Which Election was the worst? - Election Analysis 2008 to 2024 - Shehzad Ghias

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
  • Part 3 of our Stolen Election series looks at the Elections 2008 to 2024.
    The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
    Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
    / thepakistanexperience
    The first part of the series:
    • History of Stolen Elec...
    To support the channel:
    Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
    Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
    And Please stay in touch:
    / thepakistanexp1
    / thepakistanexperience
    / thepakistanexpeperience
    The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
    shehzadghiasshaikh
    Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
    shehzad89
    Chapters:
    0:00 Return of Democracy, America and Dictatorship
    3:00 Return of Benazir Bhutto and Removal of Musharraf
    7:00 Benazir Bhutto's Assassination
    11:50 2008 Elections and Democratic Traditions
    18:50 2008-2013
    20:30 2013 Elections and the 2014 Dharna
    26:50 Destroying Democratic Traditions in 2017
    33:50 2018 Elections and PTI's formation of Government
    37:05 2024 Elections and Final Analysis
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 275

  • @aima9720
    @aima9720 Місяць тому +23

    Shahzad, you have evolved beautifully! More power to you

  • @hibernationgaming
    @hibernationgaming Місяць тому +2

    Series that deal with history are my favourite on the channel. Props for all the hard work that you do for these!

  • @jamshedfbc
    @jamshedfbc Місяць тому +1

    Well explained Ghasif. By the way, waiting for your book review session. Thank you.

  • @zaheerahmed3507
    @zaheerahmed3507 Місяць тому +4

    Aap andaza karo is banday ka jo mitti pao ko support kar raha hai aur zardari ko credit dey raha, is mitti pao ki waja say hi establishment ka mu khul chuka hai.

  • @rkchoubs
    @rkchoubs Місяць тому +4

    Nice to see this matured political commentator side of yours . Well done 👍
    PS: I see future Sethi Sb in your analysis style 👌

  • @armaghanaized3666
    @armaghanaized3666 Місяць тому +6

    Too many misleading facts. dont know what the host wants to achive via this. Either speak complete truth or dont lie in between the lines.

  • @azammuhammad3749
    @azammuhammad3749 Місяць тому +4

    Waisay bhai aap ke saray programe dekhney ke bahd andaza huwa hai keh aap ka tilt khan ke khilaf hota hai jaisa keh mera tilt khan ki taraf lekin over all aap acha kam kar rahey hain always gonna watch your content which is Awsome😊

  • @nasirBAS
    @nasirBAS Місяць тому +2

    Very well summarized.. though a lot of public now understands and talks about it, still it needs to be reiterated as many times as possible.

  • @khawarnadeem1807
    @khawarnadeem1807 28 днів тому

    Rationale & balanced analysis. Keep it going.

  • @at5112opsiarw
    @at5112opsiarw Місяць тому

    You are doing a great service to the subcontinent. Very few offer such dispassionate and factual analysis.

  • @shujaullah6520
    @shujaullah6520 Місяць тому +6

    What's the use of the army when time comes to defend its territory our Army surrender which we see in 1971 and 2002 Infront of America

  • @muhammadalihashmi602
    @muhammadalihashmi602 Місяць тому +1

    good and very informative

  • @nilofer60
    @nilofer60 Місяць тому

    I had been watching this series of videos as they came out and had decided that when you reach 2024, I will watch them all in one go, which I'm about to do. Your analyses and factual research is spot on. Well done!

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      🙌

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому

      Well, yes, details many events that happened in the last one and halfs decades apart from the "deals" of Zardari with the establishment....very telling that he leaves that out 🤔...

  • @Muhammad-Burhan-Raza
    @Muhammad-Burhan-Raza Місяць тому

    Shezad, you beauty, thanks for making this video ❤

  • @muhammadmalik5122
    @muhammadmalik5122 Місяць тому +2

    We need a few more voices like you Shahzad bhai. I understand theka apka ni hai saara. But please keep at it. Lets reignite the passion for the north star.

  • @balajjamal2671
    @balajjamal2671 Місяць тому +27

    I extracted two things from this video:
    1) PTI is the worst thing that has ever happened in human history.
    2) Sir Lord Asif Ali Zardari is the greatest person ever in human history.

    • @ZainServices
      @ZainServices Місяць тому +2

      Lmao
      fact can easily manipulative

    • @Funny-je3vo
      @Funny-je3vo Місяць тому +1

      Was going to comment the same.

    • @rishisimply
      @rishisimply Місяць тому +3

      Imrandu's spotted

    • @nasirBAS
      @nasirBAS Місяць тому

      😂

    • @AHMED..KHAN.
      @AHMED..KHAN. Місяць тому +4

      ​@@rishisimply
      Patwarandu
      Jyalandu
      Militarandu
      Spotted

  • @najmussaharbangash6924
    @najmussaharbangash6924 Місяць тому

    Excellent programme and very well explained - must be shared widely with the coming up generations so that at least at some point we will have a well educated population to overcome the difficulties highlighted. Thank you

  • @AbdullahKhan-zt6rq
    @AbdullahKhan-zt6rq 9 днів тому

    Very well explained shehzad Bhai .the method of your explanation is very amicable

  • @ashishsah4714
    @ashishsah4714 Місяць тому +1

    Appreciate your efforts to revive a sense of democratic system and the effort/detailing with which you deliver.
    While we know it's a tough fight for you as well as us in India.
    But what I am saluting is the relentless perseverance/efforts put in by torch bearers like u (across) and Ravish (here) in trying to educate the masses.
    More power to u!

