How The Netherlands Failed At Housing
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 січ 2023
- How The Netherlands Failed At Housing
Support me on Patreon:
/ oliverbahl
Video by:
Oliver Franke
Research & writing:
Charles Street, Oliver Franke
Edit & Animations:
Oliver Franke
Full script & sources:
docs.google.com/document/d/1e...
The video doesn’t really explain why the Netherlands will fail at housing. It mainly focuses on available space, but there are many more elements at play here. Space is probably the least of our problems.
Also, you Dutch are experts at simply making more space.
We have so much space when you look at the farmlands yes. But just yeeting the farms away to create build more houses/apartments? Yeah the farmers won't like that.
It's not that we have a lack of space in all parts of the country. Here, in the "far north", at the edge of the city I can watch as far as 25 km over empty farmlands, where hardly anyone is living, except for a few farmers. And we have a lot of similar areas in the country, mainly close to the borders.
Houses cannot be insured as the environment: a sinking river delta system, is completely non-sustainable
It's a bit of a theme for this channel. He never actually answers the question in the title or addresses the actual problem
There's more than enough space. It's purely a political problem. About half the population and about 100% of people in charge are homeowners that have no incentive for cheaper houses (actually quite the opposite). Add some NIMBY's to the mix and changing the zoning of a piece of land to something that would allow it to even apply for a building permit becomes next to impossible.
Even with the recent price increase of materials, building a flat costs very little per home. We're just not allowed to actually do it.
Well said! It's a problem of willpower mainly. Nobody wants to piss off the minority that opposes new developments.
Socialist regulations kill every economy.
Ehm don't forget the green party's slapping a lot of extra shit on the houses like solar panels increasing the cost and building time!
You forget that home owners pay their taxes bases on the value of their houses. My taxes have increased by 80 % over the last 5 years. And I do not care about the profit value (overwaarde), because it is only on paper. I only cash in when I sell my house and start living in a foreign cheap country. The only house price rise I would like to see is inflation correction.
No. the government is responsible for building sufficient houses, art. 22.2 of the Dutch constitution. But has failed to build enough houses and rising immigration makes it worse. Yes, 1 million new Dutchies added in the last decade and they do not live in tents on the Veluwe national park.
The government has always restricted building outside of municipality limits. Except for a few Vinex new neighborhoods. But finally farmers are being kicked by nitrogen standards, so building of new neighborhoods will start soon.
@@mardiffv.8775 Hmm yes yes. I´m sure people don´t care about making money because they have to pay 0.45% taxes... Just to then move it to a different country where their money goes even further.... are you out of your mind?
As a Belgian we must say that the Netherlands is doing a very good job for us: young educated students are coming from the Netherlands because of the lower prices here.
Why are prices lower in Belgium?
@@bashdance they never stopped building
@@bashdance Belgium is very dense with houses, i think we might have no space left at this rate lmao
@@bashdance In Belgium there are less rules that protect nature. A common saying is "De Belg heeft een baksteen in de maag", in the past the government encouraged Belgians massively to build. But after the recent floods there will be more laws and in 2030 we'll have a total ban of building new homes...
It is also getting expensive hete but not at the rate of the Netherlands.
@@bashdance Because Belgium is not as incompetent as the Netherlands in the last decade. The Dutch are actually failing on so many levels, but because we still riding a wave of the decades before that was far more succesful for many people in those times, today most young people cannot afford a house not able to get a mortgage for one.
This is aside the fact that there are not enough houses for people to find. Hence the crazy rental prices. And this is just some of the many issues. We have a fairly good income on average, but plenty people don't have that and cost of living in the Netherlands is actually high.
And I don't think this is not going to be solved anytime soon
And yeah. Let's not fool ourselves how much we protect our nature in the Netherlands. The core of it all is still that we have the lowest forest cover in all of Europe with the only competition from UK both around 10-11% forest cover. Vastly below Europe's average. Oh yeah! but we have a park here and there!! Whoohoo. Yeah. Have you have been in a park where 100.000 other people are having the same idea to have a stroll? Nature in the Netherlands is a reasonable joke.
as a dutchie, I'd like to add that PART OF the real problem is the fact that foreign investment companies are buying up real estate by the hundreds of units, especially in Amsterdam and Utrecht, and then not doing anything with these assets and letting the buildings sit empty. There is no regulation against this. In fact the government ACTIVELY ENCOURAGES this. And don't even get me started on Mr.Bernard of the royal family who owns nearly half of Amsterdam and also has decided to leave the majority of the buildings empty rather than having them be used for their intended purpose. :)
owning a 2nd or 3rd house has nearly no taxation, it's high time this changes. no family should own more real estate than what they need, especially in a country that has a higher population density than India.
If they are investing they probably would like to see some returns...no way they are just gonna buy a property and then just letting it sit there without renting(or at least attempting to rent). Probably the issue is they are asking for a very high price, and maybe the apartments that are being built and bought by these firms are generally 3 beds which would be luxury given how bad the market is.
@@brownerjerry174 yes they rent it or let it buy for way more money... too expensive for starters
Exactly
So investors spend a ton of money on a house....buying it from a builder....so then the builder......DOESN'T USE THAT INCOME TO BUILD ANOTHER HOUSE???
Why not is the real question.
Government making it too hard for people to build.?
There are reasons.
This
Yes it is one of the biggest problems in our country now. And the government isnt doing a lot to prevent the worst case scenario. And thanks to dutch bureaucracy it is taking far too much time to build this many houses. I think they need to view this as a national crisis, like the post war period, when building lots of affordable housing was succesfull
At least there is some National scope to resolve these issues. We got thumbs in arses in the U.K.
@@bopndop2347 on the scope doesnt do anything really. There is talk about this problem. But talking about it doesnt do much, it creates an illusion that it's gonna be resolved in time, while thats not going to be the case.
Edit: there are some things that are done of course, but it's a droplet on a hot grill.
Total total lies. I've been to Holland, and I've NEVER seen a single homeless person ever. Stop trolling y'r nasty miserable lies about good and honourable Dutch folk
@@guff9567 Ever have been to Rotterdam South or West? You will see homeless and junkies in the evening and early morning, especially near local Salvation Army locations there are a lot of Junkies.
We got a law that prohibits begging or loitering. So most homeless people get clustered near homeless shelters and other social work projects.
And well, take in account that because we have the increased "vergrijzing", we'll be having too many empty houses in a few years that are still too expensive for starters to buy. And what also still happens a lot... A lot of houses are being build here, all too expensive for starters... *Facepalms*.
I really don't understand my country sometimes...
I studied at a Dutch University. Great education, but finding affordable student housing was indeed a hustle.
We got like 2 million immigrants... No shit there aren't a lot of free houses
@@julesverne4561 ngl fuck them we need to stop getting more people and make sure we have enough houses for the people already here 🤣
@@julesverne4561 More actually, people keep turning a blind eye to the reunification of the family. And those families aren't just one or two members but more like 15 or even more like in Germany where some families bring about 30 family members over.
@@If-Liberty-Means-Anything... Not really. It's really strange how foreigners post a lot rare cases and present them as common
@@balabanasireti Doesn't matter if some cases are rare when you take into account that in general, a foreigner has more children and relatives than a western person, so that means you can still multiply that immigration number by one or two.
In the Netherlands, our welfare state is on the brink of collapse when you can't even provide normal healthcare anymore, the same can be said for England. Both countries are swamped with refugees that feel entitled to everything, and most don't do much in return. Criminal numbers show most criminals are foreigners, and most people that don't pay for their healthcare are the same.
Bankrupting a nation to be altruistic is a moron's way of running a country.
I'm a romanian student studying in Eindhoven. Some really good friends of mine were planning on studying at TU/e, got accepted, did all the paperwork but in the end they couldn't come to the university since they could not find housing. They spent over 5000 euros in the process of applications/housing agencies, rent while they physically went to these agencies to find housing and so on. What a shame... As for myself, I did find housing, but the price is enormous. 1350 euros per month for a student is horrid.
