Why do documentaries like this blur out footage that has been available for the better part of a century. This kind of censorship is offensive and takes away an important lessons from history, violence is ugly..
I agree but the documentary cannot be monetized without blurring tge footage so it provides no incentive for the maker of the documentary He put in all that effort for nothing if tge video is demonetized
A lot of people that live in the West take for granted the privileges and freedoms that are available to them compared to many other parts of the world. I can't even imagine the feeling of constant fear these people must have felt
My relatives were working class people and they weren't afraid at all. Why do you believe such infantile boogeyman stories like some kind of toddler? You're a grown man or woman yet you're being duped by cheap capitalist propaganda.
@@anthonymccarthy8484 the west the most moral rotten place , homosexuality and all weird genders, serial killers , pedophiles, psychopaths the list is endless
I am from Georgia which was a part of Soviet union,even though I am 21 years old, we still feel the pain of the wounds what this monster did to my country! No one can ever imagine what does it mean.There was not even a single family in Georgia which was not a victim of his ferocious, tyrannical decisions. He tortured and killed all the Georgian outstanding poets,writers,just talented people. I don’t know why but here was not mentioned his nationality,he was Georgian.Grew up in little Georgian city Gori. Only in my country he killed hundreds of thousands of people.Closest friend of my grandma grew up in Gulag,where she was sent with her family when she was 3 years old.Can anyone imagine what does it mean? We renovated independence 30 years ago and still fighting to somehow maintain it,as we’ve gone through three wars in these three decades against Russia.There is not even a single day when Russian troops are not kidnapping our civilians living near their designated illegal borders.Western societies will never,ever,ever be able to understand what does it mean to leave under soviet legacy near the country of Putin. Only on april 9,1989 they killed 22 women in the streets of Tbilisi.Beautiful,powerful,peaceful ladies who were demanding independence and nothing else! My father who’s just 43 years old witnessed three wars with the same reason,against the same enemy! I was 5 years old when Russia invaded my homeland,my ineffable Georgia. We didn’t know for four days my uncle was alive or not. I can write many more things but okw what I want to underline is that, when western organizations are scolding us why our democracy or institutions are not perfect I want to tell them that even the fact that we exist as a state is already a miracle! You will always be sorry for us but will never really feel us.
No one is perfect brother man life is like that but just upon yourself in Georgia you must have to be a patriotic love your country first and remember to be a leader you can't dare but being patriotic is the best that's why you are still a sellout coz you don't follow the history never ever be the subject of Americans and Europe they lies onto you that Vladimir Putin is killing how much does George solo is he doing upon the humans but yourself you are just blinded person how much does stupidness that Adolf futler Hitler did by killing the Jews today you can't talk about that how many does king Nicholas did in Africa no one can talk about that today in day you are staying good life coz of the same Russians the polish land was a death ground of Jews upon Hitler but who made the polish to be free today my friend america is not a friend of anybody what they want is democracy upon you and me so that they conquer so tell me who is a good friend
Моя бабабушка после войны 1942 осталась сиротой. Она выросла в детском доме. Она говорила, как о детях хорошо заботились, хорошо одевали. Когда умер Сталин, как они все плакали, это был траур для страны. Моя бабушка любила СССР, Сталина. Всегда рассказывала нам. Поэтому у меня осталось уважение к нашей русской истории. И цари, и Петр I и Николай II и Сталин. Нет ненависти, только уважение и благодарность за нашу страну.
Rosja to przedziwny kraj, którego obywatele tyle wycierpieli od bestialskiej władzy, a kochają ją ciągle bezgranicznie. Stalin to jadno z najgorszych gówien, szmata, ścierwo. Największą tragedią w historii świata było to, że matka nie wyskrobała tego śmiecia.
The tube throws me off for twenty four hours at least once a week. I get censored for being a chronic “ cyber bully” what ever the hell that is. They are not giving us freedom of speech for sure. Just like the other Communist Tyranny driven countries and google is at the top of the list in this persuit.
Nah. Everyone feared him. Fun fact: Stalin conspired with the Nazis to fabricate evidence to eliminate the Marshal of the USSR, hero of the People, Mikhail Tukhachevsky, who hated Stalin nearly as much as Trotsky. So no, it was Stalin himself. 90% of his victims were rehabilitated in the '50s. By the same people who had signed the death warrants of the same people during Stalin, since the options were "commit evil things or die with your entire family" when they were under Stalin.
Dave, you went ro the root of the problem. Had the Russian people were different, we would have never heard of the revolution or Stalin. Had the Germans been sifferwntbin the 1930s, we would have heard of Hitler. People choose, whether actively or passively, their🎉 rulers.
Stephen Kotkin? The historian who says there is no footage of Stalin walking? Awful historians we have in the west. Truly dreadful and far too emotional.
Не диктатор , а великий государственный деятель , который построил сильную , процветающую страну и создал великий Народ , именно создал . Сколько бы вы там не тявкали Сталин Великий Человек и это известно всему Миру.
@@Deathstroke-r7h В США уничтожили почти всё коренное население, индейцев, часть их живёт в резервации! Что же об этом не говорите, "умник", только трепаться можете, а по сути ничего не понимаете. Не для вашей головы.
it's a matter of interpretation. Language is very slippery. For the word Lenin used there is no equivalent in English. He actually said something that only those who spoke his language could really understand. You could say he meant rude, or brutal and neither gets at the heart of what was said. Actually what he was was too ugly for any word in any language.
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh Actually he was worse than both. There is no descriptor for him in English (and probably not in any other language) . Repugnant, revolting, despicable? None of them come close.
Everything in this movie is a lie! How can you lie like that! The question is who built the great country? Who wrote 18 volumes of books? Read these books!
There is not much understanding in the Western World about how malefic this man was, and that's just because USSR happened to be in the same side with the allies during the WWII. But for those who knew that society from inside, he could easily be seen as an even more sinister character than Hitler.
@@MrMirville No wonder African IQ is so low when one reads something like this - he genocided 30million many to slow deaths in Siberia, but, of course, the camp extermination policy wasn't his invention but powerful people around him. Power was all that mattered to him not life! I'd advise you to take up manual work
The task of finding a successor to Joseph Stalin was a crucial and challenging one for the Soviet Union, impacting the course of Soviet history significantly. Stalin's death in 1953 left a power vacuum that required careful navigation to ensure stability and continuity. The process of selecting his successor involved complex political maneuvering, shifting alliances, and significant policy implications. This essay examines the key figures who emerged as potential successors, the political dynamics involved, and the eventual consolidation of power. The Power Vacuum and Initial Struggles Upon Stalin’s death, the Soviet leadership faced an immediate power vacuum. Stalin had maintained an iron grip on the Communist Party, leaving no clear heir apparent. The initial period after his death was marked by uncertainty and competition among the top leaders of the Communist Party. The major figures included: Georgy Malenkov: Malenkov was Stalin’s closest associate at the time of his death and initially assumed the position of Chairman of the Council of Ministers (effectively the head of government). His early leadership promised a shift in policy, with a focus on improving living standards and de-emphasizing the extreme repression characteristic of Stalin’s rule. Nikita Khrushchev: Khrushchev was the First Secretary of the Communist Party and had significant support within the party apparatus. He was known for his dynamic personality and for being more open to reform compared to some of his contemporaries. Lavrentiy Beria: Beria was the head of the Soviet secret police (MGB) and a key figure in Stalin’s repressive regime. He was a skilled operator and sought to consolidate power by positioning himself as a reformer, promising to ease the political repression and improve the Soviet economy. The Struggle for Power The initial struggle for power among these leaders was intense. Beria attempted to position himself as a reformist, but his association with the worst excesses of Stalin’s regime made him a controversial figure. He proposed significant reforms, including the decentralization of economic management and a reduction in the level of political repression. However, his rivals saw him as a threat due to his control over the security apparatus and his past actions. Khrushchev, on the other hand, played a strategic role in forming alliances within the Communist Party. He successfully maneuvered to undermine Beria and secure support from other key party members. Khrushchev’s approach was more focused on party politics and less on direct confrontation. He criticized Beria’s policies and accused him of attempting to centralize power for himself. The Emergence of Khrushchev By 1955, Khrushchev had emerged as the dominant figure in the Soviet leadership. Several factors contributed to his rise: Political Maneuvering: Khrushchev’s ability to form and maintain coalitions within the party was crucial. He effectively outmaneuvered Beria, who was arrested and executed in December 1953. Public and Party Support: Khrushchev’s critique of Stalin’s excesses resonated with many in the party and the general populace. His approach to de-Stalinization, which involved denouncing Stalin’s cult of personality and the excesses of his rule, helped consolidate his support. Administrative Changes: Khrushchev’s policies included efforts to decentralize economic control and reduce the power of the security services. These changes helped him build a base of support among various sectors of Soviet society. Khrushchev’s Leadership and Legacy Once Khrushchev consolidated his power, he implemented significant reforms that defined his leadership. His policy of de-Stalinization involved denouncing Stalin’s tyrannical methods and correcting some of the excesses of his rule. Khrushchev also attempted to promote economic growth and improve relations with the West, though his tenure was marked by both successes and failures, including the Cuban Missile Crisis and various domestic policy challenges. Khrushchev’s leadership ultimately faced opposition, leading to his removal from power in 1964. His successor, Leonid Brezhnev, took a more conservative approach, stabilizing Soviet policies and emphasizing continuity over radical change. Conclusion The selection of Stalin’s successor was a pivotal moment in Soviet history, marked by intense political maneuvering and significant policy shifts. Nikita Khrushchev emerged as the key figure, navigating the complex power dynamics of the post-Stalin era and implementing reforms that had a lasting impact on the Soviet Union. His tenure exemplified the challenges of leading a superpower through a period of transition and change, setting the stage for the subsequent developments in Soviet history.