  • @muhammadhassaansiddiqi8586
    @muhammadhassaansiddiqi8586 Місяць тому

    Very Good Analysis. ❤

  • @Sulpha69
    @Sulpha69 Місяць тому +12

    You have evolved my way of thinking. I was waiting for yor video eagerly. Its again Eid for me.( I was a PTI supporter before listening to your podcasts and Muzammil's videos 😁 )

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +4

      🙌

    • @ZainServices
      @ZainServices Місяць тому +1

      Just imagine you are against a party after listening certain ppl and develop sympathies for other parties
      This is called lafalism.

    • @khasho
      @khasho Місяць тому

      ​@ZainServices he never said he has sympathies for other party. You just made that up. That's what PTI cult does. They don't even accept one mistake and put allegations on others without evidence. You believe whatever IK says, without any evidence.

    • @Sulpha69
      @Sulpha69 Місяць тому

      @@ZainServices nobody invited you to talk shit and do a comment. Keep your negativity and youthiapanty to yourself.

    • @abdullahazeem113
      @abdullahazeem113 Місяць тому +1

      Tou phela sei hi patwari tha tujhei mei nei phela bhi dheka howa comments mei 😂

  • @indranilsaha9994
    @indranilsaha9994 Місяць тому +15

    I am really amazed by the depth and clarity of the facts. Must admit being a Bengali Non-resident Indian, Pakistan should embrace people like you, who have moved ahead of those medival religious systems.
    Subscribed and more views for your excellent work, definitely deserves more view than some of our famous Godi UA-camrs who are just outcome of people of my own country India, (especially the North India, not far from Pakistan in distance and religious fanatism) which is following all the mistakes of your previous government.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      🙌

    • @zackjeer
      @zackjeer Місяць тому +6

      You being a bengali, Non-resident india must be overwhelmed with western news channel, echo chambers to make such a statement
      I mean, if the events and situation in west bengal doesnt make u to comment on it, rather than saying north india becoming like pakistan is an absurdity,, keep being a NRI

    • @KushalG08
      @KushalG08 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@zackjeer... Bro that's the magic of the Indian minds when they go to press the button... Whatever may be propaganda... The common sense always tends to restore balance... Look at 2024 lok sabha election result.... West Bengal will have a BJP lead... While tamilnadu will retain DMK lead... Now which factors will lead to it.. It's not black and white... Difficult to explain to people who don't know the ground reality...

    • @indranilsaha9994
      @indranilsaha9994 Місяць тому

      The people who got offended by the North Indian remark, go and please live under the rock.
      I lived in a capital where people still care about religion, caste, Veg/Non-veg than the terrible air quality. You guys are living 100 years back not so dissimilar to your nemesis Pakistan. Basically, you learn nothing from the mistakes host of TPE podcast talks about. Thanks for proving my point.
      You have become what you hate the most, a religious lunatic state.

    • @bazigar9380
      @bazigar9380 Місяць тому

      @@zackjeer a Bengali and on top of that this bong bastard is a nri,if you talk to him about his state he will backtrack that's how this bastards are so it's better to don't say them anything

  • @confirmjannati
    @confirmjannati Місяць тому

    Great podcast ❤❤

  • @JAli-gn1dd
    @JAli-gn1dd Місяць тому

    Well explanation!

  • @azdeeacademia7513
    @azdeeacademia7513 Місяць тому

    Your analysis is correct in diagnosing the problem. Please highlight the solution too that what should youth do , the best we can do is vote and even that doesn't count due to establishment

  • @IrfanAli-wp2ft
    @IrfanAli-wp2ft Місяць тому

    Shahzad bhai, main aapki soch ka aur aapkay explanation ka fan hoon. Never for a minute it was dull or boring. Ab aik request hai, in sab polital parties par aapki pick kaunsi party hai ya future Pakistan ka kis ke saath behtar hai, is par roshni daalain. We all know considering the current circumstances who is the best solution?

    • @abdullahazeem113
      @abdullahazeem113 Місяць тому

      Zardari ki pedawar ha tera yei walid 😂

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      Thank you. Sir ye teen Bari parties toh Kuch nahee kar sakti inki bus selected selected honay ki jang hay

    • @abdullahazeem113
      @abdullahazeem113 Місяць тому

      Obviously what do you expect from these ppp tout asal mei bilal ki tarah hi peda howa ha yei 😂

  • @Rayyan90876
    @Rayyan90876 Місяць тому

    very informative information

  • @siddiqaperveen1630
    @siddiqaperveen1630 Місяць тому

    More power to you❤

  • @mrlight7516
    @mrlight7516 Місяць тому +2

    2024 was the worst

  • @navaidahmed6335
    @navaidahmed6335 Місяць тому

    Would love to see a comparison from your side on the numbers before RTS went down in 2018 and the final election results.

  • @imjaveediqbal
    @imjaveediqbal Місяць тому

    lets start watching

  • @MrCuteguylol
    @MrCuteguylol Місяць тому +1

    1:38 WHOA WHOA JUST HOLD ON A MINUTE!!!

  • @alevelbio6529
    @alevelbio6529 Місяць тому +3

    A 50 minute video🎉 , Is it eid today?

  • @mum1062
    @mum1062 Місяць тому +4

    Shehzad, your simplistic way of developing common sense of people is the most important thing

  • @navneetLEKINdude
    @navneetLEKINdude Місяць тому +3

    0:22
    Prachar sir ji, not prakar ☺️👍🏽

    • @user-nh5ke7ph5c
      @user-nh5ke7ph5c Місяць тому

      Yeah the literal meaning of prachar is advertisement and prakar is type .

