@@michellelyston8566 no one said that? Lol K-pop Stans have a bunch of kids who thinks that and use it to show their idols are better I have been a k-pop stan for a long time and I have seen many people like that
Look there aren't they only group that does this. If you do then and you need to pass around those drugs. Yall f_cktards need to make up y'all mind either there is tatent in 4th. gen. There's no talent in 4th gen because it like one we do no talent 4th gen and seem like people bandwagon to speak hate only. Maybe next we there is talent in 4tj gen and let go jump aboard that bandwagon now. Before you even think about asking that question and here is my no (y'all going something like this " you must not like them") I didn't have to listen to there first more once but maybe you had to hear it multiple times. Tank I loved that one especially when you break down the lyrics (Tank is gold). They basically are calling out the haters and one part I the most. They saying they did it that because the way they wanted to do , bot your way.
So you're telling me that Lily consistently hits A5s all the time? And it sounds healthy? They sing live quite often so it's really impressive. I guess all her training paid off.
Nmixx vocals are just inmaculate❤️❤️All of them sing beautifully and I always thought it since their debut teasers. They're the best of the 4th gen for sure
Lily's G5s sound good, Haewon F#5 sounded decent too! hope the dont go crazy high and lose all the quality like most of the notes shown here - I know a bad note when I hear one, when that sound like me I know its bad lmao.
Honestly, her head voice, falsetto, and low register are the best! I like her voice very much so I was glad when she release her own album💕. Hope to hear her sing more.
THAT'S WHAT IM SAYINGGGG the fact that it was completely live and it was a SOLID E5 and she was public enemy number one after produce48.... people love to discredit iz*one and are just now realizing their talent only after the members redebuted (specifically ive and lesserafim) i have no idea what the hate train on iz*one as a group was/is about
You all. Why should we compare them? The fact that they are trying their best to give us entertainment is enough. We don't need to compare them,just appreciate the work that they have done. All of them are very good.
Some of these aren’t really fighting to hit notes they just have high voices and they just scream or belt I feel like it sounds way better with vibrato cause it sounds controlled
itzy chaeryeong has A5 in chillin' chillin' and yeji has a G#5 adlib in dalla dalla. who would've thought xiaoting has the highest belt in the whole generation lol
Being a rookie doesn’t equal you should be incapable of singing high notes. Very weird for ppl to say ‘imagine being a rookie and hitting an A5’ she was always talented so your mind set is weird to me. Lily was chosen to train in JYP because of her great ass vocal in the first place
@@breats4703 i mean we haven't heard Lily's lower register and agility. I believe Ningning is the best at those 2 area in this generation. And their mixed register is not that far too, but head voice definitely for what we have seen Lily's better, tho Ningning hasn't show much of her upper register. For now they both tied but there's still Yechan and Nayul for sure. What makes Lily outstanding out of most vocalist in her generation is not only her technique but also her confidence, i believe NMIXX is the most confident group to showcases their vocal in this generation and I hope because of them, there will be more groups to sing live more and do it with confident without being afraid of mistakes
the most interesting thing is that she missed the note, instead of reaching a G5 she reached 3 notes above, I recently saw the analysis of a trained vocalist, who said that even though she has very superficial support, she can reach notes in the 5 octave of way more relaxed and less tense than some other idols who have better support than hers. I found a very interesting observation!
@@neuzamaria242 She actually didn't hit a Bb5 in that clip, she did the G5, she just attacked the note a bit too much and that's why at the first second it sounds like it's higher (idk how to properly explain what she did in English, sorry if I didn't get my point across)
Finally a my that doesn’t discredit lily’s skill just to complete their idol Every my in the comment section instead of saying how good their artist is instead try to make their competition seem horrible by saying their notes aren’t healthy and all
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 i mean it's not about how high you hit a note but how you do a note, low, mid or high. This video is just a strain note party, tho some has quite nice placement in the mid and upper belts area
ningning actually sang a G#5 predebut! its in the SM rookies version of "I'm your girl" for shining star. she actually slayed in that song, you should check it out if you havent already
Lily is so impressive her voice is so clean and satisfying to hear she’s definitely gonna be the best 4th gen vocalist condsideirng she hit A5 high notes all the time she’s amazing ✨ GO LILY
her voice is so pretty but she doesn't fit korean beauty standards at all so people don't really like her. she has big eyes and weird nose but she sings well so it's okay
I’m sure lily can hit higher notes. Let’s see in the future!!! Also definitely was surprised by Bahhiyuh and people said she’s not talented? Xiaoting too
Friendly reminder this is a vid for fun and shouldn’t be used to discredit any idols.
also reminder hitting higher notes does not make someone better
@@Sun-kissed_lips True.
