How GOOD is Kim Min-jae ● Tactical Analysis | Skills (HD)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 тра 2024
- In-depth tactical analysis of Napoli's Kim Min-jae, a physically robust stopper who has attracted attention from Europe's elite but what are his key tactical attributes and more importantly... just how good is he?
0:00 Intro
0:17 Heading
1:23 Positioning
2:10 Ball Winning
2:59 Possession
3:48 Creativity
4:27 Dribbling
5:16 Long Pass
6:00 Goal Threat
6:36 Tactical Talkboard - Napoli, Manchester United
8:42 Conclusion (Overall Player Rating)
If you are interested in being alerted to our weekly content, do not forget to subscribe and turn on notifications. We also use our website and social media to carry out ad hoc player and match analysis. Always feel free to get in touch, we love to hear from you guys!
WEBSITE► www.pythagorasinboots.com
SUBSCRIBE ► ua-cam.com/channels/orF.html...
INSTAGRAM ► @pythaginboots
TWITTER ► / pythaginboots
#kimminjae #napoli #manchesterunited #PSG #newcastleunited
------------------------ DISCOUNT SOFTWARE LINKS------------------------
Join our Patreon for £3 a month, to get early access to all videos, exclusive access to Serie A, Ligue 1 and Portuguese League players.
/ pythagorasinboots
Get £200 discount off a Sports Camera which analyses your grassroots team and captures your match footage, allowing you to stream it live!
share.veo.co/Pythagoras-in-boots
🖌 Want to add impactful drawings and graphics to highlight your own videos? Do it with the KlipDraw telestration software that we use!
🎥 Learn more about KlipDraw and see the different versions here: bit.ly/35Z8Lq6
🖱 Get your own licence from our affiliate link here:
KlipDraw Basic 6-Months: bit.ly/KDB6M_PiB
KlipDraw Basic 1-Year: bit.ly/KDB1Y_PiB
KlipDraw Animate 6-Months: bit.ly/KDA6M_PiB
KlipDraw Animate 1-Year: bit.ly/KDA1Y_PiB
KlipDraw Motion 6-Months: bit.ly/KDM6M_PiB
KlipDraw Motion 1-Year: bit.ly/KDM1Y_PiB
-------------------------DISCLAIMER------------------------
I must state that in NO way, shape or form am I intending to infringe rights of the copyright holder. Content used is strictly for research/reviewing purposes and to help educate. All under the Fair Use law.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
If you ever wish for more information on visual or auditory terms, please click the link below:
gyazo.com/c9af2a6f21055902dec... - Спорт
You can access exclusive videos such as Kvaratskhelia, Leao, Mitoma & more + early releases & a Patreon members only access to our lively discord with many bright & esoteric minds for the price of a coffee a month, £3. Already nearing 300 members, hope to see you there. www.patreon.com/pythagorasinboots
جيد
KOREA
Japan HONDA🇯🇵,🇬🇷🏈
I'm a person who doesn't easily give someone the title of the best easily. But this monster is a real deal. He's very good at predicting situations and he's a great technician and a wall. Finding such a player, especially in the position of CB, is as difficult as finding a pearl in a grain of sand.
I'm guessing you have never seen Napoli's game full time. If you did, you would often find Spalletti nagging Kim to move the ball forward all the time, deal with the risk. It's as if he's not allowed to pass backwards. As for his strength, most people (likes of Cannavaro, Costacurta, Bruscolotti..etc) upheld Kim's split interventions, ability to read the game (anticipate the ball, break the channel movement, cover for his teammates' blunders).
김민재 대단한 이유 이번시즌 페널티 박스에서 반칙0 PK 한개도 없음 대단한 놈
He really does come alive inside the box. Penalty area maestro 👍
What you don't take into account is his speed, which allows him to cover large areas of the defense on his own. this gives the team a huge tactical advantage, as it allows the other defenders and midfielders can penetrate deep into the opponent's half. i think you've underestimated him too much, as this was the factor that made his biggest contribution to Napoli's scudetto. he should get 80+ at least.
His speed is mentioned on several occasions in the video especially the tactical board part. 80+ would be a gross overrating of is his ability
@@PythagorasinBoots While giving him less than de Ligt or Koundé is totally nuts.
@@mifjr9558 De Ligt is still only 23. Kounde rating is based on him being a RCB in a back 3 - as a CB in a back 4, he would not be rated higher than Kim.