  • @100zaid5
    @100zaid5 Місяць тому +9

    You should also have mentioned the press conferences done by Javed Latif and Maryam Aurangzeb blaming Imran Khan of blasphemy prior to assassination attempt on him. Wo ap bhool jatay hain kisi wajah se.

    • @Asystays
      @Asystays Місяць тому

      Assassination attempt ya stunt?

  • @alevelphysics6606
    @alevelphysics6606 Місяць тому +2

    I do agree with your points but man you really have a soft spot for PPP yes yo do criticism but i feel that you simultaneously suggest ka PPP ke saath bohot bura hoa...being a karachite i just cant stand them..they are a slow poison to the city

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      That’s your right to think but how can one not think unkay saath bura hua when their entire family was assassinated?

    • @akbalushi4779
      @akbalushi4779 Місяць тому

      ​@@ThePakistanExperiencemulk b to todha wazir e azam ban k or keya teer mara he benazir ne america ke pao pakhad kar kaha Musharraf ko athao agar yehi kaam imran Khan kare wo b lobby karke jese Zi.. karte he unke politicians ko khareed kar wo b imran Khan khud nae balki uske supp.. karte he to ap jese logo.... me jalan q Hote he or PPP ke tarraki dekhne to sindh ko he dekh lo saare bhikari wahe k he Ramzan me alag shift hota he sedha bolo me nakhli bhutto ke family ko chutiya ho ABCD q karrahe hu or rahe baat 1971 ke election k bad koi election Fair nae raha sab army ke marze ke result Aae or unko public ne accept keya lekin 2024 k election majority public ne accept nae keya or army ke results k sath kush nae or ap logo ko lifafe chor kar public ko support karna chaiye chutiyapa chor kar ✅

  • @stabinhaider
    @stabinhaider Місяць тому +4

    It was good, surprising to know Jamat e Islami didn't have and pivotal role till now.
    Thank you for making it Ghayaz.

  • @muhammadnawaz3046
    @muhammadnawaz3046 Місяць тому

    مکمل سچ اللہ آپکی حفاظت فرمائے

  • @salmanayubkhan8091
    @salmanayubkhan8091 Місяць тому +2

    رانا صاحب کی تصویریں سنی دیوبندی گروپس کیساتھ تھی الحدیث اور دیوبندی عمومی طور پر نون کو ھی سپورٹ کرتے تھے۔۔ پریلوی اور اثناء عشری ووٹ پی پی کو پڑتا تھا خاص کر اثنا عشری ووٹ پی پی کی بیک بون تھی پنجاب میں ، جو انتہائی حیرت انگیز طور پر اتنی کھلی عمران خان کی طالبان حامی پالیسیوں کے باوجود عمران خان کی حمایت میں چلاگیا اور پی پی پنجاب خاص کر شھروں میں زیرو پر لاکھڑا کیا۔

  • @user-ln6cc4rf5z
    @user-ln6cc4rf5z Місяць тому +1

    MY FATHER WAS THE FIRST MAN WHO INTRODUCED DEMOCRACY IN MY HOME, (NOTHING NEW UNDER THE SON)

  • @furqanarshed9
    @furqanarshed9 Місяць тому +1

    I respect your opinion bro
    Respect a lot
    2018 k elections ka analysis aap se ikhtilaf karna chahta hoon
    plz mind na karna
    Ziada kuch nhi kahoo ga one line
    2018 k elections mein 25 july 2018 ko raat 12 baje kisi bhi news channel par party position kia thi (check on youtube on any news channel) aur 2024 mein 8 February 2024 ki raat ko 12 baje party position kia thi(check on youtube on any news channel)
    And dono elections k final results kia the.What was difference
    Please eik bar zroor dekhna

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      Sir mai nay sab dekha hay. Aap bataye kya ikhtilaaf hay Aap ka woh sir aankhon par

    • @furqanarshed9
      @furqanarshed9 Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience
      Thank you so much for reply dear sir
      Mein ne ye ikhtilaf kia hai k
      Aap chahe abhi UA-cam par ja kar likhein 2018 election results Geo news/Ary /capital tv etc Jo bhi and then dekhiye RTS bethne se pehle party position kia thi aur bad mien kia thi and in the same way check that 2024 mein EMS bethne se pehle party position kia thi and bad mein
      (In 2018 at 12 P.M RTS bethne se pehle (PTI was almost between 105-120 PMLN almost 55-60).and in 2024 at 12 P.M night balke 12 tak to sub ne chor dia tha express par aur hum par PTI 125 and PMLN 43
      And PMLN ki 9 February ki subh tak 50 bhi nhi thi Kisi eik channel par bhi
      Ab aap mujhe 2018 k election ki rat (25 July 2018 Wednesday ki Raat ) ko koi eik news channel bhi dikha dein Sara content chan marron Jahan PTI 100 se neeche ho (Rat 9 baje se le kar rat 3 baje tak).
      Plz mind na karna I just express my difference of opinion
      Plz don't mind
      Is ko kehte hain circumstances evidence
      mein 2018 k election results ki Raat ko mein jaldi so gaya tha I remember but before Isha PTI was 73 and PMLN 25) almost on Geo news
      In nut shell RTS bethne se pehle aur bad k results mieim koi farq nhi tha and EMS bethne se pehle aur bad mein wo mein chemistry ka student hoo to us mien eik SN2 mein 100 %inversion Hoti almost wo seen ho gaya tha PMLN Jo k Raat 12 balke subh 5 baje tak Kisi channel even UA-cam par bhi ,40-42 se ziada nhi thi wo agle din ,75 p finish karti hai aur PPP Jo k 30 se ziada nhi thi ,50 p finish karti hai
      In nut shell aap ko bare ehteram k sath challenge hai k 25 July ki rat 12 baje se pehle agar PTI Kahi 100 se Kam p stand kar rhi thi to mujhe deka dei. Plzz

