Orthodoxy and Smoking

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 106

  • @antonvinokurov1772
    @antonvinokurov1772 Рік тому +37

    “There is no reason for us to increase the number of battles that we need to fight” is a very good line.

  • @niki3773
    @niki3773 4 роки тому +109

    My mother used to smoke a lot before she had me. After she prayed to the Theotokos, she gave it up in a day and never touched a cigarette again. To this day she cannot stand the smell of smoke. Most Holy Theotokos, pray for us all

  • @bsdnfraje
    @bsdnfraje 4 роки тому +64

    I quit occasionally smoking as a catechumen, because it is so plainly regarded as a sin. But it was much later before it occurred to me that my constant snus habit was also equally sinful. Everyone always points out the health problems, but finally in an examination of conscience I read pointed out it wasted money that could be given as alms.
    And now I'm 6 weeks without nicotine. Pray for me!

    • @Branwolfe1
      @Branwolfe1 4 роки тому +4

      God bless you!

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +13

      Thank God! Keep up the good fight!

    • @eldermillennial8330
      @eldermillennial8330 4 роки тому +4

      What I want to know is, were Saints saying it was sinful even before the cancer connection was widely understood? As for wasting money, Chesterton would have likely said that sharing good tobacco with a poor man would have been as good as the alms.

    • @OrthoKarter
      @OrthoKarter Рік тому

      God bless you!

    • @OrthoKarter
      @OrthoKarter Рік тому

      @@BanterWithBojanAmen!

  • @justinhutchison6624
    @justinhutchison6624 4 роки тому +58

    “If God wanted us to smoke He would have given us a chimney” - Patriarch Pavle

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +8

      Precisely!

    • @robertwaguespack9414
      @robertwaguespack9414 4 роки тому +3

      In his days if you had a cough the doctor might prescribe a certain brand of cigarette to cure you

    • @e.clinton
      @e.clinton 4 місяці тому

      @@BanterWithBojan Hi.
      Another Orthodox like you, named Andrew Wilson (a guest of "The Whatever Podcast"), smokes cigarettes as a chimney and already laughs, mocking all Christians that try to correct/rebuke him. He said that they don't know what they're talking about and using a ridiculous fallacy, that there's zero commandment or Bible verses that are literally against it. I just researched what the Orthodox Church says about it, and I already found on UA-cam, many Orthodox's channels as you, that contradict what Andrew Wilson said. Why does A. Wilson say that your Church has a license for it (I paraphrase; he never said this sentence) if all of you say the opposite?

  • @TheSpekkel1
    @TheSpekkel1 3 роки тому +24

    I asked our priest about pipe smoking, but got answer for smoking in general and his answer was that smoking tobacco isn't a sin in itself, but addiction is, as it takes focus out from what actually is important. So I don't stress about my occasional pipe smoking, but of course during lent it's forbidden, so I don't do it.

    • @Max-xf1mw
      @Max-xf1mw Рік тому +1

      I'm a smoker and want to give it up. I've already given up smoking weed. Smoking dangerously harms the body that God gave us. The harm vastly outweighs the small amount of pleasure. That's enough for me and I intend to quit soon!

    • @MitigateStress
      @MitigateStress Рік тому

      @@Max-xf1mwgiving up weed is very challenging for myself, how did you do it?

    • @juanmap9213
      @juanmap9213 4 місяці тому

      @@MitigateStress In my case, working out and praying, mostly. Also fasting and going to the Liturgy

  • @richardjohnson5588
    @richardjohnson5588 4 роки тому +61

    >didn't show hands
    Downvoted, unsubscribed, disavowed and anathematized

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +37

      Hands were heavily implied in the video.

    • @tsasuyeda
      @tsasuyeda 4 роки тому +1

      @@BanterWithBojan actually, I saw you "talking with your hands" in several frames...

  • @JaythePandaren
    @JaythePandaren 4 роки тому +23

    A Orthodox friend of mine told me a story on how her friend gave up smoking after he was baptized into the church. She told me after his baptism the man was on the verge of vomiting and when he did black tar came out of his mouth and after that he stopped smoking. Not only did God Renew him but he also detoxed his soul by cleaning the necotine out of his system. And no lol he didn't vomet in church. XD

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +14

      An amazing miracle!
      I forgot to mention an acquaintance of mine. Her spiritual father told her to stop smoking, she said 'Amen' and stopped there and then, cold turkey.