Mariah Carey can hold a high note for a long time, but I still prefer Heo Solji.
@@Sun-kissed_lips No one said that. Is it wrong to just appreciate their talent?
@@michellelyston8566 no one said that? Lol K-pop Stans have a bunch of kids who thinks that and use it to show their idols are better I have been a k-pop stan for a long time and I have seen many people like that
@@Sun-kissed_lips your fave must be weak at high notes:(
NMIXX are so impressive because they're actually singing live with zero autotune 💅
Just like zero coke😂
Look there aren't they only group that does this. If you do then and you need to pass around those drugs. Yall f_cktards need to make up y'all mind either there is tatent in 4th. gen. There's no talent in 4th gen because it like one we do no talent 4th gen and seem like people bandwagon to speak hate only. Maybe next we there is talent in 4tj gen and let go jump aboard that bandwagon now. Before you even think about asking that question and here is my no (y'all going something like this " you must not like them") I didn't have to listen to there first more once but maybe you had to hear it multiple times. Tank I loved that one especially when you break down the lyrics (Tank is gold). They basically are calling out the haters and one part I the most. They saying they did it that because the way they wanted to do , bot your way.
Haewon’s voice cracked in autotune :)
@@witchyfairy_ Bruh you can't even sing that good😏
@@jaypolicarpio1179 bruh what’s the correlation 💀
Hardcore believer that NMIXX is gonna save 4th gen vocals and still didn't expect Kyujin and Sullyoon to appear in the video 😭
You acted like aespa, stayc, and purplekiss did not exist💀
@@akiraji083 I think it‘s because stayc is technique wise not really good and goeun and swan carrying PK
@@akiraji083 stayc? Really?
@@akiraji083 Stayc and Purple Kiss are okay, I guess
@@vintasahi Yup.
So you're telling me that Lily consistently hits A5s all the time? And it sounds healthy? They sing live quite often so it's really impressive. I guess all her training paid off.
@@slaypa eh it does tho
@@slaypa it does
@@slaypa ok
@@slaypa you're just jealous about lily hitting and keep sustained A5 note, it was healthy and forward.
@@twiceot9111 huele a envidia XD
Sullyoon hitting dem notes yet she isn't even a vocal liner, that's my queen ✨✨
cmiiw but I think she’s part of the Vocal line since she’s also introduced as a vocalist in weekly idol(?)
@@vintasahi Oh yeah, I remember it now. Actually, all of them are considered as ”vocalist”. Btw, thank you for reminding it!
They're all part of the vocal line. All members of nmixx have a vocal position.
She is a lead vocal (?) I think. She and Bae(?) or Jinny I forgot can shallow support.0
@@zenappa3738 to what I've recalled, Sullyoon, Jinni, and Kyujin can support shallowly
My girlies nmixx debuted 2 months ago and already proved to be greatest vocalists of this gen 🤧😍.
wait 2 months already ???
Nmixx vocals are just inmaculate❤️❤️All of them sing beautifully and I always thought it since their debut teasers. They're the best of the 4th gen for sure
The way we got “Tell me Santa” 5 different times 😭 Imagine all the main vocalists singing that song and fighting for the high notes ahah
Jihan es lead vocalist 👀
Why no one is talking about Soyeon. Main rapper doing that high note.
A true ace
she is an ace
yep. and she is so pretty too
Lilly is a different breed, a VOCALIST indeed.
Lily's G5s sound good, Haewon F#5 sounded decent too! hope the dont go crazy high and lose all the quality like most of the notes shown here - I know a bad note when I hear one, when that sound like me I know its bad lmao.
KEP1ER IS VOCALLY CAPABLEEEE PERIODT🤧❤Yowww WAKEONE give Xiaoting and Hiyyih more lineeeesss
FR
I DONT WANT THEM TO DISBAND IN 3 YEARS😭😭😭
Yesss... I'm tired of hearing consistent crackin high notes.. no hate tho..
7:00 *Park Jiwon uri Main Vocalist is so underrated* 😭🤧
Kang Hyewon being included in this list is just a slap to those haters who try to discredit her. Almost all the members are here...