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      Sir kyon Kay 2018 mai media Poora controlled tha

    • @furqanarshed9
      @furqanarshed9 Місяць тому

      I respect your opinion sir
      But poora media kabhi control nhi hota
      Chlen for the sake of argument man lete hain Geo bhi control tha and express news bhi control tha but phir bhi social media to 2018 mein bhi bohat tha TIKTOK ki bari hipe thi UA-cam bhi theek thak chlti thi
      Koi social media platform wo to shi reporting kar rha ho ga na
      Aap ab conspiracy theories ki traf chle gaye hain
      Aisa nhi ho skta k sub media control ho aur AgR control.ho bhi to bhi wo ghalt aur itni ghalat party position show nhi kr ska
      Bahar Haal koi social media platform ya twitter even PMLN ka twitter wo zra check karein 25 July 2018 ki Raat ko shayed wahan p PTI ki 40 seats hon
      In nut shell aap plz mujhe dikha dein k Kisi social media platform ya PMLN k apne mutabiq hi agar PMLN Kahi bhi ksi bhi waqt 50,60 se Uper even 70 tak bhi gayi ho to?
      Meri bat karne ka maqsad ye hai k agar RTS betha tha to us k bad party position mein changging honi chahiye thi Jo k nhi hui aur EMS k bethne se aisi changing hui k sub dekh skte hain
      Mera point phir whi aur simple hai chahe media control nhi tha man lete hai poore mulk se Jo election results Jo log akhte kar rhe the sub k sub controlled the phir bhi RTS bethne se pehle aur bad mein change to hona chahiye tha
      Aur kuch nhi to itna to hona chahiye tha na k
      Before RTS bethne se
      PTI ,=80
      PMLN =90,
      Aur RTS bethne k bad
      PTI 115
      PMLN 64
      Aap check karein kia aisa hi tha?
      Ab 2024 p ajayein
      Before 5 AM 9 February
      According almost all media sources
      PTI more or less
      More than 120
      PMLN 42
      and after
      PTI 93
      PMLN 75

    • @furqanarshed9
      @furqanarshed9 Місяць тому +2

      I respect your opinion sir
      Laikin my point is simple and clear
      Mujhe 2018 ki rat 1,2 baje se pehle RTS bethne se pehle aur bad mein PTI ki seats ka faraq prove kar k dikhayein Kisi social media par bhi agar PTI 100 se neeche ho RTS bethne se pehle to bhi batayein
      Social media platforms 2018 mein bhi Kafi active the though not equal to 2024. Poora media aur social media bhi.complete control nhi hota
      Aur for your information July 2018 mein Shehbaz sharif ne Lahore aur Punjab even Karachi mein bhi Kai jalse kiye sub ko live coverage milti thi
      I challenge with due respect
      Ye hi eik treeqa hai circumstances evidence check karne ka
      Agar nhi to baqi aap Keh skte hain k media control tha laikin circumstances evidence ki base p Jo aam insan ko Nazar aane wali massive rigging hai 2024 ki wo 2018. Mein nhi hai

  • @naumanmustafa7728
    @naumanmustafa7728 Місяць тому

    Woodruff fantastic analysis

  • @Funny-je3vo
    @Funny-je3vo Місяць тому +2

    Shahzad, your biasness against PTI/Imran khan is glowing richly 😅. Even military dictatorship is good for country compare to PTI. Also, Asif zardari is an angel 👼. Thanks for opening our eyes. We are mature now like you 😜

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      Pata nahee sunay mai problem hay ya samajhnay mai, find me the time stamp for when I said military dictatorship is good compared to PTI

    • @Funny-je3vo
      @Funny-je3vo Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperiencethanks for your attention. I respect your perspective but when someone commenting on a national issue on public platform, ut shouldn't be biased. Btw, I was sarcastic while commenting above that military dictatorship is good than PTI/IK. Also, zardari is not an angel, brother 🙂

  • @shubhamseladiya2562
    @shubhamseladiya2562 Місяць тому

    I'm from india and your videos help me a lot to understand pakistani politics. Very very informative and unbiased explanation of A to Z of pakistani politics.
    next year sanjay rajoura ke sath aake milte hai karachi festival me😀😀

  • @tajmuhammaddaudpota4041
    @tajmuhammaddaudpota4041 Місяць тому +1

    Your efforts of endless, for revealing truth of pakistan political history. Rational thinking youth can understand, But the majority of mass people do not wants truth.

  • @zaheer1633
    @zaheer1633 Місяць тому +1

    Facts based analysis.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      🙌

    • @abdullahazeem113
      @abdullahazeem113 Місяць тому

      Ppp based analysis

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому

      ​@@ThePakistanExperience
      Suure only that he conveniently leaves out some FACTS like Zardari dealings with the military establishment... very telling...