@@PythagorasinBoots De Ligt is still 23, but Juve paid record fee for him and he did not live up to expectations at all, plus he's never been even close to level of this season Minjae. Kim is 26, but this was his second season in Europe, first in Napoli, Top 5 league in the world. How about taking this and some kind of adaptation into account? He played in China just two years ago, now he's best defender of Turkish league and Seria A back to back. But age doesn't really matter in his case, he's still novice in European football, he's still not at his peak whatsoever. He can improve and he will, but If you said De Ligt's potencial is 77, then Kim is def the 80. How can he be better at tackling than MinJae? Have you seen the stats? By the way there wasn't a single ball in the whole season Kim didn't go all out for as if his life depended on it, if that's not a true A+ mentality then I don't know what is. Plus I don't think you mentioned how good his defensive scanning, anticipation and the way he defends forwards' runs behind an offside line are. He's superb athletically and great at tackling yet what makes him really special compared to others is his inteligence and mentality that are just very rare and special.
I saw your points about dribbing reading score compared to Lisandro Martinez. Really, did you watch his peformance really?? jesus.
The mention of Phil Jones at the beginning gets me interested in how good he could have potentially been without those injuries, considering SAF compared him to Duncan Edwards and Capello compared him to Franco Baresi.
Another overrated ENG player
@@ericsohn5084 Another boring hipster
He had the heart of a lion tbh, those comparisons are fair
He was a great prospect, was pacy, strong in the tackle and in the air, and could also play right back and in the middle.
Like the guy said he had the heart of a lion, many times he was ready to die for United but it didn’t workout for him.
Really good analysis. First ever good analysis I've seen of Kim. I think the only thing to add is that his best attribute is defending his marker/their number 9/main goal threat. Kim can win against any number 9, at least from what we have seen. He killed Lukaku, Giroud, Salah and many others. I think he can handle Haaland, the way Rudiger had done. His 1 season at Napoli was better than any of the seasons Koulibaly had in Napoli. Kim was the reason why Napoli were able to play so offensively with a very high line. Every club he has been, he has been loved by the fans and hailed by their managers. In terms of pure defending, he seems to be one of the best in the world and would be the best defender at United and should be a 100% starter if he moves there. What he lacks though, is the non-defensive part of the game that the centre backs are asked to do in modern football.
He's also killed Lautaro, Milenkovic savic and Tammy (Although he's pretty average).
Thanks for that comment - very insightful
Thanks for sharing those observations. I can't wait to see how Ten Hag coaches him to become even better!
Really hope United buy him while the release clause is active lol this deal seems like a no-brainer football wise
2 points that you mentioned "Napoli's very high line" and "what is asked to do in modern football" these sounds like make no sense to me. isn't it paradox?
I would love to see you make videos about players that you analyzed then moved to a bigger club but didn’t perform very good. A “what went wrong” sort of video
Will consider this thanks for the suggestion
@@PythagorasinBootsSeconded on this. I enjoy your scouting videos and would put even more weight to them if you pointed out how scouting is an imprecise science and that you can be wrong about some things. I think it could help elevate your channel above others, more so than it is already
Like a dier… dier…. Dier…..
Great idea. Do this please @PyhtagorasinBoots
I am still glad that we still have a lot of young defenders in the game with potential. Pythagoras can you do some arsenal players like saka, martinelli and odegaard because of the great season they just had.
amazing video! loved it when you compared him to some of the greats. was possibly wondering if you can make a analysis video on them such as John terry, Jaap Stam etc etc
That "laborious" came out with a lot of pain that as a United fan can heavily relate to, hopefully we take the risk & it works out very well for us😅
The only video where the tactically only united were mentioned 😂 love the vid Great stuff as always
I love that you look past any hype, and assess the players objectively, both strengths and weaknesses. That’s why you’ve earned a new sub!
Thanks bud
Same ✔️
Amazing analysis as well Pythagoras. If you could go Gvardiol as well, that will be amazing
I was looking forward to this analysis and this was well worth the wait.
Amazing work as always 👍
Hi Pythagoras, thanks for uploading it here for free as well. I know you had uploaded it on your Patreon initially but players like Kim deserve the spotlight, Asian players in particular are often somewhat underrated.
Managed to change a few things from the Patreon version. Who knows, might still get taken down so share it far and wide to stay safe.
Seeing Saliba excel in the stats comparison with other good defenders gives me joy as a gunner. The boy can really go far in his career.
Need a saliba video, watching him you think he can go all the way
Really glad to see Ibrahima Konate in that comparison list, kid's got an amazing future ahead of him, would love a video for him as well.
Will add to list
he is a beast for his age
I think at least during the transfer window most of us would rather looking at the guys potentially transfering
Nice to see an unbiased view to make our own minds up
That's the aim.
