In my opinioni both guitarists are legendary. Both have their own, unique style. And there's no denying Mick has written countless, classic guitar riffs and solos that make up the Crue sound and feel. Mick is a great rock guitarist who's work will live on to inspire future rock guitar players. John 5 is a wizard on the guitar, a true virtuoso. And a very humble player who is doing a great job playing Mick's songs. He's not getting flashy or trying to make them his own. He is playing them as true as he can to how they were composed by Mick. At least from what I see in this video. You gotta respect that. I feel lucky to have seen them both play several times. Thanks for posting this video. Respect and props to both of these great musicians.
I remember coming across a video of John 5 playing a Kiss song true to the original, yet better than Kiss could ever play it. He's really one of the most gifted guitarists around because beyond his technical wizardry he has a feel in his playing that many of the technical guys seem to have lost as the mastered the instrument.
I think John did the solo respectfully. He didn’t try to make it flashy, so I can respect that. However, true talent is not just play, but in one’s ability to compose. With that, Mick will always be the one true guitarist of Motley Crue. Also, in these videos you are comparing a 70 yr old with a spine disease to a younger guitarist. That has to be taken into consideration also😊
@@user-nz2zz2tp6c Considering Mick hasn't played a note on any Motley recordings in the better part of a decade or more, nope John will take them forward to a new level of success.
He does a great job. I like when replacements pay true homage to the original, Like Kelley Hansen singing Lou Gramm's vocals with Foreigner. He adds his own touch but nails the vocals just like the records.
Yeah, I was thinking the exact same thing. It's unmistakable in 5's mannerisms and facial expressions how much he respects and appreciates the riff and how he's really trying to do it justice. What a great homage
Nobody ever said Mick was the greatest, but he's got the most goddamn heart. He just plays Crue, the way Crue is supposed to be played.🖤 Nobody will ever diminish what he's done, and he will always be THE guitarist of Motley Crue, in my eyes.
@@TheRonZombie Mick could play just fine his career in the band , he had plenty of skill . People who say different just mean he didn't play like Vai or Gilbert level . Which is worthless anyway as none of those shredders have legendary riffs , people know .
I love watching him play it too. I was always mad that in the video for it during the solo they had the camera on Nikki practically the entire time, i wanted to watch Mick play.
This is why John 5 was the best choice to fill in for Mick. He loves the entire Crüe catalog and has studied Mick Mars so closely that he plays the parts exactly as recorded. I wonder if we will ever get to hear new Mötley Crüe material with John 5 writing new epic riffs.
Love John 5 a ton though...I appreciate him not ruining or changing the song. I would imagine he could have J'd off over the whole thing and it would be great. But he respected Mick. A legend.
You are definitely right about that. He wrote the best riffs. No one realizes that. Musically, he is the perfect fit. He made the songs what they are. His solos were extremely lyrical. You could easily sing his solos, they were so lyrical. He played with a lot of feeling too. He is and has always been great.
Mick has always been my favorite as someone who plays some guitar. If God told me I could get the gift of playing like someone. I'd cut him off and say mick Mars 🤙 without thinking twice. There's other greats like 5, slash, zack, and the list goes on. But I really appreciate Mars style and what he left for the music community
Just go man, Mick was the OG but John 5 is the real deal and the energy at their last show in MN was off the charts. Music is music and we gotta enjoy these rockers while theyre here on tour! Cheers
Mick is an absolute legend. He composed some of the best guitar riffs/solos out. He really did give Motley its distinct signature sound. On the other side, I have absolute respect for John 5 for keeping it the way Mick wrote it. A true respectful musician. Nothing but love for both guitarists.
I really appreciated the ZERO embellishments also. It's the way it's stuck in everyone's head, many other guitar player would wank all over this solo, not J5!
Good ole J5 is one of the best guys in the game, but listening to his interviews over the years it’s apparent that first and foremost he’s a fan of all things guitar.
Mad respect to Mick for really playing live all those years despite having an incurable disease while your band mates were playing to pre recorded backing tracks. You could literally here it during Mick's solo.I feel bad for John 5 because he's genuinely a decent good guy. Sucks getting mixed up with those three stooges.
He didn't get whamboozled. He met them down at the crossroads and he saw the money numbers they threw at him and happily signed his name on the dotted line 😊
Solos like this are about feel, and you can hear it in the 2 clips. John 5 is an absolutely amazing guitar player, and nobody can deny that. Here is exactly what some people have commented, "John 5 plays it like it is on the album," but Mick's sound and feel cannot be duplicated. It's Motley Crue with him and always will be.
DJ Ashba would have been a better fit for MC. Although, John 5 is a better player that DJ, I still think DJ would have brought a better street sound to MC.