  • @hassanjamil4137
    @hassanjamil4137 Місяць тому

    The relation of last 3/4 election is well elaborated but my 2 cents (these are just my thoughts evolved by listening to your podcast).
    1 - The project Imran Khan not only advocate the Chor Chor mantra against PPP and PML (N). This has been happening in parliament (official records can validate this from NA website) and in election campaigns since 1990 by both of the parties.
    2 - BB was signing COD and simultaneously doing the NRO. One can go against the agreements being a Bhutto. It's normal. Seriously this nation has a problem of short term memory loss.
    3 - Right after the BB assassination, someone said Q League a Qatil League.
    4 - All credit to 18th amendment, but the best revenge was the economic performance from 2008 to 2013.
    5 - Highly condemn the attack on Ahsan Iqbal but he was trained by Apa Nisar Fatima (you can check about her work on blasphemy). What you sow so shall you reap.
    6 - Things can set aside because I have seen how two political parties had joined hands for their own benefits and power. I don't agree with the ending. You cannot say Mariyam and Bilawal the new puppets. They are true DEMOCRATS!!!

  • @muhammadumerfarooq8477
    @muhammadumerfarooq8477 Місяць тому

    What is the correct pronounciation: Ques-ton or ques-chn?

    • @Sulpha69
      @Sulpha69 Місяць тому

      Check it on Google

  • @doctorcustomworks3601
    @doctorcustomworks3601 Місяць тому

    Salute to you Shehzad ❤❤❤

  • @imransadiq7104
    @imransadiq7104 Місяць тому

    Very interesting series of vlogs
    I agree with most of your analysis but beg to differ one point
    RTS was down because Imran Khan was gaining majority on the other hand establishment wants IK to have government on crunches like MQM and BAP

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      Boss why would the establishment that did everything to help IK win right at the end stop him from winning then after the election push electables into PTI to help them again

    • @imransadiq7104
      @imransadiq7104 Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience In my humble opinion Establishment realized after 1997 NS two third majority that they will never allow govt. to have majority
      It is in establishment benefits to have a shaky government like what they have right now 🤔

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      But boss agar PTI kee genuinely itni popularity thee toh 2017 say 2018 itni mehnat kyon karni paree establishment ko to prop up PTI

    • @imransadiq7104
      @imransadiq7104 Місяць тому +1

      @@ThePakistanExperience I think this is the beauty of educated arguments
      If establishment did everything then why can't same establishment can help PTI patriot and IPP to get few seats
      As you mentioned in your 2nd vlog that Musharaf built PMQ but the moment people had a chance it was no where
      Can I ask you one question?
      What is the way forward from the current situation for our establishment? I see them digging themselves deeper and deeper and Pakistan can not be run like this?
      Please do answer 🙂

  • @nasirBAS
    @nasirBAS Місяць тому

    I think Shehzad...
    Now its about time that we take our attention to the budget allocation to maintain these boots.
    People like the youth r doing a good job...
    Lets start saying what ahmad faraz's and the likes...their poetry was saying openly.

  • @kkbhai254
    @kkbhai254 Місяць тому

    Let us rejoin,I want to see my parents house in Pakistan

  • @Shakeel.Irshad
    @Shakeel.Irshad Місяць тому

    Correction: Sir Lahore has 14 NA seats and Faisalabad has 10. You said Lhr has 24 and Fsd has 18. Karachi has 22 NA seats I think.... Another thing, can you suggest work of Rafiullah Kakar as you said he is greatest intellectual of Pakistan...

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      Lahore district has 24
      Nankana Sahib 2
      Sheikhupura 4
      Lahore 14
      Kasur 4

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      You can watch his podcasts on our channel

    • @Shakeel.Irshad
      @Shakeel.Irshad Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience Sir Nankana Sahib, Kasur and Sheikhupura are different districts.... Plz Don't include our Kasur into Lahore 😂😂... Yes it's part of division Lahore, but not district...

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      You’re right I meant division not district, ghaltee hogayee

    • @Shakeel.Irshad
      @Shakeel.Irshad Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience koi nai Sir, hotA he, basically we are working with Geo Election Cell so that's why...

  • @sheryarahmed6331
    @sheryarahmed6331 24 дні тому

    bhai jaan amreeka ne apki democracy ka theka nahi liya hua, above all else amreeka pakistan me stability prefer karta hai. "America bad" gets really tiring after you've shifted responsibility for the 500th time.
    also this idea that if pakistan were a democracy in the early 2000s we would not have allowed them military access to invade afghanistan is really funny to me.

  • @imjaveediqbal
    @imjaveediqbal Місяць тому +2

    instead of fact this videos includes narratives disappointed and most out of context

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      What did I say which is not a fact

    • @azhariqbal12345
      @azhariqbal12345 Місяць тому +2

      @@ThePakistanExperience Painting Zardari as Hero after Be Nazir death is far away from fact , just answer me if Be Nazir was alive zardari would have been president ?

  • @SarojEkka-zc3nq
    @SarojEkka-zc3nq Місяць тому +6

    How innocently they discuss about democracy 😂😂
    Never want to analyze root cause. Democracy & Islamic states are mutually exclusive. DNA also changes with religious beliefs.

    • @atokimruk937
      @atokimruk937 Місяць тому

      These people are beyond redemption and have no capability of rational thinking. You are right, their religion has completely changed their DNA.

  • @RaheEl_Qaisrani
    @RaheEl_Qaisrani Місяць тому

    until people realise that all we need to focus on is get the power out from unelected people and that is only possible if people force there all the parties to sit together never be pawn of unelected forces

  • @Walkwithusama
    @Walkwithusama Місяць тому +2

    You lost grace after sahil adeem show. How unethical and arrogant you were at that podcast!