    • @JaythePandaren
      @JaythePandaren 3 роки тому +5

      @@BanterWithBojan Wow that is what I call great obedience

  • @russellhoward3866
    @russellhoward3866 2 роки тому +10

    I'm so helplessly addicted to cigarettes. I've tried quitting cold turkey many, many times, and have had success for a month or two many times as well. Every single time my wife & I have gotten into horrible arguments & I've started again. Failing at quitting so many times has taken a huge toll on me, & I don't think I can even do it again without a miracle. Honestly, I don't know what to do.

    • @IndiaNumberOneCoubtry
      @IndiaNumberOneCoubtry Рік тому +2

      Seek guidance from a local spiritual father. God bless you Russell

    • @russellhoward3866
      @russellhoward3866 Рік тому

      @@IndiaNumberOneCoubtry Thanks, but I've done that for years. Since Friday, I'm two compound fractures in my leg, 2 fractured ribs, & one fractured ankle closer to quitting cigarettes, lol!

    • @benjamin6776
      @benjamin6776 Рік тому

      How did it go?

    • @russellhoward3866
      @russellhoward3866 Рік тому +6

      @@benjamin6776 I'm no longer addicted to cigarettes/nicotine & blown away by God's sense of humor, so to speak. Hard to smoke with an injury like that. It's scary how decisive God is. Obviously nobody wants an indecisive God, but wow, that was intense... okay, you know?

  • @simsandwins8998
    @simsandwins8998 Рік тому +4

    Im watching this as im preparing myself to quit smoking tomorrow for lent…. God help me

  • @mfinchina__117
    @mfinchina__117 4 роки тому +5

    A random comment -- you could smoke on international flights well into the 90's. I flew to Germany in 1993 and remember looking toward the back of the plane, which was the smoking section. By the end of the flight, there was so much smoke in the air that you could see it. It was disgusting!

  • @tyneshatalley8094
    @tyneshatalley8094 9 місяців тому +1

    "There is no need for us to increase our passions"
    Brilliant

  • @EclecticLove
    @EclecticLove 4 роки тому +7

    Glad to be the first here, love your videos!

  • @bsdnfraje
    @bsdnfraje 4 роки тому +7

    One reason I come here, Bojan, is because you are just a guy on the internet, and make no bones about it. I imagine you struggle with humility same as anyone else, but it speaks well every time you say, sincerely, "Im just some guy on the internet."

  • @j.s0n
    @j.s0n Рік тому +1

    i get so happy watching your videos man I don’t know why

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  Рік тому +1

      Neither do I! :D

    • @QuotedOrthodoxy
      @QuotedOrthodoxy 7 місяців тому

      @@BanterWithBojanneither do I but I get excited too! :D😀

    • @QuotedOrthodoxy
      @QuotedOrthodoxy 7 місяців тому

      @@BanterWithBojanwow I am a year late to responding to this comment 😬

  • @johnpaulhumphrey2981
    @johnpaulhumphrey2981 4 роки тому +16

    I read the description.
    >There is no need to increase the battles that we must fight.
    Would have liked the video twice if I could.

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +7

      With sockpuppet accounts, all things are possible

    • @johnpaulhumphrey2981
      @johnpaulhumphrey2981 4 роки тому

      @@BanterWithBojan But if youtube found out they might De-recommend your video :)

  • @DrAlexandrius
    @DrAlexandrius 4 роки тому +3

    Regarding the talk about smoking not having an equivalent in nature. I believe smoking starts out connected with boredom or curiosity, but then devolves into a physical and mental addiction

  • @elizabethshaw734
    @elizabethshaw734 4 роки тому +7

    I smoked a great deal for a very long time and I quit 8 years ago! :-)

    • @normalbuerger
      @normalbuerger 4 роки тому

      I don't want to smoke, but I have nothing I do want instead

    • @makida9908
      @makida9908 3 роки тому

      Happy for u!

    • @randalejetmagalit1198
      @randalejetmagalit1198 2 роки тому +2

      @@normalbuerger Pray. Intimacy with the Breath of God will always be better than the breath of smokers. Stay strong out there. Take care of yourself, and others, as much as you can. God Blsss you.