John 5 was a session player for years. He has become amazing at playing solos perfectly. He plays it super precise and absolutely spot on. He’s probably in the top ten guitarist in the world. There’s pretty much nothing he can’t play
Big difference between being in the top 10 guitarist or top 10 session players. John 5 lacks the soul and originality to be in the top 10. Ask a none guitar player who John 5 is, they won't know. ask that same person about Clapton Hendrix John Mayer Garcia SRV ect and they know, that's it. You have to resonate with a audience that's not musically inclined to be the best.
Mick Mars will always be the guitarist for Motley Crue. John has nothing but the utmost respect for Mick and it shows in his playing. John is a fabulous guitar player. The reason Motley fans are so receptive to John it is because Mick gave his blessing. God bless Mick I can't wait to hear his new music coming out of Nashville. Love ya Mick
Why does this have to be a competition? Look, Mick was a horribly underrated badass for 40+ years with the Crue, and honestly the primary reason I ever got into music and started playing guitar. Yes, there are hundreds, even thousands of other guitar players out there that may be considered more technically adept than Mick, but NOBODY can play with the power and feel that Mick has. He will always be one of my favorite guitar players. When Mick stepped down, I thought that John 5 was absolutely the best choice to fill the spot, and I think he's doing a tremendous job honoring and paying tribute to Mick's legacy, but he's not Mick and nobody else ever will be. And for fuck's sake, can somebody please beat Vince back into shape?
Beat Vince into shape? I remember months ago there was a vid of him trying to get back into shape and he had a gym at home..... It's more like a centre piece... Vince needs a vacuum
Love Mick for everything he's done. The songwriting, the playing, the sound, the feel. Amazing guitarist and a true legend for rockin' hard while having a very bad disease.
Mr. 5 showing Mick major respect through his playing and in interviews since this all blew up. Class act all the way. The other 3 don’t deserve a player not only just someone the laid back and cool but a monster guitarist. Mick has carried the band 90% of its life and those three chuckleheads will finish their careers being carried by another smoking player. Too band the don’t see or appreciate that fact. Just three punks in the streets, oh I’m sorry, I’m the limousines…
You know a guitar solo is awesome when almost 40 years later it gives someone goosebumps. Mick wrote that solo and played it with more feeling than just about any guitarist ever. That's why people love him. He's never been flashy ( although I think he was pushed into that from time to time) he's down to earth and humble. It shows when he plays.
Good to see John 5 staying true to Mick's work. With his level of ability he could easily stand up and play some mind blowing flashy stuff, but he's showing respect to Mick. Hats off to John 5.
John knows and understands the impact these songs have had on people so being not only a true musician but a fan he pays respect to the song and the fans
2 great players, playing one man's solo. J5 is brilliant, no doubt. But the fact that you can listen to this song (and many other Crue tracks) and sing this solo, shows just how brilliant Mick is. The most under rated guitarist in hard rock.
I absolutely love the fact that one of the most amazing guitarist on the planet earth show some respect to Mars. Just awesome. Congratulations John, you are a true guitar hero.
Mick's picking on the frets gives his solos a very unique sound. I really dig his style. John 5 played it respectfully but, Mick wrote that amazing solo and no one else will ever come close to touching his talent because of that.
John 5 understands that it's easier to follow than lead and accepts his role in Motley Crue as such. I'm assuming that he got the gig because of it. Can you imagine all of the shredders, of which John 5 is one of the best, coming in to audition and stomping all over Mick's leads thinking, "I can improve upon Mick's stuff!". I can hear it now, "NEXT, don't call us, we'll call you!!" LoL
John is playing the solo as written on the record. Mick is allowed to ad lib and add parts since he wrote it. Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him. John could play this while eating breakfast. I am sure if they allowed John to cut loose he would ad his own style to the solo. In respect to Mick, he plays it as written!
"Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him." Ridiculous statement. The man is in his 70's with a crippling spinal disease that causes him to be in constant pain.
Two things. First John can play anything with his eyes close and that's skill. Secondly his performances are boring as hell...... Being able to play anything doesn't make make the person a good performer, just a good session player.
Oh my god, you live with a brain that small? "Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him." I have heard dumber things, but not many. Since you clearly know nothing about music, please keep your mouth shut and be thought an idiot, because opening your mouth removed all doubt. John 5 is a great guitarist, and I am super happy they tapped him to replace Mick. He is VERY respectful of the music for a reason. Mick is in constant pain, and 70. THAT is hard. playing a song he wrote and has played thousands of times isn't hard.
John is such an impressive player..he REVERES players like Mick, Eddie and so many others.. he plays it as close as another player who didn't write it could... many props to John 5 for playing it with no additions or subtractions.. but Mick is, was and will forever be the soul of the Crue... he literally gave his blood, sweat, tears, life and health for Motley.. and he's still a great player!..
Gotta hand it to John 5 for filling in and playing Micks part so well and accurate without embellishing or going off to do his own solo. Can tell he has nothing but respect for Mick. Great job
@ferrj710 I think Zakk has done amazingly well playing in Pantera and honestly I don't think anyone else would have or should have played instead of him.due to.their history and friendship
@@peterharder279 as true as that is, and as much as I understand that, I don't feel like he's handling it the same way that you described John 5 handling his role with the Crue. Over-embellished, and not faithful to the original... That's my only complaints.