    • @muddi900
      @muddi900 Місяць тому

      Rs. 10 have been added to your account-Sahil Adeem

  • @muhammadalihashmi602
    @muhammadalihashmi602 Місяць тому

    Sir Jamati islami ANP or Mqm etc jo parties hain unki political history k hawlaay sai share kray or conent bnayein

  • @sunilchy33786
    @sunilchy33786 Місяць тому

    Bro RIP in advance.. 🙁🙁💐💐

  • @iamwham
    @iamwham Місяць тому

    I believe when Pakistan has its democracy, they will stop being the western/chinese pawn and work on their own development. What Shahzad talks about is well understood in foreign policy circles. Read up “The idea of Pakistan” by Stephen Philip Cohen on how Pakistan has been pulled in different directions in every crisis but the people responsible have never been held accountable. You need to understand history to avoid repeating the mistakes, but the textbooks in Pakistan keep getting rewritten.

    • @iamwham
      @iamwham Місяць тому

      All of Indian politicians are morons too, army is not a solution to that problem. It’s exposing the people in power through free press and free speech.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      Yes

  • @muhammadnawaz3046
    @muhammadnawaz3046 Місяць тому

    ایک ہی سسٹم فوج کا ہے جو ناقابل اصلاح ہے جو آدھا ملک توڑ کر بھی نمبر ون ہے بس چھوڑیں.... وڑ گیا ہے

  • @zaheerahmed3507
    @zaheerahmed3507 Місяць тому

    In sab ka jawab hai mere paas i can rebuttle you my friend.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      Day do Jawad it’s a free world Aap Kay pass bhi social media hay, Humaray comments section bhi open hay, if I am wrong show me the facts

  • @kishwerperveen9633
    @kishwerperveen9633 Місяць тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @saqibmahdi
    @saqibmahdi Місяць тому +1

    Sab pagal se hean aap thek ho 😢

  • @tariqshafi1222
    @tariqshafi1222 Місяць тому

    Brilliant and unbiased analysis.

  • @AbdullahKhan-zt6rq
    @AbdullahKhan-zt6rq 9 днів тому

    Shehzad bhai ik request hai apse aur Syed muzamil shah Bhai SE please KP na Bola Kara Khyber pakhtunkhwa Bola kare

  • @muhammadnawaz3046
    @muhammadnawaz3046 Місяць тому

    جو بلا دودھ پی جاتا ہے اس کے گلے میں گھنٹی کون باندھے گا

  • @abdullahazeem113
    @abdullahazeem113 Місяць тому +2

    Pro ppp channel obviously zardari backed what can one expect 2018 elections kei upar international reports puri par pti was actually the most favoured party infact many now critiques were in favour and rigging was also done by pmln as they were in power in punjab for such a long time and had strong control

  • @faranqamar8130
    @faranqamar8130 Місяць тому +3

    I have praised Shehzad when he does a good job but this was a very lazy and flat analysis like a movie/tv character with no depth. I'll explain why.
    For example in his ongoing obsession to circle every square related to IK, he compared BB's assassination with IK's murder attempt and how Zardari didn't call for revenge(which is true) from the system and how PTI asked for it when IK was shot. Well this is why he has no depth because you have to take in consideration the circumstances while BB had a deal with the military that Musharraf would be President, deal with the Americans because they helped signing of MOD, deal with political parties where everyone knew PPP will rule and after 5yrs PMLN will rule, lawyers/judges onboard because of the recent lawyers movement and all stalwarts were among these two parties, media certainly onboard the entire system was ready and unfortunately she fell prey to the horrible terrorism that we all faced in those yrs & unless u have proof that establishment killed her I'd say ure indulging in the same conspiracy theories that u accused PTI of in the past.
    Now compare to IK where a coup was carried out with the help of all of the above I mentioned. No deal with the establishment, no deal with any foreign power, no deal with political parties, judiciary and level of the state system, victimized and brutalized leading upto it and till now so they definitely had/have reasons to point finger when the killer is getting zoom hearings and IK is asked to personally show up in court after getting shot and not allowed to even open an FIR on the ppl he wanted, dissolved assemblies didn't have elections on them for a year whatever his reason or justification might be when ppl vote for u they give u the right to make or break them.
    One had no system to blame because that system was part of BB's comeback and the other shot, tens of thousands of party workers arrested, leadership arrested, ppl made to quit, media ban, election stolen. So yeah I'd say there's no comparison.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      You’re accusing me of conspiracy theories and your theory is that the entire society was involved in a ten year conspiracy where PPP would rule first then PMLN will rule?

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      The Iftikhar Chaudhry Judiciary was anti PPP, who could they be involved in the conspiracy with them. The military relaunched Imran Khan and they were fully behind the 2014 dharnas how could they be the ones involved in the PpP/PMLN conspiracy for ten years. You’re allowed to have opinions but ye toh poori alternative history bana dee Aap nay boss

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      the coup happened in 2018 that you conveniently ignored

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому

      All PTI has done is deals with the Establishment. The ban dial court changed the constitution to favour khan.

    • @snd9826
      @snd9826 Місяць тому

      What a joke IK assassination attempt. It is all a fabricated story. As far as I know the person who was accused is a guard of one of PTI mpa or mna. Saad Rafique had won the election but his agents were kicked out and ik declared winner and when Lahore high court ordered recounting SC stopped it. You are a Youthia who refuse to accept reality.