  • @Jupiter__001_
    @Jupiter__001_ 4 роки тому +7

    I usually read the description on your videos, and on a number of others as well. It occurs to me, how did the past and present tenses of "to read" end up being spelled the same?

  • @robertwaguespack9414
    @robertwaguespack9414 4 роки тому +7

    When Chesterton was alive, medical knowledge wasn't what it was as it was today.

  • @buzuxi
    @buzuxi 2 роки тому +5

    Most Orthodox are smokers. Go to the Balkans or to Russia everyone smokes. Greece has the highest amount of smokers in all of Europe

  • @whitecloud-so1gk
    @whitecloud-so1gk 4 роки тому +2

    Whether Saint Nicolas of Serbia smoked or not isn't completely clear. Some people claim he did, some claim he didn't

  • @ktanner438
    @ktanner438 4 роки тому +3

    This is what peak Serb looks like. You may not like it, but this is what it is.

  • @clebs1261
    @clebs1261 7 місяців тому +1

    Well the church indeed have incense, and yes it's very similar to smoking because you inhale smoke from burned plants. This has been done one way or another both in sacred and profane settings all around the world since forever. Cigarettes are mostly useless though I agree, especially if one smokes everyday.

  • @LNR65
    @LNR65 Рік тому +1

    I struggle with smoking, pray for me brethren.

    • @kewinsotto2911
      @kewinsotto2911 7 місяців тому

      Did you quit? When I converted to Jesus Christ I was a heavy smoker, but suddenly all of it shuts down, I couldn't bear smoking, it was disgusting, I didn't do anything to quit, but God did.
      I promised to not smoke again because it is a bridge to my past life, my sinful life, but here I am, wondering if it is a sin or is it to be addicted to it a sin, thinking to myself if it's okay to smoke a cig once upon a time and forgive myself of the past and make peace with the sinful me as Jesus did...

    • @beautifulwhitecat
      @beautifulwhitecat 3 місяці тому

      Lord have mercy. Go cold turkey and never return to it.

  • @nicku2584
    @nicku2584 2 роки тому +1

    What do we think of imported premium hand rolled cigars? Reason being, we know cigarettes are loaded with added cancerous chemicals ( just like most food in the west). But I believe smoking a cigar ( you don’t inhale) is something completely different. Any body have thoughts? Thank you

    • @Max-xf1mw
      @Max-xf1mw Рік тому

      Inhaling smoke into the mouth is enough to cause mouth cancer. I've got to get rid of my smoking addiction but we can't pretend it's something that it's not. Smoking is dangerously harmful to the body God gave us. End of story.

  • @highviewbarbell
    @highviewbarbell 2 роки тому +4

    I think very high quality pipe tobacco can be a truly useful thing for contemplative prayer, and it's certainly not the incense of the devil. Cigarettes on the other hand, are truly evil

  • @nguyenle42
    @nguyenle42 2 роки тому

    I would place smoking under the sense of taste. That is the main reason why I smoke. The other reason is because it gives me opportunities to have deep conversations with other people

  • @thedreadtyger
    @thedreadtyger 4 роки тому +3

    I love St Nikolai Velimirovic even more now.
    Your body is a temple, but what is a temple without incense?

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +4

      Pay close attention that it's not the strange incense of Exodus 30. :D

    • @thedreadtyger
      @thedreadtyger 4 роки тому

      @@BanterWithBojan i have not yet, like Nadab and Abihu, caught fire.

    • @nguyenle42
      @nguyenle42 2 роки тому +1

      It is better to smoke in this life than to smoke in the next

  • @maxcarvalho9071
    @maxcarvalho9071 4 роки тому +1

    Hey Bojan, would you do a video commenting on the alleged misogyny of Scriptures, Church Fathers and Christian tradition in general?

  • @christophersnedeker
    @christophersnedeker Рік тому

    I tried smoking a pipe a couple of times but I threw up both times, even afterwords when I got a few puffs in it didn't taste that good.

  • @Joshualbatross
    @Joshualbatross 4 роки тому +1

    What is the chant at the end?

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +1

      "Spirit of Fire" by Jesse Gallagher

    • @Joshualbatross
      @Joshualbatross 4 роки тому

      @@BanterWithBojan Thank you Bojan! God bless you!