@ferrj710 I can only wish to see them when they roll through but everything I've seen they sound great and Zakk is filling the spot amazingly. He's not doin his 5 kin pinch harmonic solos, he's sticking pretty close to the original and he's happy doin it. Can't ask for much else
I still can't believe that he is my uncle!!! Even though I m a failure in my family, being on one and messed up all these years,,,it might not mean much coming from me but I m proud of you that you made it so big.....You are definitely 'THE MAN'
Seen Mick play that song live three times... imho The man's a legend. Stand in the back and melt your face off, spine disease and all. Glad John just respects the solo and plays it up straight. :)
Mick's guitar playing is what gives Motley it's sound. You can tell its Motley Crue just by the guitar in the songs, Mick built their unique sound. John is a great guitarist thoough.
Mick Mars will always be one Of my favorite guitarists but his physical state has really taken the toll he used to tell us about but we didn’t listen. He played on for so many years through so much pain. Thank you John 5 for what you have done here keeping it true to the original.
So much love for both guitarist. Glad that Johnny 5 kept the song as Mick wrote the solo. Mick Mars was so unique and he maintained a style that I feel was under- rated for his skills. He was a great song writer. He was the foundation for the sound of Motley Crue. Love and respect to both of them.
Both players are great and The Pain that Mick deals with while he is playing shows he has the grit to STILL do a wonderful job ! and I agree with another person who posted John is a Guitar Wizard and a Humble guy, playing the songs true and not trying to make them his own ,a very humble guy. In my opinion Motley should have quit years ago, Vince's voice has seen better days.
I have the same disease that Mic has and if his pain is like mine it's great he can play. Yesterday my hands and wrist hurt so bad and I could barely get up and move around. Today no pain at all.
Both Mick & John banged it out of the park. I saw a John 5 interview where he says that when playing someone else's music he'll try to play it as closely as it sounded on the record
John 5 is an amazing musician and from what I've read, seen and heard from him he seems to be a class act of a human being. You have to love the respect he is showing Mick.
@@fredjones8607 What's hilarious is if the uploader swapped the audio for both performances, you'd be saying the same thing, lmao. Yeah, yeah, I know... save it.
@@fredjones8607 You should be able to - the intonation is shit, the intonation on the bends is shit, the vibrato is fast, thin, and shitty, tone is shit, and it's sloppy. But yeah, that's not what you're hearing because your stone ears can't hear it.
The first time I seen the Crue was with OZZY at the bark at the moon tour! and they were with a German band called ACCEPT. (a German heavy metal band) and then the Theatre of pain tour, both concerts were in Kentucky!
I fully admit my bias for 1313 because I've listened to everything he has done and loved every bit of it. Nobody can fill his shoes. He is the heart and soul of the Crue. 5 is absolutely phenomenal too.
Both do a fine job. John played it with respect to the original and a feel of his own. Yeah, the man can totally shred any time he wants to, but this is not what the song called for and he honored Mick's solo beautifully. He's a solid player.
Sick upload john is a legend i was a danzig fan since i was 13 got aholda Lucifuge and been a fan ever since I can see the chords n i think i could nail this thanx john wish u the best
Mick hands down, especially during the shred part. Mick goes from super slow to fast smoothly and gradually. John 5 goes from slow to incredibly fast with no transition
John is fantastic, period. Passing the torch as they say. Thank you Mick for all that you brought, and our memories. Thank you John for bringing yourself to the role. Ultimately, we all win.
Both are Legends and John 5 showed the utmost respect to Mars with his Solo, he didn't flash it up, he played it the way it was written. The Things happening between Mick and the rest of the Crue most likely isn't on the mind of John 5, he has a lot of respect for Mick, and it shows in how he plays all the songs.
Lol. He plays the solos like the recording because that's what the gig calls for - it has nothing to do with Mars. Like when Vince Gill played the first Eagles gig and Vince improvised a Glenn Frey solo. Don Henley said, "Stick to the script, Vince."
In my opinioni both guitarists are legendary. Both have their own, unique style. And there's no denying Mick has written countless, classic guitar riffs and solos that make up the Crue sound and feel. Mick is a great rock guitarist who's work will live on to inspire future rock guitar players. John 5 is a wizard on the guitar, a true virtuoso. And a very humble player who is doing a great job playing Mick's songs. He's not getting flashy or trying to make them his own. He is playing them as true as he can to how they were composed by Mick. At least from what I see in this video. You gotta respect that. I feel lucky to have seen them both play several times. Thanks for posting this video. Respect and props to both of these great musicians.
Wow....very well said!
Wonderful comment and very well said!
