How Mamata Banerjee is losing the plot in Kolkata rape-and-murder case
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
- #kolkata #mamatabanerjee
Few in Bengal know public pulse better than Mamata Banerjee and yet she looks clueless as protests over Kolkata rape-and-murder case build up, ThePrint Political Editor DK Singh analyses in this episode of #PoliticallyCorrect
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read this week's Politically Correct here: theprint.in/op...
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
How cute, a dictator is merely losing a plot. She’s committing crimes, Sir. She needs to be jailed.
You know which channel it is right... what else did you expect?
Why single out Bengal?
Just within a week,
2 years old girl was rapped and murder by a man in Meerut, UP.
A nurse was gang raped by her colleagues in Moradabad, UP.
A 16 years girl was rapped in roadways bus by 5 men in Uttarakhand.
A nurse was rapped and murdered by a man in Udham singh nagar uttarakhand.
A 14 years dalit girl was rapped and brutally murdered by a 42 years man in Mujaffarpur, Bihar.
No media is debating on these issues. They are just talking about West Bengal to smear Mamta Benarji.
Mamta is a strong lady and caught the criminal within 24 hours
@@nazeerpasha2075how stupid!!
Wat is the opinion on Gujarath+ Manipur+ Singoor+ Nandigram+ Kathwa Rape cases?
this backfire on females are happening in USA too- because of rise in pro women policies and only supporting women everywhere- resulting men are getting increasingly disdain those societies- but same is happeining in India too at a lower level- this had lead to femicides- and it will increase if men's issues are not solved- focus on men not only on 'beti bachao, beti padhao..'-- focus on 'encouraging men, encouraging their employment, and marraige- because more the married ppl- less such crimes- but some ppl are increasingly promoting divorces- this will increase such crimes- since now men have nothing to loose. Gov must understand this basic thing.
Men are lonely in USA-resulting they do mass shootings, many do incel killings of only women in shopping mall etc etc.
such crimes are not done by men who are on social media- many influencers are blaming men, but blaming wrong category of men- those men on instagram, others- are not going to do it- most likely- the men who will do it, are low class, low wage, alienated men- who have nothing to loose.
This analysis is either naive or deliberately misleading. If Mamta Banerjee's party is shielding wrongdoers, it's not because they have "lost the plot". It's because protecting certain people was more important than getting justice for the victim.
Welcome to politics.
this backfire on females are happening in USA too- because of rise in pro women policies and only supporting women everywhere- resulting men are getting increasingly disdain those societies- but same is happeining in India too at a lower level- this had lead to femicides- and it will increase if men's issues are not solved- focus on men not only on 'beti bachao, beti padhao..'-- focus on 'encouraging men, encouraging their employment, and marraige- because more the married ppl- less such crimes- but some ppl are increasingly promoting divorces- this will increase such crimes- since now men have nothing to loose. Gov must understand this basic thing.
Men are lonely in USA-resulting they do mass shootings, many do incel killings of only women in shopping mall etc etc.
such crimes are not done by men who are on social media- many influencers are blaming men, but blaming wrong category of men- those men on instagram, others- are not going to do it- most likely- the men who will do it, are low class, low wage, alienated men- who have nothing to loose.
@@SubhoPlaysLet's Mix Up or CoverUp in Name of Politics
@@BilluBadshah-kh1gd😂😂who's the home minister and CM of the state 😂pls tell me ...who should be blamed U?
😂If the principle is not protected, then he will spill details about all the skeletons in the closet.😂😂
Exactly Mamata Banerjee is trying her best to cover up this rape
"Principal"
this backfire on females are happening in USA too- because of rise in pro women policies and only supporting women everywhere- resulting men are getting increasingly disdain those societies- but same is happeining in India too at a lower level- this had lead to femicides- and it will increase if men's issues are not solved- focus on men not only on 'beti bachao, beti padhao..'-- focus on 'encouraging men, encouraging their employment, and marraige- because more the married ppl- less such crimes- but some ppl are increasingly promoting divorces- this will increase such crimes- since now men have nothing to loose. Gov must understand this basic thing.