Honestly, her head voice, falsetto, and low register are the best! I like her voice very much so I was glad when she release her own album💕. Hope to hear her sing more.
THAT'S WHAT IM SAYINGGGG the fact that it was completely live and it was a SOLID E5 and she was public enemy number one after produce48.... people love to discredit iz*one and are just now realizing their talent only after the members redebuted (specifically ive and lesserafim) i have no idea what the hate train on iz*one as a group was/is about
Wow I didnt expect that B5 from xiaoting nor that G#5 from bahiyyih :O
Me neither i was very shock that they did higher than i expect
Miyeon G#5
Yeji G#5
Seea (pink fantasy) F#5/G5
Yubin (pink fantasy) Eb5/E5
Nayu(ily:1)E5/F5
Rayeon (fanatic) E5
Jimin (class:y) F#5
Chaewon (class:y) E5/F5
Boeun (class:y) F5/F#5
Moon sua E5
Xiaoting wow no wonder her position is vocal i hope they give parts to show her own tone better
To those haters of hyewon saying shes talentless take a look how she just hit a highnote easily its E5
LILY JUST. DIFFERENT 😩🔥
Huh YunJin is so complete. Love Her.
Shen xiaoting 🔥🔥🔥
nmixx 4th gen main vocals👏
If you talk about vocal, everybody now Lily is Queen of High note to 4th
yeji had a F#5 in chillin chillin and lia had an A5 in trust me and chillin chillin, also her high note in love is
Yeji has a A5 in Chillin' Chillin'
I love how XiaoTing sang the highest note shown ❤️ Queen
IZ*ONE is one of the 4th gen ggs with strong vocal line
hayoung's highest notes was in dm (that whistle notes in the last chorus sang by jiwon) its A5-A6!
Some mistakes:
Yeji has a G5 in Boom Box
Yena has a F#5 in Smiley
Haewon has a G5 in Bang Bang cover
yena’s F#5 is falsetto and haewon didn’t hit the G, she was quite flat it’s more of a F#
@ miyeons G#5 in blow your mind?
@@gt-hy3em that is F5 or F#5
why is no one talking about (Aespa) Karina,Winter and Ningning Vocal even the Main Rapper Giselle is Good and Ningning and Winter can be A5
GWSN!!! I hope my girls get the popularity they deserve 😞
Slayc and the fact that J isn’t even part of the vocal liner is awesome
Haram being on here makes me happy, she's a very underrated main vocalist and so strong
7:15 I enjoyed this...
wait but why is everyone singing that song 😭
I've never heard that audio before so I wasn't expecting Bahiyyih to be in the G#5...
Me: casually watching a random kpop video
The video: shows iz*one
Me: starts crying *I miss them so muccccch*
Fromis_9 , 9 visual , 9 vocalist , 9 Dancer ❤
More lines for Bahiyyih so we can hear her vocal
Yes, wadada didn’t really fit her calming voice
Yes she need to showcase her vocal otherwise people still hate her and saying shr can't sing
oh guys should listen Mainvocal Summer Project 🥺 She is main vocal
@@aminehbili9271 yeah ballad suits her more
CAN YOU DO KEP1ER VOCAL ANALYSIS? 🥺 thank you!^^
my favs- monnday, lily, chaehyun, ningning, swan, goeun, and bora..
Thanks for all Red Velvet, the next vocal queens of a new generation are here, and them name is NMIXX.
WAIT A FREAKING MOMENTT, XIAOTING??? EXCUSE ME MA'AM HOW IN THE WORLD?? i'm very much suprised.. :)
NINGNING GODDESS 🛐
kpop idols 🤝 covering santa tell me by ariana
You all. Why should we compare them? The fact that they are trying their best to give us entertainment is enough. We don't need to compare them,just appreciate the work that they have done. All of them are very good.