I remember coming across a video of John 5 playing a Kiss song true to the original, yet better than Kiss could ever play it. He's really one of the most gifted guitarists around because beyond his technical wizardry he has a feel in his playing that many of the technical guys seem to have lost as the mastered the instrument.
@Viteri. Yes. And that's basically what happened to deep purple in the 1980s. When Joe satriani joined. They did not sound like the purple that I love
Mick has soul John 5 technical skills not the same as Mick Mars heart and soul 💔.
It is not guitar players who is the problem. They are both great. It is the singer !!!!
Home weeeet haaa weee haaaaaw 🙄
He needs to be retired couldn't sing before sure can't now!!!!
When did Sam Kinison join Motley Crue?
John Corabi was the best thing to happen to Motley . Best album they ever made.
I agree,Vince needs to give it up.
Nothing will ever beat Mick! Mick Mars IS Motley Crue!
And will always be.......
Mick just wanted to play, but not tour. Damn u Sixx. Bring him back just to made hard rock music. But too bad it’s a FUBAR situation.
John 5 could beat Mick in his sleep!
Let us not forget Tommy!
Mick Mars is definitely more Motley Crue than John 5, but absolutely no comparison in playing. John 5 all the way.
Nothing is better than the original. Mick is amazing!!
You nailed it!!
You are ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!!!
And you are obviously blind.
Mick is amazing, John5 is too clear to this song, or too clear to Motley.
Lmao ok there buddy, lol dunces kill me, yeah Mick is amazing, ok lol..... at what?
That was awesome. He played it with total respect and homage to the original. I'm fast becoming a big fan of this guy that I just heard about.
Love how John 5 does justice to Mick’s original solo.
John 5 is just amazing, but watching that old war horse play just gives you chills.
1313 for life
Both had to put up with lead singers who were absolute shit stains. It doesn't get much worse than Vince Neal and Marilyn Manson.
@@MrBuddy7798what does that mean
@@clumzyduck2611 M is the 13th letter of the alphabet. He meant MM for life
that old war horse. Couldn't describe it better.
I think John did the solo respectfully. He didn’t try to make it flashy, so I can respect that. However, true talent is not just play, but in one’s ability to compose. With that, Mick will always be the one true guitarist of Motley Crue. Also, in these videos you are comparing a 70 yr old with a spine disease to a younger guitarist. That has to be taken into consideration also😊
Mick is still better
@@user-nz2zz2tp6c Considering Mick hasn't played a note on any Motley recordings in the better part of a decade or more, nope John will take them forward to a new level of success.
John 5 has so much respect for mick and if mick had an issue with him touring he would made it known.
@@evol1349 Doubt so....
Agree
John 5 is very talented and also a very humble guitar player. The way he respects Mick's original solos are so great. That's so great...
Agree 100%
I dig that
He does a great job. I like when replacements pay true homage to the original, Like Kelley Hansen singing Lou Gramm's vocals with Foreigner. He adds his own touch but nails the vocals just like the records.
Yeah, I was thinking the exact same thing. It's unmistakable in 5's mannerisms and facial expressions how much he respects and appreciates the riff and how he's really trying to do it justice. What a great homage
That's what I like about John. His talent is so natural, it's really not a big deal to him. Like Jimmy Hendrix
Nobody ever said Mick was the greatest, but he's got the most goddamn heart. He just plays Crue, the way Crue is supposed to be played.🖤
Nobody will ever diminish what he's done, and he will always be THE guitarist of Motley Crue, in my eyes.
well written
ME TOO!
I'll say it, "Mick Mars is the absolute very best rock guitarist that has ever been and ever will be!"
Period
I can't take this band serious without Mick Mars in the lineup.
I stopped taking them seriously bc of Vince on the mic in recent years
agreed
Why they finally have a musician that can play
@@TheRonZombie Mick could play just fine his career in the band , he had plenty of skill . People who say different just mean he didn't play like Vai or Gilbert level . Which is worthless anyway as none of those shredders have legendary riffs , people know .
@@ElTigreEsq BIG MAC, $1.03!
John 5 does a good job, but I get goosebumps watching Mick play this. Motley Crüe isn’t right without him.
John 5 is what kiko is to Megadeth
@@adrianfong5783 Kiko wasn't chosen, he just join to be Marty Friedman's successor
John 5 is a great musician (saw yesterday live), but Motley Crüe belongs to Mick Mars!
1313 forever
Mick uses the whammy bar vs John doesn't
5 is awesome in his own right. But for me Mars is Crüe. End of. Also is John 5 the love child of Manson and Danson. 😂
Both are extraordinarily talented! However, no one can replace Mick.
Props to John for keeping it real and true to Micks version. Watching Mick play it though, its a beautiful thing.
Absolu
absolutely!
Totally agree
I agree he wrote those leads they are so tasty. John 5 is a brilliant musician I am a huge fan , but Mick won this battle by a little imo.
I love watching him play it too. I was always mad that in the video for it during the solo they had the camera on Nikki practically the entire time, i wanted to watch Mick play.