Men are lonely in USA-resulting they do mass shootings, many do incel killings of only women in shopping mall etc etc.
such crimes are not done by men who are on social media- many influencers are blaming men, but blaming wrong category of men- those men on instagram, others- are not going to do it- most likely- the men who will do it, are low class, low wage, alienated men- who have nothing to loose.
@@ChandranPrema123Speaking Against is Prohibited 🚫
You need to learn about Mamata Banerjee, Bengal and its politics first. This is a shit show.
Mr. DK, you're trying to give Mamata a safe space. Your bias is too conspicuous.
Did we watch the same video? Cz his first 5mins was a blazing attack on Mamta Banerjee.
With all due respect DK Sir, your analysis is flawed in this particular case. How you are simply assuming that a Dictator CM would be completely unaware of all those actions that are being taken on her behalf by her Admin.?
R u criticizing Mamata Banerjee or BJP?😊
He lost the plot himself 😂
Exactly!!!
He was just saying nobody is really innocent in politics
😂😂😂 @ThePrintIndia look at this comment
Since 2024 LSE results, all media knows that within 5 yrs there's going to be a change in govt and they're falling in line to not be a scapegoat of the change in govt.
Where are mahua moitra and Derek o brien . I expected more from. Them
Mahua is shopping Gucci bags. She needs some rest after smashing fascist bjp.
/S
Demography of bengal ..is the main issue. Muslims will vote 4 tmc.
What do you expect from the community who always supress women freedom.
@@subham.biswas ... What is the religion of the rapist in this case?
@@subham.biswas
Compare the incidence and prevalence rate of rapes in India and any Muslim country.
@@subham.biswasBuddy, the culprit caught in this case is Hindu. There likely are others involved who are being protected. Nirbhaya 1.0 also the culprits were Hindu
@@nazeerpasha2075I agree that the culprit was Hindu and a lot of people just say random bs but coming to your point of comparison to Muslim countries, there are countries like Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iran where women can't obtain basic rights. Even in Iraq they plan to decrease marriageable age of females from 18 to 9. Even in India when govt wanted to increase the minimum age of women married from 18 to 21, owaisi protested and I believe he was against criminalization of triple talaq. It's true that the rich Gulf nations are safe but truth is many Muslim nations have a genuine issue of patriarchy. Ofc India also has a crappy society especially in places like Haryana
She has lost it
shame on you for this biased reporting, how much money does mamta begum gives you ?
This Vinesh, and her brother in law , they are not merely players they are political activists. Brij Bhushan may be a Strongman but the charges leveled against him of sexual impropriety were not proven , this was a like a me too movement and shoot and scoot policy of Kejriwal of leveling unsubstantiated charges against any individual and not allowing to investigate and find the truth out. Being national players dont give them the right to overrun the system. and bypass any scrutiny to bring about a change which was undemocratic. Indian Wrestling Federation can not be monopoly of only one state, its an organization of the whole of India and of all state, so the chief of the organization can also be from any part of India when elected democratically. Brushing of Vinesh and the rest as victims and subversion of due diligence and actual intentions of theirs is doing a disservice to your own nation. Haryana elections are coming Vinesh/BaBita/Bajrang Punia will start their tool kit again and print will try to brush them as victims of political witch hunting. Print you are doing a disservice to the nation by fudging facts to suit your communist narrative
Are you concerned about Victims getting justice or Mamata Banerjee saving her Government?
Health minister (1) reports the murder to home minister (2) answerable to chief minister = 123 is mamatha banerje is the best actor of the universe.
This is really disappointing from Print- Whenever heinous acts happen in other state, they talk about - "women safety &lack of government response", But in this case, they talk about -" Political calculation" & "related govt's mishandling of narrative", even though, the incident is barbaric...
Mamata's government should be dismissed along with the DGP.
She lost it when she was 6 years old...
She is the plotter...
Your desperation to play down mamata is disgusting. Like cheap street you are bringing in other instances. Wonder what culture you are raised in. I can understand you being anti bjp or pro some political establishment, but blatantly using rape victims for driving your Agenda is pathetic.
