Kyle Kulinski vs Sam Harris 😮 Is Hamas Worse Than Nazis?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 кві 2024
- I review Kyle Kulinski’s pushback against Sam Harris’ Hamas statement. Kyle Kulinski criticizes Sam Harris for oversimplifying and misrepresenting the role and goals of Hamas in his discussions about Gaza. Kulinski argues that Harris's comparisons of jihadists to Nazis lack nuance and ignore important distinctions and context. He also highlights the severe humanitarian impacts on Palestinians and questions the morality of Israel's military responses. Kulinski accuses Harris of moral confusion and bias in his analysis.
💥 Contact Armin for live discussions: / arminnavabi
✊ Volunteer in our team forms.gle/FPGMJTHrVnpVe8pN8
🎨 Get our FREE Blasphemous Art bit.ly/BlasphemousArtBook
💕 Support Atheist Republic on PayPal: bit.ly/PayPal-AR
👉 Be an Atheist Republic patron on Patreon: bit.ly/SupportAR
📧 Subscribe to our Newsletter: bit.ly/AR-Mail
📗 Get my best-selling book "Why There Is No God" for FREE: bit.ly/AR-Mail
🎤 Leave us a voicemail here: bit.ly/AR-Podcasts
⚔️ HELP Us Defend Against Hindutva: gofund.me/f081c6ea
👨🏫 Get thousands of educational videos on Wondrium (20% off + 14-Day Free): bit.ly/WondriumFreeTrial
🔓 Get NordVPN at a huge discount: nordvpn.sjv.io/AR
👕 Buy Atheist Republic merch: bit.ly/ARShirts
📮 To donate by check, please make your check payable to ‘Atheist Republic’ and send it to: Atheist Republic, PO Box #69, Daly City, CA 94016
🤫 We also have crypto wallets for people who want to donate anonymously: bit.ly/AR-Donate
📅 Schedule a call with Armin here: / schedule-call-44515963
🔔 Don’t forget to Subscribe to our UA-cam channel: bit.ly/SubscribeToAR
👕 We now have a discount code for Atheist Republic T-shirts: bit.ly/ARShirts
20% off exclusively for
- our patrons: bit.ly/PatronCode
- and our UA-cam members (only works if you're a member): bit.ly/UA-camCode
🎧 Listen to our news podcast on iTunes, Stitcher or your favorite podcast app: www.atheistrepublic.com/podcas...
Follow Atheist Republic
⭐ Facebook: / atheistrepublic
⭐ Twitter: / atheistrepublic
⭐ Instagram: / atheistrepublic
⭐ Website: www.atheistrepublic.com
⭐ Discord: / discord
⭐ Twitch: / theatheistrepublic
⭐ Threads: www.threads.net/@atheistrepublic
Follow Susanna (Atheist Republic CEO, Ex-Christian, Ex-Catholic, Ex-Antifa)
⭐ Instagram: / tripledimpled
Find Secular Rarity here:
⭐ linktr.ee/secularrarity
Follow Armin Navabi (Atheist Republic Founder, Ex-Muslim, Ex-Shia)
⭐ Instagram: / thearminnavabi
⭐ Twitter: / arminnavabi
⭐ Facebook: / armin.navabi
⭐ UA-cam: / arminnavabi
⭐ Clubhouse: www.clubhouse.com/@arminnavabi
⭐ Threads: www.threads.net/@thearminnavabi
The views and opinions expressed here are the commentators' own and do not reflect the official position of Atheist Republic.