This is why John 5 was the best choice to fill in for Mick. He loves the entire Crüe catalog and has studied Mick Mars so closely that he plays the parts exactly as recorded. I wonder if we will ever get to hear new Mötley Crüe material with John 5 writing new epic riffs.
Zakk would have been a better fit IMO. 5 is an incredible player, but just my take that he doesn't have the vibe or the look.
@@lrh411 Zakk would have sounded like Zakk tho..
@@VanIsleNuckFan Hahahaha well, point taken. 😁
@@lrh411 LOL :)
They are both extremely awesome, but I have to give this to Mick. He is a living legend.
Mick deserves his own wing in the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame. Most underrated guitarist ever and my all time favorite.
Love John 5 a ton though...I appreciate him not ruining or changing the song. I would imagine he could have J'd off over the whole thing and it would be great. But he respected Mick. A legend.
I have always said the same!
You are definitely right about that. He wrote the best riffs. No one realizes that. Musically, he is the perfect fit. He made the songs what they are. His solos were extremely lyrical. You could easily sing his solos, they were so lyrical. He played with a lot of feeling too. He is and has always been great.
god damn right
Mick has always been my favorite as someone who plays some guitar. If God told me I could get the gift of playing like someone. I'd cut him off and say mick Mars 🤙 without thinking twice. There's other greats like 5, slash, zack, and the list goes on. But I really appreciate Mars style and what he left for the music community
Mick deserves our respect. He is unique.
I know ppl love john.... but I just love Mick....grew up listening to him....he's awesome
I won't even go see Motley anymore without Mick.
Just go man, Mick was the OG but John 5 is the real deal and the energy at their last show in MN was off the charts. Music is music and we gotta enjoy these rockers while theyre here on tour! Cheers
Mick is an absolute legend. He composed some of the best guitar riffs/solos out. He really did give Motley its distinct signature sound. On the other side, I have absolute respect for John 5 for keeping it the way Mick wrote it. A true respectful musician. Nothing but love for both guitarists.
You've got to hand it to J5. He plays Mick's solo accurately, with ZERO embellishments others might have stamped all over it. That's respect, man!
I really appreciated the ZERO embellishments also. It's the way it's stuck in everyone's head, many other guitar player would wank all over this solo, not J5!
I'm pretty sure the contract he signed said, "no embellishments" :-). Motley loves their contracts.
Lol agree
Good ole J5 is one of the best guys in the game, but listening to his interviews over the years it’s apparent that first and foremost he’s a fan of all things guitar.
Maybe The Crue should offer Vince Neil 5% of the tour takings, he doesn't even try these days, just stands screeching.
Man I love Mick's tone. It's just something you can't replicate. The dirty grit. Kudos to John for stepping in.
Finger tone is real thing.
Is mick okay?
I love how serious Mick looks while soloing. Rock and Roll Warrior.
Mick is a pro. Nothing against J5, but Mick is the best version of Mick
He makes it more about the song and less about him...which makes me respect his playing even more. If that makes sense....
This solo in 1985 is what did it for me to play a kramer and just sound just like this. Its the feel that Mick put into this.
Micks tone is freaking awesome and unique, much like Princes! Respect bro.
Mad respect to Mick for really playing live all those years despite having an incurable disease while your band mates were playing to pre recorded backing tracks. You could literally here it during Mick's solo.I feel bad for John 5 because he's genuinely a decent good guy. Sucks getting mixed up with those three stooges.
Hahaa right on man
He didn't get whamboozled. He met them down at the crossroads and he saw the money numbers they threw at him and happily signed his name on the dotted line 😊
They needed a backup track for the vocals on this, that's for sure. The vocals in both recordings featured here were sadly awful.
@@trixlee5102 Vince' vocals suck but they're still not as bad as Axle
@@thomasstevenson5367 Axl
I've got to hand it to John 5 for respecting this awesome solo and playing it note for note. He nailed it. Mick wrote it, and John honored it!
LOL
Agree. John5 is one of the greatest in my opinion, but, he respected the iconic solo from Mick.
@@DannyPepprs Highly intelligent retort, well done ....
Rightfully so. Crowd ain't there to see John. They are there to see and hear the songs how they remember them.
J5 is such class. He clearly respects MM and kept it as Mick wanted it. Just amazing
one of my favourite solos of all time - Mick plays with his heart as much as he does with his hands
I cannot think of another solo that fits the song better than this one. Absolute perfection
Two legends. No need to compare, just appreciate their talent.
Legends of marketing
Agreed. True musicians are inspired by each other and not in competition.
John 5 is not a legend.
@@aaronkristo858agreed
John 5 is a hired guitarist. Mick has been making legendary music for 40+ years giving him the definition of a legend.
Solos like this are about feel, and you can hear it in the 2 clips. John 5 is an absolutely amazing guitar player, and nobody can deny that. Here is exactly what some people have commented, "John 5 plays it like it is on the album," but Mick's sound and feel cannot be duplicated. It's Motley Crue with him and always will be.