True
this backfire on females are happening in USA too- because of rise in pro women policies and only supporting women everywhere- resulting men are getting increasingly disdain those societies- but same is happeining in India too at a lower level- this had lead to femicides- and it will increase if men's issues are not solved- focus on men not only on 'beti bachao, beti padhao..'-- focus on 'encouraging men, encouraging their employment, and marraige- because more the married ppl- less such crimes- but some ppl are increasingly promoting divorces- this will increase such crimes- since now men have nothing to loose. Gov must understand this basic thing.
Men are lonely in USA-resulting they do mass shootings, many do incel killings of only women in shopping mall etc etc.
such crimes are not done by men who are on social media- many influencers are blaming men, but blaming wrong category of men- those men on instagram, others- are not going to do it- most likely- the men who will do it, are low class, low wage, alienated men- who have nothing to loose.
She's gonna be caught soon duffer😂
I don’t know why Bengali people still vote for Mamata Banerjee. I know she’ll win next elections as well. People of Bengal are so backward these days, I don’t believe this is the land of Bose and Tagore anymore.
Involving BJP in this. I used to love watching this series but it has gone to waste behind this propaganda
Exactly
Subscribing to PRINT is a waste of money
How is it propaganda 🤔
What he said about BJP is incorrect or its just that you enjoy till other parties are criticized but when it comes to your favorite party, you see it as propaganda?
Exactly. Used to be balance. Not just bash the bjp and protect tmc and others
R G Kar Medical is Mamta's Singur, Sheila Dikshit's Nirbaya.
Well said!
DK,
Your criticism of bjp on every issue is boring and acidic. Please keep your hatred for bjp with yourself. We expect balanced analysis from you and The Print. You are disreputing The Print... Totally disappointed with your reporting.
Where do you find that the analysis is biased? Just a humble question
Her mind is only wrapped up sadly LoL...DK spoke so well
@@jaibhaumik5971the fact that he says they shielded those involved for BJP while Mamta Bannerjee is just on the wrong footing for protecting the principal who has been involved in this rape.
@@jaibhaumik5971 can't you see how he assumed that Mamta is completely unaware of all the actions taken by her admin.? if not, then learn to hear and analyse inputs, no one can teach you that!
He has a fascination for immoral politicians. He likes Mamta, Jagan Reddy who are monsters
Such a incident cannot be carried out without the involvement of local authorities. Mamta is not losing the plot high level people of her party are involved. She is trying to protect herself and her secrets by any means possible....
But she has support of 95% Muslims. She is secular
You were supposed analyse Mamta not BJP with lot of untrue statements
He is presenting a neutral opinion. Don’t be biased in favour of any party
@@avradeepdas2427 wow !!
@@avradeepdas2427 how dumb Bengalis are😂
What did he say about BJP leaders was untrue? Curious.
@@njain1983 first the analysis was about WB/Mamta. Next take the case of Vinesh/Brig Bhushan- should the process of law be followed or mob justice?? Did you even look at the charges levelled finally?? I dont support the treatment of athletes, however NO ONE should be able to blackmail/threaten without following due course of law. Journalist like DK set a narrative which is biased & not neutral at all.
PM called only medal winners.
Phogat has failed to win any Olympic medal in three Olympics.
Wow😂😂😂
Her performance was best among all. She defeated world champion. If she wasn't disqualified it would have sure gold
@@Peace_keeper112If I wasn't disqualified, I'd have topped IIT. Why isn't Google offering me 20 cr package?
usko to netagiri krna hai- krle netagiri ab..
@@Peace_keeper112 She was actually 57 kg. She shd hv fought in 55 kg group. If you cheat like this God punishes.
She is chief minister, home minister and health minister of West Bengal but protesting... against whom, how and why? Questions...questions... questions...
The SC taking su moto because it is the badralok who are the being affected. The SC did not care when innocent women being raped in villages and when bjp workers were being killed. News outlets should highlight this regardless of politics. The problem is that reporters act in line with their political beliefs. In this way they are part of the problem and are taking part in this lawlessness
Print is soft on Mamta from day 1 !!!!
