ua-cam.com/video/EyN7B9avqSQ/v-deo.html
Terrifying, in the pitch dark, to hear those moans and roars, the muffled explosions echoing up from hundreds, then thousands of feet below you…
@@angeryrat Insane.
18:43 Stream start
55:52 Iceberg collision
1:18:49 Lifeboats preparation
1:51:40 First boat going down
3:17:10 Last boat launched
3:30:55 Breaking in half
3:37:42 Dissapearing under water
3:39:07 Animation end
Bless you ❤
Godspeed, sir.
6 minutes breaked in half, I don't understand why.
Titanic broke up in 2:18 AM amd fully disappeared only 2 minutes after that.
Why the creators decided to do the breaking up so long?
@@armenianmapper3168 Good point.
@@armenianmapper3168 THG have always been very liberal with the timeline. In this animation they have the forecastle deck going under at 1:45, when that was the time that just the well deck was flooding.
This whole OceanGate tragedy has reminded me that the queen of the seas still down there and obviously still claiming souls. How the tragedy ended reminded me of the beginning of the Cameron movie when Brock says, "These windows are 9 inches thick and if they go, it's sayonara in two microseconds.“
So I had to watch the scene again and the Titanic got me back.
Right now, I'm sitting here building the Titanic Lego set, with over 10,000 pieces and listening to this live stream. And I just wanted to let you know that right now there's no place I'd rather be and there's nothing I'd rather be doing. Keep up the nice work!
It’s achieved somewhat of an otherworldly status. It has become a legend. We love that boat and are morbidly curious/struck by the amount of life lost aboard such a magnificent piece of engineering and opulence.
Titanic Set only has 9,000 Pieces though. :/
Arrogance and the beilef by Stockton rush that his submersible Titan was far more advanced than any other deep sea submersible which he also quoted carbon fibre is far stronger than Titanium or any material .... Anyway titanic isn't on the north Atlantic seabed by a accident titanic sank because of arrogance by the belief that she was unsinkable and would spot the dangers that lie ahead .... Same applies to oceangate and the sub standard submersible titan ... Anyway cool live stream of titanic sad I missed it oh well I'm here anyway 😂
The Lego Titanic set costs a whopping £569.99
Thanks lots to the Titanic Honor and Glory's team for the incredible job that they provide. Titanic will live as long as it animates our hearts. Go on, Titanic fans, let's pass on our passion !❤
witness account from a danish survivor - "I shared a cabin with three other young girls, two English and one Swedish. We went to bed early on April 14th because third-class passengers had to leave the deck by 10 pm. We woke up to a bump after half an hour, but quickly fell asleep again.
At 12:30, there was a knock on the door, and my uncle said, "You better put on a coat and come up to the deck"... so I put on my coat over my nightgown and went up to the deck.
We had hit an iceberg and there was music in the first-class salon. There was no panic, not even when the lifeboats were lowered, no one was in a hurry to get into them, women and children went into the boats first.
Once we were in the water and a good distance away from the Titanic, we could still hear the orchestra playing. One person said it was the hymn "Nearer My God to Thee". I didn't know it as it is an English hymn. There were six crew members rowing the lifeboat. The sea was completely calm like a mirror. We were surrounded by other lifeboats, and there were many icebergs around us.
The disaster happened before anyone expected it. With horror, we heard an indescribable noise and screams from a thousand voices coming from this giant ship, it split in two, rose towards the sky, and disappeared. We sat petrified and watched it all happen, what was worse than the screams was the silence that followed, it was terrible." - Carla Christine Nielsine Andersen-Jensen
Interesting. Where did you find that?
Thank you for sharing that haunting survivor story. I can't imagine the terror and the horror.
Imagine sitting in the lifeboat, Titanic gone beneath the cold Atlantic water and people screaming in distance.. and then the silence takes over, until there is no sound out there except water bouncing against the lifeboat. I am glad that the Olympic was far away from Titanic's sinking. Seeing Titanic's identical sister arriving at the spot where her sister Titanic went down just a bit earlier would have given the survivors a very severe traumatic experience.
@@Peekarica we don’t actually know but it could be possible
@@PeekaricaIm sure they would rather see that immediately than to possibly freeze to death in a boat adrift at cold pacific ocean waters.
I like that they dedicated the stream to *all* passengers aboard the ship of whom none are alive today.
An incredible evening! Thank you THG team for putting tonight's remembrance and recreation together. It goes down in my book as one of the best live-stream experiences I have had on youtube!
I have watched these since I was a little kid. I now know how much of a impact it has had on my life.
Truly a beautiful animation they just keep getting better.