Coming from a neutral who just likes to watch both clubs (bayern and napoli), watching them almost week in and week out, it’s pretty clear and obvious that kim is a much better player than de ligt is and the influence that he has on the team is immense, delivering consistently and many times carrying napoli on his back when kvara and osimhen does not perform. Don’t get me wrong, de ligt is a beast and I personally love him, but almost every single aspect when it comes to the game Kim is better at imo and it’s by a large distance. So is age a big influence to the potentials that u set?
De Ligt is nowhere Kim at the moment. We don’t give current ratings. De Ligt has a lot of room to grow and he may never do it but based on his Ajax days - there is a huge ceiling there but needs to be exploited and not guaranteed.
Current rating for De Ligt would be around 66. He needs to up his game big time.
@@PythagorasinBoots is this based on current performance or the analysis that you did of him 10 months ago?
@@PythagorasinBoots oh thats fair! love ur series and keep it up its really interesting🙌
@@PythagorasinBoots De Ligt became chief of defence at Bayern immediately. For sure he is the better player even right now.
@@botten418710 month ago will be nice but this guy’s analysis included Chinese league from 3years ago. 😂😂😂. Top of that, he is giving rate of age potential, he can’t predict what one player will perform at sustain age.
Great video analysis!
Great breakdown!
Very well tactical analyses
Seeing Dias top every single stat was funny. He's very good but Man City really puts him in a context where he can really shine stats wise.
Have to agree but he’s definitely had a good season this year
@@PythagorasinBoots considering he just won the treble and played a huge role in it, i think it's fair to say he's the best defender itw this season.
@@teikl3434he’s the best defender in the world in general.
I love your videos, can you please do an updated AWB analysis
Would love a video of Saliba in light of the contract renewal. Very curious what you guys think of him
I’m waiting this video thanks
This analysis is trying to view him through the lens of other players, but he is his own style of defender, and he’s the best in the world at it.
This channel always delivers high quality football content. I would love to see your review on Ronald Araujo (after the year he’s had) and Alejandro baldé.
WELCOM TO THE BAYERN .!
Great vid. Can you do vids for Colwill and Nkunku?
Nkunku out soon
I wanna say bro, I’m
Jamaican, your intro is fire 🔥
Big love to 🇯🇲❤️
You should do one for timber and axel disasi. Are they worth the hype or just more Phil jones
Amazing, could you do Julían Alvarez? Thank you.
I totally enjoyed that video! Thanks man! So ehhm...ever thought of doing an Alexander Bah video? Maybe Rasmus Højlund? How about a Lil Phil Billing huh?? We hav...i mean, those danes sure got some cool players outta nowhere huh?? Hella biracial dudes on that squad boi. No more Gravesen or Grønkjær with us these days...and by "us" i ofc mean them....stay blessed dawg 🤙
Rasmus Højlund is within the next 2-4 players to be made & you're taking me back to the time machine with some of those names ☺
@@PythagorasinBoots Yooo...just the contrast over a couple of generations. From scrawny (tho very technically gifted) Grønkjær, who i could legitimately (No bullshit) out sprint, out jump and out agile before i turned 18. To these dudes who at least athletically can match up to ANYBODY! I always enjoy your work dude 🤩 Højlund is VERY promising. But i would kinda bet on Bah over Højlund, to reach his (slighty lower) Max potential! Dude has really only played the position for 3-4 seasons, and he is already a very consistent, pretty well rounded, impactfull starter, for a strong CL team.
I'd say there is a solid chance of him being a top 10 RB, this time next year. Good vibes with this boi🤗
Love your videos mate. Just a heads up; it seems your closed captions are a bit off from what you're saying and what the captions say. Great stuff on this video though, followed you for about a year or so now :)
Thanks for the heads up. Not sure how to change it?
I like how you show the good and bad aspects !
Yes but then we get attacked by fans for daring to show weaknesses! Apparently we are haters!?
@@PythagorasinBoots It makes you more special.
Hahaha 🤣
I dont see why he would take a step back in his career and go to united. Bayern would be great for him if Hernandez leaves which it looks like right now
He was voted as the best defender of the season. In the SERIA A!
The home of defending.
Giving him a 68 Rating means that the rest of Seria A defender must be worst than him (< 68).
It doesn't make sense.
As the best defender he should at least get an 85+.