Subscribing to PRINT is a waste of money
Time to impose presidents rule
just concentrate on bengal
It is not only just bjp demand people of bengal people of india want mamta banerjee resignation
Unthinkable that 21 lawyers implemented against the brutal murder of the poor young doctor by the state government.Whose money is being spent for these lawyers!!
Was not the report on Mamata's undoings in the RG Kar crime? Why bring in BJP without a context!
This seems to be analysis of BJP and wrongdoings than Mamta. Not the usual quality of Print videos.
He was quite factual throughout. He showed us that these two parties are shielding their persons of interest. He cannot be disputed on factual grounds.
Dear Mr. D.K. Singh. Addressing a not-so-important bit of the video regarding Vinesh Phogat. Once an athlete wins a medal, the PM has diligently congratulated them with a personal phone call. In Vinesh Phogat's case, a medal was only guaranteed prior to her disqualification.
Print is desperately attempting to divert attention by focusing on BJP. Talk time more on BJP rather than Mamta.
Bjp need to appoint shivraj mama in charge of Bengal, look how well he doing in Jharkhand, got champai soren his side building good anti incumbency on back of corruption in soren govt and changing demography of tribal regions
U have lost the plot DK.... Nice move to balance mamta's crime with of BJP.।।
Go! Banerjee, leave now!😮
Critics to TMC must go with BJP😂
People will forget in a week or at max a month, that is what these politicians think. People should repeat what happened in Bangladesh here in West Bengal. Then these guys will get the point.
Why did you use "Alleged" only for cases against other but not the same for Brij Bhushan and Biren Singh? Modi has called medal winners....Vinesh has been a loser...yes thats the right word...for 3 Olympics...she does not deserve that call
Oh my God! Mamata banerjee is loosing the plot. What should we do now?
Another good one DK .keep going
D K Singh analysis is always very informative
...the sad truth is, this protest has yet to penetrate the rest of Bengal...they are happy with the direct cash the government provides...
Really low standards of the print these days. Can we rise above the politics once.
Can't wait. Go! Banerjee, failure as PM
A very nice op-ed by Mr. Singh. As usual, impartial and unbiased.
I have never felt so disturbed in my life
I still wonder what stops the Superintendent or Principal to resign in such disastrous situations. I worked in Government Hospitals before I left India - I was just 30 and they kept me as an in charge of a division - I was not ready for that. I joined service just to teach for couple of years and have no administrative skills in me - after one year many things happened in personal life and I moved out of India but I still wonder - People reaching such high positions always be ready to accept the mistake and resign and eventually time and interrogations will prove who is right and who is wrong- but again the question is do we have that trust in the departments? Everything boils down to that
this guy did boy see Mamta’s role in shielding the culprits and offering 10 lac rupees to the victim’s parents. This is not the first time she did it, she does same thing for thousands of rape cases in Bengal.
Fail to understand that why the Media is also not showing the unhygienic conditions of Toilets, Wards, Doctor's Rest Room, State of various wards & general hygiene outside the Hospital Buildings, Disposal of wastes, Various Sentry Posts
Superb analysis and anecdotes on Kolkata horror incident and backstory of politics. Comparison with Sheila Dixit was top notch reporting. To reach on conclusion that Mamta ji won't worry about BJP was little streched on this topic. All in all very informative episode from Dk Sir. I wish episode could have been of 20 min., nevertheless once again best reporting and equally well thought and penned analysis. I wish some one can bring very tough law on those incidents so no one even can dream of doing those crimes
This Himalayan tragedy of the hapless Doctor is not merely about Mamata or Saffron squadron. Its about the safety of Women in their work space. Its about refurbishing the existing laws on women safety and strengthening safety monitoring infrastructure at Hospitals. Thats only way we can pay tribute to the victim Doctor.
Thank you DK ji....at least your moral compass is aligned correctly...which always was..but you delayed it and that is what was bugging your channel wale...good coverage🎉
Your analysis is perfect.
Why Vineet Goyal should not be arrested and subjected to Polygraph test, if necessary using third degree method?