3:31:30 That view of the stern from behind a piece of pack ice.... sobering.
It's so great to see one of the popular channels finally get the fourth funnel's collapse correct!
The funnel canting up in the water perfectly explains Dillon seeing it cant toward him not when when the stern righted, but rather "When she went down." And also why he later doubted whether he even saw it fall.
It also perfectly explains why several people - Jack Thayer, John Collins, Ida Hippach, Edward Buley, George Crowe, etc - thought that the fourth funnel went underwater still standing, as it would already be difficult to see, but then submerge only a few seconds later.
Much of an improvement!
It’s frustrating how people overlook the survivor’s accounts of how the Titanic went down
@@eddieroskelly1826, I absolutely agree! The collapse of the the fourth funnel (or rather lack of anyone except Dillon seeing it) happens to be one of the most overlooked elements of them.
I think it's just a desire to stick to familiarity, but hopefully this video will spread the idea and what survivors actually saw.
I'm hoping to get across the importance of witness testimonies in my updated survivor account animation series that I will start soon.
I agree! Seeing as the stern settled back during the break up (rather than a dramatic fall) I can’t think of a reason why the fourth funnel would have fallen with the guys wires holding the funnel in place.
ua-cam.com/video/RvEqb4mgTiE/v-deo.html
This! I came to say exactly this!
Thank you TTHG for this evening and morning. This was one of the best titanic sinking I’ve watched and I am looking forwards for next year.
This is the most accurate Titanic sinking I have ever seen. The small details only an expert would recognize stuns me
Easily the best, most believable depiction of the break up that I've seen to date
A stunning new animation, and great to finally see some new interior flooding animations which were truly chilling. The improvement in the water quality on previous animations is fantastic. It was interesting to see that at the end, the fourth funnel does not collapse when the ship breaks up - and the entire stern section seems to stick up at a very high angle before the final plunge similar to the '97 movie - in recent years I thought it had been agreed that this did not happen and such a high angle was ony reached in the last few seconds.
Also glad to not see the Stern roll onto it's side like the past few HG animations, lol.
Definitely the best real time sinking animation you have done great job guys really enjoyed watching it 👍
Amazing work lads. That end sequence was rather horrifying, actually brought a tear to my eye! Can't begin to imagine the horror of the last 20 minutes or so.
I think this is the first time I felt the raw horror of the final moments in a real-time.
I think all the real-times - this, Titanic Animations, OASOG/Tom - are good and have their own strengths. But this was the first time I felt the scope.
It’s the haunting silence w/ only the cutout humans imo😢
You can't really hate Titanic Animation's one. He built the model, by himself, in just about one year (THG can't finish one in ten with multiple people being paid), hand-animated every single person (their whole body moves) and did the rendering too.
Thank yall for another wonderful stream. This always pays the respect to those who have passed on and giving one of, if not the most detailed telling of the events that occurred
I walked through Project 401 the other night for the first time and was like a kid in a candy store. Your projects are historically groundbreaking. The fact I could explore an early 1900’s ship I’ve loved my entire life as if I was there is so immensely surreal. Thank you so much for doing what I dreamed someone of doing forever. Letting me live the dream of experiencing that great piece of engineering.
Love the stream and the music. Watching the ship sailing in daylight and looks amazing along with the music.
This "game" was made with passion and heart..! My sincere congratulations! I'm waiting for you on Steam!
There are a bunch of real time sinking videos, but I think this is my favorite because the animation is the best and the narrators are terrific. You guys really did a great job. It must’ve been a lot of work. It’s a tragic event, it’s hard to be excited about it, but this is just such a great record. RIP to all those lost.
One of the most haunting animations of the final plunge I've seen since I started watching these anniversary livestreams in June of 2020, I was actually startled when the glass dome shattered and water began poring in from above, even though I knew it was coming the animation of it left me in shock. Well done all of you 👏🏼
Many thanks for this livestream. Incredible animation. Amazing details provided. We appreciate all you do.
Great work guys! Especially the break up scene! It was really terrifying. Overall great work and well animated.
i honestly did not expect you guys to straight up recreate some of the 1997 movie shots in this animation and it honestly put me a smile, this was such a good animation, my only complain is that Harold Bride who fell under collapsible B was not recreated (at least, i didn't saw him)
harold bride has one of the craziest survival stories. him and the baker. charles joughin
111 years had passed, and Titanic is STILL remembered for her tragic fate (likely because of the 1997 movie), even though there actually were disasters worse than it, such as the forgotten but deadly Wilhelm Gustloff sinking, which had over 9000 deaths compared to Titanic's 1600+.