There is a solution though... Rent something in Belgium?! Being 10 kilometers from the TU/e is an option? Not sure if they would allow people with no fixed income to rent though, but if you're paying 1350 EUR, you must have some income? So hmmm.... Ever considered that route???
@A Z sa mergi tu in fiecare zi 40-60km dus intors la ore fara masina.
@user-tt3yj4lt4u Ok, nu e nevoie sa ma jignesti. Nu, nu a fost o varianta. Daca era, o luam.
@@ABC-ABC1234 Right, I have searched on a range of 50km for around 1-2 months and this was the only place I found. I'm not quite sure you understand that I got lucky. A lot of student that were accepted at the university had to go back home in their countries because they couldn't find a place to stay that was eligible to be registered at the municipality.
@user-tt3yj4lt4u Inca o chestie legata de transportul in comun. Pretul ar fi exact acelasi daca as sta in alt oras si as face naveta. Lucru la care m-am gandit. Also, "parinti cu bani"? Muncesc full time si am propria companie.
I like how the video does not mention the exorbitant rents. Leaving in a small city, outside of the main areas still costs 800 per month for a small studio.
that's pretty ok, imagine you're in Spain with Spanish income and you pay 800 as well...
very true. It seems video is sponsored to not defame. I pay 2000 euro for a junk house.
800 euro? 😅 Where did you get that from? It doesn't matter where you live in NL, rent is high even in the remotest village because they can. Tax paying foreigners are taking the burden of Netherlands growth, but they're treated as slaves who live to suffer and build Netherlands economy.
@@marektoman 😬😬 is this u? That's horrible. Spanish salaries are lousy for some reason.
@@ardmrad9278 Those tax paying foreigners are paying 30% less then Dutch citizens. They are a privileged class. It is the Dutch poor who is suffering most. Social housing has a waiting list of years. Nearly all Dutchman register for social housing the day they turn 18.
The foreigner is not the foundation of the Dutch economy. They are also treated much better by the government than the Dutch poor. Especially in this age of libertarian control of government.
I hear this misconception being parroted everywhere on the internet, but the Netherlands are NOT the second largest exporter of food in the world, they are the second largest exporter of agricultural goods (mostly flowers and seeds for sowing), indeed in value, not in tonnes (flowers and good genetics seeds are expensive). I would be so happy if one of these days, at least one youtuber will get this right.
It is the largest exporter of fruits and vegetables, after the USA, last time I checked. (edit: maybe in value not in tonnes though, don't know)
nonsense. flowers consist of only small portion of exports. food product exports have far greater share. get your story straight!
I moved away from the Netherlands in 2017. I thought about moving back when my girlfriend broke up with me here in Austria. But after 2 minutes looking online I found out there wasn't anything affordable to rent. Even in the east (Gelderland) where my family lives its hard to find something good and affordable. I'll stay in Austria for now.
You won’t find anything here I live in Gelderland aswell right next to Arnhem and so far its impossible for me to find anything either lol
@@akiri4484 lol, I live in Arnhem. What are the odds? Pretty funny.
Vienna is something else when it comes to housing. Love it here.
@@UstaleonePretty high 😂 I live next to Arnhem too
My family lives in Doetinchem so I know Arnhem pretty damn well too! I also know it's really hard to find an affordable apartment.
Biggest problem for housing in the Netherlands is priced. Home ownership is heavily subsidized driving house prices up when There’s little to no new homes being built.
And rent isn't taxed. Because it's currently ran by landlords
Prices are the issue but not because of the subsidies. We always had those, now it is even at the lowest level.
ANd the immigrants get priority housing while the native dutch guy can wait 10-15 year. but no mention in the video about that.... wonder why.... cause with a population growth f 1.7 housing should not be an issue....
This is indeed a lie. In the Netherlands middle class people are allowed to grant their children one hundred thousand or so euro’s to help them buy an apartment. This is not a subsidy.
Ireland has a huge housing problem too and the government responded with rent controls (small landlords sold their rental accommodation) and incentives for investment funds to build apartment blocks (they built apartment blocks for rich international students and IT workers). Our housing market is failing.
Well the Irish government needs to finish what the English started and completely replace the Irish with vibrant diversity with authentic ethnic cuisine because diversity means strength. 😂😂😂
@@paddy9738 Aren't they doing exactly that which is why they have a housing problem?
Also the impracticality of building outwards instead of upwards especially with how garbage public transport is in Ireland (at least compared to other rich western countries). Houses literally in different counties are practically the only things available. The fact that the Dublin Metro Area, an area home to around 1.5 million people still doesn't possess even a basic metro line is honestly insane. Trams are lacking, the Dart only services the coast. All of this just means more traffic for people trying to get to work from their homes which are located like 25+km away. Honestly, the only solution for Dublin in my opinion, is to modernise the centre and start building some high density apartments. There's too many people, and while Dublin can accommodate, placing them in the middle of Kildare is hardly a solution.
Rent control is the worst solution to any housing issue. Building more units and incentivizing people to live away from the hot spots. The solutions are easy in theory but the difficulty is the politics around it. Government can try to increase more new units to be built but some residents who own homes might try to stop it (NIMBY) because they already bought in and don't want changes, especially if the change will reduce prices of housing units. Incentivizing people to live in other parts of the country or even other parts of the metro get tricky -- there will arguments of WHERE they should try to get people to move, HOW much money to spend and HOW they will do that.
@@paddy9738 what does that even mean?
Markets are crashing, inflation is skyrocketing, and the Fed is imposing large interest-rate hikes, while treasury yields are rapidly rising-all of which means more losses for portfolios this quarter. How can I profit from the current volatile market? I'm still debating whether to liquidate my million dollars bond/stock portfolio.
Even in the midst of this whirlwind, there are chances to be found, thus an increase in volatility is not always a bad thing. You can rebalance your portfolio thanks to volatility. Employing a financial counselor to help you with every stage of the process is the best course of action.
@@yolanderiche7476 That is why I enjoy having a portfolio-coach guide my day-to-day market decisions, because their entire skill set is built around going long and short at the same time, both employing risk for its asymmetrical upside and laying off risk as a hedge against the inevitable downward turns, and when combined with the exclusive information/analysis they have, it's nearly impossible not to outperform. I've been using a portfolio coach for over two years and have made over a million and fifty-seven thousand dollars.
@@lolitashaniel2342 that's fascinating. How can I contact your Asset-coach as my portfolio is dwindling?
@@edelineguillet2121 My advisor 'Stacey Lee Decker' she’s highly qualified and experienced in the financial market. She has extensive knowledge of portfolio diversity and is considered an expert in the field. I recommend researching her credentials further. She has many years of experience and is a valuable resource for anyone looking to navigate the financial market.
@@lolitashaniel2342 Thank you for this Pointer. It was easy to find her handler, She seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her.
2:21 that is a part of why they said this universety's and HBO's get paid per student so they actively seek out international students to use as extra money for funding its not just because of there being no homes available
This is a huge problem, indeed. The universities will not stop bringing in more and more students until this incentive is gone.
In groningen, my faculty had quintuple its intake in 5 years. There weren't enough houses back then, and there sure aren't any now, with everyone blaming someone else.
A student studying Dutch had to do her master's dissertation about a Dutch renaissance poet in English on the basis of an English translation. Dutch universities are basicallly being sold out. This is not about getting the most talented foreign students and doing subjects in English because the discipline is mostly in English. This is about dropping the education levels, wrecking the language and give Dutch students a disadvantage.
There are also a lot of problems with the neoliberal policies of the ruling parties as their privatisation of the housing market has given big (often times foreign) investors a lot of wiggle room in which it has become acceptable to see housing as an investment more than a need of the people. One result of that is the fact that these investors consiously keep housing empty to drive up the prices of their other properties in those areas. For example: Amsterdam has more empty buildings (around 20k last time I checked in 2022) than it has homeless people. The housing market has been broken by the capitalists. The housing crisis would be much less severe if landlords were to actually cooperate instead of only accumulate
" The housing crisis would be much less severe if landlords were to actually cooperate instead of only accumulate" This is fundamentally the problem with capitalism. They must be made to bend the knee or risk hurting our whole society with their evil greed.