This isn't Fifa ratings. 85 in our criteria would be a GOAT
Hope united get him, he fits the profile perfectly and will compliment Martinez
So bench our best defender varane
@@gerald7351 varane is not our best player lol
@@fredtaylor7279 he is by far our best defended martinet with linderlof is a disaster that's why when his fit he played how can u even compare him and martinez or kim who I know u ain't seen even play more than 3 games verane the champs league winner world cup winner top 4 centre back in the world but let's move on you don't know football
@@fredtaylor7279 Casemiro is the best player. Varane easily the best defender
@@gerald7351then bench Martinez
How can I get the datasets of these professional players to analyse myself or do i have to collect these statistics myself
민재야 흥하자
To Bayern?
@@PythagorasinBoots IDK , there is no any news in korea haha. he is in military service now ^^ ;
최지훈 keep him safe for Man United please!
Finallyyy
Is he fast when sprinting?
We gonna need a quick defender to play high line
제대로 평가 한거 맞노?
Best analysis channel on UA-cam by far🔥🔥🤝🏾
Thanks bro
where is Lisandro Martínez ??
or Virgil van Dijk
from your list ?
im a barca fan so obv im biased but vitor roque or fabricio diaz one day pleaseee. love your videos
Hi pythagoras, when will you drop a breakdown of legendary players? It's been a while since you dropped the redondo one. And do you think scholes was intergenerational? You didn't rate him in your video.
I wouldn’t have Scholes in the inter generational bracket. Probably high generational. I’ll be doing more classics when I can do this as a full time job - nowhere near that at the moment 😂
Scholes was a magician .He would have slotted into any great team
Very good video. Could you do one on Levi Colwill?
Added to the list
Omo my God the defender I do want man united to get..you my friend know ball
What cb do you think would be better for united
Beautiful
Can we get a video of willian saliba pls
Curious, how do you decide which players to put in the comparison list? So for example, why is Konate there, but not Van Dijk?
Konate covers wider areas more than a Van Dijk. Van Dijk more a sweeper type so I tried to compare him more to secondary aggressive cbs who man mark more tightly
Mate, could you please take a look at the Nicholas Jackson lad? In a summer of multiple top teams needing a world class number 9, it's a seller's market. Just how good is he? His finishing looks world class, the deadliest in Spain.
He’d be a great addition to ETH
Kim is the real deal!
There has to be some correlation with his left footed passes and his right footed pass. Also, thank you for calling out Maguire's dawdling with the ball, essentially slowing the tempo.
Please make a video on vitor roque or Zubimendi
In almost all the statistics thats shown in the vid there's this one guy who's standing top.Can you make an analysis video of him?
Given the comment you made re. Kim not being an ideal partner for Martinez due to their lack of aerial dominance, could you perhaps do a similar video on axel disasi who they are seemingly considering as an alternative to Kim?
공중볼은 약하지 않다 단지 세트피스 상황에서 위치를 못 잡을 때가 종종 보인다 하지만 이마저도 그렇게 심각한 상황은 전혀 아니다. 그의 유일한 약점 중에 하나
When i need an in-depth analysis.. that will balance the hype out..
This is where i come.
Some other channels make it seem like a player dont have any weakness!!,
@Pythagoras in boots pls tell me is it not stupid to play Vinicious and Mbappe in the same teams
Make an analysis of vitor roque.. barca's target !
My friend played with him in Suwon tech high school.
Tell us more!
@@PythagorasinBoots Kim was good at that time, but wasn't greatest. Lim min hyeok who's former teammate from same high school with him and play for seoul now was better and had more potential than him at that time from what he said. He played videogame league of legend a lot back then and his tier was gold. He also had a girlfriend at that time but broken after he went to uni. He was funny so had many friends in and out of school he said.
Fan of your work bro . I would like you too recommend to add speed stats and comparison as well . Expecting inacio , gabri veiga , gvardiol , rice , van de den next . Thanks alot .
He's always outperformed expectations, always. But this time, the expectations are too high🤔
Please pro how good josk gvardiol and kovacic 🙏🙏🙏
With a minor bit of first-step coaching, his quickness will improve from a dead stop...
His speed is otherwise superb, imho...
Goooood
Great analysis. Would also love to see an analysis video on Jurrien Timber.
Your review is unbiased and has excellent analysis. can you review Kang in Lee as well? Thanks!
Thanks for the kind words. Will add him to the list to check out but can't promise anything with the current time schedule.
Hope UTD sort out their takeover, want to see him in the prem.
Would love an analysis on Axel Disasi
Bro is kim better than lucas hernandez?also do u think bayern is good fit for him?
김민재를 갖는자.. 천하를 가진다
Godlike analysis as always 🖤
However, I'm disappointed to see that Wesley Fofana isn't top 10 in any of those stats which theoretically makes him an awful defender. Did Chelsea get tricked again? What do you think sir?
