I missed 3 cookies: Butter Squid, Blue Slushy and Muscle. All are edible. Muscle is likely to be made of protein shake. If I had a nickel for every cookie I missed for these compilation-type videos, I’d have 5 nickels. Which isn’t a lot but it’s more than enough to infuriate me :)) I will do one for Kingdom. However, disclaimer, I quit the game like 2 years ago, plus, I have no plans of coming back. So, please keep that in mind 🙏
I REALLY wanna know what you think milky way cookie would taste like, me and my friend used to play cookie run kingdom together on the bus like 2 years ago and she was always our favorite. (I also quit like 2 years ago because my phone has less space and runs slower than my mom's hand me down I-phone 5s.)
Silverbell Cookie from Cookie Run: Kingdom is apparently made out of lily of the valley flowers (which, as we all know, are extremely toxic/poisonous and NOT edible), based on his Japanese (Suzuran Cookie) and German names (they both translate to “Lily-of-The-Valley Cookie”). His Spanish name, Galleta Convalario (Convalario Cookie), is derived from the scientific name of the lily-of-the-valley, *Convallaria* majalis. Thus, Silverbell goes in the “Dangerous! Do not eat!” category. As for Cotton Cookie, real cotton (the fiber used to make T-shirts and cotton swabs and such) isn’t exactly *poisonous,* but it’s definitely NOT digestible/edible and can cause a blockage in the digestive tract if swallowed. Humans can’t eat typical cotton seeds because they’re poisonous; they contain a toxin called gossypol. However, there is such a thing as cottonseed oil (they have to use a specific refining process to get rid of the gossypol), which is sometimes used for frying and cooking. So yeah, Cotton Cookie goes somewhere in between “Somewhat Questionable” and “Dangerous! Do not eat!”
Also, if you want to, can you do one for Tower of Adventures and Witches’s Castle?? (Preferably both in one video because they didn’t introduce THAT many new cookies)
Who knows if the witches are capable of consuming a wider variety of substances than humans? That would explain the weird and inedible flavors of some cookies.
Abyss Monarch used to be referred as "Octopus Cookie" before being corrupted by the tear of Sea Fairy Cookie that was keeping Sugarteara stable, so their uncorrupted/past form is actually quite edible, but for the corrupted? Absolutely not 😭
1. There's a Spanish dish called Christmas tree trunk which can be the ingredient of Carol. 2. For, Adventurer, I was theorizing he could be made of sand, but idk. 3. I saw somewhere that Rockstar was made of lemon creme, but I don't remember where 4. I also saw somewhere Fire Spirit was made of sweet potatoes, but, again, don't remember where
The *closest* thing we have to a chocolate chip cookie in Cookie Run so far is Crunchy Chip Cookie. And even THEN, he looks more like an *Oreo* cookie!😵
@@SparklePie05 and what about Oatmeal Raisin Cookie?? We got *Black* Raisin Cookie before *Oatmeal* Raisin Cookie! My idea for Oatmeal Raisin Cookie is that she is either the mother, aunt, or grandmother of Black Raisin Cookie
6:47 I always assumed that Dr. Bones would taste like those tiny colorful bone-shaped candy that you would find in the walmart quarter machines (I think it was called Funny Bones? Real ones know) but ice cream makes more sense tho
cyborg cookies ingredients are hinted to something related to palm trees, because if you look at aloe cookies diary, one of the stickers is a palm tree.
I think skating queen could possibly be sugar plum, which are 100% edible it's just type of hard candy in the shape of plum and her hair does somewhat resemble one, plus while she is an ice skater, she does also have some ballet inspiration as wel, and there is a part in the nutcracker ballet called "dance of the sugar plum fairy" Ps. the reason why I believe she has ballet inspiration as well, is because her only costume is based off the black swan from the ballet "swan lake" or I'm looking way into this and she's actually just grape flavored lol
While I'm late to the video, During the Line era if you max a cookie you will get a personal treasure. For Skating Queen iirc she give her hair ornament which is an entire blueberry.
Angel and Devil Cookie are most likely based on Angel Food and Devil Food Cakes respectively, but there are some references to cola and fizzy drinks with Devil Cookie, in Kingdom too, so Devil might be made with cola or just some sort of soda.
Another thing to note: Abyss Monarch Coolie used to be Octopus Cookie in the past before being consumed by darkness, and their Super Epic costume is Octopus Cookie, though it isn't called that. This makes Abyss Monarch edible only during a certain period of time.
I do remember Abyss Monarch had something to do with octopus. As for Angel, their design is so simple that I couldn’t really connect them with anything 😅
@@mirratheartist That's fair! Again, it's only a guess that they could be based on similarly named cakes, but I always thought Angel's taste was either the cake or just basic frosted sugar cookies (like the star wand they carry)
I think Princess Cookie is inedible because she's related to her grandmother, Hollyberry Cookie. Hollyberries are known to be poisonous, therfore they are not edible. In CRK, its confirmed that Hollyberry Cookie and Princess Cookie are also immune to poison. In Episode 11, Hollyberry Cookie drank a fruit punch that was tainted with poisonous mushrooms, but it didn't affected her. In the Tropical Soda islands storyline, Lilac Cookie was surprised that Princess Cookie wasn't affected by his fragrant lilac scent that was suppose to put her to sleep. (Also implying to be poisonous/toxic)
- pure vanilla would probably taste good. his clothes are waffle cones and we can assume he’s just a vanilla cookie with more pure vanilla than normal - holly berries are poisonous - dark cacao is said to be made of “the most bitter cacao beans” (if i remember correctly) so while likely edible he would taste like shit - golden cheese is presumably made of well. cheese which is golden. assuming its just regular cheese that *looks* like gold, l8kely edible but wouldn’t taste too good. assuming that its actual gold that looks like cheese. thats metal and inedible -lilies are also poisonous out of them, pv is the most likely to be edible, and holly/lily are the least (as in they’ll make you really sick upon eating) and bc is up for debate
Ok I already know the story of timekeeper and the time balance department but I just want to say thank you for not spoiling to other people who didn't know yet :D
Also, many materials/substances in Earthbread are made from edible things that cookies themselves don’t actually eat (such as the roll cake logs from Kingdom and the aforementioned salt water soda). So it’s possible that Cotton Cookie and Star Coral from Kingdom could be made from either the actual inedible materials or just edible foods shaped to be like these materials, inedible to cookies but edible to humans (Which might be cotton candy and rock candy respectively)
Also, even though cotton may look harmless but if you eat them because they are not poisonous or whatnot. But they can cause bad things to your digestive system, basically what people think chewing gum will do to your digestive system.