Khrushchev was a theoretical opportunist of Marxism and sick for power and revenge because of the tribunal against his son. His son refused to sacrifice his self against the Nazis and left his position and for that reason the tribunal punished him to death for treason and Khrushchev asked Stalin's help, but Stalin refused to involved against the tribunal. Stalin even sacrificed his own son when he let him been killed by the Nazis in a camp. Stalin's doctrine was that Germans couldn't have taken, voluntary, Soviet solders as surrendered. And the Germans wanted to exchange his son for German's generals but the son was only a lieutenant and Stalin answered that he will exchange him only with a lieutenant. For that reason, when the communist party understood which was Khrushchev's real character, deposed him.
@@user-dialectic-scietist1 Stalin fue un GIGANTE de su tiempo. Iósif Stalin vivió en una época histórica, en donde el mundo requería de liderazgos fuertes. Así que tuvo que ser un dirigente enérgico. Severo. ¡Imponente! O, de otro modo, la “Madre Rusia” hubiera desaparecido del mapa. Stalin fue lo que tenía qué ser: Un Gran Líder. Un Gran Estadista. Stalin heredó un país yermo, rural, preterido, analfabeta, hambriento, supersticioso, deprimido, insalubre, carente de todo y, para colmo, delirantemente desamparado. Rusia era entonces, un país de “Siervos” (Esclavos), y Stalin lo convirtió en una súper potencia industrializada y poderosa, que puso a temblar al mundo. Rusia estaba atrasada en 100 años con respecto a Occidente y, superadas las precariedades y todas las devastaciones que causó la Guerra, él, Stalin, el “Fundador de la URSS”, puso en marcha el primer Programa Aero-Espacial del mundo. Seis años después en 1957, lanzaron el Sputnik I. Eisenhower, al saber de semejante hazaña, creó la NASA en 1958. Kennedy inauguró el primer vuelo tripulado hasta 1961. ¡Jáh! Stalin recibió una Rusia que estuvo en guerra casi 30 años. (Empezando con la humillante derrota frente al Imperio de Japón, 1904-1905. Revolución Rusa, 1905. WWI, 1914-1918. Revolución Bolchevique 1917-1922. Guerra Civil contra los “Rusos Blancos”, 1922-1927. De nuevo, Guerra contra Japón, en 1939. WWII 1940-1945… Más la Pandemia de la mal llamada “Fiebre Española”, en 1918-1920. Después les llegó el brote de la “Peste Bubónica” en 1926. ―En 1932-33, Stalin implementó una campaña general de vacunación contra la viruela, la cual, en 1936, propuso que fuese una campaña a nivel mundial. Iniciada por Stalin y secundada por todas las naciones del planeta, la viruela se erradicó en 1980―. Y, además el “Crack Financiero de Wall Street”, de 1929-1937). O sea que, Stalin, asumió el poder de un país golpeado por las guerras, enfermo por la Pandemia y, económicamente quebrado por la crisis mundial. Estas calamidades dejaron una Rusia desposeída y miserable. Stalin la rescató imponiendo disciplina y trabajo. Un ejemplo de rendimiento y nuevas tierras productivas: Al final del Segundo Plan Quinquenal, se logró la siembra de 14 Millones de hectáreas de tierras antes yermas. Ya terminada la WWII, en 1947, se alcanzó el doble de Millones de hectáreas sembradas. Ni antes ni hoy, nadie en el mundo puso en duda su ENORME LIDERAZGO. Stalin fue genial; magnífico, cultísimo y astuto. Fue un Titán con mano de hierro. Amado por su pueblo y temido por sus enemigos. Hace más de 70 años que Stalin murió y, la Propaganda Occidental, no afloja en denostarlo. ¿Con qué propósito? ¿Ya como para qué? ¿Cuál sería su utilidad ahora? ¿Stalin se convirtió en un “Fantasma Ideológico” que causa temor? [*Y, acá, aparte, va un dato que dimensiona la grandeza de Stalin. Joseph Stalin, fue nominado DOS veces al Premio Nobel de la Paz (en 1945 y 1948), con el apoyo de múltiples instituciones universitarias de Reino Unido, Irlanda, Francia, Italia, Suiza, Bélgica, y Grecia. Esas nominaciones fueron tomadas en serio por el Comité en Oslo. A él se le acabó su tiempo a los 75 años. Stalin murió en 1953, sin recibir nada de nadie, pero sí, todo el reconocimiento de su propio pueblo amoroso y agradecido.].
@@Freiheit-qj5qd You acctualy means luckily for the West capitalists, because even today the Russian are asking where is Stalin. If you make a trip to Russia you will found that by your self. But you can see this even by your self that even today the name of Stalin brings fear in the .... West. So, Stalin!
After the death of Stalin, the USSR become constantly unstable and weak. It's was never like before, or until 1953, when he died. All Stalin's man, after the death of Grand papa, were lost and without competence to well led so big and powerful country, like the USSR. And, Mikhail Gorbacov was the weakest of all. So, that's why the USSR collapsed.
И. В. Сталин- Вождь Великой Победы! Имя Победы- Иосиф Виссарионович Сталин. Сталин не ушел в прошлое- он растворился в будущем! Как сказал Шарль де Голль. 😊
Не диктатора а Великого человека , выдающегося государственного деятеля . Который посвятил всю свою жизнь укреплению , развитию государства и самое главное сделать жизнь своего Народа достойной . Заьоте и защите трудового человека. И это ему удалось. Сталин за власть не умирал , он просто знал что если власть достанеться таким жуликам и впагам народа как Троцкии Каменев Бухарин и им подобным то они из народа сделают быдло . И поэтому он забрал у них эту власть и передал Народу.
Точное описание...))) Сталин всех убивал, сажал, а потом бац, страна с образованием и медициной для всех, кругом дома отдыха, спортивные секции, лучшее метро и прочее... Зачем это все строить для народа - раз он убийца и палач?
But for some reason it`s Hitler who`s portrayed as the most eveil person to have ever existed while Stalin is remembered as a leader who helped defeat Germany in WW2
But capitalist powers constantly lie about Stalin more. Alot more. All the things known about Hitler are just his writings and speeches put into practice. Doesn't help that all of his high ranking minions admitted to their crimes too.
Probably because Hitler invaded other countries, while Stalin basically murdered the people of his own country. Without Stalin, the outcome of World War II might have been different; and it would surely have been deferred a few years.
both are evil, and I agree Hitler far more than Stalin, however because Germany was the bigger threat to western powers and at war all propaganda was aimed at them while Stalin was propped up as Hero and ally. This period of history is so dark one can only hope nothing like it happens again. That is why the Republic must stand, to always be a beacon against tyranny, whether it comes from far right or far left.
"The contents of this video (About Joseph Stalin lol) may contain acts of suicide or self harm' LOL he also killed tens of millions of people but yeah self harm. priorities.
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times.... You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
I noticed this as well. I wondered if it was some sort of AI recreation, but I think this documentary is not new enough. In any case, it is very well done.
The Russians killed almost 22,000 Polish officers, military officials and engineers in three massacres. Those people could have been useful to the Russian war effort. Polish president in exile Sikorski and his entourage were murdered too in Gibraltar by the NKVD which must have been okayed by Churchill.
So?! The Poles were betrayed by the Allies many times, during WW2. In 1939, 1943, 1944 and 1945. It is possible that today Poland can be issue for the same powers even in these days, against Russia. So, be careful, Poland, how you choose for your Allies. We Croats were lost two WWs, but we were never betrayed like that from own Allies ( Germany, Italy, Japan, ect. ). Be saluted! And what is better? Lost two WWs or be so badly betrayed, like Poland and "win" two WWs? I like to know your opinion about that theme. Thanks!
@@lildemon6464 Yes, grated. Thank you. I guess I associate him with WWII too much. I've also seen a great deal of UA-cam WWII footage that's been blurred - how infuriating.
As a member of the Baha'i Faith I have learned that God doesn't forgive any man's oppression. Every human being is, at the moment of death, judged by his actions and faith. Terrorists, especially those who have committed unspeakable crimes against humanity, will regret their actions for all eternity. Not that I can judge any person, but God is the Divine creator of the universe, and is just.
@@MrNorma77 А Вы ученик это хромого 😅😅😅😅 Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times.... You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
Like Hitler today in Germany and Napoleon today in France. Simple as that! Stalin is like Hitler and Hitler is like Napoleon. And, both they are like Stalin. Do you get me, what I mean?! I know it is not so simple, but it could got some connection between Europeans and that three great man, in European history. What you think about that?! Be saluted!
2:27, the narrator says its the largest empire of all time, this js incorrect. The british empire was by land mass and population. The ussr was 1/6 of the worlds landmass whereas the british empire was 1/4
@@Курбский-ж7хread the life of the Holy Romanovs, the life of Saint Seraphim of Sarov, the books and the holy vision of the Saint John of Kronstadt and the life of Saint Gabriel of Georgia - the Fool for Christ and you will understand what michaelphillips5786 said!
@@mikedavis4851 what a stupid comment. Trump has already been president for 4 years and didn't do anything to be called a tyrant. You are brainwashed by the media. He was a president of peace, unlike the people in charge now!