Graphics are a nice improvement compared to the original video.
Been joining James' lives since 2020 and found you through him. I'm so glad you have this up since I didn't watch it live (though I had it on mute to enjoy the animation, it was stunning). All of your guys' work on this is phenomenal.
I loved the way you showed the sinking. As a titanic fan for life. Im glad that people 111 years later we are still honoring the lives that were lost. May there story’s never be forgotten
Sadly I couldn't catch the live as it was in the middle of the night for me, but glad I can still watch it today. RIP all those who perished.
The most realistic I've yet seen from THG, amazing work!
it’s so amazing now seeing the live chat when the ship splits. the comments were rolling in!
Absolutely sensational! So imaginatively done - the final sequence is really horrific!
The best part for me was the showing of the californian and the view it could have had of titanic.
Thank you so much for this. I wondered my whole life how it could have looked.
Keep it going
Incredible work, and it keeps getting better and better every year. Already looks this great, imagine what this might look like five years from now or two years from now.
Thank you SO MUCH for this!
I'd never realised so much time passed before the first distress call was sent or the first lifeboat was lowered.
Also didn't know that Land of Hope and Glory was one of the pieces played by the band.
Thank you!
What an astonishing effort by you guys. So well done, in every aspect. Phenomenly sad and sobering watch. Thank you.
Lovely stream! See you all next year!
God lads, ye did an amazing job with this, there are so many fantastic eery shots used , love the overhead shot looking down as the bridge goes under, and that distant shot after the break up is very eery.
Incredible tribute gentlemen. Much respect. I really love the 401 numbers written on a propeller blades. Amazing devotion to details...
This simulation just gets more amazing. Some crazy intense shots. Thank you!
Thanks again THG team for another year of amazing work. The only feedback I can think of (because everything else is perfect ; ) ) is that the sound is kind of low. That's all. Looking forward to next year!
Good job! The animation gets better every year.
Thomas Andrews was the Harland and Wolff naval architect who inspired me to become a naval architect and shipbuilder. You wonder what was going through his mind when he was spotted running up the grand staircase 3 steps at a time? We do flooding calculations to make sure that the ship does not sink below the margin line. So, as you say, once he knew how many adjacent compartments were flooded, especially in the forward part of the ship, the only uncertainty in his mind was how long it would take to sink. Fortunately the design of the watertight compartments meant that the ship stayed on a relatively even keel which enabled most of the lifeboats to be launched even very late in the disaster. Ships with longitudinal watertight bulkheads like the Lusitania and Titanic’s later sister Britannic tended to capsize if damaged from a collision or from one side. This made it difficult or impossible to launch the boats and speeded up the sinking. Surprisingly this was serious problem for the much more recent Costa Concordia. If she had been designed like the Titanic she would probably have survived! So Titanic was a good design when you think about it, but she was run by people with staggering hubris. Smith was very experienced with ice conditions and he and his senior officers knew there was a risk in running at full speed in the conditions could see and feel. So why did they take such an unnecessary risk? I guess we’ll never know for sure but there are plenty of theories. Titanic will never be forgotten by naval architects, but it seems the unfolding events you illustrate and describe make sure that it will never be forgotten my human civilization. We’ll done guys! We need a new movie. The 1998 Titanic was so disrespectful, more like a romantic romp than a serious attempt to conjure up the passenger’s and crew’s experience. The film totally misses the nightmare aspect of the final plunge because Cameron has no subtlety and no poetry just noise, action, lights like his other action movies. It also misses the reported experience of people in the water and on the boats after the sinking. It’s a hugely important aspect of the story so much so that you could ditch the first half of Cameron’s movie and follow the survivors story through to the morning rescue and even through to the events in New York when various actors got hold of the story. What do you think.
I don’t understand how collapsible D was lowered less than half full with just 20 mins remaining. It’s crazy
I stayed up all night to watch it, as I live in the uk, with the time difference it can make it heard to watch the yearly ones from the USA but I thought this year I would do it I am so pleased I did very well done
Great stream as always! Looking forward to many more future updates!
Absolutely amazing! I was there for most of the stream and loved every minute
I'm the great great nephew of Thomas Jubilee Mayzes, my great Grandfather's Brother. He was a stoker, (fireman). He survived the incident. Assumed to have been on lifeboat three. We surmise that his shift was probably over, and so he was assigned to assist passengers onto lifeboats... Then helped crew the #3 as a matter of duty... He didnt live a very long life afterwards. I hope with all my heart that he was honorable and survived by legitimate means...
titanic 111th anniversary. #neverforget 🙏💐
Amazing work! My 4 year old son really enjoys watching. He likes to reenact the scenes with his toy Titanic that we purchased from the Titanic museum ;he’s been 3 times so far!