#Israel #Palestine #MiddleEast
Kyle Kulinski, on his UA-cam channel "Secular Talk," critiques Sam Harris's views on modern conflicts and religious extremism, particularly focusing on Harris's comments regarding Hamas and the situation in Gaza. Kulinski disagrees with Harris's simplification of the issues, arguing that Harris's portrayal of Hamas as purely a jihadist organization lacks nuance and ignores the broader political and humanitarian context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He criticizes Harris for making what he sees as overly broad and historically inaccurate comparisons between jihadists and Nazis, suggesting that such comparisons fail to acknowledge the complexity of the motives and actions of different groups involved in the conflict. Kulinski also highlights the severe humanitarian impact of the conflict on Palestinian civilians, questioning the morality and proportionality of Israel's military responses. Throughout, Kulinski expresses frustration with Harris's approach, accusing him of moral confusion and bias in his analysis of the conflict.
Sam Harris Says Nazis 'Benign' Compared To Hamas | The Kyle Kulinski Show
• Sam Harris Says Nazis ...
Secular Talk
@SecularTalk
/ @seculartalk
Sam Harris
/ @samharrisorg
@samharrisorg
Thank you, Armin. A reasonable voice in a storm of hate. Keep doing the good work ❤
Thank you Armin
"Christopher hitchens lost his way" -say whaaaat?? excuse me? but who is he to say ? What has he done in comparison to the man?!
Omg The audacity to say this about Christopher hitchens is honestly embarrassing
This was so necessary and masterfully done by Armin!
Thank you, Armin! Well done!
He complains that the nazis gets dragged in to it but what side has called and compared the Jews and Israel to nazis for months now? Did he object to that?
Thank you, Armin, as always.
Thanks Armin
“Arguing with idiots is like playing chess with a pigeon. No matter how good you are, the bird is going to shit on the board and strut around like it won anyway.”
― Shannon L. Alder
Referring to Jewish histories as "legends" is condescending and rude to their culture. Do you not know how many archeological discoveries have proven many of their biblical histories as accurate?
Dont lie,there are NO archeological biblical evidence.
Every discovery that proves again and again that evolution is a fact and that the universe is billions of years old destroys "biblical history " , whatever that means.
I learned from Nigerian Steve's channel that Hamas is killing Christians in Nigeria. That guy reels off the names of Jihadi groups I never heard of who are making terror in Africa; I don't have his channel name quite right here. (I am so ignorant about international stuff; it's one of the reasons I appreciate Armin so much....)
netanyahu supported and funded hamas.
@@nmc5657
Evidence?
@@jaz3023 can you let me know if you got my previous link? i can't tell what links YT does/n't allow through.
edit: looks like non-YT links will not go through. google "netanyahu propped up hamas" if you're curious. haarez, times of is rael, etc. (and plenty of other sources) have covered this.
@@jaz3023 ua-cam.com/video/2PeYDphtHYo/v-deo.htmlsi=SJRIazbXG4FhbiPJ
They are all from the same fee groups. All mainly funded by iran and qatar. And yes, they spent 700 years stealing land from christains throughout yemen and syria, ect. Invaded and and occupoed it all to this day. Their modern day attacks constist of economies. Theres plenty of info plus the entire ha mas charter available on the CIA website. And most on the list link together in some way. Nothing has been proven. These people are strictly reacting to propaganda and the lies theyve been fed by these people. They have vowed to end jews since long before israel was ever established. Their original founder who had a group called 'black hand' that unalived many jews in the 30's. Brittain won the land in WWII and established israel. The groups also were on the side of nazis. Oct 7. Then vowed to repeat it over and over until the job was done. Now crying to be victims. It was a Diff group, (same funder) but the same reaction, after 9 11. They immediately victimized themselves. They also su icide bombed several of US military during the pull out of the war in 2021. These people arent old enough to know much about 9 11. So the younger crowd fell in the trap.
We all know it doesnt matter how grounded in reality any of it is.
armin, you have to make a short condensed version of this video, and you have got to include the laughter in 30:30 its hilarious!
i told kyle to watch this. i hope he sees my comment. to me, anyone who doesn't get that hamas is intentionally trying to maximize civilian deaths is such a stupid person.
A couple of years ago I watched Kyle a lot; especially when Bernie had a chance at the presidency. I dumped all my lefty subscriptions when they came down on Israel & held Hamas high.