Coupled with the Life Powder thing revealed (Stormbringer's Story + Wind Archer's Story + Witch's Castle)... It would be edible if its base ingredient wasn't a full-on magic drug. What would Life Powder smell or taste like? What side-effects does it inflict on its eater? Eating Purple Yam and Black Pearl would be easy... if the former wasn't made with Life Powder, and the latter is literally... inedible for many reasons (If Abyss Monarch is Ovenbreak's parallel, then White Pearl was corrupted by the Sea Fairy Tear too).
2:09 I would think ángel cookie is based on ángel cake or ángel marshmellows (the last one exists in my country) 7:54 for rockstar (this is Just a wild guess) but his guitar reminds me of candy canes and peppermints, I know peppermint cookie exists but...
In some cultures you can use pine needles like chewing gum and sometime in cooking, so I assume Carol cookie might have strange flavor, but be quite edible
I really enjoy this video and I learned a lot from it. I admire how much research went into this and carefully thought out it is. One thing i will say is that Abyss Monarch Cookie could be edible because before they got corrupted by the darkness, they were known as Octopus Cookie and octopus can be eaten when done well. Although given that Abyss Monarch is corrupted by darkness like you said, eating them is risky like eating a puffer fish, just hope the chef got rid of the all poison Overall, amazing video
About the millennial tree tree bark thing, CINNAMON of all things is actually made using tree bark, so millennial tree could just be cinnamon and…. herbs ig idk
Since you quit the game, here's some confirmations from the game itself(and other comments). 2:08 A video on the official OvenBreak channel shows Angel cookie being baked. It's probably not canon though, because it shows an unknown substance, a chicken's tear, and what I assume to be whipped cream topping for their hair? 2:16 They are most likely referring to chocolate cookies, butter cookies, and maple cookies. So yes, they are definitely edible. 2:24 The way I saw it, some ice cream/cake/etc. brands have a "unicorn" flavour. It's mostly just or cotton candy-like, and unicorn comes from the colour palette than anything. 2:34 So xylitol has been in the game long before Planet Xylitol! I only read her story maybe once
4:15 Hero's Trial of Memories costume is based on some kind of alternate universe. One where he's "made with bitter dark chocolate instead of sweet caramel". 7:42 All his costumes replace his default armour with something else(one of them is made of "icewind steel"), and his most recent one just straight-up isn't armour. 7:54 Skater's hat looks like a blueberry and Special Force shoots out sugar star candies(likely Konpeitō), but yeah no direct confirmation. Rockstar had a treasure in LINE that only benefitted him(Sour Note Jelly), but it's not the kind you got from upgrading him(he didn't have any). Ninja's ingredient is intentionally unstated so as to be mysterious.
My opinions on some of the things said in this video, sorted by when I thought of them. Very excited to see how you’ll tackle Timekeeper. 3:20 - I think I remember in the first Dessert Paradise story with Blue Slushy, during the cutscene where Pilot recalls the events in the Dragon’s Valley he mentions that his “butterscotch is about to lose it's buttery layer..” That seems like confirmation that he’s made with some sort of butterscotch to me 8:05 - Not exactly an accurate time stamp for my thoughts, but as someone else in the comments mentioned earlier many of the materials on Earthbread are edible from the trees being cake and some examples I am totally forgetting. I would say that cookies like Knight and Adventurer are definitely edible clothes and all, even if we don’t have an exact flavor. 9:00 - The dinosaurs seem edible, there are banana parasaurs and cabbage pterodactyl (I know those aren’t technically dinosaurs but sshhhhh). The big weird guys that look like pterosaurs I forgot the name of you can see in the Dragon breakout and you have to avoid their feed I have no clue though. 10:08 - That’s wild, my god. At least it told you that they WEREN’T edible as opposed to the opposite. Better to not eat something non-toxic than to eat something toxic. 12:09 - I mean, the “poison” could be just hallucinogens and Devsis doesn’t want to say it’s drugs in a kids game. The Kingdom event has cookies eating shrooms from Poison Mushroom but they’re different from what makes them up and I don’t recall anything from the stories in OB or Kingdom that say that the mushroom is explicitly poisonously deadly as opposed to just making you high. Although I would still place them in inedible as KIDS, Say No To Drugs! 13:15 - In Kingdom Star Coral’s grandmother states that Sugar Swan is made from honey. Her other facts seem true despite other cookies not believing her so presumably that’s what Sugar Swan is made from. 14:18 - Very, very excited. 14:25 - Aww… That’s… mildly disappointing. I’m pretty sure everyone knows that fact by now! And besides, I still don’t agree with putting her into the edible category. Many people say that since Timekeeper was Croissant, she should still be edible, but I don’t exactly agree. Firstly, that is not a croissant anymore. There’s barely a hint of any croissants on her design and her hair is completely different. The most likely explanation for her hair is that it’s raw dough (Croissant’s hair reverting back to its original state) which is very not edible. However, some people believe that it’s some kind of hard candy which would potentially make her edible (although I don’t see it). All of that aside, in her ROTEF costume, there is a time rift in her eye. You could say that it only appears on ROTEF but the question of “what’s under Timekeeper’s eyepatch” is into question. So there very may be a time rift inside of her. Time rifts, unlike everything else on Earthbread, are VERY presumably not edible. And besides, she’s extremely changed by her time spent in them. The effects of time rifts on her body could very well render her inedible. I dunno. I’m just kind of disappointed you brushed over Timekeeper so easily like that especially when she has a very interesting conversation to her about this topic. To me, if a Cookie Run story isn’t currently going on/obtainable, it’s fair game to talk about it without considering spoilers. Especially since the event it’s revealed in was in like, what, the end of 2020? If I click on a video promising to analyze if cookies are edible I would expect spoilers as some cookies may have ingredients revealed that way. I might just be disappointed because I expected more and I really like Timekeeper and Croissant, though. 14:29 - Since you haven’t finished the story, I’ll keep my opinion vague. I would say maybe or maybe not. I’m not sure what “black sugar” is. All I can say is that if Sugar Swan is edible she should be too.