Tele is very distinctively J5 sound as well... still, it would be satisfying live for Cru fans...
Overrated
I deny that John5 is an absolutely amazing guitar player. Overrated
@@taylorjeremy71 agreed
IN FACT JOHN 5 DOES NOT PLAY IT CORRECTLY, THERE ARE SOME PARTS THAT MARS PLAY THEM LIKE THE ALBUM AND JOHN 5 MISS THEM.
Thank you, John 5, for carrying the torch for Mick. Perfect choice. Love you, Mick.
DJ Ashba would have been a better fit for MC. Although, John 5 is a better player that DJ, I still think DJ would have brought a better street sound to MC.
@@paulytone no
John 5 was a session player for years. He has become amazing at playing solos perfectly. He plays it super precise and absolutely spot on. He’s probably in the top ten guitarist in the world. There’s pretty much nothing he can’t play
Big difference between being in the top 10 guitarist or top 10 session players. John 5 lacks the soul and originality to be in the top 10. Ask a none guitar player who John 5 is, they won't know. ask that same person about Clapton Hendrix John Mayer Garcia SRV ect and they know, that's it. You have to resonate with a audience that's not musically inclined to be the best.
@@craigfishburn5206John 5 has played on hits
One of my all time favorite guitar solos. Brilliant
Grew up with Mick and Motley
Mick Mars will always be the guitarist for Motley Crue. John has nothing but the utmost respect for Mick and it shows in his playing. John is a fabulous guitar player. The reason Motley fans are so receptive to John it is because Mick gave his blessing. God bless Mick I can't wait to hear his new music coming out of Nashville. Love ya Mick
Why does this have to be a competition? Look, Mick was a horribly underrated badass for 40+ years with the Crue, and honestly the primary reason I ever got into music and started playing guitar. Yes, there are hundreds, even thousands of other guitar players out there that may be considered more technically adept than Mick, but NOBODY can play with the power and feel that Mick has. He will always be one of my favorite guitar players. When Mick stepped down, I thought that John 5 was absolutely the best choice to fill the spot, and I think he's doing a tremendous job honoring and paying tribute to Mick's legacy, but he's not Mick and nobody else ever will be.
And for fuck's sake, can somebody please beat Vince back into shape?
HEY BUDDY, round is a shape!
😂
Beat Vince into shape? I remember months ago there was a vid of him trying to get back into shape and he had a gym at home..... It's more like a centre piece... Vince needs a vacuum
Lmao , he's been eatin GOOD !
Lol I think it’s unfortunately that’s never going to happen
Love Mick for everything he's done. The songwriting, the playing, the sound, the feel. Amazing guitarist and a true legend for rockin' hard while having a very bad disease.
Its all about heart feeling! And of course ability to play! Those nice solos riffs licks Mick! All the way!
Mr. 5 showing Mick major respect through his playing and in interviews since this all blew up. Class act all the way. The other 3 don’t deserve a player not only just someone the laid back and cool but a monster guitarist. Mick has carried the band 90% of its life and those three chuckleheads will finish their careers being carried by another smoking player. Too band the don’t see or appreciate that fact. Just three punks in the streets, oh I’m sorry, I’m the limousines…
You know a guitar solo is awesome when almost 40 years later it gives someone goosebumps.
Mick wrote that solo and played it with more feeling than just about any guitarist ever. That's why people love him.
He's never been flashy ( although I think he was pushed into that from time to time) he's down to earth and humble. It shows when he plays.
Goosebumps is right.
Good to see John 5 staying true to Mick's work. With his level of ability he could easily stand up and play some mind blowing flashy stuff, but he's showing respect to Mick. Hats off to John 5.
John knows and understands the impact these songs have had on people so being not only a true musician but a fan he pays respect to the song and the fans
Did he tell you that?
Siempre la primera mirada es la que vale . Con quien vimos y escuchamos estos riffs . Con Mick ambos son geniales
Both of them are amazing! I love them both! ❤
2 great players, playing one man's solo. J5 is brilliant, no doubt. But the fact that you can listen to this song (and many other Crue tracks) and sing this solo, shows just how brilliant Mick is. The most under rated guitarist in hard rock.
I absolutely love the fact that one of the most amazing guitarist on the planet earth show some respect to Mars. Just awesome. Congratulations John, you are a true guitar hero.
Mick's picking on the frets gives his solos a very unique sound. I really dig his style. John 5 played it respectfully but, Mick wrote that amazing solo and no one else will ever come close to touching his talent because of that.
Mick is great- but he did not write this.
@@herbtube7824 I am referring to his guitar solo🎸 I'm sure he did.