@@mikedavis4851You people are nuts and mindless. Trump was already president once and was far from a dictator. You people need to live under a real dictator to get some perspectivr.
I don't think we really know what went on between Stalin and Nadia, his wife, but it surely must have been some of the most interesting conversations and desperate power plays between husband and wife ever to lead to her suicide by shooting herself in the heart. Surely Nadia must have been a formidable opponent to Stalin, perhaps even his most formidable one he ever had in his life, certainly more aware of how to hurt him than Trotsky, to have maimed him emotionally for the rest of it, I would much have liked to have learned what battles of wills went on between her and him in secret, in which she truly had no other choice, she decided in the last to do the only free act someone in her situation has left, and it was that he never got her will of her own under his control, and her freedom, that scarred Stalin forever after that.
And even more the saddest part is that in Europa still exist the Nazis too. People never learn of historical mistakes. It is simple like that! Crazy, but it is! Be saluted!
2:13 the USSR was not the biggest empire of all time... The biggest was British Empire in early XX century with 35,5mln sq km. Then Mongol Empire of late XIII century with 26mln sq km. Then Tsarist Russia - bigger than USSR - with 22,8mln sq km. When the USSR was 22,4mln sq km. Cheers
@@jjhpor Finland, Eastern Poland, Alaska, part of machuria with Port Arthur and Dalny, territories in Caucassus with Kars, Ardahan, and Batumi, Aleutean islands etc. What is more in the period portrayed in the video (November 1938) USSR also didn't have Bessarabia, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, they were parts of the former Russian Empire as well.
In spite of the horrors, most Russians saw improvement in their economic well being during the time between WW1 and WW2. Industrialization brought great wealth overall for the majority. Some regions, particularly the Ukraine, and some sectors (Army generals come to mind) suffered terribly but with the government controlling the press few Russians knew what what happening outside of their local neighborhood.
Stalingrad was a turning point for another reason. Finally Stalin allowed Igor Kurchatov to smuggle the drawings of the Soviet atom bomb to the White House in 1942. Stalin's condition to the Soviet nuclear scientists was that he shouldn't be blamed for surrendering the design papers and air blast calculations of the Soviet nuclear research program. In return, President promised to treat the Soviets as equal allies during ww2. The Soviet nuclear weapons research program started in 1936. In 1942, two academic nuclear scientists arrived at the White House with the exact copies of the design papers of the Soviet atom bomb, including blueprints, materials lists and more papers with extensive air blast calculations.
@@VerevkinaO Stalin died 70 years ago but the western propaganda machine never stopped demonizing him. The intensity is even more now. Why? Do they fear something? They keep depicting him as a psychopath doing nothing but taking pleasure from murdering millions of his own people and interestingly enough, no one seems to question any absurdity of these claims. As if just by murdering people, Russia could be transformed from a poor rural country suffered tremendous from ruins of WW1 and brutal civil war into an industrial powerhouse, and even more than than, defeating the Nazi Germany in the most bloody war in history of mankind, turning USSR into the world’s most powerful and respected nation. All by a psychopath dictator? How did he do that? In contrast, the west think extremely highly of Mr. Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin, praising them as the best, most democratic Russian leaders in history, but what had they done to their motherland? Has anyone ask the same question?
@@АлеевИлья “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men, even when they exercise influence and not authority; still more when you superadd the tendency of the certainty of corruption by authority.” -John Emerich Edward Dalberg, Lord Acton
It is true that Stalin purged and drove many innocent people to death through tyranny, but this was not a part of Stalinism, but rather a legacy of the empire that Russia had not yet escaped from at the time. I think it's fortunate that Eurasia was not caught up in fascism because he was a leader who was thorough and never gave up.
my both parents were from USSR. My father, a russian of Cossack origin told me that his family was described as enemies of people, their belongings were taken and they were expelled firstly to Manchuria and later to Kazakhstan. Many men of the family were sent to the second world war to fight the germans, they were forced to get drank and sent on massive human waves unarmed, this way stalin could get read of the enemy of people. My mother's people were of greek origin, were also sent to Kazakhstan by force, the men were sent by force to fight the nazis, even though they were not soviet citizens but greek refugess from turkey. One of my grandmother's unlce refused to go to fight the nazis, the next day he was arrested, taken outside the village and executed. My grandparents even in the 2000s were afraid to talk against Stalin
Your father's family was treated this way because the Cossacks sided with the Whites against the Bolsheviks. Not justifying how they were treated, but yeah, they were on the losing side. However, I am skeptical of the "forced to get drunk ..." story.
Yes! The Red army was mobilized like that so many people. So, I don't surprised why the Red army got even 20 millions of soldiers, during WW2. And, even 60% died in insane charges, drank and unarmed, against the well armed and equipped German army. Be saluted and i fully understand your disappointment and pain, about lost of your people, "thanks to communism and Stalin". Be saluted from Croatia!
Thundering with fire, sparkling with the shine of steel The machines will go on a furious march, When Comrade Stalin sends us into battle And the First Marshal will lead us into battle!
Stalin was a friend of Hitler. And, Hitler was a friend of Mussolini too. So, Hitler was a very friendly man and he liked different nationalities and races. He liked even a Communism. But, problem of Hitler was that he destroyed everything what he liked. So, because that, he fall from power in Germany, in 1945. Stalin was a different man. He was not liked anybody and anybody liked Stalin. So, he survived on the power even 29 years. Mussolini was at the beginning like Stalin, but at the end he liked Hitler. Because that, he lost own power in Italy, after 21 year ( 23 years ), if we count Republic Salo. PS: I know that my words looks insane, but its not. It is some connection about that three dictators in Europa, between 1922 to 1953. Be saluted and tell me your opinion about that?! Thanks!
Your so full of shit it's coming out your ears. What murders Einstein. How do you know they happened if they don't show the actual pictures. It's called getting off it's called truth . Something that seems to make you go limp with shame.
Never to forget what happened to war veterans after the great patriotic war !!! Massacre of unbelievable proportions after all they went through in those years.
may the lord heal the people of 15 republics! Why only Russia?! He was torturing Georgians,Ukrainians,Azerbaijani,Armenian and many more nationalities!
Сталин никогда не принимал решения единолично. Обсуждали и проверяли решения много времени. С бухты барахты не принималось ничего. Страна не была настолько богата, что бы делать всё дерьмово. Очень умно всё было сделано. Жаль, что рано умер.
Диктатор на то и диктатор что самоличные решения принимает не советуясь ни с кем, чтобы уничтожить всю командную верхушку РККА перед самой войной это его решение было, а это есть один из подобных примеров...
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times and come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own.Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it.
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times.... You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
@@Qasibr Вы правы выиграть войну 1945 г 😘в 1961 г покорить космос, 😁 в первые 1957 г построить атомную станцию............................ Вас надо срочно к врачу- психиатру🥵🥶🤧🤧🤧☺
The Helsinki Moscow Group has been working in the USSR since 1976, and its branch Memorial was created in 1989. It was engaged in searching for those repressed by Stalin. Half a year ago, their representative told Radio Liberty that they can prove the total number of those repressed and executed is 2-3 million (this is for 30 years of Stalin's rule in a country with a population of 160 million). Now in Russia there are 150 million people, 266,000 prisoners, 10 years ago there were 700,000.
I was heard, in 2013, of one Russian, that Stalin was responsible about 60 millions of death people, in the USSR, between 1924 to 1953. It is a valid information or a lie? What you think about that? Thanks and be saluted from me!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh In Russia after the revolution the civil war ended in 1922. Thus in 1922 Soviet Russia appeared. The period of repressions approximately from 1922 until Stalin's death in 1953 i.e. 30 years. 650,000 were shot, 2,500,000 were repressed. The total figure is 3 million people which includes 1 million unproven victims, but hypothetically possible ones.
@@staspastukov5944 The real end of the Russian Civil war was when Admiral Kolchak was executed, in February, 1920, near Irkutsk, Siberia. Even after that the Civil war was prolong to 1922. And, even after that, in Asia were present some rests of White forces, on the Soviet soil, until 1925. About real number of the victims of the Stalin regime, we must wait for another decades and fair investigation. Because, he ruled in the USSR between 1924 to 1953. And, I think that number is much higher than just 3 or 4 millions of Stalin death victims, during that period of time. Be saluted!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh Memorial has been digging up the history of repression for over 30 years. Their motto was "find a dirty spot on the map of history and poke every child's nose into it" - these are the words of a Memorial employee for Radio Liberty. This shows how thorough their search was.
Это был великий человек создавший СССР который принес свободу угнетаемым народам Африки, Юго Восточной Азии, Латинской Америки. Помог Китаю. Всё что тут говорится по большей части враньё.
Despite all these facts, and more, Stalin is being restored as a great man in modern Russia. Also in the west, many regard him as a great man. Unbelievable!
Shoutout to the US getting a praise and admiration from Hitler in Mein Kampf, who looked upon Americas treatment upon the Natives an attempted to subject the same to Jews, Roma, and Slavs until evil Stalin forced Henry Ford’s favorite artist to paint his bunker Red, depriving the US of a future Anti-Soviet ally
The Great Purge was not the struggle for power. It was the start of the company to include the USSR in fascist club. The empire needed to be protected, and all Stalin's behavior was too logical and even cynical. According to one of the lover of his friend, Pawker, Greate Purge was used to eliminate old Bolsheviks who could resist to his plan of occupying neighbour countries instead of assistance in revolutionary actions used before. The other victims were different nationalities, wich could be spies in the coming war. Polish, Gernans, Balts, other East European nations, nationalities of Arab region (where nessesery oil reserves were situated). You can read in Gathering Storm about the symptoms of New Big War. Don't think about Stalin then he was less smart and paranoid person than Cherchill.
