Is this why you were asking for seulgi supported C#5 example's? 👀 BoA's throatiness & pushiness is distracting but i think she falls somewhere in the middle of the high a's and low aa's, maybe higher on good day's
It is! I wanted to include atleast one ok C#5 by her haha, i think she's currently at the top of the A tier, but idk if she can still handle C5
Рік тому+10
nice video, i just don’t like how a lot of Lee Soo’s notes were recycled from the same song in different parts, it’s not that interesting if we can’t hear the fluctuations lol you could’ve had Suhyun in the video instead since she got way more material
@@andinho2204 Nice ! And indeed it is a topic for discussion. Had another question, since I saw you doing some vocal analysis about Lia, Haewon and Jihyo (that were very interesting and good btw), do you think you'll do that again and if yes, with who?
@@Portugall_ Those vocal showcases and written analysis are my favorite type of content to make so yes, i'll make more. I'm currently working on an average vocalist
@@andinho2204 It's their latest single/comeback. They recently sang it live and I was wondering how well they did. Someone said SuA's and Siyeon's high notes were strained (even though they sounded great imo). I don't know how to tell all that stuff so I was just curious
They probably were strained since both siyeon and sua are not decent and don't have the proper grasp of support... They are shallow and only do ok around A4/Bb4 at their best and those are not high notes at all. The best vocalist in the group is yoohyeon who has a basic grasp of support enough for average and she does decent around A3~Bb4
Id say she's at the bottom of A-AA, below minzy, Jessica and Lee Soo. Despite the raspy mix and not cute C5s she still has the head voice and lows + some better moments up to C5 ocasionally. If by any chance she's average she would be a high one
You don't seem to know what you're talking about.. 1-Seohyun could NEVER keep up with a true high A-AA 2- pick a side lmaoo no one is 2 tiers at the same time (you're not on tik tok, that kind of nonsense won't be treated as ok) 3- Seohyun has enough materials so you can safely tell what's her ONE tier 4-what does "full C5" even means? 5- BoA has F#3 for lows 6- the (B4) (F5) things you're using don't mean anything 7- Ningning is not consistent with her head voice
Those A B C tiers don't exist... She can get better cuz anyone can, but i can't tell if she will or not. If she keeps that light lazy approach in her mix she won't be moving up at all tho
I just wanna say that Boa's A-AA factor was never the belting, it was the decent head voice and lows, if she would just have belts she would most likely be A even at her cleaner era.
@@andinho2204 It did get worse (though if you dig for 2020-2022 material there are still some easier cleaner belts here and there, also I recall she has not as raspy B4s in Time After Time).
My mother BoA!!!!!💛💛💛💛 thank you for the video
I wish Seulgi could get rid of nasality and tongue tension. She would sound much better😭
She would probably make it to A-AA
@@andinho2204 Agree. She wouldn't have a hard time supporting C5s, from my viewpoint.
BoA's voice is so beautiful, though.
I really like her voice too
NingNing is the best here
2:06 it will never fails to give me goosebumps
I'm waiting for chungha and Tiffany vocal showcase btw
Chungha is interesting tbh
@@andinho2204 yeah, i hope she releases more songs like snapping and gotta go
Yeah she back and had song that kinda the offspring of Stay Tonight in the best of course.
Nayeon and yeji best moments video plzz like how u made for haewon , Lia and jihyo like that plzz
I wish you had included NingNing's C#5 in 'Maria.' That one is soooo good.
I prefer using sustained ones
@@andinho2204 Ohh, it makes sense.
Is this why you were asking for seulgi supported C#5 example's? 👀
BoA's throatiness & pushiness is distracting but i think she falls somewhere in the middle of the high a's and low aa's, maybe higher on good day's
It is! I wanted to include atleast one ok C#5 by her haha, i think she's currently at the top of the A tier, but idk if she can still handle C5
nice video, i just don’t like how a lot of Lee Soo’s notes were recycled from the same song in different parts, it’s not that interesting if we can’t hear the fluctuations lol you could’ve had Suhyun in the video instead since she got way more material
Yeah Lee Soo wasn't the best choice kskksk she lacked materials. Suhyun on A-AA?
@@andinho2204 no, but she’s high on A, like higher than both Jueun and Seulgi. i would say she’s closer to Lee Soo in a sense lol
@ Ooh ok
Current Ben could work maybe
We could get the belters of A to AA gang and both auntie BoA and nng wouldn't stand a chance
8:21 What is the song's title?
That C#5 from Ning is that support??
Yes
I really liked this type of video ! Do you think you will do it again ?
Probably will, it's fun and can be a topic for discussion
@@andinho2204 Nice ! And indeed it is a topic for discussion. Had another question, since I saw you doing some vocal analysis about Lia, Haewon and Jihyo (that were very interesting and good btw), do you think you'll do that again and if yes, with who?
@@Portugall_ Those vocal showcases and written analysis are my favorite type of content to make so yes, i'll make more. I'm currently working on an average vocalist
@@andinho2204 I really like to see those vocal showcases so great to hear that you like to do these! Really like your content btw!
@@Portugall_ Thank you!
Can you do an analysis of Dreamcatcher's Bon Voyage?
Is that a song? And what exactly do you mean by analysis?