John 5 understands that it's easier to follow than lead and accepts his role in Motley Crue as such. I'm assuming that he got the gig because of it. Can you imagine all of the shredders, of which John 5 is one of the best, coming in to audition and stomping all over Mick's leads thinking, "I can improve upon Mick's stuff!". I can hear it now, "NEXT, don't call us, we'll call you!!" LoL
@@SixStringSteveDelivers i’m pretty sure nikki wrote it
@@herbtube7824 i’m pretty sure nikki wrote the majority of micks things
Mick and John would rock if they did a song together
Rock On Mick Mars 😍🤘✌️🤩
John is playing the solo as written on the record. Mick is allowed to ad lib and add parts since he wrote it. Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him. John could play this while eating breakfast. I am sure if they allowed John to cut loose he would ad his own style to the solo. In respect to Mick, he plays it as written!
Nothing on Mick but John could play these solos in his sleep.
"Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him." Ridiculous statement. The man is in his 70's with a crippling spinal disease that causes him to be in constant pain.
Two things. First John can play anything with his eyes close and that's skill. Secondly his performances are boring as hell...... Being able to play anything doesn't make make the person a good performer, just a good session player.
@@nassermokhtar6851
gig dab hay dab
Oh my god, you live with a brain that small? "Also, Mick is concentrating as this is a tough part for him." I have heard dumber things, but not many. Since you clearly know nothing about music, please keep your mouth shut and be thought an idiot, because opening your mouth removed all doubt.
John 5 is a great guitarist, and I am super happy they tapped him to replace Mick. He is VERY respectful of the music for a reason. Mick is in constant pain, and 70. THAT is hard. playing a song he wrote and has played thousands of times isn't hard.
You can't replace Mick! He is the heart and SOUL of the band, many can imitate but none will ever be.
Mick didn’t get replaced though, he retired
@@wazda6488 umm clearly Nikki fired him.
Dumb comment of the week.....
Last I heard Mick in an interview he clearly didn't have any hard feelings. Maybe he really did retire. No harm in that though
@@berlyningle1820 yup
My all-time favourite guitar solo, and, to be fair, John 5 played it beautifully. Mick, and John, rock ! Thank you for this brilliant post.
I like them both, Mick rocking at 70!!
No body could beat the best and that'd be ol Mick Mars!
John is such an impressive player..he REVERES players like Mick, Eddie and so many others.. he plays it as close as another player who didn't write it could... many props to John 5 for playing it with no additions or subtractions.. but Mick is, was and will forever be the soul of the Crue... he literally gave his blood, sweat, tears, life and health for Motley.. and he's still a great player!..
Gotta hand it to John 5 for filling in and playing Micks part so well and accurate without embellishing or going off to do his own solo. Can tell he has nothing but respect for Mick. Great job
Agreed, I just wish I felt the same way about Zakk and Pantera.
@ferrj710 I think Zakk has done amazingly well playing in Pantera and honestly I don't think anyone else would have or should have played instead of him.due to.their history and friendship
@@peterharder279 as true as that is, and as much as I understand that, I don't feel like he's handling it the same way that you described John 5 handling his role with the Crue. Over-embellished, and not faithful to the original... That's my only complaints.
@ferrj710 I can only wish to see them when they roll through but everything I've seen they sound great and Zakk is filling the spot amazingly. He's not doin his 5 kin pinch harmonic solos, he's sticking pretty close to the original and he's happy doin it. Can't ask for much else
J5 isn't filling in. He's replaced a metal vet who was rooted out in order to please a non bass playing drama queen.
Both Mick and John are awesome players.
I still can't believe that he is my uncle!!! Even though I m a failure in my family, being on one and messed up all these years,,,it might not mean much coming from me but I m proud of you that you made it so big.....You are definitely 'THE MAN'
I will give John 5 credit as a premier guitarist, but Mick is the guitarist
that made crew what it is!
Seen Mick play that song live three times... imho The man's a legend. Stand in the back and melt your face off, spine disease and all. Glad John just respects the solo and plays it up straight. :)
Mick Mars is a legend original member of the crue can’t compare the 2 of them both brilliant
Mick and Isabella are magical thank you for all the years Mr. Mars
There's NO COMPARISON here as far as I'm concerned- My Man Mick Mars, ALL THE WAY!
John, five to the killer job, but Mick wrote it. I’m really glad I got to see Mick play Live a few times before he retired.
Mick's guitar playing is what gives Motley it's sound. You can tell its Motley Crue just by the guitar in the songs, Mick built their unique sound. John is a great guitarist thoough.
Liked them both, but Mick will always be my favorite.
I love when a guitarist stays true to the original- never the hey look at me- just respect for the song. Awesome
Two really great talents with two different great styles.
Mick's impeccable style is what feelings sound like.
both fantastic could watch them both for hrs.
Both were on the money....! Love you Mick.
The ending part of the solo with the whammy bar of Mick Marks sounds amazing
Mick Mars will always be one
Of my favorite guitarists but his physical state has really taken the toll he used to tell us about but we didn’t listen. He played on for so many years through so much pain. Thank you John 5 for what you have done here keeping it true to the original.