Ученики Пауль Йозеф Геббельс -- Ложь можно внедрить в сознание народа, если повторить ее стократно 😁Приходишь к горькому выводу, что военное руководство Советского Союза состоит из людей классом выше, чем наше собственное😅.Отнимите у народа историю, через поколение он превратится в толпу, а еще через поколение в легко управляемое стадо.😂😂😂😂Чем наглее ложь, тем больше народ в нее верит.😆😆😆😆😆
«Победа над нацизмом» (под этим мы подразумеваем победу в войне против страны, с которой Советы ранее были союзниками и даже отправляли нацистам военные материалы) не игнорирует и не оправдывает то, что делал Сталин.
@@nat1x_Мюнхенский сговор,слышал о таком?Кто там подписывал союз с Гитлером,а как делили Чехословакию?А заводы Форда которые работали на рейх?или это ДРУГОЕ?!
@@Inbraneinthememsane I should clarify, I have read a great deal about the worst of humanity. What I didn’t know previously was the he had sex with his housekeeper ( I assumed he did) and that he murdered so many family members. I knew that he murdered a few but I didn’t realize the extent.
He had a best friend his name was Kamo he was Armenian from Georgia Kamo was more powerful and most respected than Stalin. Stalin killed Kamo his best friend to maintain the power cuz Kamo had much more beef than Stalin!!!
Can we have a UA-cam for adults? No trigger warnings. No muddied photos. No sensitive feelings protected. You know, for adults.
They know better, stop asking questions.
I agree, the pixelated photos were really very irritating. It's a shame because in all other respects it was a very interesting video.
Good idea.
You nailed it ! We’re not supposed to think . Just roll up your sleeve and stop critically thinking!
They don't want to hurt anyone's feelings. That is exactly what is wrong with our society.
Why do documentaries like this blur out footage that has been available for the better part of a century. This kind of censorship is offensive and takes away an important lessons from history, violence is ugly..
I agree
I agree but the documentary cannot be monetized without blurring tge footage so it provides no incentive for the maker of the documentary
He put in all that effort for nothing if tge video is demonetized
Ask youtube
@@kushalganesh1136 So true. I don't blame the guy who put up the video, I blame the system that made him do it.
southern Baptists?
И.В.СТАЛИН САМЫЙ ЧЕСТНЫЙ СПРАВЕДЛИВЫЙ РУКОВОДИТЕЛЬ, НАРОД ЕГО НЕ ЗАБУДЕТ.❤❤❤❤❤❤
slava Stalin
A lot of people that live in the West take for granted the privileges and freedoms that are available to them compared to many other parts of the world. I can't even imagine the feeling of constant fear these people must have felt
My relatives were working class people and they weren't afraid at all. Why do you believe such infantile boogeyman stories like some kind of toddler? You're a grown man or woman yet you're being duped by cheap capitalist propaganda.
Смерть буржуям! Слава СССР !Смерть Капиталу!!!Слава Коммунизму!
OK western brainwashed man. Lmaooo
@@anthonymccarthy8484 the west the most moral rotten place , homosexuality and all weird genders, serial killers , pedophiles, psychopaths the list is endless
@@VerevkinaO Go kiss Stalin’s feet.
Wow. That footage of Yezovs daughter was intense.
God bless her heart.
What's with the censorship!!!
French 😆
The west has become a Soviet dictatorship and everything has to be censored 🙄
I feel like they have to do it, this video keeps disappearing from youtube so they gotta make sure it doesn't
Yea, blame UA-cam, they'll demonetize it
F youtube
Everyone should see this. Note that all but a few pictures of Stalin’s face are heavily touched up.
I am from Georgia which was a part of Soviet union,even though I am 21 years old, we still feel the pain of the wounds what this monster did to my country! No one can ever imagine what does it mean.There was not even a single family in Georgia which was not a victim of his ferocious, tyrannical decisions. He tortured and killed all the Georgian outstanding poets,writers,just talented people. I don’t know why but here was not mentioned his nationality,he was Georgian.Grew up in little Georgian city Gori. Only in my country he killed hundreds of thousands of people.Closest friend of my grandma grew up in Gulag,where she was sent with her family when she was 3 years old.Can anyone imagine what does it mean? We renovated independence 30 years ago and still fighting to somehow maintain it,as we’ve gone through three wars in these three decades against Russia.There is not even a single day when Russian troops are not kidnapping our civilians living near their designated illegal borders.Western societies will never,ever,ever be able to understand what does it mean to leave under soviet legacy near the country of Putin. Only on april 9,1989 they killed 22 women in the streets of Tbilisi.Beautiful,powerful,peaceful ladies who were demanding independence and nothing else! My father who’s just 43 years old witnessed three wars with the same reason,against the same enemy! I was 5 years old when Russia invaded my homeland,my ineffable Georgia. We didn’t know for four days my uncle was alive or not. I can write many more things but okw what I want to underline is that, when western organizations are scolding us why our democracy or institutions are not perfect I want to tell them that even the fact that we exist as a state is already a miracle! You will always be sorry for us but will never really feel us.
I wish more people would read this. Sending my regards from the US, and wishing you, your family, and your people the very best.
@@nyguesswho thank you!
"Я из грызунии хрю-хрю"
No one is perfect brother man life is like that but just upon yourself in Georgia you must have to be a patriotic love your country first and remember to be a leader you can't dare but being patriotic is the best that's why you are still a sellout coz you don't follow the history never ever be the subject of Americans and Europe they lies onto you that Vladimir Putin is killing how much does George solo is he doing upon the humans but yourself you are just blinded person how much does stupidness that Adolf futler Hitler did by killing the Jews today you can't talk about that how many does king Nicholas did in Africa no one can talk about that today in day you are staying good life coz of the same Russians the polish land was a death ground of Jews upon Hitler but who made the polish to be free today my friend america is not a friend of anybody what they want is democracy upon you and me so that they conquer so tell me who is a good friend
Stalin was Georgian but you blame Russians? How many Russians did your Georgian Stalin kill?
Моя бабабушка после войны 1942 осталась сиротой. Она выросла в детском доме. Она говорила, как о детях хорошо заботились, хорошо одевали. Когда умер Сталин, как они все плакали, это был траур для страны. Моя бабушка любила СССР, Сталина. Всегда рассказывала нам. Поэтому у меня осталось уважение к нашей русской истории. И цари, и Петр I и Николай II и Сталин. Нет ненависти, только уважение и благодарность за нашу страну.
Rosja to przedziwny kraj, którego obywatele tyle wycierpieli od bestialskiej władzy, a kochają ją ciągle bezgranicznie. Stalin to jadno z najgorszych gówien, szmata, ścierwo. Największą tragedią w historii świata było to, że matka nie wyskrobała tego śmiecia.
История в этом видео кажется далека от реальной истории Сталина.
А моего прадеда в Казахстан отправили,за то,что он был той же нации,что и дезертиры и уклонисты😊.В товарных вагонах куча людей умерло.
Why the bullshit UA-cam censorship? It’s like the USSR.
Yeah bro. Censorship just like in totalitarian countries
The same people that were the bolsheviks own google/youtube.
Feministic dictatorship of the west
@@artfasil Agree, anything antti maga/mrga or pootin gets deleted:)
The tube throws me off for twenty four hours at least once a week. I get censored for being a chronic “ cyber bully” what ever the hell that is. They are not giving us freedom of speech for sure. Just like the other Communist Tyranny driven countries and google is at the top of the list in this persuit.
Great documentaries, love the format, but the subject is monstrous.
Are you one of those people who believe that if someone is a "monster" they need to be censored at all costs?
@@redriderbbgun8018 I would not say it's a great documentary if that was the case
@@jessecerasus9621 Even horrible subject matter should be examined, so that it can be understood and avoided in the future.
@@redriderbbgun8018 Maybe that's why I said it's a great documentary ??
The animation is outstanding.
For real 💯💯
Самый великий правитель всех времён тот кто выиграл вторую мировую войну тот кто создал супердержаву и Иосиф Виссарионович Сталин вечная тебе память
Russian bot learn history first ,stalin was dictator
WHERE DID THIS GO IT DISAPPEARED, I've been trying to watch this for months
The hole doc has been upploade before but disappeard a few times. I did download it a long time ago.
Смерть буржуям! Слава СССР !Смерть Капиталу!!!Слава Коммунизму!
@@VerevkinaOyou first
@@daves2552 Good. Whatever you say. You are the first to enter the ravine
@@VerevkinaOHow much did Putler pay you
No other empire had as much direct control to its territories as USSR had.
They all blame Stalin but it took an entire group of people to agree with him for this all to be carried out.
But is t that how Dictatorships work ? If you dont obey , you are shot or " dissapear "
Nah. Everyone feared him. Fun fact: Stalin conspired with the Nazis to fabricate evidence to eliminate the Marshal of the USSR, hero of the People, Mikhail Tukhachevsky, who hated Stalin nearly as much as Trotsky.
So no, it was Stalin himself. 90% of his victims were rehabilitated in the '50s. By the same people who had signed the death warrants of the same people during Stalin, since the options were "commit evil things or die with your entire family" when they were under Stalin.
Dave, you went ro the root of the problem. Had the Russian people were different, we would have never heard of the revolution or Stalin. Had the Germans been sifferwntbin the 1930s, we would have heard of Hitler. People choose, whether actively or passively, their🎉 rulers.
pretty much all of history
Se Nordkorea.