  • @n8g496
    @n8g496 Рік тому

    Day 2. Pray for me!!! 🙏🙏🙏

  • @gid3on
    @gid3on 3 роки тому +1

    I used to be a smoker. I have smoked on planes in the 90's! (I don't smoke anymore. Like Ace Ventura says, it's a filthy habbit ;-) )

  • @patrickrowan6406
    @patrickrowan6406 4 роки тому +1

    Hey can you do a video Saint Nicholas the Passion-Bearer

  • @MrPanchoak
    @MrPanchoak 4 роки тому +3

    It is completely illogical that the secondhand smoke is as horrible as we are told by the antismoking Nazis.
    That said, i quit over 30 years ago and I still dont have a Porsche. However i DO have a wife!! Maybe THATS why i still dont have a fancy car🤣🤣

  • @vladislavnikovski2984
    @vladislavnikovski2984 Рік тому

    Is snus a sin too?

    • @dannydanny2789
      @dannydanny2789 2 місяці тому

      All kinds of recreational use of nicotine are, basically.

  • @Gio-ub6pt
    @Gio-ub6pt 3 роки тому

    I feel attacked rn lol

  • @hei444
    @hei444 4 роки тому

    What about alcohol and overeating? I remember a bunch of quite overweight (like me, that's why the question interests me) and lots of vodka drinking russian priest monks ...

    • @eliyahutavas
      @eliyahutavas Рік тому

      those are all equal, haven't you listened to the video?

    • @eliyahutavas
      @eliyahutavas Рік тому +1

      go to 3:55 and listen from there, you will see the difference, even though all the things you listed together with smoking are sins.

  • @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts
    @EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts 4 роки тому

    Hey, I read them...

  • @bingjundis
    @bingjundis 4 роки тому +2

    First of all, Pray and Ask God what he thinks. Seek Guidance from him.
    (Tho i would personally argue that it fine in moderation and control)
    Also Bojan, i thought all sins are the same in God's eyes?

    • @BanterWithBojan
      @BanterWithBojan  4 роки тому +5

      I don't think that all the sins are the same.
      God makes distinctions all the time (sins unto death and sins not unto death, different penalties for different sins in the Old Testament etc.). "All the sins being the same" is just a spiteful retort to Catholics dividing sins into mortal and venial categories.

  • @jedrzejbiaokryty1925
    @jedrzejbiaokryty1925 2 місяці тому

    In the Catholic church it is actually considered a sin.

  • @Michael_Binkley
    @Michael_Binkley 2 роки тому

    Through the prayers of Saint Nikolai Vellimorovich and Saint Maria Skobtsova Lord Jesus Christ save us from the leaven of the Uberdox.
    "It's not what goes into a man that makes him unclean..."
    "Call nothing the Lord has made unclean"
    The fathers would be just as baffled by the lazy people in cars eating gmo's, who otherwise couldn't make it to Liturgy if they had to walk.

  • @EnderElohim
    @EnderElohim 3 роки тому

    I don't care smoking is sin or not because it almost looks like any addiction is a sin XD Also i hate smoking
    only person that i saw actually smoke and not bother me was was my cook master. He was like smoke once a day for social reasons and done

  • @WittyComm3nter
    @WittyComm3nter 3 роки тому +2

    IMO smoking cigs is a sin because it is downright unhealthy, that being said, my friend just left his pack here and I'm going to go spark one, Lord have mercy

  • @stefan4035
    @stefan4035 10 місяців тому +1

    pricaj srpski da te ceo svet razume

  • @MediaDream93
    @MediaDream93 3 роки тому

    Pretty sure St. Mary of Paris was an occasional cigarette smoker. I think it's generally a really bad idea because it is physically unhealthy and also spiritually since it weakens the will. But calling it a sin in and of itself seems off to me, maybe I'm biased as a former smoker.

  • @LARGEFORTHEFATHORANDTHEUS
    @LARGEFORTHEFATHORANDTHEUS Місяць тому

    video greaty
    ifand thewe may tyipe thewethen wilt tyipe smokkingthe is not a sin thebut forementionned is an offense thein wordnesses the other forementionnedthe is a deed not gainst the lord the divine theour the iycoy the xrictoy gainstbut the neighbor the self theour asand the such being the case forementionnedthe should be pardon the pun put out

  • @husq48
    @husq48 3 роки тому

    I smoke, guess I'm going to Hell...

  • @tobyroyparkerjr.233
    @tobyroyparkerjr.233 4 роки тому

    Smoke Weed every day