Indeed. This is why I suspect the internationalist left is dead. In its place we have... whatever his Fascist shit is.
Didn't Kyle became iffy when it comes to Ukraine and Russia though?
of all the crazy sh-- the left has been involved in over recent years, it was their take on a FOREIGN COUNTRY that finally led you to cutoff ties? that's deranged. why don't you just move there and get it over with?
I guess they never told you Israel was created by terrorist groups Irgun,Lehi and Haganah that were killing people before founder of Hamas was even born.
Me too
Me too. I'm feeling stupid for every minute I spent listening to these dishonest 'progressives'.
There is a revised Hamas charter form 2017 that tones down the rhetoric of the 1988 Hamas charter (according to wikipedia.) From the article, “While some welcomed it as a sign of pragmatism and increased political maturity, and a potential step on the way to peace, many others dismissed it as a merely cosmetic effort designed to make Hamas sound more palatable while changing nothing about Hamas' underlying aims and methods."
if you catch an ISIS terrorist and they wouldnt give information - of course you'd need to torture him.
saying "sam harris is pro torture" is such a stupid claim
its like saying "this man is supporting mass murder!! he said eating meat is ok!"
that sugar ray 1999 hair dye is seeping into his brain. and holy shit, if you cant grow a beard, dont even try
Great work. I went to bed leftist on Oct 7th and woke up on the 8th (sorry for the woke) rightist. Thank you so much for your work.
He dyes his hair white so he must be right,its so clear how can no one see it
This set of facts?!? What facts?!? He has presented nothing but claims and accusations but not one single actual fact or evidence that supports those!
They are all extremely confident and self-rightous considering they have nothing to back up their bullcrap.
What. Where. Who. Dude, you could check your own points, you lazy lefty. Thank you for bringing this to the table 🫠💔❤️
52:18 whenever I hear this argument about this being the deadliest conflict for journalists, sometimes aid workers are mentioned, as well, I cannot help but think it is probably even true. Not that I trust the numbers. But think of other conflicts, Sudan say, or the Tigray 2020 - 22 war with about half a million dead is an even better example. Most cruel war imaginable, but I don't think many journalists or aid workers died. Not zero probably, but close enough. Simply because there were practically no journalists there. The parties to the conflict wouldn't have allowed it, done their best to prevent independent journalists from going there, most journalists would have considered it too dangerous and the world public wasn't interested anyway. Very different in Gaza. There is a story the world wants and will pay to hear, so of course, journalists will be there in great numbers.
Early on, there was the claim of over 100 journalists dead. The issue with that in Gaza is that no one is working in Gaza without Hamas's approval. Anyway, David Collier investigated this claim and looked up those journalists he wrote about it on his website. It's called: "Exposing the lie about Palestinian journalists" It has a link to his report. It's quite interesting.
@@adigabai Thank you!
does every youtuber do a home alone face in their thumbnail these days?
Armin, much love to you, my man!
thank you Armin
Wow, thank you. I needed that. This person is so clueless and hateful.
Can’t take somebody serious that’s cosplaying as Ken? Lmfao
Very interessant
I don't understand how anyone could think Kyle is smart. If I ran into him at a store, and didn't know who he was, he would still sound dumb to me. It wouldn't matter what he was talking about. It could be the X-Men. It could be LeBron James. It could be anything. The man would sound like a fool. It's hard to have confidence in humanity, when all it takes is sounding confident to attract an audience.
Why do you think he isn't smart?
@@rohitballal5654 Because the counterfactual dreck Kyle is spouting off here is so blatantly and maliciously idiotic. Does that qualify as “stupid” or not? To me it does.
One thing that's fact is you can't engage in a constructive debate with Kyle, Yap you can yap here alone with half-truths, falsehoods, propaganda and myths all day long.