He’s had injuries and dysfunction all around him. Needs time to mature and settle before being judged too quickly.
Pls do a Ramus Hojlund analysis. The links to Manchester United are heating up and haven't seen an in depth analysis of him on youtube yet
He's on the list within the next 4 players.
Can you do vid for alejandro balde ??
At some point in the coming season I believe he'll be made.
Please make a video on valverde and barella
Kim is Koulibaly's Successor for Napoli. Anticipates danger well and has the recovery speed to make up for positional mistakes.
If united get him they definitely need a new gk whose better on the ball to compensate for his on the ball weaknesses. Great defender though and would be worth the 45M release clause.
His medium-long range passing and ball carrying is not consistent but I wouldn't say he's weak on the ball, and he probably won't asked to do that often.
But regardless who United will sign, they still need new GK. De Gea didn't check too many boxes as modern GK.
@@dimassubrata yh my wording wasn't the best I did mean that long range distribution but definitely his conservation of the ball is fine. Like u said yourself in a way though with de gea it would be a strain to only have one player out of 3 who can consistently play long range passes.
@Shush ua-cam.com/video/4haAAaohR2A/v-deo.html is a compilation of kim's passing. Seems decent enough? (keeping in mind only successful passes are shown)
he is coming to bayern 😛
How would he fit next to de ligt? Would that be a good combination?
No both very similar. Does not look compatible. Need a ball player and sweeper type next to either
@@PythagorasinBootsso if Bayern would By Him he wouldnt be good next Go de ligt or upamecano?
can you do a anaylsis on andre onana
Can you please do a detailed analysis video on Gonçalo Inácio. I think more than Kim, Inácio will be a perfect addition to Man United's defence!
did anyone realise that Ruben Dias is 1stfor almost all of the stats between the defenders chosen
I would love to see an update because Kim wont go to Manu apparently but to Bayern. I recon he will be a beast next to de Ligt
What about Upamacano he is a better ball playing centre back than both of them so how shall he fit in
@@ayub460 More prone to fuck ups. Great potential but it has to show more regularly, also also de Ligt is WAY more likely to score as well as the best "Wall" defender of the entire league. Upa had some horrible games this season.
@@8asw8 he make mistakes however he is better than both of them on the ball
@@ayub460 Yeah I saw that against City,... De Ligt is the best out of the three, the other two can battle it out for the right to play next to Mad Matt!
@@8asw8 de ligt is better as a sweeper Cb that can score goals similar to Koeman however he is not as god as Upamacano with the variety of passing ability Upamacano bring in the game
Please can you do one on Josko Gvadiol
Sure on the list to do
Super
Pls review Arda Guler
kang-in lee please and how he could fit in man united if we sold sancho
psg
💛💛💛💛
You seem to underestimate the fact that Napoli is a super aggressive team. Probably the most aggressive team in Europe last season. When all your teammates are out attacking, it is much harder to defend. Also when your team don't even have a world class defensive midfielder such as Casemiro and your CB partner isn't particularly great like Stones nor Varane either. Kim covered the vast space via speed, anticipation, strength and tackling ability. Without Kim Napoli probably couldn't play like they did last season and Napoli won the league thanks to that aggressive tactics. You know how crucial Virgil is when Liverpool lost him and their defense collapsed. Liverpool was able to attack like they did only because Virgil covered all the threats. Same for Napoli.
رائع
Finally an honest analysis on Kim. Most analysts base their analysis on stats which can be deceptive (just like Fred's) and 2 games they watched. As someone who watches serie A weekly, my worry is I don't see him and Lisandro as a good pair as they are both aggressive
I think Lisandro will need to learn how to sweep otherwise agree could be too rash.
Onana’s incredible sweeping would complement them perfectly. He should be the #1 target to replace De Gea and I’ve said it for months. He is a world-class keeper and a better fit than Costa as he far more experienced.
@@bigruss7229 I agree, he's probably top 5 keeper atm. I doubt united are in for him and even have the budget. I feel Chelsea is a likely destination due to inter wanting Lukaku on a permanent
Or can you do Ibrahima konate please
Do one on Josko Gvardiol
Nice analysis but wonder why it's tailored for a Manchester United move, especially when they were never seriously in the race to sign him, also considering the fact that they are now definitely not getting him 🤔
How do you like the fit at Bayern?
As long as he is not partnered with De Ligt long term in a back 4, it shouldn't be an issue. That pairing would be too aggressive in the highest level IMO
@@PythagorasinBoots plus they are both no experts in playing long diagonal balls like Hummels, Boateng did
Please, where is the analysis 4 rasmus hojlund
Blocked by UA-cam- on our Patreon