@@zipzap8937 greed is anywhere lol thats not just capitalism unless all countries are capitalist at this point
@@-_YouMayFind_- I'll take missing the point for 100 Alex.
@@zipzap8937 it's the left wing laws and policies that have caused this....not capitalism.
There are plenty of rooms people would be willing to rent in the country. Except it's nearly impossible to evict someone now.
They can make as much noise as they want, smoke pot everyday in the house, bring as many people over at all hours of the night, and cause as much damage as they want and the government has no law protecting the home owner...who has taken on massive debt in order to feel safe and have their own retirement looked after.
Ive heard of this happening sooo many times it's a joke.
Students ALL could be housed just in peoples homes who want a bit of extra money to pay the mortgage. But it's not worth the risk.
The tenant has more rights than the homeowner. Period.
@@zipzap8937 it's tenants who are greedy, not hard working people who want to own a home and an extra one so they can retire and travel comfortably.
I recently bought a house in the Netherlands, but it was a bitch to find something affordable
What was your budget, and what place
Your own fault for being a pauper
@@guff9567 lol!
bugman mentality
You should have come here 5 years ago. I bought my house in Gouda for just 117,000 euro. The same house is now worth 265,000.... You just missed the bubble...
@@guff9567 you're just spreading negativity under every comment lmao
the problem with this video is that it's based on Rotterdam and Amsterdam. In cities like Groningen or Amersfoort , there are huge grow potentials.
Groningen unfortunately has the same issues. It's nearly impossible to find a place as a student (we've had students sleeping in tents, for example, and there are emergency places for students every year), and now that I'm 26 and have a job, I'm still struggling to find my own place. Buying a house is too expensive, vrije sector prices are incredibly high and there is a serious lack of sociale woningen. But I do think that you're right about other cities having potential! I also think that it would help if we converted empty buildings into living spaces.
@@meowrit We should definitely turn empty buildings in living spaces. Why not build cheap small homes like university dorms where hundreds of students can get a home. You're right about Groningen being chaotic as well. I think all the studentensteden are becoming overcrowded with too little opportunities for small affordable housing. Delft is also struggling with housing its students. They even tell foreign students to stay away because of the housing issue.
im paying 1065 a month in centrum of Amersfoort for my studio 44m2. It doesnt look promising at all
Amersfoort is crazy expensive and BORING
I used to be a homeless student in Groningen... really gives a true perspective
I’m homeless right now and I have a job
@@RoarofdalioN How do you work while homeless?
@@raymondwald5864austerity politics.
I'm also a student in Groningen. Finding a room was hell
I was homeless in Breda for 4 months and it was mentally quite draining, to be honest. In my class, if 90 dozens of people were homeless for at least a month
space isn't really the issue, it's the politicians.
And immigration. It's funny that this isn't even mentioned anywhere in all these comments. This year alone over 100.000 people have migrated to this country. The past 10 years we broke record after record in terms of immigration. And now there are shortages? Imagine that.
@@WhoopsieDayZ very simplistic and populist take. You forget to mention that students where taken in but no housing was allocated. This wouldn't be an issue if they would've build better and smarter. And privatized less.
@@JJadx Hardly populist, it's simply observing what's happening. Immigration is the biggest problem, period.
@@Pietra430 true, that's the basis of populism. Hitler was "observing what happened" jews = rich, others poor = jews problem. While in reality banking was an dirty job in the middle ages and they where forced into it. Populism is looking but not seeing. Baudet won in the provinciale staten yet he didn't take his seats. He doesn't have to, his voters don't even know how it works. So he throws away votes like spoiled milk and catches new ones the next session. He perfected playing the lower classes for big $$$. He's just as bad as the VVD & groenlinks.
@@JJadx Why do you people go through all these mental gymnastics just to keep importing non educated refugees and
Poles? Why do you want this so much? Explain your fetish.
You're really skimming over the details here. There is a whole other video of room with details here. The biggest cause for the housing crisis in the Netherlands is what we call the "stikstofcrisis" or Nitrogen crisis. Simply put, every municipality has a nitrogen budget. To build all forms of infrastructure, be it houses, roads of nature reserves, they are required first to reduce emissions of nitrogen, before being allowed to "spend" nitrogen in their budgets. On top of that, they have to reduce nitrogen emissions across the country by up to 70% in places. All to preserve the biodiversity across our nation. This means in effect, that both farmers and industry have to be closed, before being allowed to spend the emissions room thus created, on housing or roads.
Naturally, people don't want to hear that they are out of a job because their company produces to much pollution. And thus the national politicians in the Hague don't want to burn themselves on the issue. And so they have forwarded the hot potato to the municipalities. Again, they do not want to burn themselves on the topic either and so the blame has shifted to the provinces. By summer of 2023 the provinces have to come up with a province wide plan to fix the problem of nitrogen emissions. However, to make it even more of a political problem, on march 2023, the dutch public are asked to vote for the provinces political parties. Usually people care very little about this particular vote and typically only about 30% of the nations voters show up for it.
On top of that, it's usually the left side voters who want to change things and they vote in favor of solving the "stikstofcrisis" by removing businesses and farmers based on their emissions, and right side voters who want to keep everything the same. But with the past 12 years having had a center and right wing government in place, and this being just 1 of the many issues that the Netherlands struggle with, there is no telling what the voters will do. This entire crisis was in fact started by the courts. In the Netherlands, the courts can overrule the government and political parties if the government doesn't follow its own rules. The government has forced itself, partly by European laws, but also by its own laws, to reduce emissions, and are now forced to act upon it.
How is the Dutch government 'right' when they follow literally every left idea(l)?
The housing crisis isn't caused by the nitrogen crisis at all, it's much older. We've been discussing it for 15 years now.
Also, saying that it was "caused by the courts" followed by an explanation of the rule of law every democracy has is very odd.
To be clear, it was caused by the agrilobby and Henk Bleeker, who devised an illegal policy that came down to "you don't actually have to keep your emissions down, you can just pinky promise you will do it in some far off future land"
@@koffiegast They don't follow a single leftist idea, and the only people who say that are far right maniacs.
@@koffiegast VVD is a center right party, D66 are a centrum party, and CDA and Christenunie are both right wing christian based parties. Notably, both CDA and Christenunie are parties supported by many farmers and Christians and so called "silent majority" voters.
As for left ideals, we have plenty of ideals left that aren't on the agenda of the current cabinet. To name a few, we would like the government to stop subsidizing fossil fuel. We would like public transportation to be free of charge. We would like a solar panel on every roof, including social housing. We would like to tax fossil fuel emissions, and subsidize electric driving and infrastructure. We would like to tax people equally, which would make rich people pay more, and poor people to pay less. We would like to make healthcare costs to be dependent on income so that everyone can be treated equally. And the list goes on for a while, but I'm sure you get the gist of it.
None of these ideals are currently part of the plans of the current cabinet. Instead, they subsidize fossil fuel companies for 17,3 billion euro's a year. Electric driving subsidies are being reduced every year, and they also want to reduce subsidies for solar panels. They let economy rule over people. Straight from the VVD book. And with both CDA and Christenunie refusing to even talk about the stikstof crisis and what it entails, it gets very hard to fix some of the biggest problems this country faces.