Thank you for the comment! Honestly, I was barely playing the game during the first dessert paradise update so I kinda missed that bit with Pilot. As for Timekeeper, it’s on me for brushing past her. I only kept spoiler in mind because a friend of mine who played before me didn’t even know her backstory until I mentioned it. I, myself, am a Timekeeper fan lol. I definitely would have tried to overanalyze her had I not made the decision not to :P
This was supposed to be done like 2 weeks ago. But a big typhoon hit, lost power for 2 days. After that I had to do a bunch of stuff with getting into university. After this, uploads may even be more sparse
From your comment, I’m not so sure they meant it literally. It could just be a metaphor like saying a girl is like as a rose could just mean she’s beautiful
@@mirratheartist i mean, both of princess' parents are berries, so i'd asume she's also made of some kind of berry too (or roses, maybe, since tiger lily is also a flower and it'd make sense for them being twins and being both flowers)
Hi. I love this video. Very educational and interesting, also informative. I'd like to see a video about other cookies from other cookie games like Cookie Run Kingdom, Cookie Run Witch's Castle, and Cookie Run Tower of Adventures. And maybe adding some npc cookies with obvious names for extra information! Oh I forgot to mention some characters from discontinued Cookie games - Piñata Cookie, Energy drink Cookie. Good luck!
Thank you for the comment! I do plan on making vids on other games too. Only after finishing this one, I suddenly thought of the NPCs, since there are so many lol
And thank You for reading my comment! Oh, I forgot to add Artichoke Cookie from CR Puzzle World. If you need any ideas about your Cookie run videos, I can help with it! I like these games!
@@bellenelly7810don’t mean to be the nerd here, but when you say “was playable”, that indicates that Puzzle World is no longer available, correct? If this is the case, I would like to politely disagree as I myself play Puzzle World. Again I mean *no offence in any way and I don’t wanna look like the annoying nerd*
5:55 It’s also said that Carol Cookie tastes like a Christmas/holiday cookie 7:22 Including sugar plums? 7:54 Rockstar’s guitar looks like it’s made out of a candy cane (or some other red striped candy). And Ninja Cookie’s staff is *shaped* like a candy cane. And Skater Cookie’s skateboard IS a candy cane!😆
Honestly, I feel like I was a bit harsh on Skating Queen, mainly because I’m not sure. As for both Rockstar and Ninja, I didn’t look at their accessories because it would be the equivalent of guessing GingerBrave’s flavor based on his candy cane 😅
In my original script, I did want to point out that detail. But besides the candles, everything is edible. The same logic applies to regular birthday cakes: you’d remove the candles before eating XD
skater cookie's hat is meant to be a blueberry with its crown so i think he's blueberry syrup just like strawberry cookie and special forces is likely poprocks
4:02 I've heard that Scorpion could be actually made out of a pepper known as "scorpion pepper" rather than the actual bug. In Centipede's case, we don't know. Maybe some sort of spice?
Timestamps: 0:00 Intro ------------------------------------------------------------------- 0:53 Edible 0:56 Edible - Drink-based 1:16 Edible - Vegetables, Fruits & Plants 1:50 Edible - Pastries, Deserts & Sugar 1:51 Edible - Choco 1:53 Edible - Other Sugars 3:32 Edible - Obviously 3:50 Edible - Random ------------------------------------------------------------------- 5:31 Unsure ------------------------------------------------------------------- 9:24 Inedible ------------------------------------------------------------------- 12:58 Legendaries ------------------------------------------------------------------- 14:34 Dragons ------------------------------------------------------------------- 14:17 Final Result + Data Visualization ------------------------------------------------------------------- 14:41 Outro ------------------------------------------------------------------- I think Pond Dino is edible becuace, while not all the cookies are made of safe to eat things, as far as we know all the other creatures are, and like irl you can eat **MOST** animals so... And all the dragons are save, so dinosuars probably? Also I should have typed safe to eat, since a lot of unsafe to eat stuff is edible but I'm to lazy to fix it. Also Ghost is 'UNEDIBLE' but that fact **ALONE** does not make her un-safe to eat, but yes the toxicity does. Also Dark Enchantress also is White Lily in Kingdom so if the ingredients are canon across all of Cookie Run then she also has white lilies, witch are poisonous last I checked but I'll check later agian.