I woke up early to watch your video. Do you know it was the day before Easter. Anyway I watched the video, it was so heartbreaking, words can't describe how you feel while watching her sinking, while watching more than 1500 people dying. I'm not sure if I can watch it again next year! Thank you very much for this video and for sharing this day with us. The video was amazing and full with all details. Titanic 111 year anniversary.
I am crying... I can't help feel sorry for all those lost souls, and their families that had to get over this tragedy. May God bless them all. Thank you again for showing us the Titanic in all her glory and his she died. Love from Mexico City.
A beautifully put together tribute as always, well done and thank you THG team.
Beautiful work. From what I've seen, images on youtube, the ship is shown breaking apart above water. But from reports back then it went dowb whole and I believe these reports. Thank you for showing it this way.
In the animation is very good to see the correct break of the hull. The hull broke in just before and below of the 3rd Funnel, because below of the 3rd funnel were the boiler rooms 1 and 2 on the tank top and just behind of them was the high engine room.
A welcome novelty to see that all the portholes are not lit. I always thought that that made no sense. Ruth Becker said that all the lights had been on, but she can’t have been speaking literally.
Thank you for this extraordinary stream. Bravo!
It was nice to be able to see the live stream. Such details.
Lovely stream great work and see you all next year thanks for all
3:37:36 Titanic cries out for her final time. "My passengers, I have tried my hardest to stay afloat. The time has come, I cannot hold it anymore, I'm too tired."
It's almost like the ship snapping in half was like the ship was sacrificing it's heaviness just so that it could keep everyone out of the water as long as it possibly could.
"Titanic wasn't just a ship... she had life." - Myself.
Cameron’s movie sinking is almost 90% to how honour and glory animated the updated sinking sequences. I always wondered if the officers just threw anyone on the lifeboats, women, kids and men would make it allot less chaos to fill those lifeboats
Yeah after many years of different theories applied, I was surprise to see that this one is closely resembled to Cameron's knowledge and the information they had at the time in 1995-1997 in preproduction of Titanic 1997, I'm looking forward to the next Titanic with James Cameron documentary and see if James have a new theory and put it into newest animation. I think Cameron's Titanic 1997 was almost correct, the only parts he wasn't aware of at the time, were the list, and didn't rise up to over 40 degree (stern rise) and the breaking in half happened in front of 3rd funnel, not inbetween 3rd and 4th funnel, so it is now like, back to being closer to the same as Titanic 1997.
Here and in Cameron's versions, the ship loses it's lights at different moments.
I've said it before and I'll say it again; jaw-droppingly ASTOUNDING WORK went into this project, AND IT SHOWS!!!! TAKE A BOW, everyone!👏👏👏👏👏/5
Not sure if it would have been stopped or not, but if I was on that ship, I might have considered using a table as a floatation device (desperate times / desperate measures.)
I'm only a little while into it, but I'm really enjoying this commentary version
I begged my family to go to the titanic museum today. I just now knew that the ship sunk 111 years ago today. Wow. Weird coincidence 😅.
Incredible and terrifying recreation. Well done guys.
Συγχαρητήρια για την καλή δουλειά! Κάθε χρόνο γίνεται όλο και καλύτερο. Συνεχίστε!
Cant wait until the Main real time upload
Thank you so much for this amazing and sadly beautiful animation and your thoughtful, knowledgeable commentary. Those text boxes in particular were wonderful and welcome. All the work into researching and sourcing the music was sensational. Looking at the lifeboat statistics is quite shocking, to learn how under capacity all of them were - some incomprehensibly so. I would appreciate anyone putting me in the direction of any more specific work you have done on the lifeboats and who was in each one and what they did or did not do to try to help others. Or if this might be something you tackle in the future? Thanks for all your wonderful work!
I missed this because I'm European. Nice gift to wake up to!
Well done guys, for the time and effort you put into this video!!!
111 Aniversario Titanic 🙏🏻💐
Thank you very much…the detail is awesome!!!
beautiful stream as always! see you darlings next year :)
mans really said 'spoiler alert: it sinks.' 🤣
i appreciate the inclusion of the souls evac'ed/still on board.
Titanic the ship of dreams now the Ship of a deadly nightmare and a haunting memory.
Greetings from Berlin Germany.
Late in the Night i realize, that the live Strem starts NOT at 23:40 GERMAN TIME XD so i tooked it to the next day
GREAT WORK. I did not expekt to see the californian and the carpathia.