@@MartinDeHill I didn't write it was the only cause, just that it is currently the one thing that stops everything else. We're not allowed to build new houses, or roads, because of the Nitrogen crisis. And until that gets resolved, there won't be any new houses built in the Netherlands. I see this issue every day, there are 2 large plots of land in my own municipality that have been ready for building for over 5 years now. Going all the way back to the courts decision of 2017. The plans are all ready. The plots have been sold. But nobody can start building there, because there is no room in the Nitrogen budget of the municipality. None of the right wing parties of my municipality dare to touch or even talk about the subject, for fear of voter backlash. In the municipality i live are very few farmers, but there are plenty of companies that produce to much nitrogen. The only way to fix the nitrogen crisis is to close companies, which will cause thousands of job losses, and thus, nobody wants to move on this for fear of voter backlash. And so they pretend its not their problem, and pass the hot potato to the provinces.
*With markets tumbling, inflation soaring, the Fed imposing large interest-rate hike, while treasury yields are rising rapidly which means more red ink for portfolios this quarter. How can I profit from the current volatile market, I'm still at a crossroads deciding if to liquidate my $120,000 bond/stock portfolio*
True, the US-Stock Market had been on it's longest bull-run in history, so the mass hysteria and panic is relatable, considering were not accustomed to such troubled markets, but as you mentioned there are avenues lurking around if you know where to look, l've netted over $650k in the past 8 months and it wasn't some rocket-science strat. I applied , I just knew I needed a firm and reliable technique to navigate better in these times, so I hired a portfoilo advisor.
that's impressive! I could really use the expertise of this advisors, my portfolio has been down lately....who's the person guiding you?
financial advisor is 'Jackson Sten Marsh'. I found him on a CNBC interview where he was featured Afterwards I reached out to him. he has since then provided me with entry and exit points in securities I focus on.
From January effectively all universities stopped active recruitment of foreigners, but they have jointly stated their disapproval. At my university in Breda, it's a growing problem that students cannot start the academic year as they have no accommodation. For me, it took till December till I found a place, some rooms have 600-700 applicants within a day.
That’s interesting, and I’m happy I managed to sneak in a year before they got the idea to stop bringing internationals in
Its good if universities can build student housing for 50% of the students who seek rooms. That would take pressure off from the market
@@dominicj7977 They have none, let alone enough for half of the seekers.
@@Vikkin1218 Seems strange. I’m new here and I was advised to not look for rooms on university tows.
But in my home country, universities have hostels for students where a certain percentage of them can reside and study.
As a Dutch student being in your mid 20s and having to live at home is mentally tough. My college is in the most expensive city I the country so I can either pay 600 for 1 room or stay at home and help my mom out. It's still funny that we had leave our home and live in an overpriced shack in a shit part of town while young refugee men get newly build homes right across the house we were kicked out of.
Oh no, white dutchie is struggling while inferior refugee is not. Unacceptable!
@@Unteragen-rg1so I mean, yeah. The country shouldn't be importing any immigrants at all if they can't provide enough housing for even their domestic population. The insane immigration rates that have existed for decades are the main reason why cities have a housing crisis to begin with.
I think i need to move to Denmark, im 18 and live in the Netherlands, I study but i have to live with my parents. Even if I finish school there is no place to live
Leave then mate
I studied in Aarhus, Denmark and it was honestly no better. I got lucky with a student apartment but some of my friends had to live in trailers for months until they found some accommodation. This was a few years ago so maybe things are better now, I don't know. I have since moved to Sweden, and things a only slightly better here.
@@julesverne4561 Sounds simple but it isn't
@@julesverne4561 sure, but how?
@@REDnBLACKnRED sweden is really cool too
"Will fail" implies it will happen in the future, except it has already failed for over 15 years.
Houses are simply unaffordable for the large majority of the populace and it's become just a way of investing instead of providing a primary need.
The biggest problem is migration. In 2022 the natural population growth was -1000 but the population did grow with 227,000 because of immigration
The Netherlands is already failing at housing my brother is almost in his 30s, and he still lives in home, though finally he might see his own house soon.
I am an international student and was homeless for 3months in 2022, horrible experience, very glad I was with a car
Go somewhere else. This country is not for you it is for us.
We’ve been failing for years. And a big part of it now is the way the system admits houses to people.
For anyone under 23 it’s nearly impossible to rent a place let alone buy one.
Yet most of the stuff being built these days is purchase houses and not rent.
You have to be 23 in order to gain back a part of the rent you pay which for a lot of people is a huge part of their income.
I’ve been signed into a housing market site since I was 18 which was 3 years ago and I’m still nowhere near a chance of finding an apartment for these reasons.
It also doesn’t help that refugees get priority on even some of the most high end apartments availible.
And all the government does is build new properties that won’t be availible for lower incomes and increase the prices
Change your government. Remove any socialism in your country release free-market.
@@montazownianr1 ngl a bit less socialists/enviromentalists in the gov would do wonders for this situation...
@@montazownianr1 The party that has been in power for the last 12 years is THE "free market" party of the Netherlands. It isn't working
@@montazownianr1 The party that has been the main one in the last 3 governments plus the current one (the right-wing, neoliberal VVD) has done exactly that: removed legislation for housing cooperations, opened up the housing market to foreign real estate investors and gutting social housing. For a large part that method is why we're in this shit state of affairs. I'm not necessarily saying throwing more government involvement at the problem will magically help, but the famed invisible hand of the free market hasn't done ordinary people any favours.
(and not to be overly snark, but if a response includes the argument ''socialism is when government does things'' I'll assume you don't know what you're talking about)
@@thomaskole9881 Nooo, everything decent is socialism. Let's trust rich people...
If 65% of the country is farmland, while 10% is homes, it seems that they have no shortage of land at all. Converting just 5% of the land from farm to homes would increase relative livable space by 50%? Reducing farmland from 65% to 55% would literally double livable space. I'm sure there's more to it, but these zoning laws were created early 20th century to assure national food security, which seems incompatible with how current markets work and how large the current dutch population is.
We don’t want to destroy our beautiful landscapes just so that a tiny minority of privileged progressive whites can continue their addiction with importing hundreds of thousands of non educated Africans, Arabs and Slavs.
Unironically, with a law against unexploited land you could see a lot of the "farmers" just giving up the land because they can't do anything with it. But even then, unless there are proper protections against free market exploitation the crisis won't get much better.
Without rich parents you're screwed
This is for the whole world not just the Netherlands.If you are poor and you coming from a working class background you are fucked up....
It’s interesting to see other countries losing people(age or migration) and have issues with abandoned properties while the Dutch have it flipped.
Yep. Bulgaria is filled with ghost towns. I think the majority of small towns are ghost towns now.
You didn't really explain why. As a planning student, studying in Groningen, the reasons are quite a lot, and would need a long video. Starting from Dutch architecture to the Netherlands becoming an economic powerhouse and to the consequences of the 2008 financial crisis.
I am also an urban planning student i think its also do rules an burocratics of the goverment
The problem is using existing space. On the south of Den Haag (and any other side of den Haag) for example, there is new housing development - "DUYN - Half vrijstaande woning" twin home for just 880k Euros. Few of them take up space of an apartment complex that can accommodate from 40 up to 200 separate families(I now live in the 12th-floor apartment complex with roofed parking space and 160 apartments in total where you could probably fit 20 tight-packed single-family housing). And these new housing developments are popping up everywhere, instead of building affordable (800k euros is not affordable at all) apartment complexes they are fulfilling rich people's dreams.
And now Dutch gov want to seize agricultural land to make more not affordable housing - a genius idea when we could have food shortage/expensive food.
In Groningen they do build a lot of small apartments, so I could give you ample of examples why your picked example isn’t really true over the broader approach to this problem.
Besides, the farmers in the Netherlands that will be bought out are mostly animal farmers. They don’t sell a lot to the Dutch people, mostly to other countries. We for example import beef from South America.
We would barely notice that farmers are bought out, but nature will definitely improve
800k Are you realistic?
@@ECTCalvin i do not think that a lot of people want to settle in Groningen, but most would like Randstat.
I just showed my point of view in the area, in example rijswijk buiten, New developments in Rijswijk Strijp and many others are just single/twin or in the line single family housing. I bet you could fit there many of apartment complex that would help in solvong the problem, because this approach will for sure not.