1:42 in the latest update they changed tje magic candy of fairy cookie, she may be green tea! (She makes green tea jellies) 9:50 Note that, in KR, BOTH lilybell and blue lily have very different names/ flower inspirations. Lilybell is based on gromwells if we look at her internal name, which are not inedible iirc
That’s interesting. I didn’t notice Fairy’s MC. I wrote that part before the update. I didn’t notice Lilybell’s Korean name. I only brought up Blue Lily’s because they changed hers in English. Anyways, thanks for comment 😊🫶
Disclaimer: Not even I advise consuming a legendary, for the fact the magical properties AND overpowered abilities of some of them may cause unreverseable side effects and even death Thanks for listening to my T.E.D talk ANYWAYS OFF TO CONSUME THE INSANE TIMELORD!!!!
5:26 Didn't it say in Werewolf's story that a piece of wolf hair/fur (if I remember correctly) fell onto his dough and got mixed into it which is why he can turn into a werewolf and is Werewolf Cookie in the first place? I'm not sure if that's still edible or if it is, it wouldn't taste very good
14:30 It's just very dirty sugar with lots of molasses or other by-products or if its made by caramel its just burnt caramel (When you fry sugar, it turns into caramel and the caramel can burn or be crispy clean). So yes its edible. But it might not be as tasty or bitter
13:18 this is octopus cookie in past but now its infected or engulfed in darkness. If this darkness is from dark enchantress then it's probably toxic. And now it's a poisonous octopus. If there's anything else, i don't know
14:30 It can be very dirty sugar with a high content of molasses or other thing in the initial composition of sugar or burnt caramel (Caramel is made from sugar and if you digest it, it will burn and turn black, and if you do it right, you can get crystal clear beautiful caramel), both options are suitable. It is edible but not very tasty
13:56 Cookies with the smell of forest air(and wind archer like veggie like) Moonlight uh idk Dream flavored cookies (sleeping pill cookies (sleep magic))
6:51 I'm pretty sure Dr. Bones is made from sugar bones or something. It is not correct to compare skeletons and ghosts, they are clearly different in composition
From the first Google result: “Crowberries can be eaten raw but the flavour is acrid. The flavour is improved after a heavy frost or when dried or cooked. They are used in pies, wine and jams”
I missed 3 cookies: Butter Squid, Blue Slushy and Muscle. All are edible. Muscle is likely to be made of protein shake.
If I had a nickel for every cookie I missed for these compilation-type videos, I’d have 5 nickels. Which isn’t a lot but it’s more than enough to infuriate me :))
I will do one for Kingdom.
However, disclaimer, I quit the game like 2 years ago, plus, I have no plans of coming back. So, please keep that in mind 🙏
ovenbreak mains! Acemble
I REALLY wanna know what you think milky way cookie would taste like, me and my friend used to play cookie run kingdom together on the bus like 2 years ago and she was always our favorite. (I also quit like 2 years ago because my phone has less space and runs slower than my mom's hand me down I-phone 5s.)
Silverbell Cookie from Cookie Run: Kingdom is apparently made out of lily of the valley flowers (which, as we all know, are extremely toxic/poisonous and NOT edible), based on his Japanese (Suzuran Cookie) and German names (they both translate to “Lily-of-The-Valley Cookie”). His Spanish name, Galleta Convalario (Convalario Cookie), is derived from the scientific name of the lily-of-the-valley, *Convallaria* majalis. Thus, Silverbell goes in the “Dangerous! Do not eat!” category.
As for Cotton Cookie, real cotton (the fiber used to make T-shirts and cotton swabs and such) isn’t exactly *poisonous,* but it’s definitely NOT digestible/edible and can cause a blockage in the digestive tract if swallowed. Humans can’t eat typical cotton seeds because they’re poisonous; they contain a toxin called gossypol. However, there is such a thing as cottonseed oil (they have to use a specific refining process to get rid of the gossypol), which is sometimes used for frying and cooking. So yeah, Cotton Cookie goes somewhere in between “Somewhat Questionable” and “Dangerous! Do not eat!”
Also, if you want to, can you do one for Tower of Adventures and Witches’s Castle?? (Preferably both in one video because they didn’t introduce THAT many new cookies)
Cookie run kingdom milky way cookie ❤❤❤❤
In Kingdom, they flat out made a cookie flavored after a toxic liquid metal.
mercurial knight 💀
mercurial knight cookie
and wind archer is after a fart
@@Help-gq9ik 💀
@@Help-gq9ik the witch gets a lil quirky at night
Who knows if the witches are capable of consuming a wider variety of substances than humans? That would explain the weird and inedible flavors of some cookies.
That theory of yours makes sense🙂
Mercury and zombie cells
Abyss Monarch used to be referred as "Octopus Cookie" before being corrupted by the tear of Sea Fairy Cookie that was keeping Sugarteara stable, so their uncorrupted/past form is actually quite edible, but for the corrupted? Absolutely not 😭
1. There's a Spanish dish called Christmas tree trunk which can be the ingredient of Carol.
2. For, Adventurer, I was theorizing he could be made of sand, but idk.
3. I saw somewhere that Rockstar was made of lemon creme, but I don't remember where
4. I also saw somewhere Fire Spirit was made of sweet potatoes, but, again, don't remember where
No offense but I feel like the more I read your comment, the less logical the statements become. Thanks for the comment though, very informative 🫶
Special force cookie's make me think of star candies in the gun.
Bruh, Devsisters missed the best opportunity to make a cookie based on chocolate chip cookies, one of the most popular cookie flavors ever 😭
The *closest* thing we have to a chocolate chip cookie in Cookie Run so far is Crunchy Chip Cookie. And even THEN, he looks more like an *Oreo* cookie!😵
He's suppose to be an oreo based cookie @akfc.6978
I like to think that Chocolate Chip Cookie was the first living cookie ever made and that they are some sort of deity in the Cookie Run world.
