Marie-Louise von Franz Shares Her Thoughts on Reincarnation: The Question of Identity and Continuity

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 67

  • @philosophy_schilling
    @philosophy_schilling 9 днів тому +36

    "How will I be able to know this incarnation is me?" I love her uncertainty. It creates so much space.

  • @christinabroadhead3810
    @christinabroadhead3810 9 днів тому +18

    I wish I could have met Marie. I knew what she was going to say a minute before she said it. She might be here visiting me...Perfect as the wind is blowing 104kl/h. and Merry Christmas to everyone. It shows how connected we all are. Just know it, how cool!

  • @Earthad23
    @Earthad23 8 днів тому +27

    “You” are not your ego, you are the awareness of it, eternally.

    • @jonhy.2024
      @jonhy.2024 7 днів тому +1

      🎯 maybe we fear loosing this sense of identity, but as you said this must come from awareness and not from some program running inside a machine we are using to walk across this Earth

    • @john.premose
      @john.premose 3 дні тому

      @@Earthad23 lol

    • @john.premose
      @john.premose 3 дні тому

      ​​@@jonhy.2024we are that machine, period. That is all there is.

    • @Earthad23
      @Earthad23 3 дні тому

      @@john.premose think harder

    • @john.premose
      @john.premose 2 дні тому

      @@Earthad23 why?

  • @francesluke7609
    @francesluke7609 8 днів тому +13

    Everyone is here, everything is now.

  • @Gneeznow
    @Gneeznow 8 днів тому +5

    Life after Life is a very interesting book, if you were to start somewhere that's just as good a place as any

  • @DiamondsRexpensive
    @DiamondsRexpensive 7 днів тому +3

    December 27 2024
    Relevant af

  • @msimons7440
    @msimons7440 8 днів тому +9

    I have this dream of an old house surrounded by untended rose bushes, the only access is a dirt lane. It gives me intense sadness and fills me with nostalgia, as if I am living in there or once lived there. Nobody visits this house.

    • @gabrielorville5334
      @gabrielorville5334 8 днів тому +2

      You could.

    • @DiamondsRexpensive
      @DiamondsRexpensive 7 днів тому +1

      @@gabrielorville5334 How? I have a similar dream about a house.

    • @Amanda1234-nqc
      @Amanda1234-nqc 7 днів тому

      Tis the past you have never let go of and the dirt road is the chaff you need to clear si you can smell the roses in all their glory. Let go 🙏🤞☘️

    • @msimons7440
      @msimons7440 7 днів тому

      @@Amanda1234-nqc Might be true if you subscribe to a linear timeline. I prefer to be a bit fanciful, and treasure the house and its exploration without 'what it means' . With all respect, the meaning is for me only, not for someone to interpret. Isn't this what Jung was all about?

    • @gabrielorville5334
      @gabrielorville5334 7 днів тому

      @@msimons7440 Good option. May I interest you in Robert Alex Johnson's "Inner Work" book. It's really helpful in giving a method for active imagination (which what you say is a form of it). Its useful to "dream forward a dream", and actually do something with it.

  • @matthiasmlk7
    @matthiasmlk7 8 днів тому +6

    Astrology shows that who you are, your ego, is based on the birth time, date, and place of your body. When the body dies so does the unique perspective that it possessed.

    • @kajwaverider9353
      @kajwaverider9353 8 днів тому +5

      We are not slaves to the stars

    • @matthiasmlk7
      @matthiasmlk7 8 днів тому +3

      @@kajwaverider9353 We could not exist without the Sun. Sol/Soul.
      Nothing would reflect our emotions without the Moon/Mood.

    • @djrg7921
      @djrg7921 8 днів тому +2

      @@kajwaverider9353 my understanding is we are slaves, until we develop beyond its control

    • @BrunoGarciaMusic
      @BrunoGarciaMusic 4 дні тому +1

      @@matthiasmlk7 the stars show influence over our human nature, but not absolute control.

    • @matthiasmlk7
      @matthiasmlk7 4 дні тому

      @BrunoGarciaMusic That's true. I didn't imply that they do. It's your vehicle, so drive it however you like. The inherent strengths and weaknesses will determine how far you can go though.

  • @jaimeXDgo
    @jaimeXDgo 8 днів тому +3

    Primitive men, and by that I mean the protoindoeuropean culture, thought of the afterlife as something linked with the memory of you left in others. So for them, fame and glory meant immortality, because everyone would tell stories about their heroes. I recommend Crecganford video on that.
    Maybe in jungian terms it means we sort of fade into the collective unconscious and we have an afterlife that's more or less privileged depending on how famous we became? I don't know, but I'd hate to see an afterlife where influencers are more rewarded than those who made a genuine effort to improve themselves and the world, lol.

    • @greentree778
      @greentree778 8 днів тому

      I have tried 🙂 it doesn't work that way either, unfortunately.
      if everyone would make the effort to try we would definitely get to our goal a lot quicker, it would require the sacrifice of this lifetime for everyone and that sacrifice counts for a lot more than you could know. but other than that I don't see any way to force a lifetime to be "the one", there are soooo many levels and there is so much work required in order to properly apply knowledge.

  • @Espiral88
    @Espiral88 7 днів тому +1

    From my own experience I’ve had past lives dreams and even felt the emotions with those lives. Been a Mayan, a doctor in the late 1800s, had dreams of being in the Victorian era. Been a native, a healer of some kind. Been around WW2. Met people who I once had a connection with in another life etc. Never believed in such things but I have certain inclinations to healing, medicine, spirituality etc that aligned with those past lives. I also had memories of being a Monk. The emotions were painful because I saw death and suffering. Funny thing when I was having these memories I came across Brian Weiss book, many lives many masters.