@@ECTCalvin Not if all that space is built on.
You're not addressing the elephant in the room. The area of the Netherlands isn't shrinking. The population isn't increasing, Dutch women have far fewer than 2,1 children on average, so the population actually shrinks. This problem has only 1 problem: immigration. Every year, another hundreds of thousands immigrants enter this country, to the point that it doesn't only cause a lot of social frustration as the integration failed, but there also just isn't enough physical space.
They should stop taking in refugees until there is enough housing for dutch youth, then for refugees waiting for a house in the country and only when that is fixed take in new ones. Also people should be getting priority for a house in their 'home region' so they can stay closer to family, work and friends. What happens now is that rich seniors sell their Amsterdam apartments and buy family homes in rural areas for 'cheap' leaving no place for local youth to go.
It's not just refugees. It's immigrants in general. The vast, vast majority of immigrants are not refugees. Even most proclaimed refugees aren't actual refugees.
Interesting video. In regard to certain things, the Dutch can be divided into 2 clear groups, the social/subsidized housing (rent), and the private market (rent and buying). A third of the market is social housing, which is a very high rate compared to other countries. Meanwhile, the other 2/3rds are private. Both have their own set of issues. There is a lack of social housing due to massive demand and not enough being built as it is much more lucrative to build private market houses (also caused due to the outrageous prices). This means very long waiting times, and meaning that if you are in a non-urgent situation (for example staying with your parents is considered a stable living environment in most cases so you won't get any priority) you can wait a decade. That is not sustainable. Due to the massive price differences between the capped prices of social housing and uncapped prices of the private market, many people stay inside their subsidized apartments even though they already earn far above the income threshold. So a lot can be connected to the massive costs in the private market, but the problems are not the same.
To tackle these issues the government is actually putting a lot of money towards building additional homes, both in the private market and subsidized market. There need to be better incentives for companies and municipalities to build more subsidized housing over the private market, but there is a shortage in both. Luckily the market is cooling down again a bit, leading to lower prices, but this could also lead to lower demand to build additional homes, so the government needs to tackle that problem decisively. The biggest problem currently is probably not incentives, but the difficulty to build new houses and capacity. This is due to very strict regulations, on top of new strict laws around nitrogen emissions. It takes a very long time to get approval and due to very tight rules, it is also difficult to get approval. This process needs to absolutely be dealt with if the government wants to reach its goals. There need to be more government employers to deal with permits so that approval can happen much more easily and quickly. Lastly, there is the problem of labor capacity. There is a huge lack of construction workers in The Netherlands, so these workers will need to be found in other countries (Eastern Europe). That process should be made easier, but an argument against that is that you are adding to the problem. As you are taking in more immigrants to fix a shortage of homes, but all those immigrants need homes as well, leading to an even greater shortage in the end.
To tackle the problems of the missing middle between the private market and social housing, the government will introduce new homes with capped rental prices called "middle rent". That means it will be divided into "low rent" (social/subsidized rent), "middle rent", and the private market (renting and buying). Also, the government has a plan of building around a million additional homes by 2030. They have made a lot of funding available to reach that goal, but there are some massive challenges along the road which I mentioned above. Space is not really a major issue really, only around 13% of The Netherlands is covered by build-up areas (including industry, semi-build-up areas, etc.). A problem could be that a relatively large share of the Dutch population lives in single-family homes instead of apartments which are also relatively large (for Europe), even in highly urban areas. Many Dutch are opposed to living in apartments. Even though multi-generational homes are not really a thing here, there are relatively few people per household in The Netherlands. That leads to a very high living space per person in The Netherlands (65 m2 per person), and the quality of (new) housing stock is very high which makes things extra expensive. Maybe that is just a luxury we cannot afford in one of the most densely populated and in-demand countries in the world if there already is a massive shortage of homes. Also, keep in mind that around 70% of the population lives in a home that is owned, so they don't really have any interest in decreasing house prices. Most incentives go where the demand is, and those are the 300k to 500k relatively large private market single-family homes with a garden in an urban area. Not really sustainable, but that is what most people want. But in the end unsustainability like that makes it worse for everyone.
Also wouldn't set your hopes on the population stagnating. The population of The Netherlands grew with nearly 230k in 2022 even without natural growth. Whenever excess death decrease again I fully expect natural growth to be slightly positive or around 0 again, but immigration will stay high. Eventually, the baby boom generation has mostly died off and after that the share of elderly people will stagnate, meaning slightly higher natural growth again. In the end, the statistical models from Statistics Netherlands show that the coming 50 years the population of The Netherlands will keep on growing under standard circumstances. We need to prepare for that, so also with our housing stock.
I don't worry too much about the water problems. It is one of the few areas where the government never sits back and lets things happen and fix them afterward, they tackle these problems proactively since the Delta projects under the new Deltaprogram which has to make sure the Netherlands is prepared for climate change and droughts (water shortages). With the deltaplan for large rivers including the room for the river project. The program will also include the "hoogwaterbeschermingsprogramma" (HWBP), which is the largest dyke strengthening operation since the deltaworks. It will tackle the most critical areas first and ensures that The Netherlands will be adequately protected by the norms of 2050. So all dykes will be upgraded to that norm and inspected every 12 years and strengthened when necessary. The HWBP program always looks at the medium term looking 30 years forward with their inspections. Short-term supervision is the responsibility of waterschappen, and there is also a long-term vision.
Just want to second this. My neighbour is a social renter but drives a porshe... So makenofnthat what you will
Very informative
don't you have anything better to do with your time? I don't even wanna know how many characters this is. Learned a lot tho. I study at KU Leuven in Belgium and the housing there is really affordable - for Western Europe standards. I pay 350 euros per month for a student housing unit with a shared kitchen. Had no idea it was this bad in the Netherlands.
Really appreciatte your comment. Good analysis.
Good analysis. I would also add the low interest rate and easy borrowing of the past years and also the money printing by the government wich caused high prices for house. Excellent points made by you!
I got super super lucky with finding a room that's at least under the 800 Euro range and taking into the account the amount of expensive apartments along with internet scams it just adds to the stress, coming from indonesia and never been to Europe at all it nearly crushed me when I got accepted into a tedious numerus fixus university program and not being able to find housing or any type of housing whatsoever.
I got lucky enough to find the room through connections within the Indonesian community and seeing how my expat friends within my program even my dutch friends as well struggle to find housing made me feel super super grateful. It's kinda really saddening to me that up until now since I moved into the Netherlands from September 2022, some students back home are still asking around for housing in the community WhatsApp or group chat.
Hopefully the dutch government will prioritize the housing crisis or try to resolve it as much as they can otherwise students similar like myself will miss their chance of studying in a wonderful country like this.
Everyone keeps mistaking food export with agricultural export. Flowers are high value export. Also, we are a net importer of calories.
Haven't we known since the Victorian era that living spaces smaller than 79 square meters are detrimental to human health?
bruh im living in 46 square meters, i feel not bad but i rly would love to live in a big apartaments
True
As an American who was planning to move to The Netherlands I aborted my plans last year when I learned just how bad the housing crisis was.... it was kind of shocking since The Dutch are known for being the best planners in the world and having really good foresight but it seems this is a problem that has been building for the past decade or more and has now reached a critical point.
Amsterdam though is no longer affordable unless you're wealthy. Rotterdam is becoming the same. College students are really struggling and non rich Dutch are not happy either. A few UA-camr's I had been following even moved out of the NL. I love The Netherlands but living there long term would not be feasible or affordable most likely. Now I'm researching moving to Germany and Scandanavia instead.
Germany is going throgh the same development like NL. NL is just a few years ahead. In Germany there are many regions, where you can not find any affordable house anymore. In 3-4 years this situation will be probably in all areas of the country.
Stay in amerika please
Germany is manageable, if you don't aim for the big, popular cities like Hamburg, Berlin, Frankfurt, Köln ect.