@@SparklePie05 and what about Oatmeal Raisin Cookie?? We got *Black* Raisin Cookie before *Oatmeal* Raisin Cookie! My idea for Oatmeal Raisin Cookie is that she is either the mother, aunt, or grandmother of Black Raisin Cookie
Snickerdoodle cookie when?!?;?!
6:47 I always assumed that Dr. Bones would taste like those tiny colorful bone-shaped candy that you would find in the walmart quarter machines (I think it was called Funny Bones? Real ones know) but ice cream makes more sense tho
cyborg cookies ingredients are hinted to something related to palm trees, because if you look at aloe cookies diary, one of the stickers is a palm tree.
I think devs are running out of flavours tbh
Probably not. There are like a bajillion types of desserts, condiments, ingredients, etc. They just pick whatever goes with the theme they choose lol
@@mirratheartist whatever that looks cool enough I'd say lol /nsrs
We haven't gotten a Meat based Cookie yet.
@@thesplatooanima8231
lobster cookie? they're meat-based since they're a lobster . and you can eat lobster
@@Nebbuwu Lobster is more Associated with Fish.... I meant a Cookie with Chicken, Pork or Beef based flavour.
For anyone wondering, Timekeeper is croissant from the future and in a a difeerent universe
I think skating queen could possibly be sugar plum, which are 100% edible it's just type of hard candy in the shape of plum and her hair does somewhat resemble one, plus while she is an ice skater, she does also have some ballet inspiration as wel, and there is a part in the nutcracker ballet called "dance of the sugar plum fairy"
Ps. the reason why I believe she has ballet inspiration as well, is because her only costume is based off the black swan from the ballet "swan lake"
or I'm looking way into this and she's actually just grape flavored lol
Oo. That’s very interesting. Thanks for the insight
While I'm late to the video, During the Line era if you max a cookie you will get a personal treasure. For Skating Queen iirc she give her hair ornament which is an entire blueberry.
Angel and Devil Cookie are most likely based on Angel Food and Devil Food Cakes respectively, but there are some references to cola and fizzy drinks with Devil Cookie, in Kingdom too, so Devil might be made with cola or just some sort of soda.
Another thing to note: Abyss Monarch Coolie used to be Octopus Cookie in the past before being consumed by darkness, and their Super Epic costume is Octopus Cookie, though it isn't called that. This makes Abyss Monarch edible only during a certain period of time.
I do remember Abyss Monarch had something to do with octopus. As for Angel, their design is so simple that I couldn’t really connect them with anything 😅
@@mirratheartist That's fair! Again, it's only a guess that they could be based on similarly named cakes, but I always thought Angel's taste was either the cake or just basic frosted sugar cookies (like the star wand they carry)
Princess cookie could easily be a berry cookie given how she's from the hollyberry kingdom in crk, if not a berry ringpop
I think Princess Cookie is inedible because she's related to her grandmother, Hollyberry Cookie. Hollyberries are known to be poisonous, therfore they are not edible.
In CRK, its confirmed that Hollyberry Cookie and Princess Cookie are also immune to poison. In Episode 11, Hollyberry Cookie drank a fruit punch that was tainted with poisonous mushrooms, but it didn't affected her. In the Tropical Soda islands storyline, Lilac Cookie was surprised that Princess Cookie wasn't affected by his fragrant lilac scent that was suppose to put her to sleep. (Also implying to be poisonous/toxic)
Hope you'll do a Kingdom one, because it's a very funny that all Ancient Cookies flat out taste bad or aren't edible at all
I mean, if they don’t kill you, they’re edible XD
GOLDEN CHEESE ??? LIKE WTF I AINT EATING THAT
- pure vanilla would probably taste good. his clothes are waffle cones and we can assume he’s just a vanilla cookie with more pure vanilla than normal
- holly berries are poisonous
- dark cacao is said to be made of “the most bitter cacao beans” (if i remember correctly) so while likely edible he would taste like shit
- golden cheese is presumably made of well. cheese which is golden. assuming its just regular cheese that *looks* like gold, l8kely edible but wouldn’t taste too good. assuming that its actual gold that looks like cheese. thats metal and inedible
-lilies are also poisonous
out of them, pv is the most likely to be edible, and holly/lily are the least (as in they’ll make you really sick upon eating) and bc is up for debate
@@DandysWorldYapperunless she’s a cracker instead of a cookie but that’s highly unlikely
Ok I already know the story of timekeeper and the time balance department but I just want to say thank you for not spoiling to other people who didn't know yet :D
Also, many materials/substances in Earthbread are made from edible things that cookies themselves don’t actually eat (such as the roll cake logs from Kingdom and the aforementioned salt water soda). So it’s possible that Cotton Cookie and Star Coral from Kingdom could be made from either the actual inedible materials or just edible foods shaped to be like these materials, inedible to cookies but edible to humans (Which might be cotton candy and rock candy respectively)
Also, even though cotton may look harmless but if you eat them because they are not poisonous or whatnot. But they can cause bad things to your digestive system, basically what people think chewing gum will do to your digestive system.
I like to think dr bones is like a sugar skull candy type thing :3
Thats what I'm thinking too! :D
"today we ask the age old question, will it gingerbread cookie?"
Coupled with the Life Powder thing revealed (Stormbringer's Story + Wind Archer's Story + Witch's Castle)...
It would be edible if its base ingredient wasn't a full-on magic drug. What would Life Powder smell or taste like? What side-effects does it inflict on its eater?
Eating Purple Yam and Black Pearl would be easy... if the former wasn't made with Life Powder, and the latter is literally... inedible for many reasons (If Abyss Monarch is Ovenbreak's parallel, then White Pearl was corrupted by the Sea Fairy Tear too).