  • @muneer-071
    @muneer-071 Місяць тому

    Sir shahzad kindlly again start review of book like u did for murder of history😢

  • @saqibmahdi
    @saqibmahdi Місяць тому

    Body language, sab thek he 😂

  • @ubaidhunts
    @ubaidhunts Місяць тому

    “phut lo jo phutna ha”
    🤣🤣🤣 bhai “putt lo jo putna ha” hota ha.

  • @SouthindianNarendra
    @SouthindianNarendra Місяць тому

    I am happy that Pakistan formed otherwise. All this shit happens. In india also

  • @saagrhussain7869
    @saagrhussain7869 Місяць тому

    AJ kal HR koi pod cater BN jata hua...u shud have started from 2024

  • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
    @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому +4

    In your rundown of events.
    While you rightly criticize the military establishment and those who previously benefited like PTI/IK. You are mute on Zardari role in "dealing" with them..be it the fall of government in Balochistan or Election in Senate upto now becoming again President... Howcome you leave that out?

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/j8Oc8kT6XZM/v-deo.htmlsi=-GvaFd3j65LbMJgT how come you don’t watch my content but then claim I haven’t spoken about things I’ve made videos on?

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому +2

      @@ThePakistanExperience
      You make a video on elections/political events from 2008- 2024. In this video would you please point out where you have mentioned Zardari dealings with the establishment ? Please enlighten me...

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      Political events apni taraf say add kardia? You’re moving the goalposts just because you don’t want to accept your whataboutism was unnecessary

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому +2

      @@ThePakistanExperience
      Well you talk of attack on Hamid Mir,, dawn leaks, the role of Saqib Nisar, the role of generals like Kayani and Bajwa... etc...you talk of many political events in THIS VIDEO. Again why no mention of Zardari's dealings with the establishment?
      Why are you avoiding this question?.. or do you think that Zardari isn't important enough?

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому

      Silence reveals a lot....😉

  • @manojchowdhary4208
    @manojchowdhary4208 Місяць тому +1

    Pakistan shouldn’t worry. Pakistan is a nazriati mulq like Israel, formed during the holy month, and Waahid Islamic nuclear power of the world. Pakistan’s problems are caused by saazish of yahood o hanood o nissara though China is a trusted friend. Pakistan is also a leader of the Muslim ummah and provides security to them all over the world.

  • @muhammadabid1993
    @muhammadabid1993 Місяць тому

    Ya batain youthian ko kia samjhty hain wo to nak de kooka hi samjhty

  • @muhammadatifjav
    @muhammadatifjav 29 днів тому

    Trying to justify all the previous things vs what is happening now is hypocritical .. sorry not going to buy it

  • @theboringdaily
    @theboringdaily Місяць тому +2

    According to u,
    Lobbying in US = US ki gulami
    Shabash

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      Begging them to intervene is ghulaami. Did you hear the Imran Khan zoom call where he saying “Maxeen please give one statement”

    • @theboringdaily
      @theboringdaily Місяць тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience
      Grow up dude,
      جمہوری حقوق کے لیے سپر پاور کی مدد مانگنا غلامی نہیں۔ یہ بنیادی حق یے جسے ریاست نے سلب کر رکھا ہے۔ آئین پر عملدرآمد کے لیے مدد مانگنا غلامی نہیں۔ اپنا ہسٹری کا مطالعہ بڑھاؤ اور reasoning کو بہتر بناؤ
      مسلمانوں پر جب مکہ کی زمین تنگ کی گئی تو انھوں نے حبشہ سے اپنے "بنیادی" حقوق کے لیے مدد مانگی تھی۔ اس کا یہ مطلب ہرگز نہیں کہ انھوں نے حبشہ کی "غلامی" قبول کرلی
      فلسطین اور پرو فلسطین عناصر کا امریکہ سے مدد مانگنا، اور وہاں لابنگ کرنا ایک عام بات ہے۔ یہ آئے روز ہوتا ہے۔ جبکہ امریکہ بطور ریاست، فلسطین پر قیامت ڈھانے میں سب سے آگے ہے۔ اس کے باوجود فلسطینی عناصر لابنگ کرتے رہتے ہیں
      اس کا یہ مطلب نہیں کہ فلسطینیوں نے امریکہ کی غلامی قبول کرلی
      فلسطینی سارے یورپ میں لابنگ کرتے ہیں۔ پالیسی میکرز کو آن بورڈ لیتے ہیں۔ اس کا مطلب یہ نہیں کہ انھوں نے یورپ کی غلامی قبول کرلی
      غلامی کا مطلب ہے، قومی مفادات کو، کسی بڑی طاقت کے مفادات کے آگے سرنڈر کردینا
      جیسے،
      پاکستان کا ڈالرز کی خاطر امریکہ کو اڈے دینا، امریکی جنگ لڑنا، امریکی ایماء پر اپنے ہی علاقوں میں آپریشنز کرنا
      اسے کہتے ہیں غلامی
      بنیادی حقوق کے لیے کسی بھی قوت سے "اخلاقی" مدد مانگنا کسی صورت غلامی نہیں ہے
      آپ کی یہ لاجک قدرے بچکانہ، بلکہ احمقانہ ہے

    • @bravewarrior1218
      @bravewarrior1218 Місяць тому

      #theboringdaily Beggars can't be Choosers. USA was funding Pakistan by dumping $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$.
      Imran Khan, the former Prime Minister of Pakistan, did have a purported Zoom meeting with US Congresswoman Maxine Moore Waters, in which he sought her help and intervention regarding the political crisis in Pakistan.
      In the leaked audio clip, Khan is heard briefing Congresswoman Waters about the current situation in Pakistan, including an assassination attempt on his life where he was shot three times.
      He claimed that his government was removed by the former army chief, General Qamar Javed Bajwa, due to the military establishment's powerful influence in the country.
      Khan specifically requested Congresswoman Waters to release a statement in his favor, highlighting the "human rights violations" and crackdown on his party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI).
      He believed that a statement from someone like Congresswoman Waters would make a significant impact.
      Khan did reach out to the US Congresswoman, seeking her support and intervention in then ongoing political turmoil in Pakistan.