But e.g. Kiel, Flensburg and Lüneburg are relatively affordable and Hamburg is always nearby. You will still need to hustle for your studio, but it is doable :)
You should never be looking for tge most expensive city. Thats the problem a lot of foreigners make is that they want to live in amsterdam. Thats literally the most populair and most expensive area so of course that means that the prices are high and not much availabke
@@ghg0709 prices are going up in the US too
At 3:34, you forgot to mark a big part of Flevoland. The forgotten piece of land to the north of the marked area was actually the first new piece of land of current Flevoland, and connected the Island 'Urk' to the mainland.
Noordoostpolder
Besides housing what also sucks is that if you have own busines real estate agents demand to see what the income was of said business over the last 2-3 years, which turns out to be a problem if you've just started out. Imagine you happen to lose a roof over your head when you just started your business
Another thing which fueles the housing prices is migration, certainly a thing which also has to be looked at.
How dare you question bringing in hordes of illiterate Somalis and Arabs into Europe what are you a Nazi?
How dare you not be politically correct!
the video is really good. I live in The Hague and it is true that there are not much availability for housing. The thing is that people want big houses and big appartements when they really need much less and because of that there is not much choice. Most houses are old 3 or 4 floored buildings which do not provide enough space compared to a skyscraper.
I to use to live in the Hague now on the streets: BA studied, playing guitar As an American, last I checked out was a studio 28m2 28 square meters== €1600 excluding GWL two groups of 70 were there to check it out, meanwhile belastingdienst government tax dept. Has a building across from HS fit for 100 people Empty since 2006.
@@TheDeathMocker dont live in that area, prices are inflated
@@fredjansen2659 tell me one which is not ? I've searched from South th Brabant and since I'm not allowed to live in the office space 200.000 2m empty it's kind hard. :) You got a spare shed haha :)
As an international student in the Netherlands myself I can attest to knowing people that after 6 months of studying still live in hostels
The waiting list for my town and many many others is allready 10 years, and my town is not even in the Randstad, also you cannot buy anything in this city under 300k unless you get realy lucky somehow or buy a sh*thole (that still is gonna cost you minimum 250k) for which you have to do ten years of reapairing and upgrading it.(for which you need permits and they cost you money too.
I'm certain they'll find a smart solution soon. I've visited almost every EU country while working, and the Netherlands was the golden choice if I ever had to migrate to the EU region.
I'm certain they won't find any sort of a solution soon. The exorbitant prices are raking in way too much money for the housing speculators and the buy to rent landlords. There was a housing shortage when I came to live here 50 years ago. There was a housing shortage when my ex husband's parents were looking for a place to rent, as a young couple starting a family in the fifties. They had to live with his parents.
There was a post war baby boom, causing pressure on housing in the sixties. And a lot was bombed flat during the war. Especially in Rotterdam. It was almost obliterated.
In the sixties, a lot of poorer people from round the Mediterranean were recrutied to do less popular jobs.
That put more pressure on the cheapest housing, as they weren't that choosy, as long as they had a roof over their heads.
Caused even more competition with the young Dutchie baby boomers wanting to start families.
Well, enjoy the Netherlands until you find out you've wasted your life here. You think you can find love? 😅 Guess again! I'm from NL, with 8k per month I live like poor. Someone scratches my car in front of me, police tells me to forget about it, forget about the damage that costs 3k to repair. I'm leaving this sinking ship. But again, NL is good for those who don't like to work and live on tax payers money.
@@ardmrad9278 where do you wanna go?
@@guyfawkes2105 Somewhere that the gangsters that run this place have no jurisdiction to take my money and limit my freedom.
@@ardmrad9278what do you work in?
Whole cities of refugees come in, few houses are built. Housing prices are rediculous
Its not the fault of the refugees. Its the fault of the inaction of the Liberal government, which has privatised the housing market.
@@Trein05 never said it was the ''fault'' of the refugees. I just stated it as one of the causes
@@lillekenatnek195 refugees work twice as hard as the indigenous. The government knows this and so plan to have the entire native population replaced
This video did not address the fact that the housing crisis is mainly caused by the government incentivising and courting housing investors.
It also did not address that the areas that see a reduction in population have been left behind by the government for many years and have been stripped of their infrastructure.
Building houses won't solve a single thing if the system that incentivises housing as an investment isn't destroyed.
The largest problem is the incredibly convoluted process to get permits for building. You have to deal with several committees and a lot of NIMBY. Add to that the rising building cost and shortage in labourers and we see incredible delays before the first brick is even laid down.
The largest problem is migration. A million people every five years.
*I mean most major cities around the world are facing housing shortages, unfortunately. All the young people & immigrants obviously want to live in the big cities where there's things to actually do & live that IG/influencer life*
Isn’t this a problem in just about every single developed western country regardless of the size? Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, etc., are all going through a massive housing crisis due to high demand and low supply. In Canada, they have condos and cranes just about everywhere. Even small towns are getting skylines. They still can’t match the pace of demand and hence housing prices and rents have become ridiculously high…eye watering high…add in Canada’s education sector and international students from all over the world, about 700,000 a year last time I checked…on top of 500,000 permanent residents a year, on top of thousands more on work permits and stuff…we have a perfect recipe for housing disaster…demand is just so high
The reason why we cannot fix this problem is called "VVD", "Mark Rutte", and "Hugo de Jonge" to name a few.
“Kaag”, “WEF”, “European union”
Rutte kaag immigratie corruptie wef d66. Huh hoebedoel immigratie record na record sinds 2014
Mark Rutte gaat binnen kort weg 100% hij zit al te laang, ik ben in Nederland sinds 2011 en hij is nog steeds Prime min here lol
@@nermor hij zal vast wel tweede worden in de verkiezingen en kaag 🤢 zou dan waarschijnlijk onze nieuwe minister president zijn. Of de verkiezingen lopen eerlijk maar ja er zijn teveel mensen die alsnog op rutte stemmen omdat de media de oppositie altijd maar in het slecht daglicht zetten.
je vergeet KAAG... en Jetten die D66 wappies
I love when they try to solve a supply problem with stimulus money. It just pushes prices up for everyone. In Australia it pushed prices up over 100% in 10 years when they started doing home buyers grants. Now people earning $100k a year have to rent share houses.
What a total nightmare. Imagine having to live in a coffin like the micro houses, just because normal housing isn't an option. Young people and starters on the housing market are screwed and many of them consider not having kids because there's no place for them to grow up. Unless you consifer a 1 room micro house enough space for a family of four. What a dystopia...
3:45 only southern Flevoland is shown, here it also has a northern part
I strongly disagree with the idea that these micro houses are a good thing. They are in fact a symptom of the failure of housing, where people are forced to accept living in an inhumanely small space. You still can't have a family there, you can't really reasonably have friends over. They are extremely cramped and bad for mental health.
I lived in one for a while and they are a solution to the housing crisis in the same way a tent by the side of the road is. I reckon living with parents is even preferable as it is less lonely.
I find the idea that micro housing is a positive thing and not a fundamental failure of housing policy to give people actual homes depressing and actually quite insulting. It says to people who are having trouble finding a home that this is how they should expect to be treated and it is frankly inhumane.
The dutch farming sector is not ''massively reducing pesticide use'' everywhere. Most notably, horticulture in open land (flowers), which is the most profitable but also most damaging way to use land, covers about 4% of all available agricultural land. It's a huge profit business but it hurts everything else.
I’ve been planning to move to the Netherlands but now I’m nervous
A huge reason why the netherlands took land away from farmers is for housing. It could easily expand their city’s borders and continue to develop in a dense sustainable way. I think they could even double their population if the will was there
Nice a concrete jungle without any open space. Nice future.
Double our population? No thanks. This country is full. What we need to do is stop allowing immigrants for 10 years and then see how we're doing. If we don't change, this country is going to be unrecognizable in 30 - 50 years.
Yep its got zero to do with climate change its just a cover for a cheap land grab
they have to make a choice, does the netherlands want to be a city state.. yes or no.