Actually, it is Bhardralok who lost the plot! And as far as this media, the real culprit is his boss, SG! Remember how these guys were low-bowling the Shandeshkhali, which was equally horrible!
He is using Victim and Alleged accuser in same sentence.
But he is right about BJP. BJP has failed in protecting their cadre.
Problem is people are electing idiots as their leaders.
Choti debe hazar taka, bhule jabe sobh katha !!
Translation : Once Rs.1000.00 credits, Bengal Forgets !
A Horror movie in Kalkatta! But it
Is Horrible Hell of people who elected the actor!the ending with
a pinch of tragedy !
The dirtiest police in India is Calcutta police group.
Who are the culprits? We want arrests
He’s right. BJP sleeps on these things.
Well analysis, DKS. All political parties is playing politics, they will forgot soon after the election
Dr Sandip Ghosh Should be Suspend and Total Independent Prode in RG Kar Should be Done (
But the sad part is DK will still not get a padma award like his boss.... he will have to wait till RaGa becomes PM
This presentation is prime example how to mislead and waterdown whole issue.
If she has little shame,she should step down..i believe she has thick skin.
OMG , what has happened to the rule of law in Calcutta in particular and India in general.
But she didn't win any medal sirji. Infact a medal was lost due to improper planning on her part. Why consume and increase weight
Sir even opposition (at centre) is not talking about dalit girl rape by sp leader and a muslim in ayodhya, of moradabad dalit girl rape at nursing home although these happened in bjp ruled state, because accused are muslims and leaders of samajwadi party..... Even media doesn't talk about these cases...... Everybody is Playing politics over these issues including media.... where all the guilty should have been punished like it could instill fear amongst who even think of such crime..... But whether its govt opposition or media everybody has used it as it suits them....
Shame on all opposition parties.... especially pappu and his pappu supporting parties.....
your concern for mamata is exemplary
How cute your criticism😂 keep your anger store for bjp
Why are you worried about her plot ? Don’t you see the gruesome thing out there @ reporter
Just show the facts how this was handled
When it comes to women safety all parties try their best to save the criminal
it was more politically incorrect
Like Elephant and Kashmir issue..every discussion with Pakistanis, even while discussing elephants will inevitably change into 'Elephants and the Kashmir issue.' Similarly a discussion on Mamta has been changed into what BJP did..😂
Brother this is your mistake. Mamota Di is getting stronger to strongest. All should accept her calibre. Many committes will be constituted now and all will be promoted to higher positions. Rest India should learn from her who deserves to be pm. We are unfortunate citizens.
the boss of criminal gang in kolkata is mamta- why court is saving her
बड़ी देर कर दी मेहरबा आते आते।
White washer or the highest order!
Essentially what he is saying is that Mamata and Modi - dono ek hi nasl ke hain...
Sidelining the main issue
Why she protesting.. Step down
Momo ???this student addressing such a topic
Unbelievable
Virendra babu
Delhi babu ?
Not clear audio
Vinesh didn't win any medal.as she defeat a world class opponent in quarters,so did lakshya sen.Pm didn't talk to him or her.he gave them support financially and sports wise in preparation of olympics and congratulate all olympicians after returning.he only call those who won the medal.its simply fact.but ,why didn't journalist understand this.maybe for their biasedness.who knows?
And all this sympathy lost when she is campaigning in haryana after returning for congress.its shows ,all her struggle maybe influenced by her future political considerations .and this type of whataboutary poorly reflects on this reporter.
Bengalis deserve Mamta
What is this about Mamta Banerjee or Vinesh Phogat, please decide the topic
On what occasion and reason there is roadshow at the first place ?
Why there shall be different treatment than other Olympic medal winners ?
one of the most sensible political analytician in the print team; woner why some listeneres are accusing him of being a partisan
Dictators in centre, dictators in states....all parties the same....congress ,bjp, ncp, shiv Sena, tmc, aiadmk even aap....every single one is the same...choice is worse or worst...i wont go for elections again.....
BJP is progressing india unlike other parties
DK eventually ended with subtle whataboutery
This episode of DK, instead of being critical on Mamatha adminstration, he is more critical of BJP than TMC.
One sided