@@andinho2204 It's their latest single/comeback. They recently sang it live and I was wondering how well they did. Someone said SuA's and Siyeon's high notes were strained (even though they sounded great imo). I don't know how to tell all that stuff so I was just curious
They probably were strained since both siyeon and sua are not decent and don't have the proper grasp of support... They are shallow and only do ok around A4/Bb4 at their best and those are not high notes at all. The best vocalist in the group is yoohyeon who has a basic grasp of support enough for average and she does decent around A3~Bb4
@@ceropketeyonage3262 you can link me content ifyou want to
@@andinho2204 ua-cam.com/video/moNg-0mp3DU/v-deo.html
funny cause I like quite a number of the high average outputs more 😭
but I think the A-AA is still showing sksksks
Mee too ngl
Id personally say:
G#4: Jueun>Lee soo>Seulgi>Ning>BoA
A4: Jueun>Ning>Lee Soo>Seulgi\BoA
Bb4: Ning>=Lee Soo>Jueun>Seulgi>BoA
B4: Ning>Lee Soo>BoA/Jueun>=Seulgi
C5: Jueun>Ning>Lee Soo>=Seulgi>BoA
C#5: Ning>=Jueun>Lee Soo>Seulgi>BoA
a yeri subiu pra A-AA, amo rainha.
que yeri?
5:24 song plssss
Oml I'm so early 😭
whats the song name in 1:18 ?
Turning the Pages of Memories
what are your thoughts on where i placed her? i estimated current BoA to be above Winter but below Seulgi and other high average girls
Id say she's at the bottom of A-AA, below minzy, Jessica and Lee Soo. Despite the raspy mix and not cute C5s she still has the head voice and lows + some better moments up to C5 ocasionally. If by any chance she's average she would be a high one
@@andinho2204 lee soo ?who's that ?
@@BAZVOCALS it's the girl below Ningning
@@andinho2204 what is boa support range
@@Forever_2424 F3 - B4 - E5 or i could be wrong
Didn’t expect to see my girl Lee Soo 😂❤
How good was boa at her best
Mid A-AA, similar to Seohyun from snsd
@@andinho2204 No seohyun High A-AA /Low AA shes Full C5
Defenity Boa same to Minzy G3-B4 or G3/G#3 -B4/C5
1 Seohyun G3/G#3-C5-E5(F5)
2 Boa F3/F#3-B4/C5- E5/Eb5
3 Minzy G3 - B4(C5)
4 NingNing F#3/G3 - C5-D5 inconst
You don't seem to know what you're talking about..
1-Seohyun could NEVER keep up with a true high A-AA
2- pick a side lmaoo no one is 2 tiers at the same time (you're not on tik tok, that kind of nonsense won't be treated as ok)
3- Seohyun has enough materials so you can safely tell what's her ONE tier
4-what does "full C5" even means?
5- BoA has F#3 for lows
6- the (B4) (F5) things you're using don't mean anything
7- Ningning is not consistent with her head voice
Can you tell me where I can find Lee Soo singing to dance monkey? she sounds great but can't find it on youtube
You can just search: Lee soo precious dance monkey
Plzz what is the name of that girl above seulgi and her group name plzz
DIA Jueun
What is the song name in 1:00 ?
BoA - Forgive Me
How about tzuyu's vocal, can she finally support up to G#4? cause i can't trust other's vocal analysis, i always go to you lol.
She's still underdeveloped and can't support anything
I wanna ask something if you resonanced around D4-F4 range , what will the tier be ? (for boys)
I don't know honestly
@@andinho2204 okay thank you 😊
Tenor or baritone?
@@Dimyixx tenor
Depends on your development but i think more like Average - Above average
who is the other high a? she sounds nice sksks
Jueun from Dia
Who’s under ningning you didn’t say her name
Monday I think
Its Precious Leesoo who Sootzubae placed in A-AA
Sorry 😅 i forgot to add their names. She's Lee Soo from precious
How would current winter compare to these girls?
Wdym current Winter?
@@andinho2204 like winter and her vocals as of rn
@@thh982 "current Winter" was a bit odd cuz she's been in the same level of skill since debut. She's weaker than all of them basically
@@andinho2204 Oh cool I see. Do you think Ningning will ever be able to become B-? Her mix seems to be getting lighter and lighter 😔
Those A B C tiers don't exist... She can get better cuz anyone can, but i can't tell if she will or not. If she keeps that light lazy approach in her mix she won't be moving up at all tho
Hiiii
Hii
Jueun reminds me of Minseo
Never heard her tbh
@@andinho2204 Go listen to her masked singer 😭
I will!
@@bigmamafan1773 ua-cam.com/video/JKbS8nnhL0A/v-deo.html this one?
@@andinho2204 Yep
I just wanna say that Boa's A-AA factor was never the belting, it was the decent head voice and lows, if she would just have belts she would most likely be A even at her cleaner era.
Thanks for the feedback! But her belting did deteriorate, right?
Do you think that's similar to Ningning's case? I think that if she didn't have the lows and the C5/C#5 she would most likely be average too
@@andinho2204 It did get worse (though if you dig for 2020-2022 material there are still some easier cleaner belts here and there, also I recall she has not as raspy B4s in Time After Time).
@@andinho2204 If she didn't have C5/C#5 ? sure, probably A, the Bb4/B4 isn't great (though we never exactly heard her go all out on those lol).
Time after time is one of her better materials recently, she's not very pushy and the C5s seem decent
Boa is average or average - above average
Lately she sounds like a low A-AA at most
is seulgi better than boa?
No, i wouldn't sav so, but the gap is smalt
Small*
@@andinho2204 just like jihyo and seulgi?
@@klauslovesrv kinda, Jihyo is mid, Seulgi is high and BoA is low A-AA
@@andinho2204 oh thank you for the information 👀