@@sloeberdoetyou must be talking about an American city. Every Dutch city I’ve ever been to incorporates a huge amount of parks and open space within the city. Including open space in urban environments is something Dutch cities are really good at.
The Netherlands is literally a Sims game: the supreme urban planning, agriculture, making more land, to even how they speak 😂
3/44 , that little "circle" shaped land above this provence is also part of the provence. We got more land from the sea with that area than said
I live in Drenthe and I've always lived in Utrecht untill we moved. Since we moved to Drenthe the house price here has gone up by 11% ... More and more people come here because they can't afford the cities anymore. This is also true for Groningen. People are looking for different places to live because it's unaffordable in the cities. I still live at home because to rent in Drenthe the waiting list is +2 years...
plz let those randstad guys stay where they are, its nove over here and far les criminality..
You cant really build density if you keep building 3 storey buildings instead of atleast 10 floors. a simple order requiring all new housing to be atleast 7 floor with a comercial area bellow would probably solve the problem
I would rather not see the netherlands end up being filled with skyscrapers lmao- space is not the problem
@@kionake1 7 floors or 10 floors isn’t scyscrapers.
Most new development is actually going up though, my neighborhood was constructed in 2018 and it's all apartment buildings between 7 and 10 floors high.
**cries in American**
The surface per capita has more than doubled in a few decades... Might also be part of the problem.
Using more land for housing/builing higher is just running a red queen's race with no end in sight, just more and more problems coming up as space/ressources will grow scarcer.
Oh. Some of you should totally move to Sweden. We have a skilled worker shortage and cheaper housing (yes we currently have a bubble but it's comming down right now) try other cities than Stockholm/Gothenburg though, also super hard to find housing. I've actually met some dutch who emigrated here and they love the nature etc.
If you go for an engineering job at a company you can probably even start without knowing swedish, english is enough (and apparently dutch is similar to swedish, I'm told you pick it up easily.?)
not the tiny home solution coming from one of the most sprawled places in the world 💀
Appartements going away for 250- 275k around 70m2 or open for rent 1200-1700 p/m. Region zaanstad. Quite insane.
kind a cheap, but thats probably the location..
As a first year international student at the University of Amsterdam I need to say that I am really happy a video like this has been made to bring this issue more to light.
I was looking for a room, an apartment, a studio or anything for 4 months before finding something in the end and to be able to attend viewings which were almost always a requirement I spent a month in the city, essentially being homeless, changing places where I stayed from a hotel to another hotel to a friend's place, to a hostel, to another friend's place and once again to another friend's place avidly searching for basically anything, no matter the price or the location. I ended up finding something but many of my friends were not so lucky and some dropped out before starting university, or after a couple of months after not being able to find a place to stay, living at their friends' or in hostels. Many fellow students also live in places that are for the dutch standards very far away from Amsterdam like Leiden, Rotterdam, Hague or Utrecht.
The crisis is worse than almost anyone outside of the Netherlands thinks and needs a fast solution. Many students coming here, including me, think that it is just hard to find a room within a certain price range and you can just power your way through by paying 1200 or 1500 euros a month for a room but this is not the case and honestly there simply just aren't enough houses or apartments to house everyone.
Moreover the problem is barely if at all caused by the lack of space in the country and it's more of a political issue which seems to be starting to get enough attention with concrete plans being made but until it is fully solved, probably min. 10 years, it is a living hell when it comes to the housing crisis and from the bottom of my heart to everyone living here or planning to move here, for example as a student, I wish you all the luck with finding housing and may this problem be solved as soon as possible.
I mean, you moved to Amsterdam, the most desired and rich place in the whole Netherlands. Everyone wants to live in a tiny spot in the middle of it too. Of course it is hard to find housing, as it is a choice to go there and fight that battle. (The same as in any megacity).
The problem is that everyone wants to go to bigger cities in Ranstad. But somehow 20 mins away by car usually there is a lot more available and cheaper housing.
you're literally part and cause of the problem, you are the last one that should complain
...And yet the Netherlands is number five here:
Top 10 happiest countries: 1 Finland, 2 Denmark, 3 Switzerland, 4 Iceland, 5 the Netherlands, 6 Norway, 7 Sweden, 8 Luxembourg, 9 New Zealand, 10 Austria. Note that all but #9 are in Europe and that the five Nordic countries are listed. 💕☮🌎🌌
In that criteria it actually doesn't ask people if they are actually happy. What the ranking should say is people should be the happiest
it's easier to house a small population in a very small densed country .
The area of the Netherlands isn't shrinking. The population isn't increasing, Dutch women have far fewer than 2,1 children on average, so the population actually shrinks. This problem has only 1 problem: immigration. Every year, another hundreds of thousands immigrants enter this country, to the point that it doesn't only cause a lot of social frustration as the integration failed, but there also just isn't enough physical space.
Exactly, its not a hard thing to understand that the biggest issue is immigration.
Where are most immigrants in The Netherlands from?
The green heart has massively aided my mental health especally durring covid. I moved to Amersfoort and I miss that area so much T_T
this problem is because of africa i live in the netherlands there are just way to many people from africa that come to the netherlands
and the goverment does not do anything about it
as an international student in the Netherlands, I can confirm, this shit is ridiculous. I started studying in September 2022 and I was able to find a place and move in yesterday (It's February 2023) now I consider myself lucky to pay 655 euros a month for a 10-square-meter room.
Expensive
That is extremely expensive
I moved to Canada in the early 80's as a child with my family. Housing was a huge issue even back then, and it's still a problem now. Although the Dutch in general are great at solving technological, agricultural, or water management issues, and indeed, are world leaders in some of these issues, resolving housing problems seems to have eluded them in the last 50 years. It's actually scandalous that this is still a huge problem even after so many years!
it is because of immigrants. you cant build against that scale.
@@user-lm5hi4cz7iincorrect. Netherlands has more housing shortages than net immigration annually
my neighbors house was on sale and it got sold in less than a week. its pretty insane
It's important to note that the figures presented are only considering exporting, the netherlands fall way behind if you consider actual overall productions
"The government reduced taxes for first house buyers " and it also stopped allowing parents to help their children to buy a house. Having to double pay taxes if they want to borrow money to them.
Reeshof (its a destrict in Tilburg) is a nightmarish example of American Urban Sprawl and its terrifying we couldn't build flats here
I agree, I absolutely dread going there and seeing all the wasted space.
Pretty much all the VINEX areas are like that, unfortunately... there are a few flats in the Reeshof though, if you look hard enough :')
I am living in Utrecht and also studied at UU. While Utrecht University sent out a questionnaire to assess how bad the housing crisis is, they also celebrated that more foreign students were admitted than last year. They don't care about it at all. (2022)
you forgot to mention that major european cities are overcrowded by foreigners. Netherlands for example is packed by Turks and Marrocans. Therefore you have a low supply but high demand.
The government for decades has restricted construction and continues to do so. There is huge potential for economic growth if the government changes its policies.
I have lived in the Netherlands for the past 5 years. I have simply never seen this massive amount of construction in any country I have been in... They are building every thing every where... Roads, Houses, schools, Business units, Office blocks etc etc etc.... literally 10 construction sites building new homes with in 10 mins from me and they are all massive ones where they are building thousands of homes.
@@dean-does-stuff-81 Just because it seems like a lot, doesn’t mean it’s enough.
Absolutely.
@@hylje There is 60,000 to 100,000 empty properties in the Netherlands. People that are complaining are the ones that have no intention of getting off their bums and working hard to buy a home... even the worst home in the worst location. ( I literally bought the cheapest house in my city just so I had no mortgage... No debt for the banks to profit off of) I worked very hard to get to that position and it has been extremely hard mentally to move to another country, but I have done it. Many people cant or wont settle for what and where they could buy. Or work harder to make more money so that they can get just some thing... un realistic expectations....
@@dean-does-stuff-81 lol ok. Just work harder, sacrifice more, expect less. Hmm, I wonder why people are obsessed with money and hustle.