Strongy recommend reading Stephan Kotkin's biography of Stalin.
and the excellent book Donald Rayfield's Stalin and his hangmen is algo recommended
Смерть буржуям! Слава СССР !Смерть Капиталу!!!Слава Коммунизму!
Читайте Ленина и Сталина
@@VerevkinaOWacko
Stephen Kotkin? The historian who says there is no footage of Stalin walking? Awful historians we have in the west. Truly dreadful and far too emotional.
Не диктатор , а великий государственный деятель , который построил сильную , процветающую страну и создал великий Народ , именно создал . Сколько бы вы там не тявкали Сталин Великий Человек и это известно всему Миру.
@@Gabriel-y7y плачешь чтоли? в какой стране они убили 100 миллионов?
@@Deathstroke-r7h В США уничтожили почти всё коренное население, индейцев, часть их живёт в резервации! Что же об этом не говорите, "умник", только трепаться можете, а по сути ничего не понимаете. Не для вашей головы.
@@vladimirkappi3369 но ведь можно открыть переписи населения в ссср и выяснить что ты обосрался
Вот о нашем руководителе фильмы гонят! Значит ,это был настоящий вождь! Если все время эти " джентльмены" о нем не могут забыть.
Как и о Иване Грозном
@@АнатолийПанин-ъ7ж ничего не можете сделать доброго для народа,для страны, но зато языки как помело зачем так вести себя?
Lenin did not say Stalin is too brutal. He said Stalin is too rude.
ленин и сралин ,два антихриста👹👹
it's a matter of interpretation. Language is very slippery. For the word Lenin used there is no equivalent in English. He actually said something that only those who spoke his language could really understand. You could say he meant rude, or brutal and neither gets at the heart of what was said. Actually what he was was too ugly for any word in any language.
@@jesuisravi and also the validity of the testament is not very solid either
He was both!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh Actually he was worse than both. There is no descriptor for him in English (and probably not in any other language) . Repugnant, revolting, despicable? None of them come close.
WATCHING FROM GUYANA IN SOUTH AMÉRICA
Jim Jones. Great Democrat and loved USSR.
Everything in this movie is a lie! How can you lie like that! The question is who built the great country? Who wrote 18 volumes of books? Read these books!
@@VerevkinaO TRUTH IS NOT RELATIVE!! TRUTH WILL ALWAYS BE TRUTH NO MATTER HOW YOU TWIST IT.
@@VerevkinaO Everything in this documentary is the truth. You just seem to like genocide.
Watching from USA brother, hope all is well.
It amazes me how 1 man can do so much evil and no one is brave enough or smart to do anything about it.
There is not much understanding in the Western World about how malefic this man was, and that's just because USSR happened to be in the same side with the allies during the WWII. But for those who knew that society from inside, he could easily be seen as an even more sinister character than Hitler.
That is so correct!
@@MrMirville No wonder African IQ is so low when one reads something like this - he genocided 30million many to slow deaths in Siberia, but, of course, the camp extermination policy wasn't his invention but powerful people around him. Power was all that mattered to him not life! I'd advise you to take up manual work
The task of finding a successor to Joseph Stalin was a crucial and challenging one for the Soviet Union, impacting the course of Soviet history significantly. Stalin's death in 1953 left a power vacuum that required careful navigation to ensure stability and continuity. The process of selecting his successor involved complex political maneuvering, shifting alliances, and significant policy implications. This essay examines the key figures who emerged as potential successors, the political dynamics involved, and the eventual consolidation of power.
The Power Vacuum and Initial Struggles
Upon Stalin’s death, the Soviet leadership faced an immediate power vacuum. Stalin had maintained an iron grip on the Communist Party, leaving no clear heir apparent. The initial period after his death was marked by uncertainty and competition among the top leaders of the Communist Party. The major figures included:
Georgy Malenkov: Malenkov was Stalin’s closest associate at the time of his death and initially assumed the position of Chairman of the Council of Ministers (effectively the head of government). His early leadership promised a shift in policy, with a focus on improving living standards and de-emphasizing the extreme repression characteristic of Stalin’s rule.
Nikita Khrushchev: Khrushchev was the First Secretary of the Communist Party and had significant support within the party apparatus. He was known for his dynamic personality and for being more open to reform compared to some of his contemporaries.
Lavrentiy Beria: Beria was the head of the Soviet secret police (MGB) and a key figure in Stalin’s repressive regime. He was a skilled operator and sought to consolidate power by positioning himself as a reformer, promising to ease the political repression and improve the Soviet economy.
The Struggle for Power
The initial struggle for power among these leaders was intense. Beria attempted to position himself as a reformist, but his association with the worst excesses of Stalin’s regime made him a controversial figure. He proposed significant reforms, including the decentralization of economic management and a reduction in the level of political repression. However, his rivals saw him as a threat due to his control over the security apparatus and his past actions.
Khrushchev, on the other hand, played a strategic role in forming alliances within the Communist Party. He successfully maneuvered to undermine Beria and secure support from other key party members. Khrushchev’s approach was more focused on party politics and less on direct confrontation. He criticized Beria’s policies and accused him of attempting to centralize power for himself.
The Emergence of Khrushchev
By 1955, Khrushchev had emerged as the dominant figure in the Soviet leadership. Several factors contributed to his rise:
Political Maneuvering: Khrushchev’s ability to form and maintain coalitions within the party was crucial. He effectively outmaneuvered Beria, who was arrested and executed in December 1953.
Public and Party Support: Khrushchev’s critique of Stalin’s excesses resonated with many in the party and the general populace. His approach to de-Stalinization, which involved denouncing Stalin’s cult of personality and the excesses of his rule, helped consolidate his support.
Administrative Changes: Khrushchev’s policies included efforts to decentralize economic control and reduce the power of the security services. These changes helped him build a base of support among various sectors of Soviet society.
Khrushchev’s Leadership and Legacy
Once Khrushchev consolidated his power, he implemented significant reforms that defined his leadership. His policy of de-Stalinization involved denouncing Stalin’s tyrannical methods and correcting some of the excesses of his rule. Khrushchev also attempted to promote economic growth and improve relations with the West, though his tenure was marked by both successes and failures, including the Cuban Missile Crisis and various domestic policy challenges.
Khrushchev’s leadership ultimately faced opposition, leading to his removal from power in 1964. His successor, Leonid Brezhnev, took a more conservative approach, stabilizing Soviet policies and emphasizing continuity over radical change.
Conclusion
The selection of Stalin’s successor was a pivotal moment in Soviet history, marked by intense political maneuvering and significant policy shifts. Nikita Khrushchev emerged as the key figure, navigating the complex power dynamics of the post-Stalin era and implementing reforms that had a lasting impact on the Soviet Union. His tenure exemplified the challenges of leading a superpower through a period of transition and change, setting the stage for the subsequent developments in Soviet history.
Khrushchev was a theoretical opportunist of Marxism and sick for power and revenge because of the tribunal against his son. His son refused to sacrifice his self against the Nazis and left his position and for that reason the tribunal punished him to death for treason and Khrushchev asked Stalin's help, but Stalin refused to involved against the tribunal. Stalin even sacrificed his own son when he let him been killed by the Nazis in a camp. Stalin's doctrine was that Germans couldn't have taken, voluntary, Soviet solders as surrendered. And the Germans wanted to exchange his son for German's generals but the son was only a lieutenant and Stalin answered that he will exchange him only with a lieutenant. For that reason, when the communist party understood which was Khrushchev's real character, deposed him.
@@user-dialectic-scietist1 Stalin fue un GIGANTE de su tiempo. Iósif Stalin vivió en una época histórica, en donde el mundo requería de liderazgos fuertes. Así que tuvo que ser un dirigente enérgico. Severo. ¡Imponente! O, de otro modo, la “Madre Rusia” hubiera desaparecido del mapa. Stalin fue lo que tenía qué ser: Un Gran Líder. Un Gran Estadista. Stalin heredó un país yermo, rural, preterido, analfabeta, hambriento, supersticioso, deprimido, insalubre, carente de todo y, para colmo, delirantemente desamparado. Rusia era entonces, un país de “Siervos” (Esclavos), y Stalin lo convirtió en una súper potencia industrializada y poderosa, que puso a temblar al mundo. Rusia estaba atrasada en 100 años con respecto a Occidente y, superadas las precariedades y todas las devastaciones que causó la Guerra, él, Stalin, el “Fundador de la URSS”, puso en marcha el primer Programa Aero-Espacial del mundo. Seis años después en 1957, lanzaron el Sputnik I. Eisenhower, al saber de semejante hazaña, creó la NASA en 1958. Kennedy inauguró el primer vuelo tripulado hasta 1961. ¡Jáh! Stalin recibió una Rusia que estuvo en guerra casi 30 años. (Empezando con la humillante derrota frente al Imperio de Japón, 1904-1905. Revolución Rusa, 1905. WWI, 1914-1918. Revolución Bolchevique 1917-1922. Guerra Civil contra los “Rusos Blancos”, 1922-1927. De nuevo, Guerra contra Japón, en 1939. WWII 1940-1945… Más la Pandemia de la mal llamada “Fiebre Española”, en 1918-1920. Después les llegó el brote de la “Peste Bubónica” en 1926. ―En 1932-33, Stalin implementó una campaña general de vacunación contra la viruela, la cual, en 1936, propuso que fuese una campaña a nivel mundial. Iniciada por Stalin y secundada por todas las naciones del planeta, la viruela se erradicó en 1980―. Y, además el “Crack Financiero de Wall Street”, de 1929-1937). O sea que, Stalin, asumió el poder de un país golpeado por las guerras, enfermo por la Pandemia y, económicamente quebrado por la crisis mundial. Estas calamidades dejaron una Rusia desposeída y miserable. Stalin la rescató imponiendo disciplina y trabajo. Un ejemplo de rendimiento y nuevas tierras productivas: Al final del Segundo Plan Quinquenal, se logró la siembra de 14 Millones de hectáreas de tierras antes yermas. Ya terminada la WWII, en 1947, se alcanzó el doble de Millones de hectáreas sembradas. Ni antes ni hoy, nadie en el mundo puso en duda su ENORME LIDERAZGO. Stalin fue genial; magnífico, cultísimo y astuto. Fue un Titán con mano de hierro. Amado por su pueblo y temido por sus enemigos. Hace más de 70 años que Stalin murió y, la Propaganda Occidental, no afloja en denostarlo. ¿Con qué propósito? ¿Ya como para qué? ¿Cuál sería su utilidad ahora? ¿Stalin se convirtió en un “Fantasma Ideológico” que causa temor? [*Y, acá, aparte, va un dato que dimensiona la grandeza de Stalin. Joseph Stalin, fue nominado DOS veces al Premio Nobel de la Paz (en 1945 y 1948), con el apoyo de múltiples instituciones universitarias de Reino Unido, Irlanda, Francia, Italia, Suiza, Bélgica, y Grecia. Esas nominaciones fueron tomadas en serio por el Comité en Oslo. A él se le acabó su tiempo a los 75 años. Stalin murió en 1953, sin recibir nada de nadie, pero sí, todo el reconocimiento de su propio pueblo amoroso y agradecido.].