Anyway off Topic: In the reason of you´r work i decided to take the sinking of the SS Atlantic in April the first, 1873, to play a little part on the Red Dead Redemption- Fanfiktion, that i am working on. No big Deal, but also by Sam, from Historic Travels, i choosed to give that Ship a little side faktor.
Greetings from me
Chris, watching your work from Berlin, Germany
Looking forward to this year's version ❤❤❤
What happened to the livestream of the 111th anniversary of Rms Titanic Sinking by Part Time Explorer!
the final 8 minutes are nuts
I always love your walkthrough of the sinking each year. Though one slight criticism of this one is that there were a lot of monents where you guys were more focused on the animation rather than the events taking place, causing more events to be missed than in prior years
I ABSOLUTELY REALLY WHAT TO SAY THANK YOU TITANIC HONOR AND GLORY FOR EVERY YEAR FOR THE LIVESTREAMS FOR THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC EVERY ANNIVERSARYS I HAVE BEEN INTO THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC SINCE I WAS 5 YEARS OLD AND I AM 35 YEARS OLD I AM ABSOLUTELY PROUD TO BE PART OF THE UNSINKABLE RMS TITANIC COMMUNITY
Depuis mon enfance l'histoire du Titanic m'a fasciné. Certainement par la beauté du paquebot, son peu de temps d'existence,les histoires qui ont entouré cette tragédie et la musique qui a accompagné son agonie
This was incredibly interesting I fell asleep through half only because of the time difference I struggle to stay awake but the whole program is just interesting I am a distance relative of a second class passenger jhon Henry Chapman his watch is in the Liverpool museum I've tried and tried to find more information but really don't know where to start from again extremely interesting
HONOR Y GLORIA!!! ❤❤❤
Honneur et gloire.
Just stunning and moving. Thankyou.
Watching the virtual sinking of a ship that was described as virtually unsinkable
Something that had to chilling. Was the clear sky and calm waters.
I WAS CRYING/ROWING ALL THE THE TIME TO SEE THE VIDEO
Do yourself a favor and turn off chat replay if you are watching this vod. What a bunch of entitled whiners. Great animation and I appreciate your commentary.
Rest in peace titanic
I never knew that the Titanic Fourth Funnel was still there even after the break up 😮
All but one survivor who noticed the funnel claimed to see it submerge standing. Even the exception said that the funnel was in the water when it fell; pushed back by the rising water.
Great stream. Really enjoyed it.
The audio levels were quite out of whack, especially when interior water shots were being shown. Maybe lower it for commentary version and as it is just for the animation video.
I look forward to next year :)
The length of time for the stern to sink! Wow!
Great job ! Thanks for all
Carpathia was not the only ship, that was coming to help Titanic. It was just the first. For example:
Birma eventually reached the given coordinates at 7:30 am, but realised the position given by Titanic must be incorrect because of the large amount of pack ice in the vicinity; they were still 13 nautical miles from where Titanic actually sank. Birma's telegraphy room picked up messages from RMS Carpathia reporting that they had rescued Titanic survivors, and Birma offered supplies. The response from Carpathia was "shut up". - from wiki
I didn't like that they put in caption 'Carpathia was the only ship that rush to Titanic's rescue' Carpathia wasn't the only one. Many officers at RMS Olympic worked under Captain Smith when he captained RMS Olympic for full year before Titanic was ready for her maiden voyage and he was transferred to RMS Titanic, RMS Olympic wanted to come and rescue the lives onboard of her sister ship, but I'm not sure WHO but Olympic officers were told to NOT come and rescue Titanic and give them PTSD of being on identical ship to the sunken Titanic, which make sense yes, but Carpathia wasn't the only one that was coming to rescue, many other ships WANTED to come but they were either too far away or, in RMS Olympic's case, too identical to RMS Titanic. But big shame to the captain of SS Californian, closest ship just able to see the distress rockets and ignored it, could have rescued many more than 1600 lives loss.
Every time i see the sink i start to cry. Feel so bad for those people trying to survive in vain... anyway thank you for this accurate representation of a terrible moment in navy history.
Many thanks for the Livestream and new animation. Please make a Livestream in the next year again.The next year is interesting for a new live stream because: the next year has a number of the year interval, which can also be read in the year 1912 if the 9 is removed. The next year will be a leap year like 111 years ago, and the sequence of the weekdays will then be identical to 1912.
Next year is the April 15th a Monday too (two weeks after the Easter Monday).
I just read that Harold Bride happened to know and be good friends with the wireless operator on the Carpathia, and his name was also Harold. Small world, especially back then.