    • @akbalushi4779
      @akbalushi4779 Місяць тому

      ​@@ThePakistanExperiencechutiya hogaya he keya wo to benazir the ghid gida rahe the Musharraf ko nikhalo 😂😂 sab dekha he hamne baki hum hesa kareghe koi invest na kare bhikaristan me balke hum overseas wale Pakistani banko ka b boycott karenghe jab tak majority ke sunhe na jae or lobbying hum karrahe he imran Khan ke pass pesa kaha itna k wo Americio se demand kare wo to apke sabse favourite angel zardari dako k pass he

  • @muhammadnawaz3046
    @muhammadnawaz3046 Місяць тому

    ونڈرفل🎉

  • @lasthopetlpislamapnipowerr5916
    @lasthopetlpislamapnipowerr5916 Місяць тому

    TLP wali bat pr fazool baten ki hain Salman taseer k alfaz ja k suno phr usko sahi maara mumtaz Qadri ne aur uske bad pmln q phansi di mumtaz Qadri ko wo bhi foran??? Pakistan mn lakhon cases hain pr us case ko foran q nimtaya pmln ne??? TLP Haq pr thi aur h...

  • @fatihbutt_20
    @fatihbutt_20 Місяць тому

    Mind blowing❤

  • @HMGilani
    @HMGilani Місяць тому

    Black vigo pic when u speak too much. Epic

  • @SouthindianNarendra
    @SouthindianNarendra Місяць тому

    Where islam there is no democracy, so why to talk about democracy in Pakistan waste your time lets be happy under the army, police

  • @muhammadatifjav
    @muhammadatifjav 29 днів тому

    Such a hypocrite! Rehnay de. Bhai..

  • @world65pk
    @world65pk Місяць тому +1

    I am neutral but try to defend N League indirectly at all cost. Mian Shazad Shareef Zardari

  • @Aliarshad000
    @Aliarshad000 Місяць тому

    Pakistan la’ilaj h

  • @engrgopa
    @engrgopa Місяць тому

    nice presentation
    gopakumar
    India

  • @tanyas14
    @tanyas14 Місяць тому

    Your intellectual dishonesty is unbelievable.What a shame!

  • @fatehyabali
    @fatehyabali Місяць тому

    Bf

  • @srujithreddy335
    @srujithreddy335 Місяць тому

    If a question arises which election is worse then my answer would be the 1946 Muslim league. British establishment established Pakistan establishment 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @priyanka0299
    @priyanka0299 Місяць тому

    3 Generation lagte hain ek country ko nurture karne ke liye, aur pakistan ne 3 Generation Barbad kr diya . We feel sorry for Pakistan people

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  Місяць тому +1

      True

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому

      Well question is always with whom or what is it compared to...There might be some who think they have a better track record, but they are also not like a Scandinavian country by any stretch of imagination. The thing is, each country has it's own context...

    • @bravewarrior1218
      @bravewarrior1218 Місяць тому

      #Priyanka Pakistan army has never ever lost a Election but has lost all the wars fought with India,including 1971 East Pakistan was liberated...now Bangladesh.
      Election in pakistan is controlled by Army.
      Any Govt in Pakistan is not civilian, but Military Installed Govt.
      Elections are always cooked up to suit the military establishments.
      If all the option exhausts military will intervene and govern.
      Not a single elected government has completed its full term since 1947.
      The army failed in all its ploy and failed to restore normalcy in the country.
      Internationally pakistan lost its credibility and earned the label as a state sponsered Terrorist state.
      Pakistan army is keeping larger terrorist infrastructure intact.
      It is double game played by Pakistani Army In this world of wisdom; there will not be any buyer for these kinds of double game.
      The only option left for the people of Pakistan is to come out on the street and fight against the Army like Myanmar civilians are fighting their Army and Terrorism otherwise their future is ruined for ever.

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s Місяць тому

      @@bravewarrior1218
      BJP IT CELL IN FULL OVERDRIVE 🤣

    • @bravewarrior1218
      @bravewarrior1218 Місяць тому

      @@user-rh5jp2sh4s
      Why not counter with a logical reply ?
      🤡
      👆Never argue with stupid people; They’ll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
      😀😃🤔😉

  • @anambutt8127
    @anambutt8127 Місяць тому

    0:14 prakaar ? Is that sanskrit? Or you meant parchhaar?

  • @fatihbutt_20
    @fatihbutt_20 Місяць тому

    Agar civil war type hojati 2008 m to kya army ki deep state khtm hojati????

  • @DK_gkp
    @DK_gkp Місяць тому

    Islam m democracy h hi nhi...
    Islam follow kro .. warna sar tan se juda ho jayega...😂😂😂😂