I LOVE YOU MINJI
I am very glad that you have not forgotten about fromis_9
XIAOTING? OMG YASSS QUEEN
IMO the one who hits A5 consistently sounds harsh
Some of the B-Sides from the F5b segment will be searched by me in spare time. Some are GOOOD
Highest I can hit is f#5 mix
If I do a G or higher it'll sound more falsetto
Tho soyeon gidles was falsetto too
Ur good. Highest ive ever gone is E5 bro... and im clearly dying at that point lol
@@meimai5139 hahah practice
My highest used to be an E5 too
I think it depends on the song too. I do better in ballads than fast songs
4th generation is wild and bold
Wonyoung F5 gave me life ♡
I love I*ZONE Cheayeon’s high note!😂
Yeah was one of my fav vocalists(by voice not technical skill)💔
loved jiwon’s and chowon’s A5
I love Haseul's tone so much
Wow lily lo hace tan limpio y pareciera que ni se esfuerza :0
Nmixx vocal Queens 👑💖🛐
Santa tell me is Korea's Christmas anthem HAHAHAH
I love all the Santa Tell Me's lol
Bora sing everything .... ultimate bias forever 😍😍😍😍😍
The amount of multistanning you have to be doing to collect all these clips damn
Some of these aren’t really fighting to hit notes they just have high voices and they just scream or belt I feel like it sounds way better with vibrato cause it sounds controlled
aespa Winter ❤️❤️❤️🔥
5:15 A MAIN RAPPER!!! Soyeon is Waooo
Great vid as always! 🌸
I wish CLASS:y members were added!
Soyeon hit G5 high note 😱
Their vocals are insane im so proud of them
liz ive is so good on royal
Yes, Secret Number is lucky to have Minji ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I thing lily vocal is the best
YASSS KANG HYEWON Y'ALL
Lmao everybody covering that Santa song
6:16 wow Bahiyyih❤❤❤
I love how much Santa Tell Me appeared haha
hyewon linda de amo
Ahn Yujin appreciation comment ❤❤
Sieun and Yoon VOCALISSSSSST
Lily has a very clean voice, especially since she stays in the treble and is a vocal athlete, she reminds me a lot of Ailee.
Totally agree
Yeah she is really good reminds me of ailee's belts and her subtle vibrato
omg yes, i thought i was the only one think that
😍😍
And then she did perform with her and Yuju this is me which was beautiful to watch
Ariana Grande contributing to the mixed A5 community in kpop
😭😭😭😭
Hahahahahahaha almost all A5 are from Santa tell me.
she is Blackpink's main Vocal along with Rosé
@@tandaseoru hyuuuuuuuuuuungggg, kita nyasar!!!
@@kimjuanrvn3713 ahahaha bisa bisanya 😭
I wish Xiaoting’s vocals were more represented cause she has such a good tone
It’s not that she can’t sing she just tend to be off pitch
@@kpopjinja it’s actually ok but uh 😕
I think because xiaoting have to learning Korean language first
@@itskyuri2604 yep:)
@@kpopjinja she does have a problem with it but even then, her tone and her technique seems to be good enough for lead voca
itzy chaeryeong has A5 in chillin' chillin' and yeji has a G#5 adlib in dalla dalla. who would've thought xiaoting has the highest belt in the whole generation lol
I thought Yeji's was also A5.
wait so it was yeji who was hitting dalla dalla high notes? i thought it's lia..
Can someone tell me where can I watch the whole video of that performance with Xiaoting? Thanks
@@ellereal8216 ua-cam.com/video/3uO3T55h77A/v-deo.html
@@Sammmm85 it's from lia
Imagine a rookie hitting an A5 and just debuted(lily)😭✊
Calm down lily😭😭😭
and consistently every time
a rookie hitting Bb5 and not even a main vocalist. xiaoting can relate.
We saw her on k-pop star so it's not really surprising even tho it's such a remarkable feat 😭
Being a rookie doesn’t equal you should be incapable of singing high notes.
Very weird for ppl to say ‘imagine being a rookie and hitting an A5’ she was always talented so your mind set is weird to me.
Lily was chosen to train in JYP because of her great ass vocal in the first place
nmixx amazes me everytime
Totally agree
5:15 can we just appreciate Soyeon, the MAIN RAPPER of (G)I-DLE doing that high note ❤️💜
ace
Ace
She kinda struggled but yah she still hit it
Lily hits those highnote effortlessly and they always sang LIVE:)
Lily's A5 is sustained which is very impressive no doubt she's the bwst 4th gen main vocal
no, that was phrased just lke the others
@yeseo loml savage 🤣
@yeseo loml yes but it still ningning>lily>monday
@@aescvlt oh my god, is it really difficult for you to accept the truth that Lily is better than them? I've seen this comment about this before tho.