ChatGPT drivel
@@Freiheit-qj5qd You acctualy means luckily for the West capitalists, because even today the Russian are asking where is Stalin. If you make a trip to Russia you will found that by your self. But you can see this even by your self that even today the name of Stalin brings fear in the .... West. So, Stalin!
After the death of Stalin, the USSR become constantly unstable and weak. It's was never like before, or until 1953, when he died. All Stalin's man, after the death of Grand papa, were lost and without competence to well led so big and powerful country, like the USSR. And, Mikhail Gorbacov was the weakest of all. So, that's why the USSR collapsed.
И. В. Сталин- Вождь Великой Победы! Имя Победы- Иосиф Виссарионович Сталин. Сталин не ушел в прошлое- он растворился в будущем! Как сказал Шарль де Голль. 😊
Joseph Stalin was born in the former Soviet Republic of Georgia and his real given name is Joseph Jugashvili
Not really… it certainly wasn’t “Joseph”
Iosif Dzhugashvilli
Something along that
Edit: Full name is Ioseb Besarionis dze Jughashvili. Shortened form is Dzhugashvilli.
Не было никакой советской республики в те года, он родился в Российской Империи
And the relevance is... what exqctly?
Иосиф Сталин не мог родиться в СССР
I love documentaries👌
What nonsense! Everything in this movie is a lie!😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈
@VerevkinaO it's western propaganda movie
@@VerevkinaO what is the truth, then?
@@avafe96 Энгельс : «Коммунизм есть учение об условиях освобождения пролетариата.
I abandoned this about 15 minutes in because it was ridiculously censored.
Не диктатора а Великого человека , выдающегося государственного деятеля . Который посвятил всю свою жизнь укреплению , развитию государства и самое главное сделать жизнь своего Народа достойной . Заьоте и защите трудового человека. И это ему удалось. Сталин за власть не умирал , он просто знал что если власть достанеться таким жуликам и впагам народа как Троцкии Каменев Бухарин и им подобным то они из народа сделают быдло . И поэтому он забрал у них эту власть и передал Народу.
Пропаганда не делает людей идиотами - она предназначена для идиотов.
Точное описание...))) Сталин всех убивал, сажал, а потом бац, страна с образованием и медициной для всех, кругом дома отдыха, спортивные секции, лучшее метро и прочее... Зачем это все строить для народа - раз он убийца и палач?
Great Doc, from South Carolina, USA
But for some reason it`s Hitler who`s portrayed as the most eveil person to have ever existed while Stalin is remembered as a leader who helped defeat Germany in WW2
Hitler was a war monger .
But capitalist powers constantly lie about Stalin more. Alot more. All the things known about Hitler are just his writings and speeches put into practice. Doesn't help that all of his high ranking minions admitted to their crimes too.
Probably because Hitler invaded other countries, while Stalin basically murdered the people of his own country. Without Stalin, the outcome of World War II might have been different; and it would surely have been deferred a few years.
Segraren skriver historien.
both are evil, and I agree Hitler far more than Stalin, however because Germany was the bigger threat to western powers and at war all propaganda was aimed at them while Stalin was propped up as Hero and ally. This period of history is so dark one can only hope nothing like it happens again. That is why the Republic must stand, to always be a beacon against tyranny, whether it comes from far right or far left.
"The contents of this video (About Joseph Stalin lol) may contain acts of suicide or self harm' LOL he also killed tens of millions of people but yeah self harm. priorities.
Proof that he killed tens of millions? There isn't any. Congrats, you've been fooled by capitalist propaganda. Not smart enough to see through it.
Смерть буржуям! Слава СССР !Смерть Капиталу!!!Слава Коммунизму!
Shutup ice boi @@VerevkinaO
@@buildyourself4075 Who are you? A monkey from a tree?🥳
Stasi@work. Der Osten lebt. 😂😂😂
it's not Stalin's Gulags, Lening built the Gulag Concentration Camp System in 1918
Lenin may have created them, but Stalin was the Premiere therefore, at this time, they were Stalin's.
@@loraweems8712agree. They were open bc joe wanted them open. Lenin was only mentioned bc Joe wanted it.
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times....
You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
@@loraweems8712 Lenin's Idea, Stalin's Practice, and Beria's implement. All three were disgusting men.
@@Freiheit-qj5qd Tsarist Russia built the Gulags long before the commies came on the scene, so you can add Nicholas II to that list.
Врать хорошо умеют.
Verbal interpretation is far much better than subtitles
I like how the producer of this documentary uses actual footage of Stalin (2:27, 4:29, 7:01, etc) to reenact his daily routines.
I noticed this as well. I wondered if it was some sort of AI recreation, but I think this documentary is not new enough. In any case, it is very well done.
@@marcinna8553 yes it was. Superb!
The Russians killed almost 22,000 Polish officers, military officials and engineers in three massacres. Those people could have been useful to the Russian war effort. Polish president in exile Sikorski and his entourage were murdered too in Gibraltar by the NKVD which must have been okayed by Churchill.
22k is a drop in the ocean compared to how much they executed of their own
Don't mix russian with ukranians nazi.
@@ABRAHAMGOLDENBERGand how much?
how many Ukrainians did you kill in Ukraine, and than deport all the people of Lemkivshyna in 1947 at gunpoint at 4am
So?! The Poles were betrayed by the Allies many times, during WW2. In 1939, 1943, 1944 and 1945. It is possible that today Poland can be issue for the same powers even in these days, against Russia. So, be careful, Poland, how you choose for your Allies. We Croats were lost two WWs, but we were never betrayed like that from own Allies ( Germany, Italy, Japan, ect. ). Be saluted! And what is better? Lost two WWs or be so badly betrayed, like Poland and "win" two WWs? I like to know your opinion about that theme. Thanks!
Why the *&$#@ do you show us film that that been censored??? This is WWII we're talking about!
This has nothing to do with WWII. It’s not mentioned at all. This is mostly about the Great Purge which ended in 1938, a year earlier than WWII.
@@lildemon6464 Yes, grated. Thank you. I guess I associate him with WWII too much. I've also seen a great deal of UA-cam WWII footage that's been blurred - how infuriating.
@@Graffenwehr that’s fine lol its normal
UA-cam won't let a video with deaths be monetized, even if it's a documentary. So dumb.
As a member of the Baha'i Faith I have learned that God doesn't forgive any man's oppression. Every human being is, at the moment of death, judged by his actions and faith. Terrorists, especially those who have committed unspeakable crimes against humanity, will regret their actions for all eternity. Not that I can judge any person, but God is the Divine creator of the universe, and is just.
Why all the pixeled scenes?
"Политическая деятельность - не тротуар Невского проспекта" Н. Г. Чернышевский
Ты сталинист что ли?
@@MrNorma77 А Вы ученик это хромого 😅😅😅😅 Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times....
You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
You know, still in former soviet republics many people consider him great man who made much for ordinary people
Вам иностранцам показывают только отрицательное про Советский Союз...,а вы уже развесили и верите.!!! К сожалению...
Like Hitler today in Germany and Napoleon today in France. Simple as that! Stalin is like Hitler and Hitler is like Napoleon. And, both they are like Stalin. Do you get me, what I mean?! I know it is not so simple, but it could got some connection between Europeans and that three great man, in European history. What you think about that?! Be saluted!
“Political activity is not the sidewalk of Nevsky Prospekt” N. G. Chernyshevsky
2:27, the narrator says its the largest empire of all time, this js incorrect. The british empire was by land mass and population. The ussr was 1/6 of the worlds landmass whereas the british empire was 1/4
Comrade 6 is bigger than 4
90% of the british "empire" was stolen land! Nothing to crow about 😂😂
The Great Mongol empire was also
maybe he meant by military power
@@boblogIIIfan we will wait here until you realize basic first grade math
This guy makes Hitler look like Micky Mouse
Hitler himself looks like goofy lol
Not at all. Hitler was a lot worse
they're both evil monsters. there's no point in comparing who's worse lol
Nah,Hitler killed far more people
Even with the Holocaust? Really?