2:09 I would think ángel cookie is based on ángel cake or ángel marshmellows (the last one exists in my country)
7:54 for rockstar (this is Just a wild guess) but his guitar reminds me of candy canes and peppermints, I know peppermint cookie exists but...
isn’t it stated that pond dino’s dino half is made of pudding? it’s mentioned they “wag their pudding tail” in their story section iirc
In some cultures you can use pine needles like chewing gum and sometime in cooking, so I assume Carol cookie might have strange flavor, but be quite edible
thanks for such a well research and thorough ob video, they are so rare!
I really enjoy this video and I learned a lot from it. I admire how much research went into this and carefully thought out it is. One thing i will say is that Abyss Monarch Cookie could be edible because before they got corrupted by the darkness, they were known as Octopus Cookie and octopus can be eaten when done well. Although given that Abyss Monarch is corrupted by darkness like you said, eating them is risky like eating a puffer fish, just hope the chef got rid of the all poison
Overall, amazing video
If we're running off of the potential fact that the Kingdom universe is connected to Ovenbreak, then I wouldn't eat Princess Cookie.
Oh? Please do explain
@@mirratheartist She's Hollyberry's granddaughter. And Holly berries are poisonous. :)
@@frannygalactica9945 That is true but I'm still not too sure
@@mirratheartist Fair. But I still wouldn't. Just to be safe. :)
About the millennial tree tree bark thing, CINNAMON of all things is actually made using tree bark, so millennial tree could just be cinnamon and…. herbs ig idk
Idk why? But I've always considered adventurer cookie being a sort of peanut butter? Cuz him, and his counterpart: black berry- seem very pb&j-esque
How interesting🤔😮
Since you quit the game, here's some confirmations from the game itself(and other comments).
2:08 A video on the official OvenBreak channel shows Angel cookie being baked. It's probably not canon though, because it shows an unknown substance, a chicken's tear, and what I assume to be whipped cream topping for their hair?
2:16 They are most likely referring to chocolate cookies, butter cookies, and maple cookies. So yes, they are definitely edible.
2:24 The way I saw it, some ice cream/cake/etc. brands have a "unicorn" flavour. It's mostly just or cotton candy-like, and unicorn comes from the colour palette than anything.
2:34 So xylitol has been in the game long before Planet Xylitol! I only read her story maybe once
4:15 Hero's Trial of Memories costume is based on some kind of alternate universe. One where he's "made with bitter dark chocolate instead of sweet caramel".
7:42 All his costumes replace his default armour with something else(one of them is made of "icewind steel"), and his most recent one just straight-up isn't armour.
7:54 Skater's hat looks like a blueberry and Special Force shoots out sugar star candies(likely Konpeitō), but yeah no direct confirmation. Rockstar had a treasure in LINE that only benefitted him(Sour Note Jelly), but it's not the kind you got from upgrading him(he didn't have any). Ninja's ingredient is intentionally unstated so as to be mysterious.
Rock star is based of an queen member fun fact
Oh! That’s cool
Robot cookie's outside body is probably wax, then those ion drinks are inside his body. They could be those wax candies that were popular once.
Dr bone could be based on the candy skulls from the day of the dead🤔
My opinions on some of the things said in this video, sorted by when I thought of them.
Very excited to see how you’ll tackle Timekeeper.
3:20 - I think I remember in the first Dessert Paradise story with Blue Slushy, during the cutscene where Pilot recalls the events in the Dragon’s Valley he mentions that his “butterscotch is about to lose it's buttery layer..”
That seems like confirmation that he’s made with some sort of butterscotch to me
8:05 - Not exactly an accurate time stamp for my thoughts, but as someone else in the comments mentioned earlier many of the materials on Earthbread are edible from the trees being cake and some examples I am totally forgetting. I would say that cookies like Knight and Adventurer are definitely edible clothes and all, even if we don’t have an exact flavor.
9:00 - The dinosaurs seem edible, there are banana parasaurs and cabbage pterodactyl (I know those aren’t technically dinosaurs but sshhhhh). The big weird guys that look like pterosaurs I forgot the name of you can see in the Dragon breakout and you have to avoid their feed I have no clue though.
10:08 - That’s wild, my god. At least it told you that they WEREN’T edible as opposed to the opposite. Better to not eat something non-toxic than to eat something toxic.
12:09 - I mean, the “poison” could be just hallucinogens and Devsis doesn’t want to say it’s drugs in a kids game. The Kingdom event has cookies eating shrooms from Poison Mushroom but they’re different from what makes them up and I don’t recall anything from the stories in OB or Kingdom that say that the mushroom is explicitly poisonously deadly as opposed to just making you high. Although I would still place them in inedible as KIDS, Say No To Drugs!
13:15 - In Kingdom Star Coral’s grandmother states that Sugar Swan is made from honey. Her other facts seem true despite other cookies not believing her so presumably that’s what Sugar Swan is made from.
14:18 - Very, very excited.
14:25 - Aww… That’s… mildly disappointing. I’m pretty sure everyone knows that fact by now! And besides, I still don’t agree with putting her into the edible category.
Many people say that since Timekeeper was Croissant, she should still be edible, but I don’t exactly agree. Firstly, that is not a croissant anymore. There’s barely a hint of any croissants on her design and her hair is completely different. The most likely explanation for her hair is that it’s raw dough (Croissant’s hair reverting back to its original state) which is very not edible. However, some people believe that it’s some kind of hard candy which would potentially make her edible (although I don’t see it). All of that aside, in her ROTEF costume, there is a time rift in her eye. You could say that it only appears on ROTEF but the question of “what’s under Timekeeper’s eyepatch” is into question. So there very may be a time rift inside of her. Time rifts, unlike everything else on Earthbread, are VERY presumably not edible. And besides, she’s extremely changed by her time spent in them. The effects of time rifts on her body could very well render her inedible.