@@breats4703 i mean we haven't heard Lily's lower register and agility. I believe Ningning is the best at those 2 area in this generation. And their mixed register is not that far too, but head voice definitely for what we have seen Lily's better, tho Ningning hasn't show much of her upper register. For now they both tied but there's still Yechan and Nayul for sure. What makes Lily outstanding out of most vocalist in her generation is not only her technique but also her confidence, i believe NMIXX is the most confident group to showcases their vocal in this generation and I hope because of them, there will be more groups to sing live more and do it with confident without being afraid of mistakes
I find this "ease" that Chuu has to reach certain notes very interesting, her tessitura seems to be really high!
the most interesting thing is that she missed the note, instead of reaching a G5 she reached 3 notes above, I recently saw the analysis of a trained vocalist, who said that even though she has very superficial support, she can reach notes in the 5 octave of way more relaxed and less tense than some other idols who have better support than hers. I found a very interesting observation!
@@neuzamaria242 She just has a head dominant mixed voice.
@@dana-wc8ng her voice itself sits pretty high but yeh, she mixes using more head than chest
@@neuzamaria242 would you mind sharind the analysis you watched? i'd really like to check it out :)
@@neuzamaria242 She actually didn't hit a Bb5 in that clip, she did the G5, she just attacked the note a bit too much and that's why at the first second it sounds like it's higher (idk how to properly explain what she did in English, sorry if I didn't get my point across)
nmixx is so vocally impressive and they can dance too
NMIXX ARE JUST INSANE BRO. IMAGINE JUST DEBUTING ANG CLAIMING THE TITLE ACE VOCAL OF 4TH GEN!
aespa are still the best vocalist of the 4th gen
@@paolatorcasio1387 idk, tell that to knetz
@@paolatorcasio1387 bark
@@shxdyshot1933 knetz love aespa. Nmixx didn't even chart well. Why are you trying lmao
@@LaraVergara did i say knetz dont love them?? bruh. as ive said knetz gave that title to knetz.
Winter's G5 and Yujin and Lily's A5 are the most solid high notes here
And ningnings G5
Finally a my that doesn’t discredit lily’s skill just to complete their idol
Every my in the comment section instead of saying how good their artist is instead try to make their competition seem horrible by saying their notes aren’t healthy and all
Its funny how half of the A5's are from Santa Tell Me covers
okay NMixx, vocal queens! and bahiyyih's G#5/ xiaoting's B5 WTF LEGENDS
I'm in love with your profile pic
Yet someone said Xiaoting can't sing
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 i mean it's not about how high you hit a note but how you do a note, low, mid or high. This video is just a strain note party, tho some has quite nice placement in the mid and upper belts area
@@icetro5145 fair enough but I'm just saying, I highly disagree with those who said Xiaoting can't sing
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 oh yeah yeah definitely, I'm not trying to sound mean or anything, sorry
Winter and Ning2's range doesnt surely end in G5. With how light and high their voice are, im sure they can reach B5 with more singing moments.
@@GuysLuvJeonghan lol what are u talkin abt. Im talking abt range itself not their technique🤷🏿♀️
@@GuysLuvJeonghan we still have a decent amount of live clips at least. Almost all of Ningning’s live C#5s are supported
Yall chill. Im talkin abt their range, why yall bring their vocal ability out of nowhere😭💀
ningning actually sang a G#5 predebut! its in the SM rookies version of "I'm your girl" for shining star. she actually slayed in that song, you should check it out if you havent already
@@GuysLuvJeonghan now they sang live at Coachella
Lily is so impressive her voice is so clean and satisfying to hear she’s definitely gonna be the best 4th gen vocalist condsideirng she hit A5 high notes all the time she’s amazing ✨ GO LILY
her voice is so pretty but she doesn't fit korean beauty standards at all so people don't really like her. she has big eyes and weird nose but she sings well so it's okay
@@ybi7544 who cares abt korean beauty standards?We are talking abt talent here
@@ybi7544 I hate the fact that now kpop is just if someone fits kbs not if they have true talent .
@@cali1012 read my comment lol u didn't understand the point .
@@cali1012 UGH haha
I’m sure lily can hit higher notes. Let’s see in the future!!! Also definitely was surprised by Bahhiyuh and people said she’s not talented? Xiaoting too
Wow, it is impressive you know the clip of Xiaoting legendary high notes back then when she was singing at China👍
I think Lily's voice is the one that catches people attention because her tone is different from the ones you find in kpop.