    • @curtrod
      @curtrod 4 дні тому

      fantasies are not memories

  • @malcolmcurran6248
    @malcolmcurran6248 8 днів тому +2

    If the identity of a common person fades after death and dissipates and is forgotten after about 60 years as Dr. Von Franz says the Chinese believe, that would make sense in being about two to three generations that are able to have known and remember someone. How many generations far back can most people trace or know something about one's ancestors with any certainty before home movies photos or now video.
    The great Hassidic philosopher Martin Buber was once at a conference of world religions where various faiths were discussing various forms of resurrection and reincarnation about which he apparently gave no opinion on the subject except to ask why we couldn't just pass and forego so many cycles and other lives and just make this one life we are living now the good one that counts.
    I couldn't agree more.

  • @bikerbobcat
    @bikerbobcat 7 днів тому +1

    I recommend to anyone to write down your dreams, illustrate it if you can. Over time you might find some consistency of place and people. Over and over again in my life I've spent days and weeks "away" in dreams, only to wake up just a few hours later, exhausted. It's so frequent I put together an illustrated magazine of the people, places and things I met "over there." Is it reincarnation? The afterlife? Does it matter? I still have to go to work and pay bills in the morning. To paraphrase Alan Watts, "When hungry, eat. When tired, sleep." That's all there is to it.

    • @msimons7440
      @msimons7440 3 дні тому

      @bikerbobcat The most down to earth and spot on comment here. Happy dreaming. Happy travelling. Happy biking...if you ride.

  • @raskolnikov1461
    @raskolnikov1461 8 днів тому +3

    She is a MASTERPIECE! So beautiful. Intelligence shines ❤

  • @lornemcneil
    @lornemcneil 5 днів тому

    Norman o brown ,life against death is interesting to read😮

  • @greentree778
    @greentree778 8 днів тому +1

    I think the reason we experience deja Vu and the feeling that we've been in places before is because we have, I think what we think are angels are actually extraterrestrials in spaceships above earth. I think based on our family line and our spiritual beliefs, our souls travel to them at night. I think which ship we travel to is based on these factors I have mentioned, and I think they shape and form our memories and psyches to their end. I think they run us through scenarios more than once so that we get it right, during a recent season of profound hardship i had the feeling in the midst of it that I had been through these trials many times before and was getting a chance to do them again so I can get them right.
    in the end I truly believe that we are all just cattle here, there is no love and there is no God worth knowing.
    we are all just food, we are all just used by some source that's higher than us. they use us for their ends and when they're done they throw us away.
    I very much believe this to be true.

  • @DannyLagano
    @DannyLagano 7 днів тому

    Someone said one time, 🤔 is it consciousness that is actually experiencing reincarnation. 🥸 consciousness experiences itself through many forms and suggests "I am" when the ego should be replying "I am not". Where does that leave room for the human interpretation of what the soul is, if viewed as something separate from consciousness. 🤔

  • @Sofi-Natasha14
    @Sofi-Natasha14 6 днів тому

    Reincarnations are written in genes, or rather - in genes are written our hormonal experiences caused by our strongest emotions - from fear and love to intellectual and creative delight ( in every life)
    Our character is woven in many lives - with different professions and environments.
    Our exceptional individuality evolves in many situations, sometimes - in hard events by karma.
    That's why we are all - such different.

  • @SarahD-s4y
    @SarahD-s4y 5 днів тому

    Anyone else creeped out how she explains accompanying several dying people and her fascination with the afterlife and the process of dying?? 😬

  • @brushbros
    @brushbros 8 днів тому

    Well sometimes I feel like I am getting somebody else's dreams. They are so clear, not frightening. Usually in color. My own dreams are usually monotone.

  • @Menofexcellence-gz5fq
    @Menofexcellence-gz5fq 8 днів тому +3

    We are everything and nothing.

  • @EPJS
    @EPJS 9 днів тому +6

    great insights

  • @kristine6996
    @kristine6996 6 днів тому

    I can’t wait to start my next life… 😄

  • @37Dionysos
    @37Dionysos 8 днів тому +2

    Even if "you" come back from human being as an insect, "you" are still an "I," a "me." What do you want to remember, the Rose Bowl?

    • @Earthad23
      @Earthad23 8 днів тому

      The center of the mandala

  • @Amanda1234-nqc
    @Amanda1234-nqc 7 днів тому

    Its impossible to evolve or ascend in one lifetime.
    Dreaming about houses is normally our bodies or states that we are in. Ive dreamt about the same house over and over throughout the years. Its been a warehouse, a derelict house, a graveyard, a mansion, a meeting place to be shown things.A place where I wash peoples dirty laundry, get it?

  • @giovanniamore2438
    @giovanniamore2438 8 днів тому +2

    i remember that and how i came here.. its not that helpfull.. life has a verý hard time with me.. 😂the river takes ýou with it effortlesslý, i have to swim all the time 😄 ..cause i cant accept anýthing anýmore 😊

  • @aleccullen2696
    @aleccullen2696 3 дні тому

    It's always wise to interview someone who knows the subject. Von Franz admitted up front she knows little. So why persist? A wasted opportunity here.

  • @MarijaMarijaMari
    @MarijaMarijaMari 7 днів тому

    ua-cam.com/video/_kgRFHaNo-Y/v-deo.htmlsi=6BpyTADnSqNcTiJ0