That's not really the problem with the housing crisis. It's part of the problem, but not the full problem. There are more important factors then the available space.
1) people prefer houses with gardens over apartments in flats. And houses with gardens take more space and are expensive to buy.
2) houses with gardens (the 400k kind of house) are very profitable to sell. More profitable then tiny houses or apartments in flats. And because houses are build by private companies instead of the government, the houses that are being build are the the "400k house with a garden" kind of house. Houses that are too expensive for starters, students and nearly everyone who wants a house right now.
3) investers have bought entire city's to rent those houses for insanely expensive prices to the people that also wanted to buy that house, but didn't get the chance to do so, because the investor bought that house before it came on the market.
4) the government isn't really doing anything radical to actually make the situation better.
The problem is housing hundreds of thousands of immigrants and a non existent border.
@@ispamalot no that's not the problem. The Netherlands barely accepts any refugees, around ten to twenty thousand per year. And the labour migrants that come to our country are welcomed by the government, because there is a huge surplus of open vacancies. Those work migrants come to do the work that we are to entitled for. Are you gonna work in the greenhouses? In the factories? Are gonna clean offices? Someone needs to do that work.
@@Aranoura immigration is a big problem. here are some numbers from last year (both from newspapers and the CBS numbers):
168.000 births
169.000 deaths
402.000 immigrants, of which 100.000 from Ukraine, luckily most of those will go back to there homeland when it's safe again
around 175.000 emigration
402.000 - 175.000 - 169.000 + 168.000 = 226.000 more inhabitants
let's say most are 3 people families (2 parents, 1 kid) that's over 70.000 extra houses needed just to cover the influx. and then we still have the existing deficit
as long as we keep getting more people like this we can't solve the current problems.
we should pause (unnecessary) immigration and solve the housing shortage, skyrocketing health costs, and integration problems first.
and when we've solved those problems we will be able to handle more people and give them and our current citizens a humane existence.
@@Aranoura @Aranoura fair enough yet 20000 refugees a year totallin about 50000 if we even take an average of 4 people per family is 12.5k houses which is still a considerable amount of the shortage. So they do pose a problem.
@@Aranoura lmao it was 200k in the first half of 2022 alone, are you slow in the head? Maybe check the actual number next time before you start making things up.
many students spend 3 hours a day commuting to school while living wit htheir parents this is basically losing 15 hours a week 2 full work days every week were you cannot develop yourself a a person also you social life suffers because you cannot attend all events at school or you have to stay up all night to catch a train home.
Kinda feels like expensive housing is a big issue everywhere right now
Im a dutch student living with my parents lol, even if there is a free spot its so expensive
i feel you, i quit my parent at 26 only when i had enough money to get out and rent something. I spend like 5k euro just to get in my studio (2k for 2 months rent + 1 month rent = 3k + new stuff like bed, pc desk etc took me another 2k)
I’m from the Dutch Caribbean and my only option to attend uni was in The Netherlands and I did not have my parents to live with or anyone I knew + no bsn till I registered at an address🫠🫠🫠 I was homeless for about 2 months before I found something decent to live in that I could afford + the added stress of having to schrijf in in order to get 1) bsn 2) bank account 3) pay tuition (you have to be ingeschreven for this) edit: It’s a struggle for most middle class people regardless of afkomst😩😩
Because Belgium is not as incompetent as the Netherlands in the last decade. The Dutch are actually failing on so many levels, but because we still riding a wave of the decades before that was far more successful for many people in those times, today most young people cannot afford a house not able to get a mortgage for one.
This is aside the fact that there are not enough houses for people to find. Hence the crazy rental prices. And this is just some of the many issues. We have a fairly good income on average, but plenty people don't have that and cost of living in the Netherlands is actually high.
And I don't think this is not going to be solved anytime soon
And yeah. Let's not fool ourselves how much we protect our nature in the Netherlands. The core of it all is still that we have the lowest forest cover in all of Europe with the only competition from UK both around 10-11% forest cover. Vastly below Europe's average. Oh yeah! but we have a park here and there!! Whoohoo. Yeah. Have you have been in a park where 100.000 other people are having the same idea to have a stroll? Nature in the Netherlands is a reasonable joke.
not all nature is forest.
we also have peat lands (turf), bird reservations, sand drifts (zandverstuivings gebieden), heath-lands (heide) and more.
and we have a lot of nature areas, not just parks. but maybe you're from the Randstad and don't know how the other 9 provinces of The Netherlands look.
The Netherlands is so much more than just Amsterdam, Den Haag and Utrecht
all "nature"in the nederlands is artificial, and there are more trees now then in the past 300 years
When hating your own country becomes easier than loving it
nobody mentioning the ridiculous amount of unused office spaces in the Randstad, that lay vacant for years, there should be law that if investers can not lease this with in a year of 2 it should be converted to affordable housing
You can only say this if you have literally zero idea how to real world works. Area’s are zoned by the municipality. You can’t live in an office because that building does not have the permit to function as an residence. You can’t do large scale economical activities from an apartment building because that building does not have the permit to function as an office.
This really is basic stuff.
Another big problem is the immigration crisis from the Middle East... Our government just refuses to stop the immigration for people from the Middle East. There are waaaaaay too many refugees in the Netherlands (record after record immigration) and our government just won't take resposibility like for example Denmark does....
exactly, but most people can't see or won't talk about it.
it's ok to set a limit.
it's better to help a (small) group in a meaningful way than trying to help everyone and failing everyone.
The idea for the video: a Soviet experiment on the free distribution of small size land for urban residents (dacha дача), for running a small personal household. For example, now 60% russian have a second home in addition to an apartment.
maybe we need to do like a agricultural campus of ducht university in places like south africa , also for town planning and protecting cities from the increase flooded land.
nice video what is your software when presenting a Map?
It's tough to succeed at housing when you let in millions of economic immigrants
Will fail? It is already barely possible to get a house out here 🤣 (that is affordable)
As an Australian, I can sympathize with the Dutch. Here, rents have nationally increased over 24% in the past 12 months and no major political party can seem to offer a solution. Commentators parrot it as a simple supply and demand issue but as in other countries the housing crisis is far more complicated. Our tax systems need to be overhauled that currently subsidize landlords over owner-occupiers, and we need greater tenant rights.
Honestly, compared to Europe, Australia is nearly a century behind in terms of our tenancy laws and the ability our landlords have to simply increase rent to whatever they like. I think for Australia and a lot of other countries including the Netherlands the basic need of housing is fast becoming our greatest source of financial hardship and diminishing life chances. If the Dutch have failed at housing, Australia's current situation is a catastrophe.
01:50 That's assuming Dutch students are able to travel to their study of choice. I have travelled 1.5 hours each way for 3.5 years now.
This is why I'm staying with my parents until my 30s save up money
The Dutch government is too busy caring about everything but ordinary Dutch people.
Who are the Dutch people to you? Turkish? Perhaps Morocco? Or maybe some Polish lmao
First they let go of the native white Dutch people for the morrocans, indonesians etc but now they just abandon everyone for illegal muslim, african etc criminals
@@mcj2219 ahh blame the immigrants.
@@mnkwazi Perhaps letting in 200.000 immigrants in a year when you have no houses isn't too stellar of a plan.
@@mnkwazi Who's blaming anyone? Facts are facts; Our government spends billions every year on things that have nothing to do with the Netherlands itself.
Question: Would dying and decaying grass not have the same greenhouse gas output as the farts produced from cows who eat the grass? It's not like the bovine stomachs are adding new elements/matter that didn't previously exist. You know, conservation of mass and all that.
It really matters what kind of emissions there are. e.g. Methane is much worse than CO2. It's also important when and where these greenhouse gases end up and how long they stay in the atmosphere. So a fire burning gras would "warm" the globe less than a cow eating it and producing methane
And the moving the universities to the countryside sounds a very good idea, I don't know why the video implied otherwise.