I dunno. I’m just kind of disappointed you brushed over Timekeeper so easily like that especially when she has a very interesting conversation to her about this topic. To me, if a Cookie Run story isn’t currently going on/obtainable, it’s fair game to talk about it without considering spoilers. Especially since the event it’s revealed in was in like, what, the end of 2020? If I click on a video promising to analyze if cookies are edible I would expect spoilers as some cookies may have ingredients revealed that way. I might just be disappointed because I expected more and I really like Timekeeper and Croissant, though.
14:29 - Since you haven’t finished the story, I’ll keep my opinion vague. I would say maybe or maybe not. I’m not sure what “black sugar” is. All I can say is that if Sugar Swan is edible she should be too.
The amount of stuff I wrote began heating up my phone and causing it to run slowly.
Sorry, I’m just gay for Timekeeper and Croissant.
Thank you for the comment! Honestly, I was barely playing the game during the first dessert paradise update so I kinda missed that bit with Pilot. As for Timekeeper, it’s on me for brushing past her. I only kept spoiler in mind because a friend of mine who played before me didn’t even know her backstory until I mentioned it. I, myself, am a Timekeeper fan lol. I definitely would have tried to overanalyze her had I not made the decision not to :P
This was supposed to be done like 2 weeks ago. But a big typhoon hit, lost power for 2 days. After that I had to do a bunch of stuff with getting into university.
After this, uploads may even be more sparse
about princess cookie. if i remember right her family did call her a little rose somewhere in kingdom.. so maybe shes a rose
From your comment, I’m not so sure they meant it literally. It could just be a metaphor like saying a girl is like as a rose could just mean she’s beautiful
@@mirratheartist i mean, both of princess' parents are berries, so i'd asume she's also made of some kind of berry too (or roses, maybe, since tiger lily is also a flower and it'd make sense for them being twins and being both flowers)
I think pond dino dinosaur parts are gummys
Hi. I love this video. Very educational and interesting, also informative. I'd like to see a video about other cookies from other cookie games like Cookie Run Kingdom, Cookie Run Witch's Castle, and Cookie Run Tower of Adventures. And maybe adding some npc cookies with obvious names for extra information! Oh I forgot to mention some characters from discontinued Cookie games - Piñata Cookie, Energy drink Cookie.
Good luck!
Thank you for the comment! I do plan on making vids on other games too.
Only after finishing this one, I suddenly thought of the NPCs, since there are so many lol
And thank You for reading my comment! Oh, I forgot to add Artichoke Cookie from CR Puzzle World. If you need any ideas about your Cookie run videos, I can help with it! I like these games!
Isn’t Artichoke already an NPC in crob? Pretty sure they showed up in an old event with the tropical soda islands
Yes, Artichoke is not playable in Ovenbreak. But in Cookie Run Puzzle World, this character was playable until the game's forgotten by Devsisters...
@@bellenelly7810don’t mean to be the nerd here, but when you say “was playable”, that indicates that Puzzle World is no longer available, correct? If this is the case, I would like to politely disagree as I myself play Puzzle World. Again I mean *no offence in any way and I don’t wanna look like the annoying nerd*
8:40 Pond Dino Cookie being based on Forget-me-not flowers. I guess it's edible.
i think fairy cookie might be green tea or just some herb.
in her magic candy, she produces green teas
5:55 It’s also said that Carol Cookie tastes like a Christmas/holiday cookie
7:22 Including sugar plums?
7:54 Rockstar’s guitar looks like it’s made out of a candy cane (or some other red striped candy). And Ninja Cookie’s staff is *shaped* like a candy cane. And Skater Cookie’s skateboard IS a candy cane!😆
Honestly, I feel like I was a bit harsh on Skating Queen, mainly because I’m not sure.
As for both Rockstar and Ninja, I didn’t look at their accessories because it would be the equivalent of guessing GingerBrave’s flavor based on his candy cane 😅
@@mirratheartist I see🙂
Ngl I think birthday cake is dangerous. Beacuse of the lit candles on her head
In my original script, I did want to point out that detail. But besides the candles, everything is edible. The same logic applies to regular birthday cakes: you’d remove the candles before eating XD
skater cookie's hat is meant to be a blueberry with its crown so i think he's blueberry syrup just like strawberry cookie
and special forces is likely poprocks
Trying to eat them would be like trying to eat a human being cause their actually..human sized, the witches are just huge
Is it weird I want to eat wizard cookie even though I don’t even like vanilla ice cream
It would be cool to see all the kingdom cookies
In the Taiwanese version of Cookie Run, Pond Dino Cookie is called “Forget-me-not Dino Cookie”.
I love this! Pleae make the cookie run kingdom one!! 🤣
Astronauts be like after realizing fariy cookie can produce Oxygen
Astronauts We should buy fariy cookie
Lol
Vegans, I heard this cookie is like plant like/based
Wow it's high in fiber low in calories and able to produce oxygen my dessert
4:02 I've heard that Scorpion could be actually made out of a pepper known as "scorpion pepper" rather than the actual bug.
In Centipede's case, we don't know. Maybe some sort of spice?