Stalin, was a demon, an absolute monster.
Откуда ты это знаешь? Ты много читаешь? Хронику,документы?
Да не был он абсолютным демоном! Для меня демоны те кто дал команду сбросить атомную бомбу на Хиросиму и Нагосаки.
@@Фекла-з7й
Don't act dumb , both USA and USSR are criminals as hell
They are worst than Germany
@@Фекла-з7йты серьезно? Тебе не стыдно такую чушь нести ?
@@Курбский-ж7хread the life of the Holy Romanovs, the life of Saint Seraphim of Sarov, the books and the holy vision of the Saint John of Kronstadt and the life of Saint Gabriel of Georgia - the Fool for Christ and you will understand what michaelphillips5786 said!
Not the biggest empire of all time. I can’t believe that you said that
*To think that some people still support authoritarian regimes or leaders.*
*Absolute insanity.*
It is happening In America now with Trump.😢
@@mikedavis4851 Dålig liknelse. Han kan röstas bort.
@@mikedavis4851 what a stupid comment. Trump has already been president for 4 years and didn't do anything to be called a tyrant. You are brainwashed by the media. He was a president of peace, unlike the people in charge now!
Selfishness.self interest and greed for personal power will always make it possible my friend
@@mikedavis4851You people are nuts and mindless. Trump was already president once and was far from a dictator. You people need to live under a real dictator to get some perspectivr.
I don't think we really know what went on between Stalin and Nadia, his wife, but it surely must have been some of the most interesting conversations and desperate power plays between husband and wife ever to lead to her suicide by shooting herself in the heart. Surely Nadia must have been a formidable opponent to Stalin, perhaps even his most formidable one he ever had in his life, certainly more aware of how to hurt him than Trotsky, to have maimed him emotionally for the rest of it, I would much have liked to have learned what battles of wills went on between her and him in secret, in which she truly had no other choice, she decided in the last to do the only free act someone in her situation has left, and it was that he never got her will of her own under his control, and her freedom, that scarred Stalin forever after that.
The saddest part is that there are still Stalinists, there are still apologists and useful idiots making excuses for this monster.
There are still stalinists because of this bullshit and idiotic propoganda, which has nothing to do with real history
And even more the saddest part is that in Europa still exist the Nazis too. People never learn of historical mistakes. It is simple like that! Crazy, but it is! Be saluted!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mhwhere?
@@krob2327 Where what?
2:13 the USSR was not the biggest empire of all time...
The biggest was British Empire in early XX century with 35,5mln sq km. Then Mongol Empire of late XIII century with 26mln sq km. Then Tsarist Russia - bigger than USSR - with 22,8mln sq km. When the USSR was 22,4mln sq km.
Cheers
What was not included in the USSR that the empire had?
@@jjhpor Finland, Eastern Poland, Alaska, part of machuria with Port Arthur and Dalny, territories in Caucassus with Kars, Ardahan, and Batumi, Aleutean islands etc.
What is more in the period portrayed in the video (November 1938) USSR also didn't have Bessarabia, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, they were parts of the former Russian Empire as well.
I am surprised to see the entire USSR mourned after such an inhuman's death.
It is only few thousands for the camera; and most of them wanted to be sure he was dead.
In spite of the horrors, most Russians saw improvement in their economic well being during the time between WW1 and WW2. Industrialization brought great wealth overall for the majority. Some regions, particularly the Ukraine, and some sectors (Army generals come to mind) suffered terribly but with the government controlling the press few Russians knew what what happening outside of their local neighborhood.
Stalingrad was a turning point for another reason. Finally Stalin allowed Igor Kurchatov to smuggle the drawings of the Soviet atom bomb to the White House in 1942. Stalin's condition to the Soviet nuclear scientists was that he shouldn't be blamed for surrendering the design papers and air blast calculations of the Soviet nuclear research program. In return, President promised to treat the Soviets as equal allies during ww2. The Soviet nuclear weapons research program started in 1936. In 1942, two academic nuclear scientists arrived at the White House with the exact copies of the design papers of the Soviet atom bomb, including blueprints, materials lists and more papers with extensive air blast calculations.
Why is Robert DeNiro in the thumbnail?
Bc he's an insane old guy like Stalin.
@@EmitOcean20 Can't argue with you on that lol
@@EmitOcean20: You talking to me??? I said, you TALKING TO ME???
I like that the map shown of the USSR is the 1939 one, not the one after 1945.
I’m Russian, I remember my mother always told me “do not say a word”
Boy…nothing has changed
@@TheHk1966
But not like USSR
What a lie 😮
Is it true ?
About who? Stalin or the communism?
He is not dictator.he know how to rule the government.
Talk about living in HELL!!! Poor people..😢
What nonsense! Everything in this movie is a lie!😈😈😈😈😈😈😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@VerevkinaO
like you
@@donnerwetter4753 😘
@@VerevkinaO: Oh look, a Russian bot!
@@VerevkinaO Stalin died 70 years ago but the western propaganda machine never stopped demonizing him. The intensity is even more now. Why? Do they fear something? They keep depicting him as a psychopath doing nothing but taking pleasure from murdering millions of his own people and interestingly enough, no one seems to question any absurdity of these claims. As if just by murdering people, Russia could be transformed from a poor rural country suffered tremendous from ruins of WW1 and brutal civil war into an industrial powerhouse, and even more than than, defeating the Nazi Germany in the most bloody war in history of mankind, turning USSR into the world’s most powerful and respected nation. All by a psychopath dictator? How did he do that? In contrast, the west think extremely highly of Mr. Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin, praising them as the best, most democratic Russian leaders in history, but what had they done to their motherland? Has anyone ask the same question?
Still can't believe that Stalin was actually shorter than Napoleon. He must have had the same shoemaker as Humphrey Bogart and Alan Ladd.
What is Capitalism？？？What is Dictatorship of the proletariat?? What is the Class struggle?? Is it necessary in our life??
Классовая борьба - это обычное явление в обществе! Она всегда была в истории человечества!
-
@@АлеевИлья “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men, even when they exercise influence and not authority; still more when you superadd the tendency of the certainty of corruption by authority.”
-John Emerich Edward Dalberg, Lord Acton
It is true that Stalin purged and drove many innocent people to death through tyranny, but this was not a part of Stalinism, but rather a legacy of the empire that Russia had not yet escaped from at the time. I think it's fortunate that Eurasia was not caught up in fascism because he was a leader who was thorough and never gave up.
my both parents were from USSR. My father, a russian of Cossack origin told me that his family was described as enemies of people, their belongings were taken and they were expelled firstly to Manchuria and later to Kazakhstan. Many men of the family were sent to the second world war to fight the germans, they were forced to get drank and sent on massive human waves unarmed, this way stalin could get read of the enemy of people.
My mother's people were of greek origin, were also sent to Kazakhstan by force, the men were sent by force to fight the nazis, even though they were not soviet citizens but greek refugess from turkey. One of my grandmother's unlce refused to go to fight the nazis, the next day he was arrested, taken outside the village and executed.
My grandparents even in the 2000s were afraid to talk against Stalin
were your family members apart of Vlasov’s Russien Freikorps by any chance
Your father's family was treated this way because the Cossacks sided with the Whites against the Bolsheviks. Not justifying how they were treated, but yeah, they were on the losing side. However, I am skeptical of the "forced to get drunk ..." story.
And I was grateful in MSSR never had to worry about food, rent, health care, education cause it was all provided by USSR Free
Yes! The Red army was mobilized like that so many people. So, I don't surprised why the Red army got even 20 millions of soldiers, during WW2. And, even 60% died in insane charges, drank and unarmed, against the well armed and equipped German army. Be saluted and i fully understand your disappointment and pain, about lost of your people, "thanks to communism and Stalin". Be saluted from Croatia!
Is this from Shudder?
После смерти Сталина, весь народ плакал искренно, а по ком сейчас будут плакать??????
В лучшем случае, 5 процентов населения имеют критическое мышление.И ни чего не изменилось. Будут и по этому, плакать.Бараны не понимают,что они мясо.
Вот это не правда.
По фашисту Путлеру будут радостные слезы
@@ТамараРуденко-э3м👍👍👍👍👍
@@Валентин-ч9д правда
Glory to our wise leader and commander, Marshal of the Soviet Union, the Great Stalin!
Thundering with fire, sparkling with the shine of steel
The machines will go on a furious march,
When Comrade Stalin sends us into battle
And the First Marshal will lead us into battle!
Thank You. ❤
3:55 i remember seeing the uncensord version on youtube was not expecting that
I believe the biggest empires were
The British Empire
The Mongol Empire
Very well made
Stalin was the greatest leader of our country
Western propaganda always do this who ever they didn't like,,I bet you all those people he killed were western dogs who worked for them ,,,,
Thanks for the notification.
Comrade Stalin, like the Führer held onto power right to the end, neither was going let go of control. Both were very similar in that regard.
Both were great heroes of the modern world
Add TRUMP TO THE LIST.😮
@@mikedavis4851 or The Clinton/Obama Regime
@@mikedavis4851 Add Diane Feinstein and Nancy Pelosi.