So much love for both guitarist. Glad that Johnny 5 kept the song as Mick wrote the solo. Mick Mars was so unique and he maintained a style that I feel was under- rated for his skills. He was a great song writer. He was the foundation for the sound of Motley Crue. Love and respect to both of them.
Both players are great and The Pain that Mick deals with while he is playing shows he has the grit to STILL do a wonderful job ! and I agree with another person who posted John is a Guitar Wizard and a Humble guy, playing the songs true and not trying to make them his own ,a very humble guy. In my opinion Motley should have quit years ago, Vince's voice has seen better days.
Micks pain was primarily caused by sharing a stage , and having to listen to Vince😖……I thought this was a SNL Debbie downer parody !
I have the same disease that Mic has and if his pain is like mine it's great he can play. Yesterday my hands and wrist hurt so bad and I could barely get up and move around. Today no pain at all.
Mick is the master and always will be! John is awesome and talented respect them both and enjoy hearing them play... gotta give them both 👍
Both Mick & John banged it out of the park. I saw a John 5 interview where he says that when playing someone else's music he'll try to play it as closely as it sounded on the record
Both amazing innovative guitarists
This song came on my car radio 96.5 WCMF On the way to my Sister's final resting place!!!🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
Both very talented. Grew up with MC. Thankful I finally got to see them last year in SF with Mick still playing.
Ive seen the Crue 3 times and hands down im gonna say Mick Mars. Way way underrated
Both players are fantastic.... different but great.
John 5 respectfully played it as it was on the album. Loved that
Still love mick... I love john5 as well but mick is sick and I mean that in his guitar playing.
John 5 is an amazing musician and from what I've read, seen and heard from him he seems to be a class act of a human being. You have to love the respect he is showing Mick.
Both great, and NOT taking anything away from John 5, but I can just feel the heart, soul, and emotion in Mick's playing.
yes! john hits the notes but in a grenic way. very bland. compared to mick
@@fredjones8607 What's hilarious is if the uploader swapped the audio for both performances, you'd be saying the same thing, lmao. Yeah, yeah, I know... save it.
@@ev25zv i can tell micks playing blindfolded compared to 5
@@fredjones8607 You should be able to - the intonation is shit, the intonation on the bends is shit, the vibrato is fast, thin, and shitty, tone is shit, and it's sloppy. But yeah, that's not what you're hearing because your stone ears can't hear it.
I like telecasters but John 5's is set up for faster playing, while Mick's strat is set up for amazing tone and grit.
I love that John kept the Mick lead in place. He showed total props to Mick, and that lead is iconic. Sweet.
The first time I seen the Crue was with OZZY at the bark at the moon tour! and they were with a German band called ACCEPT. (a German heavy metal band) and then the Theatre of pain tour, both concerts were in Kentucky!
Two great guitarists. Mick Mars is the reason Motley Crue became one of rhe greatest bands in rock history…
No one can replace the legends…..Mick Mars all day!
J5 IS a legend too! but this is a Mick song, same would happen if you put mick to play J5 songs, their sound is different.
@@goex4881John 5 is a very talented guitar player, but he is not a legend.
I fully admit my bias for 1313 because I've listened to everything he has done and loved every bit of it. Nobody can fill his shoes. He is the heart and soul of the Crue. 5 is absolutely phenomenal too.
Both do a fine job. John played it with respect to the original and a feel of his own. Yeah, the man can totally shred any time he wants to, but this is not what the song called for and he honored Mick's solo beautifully. He's a solid player.
Sick upload john is a legend i was a danzig fan since i was 13 got aholda Lucifuge and been a fan ever since
I can see the chords n i think i could nail this thanx john wish u the best
Mick hands down, especially during the shred part. Mick goes from super slow to fast smoothly and gradually. John 5 goes from slow to incredibly fast with no transition
John is fantastic, period. Passing the torch as they say. Thank you Mick for all that you brought, and our memories. Thank you John for bringing yourself to the role. Ultimately, we all win.
Both are Legends and John 5 showed the utmost respect to Mars with his Solo, he didn't flash it up, he played it the way it was written. The Things happening between Mick and the rest of the Crue most likely isn't on the mind of John 5, he has a lot of respect for Mick, and it shows in how he plays all the songs.
Lol, that’s not entirely true. I didn’t even know who the #5 guy was until he became 5 to Sixx… lol, it’s funny.
Lol. He plays the solos like the recording because that's what the gig calls for - it has nothing to do with Mars. Like when Vince Gill played the first Eagles gig and Vince improvised a Glenn Frey solo. Don Henley said, "Stick to the script, Vince."
Thank you John 5 for respecting Mick Mars it shows in how you play his solo on this song
Mick is awesome. I was expecting John to embellish the solo, but he didn't. Much respect for that.
Mick all the way! Brings soul to it. I don’t know how but he does to my senses.