For Scorpion, it seems like either way, she’d still be edible. As for Centipede, I couldn’t find anything…
bro please make the kingdom cookies
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
-------------------------------------------------------------------
0:53 Edible
0:56 Edible - Drink-based
1:16 Edible - Vegetables, Fruits & Plants
1:50 Edible - Pastries, Deserts & Sugar
1:51 Edible - Choco
1:53 Edible - Other Sugars
3:32 Edible - Obviously
3:50 Edible - Random
-------------------------------------------------------------------
5:31 Unsure
-------------------------------------------------------------------
9:24 Inedible
-------------------------------------------------------------------
12:58 Legendaries
-------------------------------------------------------------------
14:34 Dragons
-------------------------------------------------------------------
14:17 Final Result + Data Visualization
-------------------------------------------------------------------
14:41 Outro
-------------------------------------------------------------------
I think Pond Dino is edible becuace, while not all the cookies are made of safe to eat things, as far as we know all the other creatures are, and like irl you can eat **MOST** animals so... And all the dragons are save, so dinosuars probably? Also I should have typed safe to eat, since a lot of unsafe to eat stuff is edible but I'm to lazy to fix it. Also Ghost is 'UNEDIBLE' but that fact **ALONE** does not make her un-safe to eat, but yes the toxicity does. Also Dark Enchantress also is White Lily in Kingdom so if the ingredients are canon across all of Cookie Run then she also has white lilies, witch are poisonous last I checked but I'll check later agian.
1:42 in the latest update they changed tje magic candy of fairy cookie, she may be green tea! (She makes green tea jellies)
9:50 Note that, in KR, BOTH lilybell and blue lily have very different names/ flower inspirations. Lilybell is based on gromwells if we look at her internal name, which are not inedible iirc
That’s interesting. I didn’t notice Fairy’s MC. I wrote that part before the update.
I didn’t notice Lilybell’s Korean name. I only brought up Blue Lily’s because they changed hers in English. Anyways, thanks for comment 😊🫶
I did not realize astronaut was made of astronaut ice cream…
It’s only really obvious when her energy runs out and you see her hair
KINGDOM COOKIES PLS LOVE THIS VIDEO
Well duh...where else am I going to get poison mushroom cookies
Disclaimer: Not even I advise consuming a legendary, for the fact the magical properties AND overpowered abilities of some of them may cause unreverseable side effects and even death
Thanks for listening to my T.E.D talk
ANYWAYS OFF TO CONSUME THE INSANE TIMELORD!!!!
Inspiring speech indeed 👏
Now please don’t touch the quirky time cookie, she’s mine >:( /j
Kingdom
All are edible but it doesn’t mean they’re good for you
I mean, anything is edible at least once :P
if i could eat the cookies, im eating the ones i hate and i will not eat my fav ones lol
Cant wait for u to get 1k subs❤
Thank you. I’m excited too 🥺🫶
and yes please do make one for cookie run kingdom
It makes sense that most of the cookies are edible considering there supposed to be cookies
5:26 Didn't it say in Werewolf's story that a piece of wolf hair/fur (if I remember correctly) fell onto his dough and got mixed into it which is why he can turn into a werewolf and is Werewolf Cookie in the first place? I'm not sure if that's still edible or if it is, it wouldn't taste very good
It’s just a single piece of fur. I doubt it’s bad. People accidentally eat their own hairs all the time :/
@@mirratheartistok. In that case, Witchberry Cookie (a piece of *cat* fur went in her dough) is safe to eat
WHERE IS CREME BRÛLÉE RAHHHHH 🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Wrong game
@@mirratheartist 🤨
@@Tophat_DoesStuffLol This video is about Ovenbreak. Creme brulee is from Kingdom
Is Dr.Bones Cookie’s Ambulance Edible 🙂🙃
Uhm… Unknown 😅
Squid ink is edible? Isn’t he made of ink?
Many cultures consume squid ink. The most popular way to “eat” them is to make some type of noodle dish with it. You can look up “squid ink noodles”
Why is there no Pure Vanilla Cookie
This is Ovenbreak, not Kingdom
Explanation for timekeeper
Spoilers
She is croissant cookie so she is edible
KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM
plsplspls do this with kingdom cookies
Expect a video within 24 hrs
almond cookie r edible?
Answer is yes because almond is actually edible like normal almonds
Yes, unless you’re allergic
14:30 It's just very dirty sugar with lots of molasses or other by-products or if its made by caramel its just burnt caramel (When you fry sugar, it turns into caramel and the caramel can burn or be crispy clean). So yes its edible. But it might not be as tasty or bitter
12:17 these marmalade ribbons in crystal (sugar) sprinkle . It's obvious in her hair. She's like Sourbelt but not sour
13:18 this is octopus cookie in past but now its infected or engulfed in darkness. If this darkness is from dark enchantress then it's probably toxic. And now it's a poisonous octopus. If there's anything else, i don't know
14:30 It can be very dirty sugar with a high content of molasses or other thing in the initial composition of sugar or burnt caramel (Caramel is made from sugar and if you digest it, it will burn and turn black, and if you do it right, you can get crystal clear beautiful caramel), both options are suitable. It is edible but not very tasty
4:02 scorpion based on scorpion pepper. Sentepide maybe something like this
5:41 carol is a Christmas cake looks like log. Carol cookie taste like carol cake, green hair is a cream
13:56 Cookies with the smell of forest air(and wind archer like veggie like)
Moonlight uh idk Dream flavored cookies (sleeping pill cookies (sleep magic))
7:25 Look at her hair, they're definitely berries, but I can't say for sure it's probably black currant or chokeberry but I'm not sure
BAUMKUCHEN IS GERMAN IM GERMAN AND THIS ANNOYS ME SO MUCH!!!!😡🥲sorry...
Uhm… I’m sorry…? 😅
6:51 I'm pretty sure Dr. Bones is made from sugar bones or something. It is not correct to compare skeletons and ghosts, they are clearly different in composition
1:18
'Oh yeee i like eat crowberry every day'
(Lol crowberry is poison wild berry its not safe to eat)
From the first Google result: “Crowberries can be eaten raw but the flavour is acrid. The flavour is improved after a heavy frost or when dried or cooked. They are used in pies, wine and jams”
KINGDOM KINGDOM KINGDOM