To address the original question… Yes for Hamas to have their way would be slightly worse than the Nazi model of “solution”. To flesh that out with some historical comparison, the Turkish genocide of Armenians was indeed arguably worse than the Nazi genocide of Jews, in that the Turks were engineering it to be as cruel as possible, torturing to death and bringing in others like the Kurds who had no interest in the killing. The German project by comparison was aiming for efficient elimination rather than to maximize suffering, as demonstrated by the industrial-scale execution systems they implemented. Hamas behaviors are very much in line with that Turkish model, a fetish for maximizing cruelty to Jews and anyone else who resists Islam.
Navabi 🐐
All addition of nuance and complexity makes it only more clear that Hamas is Jihadist. When Hamas requests nuclear attack from Pakistan, how is that not trying to make this conflict go global?
Don’t want to waste my brain cells listening to anything with Kyle in it, so I wish comments would say who they are quoting/ responding to.
Being a Christian, I'm no fan of Sam Harris, but how does someone like Kulinski even compare intellectually with him ?
He doesn't. Kulinski is a joke.
In some areas Kulinksi is ahead of him. For example Harris knows far less about politics and thought Bloomberg would be a good political candidate. Harris has also never had a job before
Interestingly the Palestinian 🇵🇸 issue only became a leftist cause when Israel 🇮🇱 became less socialist and moved geo-politically from being aligned with the USSR to USA 🇺🇸 .
it's also interesting how many conservatives became brainwashed into loving a foreign country. i see netanyahu (who funded/promoted hamas) is now telling the US how to police its children and advising our country on what type of speech to allow. what a prick. america first.
The famous HAMAS slogan "We love death more than you love life! That is why we will win!" -- that alone shows how HAMAS (and Jihadism) is, in fact worse than the Nazis. And that is not giving Nazis any credit. That they are not as evil as the worst evil in the entire human story is a pretty low bar.
I think all the bleach got to his brain
Kyle kulinski is such an obvious dishonest actor, he's unbearable to watch.
❤❤
Ahteist Republic, A correction :
Israel never provide Gaza Electricity for free.
The Palestinian Authority has financial arrangements with Israel with regards water and electricity Israel provides.
The Palestinian Authority actually Taxed (until th war) the Gazans for that.
That never was for free.
[I'm Israeli]
Read about the many arrangements Israel has with the PA authorities, there's a lot to understand about it and many people not from this region says a lot of nonsense because they aren't aware how nuanced and through the relationship Israel has with the PA.
Kyle Kulinski has no idea what he's talking about 90% of the time, not only when it comes to Israel Palestine, but in general.
he's married to krystal ball so lay off the gay assumption cuz he dyed his hair.
MEIN KAMPH VS MEIN JIHAD......beware of the struggle slogan.....think of other overplayed "THE STRUGGLE " excuses for hate and violence and evil????
Leftsplaining Jihad :) lol
UA-cam is worse than both put together and then some.
👍👍
Dude! when I see Armin rooting so much for genocide in Gaza I wonder how can this be.... but then I remember "hey this guy thinks incest is ok, so what can you do?!"
Georgia 🇬🇪 the country needs a better name, so it stops sounding so Anglo. Sakartvelo? Gruzinia?
wasn't Kartli the ancient name for Georgia?
The God delusion a good book??? Sam Harris is the most operated of the four horsemen. If there is no God, there is no good or evil. Therefore what's the use of debating?
Kyle’s opinions are always ridiculous. And that bleached hair color is clearly a midlife crisis thing. Just sayin’.
Midlife? Isn’t he like 30?
@@tidakada7357 36 but I had to Google it. I thought he was more like 39.
@@daheikkinen That makes it even worse😂
He's a hair-splitter.
Lmao Kyle has no idea as to what he's defending...so naive.
❤🎉 ExMuslims 💯🔥
He simply peddles for the Jew-haters which are many and easy to attract for the views and likes. You are wasting your time.
❤🎉 Without lies Islam dies 😢😮😅