Stalin was a friend of Hitler. And, Hitler was a friend of Mussolini too. So, Hitler was a very friendly man and he liked different nationalities and races. He liked even a Communism. But, problem of Hitler was that he destroyed everything what he liked. So, because that, he fall from power in Germany, in 1945. Stalin was a different man. He was not liked anybody and anybody liked Stalin. So, he survived on the power even 29 years. Mussolini was at the beginning like Stalin, but at the end he liked Hitler. Because that, he lost own power in Italy, after 21 year ( 23 years ), if we count Republic Salo. PS: I know that my words looks insane, but its not. It is some connection about that three dictators in Europa, between 1922 to 1953. Be saluted and tell me your opinion about that?! Thanks!
Thank you for blurring the murders. Although there are people on here who would like to get off watching it without the blurring.
Your so full of shit it's coming out your ears. What murders Einstein. How do you know they happened if they don't show the actual pictures. It's called getting off it's called truth . Something that seems to make you go limp with shame.
Never to forget what happened to war veterans after the great patriotic war !!! Massacre of unbelievable proportions after all they went through in those years.
Insane, this man had so much power which he neither deserved or should of ever had, absolutely disgusting and evil
Dam!! That was captivating, I guess because he was so terrifying.
May THE LORD heal the people of Russia.
♥️
may the lord heal the people of 15 republics! Why only Russia?! He was torturing Georgians,Ukrainians,Azerbaijani,Armenian and many more nationalities!
May the LORD HEAL THE PEOPLE OF AMERICA.😮😊
Strongly agree Stephen Kotkin bio is a must read
Сталин никогда не принимал решения единолично. Обсуждали и проверяли решения много времени. С бухты барахты не принималось ничего. Страна не была настолько богата, что бы делать всё дерьмово. Очень умно всё было сделано. Жаль, что рано умер.
Died early? He lived into his mid 70s.
Parabéns para A grande União Soviética e o Povo Soviético.
Viva Stálin e o Comunismo
Brazil.
Lol so he killed People to save food? You are sick like Stalin lol
Проверяли, решали, но он принимал свое решение.
Диктатор на то и диктатор что самоличные решения принимает не советуясь ни с кем, чтобы уничтожить всю командную верхушку РККА перед самой войной это его решение было, а это есть один из подобных примеров...
Grazie di questa testimonianza.
Welcome to Tanzania
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times and come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own.Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it.
Paul Joseph Goebbels -- A lie can be embedded in the consciousness of the people if you repeat it a hundred times....
You come to the bitter conclusion that the military leadership of the Soviet Union consists of people of a class higher than our own. ...Take away the history of the people, in a generation they will turn into a crowd, and in another generation into an easily controlled herd.....The more brazen the lie, the more people believe in it....
Is Tanzania really like Stalins Russia?
@@Qasibr karibu sana hakuna matata
@@Qasibr Вы правы выиграть войну 1945 г 😘в 1961 г покорить космос, 😁 в первые 1957 г построить атомную станцию............................ Вас надо срочно к врачу- психиатру🥵🥶🤧🤧🤧☺
The Helsinki Moscow Group has been working in the USSR since 1976, and its branch Memorial was created in 1989. It was engaged in searching for those repressed by Stalin. Half a year ago, their representative told Radio Liberty that they can prove the total number of those repressed and executed is 2-3 million (this is for 30 years of Stalin's rule in a country with a population of 160 million). Now in Russia there are 150 million people, 266,000 prisoners, 10 years ago there were 700,000.
I was heard, in 2013, of one Russian, that Stalin was responsible about 60 millions of death people, in the USSR, between 1924 to 1953. It is a valid information or a lie? What you think about that? Thanks and be saluted from me!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh In Russia after the revolution the civil war ended in 1922. Thus in 1922 Soviet Russia appeared. The period of repressions approximately from 1922 until Stalin's death in 1953 i.e. 30 years. 650,000 were shot, 2,500,000 were repressed. The total figure is 3 million people which includes 1 million unproven victims, but hypothetically possible ones.
@@staspastukov5944 The real end of the Russian Civil war was when Admiral Kolchak was executed, in February, 1920, near Irkutsk, Siberia. Even after that the Civil war was prolong to 1922. And, even after that, in Asia were present some rests of White forces, on the Soviet soil, until 1925. About real number of the victims of the Stalin regime, we must wait for another decades and fair investigation. Because, he ruled in the USSR between 1924 to 1953. And, I think that number is much higher than just 3 or 4 millions of Stalin death victims, during that period of time. Be saluted!
@@DaliborPerkovic-sw8mh Memorial has been digging up the history of repression for over 30 years. Their motto was "find a dirty spot on the map of history and poke every child's nose into it" - these are the words of a Memorial employee for Radio Liberty. This shows how thorough their search was.
@@staspastukov5944 Thanks for your information.
Это был великий человек создавший СССР который принес свободу угнетаемым народам Африки, Юго Восточной Азии, Латинской Америки. Помог Китаю.
Всё что тут говорится по большей части враньё.
Чего создал фюрер сталин ? ....Совдеп эНто точно не он создал, он не создавал а уничтожал, при чём то лучшее что было в России на тот момент Совдепа !
После моей смерти, на мою могилу нанесут кучу мусора, но ветер истории развеет ее. И.В. Сталин.
Ты бы еще написал нет тела нет дела, солдат на фельдмаршалов не меняю или какой нибудь другой выдуманный бред
Зачем трогают свитое !! Он больше всех убил русских.
Но не развеял.
Бандит с большой дороги.
Он герой. Больше всех русских убил...
Despite all these facts, and more, Stalin is being restored as a great man in modern Russia. Also in the west, many regard him as a great man. Unbelievable!
Hitler: I am the baddest man alive…Stalin…hold
My beer…one of if not the worst there ever was…
Propaganda. Stalin was the man. May his soul rest in peace of our great leader.
@@vladnikolaev1558Nihilist loser 👍
@@vladnikolaev1558Visit him in hell
Shoutout to the US getting a praise and admiration from Hitler in Mein Kampf, who looked upon Americas treatment upon the Natives an attempted to subject the same to Jews, Roma, and Slavs until evil Stalin forced Henry Ford’s favorite artist to paint his bunker Red, depriving the US of a future Anti-Soviet ally
@@vladnikolaev1558congratulations comrade the party will allow you to live another miserable day
The Great Purge was not the struggle for power. It was the start of the company to include the USSR in fascist club. The empire needed to be protected, and all Stalin's behavior was too logical and even cynical.
According to one of the lover of his friend, Pawker, Greate Purge was used to eliminate old Bolsheviks who could resist to his plan of occupying neighbour countries instead of assistance in revolutionary actions used before. The other victims were different nationalities, wich could be spies in the coming war. Polish, Gernans, Balts, other East European nations, nationalities of Arab region (where nessesery oil reserves were situated).
You can read in Gathering Storm about the symptoms of New Big War. Don't think about Stalin then he was less smart and paranoid person than Cherchill.
I was 15 mins in before I discovered it wasn’t about Keir Starmer after all.
Bra kommentar.
🤣
Одни говорят чушь, другие слушают. Слава великому отцу народов, И. В. Сталину!!!
какая брехня как можно очернять такого человека победившего нацизм
Ученики
Пауль Йозеф Геббельс -- Ложь можно внедрить в сознание народа, если повторить ее стократно 😁Приходишь к горькому выводу, что военное руководство Советского Союза состоит из людей классом выше, чем наше собственное😅.Отнимите у народа историю, через поколение он превратится в толпу, а еще через поколение в легко управляемое стадо.😂😂😂😂Чем наглее ложь, тем больше народ в нее верит.😆😆😆😆😆
Смерть буржуям! Слава СССР !Смерть Капиталу!!!Слава Коммунизму!
«Победа над нацизмом» (под этим мы подразумеваем победу в войне против страны, с которой Советы ранее были союзниками и даже отправляли нацистам военные материалы) не игнорирует и не оправдывает то, что делал Сталин.
@@nat1x_Мюнхенский сговор,слышал о таком?Кто там подписывал союз с Гитлером,а как делили Чехословакию?А заводы Форда которые работали на рейх?или это ДРУГОЕ?!
@@nat1x_by materials USSR gained time by satisfying Hitler this saved the USSR maybe the whole world
Of all the many things I have read and seen about Stalin in my 74 years, this is the best!!!
Then you haven’t seen much
@@Inbraneinthememsane I should clarify, I have read a great deal about the worst of humanity. What I didn’t know previously was the he had sex with his housekeeper ( I assumed he did) and that he murdered so many family members. I knew that he murdered a few but I didn’t realize the extent.
Everyone's surface is nothing
special, but inner is inestimable....
Russia just loves its dictators..no matter how mad and ruthless they are,,Putin is carrying on this terrible mantra.
That is the Power of Propaganda it is happening in America NOW ! ITS CALLED MAGA AND TRUMP ! 😮
I don't know if Putin is mad and ruthless, but defiantly he isn't suffering from Parkinson's dementia as Jo!
Why do you love your dictators like churchill and rousewelt?
He had a best friend his name was Kamo he was Armenian from Georgia Kamo was more powerful and most respected than Stalin. Stalin killed Kamo his best friend to maintain the power cuz Kamo had much more beef than Stalin!!!
Слава великому Сталину!
Что, Андрюха, умишки не хватает написать, что-нибудь интересное?
@@иванворотий-н3м для тебя и этого достаточно
Make on Churchill also please
sisters-in-law, not sister-in-laws
A common error, and it irritates me as well.
Erratum: the Soviet Union was NOT the world's biggest empire - the British empire was a lot bigger..
The only question is: Why did no one kill him??